Send us Fan Mail If you’ve ever wondered why New Zealand can’t seem to build medium density housing that feels calm, green, and genuinely liveable, this conversation puts a spotlight on the real blockers and the real opportunities. This episode we’re joined by Wellington architects Tim Gittos and Caro Robertson from Spacecraft Architects, fresh off winning the F. Gordon Wilson Fellowship for their research project DIY Density. We get specific about what “DIY” actually means here: not people building their own houses with their hands, but everyday owners and small groups having the tools to lead development decisions, rather than settling for developer-led products. Tim and Caro explain why the three-storey walk-up is such a powerful missing-middle typology, how it can replace “sausage flat” backyard infill, and why facing the street while going up can preserve light, privacy, and neighbourhood character. We also talk about what matters beyond the dwelling: arrival, shared outdoor space, fewer driveways, stronger streetscapes, and keeping trees and permeable ground so our suburbs don’t bake and flood. The big theme is certainty. We unpack why risk and unknowability around consenting, cost, and process stops good housing before it starts, and how replicable models, precedents, and even pre-consented pathways could make affordable housing more achievable. Tim and Caro share insights from their work on the New South Wales Housing Pattern Book, including what it takes to make pattern books useful in the real world, and who might administer something similar here as planning rules evolve. If you care about urban design, housing affordability, walkable neighbourhoods, and building better cities in Aotearoa New Zealand, hit play, share it with a mate, and subscribe so you don’t miss what comes next. After listening, what would convince you that medium density could be a better way to live? Please Like and Subscribe it really helps :) Follow us on @designpriciplespod on Instagram and if you wish to contact us hit our DMs or our personal pages. We love to hear from you it really encourages us to keep going and the ideas and feedback we get from the listeners is awesome!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome back. This week Ben makes his long-awaited return to the fold, and we are joined by Tim Geddos and Caro Robertson from Spacecraft Architects, recent recipients of the Gordon Wilson Fellowship for their project DIY Density. Tim and Caro received their award last week at the Insitue conference, and I was lucky enough to sit down with them and have a chat about their submission. For those that don't know, Tim and Caro are Wellington-based architects whose work has a strong focus on housing, urbanism, and finding smarter ways to make our cities work harder without losing the things that make our neighborhoods good places to live.
SPEAKER_00The fellowship research looks at how we might approach medium density housing in a more flexible, accessible, and genuinely people-focused way. Today we're going to talk about DIY density, what they've learned through their fellowship submission, their involvement with the New South Wales Housing Patent Book, and what all this might mean for the future of housing in Altera. So let's dive in.
SPEAKER_00Caro, first of all, congratulations.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, congrats.
SPEAKER_00Thanks. Winning the Gordon Wilson Fellowship. For those of you out there that don't know, Tim and Caro, aka Spacecraft to Arctics, have won the Gordon Wilson Fellowship this year for affordable housing. I think is the outline of it, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01They've just changed it from public housing, I believe.
SPEAKER_00Was it 200 2023? I think they changed it to affordable.
SPEAKER_01Might have coincided with the government defunding public housing, but I hadn't thought about that.
SPEAKER_00Not a lot of information about your guys' submission out there other than what's on the NZIA website and your submission being DIY density. Do you guys want to take us through what that is and what that means and what your submission was about?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so the DII aspect is confusing people because they think we mean for people to build their own houses with their hands. But we're really talking about the development aspect of building.
SPEAKER_01We've worked on a bunch of co-housing developments and even just smaller, dense or semi-dense owner developed projects, I guess, as most architects, and just realize the value of people being able to run their own ship in that regard. Not relying on developer-provided housing. And realizing that if people are kind of in charge of what they're getting, they might make different decisions and get a better outcome. Really, we're just looking at what would be an appropriate scale and uh sort of desirable urban form for infill developments that will provide more density than's currently being allowed under things like the MDRS and that kind of thing.
SPEAKER_00So is that what led you guys to that three-story walk-up topology? Is that did you kind of see that as being the silver billet scale solution?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it it feels like it ticks a lot of boxes. I guess the the first one being that I guess since the MDRS happened and the rollout of a lot of infill, generally townhousing developments, which tend to take the form of running deeper into the block. We call them sausage flats. And so inevitably you're creating a whole lot of overlooking issues with the neighbouring site, which is also eventually going to do the same thing. And you've got a whole lot of site used up for vehicle manoeuvring, getting garages deeper into the site, and basically covering up a whole lot of bare land that can otherwise be used for gardens or trees, protecting existing trees, that kind of thing.
SPEAKER_01Storm water infiltration. So by flipping from a sausage flat to a walk-up that faces the street, you get you get all the amenity of light and view from your street boundary and then from your backyard boundary, which you're not, you know, building into because you've gone up instead.
SPEAKER_00The topology that you guys are exploring, that sort of three-story walk-ups, it's not new. It's essentially it's been done for a long time. You know, think of British terrace houses or American brownstone walk-ups, that sort of thing. The development that you guys are kind of focusing on, is it more individual houses, or is it looking at that three-story walk-up being like this co-habitation co-housing type solution?
SPEAKER_05So the framework that I think we see a lot is the three-story walk-up is provided by public housing funding. And that's one of the things we're obviously missing a bit of, and then social problems get layered on top of the specific housing type that in our experience are not necessarily associated with the type of housing, but by with the kind of amenity that goes with it and the community that's living in it.
SPEAKER_01It's kind of a baby in the bathwater type thing, right? Where it's like that's a really good functional housing type with heaps of amenity, a lot of benefits, but yeah, has it become seen as undesirable because of, you know, unsuccessful versions of it in the past?
SPEAKER_05I've been cracking up thinking about how many people leave Altero and go traveling and like love these towns that have this three to four-story, predominantly housing in villages, and you know, they that's what they they're going there for, and then couldn't kind of process what they would mean for their own lives here. We're just so keen on having better garden and green space. And one of the things we're seeing is there are other owner-developed projects of that scale in other countries. So once you when you realize that a lot of the quality of a place is whether somebody's bought into living there, uh we have a huge renter moving on, problem culture in this country.
SPEAKER_05And so it's it's kind of looking more at how what tools people would need to create their own housing that they could then invest in in that kind of long-term, this is where I live, neighborhood life.
SPEAKER_00And do you guys see that as being, and you've already touched on it, do you see that ownership, I guess, for want of a better term, being a potential solution to that New Zealand mentality or that the struggle that we have in adapting to a new style of living? You know, not your that quarter-acre dream that's so entrenched in our society. And like you said, you go traveling and you you live in these other places and you love them and they're great and you think they're, you know, you think they're wonderful and you come home and you go, oh no, I couldn't do that yet. Uh is the whole kind of ownership model that you guys are looking at, is that sort of the angle that you're taking to potentially solve that societal adaptation issue?
SPEAKER_05I mean, that's the way that we've got ourselves into housing. We came out of the architecture degree and we understood the tools beyond just the building that allowed you to get into the housing market. So subdivision, property purchase price, there are some things that we can take advantage of because we had the skill set. And then I guess having achieved that successfully for ourselves, we've looked at how you could use that same knowledge to help other people.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and looking at like say with the Buckley Road project that we did, which was four households on one suburban section. And, you know, that that went really smoothly. The client group was amazing, they really switched on, they knew what they were trying to achieve, and the the uncertainty and the risk involved didn't put them off. But in reality, you know, not everyone's got that risk profile. So to us, it's like if you can make that a bit more of a certainty, make it something that you can see before you start the process and go, hey, do you guys want to do something like this?
SPEAKER_01And you've got something to point to, rather than just saying, Hey, do you want to commit money and time and resources to doing something that we don't know what it is and we don't know what it costs, and we don't know if we'll be allowed to do it, but sounds like a good idea. Like there's just too much uncertainty in that. So by the idea of having a whether it's a pre-approved thing or it's just a a precedent that gives people a sort of touchstone, um, that seems like a a a sort of important resource to help that become more accessible.
SPEAKER_05And I actually don't think we would have been as audacious as we are at this point at the beginning of our careers, because we wouldn't have confidently felt like the the core needs of people in housing were that similar. And our co-housing project work has really drawn that out. That as much as people and a lot of architecture chat is about bespoke housing and how well it suits the people who live in the house, when you kind of zoom out at that, you realize a lot of housing is produced to make money and not to suit people. And so what we're really critiquing is the current model of getting houses to market.
SPEAKER_05They are optimized for things that are not what people need in a house. And so that's that's the angle that we're coming at this from is when people get to choose for themselves, what do they choose, and then normalizing that and making a pattern out of that.
SPEAKER_00You guys have developed from that, like you said, coming out of architecture school and kind of doing how do we design a good house for ourselves, but using different models and methods to do that, moving now into what is a better way for producing housing for all. Would you say that you've kind of incrementally or iteratively throughout your career has kind of jumped, made these jump steps with I guess pattern, the pattern book, and we can talk a little bit more about that, being this last stepping stone before jumping into this new DIY concept? Because there's similarities. I feel like there's similarities throughout the whole lineage.
SPEAKER_01I guess the common thread, one or one of them anyway, is that we have always believed that, you know, architecture should serve a broader audience, that it shouldn't be the preserve of, you know, the you know, exclusive beachside golf course subdivision or the, you know, the penthouse apartment suites or whatever. So it should be more accessible just as an everyday common good, you know. And then I guess through doing the work as the economy's shifted and people's expectations have changed, that's gone from being, I guess for about 10 years in Wellington, we could we could help people get a house where if they got a little scrap of land and we we could design them something and get it built basically for round about the same cost as a drafty old villa next door, and they'd get a much better house that that reflected their their life and what they wanted to do.
SPEAKER_01And as the economy of that's changed, that I guess led up to doing our own house where we split a section with our good mates and you know, neighbours of 10 years now, and seeing the benefits of of having some uh, you know, just neighbour neighbourliness. That was your one. And then up to Buckley Road. It's like the logical extension of that is you know, attaching houses closer together, uh making sure they're still close to the city, and maybe less focus on the the individuality of the design every time and just what constitutes a good house in the city, you know.
SPEAKER_05On the Block Party project, they picked up the existing single family home that was there and replaced it with four houses. And I just keep thinking about what that would be like on if we moved city the building stock kind of in large quantities into regional areas and replaced them with, you know, it's really hard to work around existing building stock. Uh, and especially because some of them are in great condition and some of them are in terrible condition. And so that's I think partly why we're so focused on the infill aspect, because the cityscape is really important to us and the the kind of amenity of being able to network into places and and stay in our communities that we've already embedded ourselves in.
SPEAKER_05So we've been really looking at how you retrofit density into suburbs for that reason.
SPEAKER_01And I guess shifting from thinking of infill as building a sneaky house in the backyard, which we've you know thought more about what the logical extension of that is, and that's no backyards anywhere, uh to thinking of infill as, yeah, removing one house and replacing it with, say, in this case, five apartments and and leaving the backyard as as a shared amenity for those households. Again, rather than chopping it up into five little teeny gardens, you leave it whole and and let it be a sort of a a greater resource.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, when we look at our proposal and plan, it just looks the same as the existing neighborhood. And so you actually have to look at it in three dimensions to see what is radical about what we propose, but we're trying to make it not look radical.
SPEAKER_03The block party is is so cool. It's like a when you walk in there, it's like you're walking through a little alleyway anyway. You know, it's like a little little back road and and you're kind of going past all your neighbours and your your fri friends and yeah, it's super social and interactive, which is kind of like walking down a little little street in Europe or something.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that we're so happy with how that space worked out. And, you know, since moving in, a couple of the owners have had kids and stuff, and it's it's such an active, yeah, little road without any cars on it.
SPEAKER_05They had a cracker party the other day where they each made a different meal and served it out of their kitchen window onto that street. Yeah. So we're just really keen on providing those spaces within housing so that those things happen organically. We're not, you know, we've come from a background of working with a few co-housing groups, and some of those things can get a bit too intentional and like a lot of policies and a lot of shared kind of facilities that have a bit of an admin headache. So we're kind of looking at how those things can coexist with independent housing and you can benefit from them without feeling like they're an additional burden to your already overburdened life.
SPEAKER_00Just going back to the infill comment quickly, how much did you guys look at? Was it the 2024 fellowship winners? Blue, was it Blue Field site development? Because it's sort of his whole idea was that use of interstitial space. And this seems like your um advancement on that idea, which is quite a nice continuation of one what the fellowship's trying to provide, but you know, the growth and in design development. Was that a driver for you at all?
SPEAKER_05I mean, I really love the uh search engine aspect of that, you know, to have got to that granular level of detail and see what these sites are. There was a huge part of the NSW pattern book project was just seeing what is actually already out there. That also ties in. So I think the Bluefields concept is also coming from Damian Madigan in Australia, and it's so those two things fit in quite nicely together. But the uh they're all grappling with how you deal with existing housing stock and try not to change too much about a city while densifying it.
SPEAKER_05And I think we've identified the the site cover is for us the biggest problem. You know, in 2018 they changed the law in Auckland and some horrendous amount of tree cover just vanished from the city. And you know, the council's trying to like plant trees, and and so we're really keen on livability, I guess, rather than just this direct problem solving that covers up every inch of ground with more low-rise housing. The the kind of cost and energy and material efficiency of a attached building, like what we're proposing is quite compact and very simple and easy to maintain.
SPEAKER_05And so, you know, I'm like all the thermal benefits of actually sticking houses together.
SPEAKER_01It's just it's kind of a no-brainer. And yeah, I think it was it was from doing that work because we've done lots of little infill houses and backyards, and we've kind of loved doing that work, but we did kind of end up thinking that yeah, really, if if everyone does that, what does the city look like? And maybe that's not the best best shape for how these things develop for the next sort of 50 or 100 years. Uh it's you know, it's not dense enough, basically.
SPEAKER_05The transitional element of what we're proposing is really important because it can kind of coexist happily in our view with what is there already. And so as I was saying, if somebody's house has been maintained and renovated and it's in a great shape, it stays there and lives there on happily. And then one that's just been left to kind of dissolve into the ground can be replaced by something that's much denser. And there's a you could have a run of three or four or five of these in a row, and they would still impact the neighborhood in a positive way. So I think we're thinking a lot about the streetscape and how you manage privacy and bringing verandas and kind of these really lovely house-like structures into a more denser building that allows people to have the same kind of life.
SPEAKER_03And at a time where I feel like it's so critical, over the last 10 years when you know New Zealand's basically started developing within that medium density realm, there's been some questionable buildings, you know, rogue housing, especially come up here in Auckland, it's extremely noticeable in in some suburbs around here, which is such a shame because, you know, like you said before, in areas like Europe where they have the densification and they've been working on it for you know centuries, it's just such a nice space to live in.
SPEAKER_03And because we've seen so much poor execution, I feel like it's kind of put us a little bit on the back foot. And it's good to see a lot of more development in in terms of like the how those spaces are actually developed within that realm.
SPEAKER_00It's like densification with our urbanization, really, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's like how can we there a lot of that housing you're talking about is basically just it's like how can we get more houses in here without giving up on an essentially suburban concept of what a city is. And we've just got to stop doing that because it's not gonna build good cities and it's gonna be driveways and garages covering like 90% of the land.
SPEAKER_05But it does come back to this predictable build model, you know, those people building those buildings know what they're spending and they know what they're gonna be worth at the end of the day. And so those are the answers that I think we need from what we're proposing is what's it gonna cost to build this and is it gonna have a value that the market can sustain the building of these alternatives? So I think that's it's so fine-tuned as to whether you can get something else quick.
SPEAKER_03And and just adding to that, I don't believe that all of the stuff that they have been building for so long, especially you know, the the new kind of row house developments, I think people believe that it is what the market actually wants, but a lot of them just sit on the market for such a long period of time that I believe it's what developers or real estate agents or whatever believe that the market wants, but likely not what the market actually wants.
SPEAKER_01I think that's why we find the idea of owner-developed projects so interesting as well, because then they're not guessing, they're not having this sort of averaged out idea of what people want. They go, This is what I want, and I'm gonna make it.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And then you do it, and then that serves as a precedent for other people, and they go, Oh, look, you can do it that way as well, or you can do it that way. And then so they they build on themselves as well. So, you know, the more projects like this that happen, them the broader a sense of of how you can live in the city, uh, you know, a different idea can emerge.
SPEAKER_00In terms of you guys winning the fellowship now and the direction forward, you've obviously got this really strong concept and a really strong idea on what you want to develop. What's the next outcome? What's the next steps? Because you're you sounds like you've got something pretty fully fleshed conceptually already, but what does that look tangibly in 12 months' time that that is sort of the resultant of the fellowship period?
SPEAKER_05So when we pitch for it, we were going like on about six different channels of how it might work, because we think having something that is highly permissible would allow the market to gear itself towards producing that. And I think the affordability piece needs a huge chain of consistent demand to realize any of those savings as opposed to a similar bespoke project. So we're really interested in the replicability of it. But the the work that we're gonna do first of all is look backwards and look at the successful co-housing project types and find out what in the process of getting an owner to a development that's built was successful and what was hard and what parts need smoothing.
SPEAKER_05And then the other part that we're looking at is these design elements that resolve the moments of arrival into a building. So I think nobody's too worried about what a sitting in an apartment, living in an apartment looks like, whereas some of the parts about resolving vehicles and pedestrians and ground cover and those kind of things, they're all design elements. So we're gonna draw out those and discuss why we make the decisions that we make and the designs that we're proposing.
SPEAKER_01Initially we're saying like, hey, let's let's make it uh akin to a pattern book, or this is something that would feed into any possible local pattern book, because uh in our experience with the Australian one, basically they went from terraced housing up to four to six story apartments, and there's a really obvious middle step in there, which to us ticks a whole lot of boxes like from a construction efficiency and a you know, neighborhood scale point of view. It just seems like an obvious uh thing that should be in the mix, basically.
SPEAKER_01So whether we can conduct all this research, get a really strong case study together, and then use that to talk to councils or people working on RMA reform, new district planning, regs, you know, try and feed it into the mix as all of this stuff is changing around around these questions.
SPEAKER_05Builders who already do developments on this kind of scale. You know, we really like the idea that also like even if you just think about a building company queuing up projects, they could kind of crack one of these out in a gap between some of their other projects, you know? It's like trying to actually work with what our existing building industry looks like and and tailor it to something that they would. be happy to take on rather than be a head scratcher.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So the outcome's more of like a patent book, a series of, I guess, solutions and concepts that can be applied to different design topologies or design outcomes rather than you guys actually designing a prototype of what this could be, correct?
SPEAKER_05I no, I think it is a I mean ideally we would have a pre-consented building. Right. So you would get both resource and building consent. I mean this is in La La ideal land where a multi-approach could handle it. Yeah. So like literally removing the barriers of uncertainty and completely.
SPEAKER_01Which is basically what we got to with what a pattern like a for a pattern book to be useful, it basically needs to be those things. Otherwise it's just some nice pictures.
SPEAKER_05Because in the end, design is actually a priorities game. And so you can like draw a whole bunch of like the the Alexander's pattern book is such a fantastic book, but it doesn't ever look at how one thing pieces together with another thing and gets in its way and you have to make some decisions about what so we do understand these elements as designers but in each circumstance. So they they shift about differently and so we don't think that having a kit of parts is really going to cut it. It's not going to guarantee a great enough outcome.
SPEAKER_05So what I think what we're looking at doing is finding those common sites which is what draws on the previous Gordon Wilson fellowship work, looking at what those sites are available and and trying to get it basically on the smallest one and so that it also works on the bigger ones.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03So are you who are you targeting? Are you targeting the developer in this case or the builder or the homeowner?
SPEAKER_05So we've had a few clients come to us that are groups of one form or another and they don't conform to a specific profile. Some of them are three generations are friends, some of them, you know, there are there are always some relationships in there.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05But we are just kind of looking back at the those people that have come to us and we look at what whether this what we're proposing would work for all of them even though they're quite different from each other. And we that that's what we're we're going for.
SPEAKER_03More people need to know that that is a viable option as well. I think it's probably because it because it's kind of like outside the normal realm of design build. I wonder I question how many people actually kind of know that that is an option and so as much information out there the better I guess in this case.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Yeah every time we talk we seem to bring up simplicity living because they're so cool. The way that they have they they basically came in trying to solve a specific problem. The specific problem was affordability of apartment buildings and they cracked that fairly quickly and then realized that who was buying them wasn't who needed the affordability aspect. So they were kind of somebody else was gaining the financial uptick that they had managed to by hard work get out of the build cost.
SPEAKER_05And so then they went and became property managers as well. And then they partnered with the Simplicity Keyware Savers scheme and now they do build to rent. And that's just because they couldn't work out how to get the affordability piece to the people who needed it because people can't mobilize to buy when they're in a certain financial bracket. And so they are now getting to those people who need the affordability through renting it. And housing is a long-term asset so it's a it's a really beautiful pairing of the kind of retirement funds with the livability and a just a better quality housing outcome.
SPEAKER_00The differing factor with them and I and I guess it's the same with what you guys are proposing is ownership though, right? People that are developing to flip, they've got no ownership over the final product. But if you're building to own or to lease and use it as a valuable asset, like you have so much more care and responsibility in the process and the project.
SPEAKER_01And it's essentially what this is this is proposing but instead of it being like simplicity massive scale big developer this is like homeowners a group of us let's maybe just get ourselves into a home that's affordable with a group of us and then we have this asset which we can then lean on in the future is that the idea yeah basically and like that thing for us the scale of it working on one like on a single site is really important because the amount of complexity that that takes out of it like not having to try and you know acquire multiple sites adjoining one another and then you know adjust the boundaries it's just one suburban section.
SPEAKER_01And I think again with with Buckley Road the value of having an existing house there for the period that they were doing the you know planning, consenting all of that sort of stage they were able to live there and their money was going back to their own mortgage on that property while they were doing the development and even that like the the value of that rather than you're still siphoning money off to your landlord basically while you're trying to make yourself a house like it just it just keeps bringing everything back out of the project.
SPEAKER_05Yeah and that that comes back to the DIY development and that's I think we realized so we were living in Wunganui when before we started our practice and our rent was you know really manageable. And then we moved back to Wellington and we were kind of aghast. We were like how did that even you know how does anyone sustain this amount of rental payment and so at that point we looked at how we could reverse engineer our rent payments into a mortgage equity situation and we actually got equity through subdivision. So we bought a a sort of marginally viable piece of land that would have freaked out other people to develop it because of the slope and then split it in half.
SPEAKER_05So you know it's it's what we realized what got us into housing is actually the developer type thinking and ironically the one of the days that we early on someone like the local newspaper came by and they and they took a photo of the site that we've built on and they were like developers are ruining your neighborhood or something like that. We cracked up and at that time we were like kind of like we're not developers we're homeowners but now we're embracing it you know DIY development let's get into it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah I did the exact same thing and it worked so well though.
SPEAKER_00Have you identified then that the that that key barrier to obviously you've said you've done it yourselves and you've learned probably a lot through that process. The key barrier to other people that are adopting this idea is it is it generally that risk? Is it their kind of the lack of surety about the project is it the consenting phase and is that what you guys are targeting more so than maybe like prefabrication or materials or anything in in a pre-design idea? Is it the assurance factor versus the actual build factor?
SPEAKER_05Yeah we've taken a close look at modular builders and like a lot of people have had a very good go at it and you know there's a rule of thumb out there that you need a thousand of anything to sort of make it worthwhile doing any prefabrication and we're just not getting the queue up of demand. And I think that's there's a lot of change regulatorily speaking. So we're just not we haven't got a consistent enough market and that's where Simplicity living is so cool because they've got like a massive queue of people who are keen to move in and that's how the Nightingale model worked in Australia.
SPEAKER_05The initial architects took a huge risk on proving their model worked and then they just got so many people who are keen they've they basically had I think got so much demand that they can just keep building these buildings knowing that they've got a market. So they kind of broke the mould of what people think is valuable.
SPEAKER_01But that's it right that's by providing a precedent you show people what it can be and then that then feeds into the loop of what people want. But yeah I think for us it's the obviously the building needs to be efficient, needs to be simple and easy to construct and all of those sorts of things but yeah don't actually think that's that's the problem. It's it's the degree of uncertainty and risk and unknowability at the start.
SPEAKER_05If you can show people how good it could be without them having to go and spend tens of thousands of dollars on professional services that seems like a real good leg up architecture is such a leap of faith you know when you when you really understand how much people are grasping what you've done for them once they move into the building and not before that. You know I think we always think they know what we're proposing. We provide a lot of documentation but the reality is when they step into that space they're suddenly like oh this is what you've done for us.
SPEAKER_05Yeah yeah yeah so yeah there's a certain group of people that are comfortable with that they're like I don't know what you're doing for me but I think it's going to be worth it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah and I'm gonna gamble all of my life's money ever on that being a good idea.
SPEAKER_00Yeah I mean this yeah this kind of just just takes that away it puts the control in your hands you as the DIY developer you know puts all that control in your hands. Is it the idea that these groups or the people that would adopt you know the the groups or individuals or households or whatever develop DIY developers that adopt this model, they're obviously doing the planning side of things are you looking at them building it as well or is this also an avenue to create a long a larger building industry workflow as well because if there's if this takes off right and you can see that you know there's absolute legs here it will just create easy to build fast replicable construction like you say that can drop into a builder's workflow if and when they've got lull spots we have a massive upside for the construction industry which let's be honest is battling at the moment.
SPEAKER_05Yeah I think we also you know so what you were saying before would it be a a series of principles rather than an actual design we're really keen for it to be a spatially coherent design but then allow any builder to use their own methodology, whatever building construction methods meet the code, you know, aesthetically have a have a various palette that can again meet the code but we're not we're not interested in controlling those aspects. We sort of think a spatial generosity is a language of its own and that it can carry various specific material choices within it.
SPEAKER_01I definitely think like in the sense of the wider industry that is a very appealing end game right if if these things are really well known like everyone's built one you know how to do it you can you there's no big surprises there's no big uncertainties like on a constructional side that that's a super appealing development really. Well one thing with the with the sort of cladding choices and colours and things like that like it was interesting with the pattern book for the government architects in Australia? Yeah uh New South Wales. They're interested in basically each design having three you know formal languages to it.
SPEAKER_01So be three different colours or three different um cladding materials or whatever it might be. And we're really interested in like pairing that with the construction system for each one. So you know if you're doing the the bog standard concrete construction methodology for Australia heavyweight cladding like a brick makes a sense you know the the natural pairing but if you're going for a lightweight sort of COT structure then you're going to need a lightweight cladding system as well. So doing something like tin um would make sense in that in that lineup.
SPEAKER_01And so yeah the idea of of having those options but them still being a a sensible sort of logical conclusion of the way it's being built seems like a really appealing way to have variety without it being an arbitrary kind of paste it over the top type thing.
SPEAKER_05And our values would say everything had to be decarbonised and you need, you know, we could get very narrow on what we prescribe this to be, but we we're really interested in urban form and preservation of green space and biodiversity and functioning natural environment. So we're foregrounding that so we're just like build it however you want to at this point you know obviously legislation might come in that changes what's viable on that front but at the moment we're just like it's so these buildings are probably going to last for a long time and so for our perspective we kind of really quickly want to chuck in an intervention that stops all the ground getting covered.
SPEAKER_00You can basically make these things not as expensive or as cheap as you like but you've taken away the barrier of planning. You know you've taken away the barrier of how do I even start and really the decision making is what I want this to look like, how do I want this to feel and that in a nice way becomes that individualistic nature of it and what will stop this from being just like cookie cutter this is the same topology bang bang bang bang bang. It's like here's the model behind it all. This one looks like this if it's got a value you know sitting up here and this one's down here because you know they had less money and they built it themselves or whatever but like fundamentally it's all the same outcome.
SPEAKER_00I kind of like that idea and that because I think that's one thing that I when I was reading through as much info as I can find initially about it and I was like is there the risk that you overprescribe and then everything becomes very generic? Or is there the risk that you underprescribe and then it it becomes just like a free for all and there's no control and by the sounds of it you guys have thought long and hard about this and found that balance of control being in planning and the freedom being in expression.
SPEAKER_01Again at at Buckley Road like those four houses are the same. They're the same cladding they're the same you know basic shape etc they they took control of you know interior paint we designed the kitchens and then they chose the materials and they're different in each house. They chose stuff like light fittings and the tiles in the bathroom but so none of those things really had any major flow on for the the building and the consenting and all of that sort of stuff the amenity of the buildings but you walk into each of those houses and they all feel distinct you know you're never gonna mistakenly be in the wrong house.
SPEAKER_01Like they all feel individual but really the mechanisms they use to to make them feel different are are pretty minor and and that's a lovely thing like you don't need to give everyone a different roof angle and a you know completely different spatial system for their houses to feel like their own houses.
SPEAKER_03Yeah I'm a massive fan of the pattern book and and your design for the apartment complex there. How did you find stepping out of the standard residential one off off or you know multi-unit to to apartment for a for a giving that a go.
SPEAKER_05It kind of cracked us up that we got shortlisted to do the apartment uh the four to six story apartment rather than the you know townhouse because we've Isn't that because we ticked the box? We did tick the box. I know Tim's like we should just tick the low rise box I was like whatever we're just gonna tick all the box but I I I thoroughly enjoyed you know the problem solving aspect of that and I think our initial pitch and the expression of interest for that was like look we basically do this in our spare time with you know with no client because we're really interested in the commonalities of what makes a good outcome we're really interested in many many more people living in wonderful quality housing and so that was just such an an excellent opportunity to really think about all these things that we're discussing today.
SPEAKER_01It was great having like a really well informed client because the office of the government architect is full of absolute ninjas and uh those are our clients you know so as a as a testing board or like a a a critique engine they were fantastic. Like particularly Abby the the head honcho she was across all of the patterns and you'd have this meeting you know you're like quarterly catch up about it and she'd be down the far end of this table of you know 20 people and she'd be like hang on go back three slides and you're like zoom in on like this minuscule detail that was the one thing that we hadn't really thought about and we're feeling a bit embarrassed about potentially and she's like what's going on there and you're like a little it's it's just so impressive and it's nice to know that the the right people are in those positions I guess I mean that's that that's Australian model right and they have that government architect position.
SPEAKER_00I've long said that New Zealand is sorely lacking someone in that position. Do you see that as being a barrier for the success of a concept like this here?
SPEAKER_01Would certainly be very curious if we were to roll out a pattern book in New Zealand like who's gonna administer that because yeah if we if we had to assemble and a body to do that you know that's that's a tall order rather than having that institutional knowledge and breadth of experience already sitting there and able to take something up.
SPEAKER_00And knowing how much uh local governments struggle to even interpret something as prescribed as the building code comparably across the country, you know, taking on a concept like a pattern book seems far beyond them at the moment.
SPEAKER_05I guess what you see in NSW is that they have they've created it's this the pattern book has its own pathway so it doesn't have to go through the same rubric as the rest of the buildings because in theory it's already been through it. So those buildings were developed right the way through all of the mechanical and fire services engineering is all part of that package so that you don't get all the way through that and find the building can't be built as it's been drawn. But what I was going to say about the you know the Ministry of works some of our best architectural fabric in New Zealand is from the Ministry of Works.
SPEAKER_05And so you know the the people who apply for those roles like it still comes so much down to individual people and the training I guess having people with an architectural background in those roles who kind of know what they're looking at. And I think that's partly why we were selected for the pattern book and then also this fellowship is is because the people who are evaluating the proposals are absolutely you know immersed in what we're all trying to solve here. So we have a kind of common language and I think that that's something that broadly speaking the public and the architecture community struggle a bit to to kind of get onto the same page and the problem solving aspect of being an architect is something that people are trying to get that message across now.
SPEAKER_05Like we're not actually fashion designers even though fashion designers can put pockets in or not you know there's problem solving there too. So you know we're we're kind of trying to use that aspect of architecture to make a city a a really great place to live.
SPEAKER_00I talk about communication quite a lot about the architectural communication around the architectural community and what we do as a profession. How do you guys see communicating your concept and this idea as it develops to the public because I can see that being not a struggle but it's definitely a barrier is how do you get out this information because there's always going to be that slight standoffishness being like oh architects have done it so it's inherently going to be expensive.
SPEAKER_01I think both of us are fairly allergic to the way most architects speak about their work and it tends to be a a very pretentious esoteric sort of language surrounding it. And it's almost like you know I think the profession is often guilty of kind of hiding behind language and a sort of artistic facade to to hide the fact that maybe there's not that much going on at all. And so we we talk about we try and talk about things no no this is good.
SPEAKER_01This is the same we just try and talk really plainly about what a building's doing like why it's good what the elements are just lay it out and and try and just speak in in layman's terms because the things that we're talking about aren't that complex and you don't need to you know muddy the waters further.
SPEAKER_05I'm actually teaching at the university at the moment and I think a lot of that language comes from the university you know this is a group of fourth year design students and I haven't heard anyone say door or window and you know these are the the basic elements with which we design so you know and and the the scary word cost you know one of the students asked me what they would do what I would you know how I would push them I was like well ask you to run a cost lens over this thing and then you'll find out you know that actually when we start building real buildings we have to think about these very practical pieces that make a good building and so I think yeah we're we're really interested in using no smoke and mirrors but in answer to your question I would like to build one of course just get out there and like build one myself.
SPEAKER_05That'd be the quickest way. Yeah and so I I don't I haven't put any thought into how you would fund that uh maybe you could get a real great grant that's like yeah I can fund you a couple of million dollar building but you know of course building one would be the the true test.
SPEAKER_01Which is what they're doing with the pattern book which is interesting. Yeah yeah I was gonna say that's your been your guy's model throughout your careers really isn't it build it to prove it basically yeah we often talk about that it's like oh would would we want to be like um a big practice so we can do lots of all this stuff and it's like not really rather just provide a bunch of really thoughtful precedents and if that shifts the the dial a little bit and that type of thinking becomes more common then that's a job well done.
SPEAKER_00It's like the green party of architects well I mean I don't know about you guys but I just want to make better buildings and make architecture accessible for for everybody. And I think you know if we can succeed in doing that which your model so evidently can do then you know kudos hats off job done architecture clocked is there anything else you want to sign off on you know ambitions plans we've talked about what does this look like in a year the fellowship period is successful and the outcome successful you know what's your dream 10 years down the track?
SPEAKER_0010 years? Yeah give us give us 10 years.
SPEAKER_05Well yeah so we realistic to what was it the detail something on Radio New Zealand and they were talking about how in the 50s was it there was like the government provided 30% of home loans. So my major pressing concerns are that value is lower than cost to build at the moment and I don't know what we will do about that.
SPEAKER_01Wage inflation? Yeah yeah yeah just leave the cost of housing where it is and triple everyone's salaries and it would be a much much happier country.
SPEAKER_05Nice maybe the answer is people building their own houses people building their own houses.
SPEAKER_00Clearly not something we have much say that's a good sign off awesome guys well thank you very much for your time. Yeah thanks so much likewise good luck with the research really excited rather than just talking about doing it. Just talk about it. Yeah so actually that's a good point. When do you when do you guys hit play?
SPEAKER_01I guess once we've officially got it yeah I think you have to start within six months of being told you get it and you have to finish within a year. But I imagine we'll just get stuck into it.
SPEAKER_05Yeah we're already stuck in yeah that's right
Send us Fan Mail If you think sustainable architecture is mostly about energy ratings and lower carbon, this conversation will stretch your frame. We sit down with Indian architect Chitra Vishwanath, founder of...
Send us Fan Mail 2030 is not a distant milestone, it is already colliding with the reality of long design and construction timelines. We sit down with Ewan Brown, Director at Tenant Brown Architects, to unpack what...
Send us Fan Mail Designing with people sounds like a slogan until you hear what it demands in real life. Recorded at the NZIA Institute Conference, we sit down with Sydney-based co-founders David Kaunitz and Ka Wai...
Send us Fan Mail Two architects walk into a conference and we hand them a mic. What comes out is a fast, honest look at how New Zealand architects make decisions when nobody has time for fluff. We’re joined by Hamish...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode we are talking with Dr Albert Refiti, professor at AUT and co-director of the Vā Moana Research Centre, about Vā: the relational space that holds people, culture, hierarchy, and...