Damien and Nikola chat about the controversial rise of anti-AI sentiment among brands, especially in the creator industry. They explore recent anti-AI pledges by notable brands like Procreate and Dove, scrutinizing whether these are sincere stances or marketing tactics, deliberating the balance between human artistry and technological advancement. All this, plus Olympic men's basketball, in this episode of Deep Learning with PolyAI. Follow PolyAI on LinkedIn Watch this and other episodes of the Deep Learning pod on YouTube
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Nikolahow do people. React to this technology. We want to take away jobs. It's like the great menace coming in to, make people unemployed and give companies back efficiency. And the truth is, I don't think we have a single client that bought this for the purpose of firing people and doing cost cutting. people do it to improve service and maybe to restore service to good levels after they've lost a number of employees to attrition what technology can give you versus, piling more humans.
DamienHello everybody. And welcome back to deep learning with Polly AI. The only podcast that pits the Serbian against the American and the post Olympic. Maybe spat with how close the men's basketball team came to getting a massive upset. Any comment on that?
NikolaI was not given advance warning.
DamienI couldn't tell you about this. Otherwise I knew you wouldn't talk to me today.
NikolaYeah, no, that was the game. That was the game.
DamienIt was a game. It was pretty fantastic a good showing by both teams, but I'm glad ultimately at the final outcome of the men's basketball finals, but we'll skip past that. I
Nikolathink, I think that was really the final, right? I think that, the, both the way that America ran over France and what Serbia did to Germany and the other thing was like a quick dispatch. I agree. I agree.
DamienI would think that was definitely a more exciting game than the gold medal game. But Absolutely. I
Nikolathink that I was watching it and you always hope I don't think we're in like peak peak form, but we're pretty close. And it was like the real can European tactics and FIBA rules versus The overwhelming physical and individual superiority of all but one. On our end. Could it prevail? And it almost. One slit, one extra push. But it was, I've not gone that close to a heart attack watching basketball. Probably since 2002 and that Indianapolis world championship where well, you were solving one, but that was also where America did not send the top team.
NikolaSo this was something.
DamienIt was pretty electric. All right. Well, hopefully you're healing well from that. And hopefully the heart's back to a normal pace.
NikolaI think that they've unified the nation behind, just the effort they've put in. They had the welcome in Belgrade. Pretty much felt like they had won the gold medal. And I think for the hearts and minds of the nation, they definitely did.
DamienYeah. Yeah, it was, it was a fantastic games and that was definitely a highlight that in the Turkish sharpshooter but that's for another episode. So, I thought today there's been a little bit of a rising sentiment and we know that, not every, Nothing satisfies everybody. And Forbes recently reported on a little bit of a proliferation of anti AI pledges. Mm-Hmm. coming from brands. And this isn't just tech and creative upstarts. I think it was really inspired, or at least a high profile case comes from the CEO of procreate which is a a creationist platform.
DamienAnd they said, we're not going to ever incorporate generative tools into our platform because, and this is a paraphrase art is created, not generated, and we've seen some little whispers of this in other in other, mostly consumer facing brands, dove made a statement that they will only use real human models in all their advertising, nothing generated. And we of course have seen some other apps, some other creationists apps like Kara as a creative platform that has said that they will not use generative models as well.
DamienAnd It, I'm curious obviously there's some marketing juice behind this, right? Kind of a damn the man approach. Yeah, this is tech, but we want to keep it. We want to keep it human. We want to keep everything in contact, but I feel like it might be a little, there might be something else going on behind it. So I want to get your initial impressions on this sort of recent spate of anti AI pledges and really sift through the smoke and see, is there anything there What's your opinion on this?
NikolaListen, I think that, I have to go back to your Olympics and the memes with the sharpshooter versus, was it the Korean? Oh, with
Damienthe, with the entire kit and everything. Yeah.
NikolaYeah. What did the Turk win?
DamienHe won silver.
NikolaSilver. Yeah. I think there was a Serbian person who won like gold and that one without as much equipment as a Korean person who had more equipment than like a cyborg. So I think that was that was interesting, but He was popular because he looked like a regular Joe that just went and like shot. I guess he's like the epitome of the artisan that these guys will have to cater to. The truth is you're going to create a better thing if you use technology. We could look at it as different disciplines. And say, well, Hey, like here's what you can create without AI helping you.
NikolaAnd then here's the best thing that you can create while using AI. It's not the same thing. And I think that, whether we're looking at it from the lens of how to create the best possible thing versus how to, What do you can create on your own? I think those are different disciplines. I can't help, but feel that they're fighting inevitability. I think a lot of work in every discipline is filled with a lot of menial labor where you do something for a while that, may not be the crux of creating a creative endeavor.
NikolaMaybe you're, filling out part of the painting where, you're just doing groundwork. I don't know. I don't know much about that. But It feels like a cheap shot towards, and I have no doubt that they actually fully believe everything they said in that statement around, the creative process, but,
Damienbut that's like now, right? It's it, the way it's carried forward, it's almost prescriptive. And it seems as though there's something else that's behind it. And I'm wondering if this is something that's based on sort of internal mandate where they're facing an issue of people using too much generative AI internal to either their. Personal responsibilities, a little hesitation for other, means to incorporate it into standard business processes. So they're going to take that momentum and make it a consumer facing marketing point. It just, it feels a little inauthentic to have such a hard line stance.
NikolaI'm sure that there were. People doing, calligraphic stuff and in monasteries, copying the Bible came out and they were like, well, we don't believe in that. We think that the word of God should be copied by hand and bubble. And like at the end they lost decisively. And I think that if they are really to take that stance fully all the way through that, new forms of art and God knows what medium will be created when you use technology coupled with human creativity. So no, I think that like it might be that their product roadmap is lagging and they haven't incorporated it.
NikolaSo they might as well play this move, right? Interesting. I think in this podcast, we specialize in creating every cynical and what we can find. So,
DamienIt's essential. We are the hearts and minds of the people out there. We, we want to pick it apart we should rename ourselves to devil's advocacy with poly AI. I think that's the, way to go. But it also, feels a little less hefty when you see that the brands that are making these sort of announcements aren't necessarily market leaders. One could argue that Dove, I think has a foothold in the hygiene and soap space, but a lot of the other folks, is this just a way for them to feel relevant?
NikolaI think it's also about, I've spent time with many clients and prospects over the past few weeks. And there were a number of people who said, Hey, like that AI and your name is not helping me, endear you to the greater company, right? Oh, really? I'd often be asked by investors, by clients, et cetera, like how do people. React to this technology. We want to take away jobs. It's like the great menace coming in to, make people unemployed and give companies back efficiency. And the truth is, I don't think we have a single client that bought this for the purpose of firing people and doing cost cutting.
Nikolapeople do it to improve service and maybe to restore service to good levels after they've lost a number of employees to attrition or, basically their hand was forced. And some do it to really just get the supercharged customer service estate where you pick up immediately anytime, night and day. What technology can give you versus, versus, piling more humans. Now you look at this whole thing and it's well, we have customers now saying this AI in your name, people look at it and they're like, why are you doing this?
NikolaCause I think the hype has reached a level where people have now imagined that there's just giants. Piece of mass, which is going to hit the world and everything's going to change,
Damienright?
NikolaIt's something happening not in the way that you know, some would fear but it's a
Damienchip away approach this isn't a meteor tiered Yeah, I think it's acid
Nikolarain Yeah but I think that it's really more to do with those companies and their internal politics and everything where Whoever brings up the topic looks like someone who wants to bring that Meteor and have it land and exterminate the dinosaurs. And like the truth is it's going to take some time everywhere. And I think it is a cheap shot here. And it's also probably just a lack of depth because I think if they'd looked at what the software can do for them. It would just make the product better, right? Maybe it'll give you a good starting point.
NikolaAn interesting one. You still need the human touch, even if you're going to fully generate images and things,
Damienright.
NikolaWe'll need to prompt it. And yeah, maybe you'll get a faster end. I'm sure that they perceive this, that industry perceives this as a threat to the viability of all their jobs. And they are right. There will be fewer of these jobs. If everyone gets 10 times more productive. And there is a general trend where I think technology to existing industries has always increased inequality, right? The best people got even better. The best people have resources to invest in new tools and technology, and they get further ahead of the pack and they become more productive.
NikolaSo if that industry is not now producing, if there isn't a need for that industry to produce a hundred times as much of whatever they're producing, That means that there will be fewer jobs around it, the whole value stack around it, the supply chain and all the other industries that will emerge on the back of those technologies, invariably through human history, create other jobs and create more employment, right? Like the industrial revolution did not leave us all unemployed. In fact, we still have that magical 3 percent unemployment and by and large countries around the world seem to be able to hit it for the most part.
DamienAnd obviously the sentiment is coming from largely like creative and artistic sectors of the industry, because there isn't going to be a player in an industry that relies on productivity and efficiency production or any sort of like. Generative business that isn't going to appreciate this as a tool. So they're not going to take that hard line stance. It feels easy when you are in the art and creation of space. So music, physical artists, visual artists, et cetera, authors, obviously it's really easy to come out as a publisher and say, look we're rejecting the generative AI editing tools.
DamienEverything's going to be edited by a human being because it feels like that's something that is. It's okay to not have any sort of AI based assistance in that, to your point, the, this is the new industrial revolution. Like you can't ignore the results of what this is delivering to other industries and sectors.
NikolaYeah. Look, if you're working in agriculture and you fail to adopt mechanization, maybe there's an angle for you saying, Hey, I have the best. Organic tomato in Europe, and it's all handpicked and someone's willing to pay premium.
DamienYeah. But it's eight times the cost. Yeah, exactly.
NikolaYeah. And it's maybe it's better. Maybe it's not, maybe it's worse because you've not done something else that you could have done with mechanization. You're definitely going to have a lower top line. Maybe if you're a marketing genius and you can find the right angle for it and there is organic appetite for it, some will pay you more, but hard press between let's say the same outcome and have the price. For those services. Well, it's inevitable that buyers will opt for the cheaper thing. And invariably with AI, I think that it will raise the quality.
NikolaOf work for a lot of people, if your things look like kids drawings in comparison to someone else's who, with, a few quick clicks manages to get something way better out there, then, you're deliberately choosing to perform in a specific discipline that may or may not have the same demand. And at that point, you're just, Well, hurting yourself.
DamienYeah. Speaking of disciplines that are in demand it's such a fluctuating type of space as well. When you look at something like let's say physical art people are out there still buying, there's going to be a market for an elephant who sits here and swashes a brush against a canvas. And there's nothing that's going to replace that. That being said, it doesn't, it's not a finite, marketplace where You can't have these new players who are experimenting with new approaches and new tools to tackle the medium, and they can establish their own following and, artists objective, everybody has their own taste. Maybe they're missing out by not exploring how generative can add to their palate as opposed to overtake it.
NikolaAbsolutely. And look, I think we've had many industries that had been threatened, nearly existentially. By an innovation in technology, right? The Swiss watchmaking industry almost got eradicated by the Japanese. Saito Casio and
Damienwe talk about watches a lot on this podcast. I'm realizing it.
NikolaWell, it's interesting, right? Because a quartz crisis when these guys are making like movements that are battery powered, it took a serious rebrand by the greats of the Swiss watchmaking industry to an even stronger deliberate push into the luxury market. And now that market's greater than ever and growing and very healthy, right? The Japanese have their own like flavors of these products. And it's interesting, right? Create that competition, created something new. But I would say that both got better out of it. And you can't ignore it. You can't just pretend that it didn't happen.
NikolaYou should have a very active strategy through going up market and creating something that people have a need for and that they really appreciate for. And you have to brand it the right way. And if you can't do that and you just have an inferior product at higher costs and well, see you later.
DamienYeah. And I think you touched on this earlier, but obviously with the watch example it crafted or maybe galvanized two separate paths, right? Like the old school mechanical type watches are going to be seen as these handcrafted masterpieces that are worth the time and energy because of the separation of it from, digital power and a digital motherboard. What is the mid ground that you see that exists? Right now within the industries that are making the most anti AI noise, you touched a little bit on using it as an assistive tool along the process.
DamienWhat does that look like for your modern artists? And go ahead and pick your medium or discipline, but what does that mid ground look like?
NikolaI don't really know. I don't know enough about the, the process of creating like the painting or anything like that to,
Damienwell, you're a published author, let's not forget that when you were a young child, you were selling sci fi stories actually for writing, for writing. I
Nikolareally genuinely don't know how you would go about that. That's one that may be under even like the mental level narrative, the plot twist. I dare say that no one really cares about the exact language or stylistic, the style of the prose that, I don't know, J. K. Rowling had when she wrote Harry Potter. I think it was the world she created.
DamienYeah, it
Nikolawas the world, right? I remember reading Tolkien for the first time in English when my English wasn't what it is today. And that was like an endeavor, right? That was really difficult for a non native speaker to read. Sure. If anything, like I love that role. That subsequently read the Silmarillion probably 10 times. Honestly, like it's the world that had the appeal. Silmarillion reads like a set of facts and it was more interesting to me. So I think the, the appeal of that is like how ambitious and great the story can be.
NikolaAnd I think, with LLMs and stuff, you can definitely use them to power and create a lot of the text, but it's the goal of hyper production of 50 novels, people barely read anymore, so, at this point, no, but at this point, it's really all about condensing it to be like very impactful. Sure. People will watch the film, but man, if you can turn that into a good TikTok or YouTube short that motivates people to go and take a look, like a good ad for it, like I'd argue that that becomes more and more important. So like to do that, you need tools and stuff.
NikolaWhat do you use to develop, it's like a program, right? Like great software is still being written by people and they're still being engineered by people who have a lot of artisanal skill and understanding at great scale, how, to structure a service that provides something for millions of people efficiently. The fact that they're not writing out every script manually and that they're using co pilot, it doesn't really matter.
DamienYeah.
NikolaAnd we're writing more and more software and more complicated software. So I think for art, can we create just. Substantially more complicated things. Can we go and paint, I don't know, the whole Berlin Wall with something that's a consistent, I don't know, ontology of the Berlin Wall. Like something like that. That could probably be done by one person now, rather than, and I think you can be more ambitious in that. The projects that you're going to take on, if you do,
Damienmaybe it's also just the perception that the artist views, the time, energy, and resources that goes into it as part of the final product. So the longer it takes, the more, they spend, it's the oyster effect, right? Why do people like oysters arguably? Or I would say objectively there, it's a gross food. When you think about it, it's like, why would anybody actually eat this
Nikolaliving where you live? Living where you live. You're allowed to say that.
DamienOh, I love oysters. I eat them all the time, but I'm just saying you look at this thing. There's nothing appetizing about it whatsoever across species. It's just a gross thing, but there's something about shucking your own oyster that makes it a little bit more delicious. So the effort that goes into it probably adds to the final output. So you cut a lot of those corners per se in the time and energy it takes to create something, and all of a sudden it diminishes its value. Perceptively let's take a look. Artists aside, I think that they can make a valid argument about this. Discover recently ran a TV ad starring the inimitable Jennifer Coolidge AKA Stifler's mom, AKA and every Christopher guest film fantastic.
DamienActress and. She playing her, archetypical kind of a little bit of a ditzy self is calling into discover contact center. And she asked the agent if they're a real person and they say, no, I'm not a robot. And she says, prove it. And they say, are you a robot? And she says, I don't know. And it's hilarious. Everyone laughs, eat some more popcorn discover. This is not an artistic business. This is a financial institution. It's a credit institution. Why would they. Come out and make this statement. This is one of those businesses that obviously has nothing but greatness to gain from refining process and increasing operational efficiency.
DamienYet they're over here, crapping on, on, on technology within the context,
Nikolathey have deployed a great deal of automation. If you call 1 800 DISCOVER, I think that may be a recently acquired IP soft that implemented. That system, well, decent, decent sounding one, long latency. I don't know why they chose to talk about it. I think it's. More than anything, I think she's really cool. That's a good ad.
DamienWriting that white Lotus of fame, huh? I think so.
NikolaFor sure. I don't know. What do you think? I can't really place it. Yeah.
DamienI just think it's a pure marketing play. I actually went back and watched the ad a few times and realized that they said you can always talk to a real person as opposed to you will always talk to a real person. So I think that they're giving themselves a little bit of an out by saying, Hey, nothing, nothing more than just quick escalation that's facilitated by an automated system, but they're making it feel okay. I
Nikolamean, all of these companies, that are rough comparables are chasing Amex and their customer experience. And I think overinvested quite deliberately and their marketing position allows them to do that. So. Yeah, I don't know. I think it's maybe playing on the fact that we're not like a number of other providers that may be different from that.
DamienYeah. It's some sort of differentiator.
NikolaWho they're going after. And I see them as like that, like MX minus one level rather than going further down the market, right?
DamienMaybe. And, and is that what it is is just trying to gain, clout and sort of notoriety. And so they have to have some differentiator when you're talking about a commoditized market, like credit are they are to your point? Are they going after Amex as support model?
NikolaWell, I think they're going, I think they're trying to show that their model is as cool and as good, and that you can always speak to a human. If their assistant was as good. They might be able to claim that with some credibility. If they want that to be the case, they should get in touch, but yeah. Call me, call me, call me.
DamienYeah, that's good. There's a part of me also that just wonders, did they just want a marketing campaign that would fit with their celebrity endorser? And that it's pretty picture perfect. When you see Jennifer Coolidge's confusion as to how to prove she's not a robot. I thought, I think it was pretty solid.
NikolaYeah.
DamienAll right. Cool. Anything else around this space that you think, just final thoughts with regards to this motion, is it a flash in the pan? Is it going to be a thing that's just a part of every technology's hype cycle, the haters come out in full force and maybe they get a little like corporate sponsorship behind it, but eventually it'll die out and people realize it was just a lot of smoke and fire.
NikolaGo back to our like basketball analogies, right? Like it's the first quarter, people show a few good AI demos, like that team AI looks powerful. Then they start stumbling, they take a few three pointers, they lose the lead. And then the others, like mockingbirds descend and try to capitalize on the fact that these guys seem to be stumbling. But the other side has, like a bunch of players that's far stronger and improving by the minute, right? They will do better cause they have superior, not technology, but they have like resources.
NikolaThey have the equivalent of much more resource to put up against the challenge. So you can temporarily. Make fun of the approach. You can laugh at its current inadequacies and point out, try to really appease to the conservative, like Luddite part where it's I know that won't work. What I do has intrinsic value and it does. Sure. They did. AI to do part of it. But I think for, especially in art, I think.
NikolaThe true greats embrace this technology, right? They don't stand for the status quo. None of the great artists of history were like hyper conservative in their approach to it. Maybe that's wrong, but I think that many of the great innovators and people who redefined, artistic directions and stuff for people who were unafraid to break with the orthodoxy, and I think you're going to see. People doing the same here. And I understand the sadness that people feel at the fact that someone who might have trained for years creates a similar thing to what I can with a promise, right?
NikolaThis concerning, this concerning to me, and I'm not even an artist. I can't paint a cow, let alone like something more complicated, right?
DamienYou can't paint a cow. It's just getting them to stand still. That's tricky. Man, but that's a dad joke. Sorry. I'm,
NikolaI'm really bad, yeah, that's uncomfortable. But, I'm also uncomfortable with the fact that, GPT four can do 80 percent of all the work that my PhD did with a single prompt, that's arguably a lot more technical and it was a lot more differentiated back when I was doing it. So you look at that and you're like, well, You have two choices. One is to have an existential crisis and say that generative is evil and that I'm going to use this older form of deep learning, right? Or the other
Damienis to tip your king and just move on. We'll
Nikolajust, yeah, get on the bandwagon and hopefully see how we can continue, right? Because you've been given a far more powerful tool. Now, I'm an AI researcher, right? So to me, being given that is actually for this stuff. Yeah. I understand that it's uncomfortable. It's very, very uncomfortable. And I think that the job for those guys becomes, how can you be as unique and differentiated and special while using this wasn't easy for them to differentiate even before generative AI could create like amazing, that's very
Damientrue.
NikolaA lot of the stuff that generates for now is just like terrible. Like random limbs flaring up in different places.
DamienOh, the fails are better than the good stuff. Actually. It's more fun to watch.
NikolaWell, yeah. So I don't think that that whole thing is there. I think you could very easily look like one of those, like Instagram or Facebook edits where, someone's hip just magically, like cuts off one's head in the background or something. So, I think that it's a double edged sword. If you're at the peak of your craft, like you wouldn't easily use it. But if you can use it for some kind of like special effect in the background if you can like Create a new style by doing that. Yeah. Like you should, because there's a lot of glory to be had.
DamienIt's finding the medium in the medium. I like that. That's good. All right. Cool. Appreciate it, man. This is always, as always just a lot of fun to talk with you and get your perspectives on these things. I guess we'll see what the market holds, but I agree. I think there's going to be a lot, this is just a lot of a lot of squeaky wheels and there's plenty of grease to go around. So, great talking to you. Can't wait to chat again in the future. And uh, thanks everyone for listening. We'll see you next week. See you all later.
Three years ago, Simplyhealth's PolyAI deployment was only resolving simple FAQs over the phone. Today, they run voice, in-app, email, chat, and WhatsApp conversations on the platform. Nikola Mrkšić talks with Paul...
An agent that gets better every day compounds into a very different agent within months. That's the idea behind Wren, PolyAI's new release: an agent whose job is to make your other agents better. Some of what it finds...
Companies are pouring money into AI, but not everyone is getting the returns. Ian Jacobs, VP and Lead Analyst at Opus Research, thinks he knows why. In this episode, your host Nikola Mrkšić sits down with Ian to work...
When PolyAI built its Builder MCP, one client helped shape it: Vixxo Facility Solutions, one of the largest facilities providers in the US. In this episode, guest host Damian Sasso talks with Vixxo's CTO Derek Neighbors...
PolyAI just launched Dialog-RSN-1, its first audio-native model, and your host Nikola Mrkšić sat down with its builder, Matt Henderson, to unpack why it’s a game-changer for building voice agents. Most voice AI either...