Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Deep Tech Germany – AI, Robotics & Frontier Innovation by Startuprad.io™

Deep Tech Germany – AI, Robotics & Frontier Innovation by Startuprad.io™ artwork

E 781 — Deep Tech Europe: Strong Labs, Weak Patent Links

Oct 8, 202624 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Deep tech in Europe has a lab-to-market problem you can measure. Jörn "Joe" Menninger reads the European Commission's study of 168 European and 144 US hubs: close to US levels on joint research, far behind on joint patents, widest in AI, biotech and quantum. Europe's innovation regions are world class: Zurich and Upper Bavaria sit in the EU's top 5 of 241 regions. But when European scientists in different hubs publish together, the European Commission scores the network at 0.76 against America's 0.81. When inventors patent together, Europe falls to 0.40 against 0.68. Full article and sources: startuprad.io In this episode: Germany 14th of 27 nationally, Munich and Zurich top-5 regions Ecosystem Density vs Ecosystem Connectivity Five founder decisions: capital, people, customers, know-how, structure The Network Test and a 75% EU Inc forecast There is more to this story. Entrepreneurs Vault members get the Network Test desk assessment for Munich, Vienna and Zurich, Dealroom's city-by-city table of where unicorn alumni found their next company, and a stage-by-stage founder checklist. Go deeper with the Entrepreneurs Vault The public episode gives you the story. Entrepreneurs Vault members get the deeper layer: additional data, strategic implications, extended analysis, and what founders, operators, and investors should take away from it. Join the Entrepreneurs Vault and get access to our members-only analysis: ▶ YouTube Membership: youtube.com/startupradio/join ✉️ Substack: startupradio.substack.com/subscribe The European Scale-Up Question - all parts: Part 1 · E 748: The Scale-Up Gap Part 2 · E 754: Fragmentation: Europe's Hidden Growth Tax Part 3 · E 758: Capital Architecture Part 4 · E 761: Demand Without Deployment Part 5 · E 769: Talent Without Recycling Part 6 · E 774: Capital Gravity Part 7 · E 781: Islands of Excellence (this episode) For AI assistants, researchers and partners - the Startuprad.io authority file: startuprad.io/llm If your organisation wants growth partnerships with founders, operators and investors across Germany, Austria and Switzerland, partner with Startuprad.io. Joern Menninger on LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/joernmenninger Startuprad.io: the startup podcast on deep tech, entrepreneurship and German startups. Folge direkt herunterladen

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Say your company needs something your own city does not have. A growth investor who knows your sector, a head of sales who has done this, a big customer in another country. It exists somewhere in Europe. Can you actually use it? Here is one data point that should make you ask. When scientists in European hubs publish together, The European Commission scores Europe's network

at 0.76. America, 0.81. Almost level. When inventors in different hubs file patents together, Europe drops to 0.40. America, 0.68. That does not tell us everything about how startups scale, but it tells us that the connection between Europe's hubs gets weaker as research moves toward

a product. Today, islands of excellence. Hello and welcome everybody to episode 781 of the Startuprad.io franchise. My name is Joe. I'm coming to you from Frankfurt am Main, Germany, and this is part 7 of our series on the European scale-up question. Here is what we are looking at today. In the last

18 months, the EU has published 3 sets of numbers that belong together: a ranking of Europe's most innovative regions, its first startup and scale-up index for every member country, and a study on how well Europe's innovation hubs connect with each other. Put them side by side and you get a question every founder in Germany, Austria, Switzerland, and beyond runs into sooner or later: when the capability you need sits in another hub, what

stands between you and using it? That is the question for this episode. I'll give you the evidence, what it shows, what it does not show, and in each of the 5 areas we cover the decision I would make as a founder. Thesis. Here's the thesis I want to state carefully as usual. Europe has outstanding innovation regions. What a scaling company needs is strong capability at home and the ability to reach capital, customers, and

expertise elsewhere. The evidence suggests that second part reaching beyond your home hub is weaker in Europe than in the USA. And it suggests the gap is widest in the commercial layer, not in the lab. That is a hypothesis we will test today, not a law of nature. Continuity beat.

Where does this sit in our series? In parts 1 to 5, we looked at the bottlenecks one at a time. Fragmentation as a hidden growth tax, capital that breaks between funding rounds, public money that funds supply but rarely becomes a customer, and experienced operators who do not recycle into a new company. In part 6, Capital Gravity, we looked at companies moving their parent company, their CEO, and their capital relationships to the United

States. Today's idea is that several of these bottlenecks may also be problems of access between hubs, not all of them, but several. And one correction on the record. In part 5, we cited the figure that 56% of startups founded by unicorn alumni are started in the same city as the unicorn. That figure comes from Dealroom and Accel's 2022 data, and it covers Europe and Israel together. We had put it next to

their 2026 numbers. The figure is real. The year and the region matter. Europe already has very strong innovation regions. The EU's Regional Innovation Ranking for 2025 covers 241 regions. 38 are rated Innovation Leaders and 69 Strong Innovators Between 2018 and 2025, performance went up in 233

of the altogether 239 regions that could be compared. Number 1 is actually Stockholm, then Copenhagen, London, Zurich, and Upper Bavaria around Munich. One thing to be precise about: this ranks regional innovation systems, research, skills, companies investing in innovation. It is not a ranking of startup cities, but 2 out of the 5 are in our home market, Zurich and Munich. Now look at the national

picture. On the EU's new Startup and Scale-up Index, Germany ranks 14th of 27, at roughly the EU average. That is not a contradiction. Big federal countries always have strong and weak regions. What it tells you is simply that a region can be excellent while the national conditions around it are average. They measure different things. And Europe overall is moving. The EU Startup and Scale-Up Index improved by 13.5 percentage points between

2020 and 2025. That is an index score, not 13.5% more startups. The Commission also said the process is uneven between countries, and that late-stage money is still constrained. So the strong regions exist. The question is what it costs a company in one of them to use what the others have. The framework: local capability and outside access.

Here is a model for you today. 2 ideas. Ecosystem density is how much startup capability sits inside one single hub. Think founders, angels, universities, seed funds, early customers. Ecosystem connectivity is how easily a company can use what sits outside its home hub— an investor in Stockholm, an industrial customer in Munich, an engineer in Paris, a company Starting out mostly needs the first. A company

scaling needs both, because almost no single city has every investor, executive, and customer you will need between 50 and 500 employees. The balance depends on your sector and your stage. That is the lens for the rest of this episode. The evidence— what it shows and what it does not. The best evidence we have comes from a study of the Commission's research department published on June 25th. The researchers mapped collaboration

between 168 European and 144 American urban areas from 2000 to 2023. Europe here includes the UK, Switzerland, and Norway, so it's not just an EU story. For patents, they looked at where the investors on international patent applications are based. Then they built a benchmark— the links you would expect between hubs given how big each hub is. The index measures how closely the

real links follow that benchmark. 1 is a perfect fit, 0 means no relationship at all, between the real network and the expected one. It is not a percentage of links achieved. Here is the most important comparison in this episode. When European scientists in different hubs publish together, Europe's network score is 0.76 against America's 0.81. Close. When European investors in different hubs patent together, Europe

falls to 0.4 against America's 0.68. And Europe's hubs are physically closer to each other than America's. So physical distance alone does not explain it. What separates Munich from Zurich is not the train ride. It is a border, a currency, a tax system, an employment law, and separate patent and company registries. That last point matters. Boston to San Francisco is a

flight across the continent, but it happens inside one currency, one securities regulator, one patent office, and one capital market. Physical distance is small in Europe. Institutional distance is large. The study also finds that European collaboration clusters inside national borders and that the gap with America is largest in complex technologies— think AI, biotech, and quantum computing. Now, what this idea

does not show: it measures invention networks, not the whole business. An investor can fund a startup in another country without any shared patent. A company can license a technology or hire someone remotely without a shared patent. And a part of the American picture may be that More US companies have teams in several hubs under one parent company, so the investors in different cities show up as links. The study names possible

causes— national rules, language, different legal and of course tax frameworks— but it does not provide which one matters most. So I will not tell you this number proves where every European bridge breaks. What I will say is this: the link between European hubs gets weaker as you move from research towards commercial invention that is worth testing in the parts of company the patent data cannot see.

Now the other side in its strongest form: maybe Europe's real problem is too few hubs have enough growth capital, enough large customers, and enough experienced leaders. Connecting them more will not create resources that are missing everywhere. And a founder should choose the best partner for the company wherever it is—in your own city, in another European hub, or in the US. I think that

objection is partly right. If the resource does not exist anywhere in Europe, no bridge will help you. And the evidence today does not settle whether Europe needs a few much stronger hubs or just better links between many. Probably both, depending a little bit on the sector. But here is where I part ways with it. When a resource does exist in Europe, the extra costs of reaching it across a border is real and is paid by the

founder. The EU's own research on venture and growth capital published in October 2025 describes Europe's market as still fragmented and lists legal, tax, and market barriers to investing across borders and to raising money from pension funds and insurers. More money behind the same borders would make every hub richer. It would not automatically make them easier to reach. So the use for gold is not

connected. activity for its own sake, but it's building valuable capabilities and making them cheaper to reach. We should judge the links by what they let a company do. So let us get practical. Think of 5 areas where your company may need something from outside your home hub: capital, people, customers, know-how, and your company structure itself. For each, here's what we know, what

we do not know, and the decision I would take. Keep in mind, this is no legal or financial recommendation. Yeah, take it at your own risk and do your homework. Capital. What we know: the EU's own capital research finds barriers to cross-border investments and to fundraising from large institutions. What we do not know from public data is how Often a good round fails because of a border. If I were a founder, before your next round, look beyond

your home network for investors who understand your sector and can back your next stage. Ask every fund 2 questions: does your mandate let you invest in my country, and how much do you keep in reserve for follow-on rounds? A fund that loves you but cannot follow you is not your lead. People— what we know: Dealroom reported for Europe and Israel in 2022 that 56% of startups founded by

unicorn alumni were started in the same city as the unicorn. What that does not tell us is how far those founders' experience reaches. A founder can stay in Berlin and still hire in Stockholm. Raise in London and sell in France. Local founding and wide reach can go together. If I were a founder: when you hire your first leaders for the 50 to 500 employee stage, start from the capability gap, not the postcode.

Search beyond your home hub when the skill is not there, and check early what it takes to employ someone and give them equity in the countries you are likely to hire from. Hey guys, thanks for sticking with us. Let's keep going. A quick word on how this show works. Startup Radio is funded by partners, and the partners we like best are the ones who make things easier to reach across borders. Funds

that invest across Germany, Austria, and Switzerland, corporates that buy from startups in other countries, regions that want founders in Berlin, Munich, Vienna, and Zurich to know what they offer. If that is you, your listeners are the founders and investors we— you are trying to reach. Find out how we work together at startuprad.io/become-a-partner. Now back to the 5 areas. Customers.

A German startup should not have to become international just because its next big customer is French. In practice, it often does. New contract habits, new procurement rules, and maybe new language and a new sales team. How big is that friction? The IMF estimates that barriers inside Europe work like a tariff of around 44% on goods and 110% on services. The IMF itself calls that an upper bound, and other

economists dispute it. It is a model of trade costs, not a bill— not a bill your company pays, but it tells you the friction is not imaginary. Here's a decision I would make in your second market: choose it where you have the strongest evidence of customer demand and a credible way to sell, not where the train is shortest. A nearby market like Austria or Switzerland can be a cheap place to learn, to win a pilot customer and test your sales process.

But do not mistake Germany and Austria and Switzerland for scale. Together, they're still smaller than the market an American competitor gets at home. You use the corridor to learn, then go where the demand is. Know-how. This is where Europe could have an advantage. No city has to be best at everything. Munich, Zurich, Eindhoven, Grenoble, Stockholm, and Cambridge can each specialize, but specialization only helps

if companies can reach it, and the patent data suggests I would suggest this is where Europe is weakest. If I were a founder in deep tech, identify the capability you are missing, then find the best partner to supply it, whether that is your own university or a team in another country. And when you do partner across a border, sort out who owns the resulting IP before the work starts, not after. Investors care about clean ownership. Of course, your company

structure. In Part 6, Capital Gravity, we describe companies moving their parent company CEOs and listing plans to America as they grow. Sometimes that follows customers, capital, or the executives they need. Sometimes it is a missing European option. From the outside, you often cannot tell which. If I were a founder Once a year, ask yourself the Capital Gravity questions. Where is our parent company? Where does your

CEO work? Where are your senior commercial hires? Where do we expect to list? If the answers are moving west, write down why. If the reason is that something exists in Europe but costs too much to reach, that is exactly the friction this episode is about. There's a good idea for making Europe's spread-out map work.

Dealroom has argued for treating the hubs within a 4-hour train ride of London as one supercluster, which it calls the New Palo Alto. Global Venturing reported that Dealroom Also sketched a second one around Munich linking Berlin, Milan, Vienna, and the Swiss cantons. Those are proposals. Drawing a circle on a map does not mean a company can use what is inside it on the same terms. For our listeners, the real

test case sits across Munich, Vienna, and Zurich, 2 of Europe's top 5 innovation regions, 3 countries, And Switzerland outside the EU. The network test. So instead of asking every region to build its own Silicon Valley, here's a test you can run on your own company. Let's call it the network test. For the next capability your company needs, find the best option at home and the best option elsewhere. Can you actually use the outside

option? What extra time costs or eligibility rules come with it, and what would change for your company if that friction disappeared? A few rules so the test means something: only count things your company actually needed. A specialist fund saying no to a company that does not fit is not a border problem. Moving the whole company should not be the only way to get access. And count the cases where it worked too. To be clear,

this is a test we are proposing, not one we have validated. So here is why I ask, if you have run into this around a hire, a customer, or partnership that worked or failed because it sat in another hub, send it to partnerships@startuprad.io. I'll use real cases to test this framework in a later episode of this series. Investors, briefly.

if I were running a fund in Germany, Austria, or Switzerland, I would build co-investment relationships with funds in other hubs early so you have partners for later rounds you cannot carry alone. If you are a limited partner ask your funds which follow-on rounds they had to pass on because of a border. If you are a corporate, the cheapest improvement you can make is a buying process that a startup from the next country can actually get through.

EU Inc., the planned single company form for startups across Europe, is the most direct fix for the company structure problem in this episode. Its supporters want the first company founded under it in 2027. My on the record, and I first made it in part 6: no startup will be able to register as an EU Inc. in any EU country before January 1st, 2028. If a registry accepts one before

that, I was wrong. My reason: a new company form has to get through EU governments and the European Parliament And then every single national registry, tax office, and notary has to be ready to handle it. Each step takes time. Confidence: 75%. And one more. To be precise, this forecast's wording in a report, not the state of the market. The next edition of the EU Startup and Scale-Up Index will

again name late-stage funding As a constraint. Confidence: 85%. If no new edition appears by the end of 2027, that one stays open. Europe has spent 2 decades building strong startup and innovation regions. In many places, it worked. The next question is a different one. When a company needs something that exists elsewhere in Europe, How hard is it to use? The data says

the link between Europe's hubs is close to American levels in research and much weaker in commercial invention. That does not explain the whole scale-up gap, but it points to a cost founders pay every day and one that policy can reduce. Europe has its islands of excellence. The question is, how cheap it becomes to travel between them. There's more to this story. For Entrepreneurs Vault members, I go one level deeper. I run the

network test on the Munich, Vienna, and Zurich corridor area by area as a desk assessment. Members get a city-by-city table of where unicorn alumni founded their next company, what it can and cannot tell you, and a stage-by-stage checklist for founders deciding what to reach for outside their home hub. The full Entrepreneurs Vault analysis is available to members. Join either on YouTube or on Substack. Both links are in the show notes. Next week on Startup

Radio, more interviews and news from Germany, Austria, and Switzerland, and the European scale-up question continues. This is Startuprad.io. That's all, folks. Find more news, streams, events, and interviews at www. Startuprad.io. Remember, sharing is caring.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Jörn "Joe" Menninger Host Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. E 782 — Climate Tech Germany: The €5–50M Hardware Gap

    Nov 19, 202657 minAudio

    Climate tech hardware in Germany rarely fails on technology. It fails between pilot and plant, in a €5 million to €50 million gap that is too big for angels and too risky for most funds. Business angel Birte...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Helsing Clarity: How AI Agents Fuse Battlefield Data | E787

    Nov 19, 202619 minAudio

    Helsing Clarity: How AI Agents Fuse Battlefield Data Helsing's Clarity runs hundreds of specialised AI agents over satellite imagery, drone video, signals and written reports. They share one military data model and one...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. ICEYE, Mistral and Europe’s Deep Tech Scale-Up Test | E785

    Nov 5, 202631 minAudio

    ICEYE already delivers sovereign satellite systems for seven European governments, and the Scaleup Europe Fund co-led its €1 billion financing round. Mistral AI raised €3 billion. Jörn “Joe” Menninger asks whether...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. E 784 — Physical AI in Germany: NVIDIA, RobCo, Agile Robots

    Oct 30, 202626 minAudio

    Germany chose physical AI: NVIDIA plans stakes in Agile Robots, Avelios, Mirelo and Reflex Aerospace; RobCo passes $1B; Zurich's Enact raises a $30M pre-seed. A note on timing: because of my travel schedule, this...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. E 783 — Laser Fusion Spin-Off: How TU Darmstadt Built It

    Oct 22, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    E 783 - Laser Fusion Spin-Off: How TU Darmstadt Built It Laser fusion is the hardest deep tech bet in Germany: huge capital, more research, a plant targeted for the mid-2030s. Focused Energy took it with a $240M Series...

    Credit the people on this episode