It's the season 5 finale and we're going whimsical, when Natalya Shelburne joins us to talk about the psychology of creativity. She makes a case for why creativity is not a personality trait, but a muscle most of us were slowly trained out of, explains how creativity killers show up in workplaces and daily life, and why "I'm not creative" almost always traces back to a single formative moment of being shut down. Natalya also introduces whimsy as a practical gut-check for creative readiness, shares her own daily rituals, and argues that reclaiming your creative practice is ultimately about deciding your time is yours to assign value to. Guest Bio Natalya Shelburne (she/her) is a designer, developer, artist, author, educator, and doer of good deeds. She leads the designers working on the DRUIDS design system at Datadog. Previously, she worked at GitHub working on design infrastructure and leading the Primer design system team. Before that, the New York Times and teaching at Harvard Extension. She loves to write, publishing the Design Engineering Handbook and articles for various online publications. Natalya holds bachelor’s degrees in Studio Art and Psychology, and a master's in Creativity and Talent Development. Crossing disciplines and building bridges between design and engineering is at the foundation of much of her work, and building teams, growing community, and investing in human creativity at scale is the next big adventure. Links Natalya’s website: https://natalyashelburne.com Natalya on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/natalyashelburne/ Books by Mihály Csíkszentmihályi: https://www.goodreads.com/author/list/27446.Mih_ly_Cs_kszentmih_lyi Credits Cover design by Raquel Rubio Breternitz.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to Design Downtime, the podcast where we celebrate the joys of living a balanced creative life. I'm your host, Guy Segal, a design director in Toronto, Canada, and I invite you to join me on this journey as we redefine what it means to be a successful design professional. Let's break free from the shackles of hustle culture and embrace the full spectrum of human experience, because life is too precious to be spent only in pursuit of productivity. Today, I'm delighted to talk to Natalya Shelburne. Natalya is a designer, developer, artist, author, educator, and doer
of good deeds. She leads the designers working on the Druids design system at Datadog. Previously, she worked at GitHub working on design infrastructure and leading the Primer design system team. Before that, the New York Times and teaching at Harvard Extension. She loves to write, publishing the Design Engineering Handbook and articles for various online publications. Natalya holds bachelor's degrees in studio art and psychology, and a master's in creativity and talent development. Crossing
disciplines and building bridges between design and engineering is at the foundation of much of her work, and building teams, growing community, and investing in human creativity at scale is the next big adventure. Natalya, welcome to the show. Hey, happy to be here. Great to have you. And you want to talk to us today about creativity. Yes, but entirely outside of the scope of work, productivity, or doing anything for work. Perfect. Otherwise, it would be illegal for you to be
on this podcast. Immediately end the episode. And stop. Yep. Back to shareholder value. Let's go. Do you want to do the design thing and define terms? We could. So, you know, you read my fun bio, which just says I took the scenic route to all the things I do for money. And, you know, the part where it says, like, she has a master's degree in creativity and talent development, which just seems made up. But that's where I got the definition of creativity that I truly
love, which is an original idea of value. And there are many definitions, many frameworks, and that's largely what this graduate program was. It was learning. psychology a very unique program in texas state run by this amazing brilliant woman dr waite who honestly introduced me to some of the greatest ideas about creativity talent development how to grow it in any discipline and i've been obsessed ever since and so yeah we can define terms talk about frameworks research methodologies all of this i i aim to have science
backed and not just influenced by my own anecdotal opinions and lived experience so those do make funny stories We can add both. We're going to do everything. So before we actually start, I'm really curious to know, when we talked about what sort of topic you want to have for this episode, you were super passionate about, I want to talk about creativity. Why? Why is it so important to you? I'm going to try not to have a cliche answer, but having a creative practice. that I have shaped for myself intentionally as a result
of this graduate program has, I would say, fundamentally shaped my entire career trajectory and the things I aim to do. So to me, it's just such an important topic that's... in every aspect of my life. That's also made me a lot happier. It adds joy. It adds whimsy. It adds so many things that I love talking to people about it. And it's something that I feel like you can always connect on because if you ask someone like, oh, what do you do for work? That conversation dies. But if you ask someone what lights them up and makes them feel
creative, passionate energy, and you get talking about it and you learn something about it, that always leads to fun, creative friendships, adventures. Possibly new hobbies that are very expensive. But it's one of my favorite topics to talk about in general. So when you ask this question to people, what are some of the really unexpected answers you get? My least favorite is, I don't know. Nothing. I like everything. I'm not creative. Oh, the I'm not creative is the fastest way to get me like, all right, let's sit down. Let's
figure out, workshop this. But some of the more surprising ones that, I mean, it's just, I feel like. For a lot of people, the thing that lights them up creatively is often they're also closest guarded secret. So you don't always even get that answer. Like nothing, don't worry about it. Like, ah, they'll give you some answer. But if you are lucky enough to hear what lights people up, it's rarely the thing they're doing for work or it's rarely the thing they might even consider being valuable. They just, they're like, this is just a joy in my life. This brings me happiness.
And it doesn't have to, like, it's an original idea. that brings value to them. And I think that's, that's the part I love about it because like no one size fits all it's, if it's an original to them and it's an idea for them that brings them their life value and it lights them up, then that's a guaranteed good conversation to have. So, I mean like one example is like. Some people are music, the arts, the classic things. Some people are like, I'm into weird shaped plants and I just want to own every plant with weird
leaves or succulents or something. It's like, wow, tell me more. I love hearing about that too. It could be very niche. What is yours? Too many. This is the reason I'm talking about creativity here too, is I have never been able to stick to one hobby enough to specialize it enough to be like, this is going to be online for a really, really long time. This is the hobby I wish to be associated with. I like to do lots of stuff. I like to have the experience and then I can make the decision whether I want to do more or
not. So for me, I like the... act of learning and trying new things and having the experience just enough so if you look around my apartment and you're like oh my god it's an emergency we need a wood burning kit I got you do you need some crochet hooks no problem do you need every paintbrush possible got it do you need to engrave something I got three different tools ready to choose from and it's like do I do this every day no but being able to learn across many different things That's something I like to do. So there's
all kinds of people in the world. There's some people who jump from interest to interest and there's people who really delve deep into a hobby. And I think both are equally valid as long as they bring them joy. So where does creativity come into play in your personal life? Is it not the things that you do, but is it something that's kind of like, okay, now I'm going to do one of my creative pursuits or is it something that's always there in the background? So why would you say it's in the background? Why did we shove creativity into the background? Ah, gotcha. Just
doing it in the margins of everything else we have to do, I guess. I'll be honest, when I started my graduate program about creativity, I was teaching design and I was like, I'm creative. I don't need to learn about creativity. I am creative. So let's see what this program can teach me. But sure, let's go. You know, I came in with full... My understanding was fully shaped. Right. And then what I learned blew my mind was like, oh, my gosh, we not only don't teach creativity in schools, we actively suppress it. And as a society, we've framed us into output machines
that, you know, like it's never I'm going to make some art. It's I'm going to make an art piece. I'm going to have a finished piece at the end of it. And if I don't have a good piece at the end of it, that time was not spent well. And I knew I felt that pressure as an artist. and so what what creativity means to me is taking everything that was put into my brain by conventional schooling and everything you hear about what it means to you know the efficiency creation making things is external to you this is the
artifact that you've created and instead internalizing the process is it good that i made this Not is the thing that I made good. Is it good that I did this? And seeing myself as part of nature, like humans create the way birds sing. We need to create, we need to express ourselves and we need to have a good way of doing that. Otherwise that energy is going to come out weird. It's going to like, I hope anyone listening to this knows like, yeah, if you don't channel that force within yourself into something, it's just, it's
either going to hurt you and give you some autoimmune disease or it's going to come out like. popping off at the people you love. We have a tremendous amount of energy within ourselves and learning to channel that into something that feeds you in return. That's the creative practice. It's just as important as eating well, working out. And then this is for that human part of ourselves that demands to be developed. So yeah, it's just something I thread through every single day. How did you train yourself? to stay away from
that learned notion of i'm creating something and then when it's done or as i'm working on it i'm part of a society that judges things right and critiques things and says this is good this is bad how do i avoid that inner judgment how do you unlearn a lifetime of conditioning of judging and even question whether the judgment you hear inside your own head is even yours to begin with that is what i mean it's a practice it is a lifelong practice and for me it was rooted in understanding so just like the more you understand
something the less you fear it the more you can understand something the more you can create systems to support that you know a lot of us have a we're so hard on ourselves oh i guess i'm not creative you know like someone says something bad about your drawing when you're seven years old and that's it like a branch cut off a sapling the rest of your life you go with this core belief thinking you are not creative and you see it play out not to bring tech into this but you see it playing out in you know like in engineering we're like design gets to be creative but engineers no it's like you're everyone's all humans are creative inherently but you can cut that off
from yourself and then you have to reclaim it so for me specifically i'm gonna probably send you some links to post around but the works of Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi You need to just see how that's spelled. That's the researcher who spent a lot of time studying the flow of what it means to enter a creative flow. You need to create the right conditions. There's also Dr. Amabile, who's a Harvard researcher, who was like, hey, there are some creativity killers. And surprise, a lot of them are just how we work in the workplace. So being able to, especially as a manager, set
up systems to where those creativity killers aren't getting near my team as much as possible, creating those guardrails. The way that I do it is just such a multi, like an ecosystem approach is you want to set yourself up for success. So as an example, I have my watercolors easier to reach than my phone in the morning. I have my journal to write my thoughts set out and ready, open to the page with the pen ready to go so that I will reach for that before I reach for
social media. so setting yourself up for success in every possible way with your environment with the the people you associate with making sure they're the ones who also have something that lights them up and you can bounce those ideas back and forth to understanding what it means to enter a flow state and the conditions that need to work for you personally and making sure you meet those needs for yourself and then just giving yourself grace because it just it's a habit you have to build a habit on top of a very shaky foundation of everyone telling you you're not good enough if you don't have some external
project to prove that this time was worth spending so even at the heart of it it's wrestling back your own time and saying i get to choose how to spend my time and the value that i assign to it is mine to assign and that's i think like how you can assign your own creative like how you can create your creative practice is that the fundamental layer is i'm allowed to waste my time because it's just my time And wasting your time is the kind of judgmental way of saying it. But the scientific reality is being able
to play, pursue ideas, do things wrong intentionally, do things clumsily and sloppily and just with full whimsy. Those are core and fundamental to how we learn as humans. And yet, for some reason, we're not allowed. So it's really, it's a lot of unlearning and wrestling your time back and realizing you get to assign the value to the ways you spend your days. You mentioned that not only are we not teaching creativity, we're also killing it in school. Tell me more about that. And I speak from a lot of time spent as
an educator in the classroom and not just as a third party observer. You know, I taught design. I was in the classroom and I definitely observed some differences. There were some. People who are like, I'm not good with open-ended situations. I'm not okay navigating ambiguity. I just need a clean, crisp, tell me what to do or I get anxious. Well, if you spend all day on convergent thinking, problem solving, and here's your question, answer it correctly, the best answer, and just nailing
things down to a point, you can lose the muscle over time and atrophy over time on problem finding. What could the problem be? What is even the opportunity ahead of us? What is worth attending to with your attention in the ambiguity of everything? That's something artists have to do a lot. That's something creative people are essentially from the outside, they look like they're just pulling ideas out of thin air, but it's really using a muscle that we don't really tend to reward or... practice in schools. And, you know, there's
even research to back this up where there's this, I think it's called determined test of creative thinking. And they give it to kindergartners, first graders, second graders, and on and on and on. And at 12th grade, it's like maybe 8 % or some low percent of kids are scoring the genius category for creativity. But can you guess what number is that kindergarten? 98% it's like every kindergarten is a genius when it comes to thinking like quite literally outside of the box um and then there's a framework for it you know it's like fluency originality uh you know
like there's a whole framework like how many ideas can you come up with how many ideas skipping categories how many ideas outside of the default answer you can come up with kind of lateral thinking creative thinking and yeah they find like The longer kids spend in a conventional school, the less they are able to wield that muscle unless they intentionally found a way to practice it. So I'm not saying it's too late for everyone. You know, if we finish school, it's that I'm almost saying like it's OK to acknowledge that you may have had an atrophied creative muscle rather than you're not creative at all. Like
just like a no, yes or no. It's like you have to develop it. So just like going to the gym, your muscles are going to be weak. If you go regularly and practice your creativity. you're going to be able to think in this whole new dimensional way that is going to bring joy, richness, and just massive amounts of enjoyment that you'll realize we're supposed to have as humans into your life. So when you run into someone who says, I'm not creative, that's how I am. I am innately non-creative. What would you prescribe them?
I would just have a big smile on my face and just start asking questions like, how'd you get to that conclusion? Wow. you know some people are like no i don't want to like i'm good i don't want to be that like i got my thing cool we gotta respect like that's fine but if somebody's like oh i've always wanted to be but i'm just not and they always have some terrible story from their formative years or somebody close to them let loose a stray comment that hit them in the fundamental belief that they're not creative. And so ultimately it's, it's, there's always
some, some core wound, I think, where, where they went out on a limb, they were uncomfortable, they were visible and they were shut down. And it's like, you got to remember, like that hits so hard when we're children, when we're teenagers, oh my God. And especially now with social media, you can fail so publicly and we're seeing it. it's it's like uh as a millennial i'm like hey we grew up cringe because we were not being observed and posted on social media uh whereas now we're
seeing lots more young people not even try or say i'm not gonna post my art i'm not gonna make anything because it's gonna be cringe it's gonna be bad and they they shut themselves down which i think is just sad so i get a big smile i ask why and if we retrace our steps i try to encourage people to do it for their own sake and never they don't have to show anyone but They don't have to stay in that fixed belief that this is them permanently. It's just a muscle they haven't used in a long time. You mentioned that you have a lot of friends who practice their creativity
in different ways. Do you ever collaborate with them? Do you do something together? All the time. I love asking my friends what they're into. And, you know, earlier I said, what lights you up? I feel like all I do is learn about what my friends are up to. And like I said, there's friends who are like... here's my new hobby this week. I'm like, oh my God, let me in, show me, onboard me as fast as you can, because I bet you've been just super fixated on this hobby. Like, let's go. What did you learn? What did you do? I'm in. And then there's friends who have the deep level of expertise. And I just want to hear like,
what's your mental model? How does it work? Sometimes I just indulge in hearing about it. And I find it incredibly fascinating what people, you know, what creativity people are capable of. And it is just any discipline, any industry, everywhere. It doesn't even have to be you know work it's like out in the world what people are this podcast i think you know you see like people are so interesting and they have so many things they're passionate about but for me i also really like collaborating uh with people you know that complement my my own kind of like scattered interests all over
and i just love someone who's like i can do a deep dive into something i'm like wow i could never but what's that like we're adding like a what if my thing is to just add a big what if on top of everything um and say like what if we did this or what if this other hobby i know combined with this one for fun silly and usually entirely useless outcomes other than fun joy and friendship when we met A few months ago in person at a conference, you were giving your talk dressed as a witch and you were talking
a lot about whimsy. Tell me about whimsy and whimsy in your life. So just for extra context, it was Halloween and it did tie into the talk. I was referencing, it was a metaphor. So, okay, word you've heard me say even a couple of times on this podcast is whimsy because I think that one just gets through. nobody can take that word very seriously and therefore it works i see it as a canary in the coal mine which is to say is it's a little check if you cannot access your whimsy joy and just kind of like that little
bit of silliness almost odds are you probably can't access your creativity either and what i mean to say is likely you're not feeling safety whether psychological or actual you're probably feeling time scarce i can tell you this when i'm in a hurry i'm not feeling whimsical i'm feeling mad and like you better go um if i'm feeling surveilled and i feel like everyone's watching what i'm doing and checking checking up on me i'm certainly not gonna have any whimsy
available to me when i'm feeling any one of those things that's i'm basically listing out the creativity killers from that harvard study now so if you look up the creativity killers uh you're also gonna find like you're not gonna feel very whimsical in those moments as well but when you're you know, I'm not going to bring it back to work. But when your job relies on you being creative, that's a good gut check to have when you're trying to, you know. get in the flow and feel the joy of creating, it's a good gut check to say like, you know what, I'm not feeling it. What else
is going on? What do I need? What am I missing? And just not getting mad at yourself, but just being like, what conditions are absent? What do I need to fix so that I can get back to my creative practice? Because the other field of study is, you know, in addition to the psychology of creativity is there's a whole bunch of writings on the creative practice and the rituals that that humans need so even famous writers or creatives they're like you know what before i write it's a big task sitting down to write is a giant task and and sometimes i can't even get up to do it
what i can do is light a candle that's a little thing and by the time they light that candle they're back in creative mode so uh you know setting up all these interesting systems for ourselves even if they seem a little silly and maybe a little whimsical. Can't write until I have my candle. They're actually really science -backed as just the things humans need to be able to create at such a high capacity or to enter a deep flow state or to be able to access
those parts of themselves. Yeah, whimsy is one of them. What are your creative rituals? Oh my gosh, I feel like I'm just a lot of coping mechanisms in a trench coat here, just trying to get creative. I am always time scarce and I'm always running around from thing to thing. I, you know, I'm always thinking about 12 million different things all at once concurrently and playing calendar Tetris. So, you know, I am very self-aware that the conditions for creativity are often very absent from my life. And so for me, it's like
this wrestling. everything back from the adulting and the day-to-day that we have to do i feel like that's such a huge effort for me so you know i aim to journal every single day so that i can get something out of my mind and onto paper i aim to take a brush dip it into some watercolors and do some colors on paper as often as i can it's not daily but it's about as close as it can get just so that i do some non non-verbal like a visual expression of some sort you know
i i find spending time in nature also being creative just wandering about outside can be a creative act if you're just allowing your mind to wander and letting ideas flow there's no one way to be I found my way through the arts, but, you know, there's music, there's creative through math. People are creative just at any discipline that they have where they are able to access that flow state where time passes quickly. You're feeling like things are just moving and you forget time and space exists. You might forget to eat. Hopefully not. But yeah, for me, it's just having
small little triggers to get a daily practice really, really helps. And it could be like, you know, for some folks, a good entry point is that Inktober thing where every October there's a prompt and every single day of that month, you know, you're supposed to draw something, even if it takes five seconds, but just to get you into a consistent habit of creating something. So it doesn't have to be big, but for me, I basically am always within reach of art supplies. You mentioned that part of your, and I don't want to get to talk too much about work, but you are thinking,
how do I create the system and the space and the environment for people to be creative? So how do you approach that? That's a hard one because it is different for every person. But I think meeting the fundamental need for safety, for time to think, those are two things I'd like to focus in on. One of the big principles I have is just us versus the problem and realizing like. There's a Pygmalion effect, which is like people will rise to the expectations you have of them. So if you're like, I know this team has got it. These people are awesome. We're going to get
there somehow. Everything is figureoutable. Yeah, it is. And we're really going to get there. So for me, just making sure that everybody feels safe to experiment, you're supposed to be allowed to fail. because if you don't fail you can't learn as fast the fastest way to learn is to fail and a deliberate practice with the appropriate support um just basically every single time i do anything i just have this wealth of research running in the back of my mind it's like you know like a strength-based approach outweighs the one that focuses on the negatives and then
also the pygmalion effect so i need to communicate like it's pretty loud in my brain but what comes out on the other side is you know if you raise your expectations for people you need to also raise the support and structures because again i talk about structures that's what i'm accountable for um so that's that's how i do it so if i have really high expectations which you know i do then i am accountable for creating the conditions in which people are able to reach those without dipping into the parts of them that don't recover.
So you can't do this at the expense of your kids or your time with your family or anything like that. I don't want people to throw time at a problem. I want people to come and throw cleverness at the problem and be the most creative versions of themselves because that's what's going to move the needle the most anyway. So high trust. Full faith that, you know, in my career, especially the creative path has always been the way forward. So you mentioned several different creative pursuits that were part of your life. Do you have any
that you're curious about that you want to get into? Oh my gosh. Yeah. So, you know, sometimes you buy the thing first and then you're like, great, now I see it every day. So I've just got this beautiful PRS shiny sparkly guitar looking at me every single day. So up next is making more time to play that. you know there's there's music then there's also uh i was doing pop choir for a little bit and learning how to sing everybody needs an alto and that's me you know one of the next things i want to do is i want to get back into rock climbing because that's just all the
people who rock climb are super cool and i just want to go hang out at a rock climbing gym am i going to stick with it probably not but i already did it once so i feel like i'm going to literally circle back to it and you know if over the course of a lifetime i get much better climbing it's good enough i get to have the experience and that brings me joy And there's more, but we only have 30 minutes. Before we wrap up, is there anything you want to leave people who are listening to this with? I would ask everybody who's ever thought, I'm not that creative or I'm not the most creative person in the room to kind of put
that aside and go do some research and buy some books on creativity and just indulge in learning about yourself. We do so much work in the industry learning about. you know a great user experience or a customer's journeys or the needs of others and this is one where i'd say indulge in your own needs and delight in this incredible superpower you have to have your creative every single human is creative and the more you learn about how
it works and the research behind it i guarantee you're going to have a million ideas about how to weave it into your everyday life and i think you know for what what output what joy it'll make your life more enjoyable it'll make it more fun to connect with people and you'll find community in whatever it is that delights you so there's nothing to lose and everything to gain thank you so much natalya where can people find you uh i'm extremely online i think we're all on
linkedin now aren't we We're all on there now. Yeah, I'm on LinkedIn. And otherwise, I am extremely offline running some community events in New York City for designers, for engineers, builders, everybody. So I guess LinkedIn or in real life in New York City. Thank you so much for joining us today. Thank you for having me. This is all for this episode of Design Downtime. Thank you for joining me. And until next time, I hope you enjoy your downtime.
In this conversation, Anna E. Cook and I talk about what happens when the work that defines you stops being the work you're hired to do. Anna traces the systemic forces pushing accessibility specialists out of their...
You're guaranteed to catch the Love Bug, when Dave House joins us to talk about his love of old Volkswagens. He shares how owning and restoring old air-cooled VWs filled a gap left when music stopped being his primary...
Get ready to be swept away to a world of magic and giant swords, when Araxie Miller joins us to talk about her love of Japanese role-playing games. She explains what sets them apart from Western RPGs: rather than asking...
No need to break your Duolingo streak, when Stephanie Tuerk joins us to make a case for learning languages. She traces her journey from high school French to PhD-era German to humbling Russian, arguing that language...
It's dangerous to go alone! Take this episode where Andy Bell joins us to talk about his lifelong obsession with the Legend of Zelda. He explores what makes the franchise compelling: its creativity, humour, weird NPCs,...