Divorce Explained with Steve Benmor & Leanne Townsend

Marriage Annulment - Recent Case Law
Annulments are rare - but what happens when a marriage isn’t consummated and the court is asked to undo it instead of granting a divorce? In this week’s episode of Divorce Explained, Leanne and Steve speak with family lawyers Barry Nussbaum and Rebecca Ye - counsel for the applicant - to unpack Justice Presser’s January 2025 Ontario decision in S.M. v. R.F. (2025 ONSC 4155), where the court granted an annulment for non-consummation. We’ll cover: Annulment vs. divorce - what an annulment is (and isn’t) The legal test for non-consummation: incapacity vs. refusal Culture and religion - why the court focused on the legal test, not social stigma Evidence that moved the needle: digital messages, medical checks, and a religious witness Practical takeaways: costs, risks, and when pursuing annulment makes sense Tune in for a clear, candid breakdown of a rare remedy - and what it reveals about how Ontario courts view marriage and annulment today.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
