Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Docs Outside The Box

Docs Outside The Box artwork

Medical Violence Against Patients. #459 Part 3

Apr 29, 202523 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

SEND US A TEXT MESSAGE!!! Let Drs. Nii & Renee know what you think about the show! Our discussion stems from a shocking case of obstetrical abuse where an attending deliberately created a fourth-degree laceration on a Black patient who had just delivered her baby without complications, solely so a resident could practice the repair. We go deep into how medical training can sometimes cross serious ethical boundaries and remaining silent when witnessing unethical practices doesn't just harm patients, it erodes one's own moral foundation and perpetuates a culture where abuses can continue unchecked. FREE DOWNLOAD - 7 Considerations Before Starting Locum Tenens - https://darkos.lpages.co/7-considerations-before-locums LINKS MENTIONED Q&A and Suggestions Form - https://forms.clickup.com/9010110533/f/8cgpr25-4614/PEBFZN5LA6FKEIXTWF Send us a Voice Message - https://www.speakpipe.com/docsoutsidethebox SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER! WATCH THIS EPISODE ON YOUTUBE! Have a question for the podcast? Text us at 833-230-2860 Twitter: @drniidarko Instagram: @docsoutsidethebox Email: team@drniidarko.com Merch: https://docs-outside-the-box.creator-spring.com This episode is sponsored by Set For Life Insurance. What the Darkos use for great disability insurance at a low cost!! Check them out at www.setforlifeinsurance.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1previously on Dr Outside the Box.

Speaker 2Listen up everyone, particularly if you're a program director and you're listening. I'm going to tell you something right now. These students are special yo, how they work, how they hustle, they all have a mission. And when I say mission, it's not like I just want to become a doctor. It's I want to become a doctor because I want to do this for family community. If you're looking for leaders, look of leaders. Look here, look at the SNMA.

Speaker 1Let's change direction a little bit and let's do a little bit of some clinical talk. Ew, all right, we don't talk about clinical stuff on Docs.

Speaker 2Outside the Box. We're about to talk about clinical stuff, so I'm going to share this. I saw this video that was put out by an OB doc about a week ago and another doc had reposted this and gave her example of what was going on, and I really needed you to explain this to me. So I'm going to play this and then I want you to really go into depth about what is going on here.

Speaker 3Okay, I am going to share a story that I've thought about sharing a gazillion times since I've been on social media. I think today's today. So I was in medical school from 1996 to 2000 when I was in my third year OB rotation. Back then all the patients delivered in the OR. Vaginal delivery C-sections they all delivered in the OR. Vaginal delivery C-sections they all delivered in the OR.

Speaker 3And I remember going back for a delivery black patient this was her fifth, fourth or fifth delivery delivered seamlessly, not an issue. And I remember it was me, the faculty and a resident Don't remember what year the resident was, doesn't really matter. But after the patient delivered, the faculty looked at the resident and said have you repaired a fourth degree laceration yet?

Speaker 3And the resident said no, so. So the faculty got a pair of scissors. Okay, the faculty got a pair of scissors and he put one blade in the vagina and one blade in the rectum and he cut. He cut a fourth degree in a patient who had already bled. Now I was a medical student.

Speaker 3I didn't know if that was what was done and that's how they trained residents. I don't think it even computed with me what was happening and how wrong it was, obviously, until I got more training and became a resident myself and realized what had actually happened. There's a lot of things that happened back then that we were made a party to because of the practices and obstetric abuses that were commonplace and we couldn't say anything.

Speaker 3We couldn't say anything and although I will never know what it's like to be a Black pregnant individual in this country, I can educate myself and understand and teach and learn some more.

Speaker 2All right, we get the point. So I wanted you to explain this because I think there was another doctor. She did a really good job of explaining this. Well, she did a good job of saying what happened in her experience. But I even had to come to you because I didn't understand specifically what was going on and who you explained to me. I was like wait, that's what happened. And I was like, hey yo, so please let the audience know, explain to them what happened in this situation.

Speaker 1So first I want to say that this is an indictment on your OB rotation as a medical student. You said what? This is an indictment on your OB rotation as a medical student, that you did not understand this story.

Speaker 2Wow Listen, man your OB rotation. Those days have gone and passed. Those days have gone and passed. Those days have gone and passed. Did I get my?

Speaker 1degree. Please explain Did you deliver a baby?

Speaker 2That's the question. Explain please.

Speaker 1Okay.

Speaker 2I did deliver a baby. Okay, sure you did.

Speaker 1So this is a unfortunate and egregious obstetrical abuse that she is describing. So, for context, she says that she had a Black patient who was having her fourth or fifth baby and what is very important about that? Right, because it's a fourth or fifth baby being delivered vaginally. What's important to understand about that scenario is that oftentimes if you are delivering a fourth or fifth baby, it's a very seamless delivery, right.

Speaker 1Oftentimes these patients will not even tear. I even told you I've had patients. I had a patient once who had her fifth baby and I literally was just standing there telling her jokes so that she could laugh and she laughed the baby out. She didn't even have to put much effort into pushing and she did not tear. So I want people to kind of keep that in mind at how seamless and easy that delivery is. So the fact that this patient had already delivered means that there was really nothing to do in terms of repair.

Speaker 1It sounds like there were no lacerations.

Speaker 2repair it sounds like there were no lacerations and so so this is a perineal tear that could occur between the vagina, the bottom of the vagina and the anus.

Speaker 1If there is something to be repaired, right If there is a tear, but it doesn't sound like there was a tear right. Patient delivered, it was seamless it was fine, based on the story that she told. So that should have been pretty much after the placenta. That should have been the end of the delivery, but it sounds like the faculty member, the doctor, the attending doctor who was supervising the resident, wanted the resident to have an experience of repairing a fourth degree tear, and so, very simply, the tears or the lacerations that can occur when you are pushing a baby out can go pretty much from any point you know, anywhere in the vaginal area down all the way to and through the anus, okay, and involve the rectum right, involve the actual rectum itself, that's a big deal.

Speaker 1If it goes all the way through and into the rectum, that's a huge deal. And the problem with those tears that go all the way through is that they have a really bad complication rate or risk, at least they have major complication risks, especially for what we call fistulas, which is a hole that develops between the vagina and the rectum. And so you know, communication, communication, right. So stool getting into the vagina and and all of this kind of stuff, so it can be a very bad social thing as well.

Speaker 1Right, for these women, because if you have stool kind of leaking into your vagina, that has a lot of different social implications, implications. Yeah, and it sounds like what this doctor did was he took a pair of scissors and essentially cut a fourth degree laceration or episiotomy. In this case we call it episiotomy because he did the cutting after the patient delivered, so not to facilitate delivery, because this patient already delivered, just so that he could have the resident practice a fourth degree laceration or episiotomy repair, which is egregious, unethical, immoral, frankly, it's assault really is what it is.

Speaker 1It's assault and so for me, in uncertain terms, really should have been followed up with some sort of legal action, if not criminal legal action, legal action, but you know it sounds like this young lady.

Speaker 2Here's a picture of the repair, but these are not. That's not insurrection, but this is a second degree repair.

Speaker 1Yeah, so it sounds like you know. When she was a medical student, it didn't dawn on her what was going on, right? Because you don't actually know exactly what's going on, because you're learning for the first time, and so when you're learning for the first time, you may not realize that what you're witnessing is something that is extremely abusive. You may not even realize that, right, I don't know at what level the resident was and what I forgot the name of the other doctor, but she puts out good content.

Speaker 2But she said that this happened to her.

Speaker 1Or to a fellow resident she was a witness witness.

Speaker 2She was witnessing what was happening as a med student and the resident stepped in and said no, like you are not going, she said. The resident said this to the attending you are not going to create a fourth degree tear in this patient.

Speaker 1Absolutely, absolutely. I will tell you, as a resident, I likely would have done the same, because you can't. You can't stand there and watch somebody do something to someone and just not say anything.

Speaker 2Yeah, have you ever seen anything like this before? Have you ever? Okay, maybe not to this. Well, yeah, have you ever seen anything that crazy in residence?

Speaker 1Not to that extent. Not to that extent I've had an attending jump the gun before. I've had an attending jump the gun and make the wrong call due to impatience. You know, there was a point at which I was signing, so I came in on the 19. They were signing out to me about this patient and there was a question of whether or not she had an ectopic pregnancy.

Speaker 1But they were asking if it was a corneal ectopic pregnancy, basically a pregnancy that's kind of stuck in the corner, if you will, of the uterus, in one corner of the uterus, and those require resection. You have to actually cut those out. But the story that they gave the patient kind of walked into clinic and she didn't have any pain, she didn't really have much in terms of bleeding, and then somebody did an ultrasound and they saw this cystic structure.

Speaker 1There wasn't a fetal pole, but there was a question because she had a positive HGG level X, y and Z and the story just wasn't quite making sense to me. The problem was that we were in sign out and this patient had already been sent down to same day surgery, right To pre-op, you know to to essentially be whisked off into surgery. So the day team was now signing out and so me, as the night team, I was gonna be taking over and doing this surgery.

Speaker 1And so, because the story didn't sound right to me, I was like hold on a second, let me look at the ultrasound myself. Go back in her records a little bit. The problem was the technology at that time. I forget what system we would use at the hospital, but the technology at that time you try to sign in to their PAC system, you know, to see the images, images, and it was like it would take forever and ever and ever, and then it would log you out, then log you back in and then log you out.

Speaker 1So it kept doing that and anesthesia was like are we going yet? Are we going yet? And my attending goes oh well, don't, let me be the hold up, let's go. And I was like wait. And I literally said to her I was like wait, I mean I want to see the images. And she's like no, no, no, let's, let's take her back. So they start taking her back. I try again, try again. The system is not working. And I'm like okay, whatever, so we go back to the operating room. As we're in the operating room, I'm like let me just do a quick vaginal exam on her, because for me I was like is she really having an ectopic or is she actually just miscarrying?

Speaker 1And one ways that you might be able to tell is if her cervix is open. Right, if her cervix is open, then you know she might be miscarrying or she might be having, you know, an incomplete miscarriage or something, cause I don't remember exactly what the story was, but I remember thinking that and my attending said no, do not examine her, let's go. They said it's a corneal leg topic, let's just go. I'm like I don't agree with this, fine.

Speaker 1So she goes and she starts operating. She makes the cut, she keeps going down, she keeps going down to the point. I even say to her wow, you, you're really doing a good job at at um, at doing this surgery right. Meaning you know I'm supposed to be operating but you're doing it. But okay. So she goes down, down, down. We go to the uterus Nothing there.

Speaker 2Like weapons of mass destruction. Yes, ain't nothing there.

Speaker 1Nothing, not a bulge, not a nothing. And then I say to her can I do a vaginal exam now? And she's like uh, yeah, so I do the vaginal exam, cervix one centimeter open, and get my finger right through it, which she probably just needed. Dnc.

Speaker 1Right so anyway, we patch her up, we do the DNC um, take her out and at some point during the night I go back and I'm like let me see if I can get into the images. And finally I get onto a computer where it is working and I go back two years before. Guess what's on that ultrasound Little cystic structure right at the corner of her uterus.

Speaker 1It had been there the entire time.

Speaker 2So what would you guys, what'd you guys tell the patient?

Speaker 1So I told the patient the truth. I told the patient the truth. You know I'm like the truth. You know I'm like you didn't. That's not the surgery that you needed. And I told her surgery that we did. You know, I wanted her to know like this is. You know cause patients will confuse things. This is not a C-section. You did not have a C-section. You just had a cut where we went.

Speaker 1We looked inside to see if we could find a pregnancy there. We did not find it. Instead, we I ended up doing a vaginal exam, found that you were miscarrying and we did a DNC. She must've been, she must've been bleeding.

Speaker 2She actually must've been bleeding, but um, so I I think I try, I try to figure out if does this happen in surgery? I'm sure it happens in surgery. I just can't think of it because this like I know we were talking about this last, you know a couple of days ago like man, what's would you see an attending like injured a common bile duct, so that their resident can fix it? And I'm like I can't see that happening because it's such a vital structure, the complications are so high. Why would you even F of that? The thing that the closest thing that I can see, where it's kind of like the gray zone, who knows, but it's sometimes for the most part is a benefit to the, to the resident, is the appendix.

Speaker 2You know you do like an incidental appendectomy. You know you have a gunshot wound to the belly.

Speaker 1You have injuries all over.

Speaker 2Sometimes they're like hey, man, take, take this appendix out so we don't have to ever come back into this belly. I've seen that happen and so forth. But I just, man, I really I can't see that happening. I, yeah, I just I cause I, I I understand what you're saying, like the based off of the pictures, morbidity, right, like the issues that you could have of creating this type of tear that I'm assuming based off of this video. Just the ob dog did it because I'm for fourth degree tears, isn't? That should not be a combination of like surgery and ob, you don't have to I mean unless it's really that bad.

Speaker 1But no, you don't usually we will repair that and it's a. I mean, I'm sure you know it's a. It's a extremely delicate repair, a very time consuming repair, a very risky repair. And just you know, you deliver a baby and you pray you never get a fourth degree tear. You just don't want it, do you?

Speaker 2do you think ever? You know I always think about like, so, for example, like we're going to talk about sinners and, like you know, making a deal with the devil. Or you know you won't ever wonder how some people get to a point where they make a really bad decision. Or you know when people get into a bad situation. When you go back and you look at that bad situation, it's usually there are multiple mistakes that are made before that really big bad decision right?

Speaker 2what I'm saying is like for a resident at that time to see that type of situation occur and for them not to say anything for a whole host of reasons. Maybe they don't want to say anything because they don't have the courage to say something, or maybe just have they don't say anything because they just don't know. But do you think that's kind of part of like the process of like leading down a bad oh yeah, path, so that when you're in attending like you really don't, your moral compass is off?

Speaker 1Oh, absolutely, you see what I'm saying.

Speaker 2Whereas, whereas even if you're a resident and you see that happening, like it takes a lot of balls and a lot of guts to be like yeah, that's not happening on my watch, right, but like, is it worth it to speak on something like that then, so that by the time you're attending, you've already flexed that muscle multiple times to be like I'm going to really stand up for what's going on with the patient. What are your thoughts on that? Because a lot of times I feel like people who really make bad decisions in attending a lot of times they were making bad decisions as residents.

Speaker 1Or they saw people making bad decisions and really didn't think about how bad a decision, those decisions were right and so they gave themselves a pass, or they gave that person a pass and justified in their minds that, well, it was for the greater good of name. Whatever good they have, you know, in their head, right?

Speaker 3And so, in this case, the good quote, unquote being that.

Speaker 1Well, I get to teach my resident how to do this repair. Because if I don't teach the resident how to do this repair, then if they should ever encounter fourth degree repair, how will they ever know how to do it?

Speaker 2and there are ways. The question, though, is would you, would you do that on a patient that is of a different hue? Would you do that on a page?

Speaker 1you know, like these are things that you know, that that's the question right would. Would would this physician have done it on a white patient? You know, I've I've had, I've had attendings. Tell me that patients are VIP. Yeah, yeah, and I had one physician, one attending that said, oh, this is my VIP patient, she's a lawyer. And I flat out said to him I was like your patient is not VIP to me. She might be VIP to you, I said, but she's not VIP to me.

Speaker 1I'm like every single patient will get the care they're supposed to get on my service, that's so. Oh, but she's a lawyer. I'm like I don't care what the hell she is, she's going to get the care that everybody else gets. On my watch, you know like sometimes you got to say things like that because otherwise you know you. You feel like here's my question what does it do to you? What, like what do you think that it does to you to watch these things happen and never say anything that don't eat you up inside like it doesn't?

Speaker 1You got to speak, you know, because you know a lot of these mugs be a lot.

Speaker 2A lot of times you talk about this stuff on your personal statement or you talk about certain things. It's like yo, this is your time to shine. You remember what you said in your personal statement. Whatever it may be, this is your time to shine. So you got to speak up on this. I got you 100% on this. I got you 100%. What's good everyone. This is Dr Nii Yo. This is the end of this segment. I appreciate you for listening, but this ain't the end. If you want more, go ahead and click the next button on your favorite podcast app Listen. That's next for more banter between me and Dr Renee. That's next for more topics.

Speaker 2That's next for more segments.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Someone Made a Bet on Me. Now it’s my turn. #486

    Nov 10, 202627 minAudio

    SEND US A TEXT MESSAGE!!! Let Drs. Nii & Renee know what you think about the show! I want to begin by honouring Javits Frimpong, the 15-year-old Ghanaian student who was fatally shot on his way to school in the Bronx....

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 2012: The Year I Stopped Asking For Permission. #485

    Oct 27, 202626 minAudio

    SEND US A TEXT MESSAGE!!! Let Drs. Nii & Renee know what you think about the show! Most people can point to one year that changed everything. For me that year was 2012. I finished my trauma surgery fellowship in Miami....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. A Dental Student Just Ran Out of Money. The Government Did This. #484

    Oct 13, 202627 minAudio

    SEND US A TEXT MESSAGE!!! Let Drs. Nii & Renee know what you think about the show! A first-year dental student posted a video on Instagram that stopped me cold. He's run out of federal funding. He's run out of private...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 20 Years Later — What I'd Tell Every Medical Student. #483

    Sep 29, 202633 minAudio

    SEND US A TEXT MESSAGE!!! Let Drs. Nii & Renee know what you think about the show! Twenty years after medical school, I went back to Kansas City with Renee and our boys. Walking through the place where it all began...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Want to Do Global Surgery? Start Preparing Now. #482

    Sep 15, 202643 minAudio

    SEND US A TEXT MESSAGE!!! Let Drs. Nii & Renee know what you think about the show! A first year general surgery resident slid into my DMs after our previous episode on how GHANA MADE ME BETTER. She’d been following the...

    Credit the people on this episode