068: DOGE bites federal phone lines. Are Elon & Co. shutting down toll-free?
17 minAudio
Damien and Nikola are back to discuss the impact of removing toll-free numbers for government services, focusing on the DOGE/Social Security Administration's briefly considered decision. They explore the potential operational and cost-saving implications of voice AI in government services, the challenges of optimizing such large systems, and the long-term strategies for digital transformation. The discussion also touches on the changing preferences of Generation Z towards voice communication and the importance of careful, well-planned implementation of automation in government operations. Follow PolyAI on LinkedIn Watch this and other episodes of the Deep Learning pod on YouTube
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
NikolaSo when we say that we might see wavering voice usage, like that's a good thing. 'cause even a voice AI call costs you something. And if your product came with a sticker that prevented you from calling'cause it told you how to do something. That's just a good thing and it's a better user experience, right?
DamienHello, and welcome to another episode of Deep Learning with Poly ai, the only podcast where half of the host and guest combination is suffering the consequences of us over the counter pharmaceuticals. Nicola, how are you feeling today?
NikolaWhat ring endorsement? Yeah. No, we were just talking about I think I've had too much decongestion at this point. I feel like. I've done something to my voice that sounds ir irreparable, but we'll see. We'll see. How are you doing?
DamienNo better time than, yeah. No better time than to get you on a podcast, is to make you talk for the next 15 minutes or so about a topic of my choice and surprising you with it. I'm doing okay. But you are back in the UK now, is that correct? I. All right. Cool. Anyway I'm sure while you were here, you heard some rumblings in the news about politics. We're not gonna have a political conversation today, but we are gonna talk about something that overlaps with what we do here at Poly ai, which was a story that I believe Axios broke a couple weeks ago.
DamienTalking about the Department of Government Efficiency Doge, the Elon Musk led entity that's been going through and allegedly slashing inefficiencies across the government, right? One of those high profile things was the toll free number for the Social Security Administration that serves. 70 million individuals here in the United States was on the chopping block. It's been walked back since, but a sort of, a lot of alarms went off when it came to probably what we argue is one of the most accessible and intuitive channels for communication.
DamienYeah, let's just talk about that. Why? In the name of efficiency, if they're staying true to their name, why is this a terrible idea? Had they moved forward with removing a toll-free number for a government service?
NikolaYeah, like this is a story that repeats nonstop across the world, right? Another famous example is the UK's HMRC line, where, I think of it once or twice a year, they announce that it's going away, and then they roll it back really quickly. I think the issue is like you do math locally and you say, okay, like I don't have that channel. Hence they save that much money and people will just figure it out on their own. They'll read stuff online, they'll do this or that, and then someone goes and reads something misconstrued or reads the wrong source of information or outdated piece of information and they start filing things the wrong way.
NikolaOr well, booking things the wrong way and thus creating things that downstream create operational costs. That is way higher.
DamienYeah. And
Nikolathat just causes like catastrophic service delivery issues. And you can't account for them. And I think if you're like taking off a broad stroke and just trying to do things quickly, like sometimes it's impossible to account for it even when you do the best. Job you can. And I don't think it was really done here. It was just like whoop, like I'm gonna cut that. See you later. Are you really, and it's like you do it just to see who screams and if they scream loud enough and, maybe it's a valid way to shake up government if you think about it. You try 10 things, you get pushback that is valid on 8-year-old and back, but two go through and maybe that's okay.
NikolaBut just the idea of stopping the phone service for. Especially vulnerable customers. Makes no sense. And that's that channel, the channel is so sticky. The data is so exactly that. You're just like, you might as well not try. Or you should really deploy a voice agent. We don't think Elon is part of, our audience just yet. But, if someone listening can get to him. We've been trying to, I think we can do a lot, provide better service in certain places while, rationalizing costs, but not everywhere.
NikolaAnd it definitely can't operate as a, stop you up measure. There will be no phone. Like I recommend that you deploy a voice agent with no human handoff, right? Maybe you can make a handoff more difficult and more nuanced so that you help people in places where they really need help. That's an evolution. That's a journey mapping exercise that won't be done overnight, but let's just talk right now.
DamienYeah, and chances are they are, you never hear about good experiences over the phone with whether local municipal entities like the r and v dv, the Department of Motor Vehicles, the Internal Revenue Service. I know that I personally have had experiences calling up and spending literally three hours of which 80% of that time was on hold trying to communicate. And that's the only channel. For a long time, there was no email, there was no digital self-service, nothing like that. Social security, and you touched on this particularly interesting because of such a vulnerable audience.
DamienWe're talking about people who are in a certain age group, for the most part, that are benefiting from social security in the administration itself. I, it seems like it was a real as backwards move to go after the phone channel there. Is it just because the phone channel operationally looks clustered? Inefficient and ideally stands out as a beacon of change for change.
NikolaListen, it's really expensive to man the phone for something of that scale. It really is. And then the other thing that always somehow inevitably happens with government is, people in government and in these roles try to do the best job they can. Sure, but the famous example is Singapore, where, I dunno what the Prime Minister has paid or president, they paid a lot like a lot of money. So multiple of the US president who's 400,000 a year.
DamienYeah.
NikolaSo you know, you like, because the best people who know how to manage and run these things makes such an operational difference to a company that they cost a lot of money. That's just market, that's capitalism, right? So I think in government, because they're like so stringent limits and trying to do things. Cheaply efficiently, like when systems falls up, it actually becomes really difficult to optimize without the right expertise. So you end up probably with a heavily under optimized contact center operation, right?
NikolaIs labor in the right places? Often they have other, in trying to do right by the country, countries trying to keep these things onshore, right? So in the case of America, that means that you're. Hiring a lot of people in one of the most expensive countries in the world. That makes sense. That's fine, right? That's an active decision, but then are you staffing the right way? Are you like optimizing the shifts and stuff? So I think it's very likely that I. Even if you didn't do ai, you could probably bring in like customer journey mapping experts to really optimize that operation.
NikolaEven that probably wasn't done. So I think if they brought in someone like that to look at that operation, it was so bad. I can totally see any going let's like remove it and build it back if we have to from the grounds up. And that may be a valid approach, right? Because sometimes changing a very. Old system, old technology, old processes set in its ways can be really difficult. So I'm sure.
DamienDo you think that somebody who historically is a capitalist who's leading a department, a newly formed department on government efficiency, is really concerned about things like the customer journey or really thing concerned about, even the nature of constituent services in general, it seems like. For, again, the capitalist at heart. It seems like there's a bit of a and not for his particular businesses, but just in principle, there's a conflict of interest there.
NikolaWhat do you mean? We've flipped the roles? I'm supposed to be the communist grandfather. I like
Damienrole play. Nick, what can I say?
NikolaI think that journey mappings, conversion funnels, UX experience and stuff like that are close to any product guys. And that is what Elon is fundamentally right. Okay. So I think they got enough of his time to optimize it. He'd get interested, I'm sure. Because there's also money to be saved and the experience improved. It can be a win-win, win all over. It just needs forceful change. And that way we're committing to do it doesn't have to be. We fire people. Some am people like saying it, it's loud. I'm not gonna go into what the political climate and what different sides in America wanna hear, but it can be really like you, they could do a lot more with like subtle changes, but that's not gonna get the headlights.
NikolaAnd maybe they did and it never got picked up, and then when they do this, it gets picked up.
DamienIt's important because, again, going back to the fact that a toll free number. Especially when it comes to access to constituent services in the government is the standard and always has been. It's the primary channel. As I mentioned earlier, the IRS has no other means to get in touch with them. Yeah. So why, what was. The mindset, and I'm obviously, this is all speculation, right? But why would the mindset go to, Hey, this is the most popular intuitive channel for a vulnerable audience. Let's get rid of it and see who complains.
DamienWhat did they think would happen?
NikolaI think the new people will complain. I think the extent of it and the operational downstream implications are what probably got'em to back off, right? Yeah. I think yeah, no, I. It never really pans out. You have phenomenal examples of countries with like digitalized government. The uk GB UK is a spectacular piece of digital transformation. It's basically citizen services for everything. Most things can be done online. It's very clear, very well optimized. We can use GO UK to create like a voice agent that's gonna do most of these things the way that a human would, right?
NikolaYeah. Yeah. And then, it's like considerations of cost. They have a budget, right? So we can probably make the experience better just by using that stuff to deal with half of the queries and that's what they should be doing. Now, that's a lot more work than firing everyone, right? The phone line, right? But like one thing we always say to clients like, look, you can get a hundred percent containment. You just refuse to hand off to a human right. And equally you can solve. Customer contact by not offering customer contact.
NikolaPlans are for shyness by chopping off your foot or you can
DamienYeah.
NikolaMight change some other things, but hey,
Damiena few other things. The impact there. Tell me how long has the citizen services and what was the name of the program in the uk?
NikolaOh, it's just Gov uk, the website if
Damienyou got Okay. Oh, okay. Gotcha. Gov uk. So obviously a lot of digital transformation that's happening there, but, it wasn't with a, by blunt force trauma. This has been a longstanding initiative in place.
NikolaYeah, of course. And I think that many countries in Europe have followed up. I know that like Serbia has done a lot of similar stuff to create the online digital services and, but just seamlessly, I started getting emails of yearly taxes to pay for, like property and stuff. And I was like, wow, okay, cool. So it's happening, right? And, adoption is. Because, you gradually get people to do something because they might prefer to do it over email or over this or that. Now if you have hard budgetary constraints, maybe you can give it more forceful about where you push. But I think social services for healthcare voices can, it's mistaken, right?
NikolaIt won't change. We have enough data and consumer preferences. The recent thing, the survey we did where we see the Gen Z actually. Is drawn to voice much more than millennials or Gen X are like, that's a data point that you can argue, you can rerun the survey. We're fairly confident. We've done like a really thorough job, like Gen Z likes voice more, so it's not going away. So you start, you pull up, you roll up your sleeves and you're like, okay, let's go and build like a digital channel.
NikolaInvoice, right? Yeah. Automation. That's where you should do it, right? It won't come overnight. Adoption won't be overnight. It'll take people time to adjust. Especially in the US there's been so much of that first generation nuance side, the yard that makes people pull their hair out. That right? You want people, you, if you want complaints, you're gonna get a lot of complaints just from that, right? It's not gonna be popular that you introduced it, but that's how you strike a middle ground between. Balancing a budget and offering a service, you have to offer the service.
DamienAnd a lot of times, especially when it comes to uk, the well federal government agencies, they're operating on the most legacy of those legacy IVRs, if there's automation at all. The doom loops are more common and more frequent. The ability to actually route to the right department or individual is often the key because it hasn't been touched in 30 years. Because to your point as well. The staffing crisis that has always existed on those like frontiers, the number of agents that are able to handle anything. Yeah. It goes the way of the dodo. Let's, by the way, the interesting thing about that Gen Z piece is that, and this is to assuage any parents out there that are like, I'm gonna wave this factoid in front of my kids who never call me.
DamienIt's strictly tied to when they need. A service or support issue. They prefer the phone as the channel. So they still don't like to call anybody just to call and chat.
NikolaHold on. I remember being like a kid and a gamer. And I remember when we started using like ventral and TeamSpeak and at that point that wasn't very common. Today people are streaming and talking nonstop.
DamienThat's true.
NikolaSo they don't like to call their parents. I don't know that was different for our generation, for older generations either. So that whole like meme there is like probably nothing, just, it is just run rate. They call each other and they send each other asynchronous voice a lot more as well. And they spend,
Damienthat's true. There is a boost in like social use of voice memos where instead of sending texts, you just drop a voice memo. That's very true.
NikolaThat's one thing. And the other thing is, think of gaming platforms and everything now it's like pretty much run rate than in every game. You're speaking to people nonstop. You just have the voice channel. Previously you had chat and you were like, have a chat screen going on. And that's how you do that interaction. Today it's mostly speaking, right? So again, people like to communicate.
DamienThat is interesting. So maybe phone is wavering with regards to utilization, but voice will always be king. As long as their voice channels,
Nikolacompanies like the government that we're talking about,
Damienright? Yeah.
NikolaHave done so much work to make problems go away so that people coalesce.
DamienYeah.
NikolaThat's the never ending effort by every organization. So yeah, people coalesce. They also send less chat requests. Now if you forcibly push them to chat, right? Like you'll see a bit more chat and a bit less voice. But the total contact for most enterprises that we work with that are good at. Customer journey mapping and finding root causes of why people call right year on year, especially for like stable products that have been the same for many years. The contact volume across all channels decreases. So when we say that we might see wavering voice usage, like that's a good thing.
Nikola'cause even a voice AI call costs you something. And if your product came with a sticker that prevented you from calling'cause it told you how to do something. That's just a good thing and it's a better user experience, right? So I think that a lot of those surveys and questions are like how you ask the question and how you see all late in factors, right? And
Damienyeah, very true. All right. Fair enough. Then, only have about a minute left, so real quick, Elon calls us back, right? Says, Hey. All right. Tell me how automation, tell me how I should approach the inefficiencies here for this particular agency. And we wanna use voice automation as part of that solution. What is the 32nd roadmap that we present to Elon when it comes to, this is what you're gonna wanna do, inclusive of organizational redesign or preservation.
NikolaThey should just start with the departments where they're struggling the most. Where are the long waiting times? Is it the IRS? Is it social services? Medicare, Medicaid, like all those things. Let's go and figure out where the biggest problems are, where we can automate like 30, 50, 70%. We'll give'em a roadmap for each of those. We have it for each of those. And let's go, let's do some work, right? Like it can be done quickly but, it's gonna take some work, right? And in the end, it's gonna save a hell of a lot of money and make the whole system better'cause in answering the questions you need to answer to provide a conclusive answer, you're gonna find out that you're probably giving wrong answers by humans.
NikolaAll along, right? That many things are out data stuff, and as you create this new channel and interface, you're gonna redevelop your service to be even better, right? Yeah. Won't be done overnight. Can't be done with one announcement, or can be done relatively quickly, by the end of this administration, they could have a very different, digitally enabled America like they, they should take it seriously. They have a big opportunity.
DamienSo grab a scalpel, put away that chainsaw, please.
NikolaYeah. We're just cold with all the work.
DamienSounds great. Good last second pitch there, Nicola. A pleasure. As always. I hope your cough gets a little bit better and I look forward to chatting with you next week.
Three years ago, Simplyhealth's PolyAI deployment was only resolving simple FAQs over the phone. Today, they run voice, in-app, email, chat, and WhatsApp conversations on the platform. Nikola Mrkšić talks with Paul...
An agent that gets better every day compounds into a very different agent within months. That's the idea behind Wren, PolyAI's new release: an agent whose job is to make your other agents better. Some of what it finds...
Companies are pouring money into AI, but not everyone is getting the returns. Ian Jacobs, VP and Lead Analyst at Opus Research, thinks he knows why. In this episode, your host Nikola Mrkšić sits down with Ian to work...
When PolyAI built its Builder MCP, one client helped shape it: Vixxo Facility Solutions, one of the largest facilities providers in the US. In this episode, guest host Damian Sasso talks with Vixxo's CTO Derek Neighbors...
PolyAI just launched Dialog-RSN-1, its first audio-native model, and your host Nikola Mrkšić sat down with its builder, Matt Henderson, to unpack why it’s a game-changer for building voice agents. Most voice AI either...