Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Diva’s Substack Podcast

Diva’s Substack Podcast artwork

How to Sing from Your Diaphragm: The Language of the Voice Studio

Sep 11, 202647 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Timestamps * Welcome back, Intro + How did we get here? 00:28 * What is your experience with imaginistic vs mechanistic language as singer or teacher? 04:46 * Student-centered language + click-bait content 08:35 * The Importance of the Beginner’s Mind + Self-Awareness 14:48 * Patience is a Virtue! 18:00 * How Many Ways Can You Do It Wrong? 21:00 * Different Strokes for Different Folks (or Points Along the Way) 23:47 * Is Imaginistic Language a Crutch? 29:30 * The Black Hole of Accuracy 33:37 * Iterate on Success + Wholistic Singing 37:03 * Challenge Your Learning Style 39:10 * Sing from Your Diaphragm 42:57 What are your hot takes about mechanistic vs. imaginistic language in the voice studio? Drop your comments below! XOXO,Sarah + Kaitlyn P.S. Join the Diva Crowd on our brand-new Instagram, @thedivadiaries_blog, for behind-the-scenes chaos, podcast clips and more from your favorite divas! 💅 Mentioned in the Episode * The Diagnosis and Correction of Vocal Faults by James C. McKinney * Master Singers: Advice from the Stage by Donald George & Lucy Mauro * Great Singers on Great Singing by Jerome Hines The Diva Reads Kaitlyn’s Reads * The Retirement Plan by Sue Hincenbergs * Still Life (Inspector Gamache #1) by Louise Penny Sarah’s Reads * Happiness for Beginners by Katherine Center * The True Love Experiment by Christina Lauren * Lady Eleanor Swift Mystery Series by Verity Bright Upcoming Performances * MarktMusik Concert: The Anemoi (Kaitlyn) with Aline Klieber, soprano and Benjamin Pfordt, pianist Überwasserkirche, Munster, Germany Saturday, September 12 at 12 noon * Internationale Herbstakademie für Gesang und Orchesterleitung Wernigerode (Kaitlyn) with Dame Emma Kirkby, Howard Williams & Florian Franke Konzerthaus Liebfrauen, Wernigerode, Saxony-Anhalt, Germany Friday, September 17 at 7:30pm and Saturday, September 18 at 7:00pm Thanks for reading Diva’s Substack! This post is public so feel free to share it. The Divas We’re two 30-something classically trained singers pulling back the curtain on insider culture of being professional musicians. We love talking about gig life, teaching and taking voice lessons, emotional and physical health, honing our artistic messages and all the other ins and outs of the industry nobody talks about - like where to find a concert gown last minute. Thanks for following along on our journey! Join the Diva Crowd on our brand-new Instagram, @thedivadiaries_blog, for behind-the-scenes chaos, podcast clips and more from your favorite divas, or follow our individual journeys below. Sarah Hamilton * Website * @hamiltonvoicestudio Kaitlyn Townsend * Website * @kaitlyn.townsend.sings This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thedivadiariesblog.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[music]

SPEAKER_00go! Welcome to the Diva Diaries podcast. I'm Caitlin.

SPEAKER_01And I'm Sarah. We are two 30-something classically trained singers pulling back the curtain on the insider culture of being professional musicians. The Diva Diaries are the confessions, reflections, and musings we've gathered on our artistic journeys.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back, divas. This is the official start of Season 2. If you're interested in what we got up to this summer, check out our little mini-episode that was published last week. And today, we're kicking off Season 2 by talking about imaginistic versus mechanistic language. Yes, semantics. Within the studio, whether you're the student or the teacher or... In my case, the choir director and how that affects learning and those kinds of things.

SPEAKER_00So Sarah's going to kick us off with a long quote.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yes. Okay. So we're going to start off right away by being, I think, depending on who you talk to, controversial. Some people are going to be like, oh, absolutely. Others are going to be like, oh, my gosh, not this person. But I think this is part of the reason why it spawned this thought for me and where I first experienced this language and kind of like started to understand it. So I'm going to read a little snippet from The Diagnosis and Correction of Vocal Faults by James McKinney. This for me was reading back in college,

SPEAKER_01which I think it was for a lot of people in a pedagogy class. But it kind of opened my mind at that point to the different ways of understanding our voices and how we relate to it. So he talks about many different faults, but then he says, a third semantic problem may arise from the mechanistic and psychological controls employed in the act of singing. Extreme advocates of the mechanistic approach believe that singing is largely a matter of getting the right parts in the right place at the right time, and that correcting vocal faults is accomplished by calling direct attention to

SPEAKER_01the parts which are not working well. At the other extreme are those who believe that attention should never be directed to any part of the vocal mechanism, that singing is a matter of producing the right mental images of the desired tone, and that correcting vocal faults is achieved by learning to think the right thoughts and by releasing the emotions through interpretation of the music. As is often the case, the truth lies between these two extremes, and it's a composite of both approaches. So it's really clear where he stands on this.

SPEAKER_01But this book, when it kind of defined that earlier, was where I was first introduced to the different ways of teaching. And at that point, I'd actually had one of each. I'd had a very imaginistic teacher that was very, which I would kind of put Bel Canto in the very imaginistic way.

SPEAKER_00Vibes only.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, which, I mean, again, I'm not deep in the Belcanto, so Belcanto people, please don't come at me. But, like, just my experience with it has been much more sensational, much more imagery, much more external of your body slightly.

SPEAKER_00Which, I mean, makes sense for the time period it's coming out of, right? Well, yeah, because what else do they have? Right. Yeah. I mean, they're, well, they are starting to, like, you know, do the whole cadaver thing. But it's not... You know, there was a...

SPEAKER_01It's pre-Garcia.

SPEAKER_00They had a long way to go as far as all that stuff goes.

SPEAKER_01Pre-laryngoscope, post-laryngoscope is kind of like a really weird way that I like to word it. Because I feel like the mechanistic... And again, this is opinion in my experience, but I feel like mechanistic really came from Understanding what's actually happening and like, oh, okay, well, here's what we want to notice. I think there's blurred lines. Of course. I think when we do talk about sensation, like, yes, we are bringing attention to the body. But I think it's just an interesting way to think about it because the reason why this is big on my mind and heart is you just see so much out there

SPEAKER_01about technique. And one of my biggest pet peeves Is seeing people that are like, ugh, people say to do it this way. What a stupid way to do it. They're wrong. You should do it this way. And immediately I don't trust that person. Because I'm going to be just like McKinney and kind of put my thoughts out there. I think there is such an important value on both. And employing both and understanding both. But I also learned from this that I am a much more mechanistic learner by nature.

SPEAKER_01That I like understanding the why and the way things work. And it helps me make sense of things so much more. So I'm weirdly biased for like in two different directions.

SPEAKER_00But I'm curious, like we briefly talked about this before, like what

SPEAKER_01was your first interaction and experience with looking at the voice world this way? And what was it before you discovered it? I'm just...

SPEAKER_00Right. So I think explicitly... I actually never discussed this, or at least I have no memory of discussing this in pedagogy class. I think the first time I explicitly discussed it is actually with you the last couple of years. Growing up largely in choirs, it tends to be a lot more imaginistic language. I think partially, and as a choir teacher, I tended to default to imaginistic language.

SPEAKER_00I think partially because you're trying to reach a large group of people quickly. Some people would argue that choir is not the place for technique. I would disagree with them. Yeah. And I don't know. I think maybe... It'd be interesting to talk to a psychologist about this. Oh, yes. It seems like that imaginistic language is easier for younger people to grasp.

SPEAKER_00Sure. And so I tended to that. But I did also have groups where occasionally I would be using those words and... Their sound wouldn't change or it wouldn't change in the way that I wanted it to change. And so I'd either have to change the kind of imagery I was using, or there were a couple of groups where I had to go more mechanistic because they, it just, it wasn't working for them. Yeah. You know? Um, and then personally, when I, one of my early teachers,

SPEAKER_00like, I think it was part of it. I was very disconnected from my body when I was younger, done a lot of like, You know, yoga and therapy to like get more connected to my body. But, um, when I wasn't getting things, she was not the most flexible teacher. And so she would just switch to highly mechanistic with like lots of diagrams and like anatomy books. And, and I just like, it was too many words and I just sort of like tuned her out. Like, honestly, I, it was not what I needed, but she was not recognizing that.

SPEAKER_00And then it still didn't help really.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Because I wasn't, like, connected to my body, so I couldn't look at a diagram. And I think she was thinking, like, oh, you're book smart, and so this will fix it.

SPEAKER_01And it didn't.

SPEAKER_00It just, like, made it worse. Like, I was like, why are we taking, like, ten minutes to discuss this thing over here? I'm like, it's not working for me. So, yeah. And then after her, I had a way more imaginistic teacher, and that was helpful at that point when I was really starting to pursue the professional thing. And now the teacher I work with tends to be more mechanistic,

SPEAKER_00but sometimes she uses imaginistic language that's closer to Like what my yoga teacher uses.

SPEAKER_01Oh, interesting.

SPEAKER_00And so it is imaginistic in a way that makes your body do the thing that you want it to do rather than like sort of purely imaginistic of like a white sound or, you know. And so I think that's been helpful. But the other thing is... She will say, OK, that was the right thing when I do something. What were you thinking? And then she will adopt my language. Yes. And I think that is the most helpful.

SPEAKER_00And I remember doing this as a teacher, too. If you can figure out what your students are thinking and adopt their language, right, rather than putting yourself at the center of their universe. Yeah. I think that that is the most helpful.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I think that is a more recent shift. Yes. Because I think it very much used to be like, you better figure out this language or you can't do this.

SPEAKER_00But if somebody can't hear or perceive it that way, it doesn't matter. And why do you care as a teacher? Because you've already figured it out for yourself. So why do you care what words they use?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I agree. I agree, but I don't think that was the case, like, even 20 years ago. Yeah,

SPEAKER_00it's true. But if they're doing the right thing, like, why do you care? Like, that's such a weird power struggle and weird hill to die on.

SPEAKER_01This, too. And I think this is why I take such issue with, and I see this mostly on Instagram, because I'm not on TikTok. I'm sure it's there, too, but I refuse. I can't do it. I just, no. I want to keep some level of sanity, and that is one thing. It's a hard no for me. But... I see enough on Reels with Instagram and I'll get an advertisement or get a post that I see from a teacher and it's like this kind of mocking. People say to do it this way, like I was saying earlier, but this doesn't work.

SPEAKER_01That's dumb and that's not actually good. And I'm like, what I feel like you've done with that language is People aren't just making stuff up for no reason, right? If someone is saying, oh, hey, try this. It's because it worked for them.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01And it's not going to work for everybody. Right. But it's working for somebody. Right. And if you, if someone is like watching your content saying like, oh, I want to learn something. And then they just made fun of something that you always felt like made your voice feel better. All you've done is create some inner turmoil in a young singer specifically, if they're watching and, and put down Someone's way of connecting to their voice. And I, I feel like that's never okay. Right. And I'm very, I'm very much of a, this is,

SPEAKER_01this is coming from time, a school of thought that is, that they're all right. And they're all wrong at the same time.

SPEAKER_00You read like, what is it like master singers or great singers, right? These like long, these populations of interviews and you finish those books. And if you're not careful, you end up feeling like I have no idea how to sing. Because everybody says something different and sometimes they are directly contradicting each other. These like true divas.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean we're talking like Pavarotti. What is it? The Great Singers compilation book where you even just look at how they all describe breath and none of it is the same.

SPEAKER_00I have no idea how to breathe.

SPEAKER_01And yet you often walk in a studio like, okay, great. This is how you breathe. It can be a challenging thing as a teacher because yes, I want to go over that stuff. But then I also have to be very clear of actually how I breathe changes depending on the style, the genre. The day? The day, yeah, and how my breath is. Not all breaths are equal. My job is to show you, hey, did you know that you can also breathe here? Did you know that you can also feel your breath down here? Yes. Wait, I think we all agree that maybe don't do a clavicular, up-in-your-shoulder breath.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_00Because anatomy.

SPEAKER_01But maybe in music theater someone would come back and be like, well, but I need that because it sounds more emotional and it sounds gaspy during a song that's really overwhelmingly emotional. Okay, you know, and I think when it comes to, we can break down the styles more, but I think what it comes down to that we all have to acknowledge is how incredibly subjective What we do is. It is not, and I don't know other instruments super well, but it's so different from what other instruments do, which is a clear, like, this is how you strung the chord.

SPEAKER_00There's a lot more external variables that you can control when you're playing an instrument. Yeah. Right.

SPEAKER_01But we are all separate instruments built completely differently. Right. With different brains and different processes. Yes.

SPEAKER_00And different, like, body structures that Entirely. Yeah, I think one of the most helpful things that I've been noticing with my teacher lately is it feels very much like yoga. Like, what do you need today? Feel your body and, like, let's talk about... And I'm starting to realize now it's been months of her asking me this question. And at first I was like, I don't know. And so she then would say, this is what I'm hearing.

SPEAKER_00This is what I think you need. And then adjust my warmup accordingly. And I'm finally getting to the point where I'm like, I can tell based on how I feel that this is what I need. Now, I'm not at the point where I can always fix it immediately. But I can tell at least... Like, this is what I'm feeling. I think also, as you were talking, that using consistent language is really important, right? Once a student has identified sort of their vocabulary,

SPEAKER_00using that consistently is really helpful. But also iterative, like the same image is not always going to work. No, it doesn't. Yeah. But you can still iterate on like, okay, do you remember this thing over here? Okay, let's do that plus whatever. And I think also as you were talking about the breath, that whole yogic idea of like the beginner's mind, right? When you go from side to side and yoga, it's like not the same.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And when you go from day to day in yoga, it's not the same, same thing when you're singing, right? If from piece to piece, it might not feel the same from day to day, it's not going to feel the same. And so how do we train our singers and train ourselves to notice and respond?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that that right there is the key before even like breaking it down, because I also think between mechanistic and again, what we're talking about, imaginistic being Add some shimmer to that sound. Right. Or can you... I've heard you even use some of that. You feel like it's coming from... What's the terminology that you've used? The upper, middle, and lower...

SPEAKER_00Oh, feeling it in my head. Feeling the resonance in my head.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I've kind of heard you explain...

SPEAKER_00The first and second exit. There we go.

SPEAKER_01The first and second exit. Yeah. Which is very... Imaginistic kind of space with that. Yeah, so I think there's a fine line, very fine line between these where it's very blurry, where it's like, okay, well, Mechanistic can also be very, like, sensation-driven. But I also think of mechanistic as being very much, like, this is what the vocal folds are doing. We sing using the thyroidnoid and the cricothyroid. You know, like, looking at the muscles of the tongue.

SPEAKER_01Right. And, you know, understanding what the diaphragm actually is when you say sing from your diaphragm.

SPEAKER_00You can't do that.

SPEAKER_01We all know this. But anyway, so, like, things like that. And I think there's that extreme of, like, being very... Down to the musculature versus like seeing it like it's yellow, right? Like the two extreme opposites of that. So like just to kind of like frame where that is. But what I think is really important that you said is when we first start coming into this, there is always the, okay, what do you notice?

SPEAKER_01And I think we don't give that enough space.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01Because I, and I noticed this in my young singers too, especially ones that are skeptical when they first come in here. I'm like, great. What do you notice? And like, when has anybody ever been like, what are your feelings right now? What do you notice in your body?

SPEAKER_00Only in therapy.

SPEAKER_01Only in therapy. Right. And if they've had like parents that are like in that kind of space, you know, like if their parents are therapists or just the kind of people that are just much more in tune with their emotions, but it's not a thing that we take a lot of time to learn. And I actually think it's one of the best gifts that music has to give is self-awareness.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01But it's like they expect to understand it. They expect it to come in and be like, oh, this particular key on the keyboard is C. Hit that and that happens. And they kind of expect that to be the same thing with singing is like to come in and be like, OK, well, you know, you open your mouth like this and the note comes out. Well, maybe there's like 50 other things that could be happening there. But I think we need to lean into before we even look at style. There's the phase of,

SPEAKER_01I don't know, I have to start paying attention to my brain and my body and noticing. Yeah. And that stage can last a very long time.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, and I think similar to that with the time I think teachers also need to really lean in on the whole patience thing, right? I know how many times did I say the same thing, like the same five things to my kids, right? Over and over and over again. And finally, one day, one of them would go,

SPEAKER_01I get it. Or even better, they come back, guess what I learned from this other person? They told me to open my mouth. And I'm like, oh my God.

SPEAKER_00Wow.

SPEAKER_01So fascinating. I wonder if I've ever said that to you. I'm so glad you learned it from them.

SPEAKER_00Yes. But sometimes it just takes time for all the dominoes to line up, right? Self-awareness, being able to actually hear what you're trying to say, being able to actually do it, do it and hear the difference. All these things have to line up for the light bulb to go on.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Especially for younger singers.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01Like prefrontal cortex stuff.

SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, even me, I'm in my 30s, right? And there are so many things just in the last like two months, like in that one week with my teacher that I was like, oh, I get it. And I know you have said that like 50 times.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. But until you experience it.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01And I think it's like, yes, we can say it all we want to, but it's like, and this is where I think it's important to know both sides of the imaginistic and mechanistic is because I will say things 500 different ways.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01Until I see that light bulb. Right. Yes. Yes. This happens. And sometimes it's about something completely unrelated. Right.

SPEAKER_00Yep.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And it does require a massive level of patience on the teacher's side. But also the singer side. And that's not always something that we have.

SPEAKER_00That is so true. Yeah. And, and it, yeah, it is, it is like once you can do it, okay, can you do it consistently? And can you do it all the way, right? There are things I'm working on right now that, that I can do, like consistently, but I'm still finding new levels of Yeah. And I think also the...

SPEAKER_00Especially if I had a split group, like some kids that really responded better to imaginistic and some kids that responded better to mechanistic when I was teaching a choir. I think one of the quickest ways that I found... That I could fix a concept, right? Was to demonstrate it. But demonstrate it the correct way, but also demonstrate it with changing several variables, sort of like a matrix, right? Okay, so I'm going to take a big breath, but I'm going to constrict my throat.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Okay. I'm going to take a full breath, but I'm going to and I'm going to relax my throat, but I'm going to breathe with my shoulders. Okay. I'm going to do it correctly. I'm going, you know, I'm going to do it all. I'm going to constrict my throat and move my shoulders just so that they could. I knew that they were seeing all the iterations. And then it was a better success rate because there are so many variables.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So if you, you know, if you can demonstrate one correctly and incorrectly, but demonstrate incorrectly several different ways.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I think, I think this, this brings it to the point of, of how valuable knowing all, all colors of understanding, like, and I think There are two different jobs here. If you yourself are a singer and you have no intention of ever teaching, you only have one instrument you have to learn. Just one. And that's so much easier. And if that is what your goal is, great. Become that expert of your own instrument. And then you use that to find a teacher who is willing to work with you in

SPEAKER_01the way you approach your instrument. So I think that is such a different focus in getting to know your instrument super, super well, whether you sit on that mechanistic, imaginistic side. If you're going to teach, you don't have that luxury.

SPEAKER_00No.

SPEAKER_01Because you are going, I mean, essentially now I've worked with over 200 instruments. Not a single one of them did anything the same.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, I actually would argue with you about what you said first about being a soloist.

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_00Because you still need to know about other people's instruments and ways of thinking because you're going to have conductors that say things to you and you're like,

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's true.

SPEAKER_00I have no idea what you're like asking.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. No, it's true. That's true.

SPEAKER_00And so you need to have enough options in your head that you can guess.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, and I also I was actually thinking about this before we talked about this, because instinctually, I would say I'm a mechanistic learner. Cynthia might disagree. Because she uses imagery with me a lot and I respond well to it. Yeah. Sometimes that annoys the crap out of me that I'm like, why did she? She literally will sometimes say, can you sing it like it's blue? Can you sing it like it's red? And it does things. And I hate that so much. But I am really grateful that over the course of working

SPEAKER_01with my four different teachers, that all of them have had such different approach. And I am uncomfortable is not the right word. It didn't flow as well with some of my more imaginative teachers. But I would be completely remiss if I did not say that they taught me so much still. Like I want to learn to understand that language. And there were times that I remember just like looking and being like, what? Singing makes no sense. I don't know how any of this works.

SPEAKER_01And what did they just say? Because it means nothing to me. And I think we get trapped in that as students sometimes. I think we've talked about this before. It's so easy to be like, God, this teacher sucks because of that. And I think that's so rarely the case. I think it takes a lot to truly suck as a teacher. I think you have to just hate people. And not treat people like humans to suck as a teacher. But everything that a teacher says, I think we can find something in that to play with and to understand.

SPEAKER_01And I'm grateful that I had to stick it out with those teachers. Different situation for me. Mine were just clearly very They were very good and they were good at the human thing. But there were some that I understood less. But I would say the teacher that I probably understood the least was probably the one that got the expression out of me. That I didn't know how to pull out, that I actually couldn't pull out in a mechanistic way.

SPEAKER_00Well, I think that's an interesting point, right? Just like we've talked about, we both have had experiences with different teachers teaching different ways, right? And that's been good for us at different stages in our careers. Yeah. I think there's also something to be said for where you are in learning a piece and what's going to be maybe the most efficient way to coach that piece. If a student is just learning a piece... Hi, Zoe.

SPEAKER_01Zoe has come to join us. She has many thoughts about this.

SPEAKER_00Yes. If a student is just learning a piece, I don't know that teaching them using more imaginistic language is going to be super helpful because they don't yet have it in their body. Maybe. Versus if you're at the point where they need to get off the notes on the page and into the piece, I think at that point using more imaginistic language is probably going to be more helpful.

SPEAKER_00Not like warmups and just like general vibes in the studio. I feel like that's kind of another ball of wax.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, totally. That's interesting. I've got to think about that.

SPEAKER_00Thinking about it in like a more, you know, workshop coaching kind of situation.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I don't know that super imaginistic, if they're really early on in the piece, is going to be helpful. I don't know.

SPEAKER_01I mean, it depends on the level. Like if we're talking about we've got to get these rhythms down We've got to get the notes right.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. That's kind of what I'm... Yeah. Or they're just starting to figure out the whole of the piece. Yeah. I don't know that super imaginistic stuff is going to be helpful.

SPEAKER_01This is where and I'm thinking there's actually someone that I think we should have to talk about this later. Yeah. Because I think there was a friend slash colleague who grew up in the piano world. Yeah. And that's such a different world from the I think that is a very mechanistic world. Yes. Which is understandable.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And then I feel like for me growing up in music was in a very imaginistic world and it never felt like it fit. And so putting on the mechanistic felt really good. Yeah. Where she found that making piano imaginistic was what was needed in the piano world. And so we were kind of approaching, we've discovered that we were approaching this from very opposite directions of, oh, I'm trying to add more mechanistic into my world. Oh, I'm trying to add more imaginistic into mine. Weird that we're having this, like, because we had opposite reactions to that experience.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Because I think she tries to take, and I'd have, that's why I said it'd be really interesting to talk to her. She tries to take even learning it in a much more imaginistic, like, very pictured approach. And I'd be really curious about how she does, I mean, it's piano, but I'd be very curious about how she does that. And because I do think that some people do, and again, if they make It depends on what we're learning. And I don't know what the trend is going on right now, but I have found that for a while everybody wanted to do music theater all the time.

SPEAKER_01I'm feeling a switch already this semester. Everybody wants to do more pop songs and popular styles. I'm like, okay, I'm just kind of watching what's happening here. And that one is different because I wouldn't say it's quite as imaginistic. There's a lot of going back and listening to what an artist is doing, kind of imitation. And learning by like feeling the vibe of the song and responding that way that we would never do in classical.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01Right. So I think that also depends on the genre that we're playing with. I don't know if I would want to go, and sometimes I do because the students are learning how to read music, but I wouldn't go after popular music in a very mechanistic approach. I would kind of do the opposite.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01But again, that's where I think we're getting into blurred lines a little bit of like what truly defines that And then what are those things in between? Because I think, again, that quote from the book, this book is older.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So I'd be really curious about some of the literature out now that talks about what are these different pedagogical styles. I do think for a while they were at war. And I think we're finally being like, oh, no, like, a blend is good.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I also wonder, like, we've talked about this with some sort of tangentially with some different situations. Yeah. And I felt like this at points with the teacher. Do you ever... I personally feel like that the whole mechanistic thing was a reaction to teachers feeling like that other teachers were... This is like such a hot take.

SPEAKER_00We're like lazy.

SPEAKER_01Oh wait, okay, explain more.

SPEAKER_00Here's how I sort of see people that are very hard on one side or the other of this line, right? People that are highly mechanistic would say, well, the imaginistic people are just lazy and they're using this language as a cover for the fact that they don't know enough about vocal pegs. Yes. I would agree

SPEAKER_01with that.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01I think I agree with your hot take.

SPEAKER_00Not everybody, right?

SPEAKER_01But there was this superiority of I know more than you.

SPEAKER_00I know more than you about the body and how the voice works. Yes. Right? But on the flip side, People that were this is the stereotype of the imaginistic people, right, would say, well, those mechanistic people, they've like beat the life out of music. And I actually have heard teachers that are not hard liners on either side talk about experiences where, for example, I know a teacher, they inherited a student from a super mechanistic teacher.

SPEAKER_00And this student had learned, like, all the exact vowel modifications for, I can't remember, some, you know, like, teacher theorist person. Like, all the sort of perfect vowel modifications. And to the point that the singing sounded kind of bizarre.

SPEAKER_01Oh, interesting.

SPEAKER_00Mechanistically, though, it was, like, perfect. Yeah. Or you watch these, I mean a lot of early music people will talk about, this is like a big part of the early music world actually.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_00Which is the whole other, again, a whole other ball of wax of like older, more in the instrument world, the older players feeling like the younger ones have beat the roughness out of early music because they are more technically proficient on these reproductions of old instruments. And so, you know, they'll argue, no, we need to, you know, stay more imaginistic because, yeah, these, like, technically perfect things have, like, beaten the vibes out.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I don't know. It's just, I mean, I think there's some truth there, right? There's truth on both sides. People covering for not knowing enough about the voice.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Versus other people getting so technically perfect that then it just starts sounding weird or dead or... Yeah.

SPEAKER_01You know. You're not connecting to it. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And I think... Yeah, that is, in the end, the really tricky thing about music and about singing is, I mean, and I think in some ways this even relates to AI. If it becomes too technically perfect, then we start missing the humanity. Yes. And there does need to be some level of, like, imperfection or vibes only for it to retain its heart.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I don't know.

SPEAKER_01I agree with that. I think, I guess in my mind that adds on a third component. Because I think mechanistic, it's not even mechanistic, I think both sides can have a black hole of accuracy. Meaning you work so hard to be accurate in that specific space. Yeah. That you forget that what we do is art.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And subjective and human. Yeah. I think both sides can easily fall down that rabbit hole because it's you're not feeling things the right way. You're not picturing things the right way. Yeah. You're not... It doesn't, because I guess for me, I always picture that slightly differently. That's kind of like accuracy space. Because for me, when I think mechanistic, I think, oh, the voice sounds tight. Okay, I want to know, is that your tongue or your constrictor muscles? Right. Which is causing that, not like those are the only two options.

SPEAKER_01But oftentimes, it's one of those two. Sure. And here are the exercises that will physically get into that space. Yeah. And that, I think more of mechanistic as anatomically accurate. Yes. Where...

SPEAKER_00I guess the mouth, the vowel modifications, I mean, it is related to anatomy, but I see what you're saying. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Because that, even the vowel modifications, That can't be... I mean, yes, to a certain level, it can be mechanistic.

SPEAKER_00I guess I was thinking about it more with, like, the formants and all that stuff. Yeah, yeah. Which I do associate with the very mechanistic science.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, getting into very... I feel like maybe I picture the acoustical science a very different space. Okay. I'm not saying that that's correct.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01That's why I'm, like, sitting here, like, oh, interesting.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01That that's the... Yeah. Because that is a whole different beast, isn't it? Like, really... And that world has never... Been the one that I'm like, oh yes, I know. And I've taken classes on this, but my brain was like, what?

SPEAKER_00Yep.

SPEAKER_01Same. I don't know. Looking at the formants and understanding all of that and looking at a piece of machinery, which I think can be helpful.

SPEAKER_00I think it has its place for some learners. But at the same time, I recognize this limitation. There are plenty of recordings we have of some of the great singers, at least in the classical world. And the formant people cannot explain why what they're doing works. Because technically on the little formant machine or whatever it's called, It doesn't work. Yeah. It doesn't work. Yeah. You know?

SPEAKER_01Well, it's like hearing... Have you ever heard or watched the videos where they actually played vocal folds, but like without the upper body, like with the cadaver? Like they actually take vocal folds and put it over air?

SPEAKER_00Oh my gosh.

SPEAKER_01And it sounds almost like a kazoo. Like there's just, there's nothing to it. Right. That's a total sidebar. But it kind of makes me think of that as like when you get overly focused on formants, you're almost turning into that like very bland acoustical space. Right. Yeah. I think all of this is just like one more reason why all of the components need each other. And why, if you go to a mechanistic, I do feel like you've lost the play.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And the joy and the fun. Now, again, and I say that as someone who loves mechanistic teaching. Yeah. And who has taught other students who love mechanistic teaching. But I will confess, because I think I confess it to those students, is that even, I will find that as a starting point.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01But then as I go, I will be like, Okay, you can also call it this. What if we were to try, like, I kind of like feel out a student and be like, okay, well, let's play with it more this way and see what happens. And as I kind of had gained that trust of like, okay, I will speak their language for a while, but then let's look at it other ways because, and that can be hard. Some are very resistant. And really fight that. But as someone who has, again, been with teachers of all different styles, it makes you so much more well-rounded,

SPEAKER_01I think, to be in that space where you can think All those different ways, because there's not a single time where I don't step into a little bit of each of them. Right. I mean, yes, as a teacher, I really mean more in my own singing that I sometimes I'm thinking, oh, my gosh, I can really feel my tongue retracting. Like, let me let me pull out those tongue exercises because I can feel the tension back there today and I got to release that, whatever. And other days where I'm like, I got to stop thinking and I just need to sing like my voice is

SPEAKER_01the sparkly little song. Piece of jewelry. Not like I would ever think that exactly, but yeah, where that kind of space is really necessary and being able to be in both, I think just makes us better performers.

SPEAKER_00Well, yeah. I mean, I think just in the end, what you're saying is just something that I think we forgot and we're trying to recover is that as humans, we are a whole person. Right, we've forgotten this in so many areas.

SPEAKER_01And we continue to forget. Right, yes.

SPEAKER_00We're humans as a whole person, you know, mind, body, spirit.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00And if we neglect one or two or all of those areas, then... We start falling apart because we were never meant to function as one of those components and neglecting the others. But we're supposed to be attuned to all of those components and encouraging the integration of all of those components.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I think my thinking and where people could take this conversation Assess where you are and where you've been. And I would even say, think about what feels uncomfortable for you and maybe actively seek out someone who specializes in that space. Either like as a friend to kind of like talk through and like compare or take a couple lessons with a teacher you completely disagree with. Because I think you'll know...

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01When things feel really, really wrong.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01Like if something's tying you in knots.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01But I don't think there's anything wrong with occasionally learning from someone who thinks about it completely different from you. Because you may not like 90% of it. But without fail, there's 10% of something that someone can teach you in a way that you didn't anticipate if you're open-minded to it. So I feel like it would be It would be a very, I think, valuable challenge to anyone to try switching it up. If you're used to one way, check out another and see what you notice.

SPEAKER_01You might be mad about it. I find that I do. When someone starts explaining something in a way that I think makes no sense. For a while, like there was one time I literally walked out of a seminar because I could not... I was in my 20s. I remember being like, I think it was a conversation on chest voice and head voice. And someone would do an example of chest voice and they would sing. She's like, exactly. And I'm like, no, that was not it. And it was because for her, I was more like, no, I want to hear thick vocal folds.

SPEAKER_01And she was going for more of an acoustical sound and calling it. I was so ragey. Now I would love to go back into that and be like, okay, I want to understand that. Because what is she hearing that I'm interpreting as something else that I could have learned from in that moment? Because someone else without fail is going to feel that same way. And I think that was a little bit of my stage of mechanistic superiority when I was learning about all of that stuff. And I was like, oh my gosh, this stuff is so brilliant and it's better.

SPEAKER_01And I think I had my moment of that. And then I had to be like, oh, no. Because I am not wholly in that either, and I need that other space to be more expressive. So I feel like that would be an important challenge for especially young singers to play with, just to be curious.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01But then also, I think we all need to be more careful with our language. And I think especially, because this is where I see it the most, but teachers and social media content creators where... Don't go for the clickbait. Yeah, well, and yeah. And I'm immediately not going to try. In fact, that's usually what I will tell students. Like, I don't care if you online learn stuff from other people. Great. Go bring it in here. Tell me what you found interesting. Because that tells me more information about how you process and what you like. So I've got no qualms with you going outside and bringing stuff in. Yes.

SPEAKER_01Fantastic. You have an interest in learning? Well, I'm going to be like, no, don't do that because they're not going to teach you the right thing. No, do. But then let's bring it in and talk about it and then play with it and see what you're relating to. But I will tell them the ones I don't want you to listen to are the ones that say, don't do it this way. Do it this way. Because I just immediately don't trust them. Like if they're putting down a method, it's not helpful immediately. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I can only think of a couple of things that people would say, you know, don't do it this way, do it this way, that I'd be like, yes, you should say that. Like things that are anatomically false.

SPEAKER_01Okay, things that are like literally false.

SPEAKER_00As in sync from your diaphragm.

SPEAKER_01As in sync from your diaphragm.

SPEAKER_00That is one maybe we should say, don't do it this way. Yeah. Do it this way. Yeah, and

SPEAKER_01that's different.

SPEAKER_00Literally can't.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and also like, it's also like saying breathe from your diaphragm. It's like, okay, blink with your eyelids. I think that's a really good idea. You should, now, did you blink with your eyelids today? Did you think about that really, really hard? What else are you going to blink with? Oh, this is like such a song, but my favorite thing, and I hear that less and less, I will say, so I think education is really good. But for a while, I would hear people come and say, okay, and then I got to breathe in with my diaphragm. Like, great, what is that? And just like the stares back at me and I'm like, yeah, okay, this is why we don't

SPEAKER_00talk about it like that.

SPEAKER_01And then we got to get into that for a minute because that is my annoying little soapbox. So whenever they repeat that, I'm like, ah, how do I feel about that? You know I have opinions. So yes, there are things like that where, and like I think one other situation that happened a long time ago, and I might have mentioned this before, where a student came to me that had really, this was a long time ago, that had a really gravelly voice. And I was like, I was a really young teacher and like, okay, this is, it's consistently kind of scary. I don't know. So I like subtly brought up like, hey, maybe you should get this checked out.

SPEAKER_01And she was like, oh, well, my last teacher checked it out and said that I was fine. I didn't have anything. And I was like, what do you mean your last teacher checked it out? Can you like describe? Oh, well, she had me tilt up my head and just like felt along my throat and said that I don't have any nodules or anything. And I was like, oh my God.

SPEAKER_00That's not even a thing.

SPEAKER_01That's not remotely a thing.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So things like that. Yes. Okay. If something is anatomically incorrect. But if someone truly feels like they sing better and they do sound better when they sing as though they have a unicorn horn. Okay. Great. Shut up. That's okay. Lean in. It's like, great. Can you sing with the unicorn horn here? Because it's really working for you. You know? Yeah. Anyway, so yes, I totally agree with you. Like, there are those spaces,

SPEAKER_01but I think that's the kind of thing that I want to watch out for is, is it opinion that they're talking about? Right. Or is it... Like, do some research into that. It's worth looking into that. Yeah. But anyone who's automatically, like, putting down another person Based on how they approach their voice, I'm just immediately skeptical.

SPEAKER_00Well, at this point, we would love for you to come at us. Okay, don't come at us. But, you know, we would love to hear your hot takes about imaginistic versus mechanistic. Is there a hill you're absolutely willing to die on? Please let us know in the comments.

SPEAKER_01Is there another even approach that we're not even talking about? Right. A different color.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01Or a different method.

SPEAKER_00Right. Please let

SPEAKER_01us know. Share your thoughts on that.

SPEAKER_00Well, thanks to all you divas for joining us today. If you enjoyed today's episode, we'd love you to join the diva crowd. If you're listening on Spotify, please make sure to subscribe and leave us a rating. And if you're listening on Apple Podcasts, please subscribe and leave a review. That just helps us to get bumped up a little bit in the algorithm. And to get access to all of our podcasts, plus written articles and notes, subscribe on Substack at thedivadiariesblog. You can also follow us on our new Instagram page at thedivadiaries underscore blog

SPEAKER_00or follow our individual journeys on Instagram at caitlin.townsend.sings and

SPEAKER_01at Hamilton Voice Studio.

SPEAKER_00See you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Live with Diva Diaries: The Artist’s Way

    Nov 6, 202655 minAudio

    Thank you to everyone who tuned into our live video! Join our for our next book discussion in the spring on Trauma and the Voice by Dr. Koriath. Xoxo, Sarah + Kaitlyn Thanks for reading The Diva Diaries Substack!...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. A Day in the Life with Mira

    Sep 25, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    This episode was recorded in the summer months of 2026 Timestamps * Mira’s Story: Childhood Music, Writing, Grad School during Covid 0:42 * Post-College: Getting a “Real” Job 10:00 * Work-Life Balance and “What’s Your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. XOXO, Summer: A Heatwave to Remember

    Sep 8, 202615 minAudio

    Welcome back, Divas. 💋 Did you miss us? We certainly hope so, because we’re back from summer vacay and ready to once again pull back the curtains yet again on the things everyone is thinking but nobody wants to say out...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Summer Adventures: 2026 Edition

    May 25, 202656 minAudio

    TIMESTAMPS *Thank You + Call for Season 2 Guests! 0:39 *Sarah’s Plans: Unstructured Time, Having a Bedtime, PCOS, Gathering 2:13 *Kaitlyn’s Plans: Dixit Dominus, German + Italian, Reading List, Habits *Finishing The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Safe Enough to Sing Pt 2

    May 15, 202648 minAudio

    TIMESTAMPS *Episode Recap 0:28 *Dealing with & Recognizing Burnout (& an appearance from Zoey, the cat) 1:23 “Are you actually listening to what your body and brain [are] telling you [that] you need, or are you...

    Credit the people on this episode