Supernatural Season 9, Episode 16, Blade Runners recap 🍕 Crowley is in a hotel room in silk pajamas, surrounded by drained bodies, eating pizza and crying at sad movies. Nobody call Hell right now, on Denim-wrapped Nightmares, a Supernatural rewatch podcast. The King of Hell is now a human blood addict, and Abaddon is taking over his kingdom while he's binge-watching. So Sam and Dean stage an intervention, drag him back to the bunker, and follow the First Blade’s trail all the way to a magical, invisible mansion. It belongs to a Men of Letters reject with a collection problem, and he thinks Dean would make a lovely addition. Episode Highlights: Crowley drunk-dials Dean, and Sam gets to hear the voicemail Silk pajamas, pizza, sad movies, and a closet full of “supply” Snooki shows up as a crossroads demon An intervention, and Crowley goes cold turkey in the dungeon Crowley gets sentimental about the moment he and Sam shared in that cathedral Crowley steals candy from a vending machine, then roots around in an art dealer’s brain The antiquities curator gives Dean her card (only Dean) “We’re legacies!” Sam holds Henry’s box up to an empty field, and a smoky portal appears Cuthbert Sinclair, the Men of Letters’ master of spells, and his very creepy “zoo” The First Blade finally meets the Mark of Cain, and Dean’s arm won’t stop shaking Both hosts liked Cuthbert as a quirky villain, even if he’s mostly a means to an end. Berly loved Sam and Crowley’s chemistry, and she pitches an arc where helping Crowley through his addiction helps Sam finally accept himself. The gore: a slit throat and a decapitation with a shockingly clean cut. Berly’s continuity complaints: a shapeshifter that transforms without shedding its skin, and a “sex scene” where Crowley stays fully dressed (she has a tattoo theory). Plus, the director, Serge Ladouceur, is usually the show’s DP. In the lore segment, LA covers the real Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn, an 1888 Victorian occult society with ranked grades, secret chiefs, and members like W.B. Yeats and Aleister Crowley. Crowley’s hexagram later became the Men of Letters crest, so the bunker’s glorified book club has real occult bones. “You don’t know what it’s like to be human.” - Crowley Your turn, hunters: Would you watch a Sam and Crowley buddy arc? And should Crowley really be the one holding the First Blade? Tell us in the Spotify comments, leave a rating and review on Apple Podcasts (it’s how new hunters find us), or send us fan mail. Bonus points for fandom fun facts we missed. Sources: https://supernatural.fandom.com/wiki/Blade_Runners https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hermetic_Order_of_the_Golden_Dawn https://supernatural.fandom.com/wiki/Men_of_Letters Send us your review! Support the show Denim-wrapped Nightmares is a Supernatural rewatch podcast hosted by Berly and LA, breaking down every episode of the Winchester saga with lore deep-dives plus cast and crew interviews. Special thanks to David Fesliyan and Fesliyan Studios. Subscribe, leave a review, and, if you choose to drink, please drink responsibly. Join the hunt at linktr.ee/dwnpod where you can find links to socials and sign up for emails. Until next time, cheers!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
BerlyWelcome to Denim Wrapped Nightmares, a supernatural rewatch podcast, where we explore the TV series episode by episode.
LAOver drinks, we'll discuss the lore, the gore, and what we adore about the Winchesters and their adventures.
BerlyHello, LA.
LAHi. I'm not very good at these jokes. Last episode was titled Thin Man. A teenage girl, Casey, was killed in the final selfie she took before she was attacked by a ghostly figure from the background of her picture. And looking for something to keep them busy, Dean and Sam headed to Washington to find the ghost. While the two interviewed the girl's mother, they were surprised when she started talking about cold spots and fritzing.
LAWhen they asked her about bringing up paranor paranormal signs, Betty replied that the supernaturalists who called earlier brought it up, who ended up being Harry and Ed from the Ghost Facers.
BerlyWell, today's episode is titled Blade Runners. It's the 16th episode of season nine and originally aired on March 18th, 2024. We open up at the bunker, and Sam, he's Googling Kane and Abel. So I commented on the last episode about how Sam clearly saw Dean stab that poor guy and kind of was like, ugh, but didn't bring it up.
LAYeah.
BerlyIt's obviously still on his mind that that was weird. Uh yeah. Let's let's do some research about all of this. Dean is calling and calling and calling Crowley. He's really upset. Crowley's not answering his calls or returning his calls, but he does play for Sam. He's like, I mean, he called me back and left a message, but I don't understand what he says. He plays, and it's just like, Dean, uh and Sam's like, oh my god, Crowley drunk dials you. I thought that was funny.
BerlyThen we cut to a hotel room, qualm number one. We hear like moaning and noises, nice little noises, and we see heels and clothing strewn about. So why when we got to the bed was Crowley fully clothed?
LAOh no.
BerlyLike, listen, okay, here's what I think it is. Mark Shepherd is tatted up. And I'm assuming they felt like Crowley wouldn't be tatted up. Who are you to judge that? Why can't Crowley be tatted up?
LAI mean, they have makeup for that to cover them.
BerlyBut I think they didn't want to do the makeup. That's why they just had him in clothes. Uh-oh. Okay. Right? Is what I'm thinking here. But I wanted sexy, naked, topless hobbit. Tatted all over. And we just got sweaty silk pajamas.
LAYeah.
BerlyAnyway, Crowley is with Lola, his little, I don't know, assistant right now, who is getting apparently great sex, because she seemed sweaty and all that stuff too. Also, pretty, pretty clothed, less clothed than Crowley. Again, problem. But whatever. She gets up and they have a dude tied up in the closet, get some blood from him, and he passes out. And so she's like, hey, like, so the closet's almost dry. Your supply here. So Crowley is still addicted to human blood, and this woman is serving as his supplier.
BerlyHe tells her he's feeling ravenous. And so I'm thinking it's sexy time again, but no, she leaves and goes and gets him pizza and comes back. And he's watching sad movies and crying and all of that. So that's where Crowley is. He's still very much addicted to human blood.
LAYeah.
BerlyWe then see that Lola, she's a double crosser. She is reporting to Abaddon, except it's not Abaddon who comes and visits them. We don't see Abaddon this episode. I guess Elena Huffman, maybe she was guest starring on something else at the time. Maybe they didn't have it in the budget to have her on the show this episode, but some dude named Aldo shows up instead. And Lola totally rats on Crowley. He's addicted to this human blood. He's a sobbing, whining mess. If it's not pizza, sex, or human blood, he doesn't care. He's totally unmotivated.
BerlyAnd then she fucking had to do it, where she said, Oh yeah, the Winchesters keep to calling him also. And something was mentioned on a voicemail about the first blade. So it's like, ah, shit.
LAShit.
BerlyAnd then she said, Next time I have intel, I expect to speak to the next queen of hell. And I was like, oh, she's not gonna like that.
LANo.
BerlyAbaddon is saying she's already the queen. Why are you calling her the next queen? You need to change that, Lola. Sam and Dean decide to summon a crossroads demon to see if they can't get more intel on where the fuck Crowley is and whether or not he's found the first blade. So they summoned Snooky. So weird. It was a very weird cameo. It was odd. I mean, she did fine. Yeah. She did fine. And I knew something was coming because I happened to see her name in the credits at the beginning.
BerlyBut I was like, what the fuck? What is she gonna be doing? So if you're gonna have Snooky star to have her be a demon, I thought was kind of funny.
LAWell, and it took me a minute to realize she was playing herself and not a character.
BerlyRight, yeah.
LAOkay.
BerlyAnyway, she lets them know that she heard he's been like out in the ocean looking in the western Pacific, and she's like, I don't know what the fuck is going on, but I got a thing. All right, like that I've told y'all what I know. Let me go. Oh, and she does tell them like Abaddon's making her move. She is taking shit over, down in hell, and even Crowley loyalists are starting to support Abaddon because Crowley's just been MIA, which, you know, yeah. I mean, understandable. Lola returns to Crowley, and luckily he's not dumb.
BerlyHe knows that she's betrayed him. So I don't know if like Aldo, I was trying to figure it out. So was Aldo actually Crowley's minion and he just pretended like he was Abaddon's. But Abaddon does figure out that they're looking for the first blade because she's starting to look for it too. So I couldn't figure out how Crowley exactly jumped to that conclusion of uh you double-crossed me. But he knew somehow that she did. Yeah. Kills her with an angel blade, and then looks around the room and sees like three bodies thrown about and starts to like tear up.
BerlyLike very clearly drained of all their blood, too. Oh yeah.
LAPale as hell. And I'm like, who just sits around with all these bodies? It's gonna start stinking. Yeah.
BerlyAll that pizza. And then I said, and he looks like he needs a shower. Like he's still pretty dewy.
LAI would not want to be in there.
BerlyWhen's when's the last time you changed out of those pajamas, Crowley? Like, yeah. Not in a good place. Not in a good place. Well, Crowley acknowledges this, and out of desperation, he makes a call to the only people he can call right now, the Winchesters. He lets them know that he needs help.
LAWhen I I like when Crowley like comes back to his little hotel room or whatever, and the boys are just sitting there, I'd be like, oh, oh, how nice.
BerlyIntervention time. Yeah. They decide to take Crowley with them back to the bunker that he needs to get clean, sobered up, cold turkey. So they toss him back in the dungeon. Bless his heart. He's just like, oh.
LAAs soon as I saw him, I was like, oh my God. This poor guy.
BerlyCrowley also is like staring at Sam while Sam is down there taking notes on everything Crowley's been tracking. What did he say? Like he he couldn't find it in the ocean. And so he found out some pirates found it, and then they sold it to this, and then they sold it to that, and then they've sold it to this. And they know that buyers are looking for it, but they don't know where it actually is yet. Sam's taking notes, and Crowley's just staring at him. And then Sam's like, what? And Crowley's like, I'm sorry, okay? Like, I'm just I'm feeling sentimental. You and I, you and I have had a moment.
BerlyWe had a moment in the cathedral at the end of season eight. Do you remember? You're my Marnie Moose. I miss you. And Sam's like, stop it. Stop it. Get your shit together, Crowley. They end up finding an arts dealer of some sort, like an underground arts dealer. And they set up a meeting with him in a park. And Crowley steals candy from the vending machine. He was hungry, okay? He's ravenous. Remember?
LAAnd the boys are real irritated.
BerlyBut it was a good plan. Crowley sat on a separate bench. Sam and Dean are, you know, investigating, or not investigating, interrogating the a the guy, the arts dealer. The arts dealer isn't going to give them shit. So Crowley just decides I'll just possess his body, root around in his brain, find the information that we need, and we're done. So he does that. They send the arts dealer on their way, and they know they are going to the National Institute of Antiquities in Kansas City, Missouri. We cut to the Institute, and we see two gentlemen, they're just playing cards on their shift.
LASecurity.
BerlyJust enjoying each other's company. And then we see two black clouds come in, and we're like, okay, well, Crowley's not working with any other demons right now, except Lola's out the picture, right? So the black clouds mean that must be Abaddon's people, not Crowley's. They possess the two security guards, go and look through the vault. This poor woman brings them food.
LAI feel like she had a little crush on him.
BerlyI thought so too. Yeah. Like, I'm like, which one? I couldn't figure out which one, but you know, she she's like, walks in and is like, hey, I brought y'all something for your shift. And they're just ignoring her. Like she's not even there. So she goes up to put her hand on one of their shoulders and they pick up like a plaque, like a metal, like a nameplate looking thing is what it looks like to me. It was just this metal thing and just slit her throat. That special effect was really good. There were some cool special effects in here in this episode today. Kill her. And then Sam and Dean, they arrive, and of course, it's a murder scene now.
BerlySo there's investigators everywhere. They show them the security footage where I was like, okay, I guess the security footage didn't pick up the black clouds coming in and possessing the two guys because we don't see that. We just see the two guys up looking through the vault, killing the assistant, and then one comes out of the vault, shoots the other guy. And I'm like, why'd y'all shoot him? Didn't they shoot each other? Yeah. He shot the other guy, and then the other guy shot him, and then the guy from the vault came over and shot the camera. So basically, the demons killed the two vessels so that whenever they left them, they'd be dead.
BerlyBut I'm like, it really doesn't seem like y'all needed to kill anybody. No, not at all. Just chaos. Chaos and carnage under the rule of Abaddon, apparently. They just do not give a shit about leaving people alive. You know, under Crowley, the guy would have turned around and pretended, oh, thank you so much for the food. Okay, now go away. Or he would have been mean to her and made her cry and run away. Okay, I'm just saying.
LAIt's true.
BerlyAll right. So they're just like, well, fuck. Okay, I guess we're screwed. But the antiques lady in charge, they start interrogating her, asking her. Dr. McElroy. Oh. Dr. McFuntimes. She was she was wanting it, yeah. But she was like, ooh, are you gonna are you gonna compel me to speak? What's that going to entail?
LATell me how.
BerlyTell me more. Here's my card in case you need anything later. Not you, Sam. Yeah, no.
LADean. Talk about like uh, what do they call it? Like eye fucking somebody. Oh my god.
BerlyAnd Dean was Dean was into it. Yeah. He kept he kept switching between like, oh, and no, I'm serious, I'm serious, investigator man, with his face. There was a lot of great facial acting in this scene between those two.
LAI feel like at first It was cute. Like one of the times he was looking at her and it looked like he was like, Is she flirting with she?
BerlyI'm not sure. I like this. But I'd not into it. And then she walks away. He's looking her up and down, and Sam's just like, Dean. Oh, and then the giving of the card. Oh, yeah. That's why I said, like, not you, Sam. Yeah. Dean. It was cute. This was a cute little scene. So they find out from her that she was able to carbon date the first blade to biblical times, but other than that, she wasn't going to be able to authenticate it in any other way, which means it was just going to sit in the vault forever. So why not, you know, make a little, make a little money off of it?
BerlyWhy am I just gonna leave it in the vault? She's a naughty lady. Naughty, naughty, naughty. She was like, I got a I got an offer I couldn't refuse. You know what I'm saying here? And they were like, okay, well, who was it? And she said, I don't know. He used the name Magnus. I mean, he was clearly an alias. He's very secretive, whatever. That's all I know. Talk to you later. Sam and Dean go back to the bunker and are talking with Crowley about all of this again for some reason. I don't know why.
LAUh, well, because they realized that the Magnus was a pseudonym that the Men of Letters always used to use to be like another.
BerlyWhy does that include Crowley?
LABecause they realize that there must be a lingering Men of Letters they don't know about. And I guess Crowley somehow because they asked him.
BerlyThat's what I'm saying. Like, I still don't I still don't understand why they assumed Crowley would know anything. But anyway, while they're down there talking to Crowley, Crowley ends up throwing a shit fit. You know, basically telling them, I'm fucked because of y'all. You know, if you hadn't taken me and shot me up with human blood, I wouldn't have become an addict. I wouldn't have lost my kingdom. All of these things wouldn't have happened. I'm totally fucked because of the two of you. And so they were like, Well, what do you want? What can what can we do? And all he wanted was out of the dungeon. He just wanted to go and hang out and play with them.
BerlyI thought that was funny. So we cut to the library. Crowley is sitting there enjoying, well, I shouldn't say he's enjoying scotch. He actually wasn't very happy with the scotch at all. But he's having a glass of scotch while Sam and Dean are going through all of the members of the Men of Letters because they know Albert Magnus was the alias that the men of letters used. This person used the name Magnus. Surely that's not a coincidence. Then Crowley pointed out to them, You're looking through the active members. I'm telling you, I know somehow, we still aren't sure how, but somehow Crowley knows that there was at least one men of letters who got booted out.
BerlyAnd he was like, You need to look in somewhere else. And so they fortunately are able to find out about Cuthbert Sinclair. He was the master of spells. He was super fucking good at warding. He's the one who warded the bunker against anything and everything. And he was, in fact, booted out. He got expelled because he started having uh ambitions that a lot of the other men letters were thinking would be reckless and kind of not their place to be doing. And he got booted for that reason.
BerlySo he's a rebel. We also find out he's crazy, but you know, at this point in time, they're thinking, oh, he's just, he's just a rebel who wanted to do his own things. Like they didn't actually go through his projects just yet. Sam does does that later, whenever he realizes, uh-oh, I don't think this is a good guy. Then they go through the actual things. But, you know, at this point they're just like, oh, okay, he's just a rebel. He's just a rebel. And he got kicked out in 1956, so that means he wasn't there whenever Abaddon massacred everybody.
BerlySo this is their threat. They're gonna follow it. Crowley takes Sam and Dean to a field in the middle of nowhere and says, okay, whatever. I was trying to find him to kill the last men of letters, you know. Which I'm like, why was Crowley trying to help kill off the men of letters? Why did you care? You were a crossroads demon at that time, weren't you? Oh yeah. Well, maybe he was king. I don't know. I'm not I don't think we're supposed to think this much about this plot point. Yeah. I think we're supposed to just kind of go with it. Let's go with it. So let's just go with it.
BerlyAnd he explains we were able to track everything to here, but as you can see, there's absolutely nothing. And the trail goes cold from here. He was like, I promise this is the exact same spot, but I got nothing more for you. And then Sam was like, well, he was the master of spells. He was the one who warded the bunker. You know, maybe he used warding or something. Yeah, and if this is where everything is, we can't see him, but that doesn't mean he can't see us. So they just kind of start talking out loud, really loud, like we're we're legacies, we're minaladders.
BerlySamples that box out that Henry Winchester gave them and is like holding it up. Like that's their idea.
LAWe're totally cool, guys. Come on.
BerlyWe're Henry Winchester's grandbabies. Look, I've got his box. Well, it works. And I liked how the door appeared.
LALike the portal, yeah.
BerlyYeah, the portal with kind of the smoke and everything. That was really cool.
LAI thought somebody was gonna come out of the smoke. I didn't realize it was gonna be a little bit more. I did too.
BerlyI did too. Sam and Dean walk into it, and they suddenly find themselves in a house with beautiful woodwork, beautiful wood paneling everywhere. They're walking through, like, what the fuck? And then these two vampires jump out of nowhere and attack them. They take them out really quickly, and then Cuthbert so Claire is like slow clapping over like a loudspeaker or something. You did exactly what you should have done. I'm impressed. It's it's nice to have a zoo on hand. I'm like, what the fuck is going on here? Well, then they explain how they are legacies, but actually we're hunters, and he's like giggling, like, oh my god, the middle letters must be rolling in their graves that you're here.
BerlyThey explain, you you have the first blade. We know you have it. Uh, we need it because we need to take out Abaddon. And don't you want us to get revenge on Abaddon? She killed all your friends and everything. And he says, Well, the first blade is useless without the mark of Kane. And Dean shows that he has the mark. And so Cuthbert is just like, oh my God.
LAHe is excited.
BerlyOh my God. He's like, You're he's hot. He's got the mark of Caesar. It's gonna complete the set for my collection. And he was like asking Dean, I want you to be my companion. It gets lonely here. Wink, wink, wink. Well, anyways, Sam is not of use to him. So he like says a spell, blows some dust in him, boots Sam out of the building. So we see Sam running through the bushes again, and Crowley's like, the fuck? He explains to Crowley what happened, and now they're going through the files to try and found out more information on this Cuthbert.
LAWhen have we ever seen them have files in the in the car just randomly to go through?
BerlyRight. Like you thought that they might be important later, and so you brought them with you, but you didn't think it was important to look at them before you walked through the magical portal. Yeah. While Sam is doing this, Crowley is talking to him more about like, I'm doing, I'm doing a good job. I'm doing a good job. Like it's so cute how much. Oh, sorry, I skipped a step. So while he's going through everything, Sam finds the spell that Cuthbert Sinclair created that would make a building invisible. So Sam finds that and he says he's gonna need quite a few ingredients that are gonna be hard to get.
BerlyCrowley goes and gets those ingredients, and so it's after that that Crowley's like, didn't I do good? Yeah, I did a good job. Yeah, he wants Sam's approval so badly.
LAI mean, Sam just is giving him nothing.
BerlyNothing. Nothing. He's not giving him a damn thing. Well, they get in and Crowley hides while Sam gets caught by Cuthbert Sinclair, and Cuthbert is like cutting up Dean's or Sam's face, and he has Dean under a spell where he took away all of his will, all of his thoughts, all of this stuff. But I guess that spell wore off because he did say, like, imagine how it's gonna feel after I do that to you a few times. And Dean was clearly upset whenever Cuthbert was hurting Sam. So I would be too I guess the face, man.
BerlyWell, I guess the spell had worn off a little bit, is my point. Yeah. Because he he he was having his own thoughts in that moment. Another qualm I had in this episode, when the shapeshifter jumped out and was Magnus, it didn't shed its skin and stuff. It just like magically wavelength into the shapeshifter. Oh yeah.
LASee these continuity things.
BerlyYeah, there's a lot. Yeah. I really feel like it had to be budget. I feel like they've gotten budget and time.
LAI guess so. Something.
BerlyBut also, like, then just make it not a shapeshifter. Just make it he's a magician. He could have just cloned himself, you know? Yeah. If you can't stick to the rules, the skin should have burst off.
LAAnyway. He's a special kind.
BerlyCrowley sneaks in the room while Sinclair is distracted with Sam, which understandable.
LAWhich I love how casually he just waltz into the room, like oh he helps with Dean get free.
BerlyAnd Dean, I'm thinking there's gonna be like a confrontation where they say something something, but no, Dean just like whack decapitates Sinclair.
LALike, just like taps him on the shoulder and then just boom.
BerlyIt was fast. And then his arm is vibrating like crazy. And it was doing that earlier. And Sinclair was like, Oh, it'll it'll be easier next time you hold it, and you'll even come to welcome the feelings. And so you can see he's shaking, and Sam like had to talk him off a ledge and be like, put it down, put it down. He finally dropped it, and it's just like damn.
LAYou could tell he was really fighting like his face, he was really fighting something.
BerlyYeah, what exactly? Yeah, you know, that's where it's like, Oh shit, it looks scary. It looks like it's gonna be a problem, guys. Yeah, this might not be the easy peasy solution that y'all. Thought it was gonna be. Like, damn. Anyway, they get out and they see that the Impala has been ransacked. Luckily, everything in the trunk was fine, so they didn't get the important stuff, but they did key the side of the car. And it was a warning to Crowley that said, be afraid, signed your queen.
LAI love how right after this happens, Sam's all, okay, you said the only reason we need Crowley is to get the blade. It's time. Let's get rid of them.
BerlyLet's get rid of them. And Crowley wisens up to it very quickly, pushes them up against the car, and he's like, you know what? I'm taking the blade. Because y'all are sitting here saying they're like, we can't trust you. And he's like, well, apparently I can't fucking trust you either. So I'm gonna take this. And once y'all track down Abaddon and you need it, then I'll give it to you. And you know what? I gotta say, after seeing how Dean was reacting with it, I don't think it's a bad thing that he's not gonna have that on hand. Yeah.
LAThat and I don't blame Prowley with especially like how hard he has been trying, and they just don't give a shit.
BerlyMm-mm. Do not care. So I don't blame him one bit for being like, okay, I'm just gonna. This is gonna be my security. That and keeping it it it safe from seemingly deemed. I don't think that's why he's doing it.
LANo, I mean like I think that's gonna be good. Yeah, these are the pluses of him doing it.
BerlyEspecially since Sinclair, he said something about how like you're gonna welcome the feelings that it brings. So if that's something he's gonna start like craving practically, I think it's a good thing that he that they aren't gonna have it on hand. Yeah. That Crowley's gonna keep it separate. And that was basically the end of the episode. Yeah. It was written by Brad Buckner and Eugenie Ross Lemming, and it was directed by oh, Serge La Dessours. The sweetness. He's typically the DP, which means that um Brad Creaser probably was the DP on this episode.
LAOh, okay.
BerlyAll right, gore. I mean, Cuthbert Sinclair's head decapitation was pretty shocking.
LAI mean, he did such a good clean cut. There wasn't much blood.
BerlyNot a lot until the body fell over and then some kind of spilled out, but it's not like there was a splooge or anything. I mean, damn. You would have thought he would have had to saw that thing. That blade doesn't look very sharp.
LAYeah, that's what I didn't see it happen because once again I'm taking my notes. But then when I realized it was that, I was like, oh, that was a really clean cut for how it's magic. That looks magic. Yeah. It's because it's magic.
BerlyDid you adore anything about this episode? It was kind of just like, okay, we just need to get him the blade already.
LAI feel like I started to like Cuthbert just as like a bad character. He was quirky.
BerlyYeah, he was a quirky little villain. I liked Cuthbert as as a as a villain, but also I understand that he was kind of a means to an end here.
LAYeah.
BerlyFor us to just kind of get the first blade already. Um, just having Crawley find it in the Mariana trench. I understand how that would have been boring. This was more interesting for it to have already been found and traveled all this time through all these people who didn't even really know what they had and all of that. So it was it was interesting. Um, I was loving Crowley and Sam and their uh their interactions, their chemistry. I think there is a lot of potential between Sam and Crowley.
BerlySpoiler warning. Spoiler warning, spoiler warning, you're gonna want to skip ahead if you're watching the show for the first time with us listeners. I had actually talked with our good friend Sadie about how what I thought was gonna happen with Crowley and Sam, and was informed that is not what's going to happen in this show. Not at any point. And I just want to say, especially after seeing this episode, what a lost opportunity. What I thought was going to happen with Crowley and Sam was that they were going to bond with each other, and that in accepting Crowley, Sam was going to accept that part of himself that he's been so ashamed of all these years.
BerlyYou know, Sam was going to see, because you remember whenever it showed Crowley shooting up the human bud, and Sam saw him and then just kind of hid alongside. That's when I started thinking, like, oh, Sam's gonna end up helping Crowley because he's going to remember when he was addicted to demon blood, and now he sees Crowley's addicted to human blood. And through accepting Crowley and helping Crowley, he's gonna actually live to learn to accept himself and stop thinking he's a freak. And like, all that's where I thought this was gonna kind of go. That's not gonna happen. And I just especially seeing today, this episode today, what a lost opportunity.
BerlyYeah. I mean, and to give Sam something to do, give him his own, like okay, it's not an angel. Like, but Dean has so much he gets to do with Castel for Sam to get to have his supernatural entity who helps him, and for it to be a demon, I I don't know. I feel like that that could have been really interesting.
LAYeah.
BerlyAnd it makes me sad to know that that's never gonna come to fruition. That he would like actually tell Crowley, like, yeah, you did do a good job. You know? It'd be nice. I guess that you can't have something like that happen though, and have Crowley still be a threat, still be an obstacle for them, as the only reason why I can think that they wouldn't have gone that route. But I wish they had.
LAYeah, it would have been good. All right, well, what about that lore? All right, well, it turns out that the Winchester's favorite secret society of magical librarians might have real-world DNA. And it traces back to a very real, very dramatic Victorian occult club. All right, so we're gonna meet the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn. Founded in 1888 by three English Freemasons. This was a real secret society devoted to studying the occult Hermeticism, ceremonial magic, astrology, tarot, and alchemy.
LAIt ran on a strict hierarchy of ranked grades, neophyte, zealotor, adept, all the way up to mysterious secret chiefs who supposedly guided the whole order from behind the curtain. If that sounds like initiates working their way up to Elder Master of Spells status while guarding ancient secrets, yeah, keep that thought. It attracted a genuinely wild membership roster. We're talking poet W.B. Yeats, actress Florence Farr, Dracula adjacent, horror writer Arthur Matchin, Rom Stoker's actual friend circle, basically, and the infamous occultist Alistair Crowley, who eventually split off to found his own philosophy called Thalema.
LACrowley's Thelema uses a symbol called the Universal Hexagram. And according to the supernatural wiki itself, the exact symbol, sometimes called the Aquarian Star, is literally the Men of Letters crest in the show. The same six-pointed sign, straight out of real occult history, now stitched onto Sam and Dean's bunker walls.
BerlyAnd their box.
LAOh. I had to think there for a second. I was like, what, what? Uh the real Golden Dawn had ranked levels of initiation, guarded secret knowledge, and considered itself above ordinary practitioners. Show-wise, the Men of Letters are described almost identically. An elite ranked order of preceptors, observers, beholders, chroniclers, who consider hunters beneath them, pass membership down bloodlines, and guard a vault of magical knowledge under a mountain of secrecy.
LAEven the book club joke tracks historically. The show's wiki notes, the name is basically a wink at well-read individuals, and the real Golden Dawn was exactly that in practice. A bunch of British intellectuals, writers, and occultists cosplaying as ancient magical adepts while actually just being extremely into ceremonial ritual and secret knowledge of its own sake. The takeaway is the Winchester's glorified book club isn't just a cute writer's room joke. It's built on the actual bones of a real Victorian secret society, right down to borrowing one of its most famous members' personal magical symbol at their as their house crest.
BerlyQuote to close it out was from Crowley. When Sam and Dean showed up for their intervention, he said, You don't know what it's like to be human. Cheers. Thank you for listening to this episode of Denim Wrapped Nightmares, a supernatural podcast. End-to-end production is by Burley Land. Music is by David Beslian. This episode is co-hosted by Burley and LA. If you enjoyed this episode, please leave a review or rating. It helps other supernatural fans find the show.
BerlyAnd if you choose to drink, please drink responsibly. This was fun, jerk.
Supernatural Season 9, Episode 23, Do You Believe in Miracles? recap 🛝 It’s the Season 9 finale: Heaven’s gate is in a playground sandbox, Metatron is working miracles for the cameras, and Dean has the First Blade...
Supernatural Season 9, Episode 22, Stairway to Heaven recap 🎳 Angels are blowing themselves up in Cas’s name, Dean can't part from the First Blade, and Metatron is bowling for recruits, on Denim-wrapped Nightmares, a...
Supernatural Season 9, Episode 21, King of the Damned recap đź‘‘ Abaddon brings a guest from 1723, Crowley sweet-talks a hellhound over speakerphone, and Dean finally gets his hands on the First Blade again, on...
Supernatural Season 9, Episode 19, Alex Annie Alexis Ann recap đź§› Sheriff Jody Mills (Kim Rhodes) is BACK, and she's protecting a troubled teen named Alex (Katie Sarife), who was raised by a nest of vampires and really,...