Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Do Beautiful Things

Do Beautiful Things artwork

Who Should Pay for Recycling? How Recycling Laws Are Changing Across America

Nov 13, 202635 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Who should pay for recycling? In this episode of Do Beautiful Things, Jennifer Lawson, president and CEO of Keep America Beautiful, welcomes sustainability and recycling expert Michael Washburn to explore extended producer responsibility, or EPR, laws that are shifting more responsibility for packaging waste. They discuss what’s happening in states including California and Oregon, how these policies could change recycling for companies, communities and consumers, and what emerging waste streams, from batteries to data center equipment, could mean for the future of recycling.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to Do Beautiful Things. I'm your host, Jenny Lawson, President and CEO of Keep America Beautiful. On this podcast, we explore all the ways, big or small, that people are stepping up to end litter, rethink recycling, and create cleaner, greener, and more beautiful communities. You'll hear from changemakers, industry experts, community leaders, and everyday doers who are showing that when we unite to care for the places we love, we can make a real difference.

For each other and for the planet we share. So let's get inspired, let's get connected, and let's do beautiful things. Welcome back to Do Beautiful Things. The world of recycling is constantly changing, and not just because of what people put in the bin. New laws in several states are requiring companies to take more responsibility for the packaging they create And to help in paying for it to be recycled. Today,

we're asking some basic questions to better understand these laws. What are they meant to do, and are they actually helping? And what happens to other kind of waste, like the equipment inside data centers, when it's no longer useful? Joining us today to answer these questions is Dr. Michael Washburn, a sustainability and recycling expert who leads Washburn Consulting, supporting stakeholders working on EPR and compliance. His career spans business, nonprofit,

philanthropy, and environmental policy, including serving as Vice President of Sustainability at Nestlé Waters North America and as Senior Director at the Wilderness Society. Michael, welcome back to Do Beautiful Things. Jenny, it's So fun to be back in the virtual sound studio with you. It's great to see you, and I'm thrilled to be back, what, 3,

3 and a half years later. How about that? Yeah, for those of you who've been listening all along, you may remember that Michael was in fact our very first episode of Do Beautiful Things. At that time, we talked about what happened to our recyclables after putting them in the bin. Today's conversation will be a little bit different. So let's get started. And in fact, I'll stop and say it'll be different also because I believe in that first episode, my mother

joined us with her recycling question. I will tell you, she still has recycling questions. She's not alone. And I'm sorry that she's not back on with us today, but Always happy to take mom's questions. That's good to know. We'll put you on speed dial from here forward. Great. So listen, several states across the country are passing these laws, putting the responsibility of recycling in the hands of companies and creating— and the

packaging that they create. So can you explain how that works in simple terms. I know, let's just get terminology straight from the beginning, right? I introduced you as being a leader in EPR, and you and I, you get into the acronym world and these things get really hard to understand. Let's start there. What is EPR? Yeah, it's a good starting place. So the letters stand for Extended Producer Responsibility.

And as that phrase would suggest, and as you Explained in the setup, Jenny, the responsibility for waste has historically been on the back of communities, right? We dispose of things from our home, the municipality collects it, your taxes pay for it, things go where they go, they go to the landfill, they go to recycling streams, whatever. EPR is changing that a little bit and placing the responsibility of

the collection and recycling of packaging on the producers. And producers in this case are those companies who are the first to place it in the market. So they're not necessarily the maker of the thing, of the wrapper, of the jar, of the can, of the bottle, but rather the people whose brand is on that. package. Those are the producers. And just for context, might be helpful for people to know

where is this phenomenon happening, what states have passed these, these EPR laws. When we talked a few years ago, there were only a couple. Now there are 7. Those states are California, Colorado, uh, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, Oregon, and Washington. Wow. That's a huge growth for these programs.

Now, I believe in California, it's called the Plastics Reduction Law. And so it's focused on plastics recovery? Yeah, California's is a little different. So a basic EPR law And this is true across all the states, is focused on improving the recycling system. So you have the producers pay fees, they pay those fees based on how much material they sell in that state. And the fees pay for the collection, the processing,

making sure that those materials actually get to where they need to go to be recycled. That's often a question, right? Like, I put it in the bin, does it really ultimately get recycled? So in California, in addition to reforming how recycling gets done, there's a feature in their law, which is affectionately called SB 54, that is asking the companies who use plastic packaging to reduce the amount of packaging that's sent into the state of California.

between the years 2023, which was the first full year after the law passed, and 2032. So a decade. So just to play that back, you start with however much material there was in California in 2023, and now we're going to try to reduce that by 25%. And by the way, that's regardless of whether companies or an industry has grown or not. It's an Absolute reduction. It's a huge experiment. Can we actually

do that is an open question. Yeah. How's it working? I mean, we work with companies every day who are reviewing their packaging portfolios, looking at different items, right? So first you make a list. These are all the things that we make and sell. Okay, what kind of package is it? Is it made of plastic or not? And for those things made of plastic, you start looking at it and saying, well, Can we make it lighter, right? Does it have to be this thick or this heavy or this big?

Can we do something that's reusable or refillable? That's a requirement of the law. A certain percentage of this reduction has to come from making things refillable or reusable. Then you start to ask, well, can we switch it? So here's a very easy example. If you recall the polystyrene clamshells that one might bring home Chinese food in. Those are actually banned in California, but there are alternatives to that. You can move that to a fiber-based,

sometimes compostable food serviceware format. And so the companies are working very hard to do this, and that's true for companies that make candy, companies that— restaurants, people that sell you cosmetics, even things that you find in a Home Depot, right? This isn't just— Yeah. Metals. This is everything. And it's amazing to see the innovation both on the materials science side, but also on the, hey, is

there a different way to sell this and get it to the consumer? And, you know, we're coming up on holiday time, and I always think about the holidays and people opening gifts and just the giant mass and mess that's on the floor, right? That's what this is trying to solve. Does that really need to happen that way? I think most of us think it doesn't. So are Californians seeing this difference? I mean, my sense is yes. You and

I both travel around the country a lot and coming in and out of California, and I have a ton of family out there, I feel like it's a different environment out there now that what you get your burger wrapped in or not hermetically sealed anymore is changing. And whether you get straw or not a straw and plastic bag or no bag at all, those things are really changing out there. They are.

And what Californians and the folks in the other states where this is happening or will happen, you know, what they can look forward to is there— we're just in the process now of getting a finalized plan for how the industry is going to lay out the program in California. And what we're seeing is, hey, there's going to be access to recycling now in communities that didn't have it before. You'll see a unification of

what's accepted for recycling, right? So this thing where you can recycle this thing in this community, but you go over there and you can't, like that's going to start to get more consistent. That's a feature of EPR laws everywhere. And yeah, you're going to see differences in packaging. You're going to see things that are more efficient. You're going to see, you know, brand presentation on packaging start to change. And sizing start to change. It's really a fundamental shift in how things are going to get to market.

You just said a couple of things that I think are really interesting and kind of get at the heart of what's recognized as some of the key problems with recycling now, which is this differentiated infrastructure, market-to-market, Here in Connecticut, town to town. Yep. Those things are going to start to change. Is there a tipping point where they're going to change at a national level? So you've got 7 states that are going to start to

each align state by state, but my guess is somebody gets a system that works and other states will start to look to adopt it more quickly. 10 states and we might see change that's sort of national. What do you think about where all this goes for really addressing some of this infrastructure functionality problem? Yeah, I mean, we'd like to think that good ideas are contagious, right? I think there's 2 ways to think about

how it spreads to other states. So one thing is if a company that's national or global is making changes to its packaging, it's not doing that for a particular state. It's doing that across the entire enterprise. So, you know, even if California is the primary driver and a company changes a package, people in Nebraska are going to start to see that same package on the shelf. And I think that's good news for everybody. Great point. Less waste and more recyclability across the board. On the infrastructure side

and sort of how the policy goes, I do hope other states are going to adopt good models. This is a marvelously nonpartisan policy instrument. If you look at the list of states that I mentioned, they're predominantly blue or maybe purplish. But there are discussions about this in, in the more redder parts of the country, and the reason is recycling is not just an environmental endeavor. It's, it's industrial policy. It's local

economic development. It's municipal tax relief, right? So the fees that get paid to go through the third-party nonprofit that runs this whole thing to do the recycling are fees that people no longer pay locally in their taxes. So communities are going to be the beneficiaries of this because they're going to have less material going into their landfill. That is a Is a cost, sure. Forever.

So there's a lot of ways. Now, the other, I don't know if you intended this, but people do often ask, you know, could we see this adopted at the federal level? And I would say maybe. Waste is really the purview of the states. This isn't something that the federal government would typically engage in. But I'd actually argue we may not want a federal system. And the reason is, if you think about how we were talking earlier, recycling is different community to community because

that's how it was originally built. Well, it's very difficult then to build a policy that acknowledges that difference across such diverse a land as ours. Right. So having it at the states, the states are often, what do they say, the laboratories of progress, might actually be the better way to do it, even though I will say the companies get frustrated because every state wants to do it a little bit differently. And at the same time, so as a producer, you're trying to find the common denominator across all of the programs

and develop to that standard. It sounds like a problem for AI. But so let's bring up AI, like data centers and all of this material. I'm not sure anybody even 3 years ago imagined the rate that these things would start to happen. Do companies and things like that come under these EPR standards too? Well, not yet, but I think that's a

when, not an if. There is EPR for rechargeable batteries. There's EPR for carpet, for paint, for pharmaceuticals, things that are problematic when they end up in the waste stream, dangerous, For example, to the fantastic people who pick up your trash. I mean, certain things need to be handled with more care. And by the way, this is fascinating. You

talk about data centers. We talk so much about rare earth minerals or critical minerals. Well, where are they being used? They're in those server towers. They're in those data centers. They're the copper wires that put it all together. Like, that stuff has tremendous value. It does wear out. And where's it going to go? So we see early discussions, not on data centers yet. We're still debating do or not do on the data centers, right? But

used solar panels. Oh, true. Wind turbine blades that wear out and need to be disposed of and properly managed. So I think this policy tool, this idea of, hey, if If you're the industry that's the beneficiary of this product being sold into the market, you should be responsible for thinking about its design before you sell it and helping build a system to manage it when it's not in productive use anymore. Right.

It's a marvelously elegant idea because no community is ready to manage the kinds of things that are now out there that become waste. Well, and that sort of recycling goes all the way to vapes and other products that have batteries. And yeah, exactly. Yeah. And nicotine is actually a listed hazardous substance. So when you get into the vape pens, you've got 2 issues. You've got, well, 3. You've got the plastics that are the case, you've got the battery,

and then you have the nicotine pouch. It's a fascinating complicated, tiny but big looming challenge. It's amazing how, I think for the majority of us day-to-day, you're thinking about your aluminum can and your plastic bottle and what happens to those. But recycling is a multi-stakeholder opportunity, challenge, and industry at this point with with recovery. And I would think, you know, getting

back to those rare minerals, that recovery of these materials, and that's, I would assume, some part of EPR is recovery of some of this material so that it can be reused. Yeah, the packaging laws all include requirements where the collectors and the processors have to demonstrate that the material is being sent back into the market and being kept in productive use. So we can't, you know, tell consumers

that something's being recycled, but then quietly put it on a barge and send it to a developing country somewhere to be disappeared. That has happened for decades. It's not going to happen under these laws. And what that's going to do is, you know, push that material back into domestic industries. Which is a benefit to all of us. And as we already observed, not send it into our landfills or into incinerators. So— What I think I heard you say is,

and companies are going to have to show that that's happening. Yes, they're going to have to show it to the state regulator. Interesting. You know, one of the questions I get a lot, because you get into these policy discussions and it sounds very ethereal and maybe foreign to people who don't spend their time in legislative hallways is what do I do as a consumer, you know, just as a regular citizen? What am I supposed to do about any of this? And part of what EPR does, which has been something that has

inhibited recycling in America for years, is it provides a funding stream to do the kind of education which KAB is marvelous at. to help citizens understand what is recyclable in their community. So you'll start to see more advertising. You'll hear radio communications in some states. You might start to get stickers that go on your recycle bin that are literally images of yes and no, put this in, don't put this in. And the single

biggest thing that consumers can do— obviously, we want people to recycle a lot. But importantly, they have to do a lot of putting the right things in the recycling bin and not putting wrong things in the recycling bin. Because when you put wrong things in, I'll use an extreme example, a dirty food container, or God help us, a bowling ball. That's a real thing that people try. That gets to the recycling center and it can attract pests. It can cause

damage. It can harm workers. So the responsibility for us as just regular folks is understand what you can recycle in your community and be pretty persnickety about what you put in your bins. What we call wish cycling. So minimize the wish cycling. If you're not sure, best to not recycle it. Yeah, for all the listeners out there, no, umbrellas are not recyclable. That's a good one.

So we talked a little bit about these EPR laws in California. What's happening in some of the other states like Oregon? You know, Oregon and Colorado and California were the first 3 to really start to build out their programs after the laws passed. And Oregon is the farthest along. So Oregon has now gone 2 cycles of having producers report how much packaging they sell and collecting fees on that packaging. And the fees are already

doing things like enhancing material recovery facilities, what we call MRFs, the recycling centers. Maybe they're getting new technology that helps them sort material better, or they're getting an additional shift and more workers because they're bringing in more material. There are more routes already being established across Oregon, particularly in rural areas. that didn't used to have collection. Um, so that program is moving ahead marvelously. Colorado is close behind, and all the same

things are true. There just haven't been as many months in the implementation. There are some challenges. There's some litigation folks who have sort of, uh, narrow issues where they think their industry or their stakeholders weren't treated the way they would like in how the law was written. Those things will Sort themselves out. But if people wonder, is, is the litigation somehow going to stop EPR from, from its sort of fervent march across the landscape? My answer to that is no.

And the reason is very simple. We can argue over whether or not EPR is the best approach. We can argue over whether the laws are structured perfectly, and we should have that argument, but we still have a problem to solve. Too much waste and it costs too much. So until that's solved, some public policy instrument is going to be brought to bear. And I've asked the question 1,000 times, if there's a better way to do it, then let's do it that way. And nobody's ever offered a better solution than EPR. It is, I think you used the word elegant

and the process by which all of the stakeholders are at the table and all stand on some level to benefit from the outcome. It feels like win-win. I am not a company who is having to pay these fees at this point, but it seems like it addresses what even these companies would articulate as challenges in the current infrastructure. Right.

It does address some of the challenges that are really front and center For all the players in the space. Absolutely. And we, you know, we work with companies day to day and we see the whole spectrum. There are folks who maybe don't understand why this is happening, but recognize it's, it's a requirement now, right? So they, they're trying to figure out, they're trying to do it, they're trying to do it at the lowest possible cost, but fulfill the requirements. And then once in a while, somebody will pull me aside and they'll say, you know, this is a cost to my company now. Some of the executives

maybe don't like it very much, but I'm really glad this is happening because, you know, we don't like that our brand is on something that isn't being managed properly and is maybe ending up in the wrong place and should be recycled. So it's interesting. Now, the other topic that's top of mind for a lot of folks is affordability and the idea that, you know, Jenny, as you said, you're not a company that's paying these fees. If you are a company that's paying these fees, And now you have, you know, I've seen numbers from $15,000

to a couple million depending on the size of the company into a state to pay these fees. That's a new cost on your balance sheet. So it's a little bit of a sticker shock. However, there is a study in California that talks about, if I get the number right, I think $20 billion over a decade. Back to the California taxpayer through full implementation of SB 54. So we're the same people,

you know, taxpayers and consumers are the same. That's your mom. Yeah. And ultimately, my hope and my belief is this is going to cost all of us less. We can't prove that yet. It hasn't been out there long enough, but I'll come back in a couple more years. We'll talk about it. That is a deal for sure. I agree. It's going to be so interesting to watch these evolve state by state. You sort of rattled off the 7 where

laws are in place. Where are they coming close? Yeah, so there have been proposals in legislatures spanning New York, New Jersey, Hawaii, Rhode Island, Tennessee. There are conversations in Texas. Yeah, so purple as they can be. Sure. Illinois is close to finishing a statewide

assessment of their recycling system to be the basis for bringing a bill forward in 2027. So that's a space to watch. I actually just recently saw a new bill pop in New Jersey, in Trenton. So this is being discussed in more states. I think more will pass. And, you know, we'll just, we'll just have to see. I think when we look at the early laboratories of California, Colorado, and Oregon,

we should take the best of what's working and have that infuse the the new models and, and keep going. So I have to ask a self-serving question, um, from a KAB hat specifically. Um, you know, we're always about doing more beautiful things, and I know some of the EPR funds in many of these states are directed at public education and communications. Is that money starting to flow yet, or what's, what's the pipeline on,

on some of that? It is. And in Oregon's law, there are even some dollars that are focused on litter education and remediation. So keep an eye on that. Yeah, those dollars are allocated by the Circular Action Alliance. We didn't talk about CAA, but that's the industry nonprofit that is stood up to help thousands of companies who are obligated under the programs interact with the individual states.

So CAA under the law has to write a plan for each state. That program plan allocates how the funding gets dispersed for collection, processing, end market development, education. So yeah, maybe, uh, there should be a conversation there about how KAB and CAA might find a way forward together in some of the education. We're doing a lot of education work right now. And so

always interested in how we help more people find the way to litter less and recycle more. And so look forward to that possibility. What makes you hopeful about recycling in this moment? You know, I think a couple of years ago, There, and I'm not sure it's not there in many states even right now. There's a lot, still a lot of uncertainty and financial challenges that are pushing recycling out

of municipal budgets. Anything hopeful there? Here we are in late 2026. There's a lot happening in the world. I think, first of all, the tariff dynamics have made it manifest that the value of a thing can change very quickly, and who pays how much for a thing can change as a variety, for a variety of reasons. And so an aluminum can in the United States right now, given the tariff dynamics, is worth an awful lot

more than it was a year or two ago. So when I think of recycling, obviously, I think, Jenny, you and I think about it as an environmental imperative and not being wasteful and not putting pressure on our natural resources to have to go get as much new stuff. But there's all of these costs, right? Like how much is the thing worth just sitting on a table? How much is a steel can worth? How much is a plastic bottle worth? But then there's the cost of, well,

if I send it this way, which is to a landfill, how much does that cost over decades? And it can be a considerable number. If it goes another pathway and ends up in a waterway, what's the cost to society? We don't have good numbers for that, but I think we can all agree it's bad. And so where I'm hopeful is this, this EPR thing is sort of focusing policymakers, communities, recyclers, advocates, NGOs. We're talking

about waste in an entirely different way than we used to and getting that sort of full cost out on the table and making a choice as a civil society about what's in our shared interest. That to me is exciting, not just for waste. We should probably be doing that on a lot of other issues. Yes, I completely agree with you that shift in how we understand the material that ends up on the ground is everything and ends up in our

bins and hopefully in those blue recycling bins as much as it possibly can. Michael, I have a feeling we could talk for hours, but I'm going to take you up on that offer to come back in a couple years and see where we are, maybe even sooner. in this conversation. I really appreciate the update and the deep consideration for this new phase of the recycling journey across America. Thanks for being with us.

Oh, Jenny, thank you. And I'll just say, I'm so happy to see the growth and the evolution in KAB. And, you know, EPR is great. It's going to help with some of the problem, but what KAB brings to the table with your affiliates, your active members, the millions of volunteer hours that you put on the ground every year are very much a part of the larger solution set as well.

And I'm thrilled to even be a small part of your conversation. To coin a phrase, I look forward to keeping doing beautiful things with you and this work together, Michael, for years to come. Thanks, Jenny. Thank you, Michael. Michael, thank you for helping us understand this topic that is complex and varied in both the challenges and the solutions. Because, you know, recycling is about much more than what we put in the bin.

The choices companies make about packaging, Packaging and products matter too. What happens at the municipal and state level clearly matters as well. Better recycling will take all of us working together, from companies and government leaders to local communities and individuals choosing not to wish cycle but to recycle smartly and appropriately. These laws are still really new, so it may take some time to know how well They're going to work, but they ask important

questions. Who needs to pay to help to deal with the product after we're finished with it? How can we create less waste in the first place? And how can we reuse valuable materials instead of throwing them away? To learn more about recycling and the work of Keep America Beautiful, visit us at kab.org. And be sure to subscribe to Do Beautiful Things so you'll be notified when our next episode drops.

Thank you for listening, and as always, take care, stay inspired, and let's keep doing beautiful things together. We'll see you in the next episode.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. From Bottles to Beaches: A Small-Town Recycling Solution

    Nov 6, 202631 minAudio

    In rural Franklin County, Florida, glass bottles are getting a second life as sand. Host Jenny Lawson talks with Lynn Wilder, Executive Director of Keep Franklin County Beautiful, about how volunteers, local...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. What Americans Really Think About Litter: The Perception Gap

    Jul 10, 202636 minAudio

    Why do 94% of Americans see litter as a major problem, yet many fail to notice progress even as national litter rates decline? In this episode, Jenny Lawson, President and CEO of Keep America Beautiful, sits down with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. From Highways to Coastlines: New Research Uncovers the True Scope of Litter in America

    Jun 15, 202625 minAudio

    In this episode of Do Beautiful Things, Jenny Lawson talks with Veronica Roof, HDR’s national solid waste planning leader, about the groundbreaking 2026 Keep America Beautiful National Litter Study. Together, they...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Counting 35 Billion Pieces of Litter, Part 2: What the 2026 National Litter Study Reveals Next

    May 29, 202617 minAudio

    In part two of this two-part episode of Do Beautiful Things, host Jenny Lawson, President and CEO of Keep America Beautiful (KAB), talks with David Scott, PhD, KAB’s Senior Vice President of Data and Research, about the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Counting 35 Billion Pieces of Litter, Part 1: Digging into the Keep America Beautiful 2026 National Litter Study

    May 15, 202617 minAudio

    In this episode of Do Beautiful Things, Jennifer Lawson, President and CEO of Keep America Beautiful, joins David Scott, PhD, SVP of Data and Research, to discuss the 2026 National Litter Study and what a 34% decline in...

    Credit the people on this episode