0:00james Robert III: "Perfect health is a temporary condition. We're not just designing for people with disabilities today, we're also designing for ourselves in the future." Jodi (2): A gripper, a wristband, and a wheelchair made with a 3D printer. What could these possibly have in common? Keith (2): They were all designed to meet a need, but how well do they actually work for the people using them? Welcome to Disability Deep Dive. Today, MakeGood's James Robert III talks 3D printing and designing assistive technology.
0:31Jodi (2): In the Reef, HapWare's Jack Walters introduces ALEYE, a wristband that translates facial expressions into vibrations. Keith (2): In our Deep Cut, the documentary Objectified explores the thinking behind everyday product design. Let's dive in. Jodi: Before we get started, we provide visual descriptions for listeners who may benefit from them. I'm Jodi, a white woman with blonde hair, glasses, and blue eyes, and I'm wearing a black shirt with a black and white bow. Keith: And I'm Keith, a white man with brown hair and eyes, a graying
1:03beard, and I'm wearing a black shirt with yellow and white writing on it. Jodi: James, would you like to give us a brief visual description of yourself? james Robert III: Of course. My name is James Robert. I have brown curly hair, green eyes, a mixed complexion, and a white and purple plaid hoodie on. Jodi: Fantastic. Well, to start us off, could you introduce yourself to our listeners and tell us a little bit about the work you do at MakeGood, including how you found your way into assistive technology and 3D printing?
1:34james Robert III: So to tell this story properly, I feel like it does best justice to start at the beginning. born, I had no fingers on my left palm whatsoever, so my parents signed me up for an experimental surgery at the time. This is 2004. They signed me up for an experimental surgery in UCLA. With several specialists and plastic surgeons who took the toes from my left foot transplanted them into my left palm, so that way I could have
2:05two appendages that work together, kind of like a claw machine at the arcade. However, due to scar tissue development and myself being two years old at the time, I didn't take my physical therapy very seriously and developed lots of scar tissue and nerve damage over time to where now I only have one opposable digit on my left hand. Growing up in rural Louisiana, I was an athlete. I was a very well-rounded, uh, young man trying to do as much as I could on the
2:37farm and help in any way that I could. Through the process of that, I started putting together or welding and putting together scrap metal to strap to my arm to allow me to do different tasks, either at home or on the field, playing football or basketball or even running track. Through that process, I was introduced to LSU Engineering, and they did a few projects on me with their engineering students to create different types of orthosis and prosthesis that I could use at home or in sport.
3:09In that process, I was also introduced to the field of prosthetics. Jodi: Ah. james Robert III: At that time, I didn't even know prosthetics or orthotics was a word. But that's exactly what I was trying to do. Jodi: Yeah. james Robert III: And then cut to a few years later. I've since graduated high school. I'm now a sophomore at LSU. I'm introduced to this architect named Noam Platt, who is also volunteering at a disability gym down in New Orleans that focuses on helping people with every
3:40level of disability improve their physical capacity in any way that they can. I met Noam and worked on a few projects together making adaptations for wheelchairs. Then I had to unfortunately go back to school in Baton Rouge, and Noam continued doing his work in New Orleans. Then about another year or so later, he reached back out to me and invited me to join his nonprofit, MakeGood NOLA or MakeGood Inc. And through that process,
4:15I have explored types of riding devices, different types of ambulatory devices. We've completely 3D printed toddler wheelchairs Jodi: Hmm. james Robert III: start to finish. The tire treads, the straps, chest harness, seat cushions, the body of the chair itself, everything fully 3D printed. We've also done tons and tons of wheelchair adaptations, cup holders, phone holders, belt buckle holders, um, table trays.
4:48We've done potty chairs. We've done walkers and canes and modifications for each. And I've just fallen so much more in love with the field to the point now where I'm in graduate school actually getting my master's in prosthetics and orthotics. Jodi: Wow, fantastic. Keith: Nice. Gosh, I mean, what a journey. What an interesting, uh, st- story to get you where you are right now. I'm glad you started from the very beginning 'cause that's all fascinating stuff, you know?
5:18And, and that experience, I mean, that, that gives us, um, it gives you that personal connection to this work. Um, and, you know, knowing how to make something and knowing whether it works in everyday life, you know, are two different things, and so I think experience really matters, Um, james Robert III: Absolutely. Keith: So as you mentioned, you were born with a limb difference and, and today you help design technology for people with, with many disabilities, uh, and, and needs. Um, tell us more about how your own experience, uh, influences the way that you think about whether something is actually useful
5:50in a person's everyday life. james Robert III: So through my time with MakeGood, I've kind of been privy to helping define what the workflow is, how we would initially meet with someone, right? And then fi- find out through s- a few tests and measurements what they're physically capable of, and what they're can do on a repeated basis, like can use throughout the day, and trying to figure out what they want to be capable of and what they want to do and how they want to interact with the world around
6:24them, and make something to fit that gap that mainly fits the criteria of, is this a replicable movement that the person can do all day long, and will the device stand up to interacting with the ex- the external world all day long? And then what we do is right there in the middle, kind of fitting the hardest parts of each, uh, criteria and then, and then creating something that
6:58bridges them together in the safest and most efficient and most cost-effective way, which is why we use 3D printing. Jodi: Yeah. Yeah. One of the real neat things I s- I saw looking through the website and, and watching, uh, you guys on social media is you use this term "need knower," uh, for the person who knows their need because they, you know, live with it. What does it look like to make that person part of the design process from the very beginning?
7:30james Robert III: Honestly, it's the conversation. Like us talking right now, you know? Like actually getting to know the person on a more intimate level than just a patient-clinician relationship. We're trying to understand, like, "Okay, what time do you wake up in the morning? Well, why you wake up that early?" Or, you know, stuff like that. Or trying to figure out what is the hardest part of getting to school, right? And then going deeper into whatever we can from that really broad question, and then trying to, like, really figure out the exact details of what a person
8:04is capable of and what they can… what types of movements they can do a lot of throughout their day so that whatever we design is comfortable for them to use throughout their day. Keith: So once you get to that point, once you kinda have that better understanding of, of what this individual needs, how do you then turn that idea into something that they can actually use? Like, can you walk us through what happens from, you know, the first idea, uh, through designing, printing, testing, um, and then maybe making changes and
8:35back to designing and printing and so on? james Robert III: Yeah, absolutely. So I'd say at least 75% of the time, someone that comes to us with a request already has a general idea of what they would like. Our job is to take that into consideration, obviously, but then to also take into consideration would that be something that they can use? And then from there, We would take all of our tests and measurements to find out
9:05the, the constraints of how big something is that we need to make, and then we would go into the design process with the person, like, actively giving us input. So we would see, like, the size of their hand, right? To make something completely custom, we'd measure across the width of their hand, and then from the tip of whatever movable fingers that they can use to the base of the palm. Jodi: Mm. james Robert III: And we would use that as a radius for holding things so
9:35that we know it fits into a person's hand, just for an example, right? Keith: Yeah. james Robert III: Then we would print out our first iteration to make sure that everything is sized right. Then we would print out a second iteration, which is a functional test, to see if the actual mechanism that we make does the job it's supposed to do. Jodi: Mm-hmm james Robert III: And then we would deliver that to see if, okay, everything fits and everything works. Now let's see if the person likes it. Jodi: Mm. james Robert III: Hand it off at that point to the, the individual, and they
10:10would use it for a little while and give us any feedback that they may have. And let's say, for example, at this point, they don't like the color of the entire thing, and they don't like how the back end of it bulbs out into, like, a, a light bulb shape. Jodi: Okay. james Robert III: What we would then do, we would thin down the back whatever size they would like, and then whenever we reprint, we would just change the color. And then something else that we would take into consideration is printability of the device.
10:40So let's say we're printing a cylinder that fits into someone's hand, and functionally, it's to hold things going from up, up and down, let's say. Jodi: Okay. james Robert III: If we were to print something like that on its head, so with the part that's holding something at the base of the plate and everything else going up from there in a spiral direction. Whenever you're holding something sideways on it, the layer lines would snap.
11:12So functionally, it's not viable Keith: okay james Robert III: for, for extended use. Jodi: Mm-hmm. james Robert III: So that's something else we would change, would be the print orientation. So, instead of printing it on its head with the whole thing spiraling up, we'd print it sideways with the whole thing going longways across and across and across and across. That way, functionally, it could hold more weight or be much more durable to use for prolonged periods of time, without us having to worry about, okay, after twenty uses it's gonna break.
11:43Jodi: Yeah. Never thought about the orientation on, on there, how it prints, Keith: Sure. No. Jodi: really affecting that. And y- you know, that's where 3D printing becomes, you know, interesting because you guys also are not necessarily limited to just a single version of a product. Um, you guys have printed everything from writing tools and wheelchair accessories to, like you mentioned, the 3D-printed toddler mobility trainer. What does 3D printing allow you to do differently when you're trying to create
12:15something for someone's specific needs? james Robert III: Well, the, the elephant in the room is the cost. Jodi: Yeah james Robert III: Whatever we produce is gonna be pennies on the dollar compared to whatever's medically available or available through conventional means. And aside from that, the, the customability, I think is a major aspect. So being able to have complete creative control of whatever color, whatever design, whatever theme, that in and of itself makes any device more
12:48personable, or more unique, to an individual, which just increases their likelihood to adapt it or to use it Jodi: yeah james Robert III: in their daily life or to be comfortable with it. Jodi: Yeah james Robert III: Then, aside from that, everything that we do is we're, we're a nonprofit based in New Orleans. Everything we do is donated away. So we, we give lots of our devices away at conferences, at medical centers, to individuals in our community that we know could use them.
13:20And we're trying now to build a community of makers as well, of people with 3D printers at home who see a need in their community and can use our open source files to make devices for the people in their own community. Keith: Well, that's a-- Yeah, it's amazing. I, I love that, and that's a perfect segue. I mean, my next question was going to be talking about the designs. You know, you make a lot of your designs available as, as free open source files, so people can print them in other communities.
13:50Why is sharing the designs such an important part of the work? And, and what could that model change for people that have trouble getting assistive technology due to cost, insurance, where they live? So many factors, really. james Robert III: Essentially, we make all of our, all of our files publicly available because we see that there's a need for it. see-- We, we're, we're human as well. We see that insurance is through the roof, and they are so, so, so reluctant to sign
14:25off and pay for anything that it's just, it's diminishing our community capacity. It's diminishing our ability to interact with the external world. It's diminishing our ability to exist for some, in some cases. So we see it as-- One of, one of my favorite quotes of all time from MakeGood is from Noam. He said that perfect health is a temporary condition.
14:57We're not just designing for people with disabilities today, we're also designing for ourselves in the future. We're creating the community now of people who see that there's a need for this, so that whenever our time comes that we're at a state of "diminished capacity," we will be able to reap the benefits of what we're doing today Jodi: Great quote. That's awesome. Keith: Yeah, it's so true. james Robert III: And, and that's what I feel is at the heart of MakeGood, is
15:27making sure that everyone is taken care of, and that they can have access to what they need for very, very little cost. Jodi: Absolutely. james Robert III: Or, at the cost of just connecting with our own community. Jodi: Yeah. Yeah. That's great. So is there one project that changed the way you think about what good, uh, assistive technology can make possible? james Robert III: From my perspective, the one device that I would say increased
16:05my belief in what we were doing would be the Ulta holder, which is a cylindrical device that has two TPU, I guess, tooth parts, in the inside of it that you could push a toothbrush, or a hairbrush, or a screwdriver, or a pen or a pencil in it. And then there's a hand strap that holds your hand to the outside of this little cylindrical cone with the TPU pieces inside of it that you could
16:39use to strap your hand to the device. And then there's also several modular pieces. So there's a finger grip you could add on if you needed it. There's also a rough texture you could add on. There's little beaded texture you could add on just to-- anything to, like, help make the person's connection to holding the device a little bit better. Jodi: Yeah james Robert III: In my opinion, the versatility of use, the interchangeability of parts being that you can add whatever type of little custom grip you want
17:12onto it, you can change how hard it holds onto something depending on if the person has shakes or severe Tourette's, Jodi: Mm. james Robert III: if the person just has diminished dexterity in their fingers. It can serve such a wide variety of population that I think it's honestly one of the coolest things that we've made. Aside from, you know, the toddler mobility trainers, which are amazing in their own right.
17:43Keith: Yeah. james Robert III: But I think that the, the variety of patients that the Ulta holder can help is what kinda sets it apart. Jodi: Yeah, such a simple device, but it can, it can change so many people's lives with, with, uh, with the use of it. That's fantastic Keith: Yeah, that's a great answer. Yeah. Yeah, I love that. Well, before we let you go, we like to end our conversations, um, with something called we, the Deep Cut, where our guests leave us with something they think is worth spending a little more time with.
18:15So is there a book, a movie, could be a TV show, um, a song, a podcast, anything like that, that you love, that inspires you, or that you think more people should know about? james Robert III: He, it, there's two. Jodi: Okay james Robert III: There's two I'll, I'll pass on here. The story of Jim Abbott, who was a Major League pitcher with one hand. Jodi: Okay Keith: Okay james Robert III: and then the Netflix documentary Crip Camp.
18:45Jodi: Yes. Keith: yeah. Mm-hmm Jodi: Yes. It's such a good one. james Robert III: It is. It is. I saw it for the first time when I was at LSU getting my undergrad, and mind you, at this point in time, I had only heard the word disability for like a year. Watching Crip Camp just blew my mind. Like , I had no idea any of this stuff existed. Jodi: Yeah. Yeah, it, that, that movie really opens up, uh, the history of disability and the disability movement.
19:17It's, it's definitely a must-watch. Good choice. Keith: Yeah, no, for sure. Awesome Jodi: Well, James, thank you so much for joining us and giving us a look inside MakeGood. james Robert III: Of course. Thank you guys so much for having me. Thank you for inviting me out, and I'm glad to be here. Keith: We appreciate it. You know, one thing that really stands out from this conversation is where the process begins. The technology is important, but you-- first you have to listen to the person who understands the need because they're the ones living with it.
19:47Jodi: Yes. To learn more about MakeGood, explore assistive devices, or learn about its open source design, visit MakeGood.design. Keith: And you can find more episodes of Disability Deep Dive at DisabilityRightsFlorida.org/podcast or wherever you listen to podcasts. Jodi: If this conversation gives you something to think about, follow Disability Deep Dive and share the episode with someone who might appreciate it. Thanks again. Keith (3): All right. Hi, welcome back. This is The Reef, our brand new segment from Disability Deep Dive,
20:17where we bring in more voices from the disability community for focused conversations about the ideas, experiences, and issues that matter. Jodi (3): Today we're joined by Jack Walters, CEO of HapWare, to talk about ALEYE, a wristband designed to make facial expressions and body language accessible t- through touch. Jack, welcome to The Reef. We're so glad you're here. Jack Walters: Thank you for having me. Yeah, excited to dig in. Keith (3): Awesome. Well, before we get started, we'd like to give a brief visual description to our listeners. I'm Keith, a white man with brown hair and eyes, a graying beard,
20:49and I'm wearing a gray shirt. Jodi (3): And I'm Jodi, a white woman with blue eyes, glasses, and blonde hair, and I'm wearing a black long-sleeve shirt. Jack, would you like to give yourself a visual description? Jack Walters: Yes. Um, my name's Jack. Um, I'm a white male with, uh, curly blonde hair, blue eyes, and a gray button-up. Keith (3): Alright, well, Jack, to start us off please introduce yourself to our listeners and tell us a little bit about yourself and HapWare. Jack Walters: Um, so as I mentioned, my name is Jack and I'm the CEO and co-founder at HapWare.
21:20And HapWare is a assistive technology, um, company with the mission to make communication universally accessible. Um, and our flagship product is called ALEYE. and ALEYE is a wearable, it's a, a wrist-worn wearable, kinda like a watch, that communicates all the different non-verbal communication cues, like gestures, body language, facial expressions, the things that are usually largely visual, um, or difficult to understand. And we do this in-- We communicate this information to people who are
21:51blind, low vision or deaf-blind, um, primarily, and also neurodivergent. And then the way that we communicate the information to be accessible, um, right, because if something, if someone is blind or visually impaired, they can't get information in visually, perhaps. If someone is, um, deaf-blind, they might not be able to receive the information auditorial or visually. And then people that are on the neurodivergent or autism spectrum, it might just be hard to understand. So we communicate information all through the sense of touch or haptics. Um, so this is like different vibrations, um, and sensations
22:24all on the wrist that indicate the non-verbal cue that someone shows you. So if someone is smiling, you get like an upwards arc or U sort of smiling face on your wrist. We integrate with, um, you know, different cameras. So we integrate with the Meta glasses, we integrate with your phone and the phone camera, and then really just use that camera to pick up the visual scene and then translate it to our wearable all in real time. Keith (3): So cool Jodi (3): Fantastic. Well, you, you know, you said that ALEYE, uh, translates facial expressions
22:55and body language into vibrations. Um, what can the wristband help someone access in everyday interactions, and what possibilities do you see this technology opening up in the future? Jack Walters: Totally. Um, so at our core, you know, we're definitely an independence device and want to improve outcomes in employment, education, and then general social interactions. So in the employment realm, um, we're really thinking about intercommunication, whether it's a job interview or you're working with a peer, uh, a teammate in, in-- on a meeting, you're giving a presentation,
23:30you're talking to a customer, because over fifty percent of that communication is visual and non-verbal. So we really wanna be able to support people where they're at and in their employment process. Um, so being able to do all the communication that would be in the workforce. And then that kind of also fits very similar to education, you know, being able to get access and being able to communicate better with your peers. And then overall, just quality of life and social interactions, where we're really thinking about, you know, so much of the communication, whether it's whether you're on a date or you're with a friend or you're out to dinner.
24:02Um, we hear these stories all the time, like parents talking about being able to recognize their children's facial expressions when they do X, Y, or Z. Or their spouse, um, you know, when the waiter or someone around them is like, "Hey, it's over there," and they're pointing, and it's obviously inaccessible - visual. So, so really, like, those are our pillars of creating independence and then just opening up the layer of communication that is visual. Jodi (3): Amazing. Keith (3): that's awesome. so on October 15th, um, something, something big happened, right?
24:32Uh, something new that you guys wanted to share? Jack Walters: That's right. So, um, not to toot our own horn, but we were named one of Time's Best Inventions of 2026 in the accessibility category. Jodi (3): Congratulations! Keith (3): Awesome. Yeah Jack Walters: Um, so it's a huge award, you know, like one of the largest brands and presses, um, in the world. And, you know, we were super honored to receive that. And I think that what we're most proud of is, is, is really just that accessibility is being brought up on a national scale and that, you know, we get to play a small part in at least telling that story to the world that, you know, accessibility
25:05matters, um, that, you know, it's, it's, it's important and that, you know, we get to kind of show that, uh, communication accessibility through HapWare. So really, really excited. But I think it's just great for the industry as a whole, um, and the different communities that, you know, we all serve. Keith (3): That's tremendous. Yeah. That's wonderful. Yeah. Congratulations. Um, Jodi (3): Yeah. Keith (3): Yeah, it's such a cool product. I mean, so much of how we communicate happens without words, and it's interesting to think about how technology might, you know, make those interactions more accessible.
25:37So thanks so much for sharing your work with us, uh, and for joining us on The Reef. Jack Walters: Thank you. Yeah, thanks for having me. And for anyone that's interested, go to our website, follow us on social media. It's HapWare, H-A-P-W-A-R-E.com. Um, would love stay in touch. Jodi (3): Awesome. Thank you everyone for listening. This has been The Reef from Disability Deep Dive. Jodi Deep Cut: Up next, is this week's deep cut.
26:08Jodi (2): For today's Deep Cut, we're talking about Objectified, a documentary from filmmaker Gary Hustwit that explores something we probably don't spend much time thinking about: the design of everyday objects. From toothbrushes and kitchen tools to phones and other technology, the film takes us behind the scenes to meet the people who decide how these products look, feel, and function. Keith (2): While Objectified isn't specifically about disability, it raises some interesting questions about how products are designed, the people they're intended for, and what happens when someone's needs are overlooked.
26:41So today we're talking about what makes good design, how the things around us influence our lives, and where accessibility fits into that conversation. Jodi (2): Right, so the film starts with something most of us probably take for granted. Practically everything we use has been s- been designed by someone. Keith (2): Yeah. Jodi (2): So after watching Objectified, did you find yourself looking at any everyday objects differently? Keith (2): Yeah, some for sure. Uh, you know, when, when you, when you step back and, and think about how things are made, 'cause we, you know, we don't think about that so much. We just have our objects, we pick things up, we use them.
27:12Uh, sometimes, uh, when you go… If you step back and think about how these things were made, you have a much bigger appreciation for, for, for what they are and, and, and, and the thought that might have, you know, gone into them. Uh, I, I, you know, we may not automatically think about, you know, why is this button here? Jodi (2): Mm-hmm. Keith (2): you know, why is the, the, the height of, of, of this, you know, counter, uh, you know, where it is? Or, Jodi (2): Yeah Keith (2): how much strength to open something. But, but, uh, all those little decisions, you know, they really determine how
27:44someone can use a product independently. Jodi (2): Yeah. The other thing is there's this thing on, on TikTok where people are talking about car tongs. And they're the little, like, hot dog tongs or kitchen tongs that you use, but people are keeping them in their car for, like, pushing ATM buttons or getting, like, receipts from, you know, like, the parking garage or whatever. And the first time I saw those, I was like, "Girl, that's been around for short people forever." Like, I have so many different lengths.
28:18Like, this is … You should've had car tongs years ago. Keith (2): Wow. Jodi (2): I even got, like, different length ones depending on what I'm trying to reach in the kitchen. But I just think, you know, it, it's, it's coming across, it's that universal design again. It's, you know, it's designed for maybe flipping hot dogs. Then people with dwarfism use it to grab things. Now everybody's using it because they can't necessarily reach things outside their car. And I, you know, it's an everyday tong, but now it's got multi, multi purposes to it. Keith (2): Indeed. Yes, indeed. I've got my grabber tool as well, actually.
28:49Jodi (2): Yep. Keith (2): yep. Well, one thing that surprised me about the film was how much attention designers give to the smallest of details, you know, from the shape of the handle to the material something is made from. What did you find most interesting about the way these designers approach their work? Jodi (2): Um, one of the things, 'cause I, I try to look at it from an accessibility lens, and just because they're, you know, paying attention to every tiny little detail doesn't make it accessible to other people.
29:21And where that gap is, is the people testing these products, um, should be from a, a, a wide range of people, um, including people with disabilities so that you can see where, where, where the gaps are. Keith (2): You know, that's very important, you know, and they don't really, they don't really go into that. Um, but it's true. It, it-- That's-- You, you need different types of people with different abilities to test and, uh, yeah, that's, uh, very important. I mean, you know, des- design is essentially like a, a
29:55form of problem-solving. You know, they kinda talked about some of this. And, you know, the thing is, what might be a problem to solve for you might be a different problem for someone else. Um, and if you're solving one, doesn't mean you're solving the other one. Uh, Jodi (2): You could be making a problem. Keith (2): You might be. You might be, you know? So something can be very thoughtfully designed but still be quite inaccessible, Jodi (2): Yeah. Yeah. Keith (2): you know? Jodi (2): So one of the examples, uh, that they talk about in the story that stood out to me was, uh, the vegetable peeler. Uh, Sam Farber realized his wife Betsy, who had arthritis, was struggling to
30:29use a peeler, and that experience helped inspire a redesign that ultimately became popular with a much wider audience. I, I looked and it- that's exactly what my vegetable peeler looks like, but I didn't pick it, you know, because Keith (2): Sure Jodi (2): for me, for gripping. It's, that's just kind of what's out there now and universally what carrot peelers, you know, are starting to look like. So what do you think makes such an interesting example of how, you know, products can evolve? Keith (2): Yeah. I, I think that was a, a, a wonderful example. And I, you know, I'm in my 50s, so I remember very well helping my mom in
31:01the kitchen and using that metal aw- Jodi (2): A little thin? Keith (2): Oh my God. And it's not com- I don't, I don't really care who you are, that thing's not comfortable. You know, it wasn't designed for comfort, it was designed for utility, and that was it. Jodi (2): Mm-hmm. Keith (2): Um, and but that's, that's it. That's… You wanted a vegetable peeler, that's what, that's what you got. Jodi (2): Yeah Keith (2): and I can't tell you when it changed, but I do remember, like, you know, maybe, I don't even, I don't know how long ago, but at some point there started, there, there started being options, and there was a handle. And it, it was… I remember… It's so funny they picked that item because
31:32I remember s- thinking the same thing when, like, finally there was one of the… And I can't remember if I was, I had moved out, I'm alone or I'm, this is still at my pa- I don't know. It was at some point in my life there was another vegetable peeler, and it had this nice grippy handle, and I was like, "Well, why didn't anyone think of that before?" You know? Because this other thing has been crap. I hated this thing. So, uh, it's funny. That's an object that I've really thought about in the past, and so that they picked that as an example really, really resonated with me, um, 'cause I remembered it very well. Um, and yeah, I mean, it's, it makes it better for everybody.
32:04Jodi (2): Mm-hmm Keith (2): You know? Um, I didn't have an issue with grip strength or, or, or, or disability in my hand, but boy, that made it so much easier to hold, you know? Um, Jodi (2): Absolutely Keith (2): yeah, yeah Well, the film shows that even something as simple as a handle can take a surprising amount of testing and experimentation to get right. What did that process tell you about the differences between having a good idea and creating something that actually works? Jodi (2): Well, one of the, the big things is, you know, real world use is different
32:36than testing a prototype, you know? And, uh, you know, I don't know how many times we say this, we need to get it on a T-shirt, you know, disability is a spectrum. It's not a single experience. You know, people, you know, who use wheelchairs, they- wheelchairs come in all different heights, you know? And people who are visually impaired are on a spectrum. So it, it's… disability isn't this single exper- experience. So something that works for one person with arthritis may not work for someone
33:06with li- limited finger movement. You know, that carrot peeler, back to that, is great, but I have small hands, so it is still a little big in my hand. Keith (2): Okay. Yeah, Jodi (2): to use. So it, it's much nicer than using that small, teeny thing that it, that was almost torturous, but it's still not quite right for me. Um, so I think testing and who's doing the testing and using it, uh, for extended periods of time, uh, you know, will help with that, you know, universal design process.
33:38Keith (2): Yeah, that's interesting. Like, the handle doesn't have to be that big. It could be smaller and still be comfortable, right? You know. Jodi (2): Yeah Keith (2): You know, you know, another aspect, uh, you know, I, I, think, you know, for something to be truly accessible, I think it also needs to be reliable, you know? I mean, if you're using assistive technology every day, um, that thing needs to work, you know? Um, I mean, how often have we seen, you know, stories of, individuals who suddenly their wheelchair breaks? Jodi (2): Yeah. Keith (2): For them, that is, that is r- that ruins their day, their week, their month maybe.
34:09It depends. I mean, sometimes it can take forever to get them repaired. Jodi (2): Right Keith (2): it-- that is, you know, that is, that is such a huge thing, and that's because, you know, they're using it most of the day. I mean, uh, you know, that's Jodi (2): Yeah Keith (2): you know, their, their, their, their, their life is that wheelchair. And so, um, you know, the, the, the more durable and reliable something can be, I think that also has a lot to do with, uh, accessibility. Jodi (2): Yeah, I bet you people with dwarfism go through a lot more tongs than people without.
34:41Keith (2): Oh my God, I'm, I'm picturing the, the tong use bar chart Jodi (2): Yes. So the design… Keith (2): that? Sorry, go Jodi (2): Maybe, maybe I need to do that, Keith (2): That's Jodi (2): conduct some of that research. Keith (2): Yes Jodi (2): the designers in the film have different ideas about what makes a product successful, and some emphasize the simplicity and the practicality, while others focus, you know, on appearance and creativity or how an object actually makes someone feel. So do you think there's a point where making something visually appealing can
35:13actually interfere with making it useful? Keith (2): I mean, yeah, for sure. I think, you know, minimalist design is, is, you know, sometimes can really look, you know, stunning. It's the simplicity of it can look great. But I mean, that, that, that in itself can create accessibility barriers, Jodi (2): Mm-hmm. Keith (2): Um, uh, so if you're, if you're missing features and you're making it as simple as possible, um, it may be there's something that's not there now that that individual used to rely on to make it work.
35:45Um, I think a good example of that too is, you know, the touchscreens we have for most things as opposed to buttons. Um, if you need tactile feedback, that's a problem, you know, unless there's some, you know, really amazing accessibility software. Uh, th- thankfully, smartphones have kind of figured it out, but there's plenty of other touchscreens out there that have not. And so making accessible touchscreens is still a, a big problem. Jodi (2): And I, you know, when, on the opposite side of, you know, making things look good, most of the time when you're talking about accessibility, uh,
36:19things, tools, they're very clinical. Um, they're usually all, like, either white or have, like, blue grippers. Like, you can tell when you look at it, like, oh, that's a, uh, an accessibility tool. And if someone's using it in their real life, uh, they want it to match their personality and, you know, have an aesthetic to it as well. So, you know, uh, uh, on the same token, you know, there's no reason why… And we're starting to get there, where, like, wheelchairs
36:49can be pink and green and red and, Keith (2): Sure. Yeah, Jodi (2): you can have some of your tools come in this, these cute little pouches. Um, so th- we're slowly starting to get there. But, Keith (2): And groups like MakeGood, I mean, we just talked to them earlier in the episode, and, you know, they, they make things that are, like, a lot more attractive, you know, that kids might want to use, you know? Jodi (2): Absolutely. So you don't have to sacrifice look, um, for, for it to be, be accessible. Keith (2): Absolutely. The film also explores how objects can become a part of your identity.
37:22Think about, uh, the products that people are loyal to, the things they collect, and even something they've kept for years because it means something to them. Why do you think we sometimes develop such strong attachments for everyday objects? Jodi (2): Well, I think because a- a lot of times, you know, looking at it from a disability point of view, this tool, this thing that you're using represents this independence, you know, that we're always talking about, and this freedom that you have. It becomes part of you. You know, people sometimes name their things.
37:54You know, this is my wheelchair, you know, Betty or Bob or whatever. Um, because it becomes an extension of you, it becomes something that you use every day. Hopefully, it's reliable enough that you're using it for years, and, you know, you have the ability to decorate it and customize it and choose colors and features that are for you, and, and y- you have your ability to express yourself. So I think they become part of the person that, that uses it, and I think that's why people form this, you know, this attachment.
38:29Keith (2): For sure. Yeah. I've seen the back of your scooter. You've got all kind of, uh, interesting stickers and personality on that, you know, and that's great. Um, uh, you know, I think also another way to look at it too is, you know, uh, we get comfortable with the devices that we're used to, and we don't always have control, you know, over the path those objects take in production, and so what if something that you love, breaks down and needs to be replaced, but that same model doesn't exist anymore? Jodi (2): Oh, it's the worst. Keith (2): They've changed it a bit and it's not quite right, you know?
39:00Um, Jodi (2): Yeah Keith (2): That's a, that's a big deal. You know, these objects are essential, and, losing it means losing access to everyday activities. And if, if something has changed, you've gotta learn how to readapt and, and change and, you know, it's a big-- it's a, it's a bigger deal for people with disabilities than just someone, you know, with a piece of tchotchke or something on their, you know, their, their mantle that looks good. Jodi (2): Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. So something the film, you know, made me think about is how designers make decisions about who they think is going to use the products.
39:33You know, sometimes those decisions are based on assumptions of, you know, what the average person can do. So what kind of problems, um, can that create for people whose needs fall outside, you know, the average person's, uh, uh, ability and expectation? Keith (2): Yeah. Well, if you learn anything from listening to this podcast, there is no average person. I mean, you know, that's the whole kind of point of this, is that we're all different, we're all unique, and we all have different heights and strengths and, you know, mobility methods and sensory abilities.
40:05And, and even ways of, of thinking and processing information. Jodi (2): Sure Keith (2): but, you know, products are unfortunately often designed around that narrow idea of what the, quote, "typical user" looks like or can do. Um, that and accessibility comes with, you know, additional cost maybe, where someone with a disability might have to purchase adapters or, specialized equipment, uh, make modifications. Those things are important and need to be considered. Jodi (2): Yeah. When, you know, a lot of times when people struggle to use a product, they are
40:37assuming it's because of their disability and not a problem with the product. Um, and, you know, to me that assumption is maybe the, the design is too narrow a range of, of human, uh, abilities. Keith (2): Yeah. I mean, you know, th- th- the idea of the people not being disabled, the world being disabling around them, you know, comes into play here too. You know? Like, these, these objects are made for what they think the typical
41:07user is, and that leaves out a lot of people, and that's, you know, so, that sort of, you know, way of looking at disability is that, you know, these, inaccessible objects are what make the world inaccessible, not the fact that you have a disability. Jodi (2): Mm-hmm Keith (2): and that's, you know, s- talking about product design, that's, you know, that's huge. That's what Jodi (2): Yeah, I bet you the hot dog tongue guy had no idea. Keith (2): No idea at all. No idea. I, I-- There were a couple of, uh, designers though, I think maybe the, maybe it was the same ones in the beginning that talked about the
41:37vegetable peeler, um, though had the perspective of that the product needs to work on like two extremes. Like, you can't just look at the average person. It needs Jodi (2): Yes Keith (2): you know… And I forget how they define those extremes, but, you know, someone that like, you know, it's the easiest thing in the world to use and someone that might be u-the most difficult thing to use, and you gotta find a way to make it as workable as you can for b- And that was great to hear that someone thinks of it that way. But you're right, a lot of the other designers didn't see it like that. They saw it as sort of like finding the average, you know?
42:09Jodi (2): Yeah Keith (2): that's, that can be a mistake. Jodi (2): Yeah Keith (2): Well, one of the directions the film takes is into consumerism and sustainability. We live in a world where there's always a new version of something, right? And we, we're often encouraged to replace products that even still work. How does that constant demand for something new affect the way products are designed? Jodi (2): Ugh. Be- you know, the big thing is we were just talking about how, you know, you use a product for years and it becomes an extension of you.
42:39And, you know, for people with disabilities, uh, they can lose accessibility when, when they redesign a product, um, uh, and replace things with, you know, from physical buttons to now touchscreens or the software updates, um, and things that were once familiar on, on the screen that you've finally gotten used to, to using is now completely different. And, you know, you had mentioned it- how you take a product and sometimes people with disabilities have to adapt that product with other things.
43:11So now you have to go back and buy new things that fit, um, you know, new cases for your phone with grippers or whatever. And so there's a financial cost to people with disabilities that, you know, the average consumer may not have to incur. Keith (2): Yeah. Yeah. You know, um, I, I, I agree with all of that and, and, and I do wanna though-- the flip side is that innovation itself isn't necessarily a bad thing, right? Because technology, just to make sure we're clear here, technology has opened up some incredible opportunities for people with disabilities.
43:43So we don't want to say that like, you know, making advancements is automatically a bad thing. But the idea of if it works, why are we changing it necessarily? Um, you know, uh, I, I-- sometimes it's just about fashion styles and, and, and trends that change, and so the object has to change with it. Does that mean we can't use the old one? Uh, I don't… I mean, I think that's, that, that's sometimes an absurd question. Like, you don't have to buy new things just because, you know, your taste or style has changed. Um, but yeah, you know, technology in itself, you know, the innovation
44:16that might lead to bigger and better things for people with disabilities, we're all on board. Jodi (2): Yeah. Yeah. Keith (2): Keep that up, definitely. Jodi (2): Yep. Just design with us in mind. Keith (2): Please Jodi (2): So today we explored Objectified, Gary Hustwit's documentary about the everyday products we use and how people design them. Keith (2): It's interesting how something as ordinary as a vegetable peeler can lead to a much bigger conversation about creativity, usability, and understanding how people interact with the things around them. Those choices can have a real impact on people's lives, especially
44:49when it comes to accessibility. Jodi (2): To learn more about Objectified and explore Gary Hustwit's other films, visit hustwit.com/objectified. Keith (2): And that's our deep cut. Maybe the next time you reach for something you use every day, you'll think a little differently about how it was designed, who the designer had in mind, and maybe how to even make it better. Jodi (2): Yeah A big thank you to James Robert III from MakeGood for joining us to talk about assistive technology, 3D printing, and the importance of involving people with disabilities in the design process.
45:21Keith (2): Also thanks to Jack Walters from HapWare for joining us on The Reef to explore ALEYE and the possibilities of making nonverbal communication more accessible. Jodi (2): Our Deep Cut, Objectified, gave us another perspective on the everyday objects we use and how the choices designers make can affect our lives. Keith (2): Best solutions start with understanding the people who will use them. Jodi (2): Thanks for joining us. Follow Disability Deep Dive wherever you get your podcasts or watch us on YouTube. Leave us a review or comment while you're there. Keith (2): And you can find more episodes or use our new contact
45:53form to get in touch with us at DisabilityRightsFlorida.org/podcast. Disability Deep Dive is a podcast that is brought to you by Disability Rights Florida, where real conversations about life, culture, and ideas, meet the lived disability experience. Follow us on YouTube, Spotify, and wherever you get your podcasts. You can also find us at disabilityrightsflorida.org/podcast