Your schedule can look “mysteriously” empty even when you diagnose plenty of dentistry, present treatment every day, and keep seeing new patients. I see this in practice after practice, and the most surprising part is where the leak really happens. It is usually not that you need more leads, a bigger ad budget, or a perfect financing pitch at the front desk. It is that nobody is capturing the real reason patients choose not to schedule. I walk through the simple moment that determines dental case acceptance: the handoff after the clinical conversation. When a patient says “I need to think about it” or “I have to check my schedule”, that is rarely a clear objection. It can be fear, confusion about the diagnosis, low urgency, lack of trust, or uncertainty about why the treatment is necessary now. You will hear the exact respectful script I teach admin teams to use, how to pause and listen without sounding salesy, and why documenting the patient’s actual words is the fastest way to improve your treatment presentation. Then we close the loop. Those reasons are feedback for the dentist and hygienists, not ammo for blame. I share a real coaching example where tightening the message, improving co-diagnosis, and focusing less on “how the procedure works” helped a practice get busy with only 20 new patients a month. We also hit the often-missed final piece: follow-up ownership and protected time, so patients who truly need time do not vanish from your unscheduled treatment list. If you want more production without working harder or spending more on marketing, start here. Subscribe, share this with your team, and leave a review with the biggest case acceptance challenge you want to solve next. Register for our upcoming free webinar REMOVING THE DOCTOR BOTTLENECK Stay on top of your Online Marketing! Get a Free Practice Audit @ www.relevanceonlinemarketing.com Take Control of Your Practice and Your Life We help dentists take more time off while making more money through systematization, team empowerment, and creating leadership teams. Ready to build a practice that works for you? Visit www.DentalPracticeHeroes.com to learn more.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Paul EtchisonHave you ever looked at your schedule and wondered how the heck you still have holes? When you're diagnosing so much dentistry, you're seeing new patients, you know you're seeing enough new patients, you're presenting treatment, you're telling people what they need, but still for some reason they're not scheduling and you have more time in your schedule that you know you could be using to do dentistry. And you know you've got this huge list of unscheduled treatment just sitting in your practice right now. So what is the problem? Is your front desk not doing a good enough job?
Paul EtchisonAre patients just too worried about money? Do you really need to get more new patients coming through the door? Because I know that's what you're probably thinking. And the answer is well, maybe, maybe that is the case. But I've worked with so many practices that were struggling with this exact thing. And what we always discover is always really surprising. So I'm thinking of this one doctor down in Florida. And according to him, everything case acceptance was going really well. His team was presenting well, everything was good. He just needed to get more new patients through the door.
Paul EtchisonHe just needed more people coming through the funnel that would fix all of the issues. And it seemed like that might be actually the case. He was only seeing about 20 new patients a month. And if you listen to this podcast, you know that we always recommend at least 35 per full-time doctor. But here's the thing a lot of dentists are thinking the same exact thing. And there is a problem in their system, and they don't even realize it. So today we're gonna talk about why so much of the dentistry that you diagnose never gets scheduled and what might really be going on in your practice and how fixing that could be one of the biggest opportunities to completely change the way that your practice operates.
Paul EtchisonAnd I guarantee it's not what you think. Now, you are listening to the Dental Practice Heroes podcast, where we talk about the systems, leadership, and strategies that help you build a more profitable practice and a team that you can depend on. Now, I'm your host, Dr. Paul Etchison. I am the author of two books on dental practice management. I'm a dental business coach and the owner of a large five doctor practice in the south suburbs of Chicago. All right, let's dive into this one because this one I know is gonna help a lot of dentists out there.
Paul EtchisonNow, here is why you're probably believing the wrong thing. You diagnose the problem with your patients and you assume that the patient understands and agrees and they don't have any questions because you asked them, right? You said, Do you have any questions? They told you no. So you're like, okay, cool, I'm done. Then you hand the patient off to the front desk where the scheduling and the financial conversation is going to happen. And then they don't schedule. And to you, you look at this and you say, This must be a front desk problem. I've done my part. They didn't ask for the close. They weren't confident enough. They didn't offer financing.
Paul EtchisonAnd then further down the line, well, they didn't follow up with people. There's just something that they're missing, and you've worked with them on it already. So, like, there's nothing left for you to do. So you look at the marketing because it's something tangible. It's something you can spend more money on. And the fact of the matter is, it's a lot more easy to do that than work on your communication and case acceptance, especially when communication issues are a lot harder to see. But what I want you to consider is that you might be presenting the treatment poorly. Your front desk could be mishandling the conversation.
Paul EtchisonI mean, that is totally true. And I would say in most offices that I work with, that is a factor as well. But without finding out why the patient didn't schedule, nobody knows. And that is what most people are doing. They're not finding out why the patient didn't schedule. So, what is this costing you? Well, first of all, I mean, if we're trying to take good care of patients, they now delay or they never receive the care that you recommended. So it's costing them. The practice is losing production opportunities that it's already worked to create. It's already in a new patient that's been generated, somebody that's already come through your office.
Paul EtchisonAnd now you're spending more money on marketing. You're not addressing existing problems. So you're throwing more fuel on a fire that was never burning to begin with, and you're building up some resentment for the poor results that your front desk is getting you. So it just keeps repeating and nothing changes because the only solution for your issue in your mind is to get more new patients. But there's a big opportunity that we're missing. So if you're not finding out why patients aren't scheduling, you are completely flying blind and you can do that for your entire career. And ask me how I know that your front desk is not finding out why your patients are not scheduling, because nobody's front desk does this.
Paul EtchisonI have yet to work with an office where this is happening. So we're gonna talk about what should be happening. So the first thing we have to change, it's not our follow-up system, it's what happens when a patient decides not to schedule. If you, as the doctor, as a healthcare provider, really want to help the patient, you have to understand that hesitation that they have. Why are they not scheduling? What is going on? A patient that's telling your front desk, I need to think about it, or I have to check my schedule. It's not a specific objection. They're not giving anything.
Paul EtchisonThey're just nicely and politely saying no. That could mean fear of dentistry. It could be money, like we always want to say it is. And I don't really think that's the issue most of the time, but it could be money. It could be trust, it could be confusion, it could be the lack of urgency, or it just could be maybe just the patient needs more time to think about it, like they said, but most of the time that's not the case. And the front desk and people on your team, they're usually going to assume that the reason is financial. It's money. Obviously, things are tight. Everything's more expensive now. Of course it's money, right?
Paul EtchisonBut let's be real here. If we don't ask, we don't know. And front desk employees, they're already feel somewhat uncomfortable talking about money, at least most people do. And if they haven't been trained how to ask properly why a patient is hesitating or not scheduling, to them, it's something that they're just not going to do. They feel uncomfortable because it feels like selling to them. They don't want to be pushy, they don't want to come off as like disrespectful or making the patient feel uncomfortable, which I understand. But my thing is that if we can ask this question and we can be respectful at the same time, we can be kind, we can be polite, that is different than pressuring somebody.
Paul EtchisonSo the language that I tell my front desk to use when somebody says, I'll get back to you or I'll think about it. I just want to say, I want you to come from a place of like, I'm trying to help this person, and there is something that's keeping this person from scheduling. And I can likely help the patient feel good about scheduling and feel confident and like get rid of that uncertainty that they're having, but I can't help them if I don't know what it is. So here's what to say: say, okay, think about it. Say, okay, no problem at all. But just so I understand and so I can help in any way that I can.
Paul EtchisonIs there anything in particular that's keeping you from scheduling today? And then just wait. Just let the patient answer. You're not trying to argue with them. You're not trying to force them to like justify their decision. You're genuinely trying to understand if there's anything that you can help with. So this doesn't have to be part of like sales. The intention is to help the patient understand and make a comfortable decision. And what's so important to understand, like deep down mindset, is that you can respect a patient's decision to not proceed while still asking what their concern is.
Paul EtchisonYou just are curious. You just want to know. Maybe they're afraid of the procedure. Maybe they don't understand the diagnosis. Maybe they need help understanding what financial options they have. Maybe they just genuinely need more time. That's a possibility too. And there's a chance that they don't even want to discuss it. And that's okay. We can respect that, but we're going to ask at least one time. And if they say, I just need more time to think about it, that's cool. We're not going to keep prodding and keep asking and asking. Like, that's not cool.
Paul EtchisonThat starts to feel a little crappy, right? So we're trying to create an opportunity to help, not an opportunity to overcome the objection. We're not trying to use special words that's going to change the way the patient feels and make them do something they didn't want to do. So if nobody on your team is asking why the patient isn't scheduling, that opportunity is gone the moment that the patient leaves. And now we've got to follow up on that person. And now we might have somebody that's just not going to come back to our practice. We don't even know sometimes, right?
Paul EtchisonWe have no idea what happens to these patients. And most dental practice owners have no idea how many of their patients are doing this, how many are leaving and not coming back. So I don't think it's disrespectful to ask. I think it's different if you were like saying you said to like a patient, you're like, so like, can you not afford it? Uh, I thought you were a big baller, Mr. Jones. You can't afford this. Please tell me why you can you can afford this. Let's go. Do you want to come in Monday or Tuesday, the dual opportunity close, just going for it?
Paul EtchisonThat's not the type of sales. We're not doing that, right? We're just asking out of curiosity. Here's an even more important reason for doing this is that their objection, what they tell you for the reason that they're not scheduling, that's feedback on your treatment presentation. We rarely get feedback on our treatment presentation. And as a doctor, you need to know why patients aren't accepting treatment because the problem might have started long before the patient got to the front desk to talk about the financials. Now, I know this because I am also a doctor, is we often assume that, you know, the treatment was explained, the patient understood it, and we did our part.
Paul EtchisonBut the fact of the matter is that patient might not understand the condition. They usually don't understand the consequences of waiting, and they really usually don't understand why the recommended treatment is appropriate for their specific case. And sometimes it's just that the doctor didn't like spend any time to build the trust or build the confidence, or the doctor didn't present with enough confidence. So there's very little trust. So there's a lot of opportunities where we can change our verbiage in the way that we present things that reinforce that diagnosis and help the patient understand why it's important and why they need to get their treatment done.
Paul EtchisonBut when the patient doesn't schedule, man, who's the easiest person to blame? If you're the doctor, it's usually not you. It's easier to blame the front desk. But if I had to put a percentage on it, I think the doctor and the hygienist, the clinical team, they're probably responsible for about 70%. And I think the front desk is maybe responsible for 30. So they can't save a bad case presentation done by the clinical team. If we're not asking, how do we know that our patients are believing in the treatment that you're recommending? How do you know that they understand what happens if they wait?
Paul EtchisonHow do you know that they trust the recommendation? If they don't schedule, how do you find out what happened? And if you don't ask, you lost every opportunity. You're not going to get it. So if it truly is a case presentation thing, something about the urgency or the understanding, without that feedback, there's nothing to improve. We will never ever know about it. So your front desk needs to ask, and they have to document what the patient actually says, uh, not guess what the reason is. Oh, I think it was money. Oh, I think it was time. I think it was no. What did they say?
Paul EtchisonWhat did they say? Write it down. And we got to make sure that feedback makes it back to the clinical team in the near future so that they can improve on it. So you can improve on it. And that might be like a message, it might come up in a meeting, it might be you're just keeping a list. But the feedback loop needs to be closed. And when that feedback comes back to you, you have to be receptive to it. You can't get defensive. Look for the recurring themes. And even if it's the craziest patient in the world, you're like, I don't care what that person thinks. They were nuts. There is some truth to what they are telling you.
Paul EtchisonSo listen to that, internalize it, take it in, take it as feedback, and it's going to help you help more patients in the future. But it's not going to do anything for you if you're just defensive and you're all, no, no, no, that's not my fault. No, no way. I did all my part. It's the front desk. They're not, they're not talking confidently. They're not offering financing, all that stuff. So make sure that your front desk is documented and don't turn it into a really complicated new reporting process. This is simple. I mean, just write it on a post-it note if you want to. I just want to make sure that feedback gets back to the clinical team and the doctor.
Paul EtchisonAnd this is what happened with that client I was talking about that I worked with in Florida. We looked at this. We started to get the front desk team to ask. And a lot of the times it was like the patient would say something like, you know, it doesn't hurt. Or they would say something like, Yeah, I didn't, I don't know if I had to get this done right away or if it was like urgent. Or they would say, like, I'm not sure why I need this. So these things kept coming up. And that was just a dead tail sign that something that we are communicating is not landing. You know, they say like communication, successful communication means the message sent is the message that is received.
Paul EtchisonWell, what the doctor was sending was not being received. So we uncovered some very important things. And then when we worked with the doctor and we watched some case presentations, and then we worked with the hygienists and we talked to them about how to communicate about treatment, how to effectively do it. This is all part of our coaching program. We give your team the verbiage and we give you the verbiage, but we we looked at some case presentations and it was very obvious that we weren't spending enough time talking about the right things, but we were actually spending a lot of time talking about like the procedure and the how.
Paul EtchisonAnd we just decided this is going way over the patient's head. This is way too much information. So we tightened that up. We made sure that the hygienist was co-diagnosing. And you know what happened? That whole thing, like we need 35 new patients a month for this doctor, we didn't need it anymore. We were fine to get that person busy on 20 new patients a month. And that's the beautiful thing about increasing case acceptance. You don't have to change anything with getting more new patients in. You just need to work with the patients you already have. And when your office gets to a point where you have more demand than you can supply, that's a great place to be.
Paul EtchisonBecause now we can get intentional about our schedule. We can make sure that we schedule certain procedures at certain times of the day so that we always hit our production goal and our days are super chill and they're very relaxing and they're very not low stress and the team isn't running around like crazy. But that's not what we can do when we have openings in our schedule, when we don't have enough demand. Because when you don't have enough demand and you have those openings, you'll try to get everything you can, same-day dentistry, and you will push your team to the breaking point over and over again just to have a big ass opening for like two hours the next day, which makes no sense.
Paul EtchisonThat's not how we should be doing it. So if we can get the demand to outpace the supply in our office, it's a good thing. And that's what we did with this one office just by changing the case presentation. And lastly, of course, even if we're asking, we're asking the patients why they aren't scheduling, they'll give us a reason. There is going to be some patients that just aren't ready today. And that doesn't mean we should abandon them. We need to follow up on people. And we talked about this in a recent episode. The thing with follow-up, uh, nobody ever owns follow-up, nobody has scheduled time to do it, and nobody has a system for doing it.
Paul EtchisonIt's not surprising when we look at these offices and we realize that this isn't happening at all. And what a big missed opportunity. So there is going to be some patients that just need more time, and that is totally cool, but we need to make sure that we don't just abandon them or forget about them. We need a follow-up system. So the big thing I want you to communicate with your team is we need to reframe their mindset. Our purpose with doing this, with changing the system and trying a different way of presenting is not to pressure people into accepting dentistry they don't want. Our goal is to support the patients who have a legitimate recommended treatment plan and they might need assistance because they're uncertain about something about the procedure or why they need it.
Paul EtchisonAnd lastly, respectful, you know, that big emphasis on the word respectful. Respectful questions and respectful follow-up will help to clarify those concerns and it will help patients make an informed decision. And if we're only treatment planning the things that patients need, that is helping the patients get healthy. So my hope is that you will stop immediately looking to marketing when you want more production and actually consider how much diagnosed treatment is already sitting unscheduled in your practice. And for if you're like most practices, your case acceptance dollar for dollar is like right around 30 to 33%, which means if you're in a one and a half million dollar practice, that means$3 million are getting diagnosed every year that aren't getting completed.
Paul EtchisonSo what a huge opportunity. Even just like a modest improvement will represent a significant chunk of production that will fill your schedule and push you to that point where you can start making some more intentional decisions about your schedule because you'll have more demand. And like I said, in that one office I worked with, they got plenty busy with just 20 new patients per month. Now we eventually increased those new patients too, but that helped because eventually this doctor brought on an associate. So all good things. So before you bring another patient through your door, find out what happened to the patients who already walked out of it.
Paul EtchisonHere's your tactical takeaways from this episode. One, ask the question. Train your admin team to respectfully uncover the reason the patient's not scheduling. Don't assume it's money. Don't assume that they don't care. Ask, be curious, listen, and document what they say. Two, close the feedback loop. Make sure the doctor and the clinical team are learning why the patients aren't scheduling. Look at the patterns and sit down with your team and come up with ways to improve the way that the treatment's explained, how you can build more trust, and how you communicate those recommendations.
Paul EtchisonDon't automatically blame it on the front desk. That's the easy way. Don't do that. And lastly, make follow-up a true responsibility at your office. Give ownership to somebody, schedule protected time, and create a consistent process around it that everybody can do. So the patients just don't disappear and never come back to your office. So you can't improve a process when you don't understand why it's failing. And you can't grow your practice effectively. You keep overlooking the opportunities you already have.
Paul EtchisonIf you're listening to this and realizing that your team or your case presentation systems aren't working the way they should, and you're not getting feedback and you're not finding out about those objections or even working the unscheduled treatment list, that is exactly the type of thing that we help practices improve. You know, at Dental Practice Heroes, we work with case acceptance. We teach the team how to speak about procedures. We give them the training, we give them the mindset change that they need to approach this from a different way so that they're motivated to do it for the right reasons. And that's going to help you grow production without really, I mean, not working harder or spending more money on marketing.
Paul EtchisonSo if that's something you want to discuss, set up a strategy call with me, dentalpracticeheroes.com/slash strategy. We'll have a no pressure conversation. I'll listen to your goals. I'll listen to what's going on in your practice. And if I think dental practice heroes can help you, I'll tell you and show you what that looks like. And at the bare minimum, you'll at least find out what is the next thing I should be working on as a practice owner. And I will give you some immediate, tangible, timely advice that you will be happy you had the call with me. I promise that. So, closing thought here don't just look at how many patients are coming into your practice.
Paul EtchisonStart paying attention to what happens after they get there, because that's where you might find your biggest opportunity. Thank you so much for listening, and we'll talk to you next time.
Why aren’t you making more money? Is it overhead? Are you paying your hygienists too much? Do you need to bring on an associate? In this episode, Jake Conway, the founder of Custom Practice Analytics, shows you how to...
Afraid your team will quit if you hold them accountable? This is why so many practice owners let things slide, avoid tough conversations, and dread going into the office. Katherine Eitel Belt, founder of LionSpeak, says...
You can feel it the moment a practice starts to drift: the phones get answered five different ways, the schedule depends on one hero employee, and “that’s how we’ve always done it” becomes the loudest system in the...
Your team makes the changes you ask for. Then they slowly go back to the old way. In this episode, the DPH coaches break down how to make changes in your practice actually stick. You’ll learn the question to ask...
Your team looks slammed, the phones never stop, and patients keep checking in, yet production still feels soft. That disconnect is maddening, especially when you spot missed opportunities like unscheduled treatment that...