Nikola welcomes Oisin Glynn, VP of Solution Consulting, to discuss the fascinating history and evolution of modern telephony. Going back to the inception of telephone systems, from their early manual connections to the adoption of the PSTN and the advent of private branch exchanges (PBX), the conversation touches on the impact of the internet and mobile telephony on traditional phone systems, the rise of VoIP, and how companies like Cisco and Avaya played pivotal roles in transforming business communications. Whether you're curious about the historical milestones or the technical nuances of modern telecommunication, this episode is a perfect start to a series on the wizardry in present day telephonics. Follow PolyAI on LinkedIn Watch this and other episodes of the Deep Learning pod on YouTube
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
OisinSo for example 212 is manhattan's area code because that was where most people most business was And on the rotary phone in the north american plan, that's the shortest dialable number So how easy it was to dial when you had to wait for that thing to go all the way around in a circle was a thing
NikolaHello everyone. And welcome to another episode of deep learning with poly AI today. We have our VP of solution consulting Oisin Glynn on the podcast with me. Hi Oisin.
OisinHi Nikola. Great to be on finally getting finally got an invite.
NikolaAbsolutely. So, you know, we do a lot of talking about like modern AI, it's adoption, it's uses, who benefits from it and how you get it out on the road. But one thing that you taught me a lot about, and that I think we would be, it would be a mistake not to talk about here is just the magical world of telephony, right? Like how it came to be, what it is today where it's going, what's still hard about it. But before we go and told that I thought maybe, and I don't know anyone who knows more about it than you and your team do.
NikolaCan you tell us a bit about how it came to be like the whole thing?
OisinI feel like, first of all, we've got to be careful, right? There's a, there is a little bit of a debate here, depending on who you ask, who even invented the telephone, right? There's a band of folks who feel it's Bell. There's a band of folks who feel it's Marconi. And I don't know I'm not going to pick or choose between them. I did spend a little bit of time living in a place in Massachusetts, very close to where the first ever production phone call was made in Somerville, Massachusetts, which was pretty cool. It's come a really long way from there, right? I mean It began just as a way to communicate, right? We had maybe things like, ability to sell Morse code messages, stuff like that before, right?
OisinRadio networks became a thing. And then the telephone system began and was really adopted mostly to begin with in the U S and the UK. And it grew from there. And I think. You really went a very long way when the public network, PSTN, as it's often still called today, although that turns out to be public switch
Nikolatraffic, right? Yeah. Okay.
Oisinit means is probably the easiest thing for people is Stuff with an actual phone number you can dial from any phone, right? It's public. It's a public network. So in Piri, anyone can dial any number and there are obligations on carriers to allow people to dial numbers. Although perhaps, right, if there's a number that costs you a lot of money to call or something, your carrier might prevent you from doing that as a safety feature to block spam or scammers in these days. But in general, it was, think of those numbers that you can dial. And of course.
OisinEach country has their own dial plan, right? In America, we're very used to dialing 10 digit numbers or maybe putting one on the front. Europe, a lot of folks have an area code that starts with a zero, but then they drop the zero off that if they're making an international call, although not the Italians, because they like to keep the zero for that, which is kind of interesting. So, different kind of ways of doing that. But the public switch network, to me, it's those publicly addressable, publicly dialable numbers.
NikolaSo when did this come to be? Like, when did, like the UK, US, like the countries that adopted it first. When did it have properly functioning?
OisinVery early stuff is in the early 1900s. It was there from then but you weren't dialing numbers then. I think that's an important part. You used local, right? Yeah, so you would pick up a phone and an operator would get on the end and I don't know, it's kind of weird to say. So my aunt lived in the place in Ireland that was the last place to ever get a mechanical or an automated exchange. So I can remember, and I better not say her phone number out loud, but I would say the name of the town, 3 5. And so I talked to this operator and say, I need name of town 3 5.
OisinAnd it was the 35th phone, in that area. If you think about that very famous, that thing of the plug board, right, that person would physically connect you through then to that line, and you'd be speaking to that person. And so, we went from a mode where an operator, a human connected to callers together in a very physical way. To dialing numbers and that changed over time how that even happened, right? There's rotary to hitting a button now instead of that and but that changed over time and so how the connection was made Changed but those were very physical connections like much like that plug board's a great way to think about it
NikolaWhy did it have to be done manually?
OisinI think the answer probably is like machines weren't good enough at that at that point in time at scale Like you had to interpret I think and this maybe starts to go towards some of what we're doing, right? You Understanding the input from the human at the first end, like I want to call Nicola do I have an easily understood way for a machine to understand that instruction and then to put that call through and make the connection? So I think the mechanics of making the connections probably wasn't difficult, right? There were relays and there were other things like that, but maybe actually this comes down to the understanding of humans and the input of that communication and that action to be taken by a machine was hard.
NikolaI think of it as just like a generalization and Making the entirety of the post system instantaneous. Cause like that whole like, 35th number, 35th house. And city this, that's like your postcodes and stuff, right? It is very similar.
OisinYeah. No, it is super similar. And look, I think it was about instantaneous communication. That was, I think, right where, Telex and other things like that were coming along that were less voice related, but the ability to talk to somebody very far away, I think was revolutionary. I think even for, as people began to move around the world and do stuff like that, versus a letter once a month, you could now speak to somebody once a week or in business, you could speak far more often.
NikolaYeah. And you think of like yellow pages and stuff. And that was like the first search over the end point where you could communicate to someone.
OisinYeah. Okay.
NikolaOkay. Then it goes national, right? And every country starts building these behemoth, like national companies that are there to, at the end of the day, make money and do the CapEx investment of creating
Oisinnot originally make money. I think nearly all of them. Maybe the U. S. is the exception here, but you think about British Telecom in the U. K., Telecom Eireann in Ireland, a lot of them tended to be, and probably in a lot of countries it feels like, the Postal Service ran that thing, right? So it tended to be almost an extension of the Postal Service in a lot of countries, and probably government run or semi state run it feels like in a lot of them.
NikolaOkay. Okay. And then like it goes national. And then like we started getting like what international things and stuff and the, what it feels like the infrastructure just becomes what it is for a while, right?
OisinYeah. It gets really large. I think there's certainly moments in time when, depending on your definition of machine, the public switch telephone network is the world's biggest machine and it's referred to as such. And then probably the next big thing, and we get into another one of the acronyms here, It's PBX, Private Branch Exchange. So what this is now, this is not the public network, right? This is the private network. So within the company, right, I want to call down to the shipping dock.
OisinI want to call to somebody in accounts. And I don't need a publicly addressable number for that. Maybe that person wouldn't want that to happen at all. And I want to be able to do that maybe without, paying for that phone call. And so initially then you start getting these private branch exchanges, which is. Machinery that you're going to position within your organization that allows you to communicate internally and these again developed in a lot of cases under very strict control at the time even a phone for a house. A lot of times the local carrier would have a certification for that.
OisinYou might only be able to buy it from them. You might even have to rent it from them. And in some countries, as the PBX became a thing, the private branch exchange. Okay. You literally might have to buy that from whoever your phone company was and in a lot of countries That was a monopoly or a very, small group of companies And so there was huge tight control placed here and I would say Looking back feels like a lot of that control was done under the auspices that the network must be Sanitized and it was hard to operate. I'm not sure. A lot of it wasn't financially driven at the time.
OisinRight. There was a lot of money
Nikolaon the whole thing.
OisinYeah. So that began then, right. You could dial within a company and now you had a numbering plan within that organization. And for most people at that time, right, this is where extension one, two, three, four, or whatever that looked like. And maybe even this is the beginning of dialing zero. I'm not sure what the origin of zero was. But essentially at that point you were in this mode where you could now dial within a company but it required pretty significant equipment, it required a lot of maintenance, and it was, A rigid piece of technology.
OisinLike fun fact, I think how easy it was to dial things was a thing back then, right? So you had still the rotary phone So for example 212 is manhattan's area code because that was where most people most business was And on the rotary phone in the north american plan, that's the shortest dialable number So how easy it was to dial when you had to wait for that thing to go all the way around in a circle was a thing
NikolaYeah, I think it's really interesting, right? I mean I Like did quite a few of the computer networking courses at university, all the way to like grad level once. And it always really started with like the postal system and the analogies with that, like what is in that box, behind IP addresses and stuff, and it only really occurred to me as we got deep into this, that the technical issues of like, people with like the same phone number and stuff and like, calling something or like not being able to call cause someone else is calling are things that come from the limitations of being given that like sole identifier against which.
OisinYeah. And we didn't have this in Europe as much, but in the U S there was a big thing for a while called party lines. So where they hadn't run directs, dedicated connections to everyone's house. And so if you lived in a neighborhood, you might be paired up with like three or four houses, and when you picked up the phone, it wasn't just that you could hear someone in your house talking, you might hear anyone in those four or five houses talking, and you'd be like, hey, I have an important call coming, get off the phone. And so, There was this really
Nikolaearly audio conferencing solutions. If you think
Oisinof it, probably not ideal conversing, right. People are listening into their phone calls, shouting at people's kids to get off the phone. But yeah, so I think the dedicated nature then came later. And I think you got to the point where both internally and externally you had this, but I think the addressing thing. It was solved really by making and breaking these connections that lay there idle, right? If I wasn't talking on my phone, that piece of copper was sitting there doing no useful work. And I think that was probably, when you think about this circuit switched aspect, where I'm making and breaking connections between two pieces of wire that are sitting there, That was probably the flaw in that, in that you had all this infrastructure that really wasn't getting used for anything else that just sat there.
OisinAnd I guess at some point, right, I don't know where we are in our timeline and we're probably not going exactly chronologically. Things like ADSL, where you could have what we would now consider to be not a great home internet connection work. Over that same piece of wire that did start to take a second use out of that kind of dedicated piece of copper, where now you could have a phone call or maybe some Internet.
NikolaWell, I mean, maybe just to kind of guide the discussion a bit, right? Because I think, like, for landlines, as they were established and rolled out properly and scale. It was a pretty well functioning system. It felt like it had hit, like, steady state, right? And then I feel like two things happened, right? One is the onset of the internet, right? And, like, dial up connections and I think to a lot of people listening who are, either younger than me or grew up in more developed parts of the world and hence did not have the joy of dial up for as long as, say, Serbia did.
NikolaThey might've missed that on the delightful sound that look motive makes when like connecting. But I think what's really interesting is like one, one part is that like the almost like latching on of internet onto telephony as like just this network that's already distributed and can be latched on to transmit data of kinds that is not just like the human voice. The second piece is like the mobile telephony, right? And then the need to have these things going around and like rolling out. That network because really that's a predecessor to the internet we use on our phones now.
Oisinyeah, I think the there were certainly two big things that happened there. I think the obviously the internet went and took its own path and starts to become part of the future of telephony at some point and obviously The mobile networks become a huge thing and I think it was interesting right that the mobile networks took on if you know If we go back to the postal analogy They took on and they leveraged that same addressing system. Now, I think there was a huge benefit in that it meant then that you didn't create two separate networks You could call from a landline or from a business phone to a mobile phone and vice versa So I think from an addressing perspective if you wanted to create one, you know Take advantage of that large network effect when at the beginning very few people had cell phones or mobile phones I think that was like a very useful concept, but I think it's interesting that There's been a couple of different points, and that's certainly one of them in my mind, where the phone number retained its kind of supremacy as that addressing format.
NikolaNo, absolutely. So I think like for us, we spend a lot of time talking to people about like voice and voice versus text and like communication of enterprises with their consumers. But the other thing is just like the stickiness of like the default way of communicating. Right. And I think that the phone, like the landline, then really used its. Initially overwhelming and currently probably about 20 percent of the calls we take at least are those from landlines. And I didn't even run the numbers for a few years. It might be lower now, but it feels like mobile telephony, which maybe could have been built for like a mobile first way ended up just like really living and breathing and adopting a lot of the problems with Right.
Nikolabut like the telephony system at large, and then over time, like it flips over to mobile, but where does VoIP start coming in? Why does it start? The idea that telephony now runs over the Internet, right? Because our Internet infrastructure is so good that we no longer need to rely on, you know, cables put in, you know, 100 years ago by AT& T or British Telecom or Telstra, these like large national companies, but instead, like, We all pay a lot of money, much more money. Many don't have landlines now, but have internet, right?
NikolaSo that's almost like your default connectivity as a household, as a mobile subscriber, where then hopefully that is your link and the piece of infra that more money is spent on maintaining so that it can become what your default voice channel.
OisinYeah. I think part of it was certainly driven by a desire to have Single multi use infrastructure, right? Whether that be cabling, switching, all that other stuff. So I think in my mind, at least that was a significant driver for that. I think there was also maybe an interesting technical challenge here, right? Like you had previously a dedicated piece of wire, stuff could go up and down it. It was very, very resilient, very redundant. And then when you moved into VOIP.
OisinAnd I would say one thing, like I think VOIP means a lot of things to a lot of people. Like I think about it really, really at the basic level of this is a voice call that's moving over an IP network. It could be the internet. It could also be the network within your home or within a business. So I think like it can be a little bit confusing. And I think in the evolution here, you probably saw more of it being used either at the carrier level in their kind of networks, moving things around intra carrier or within themselves.
OisinAnd within businesses, you had A-V-V-O-I-P-P-B-X, but the next connection when you actually went out to the PSDN wasn't anymore. So I think it, it arrived at the edges and true end-to-end, VOIP maybe doesn't exist everywhere today, although a lot of teams, even when you think you're not using. Are really wiping the central offices today. Interesting.
NikolaInteresting. So, one thing that I always thought of just moving from one country to the other and stuff is like the avoidance of roaming costs and stuff like that circumventing that piece So I think that's where internet really disrupted a big money making machine for a lot of these companies, although Weirdly, many, many, I mean, I've got like an American, a British and Serbian number in this thing now, courtesy of eSIMs. It's very, very smooth. Although you can't have more than two active at once, but like you still back off to that, like mobile piece quite often, because lo and behold, it tends to work a lot better in many parts of the U S or the UK then 3G all the way to 5G, right.
NikolaBut was that like a main driver of adoption as well, or was it something that almost telcos would not want to promote
Oisinmean, I think, when you talk about VoIP being promoted.
NikolaWell, it's just the general adoption of like things running over the internet, right? Because we will talk about it. I think maybe we can probably leave it for the second one. Around how the contact center moves over to VoIP. But like, when does this start happening? When do like big pieces of this, Public or private inside companies infrastructure move away from just like putting on the phone to people kind of what are the companies that Bring in the first version of this.
OisinYeah, I mean look, I think there's a whole plethora So I think within companies in the kind of corporate environment you folks like Avaya, Cisco, Mitel, I would say most or nearly all of those business phone system providers are creating systems that have these capabilities within the business. And I think they probably start to also take advantage where, oh, hold on, it might not be cheap, it might not be easy. But networking multiple locations together using technology like this starts to become easier, and you're probably still before any type of work from home, right?
OisinThat's later on in the general direction of this traffic, but I think you're definitely getting to this point. It isn't a straight line path, like early adopters, like folks doing this in the, late 90s, maybe early 2000s, into like the 2000s. First of all, There isn't one way of doing this. There's H323, there's SIP, there's various protocols. Folks like Cisco have another protocol they use for when they're using their equipment. So it's not all as interoperable as maybe the academics would have loved as they created standards.
OisinAnd you start finding that a lot of people who are deploying these networks, even though part of the goal or the thought here is to have this multi use piece of wire, they suddenly, well, we're going to have a voice network and a data network. And they start building separate networks, literally like there's two wires coming to each desk now, very similar looking wires, perhaps plugged into the same piece of equipment, but with two logical ports. That are differently serviced and kept apart. And some of that is because Look, I've got,
Nikolalike, an Ethernet and a phone port here and here. Like, in the
Oisinhouse. And so there's an element there where people are not There's an element of, I think, a little bit of fear. There's an element of quality, right? These packet switch networks Because now, literally, and I think that's what we're saying. So, in a VoIP call And in almost all of this stuff today, essentially every 20 milliseconds, a little piece of audio is getting shot in each direction. So 50 times per second in both directions, these things are firing up and down. And they're going over a protocol where. Some of them might get lost. You're not checking that every one got there, because if you've got to wait, see if it got there, then get a message back to say it got there, you're essentially tripling the amount of time for transmission.
OisinSo it's better to just fire
Nikolathem. Like when we use like say a non void. Like PSTN thing, we've created a physical connection, semi physical cause it might be running over, a mobile signal to you. Right. But like, which again, we'll have the same kind of like packets
Oisinin
Nikolaand out. So like, it is really like, to anyone who's not studied networking of any kind, like the multiple layers of abstraction are just like one of the most fascinating things in computer science. But with regular telephony, we do have a connection, especially like if it's cable, right? It is synchronous.
OisinIf you can really, I think this is the hard part. I think it's really hard to find something that if you like, even if you called your next door neighbor and you feel like you're having a PSTN call today, are you sure there isn't an IP somewhere in the middle of that?
NikolaI mean, I know the answer.
OisinAnd I asked that question kind of like, I think my view at this point is. I think there's IP almost in every call, even if you're like, I'm, don't trust IP. It's not reliable enough. I need my call quality and you're, but I think at some point somewhere along the journey, I think there's a high, high probability. I think 99 percent there's IP somewhere in the middle of your call, unless you're literally, I don't know, some guy with two bean cans and a string there. Who's trying to really, really book the trend.
NikolaSo like, where's like Skype and all of this, that's an early form of work, right? One over the internet.
OisinYeah. And again, I think it's right, that's, you start getting into a mode there, right? Where one big thing, right? You weren't necessarily using phone numbers, you could call someone based on an email address, right? You had these things, whether it's Skype or if you didn't think of the US early on, like a OL instant messenger. You had these communication protocols that were, they were organized in those cases by a company. But there was an addressing scheme that really left phone numbers behind, right? It was doing something else. And it is a bizarre thing that there is no requirement in VoIP for phone numbers.
OisinSo just like an email address works, and I can remember being at a training class in like, It's like very early 2000s and the person giving the class was like, yeah, phone numbers will be gone in 10 years. That did not age. And so I think there is nothing preventing the world from having phone communication or voice calling be just like email. You could use like Nicola app and you could dial that. And as long as the interworking was there, just like with MX records for email, it would just work if everyone did it.
OisinAnd I guess. Maybe there's some, big telecom story somewhere in the back of that, right? Because, in theory, there was nothing stopping us from going that road. And if you look at the difference between the postal service and email, and the fact that you're not paying really for every email you're sending, right? Versus what's happened with phone, there was, it didn't follow the path that was there. And it was laid out in the very same way with DNS and all those supporting open internet standards.
NikolaYeah, I feel like there's like two threads we're gonna have to unpack in future episodes. One is just around like, the different suppliers and different webs of it, right? Whether it's like, Telecom networks all the way to like WhatsApp and the others that are keeping inside their ecosystem, whether it's by a phone number or not. And then the second piece is just like the many flavors of VoIP and how it came to be. SIP. I really, just want to have a whole episode where we talk about SIP and asterisk and everything around it. Cause that to me was like truly. Chris, when we started, but I think we're out of time for today.
NikolaSo thank you very much. Machine. Thanks for the great intro and we'll we'll keep talking telephony in the next one.
OisinAwesome. Thanks to be honest. It's been a lot of fun.
Three years ago, Simplyhealth's PolyAI deployment was only resolving simple FAQs over the phone. Today, they run voice, in-app, email, chat, and WhatsApp conversations on the platform. Nikola Mrkšić talks with Paul...
An agent that gets better every day compounds into a very different agent within months. That's the idea behind Wren, PolyAI's new release: an agent whose job is to make your other agents better. Some of what it finds...
Companies are pouring money into AI, but not everyone is getting the returns. Ian Jacobs, VP and Lead Analyst at Opus Research, thinks he knows why. In this episode, your host Nikola Mrkšić sits down with Ian to work...
When PolyAI built its Builder MCP, one client helped shape it: Vixxo Facility Solutions, one of the largest facilities providers in the US. In this episode, guest host Damian Sasso talks with Vixxo's CTO Derek Neighbors...
PolyAI just launched Dialog-RSN-1, its first audio-native model, and your host Nikola Mrkšić sat down with its builder, Matt Henderson, to unpack why it’s a game-changer for building voice agents. Most voice AI either...