Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Deep Cover

Deep Cover artwork

Nikki Cheng Saelee-McCain | Gone: The Disappearances

Nov 16, 202640 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

A young teacher fails to show up for her first day of school. A hiker vanishes from a mountain in Colorado. A man leaves for a meeting with his neighbor - and never returns. How can someone just disappear? On Gone: The Disappearances, journalist Lucy Sherriff unravels cases of people who’ve gone missing, and what their disappearances reveal about the places and people they leave behind. In this episode: Kaye Ford and Chloe Saelee always thought of their older sister, Nikki, as the ringleader of the family. But after Nikki entered a tumultuous relationship, they started to notice changes in Nikki’s demeanor. And when she disappeared in 2024, they were determined to find out what happened - and to fight for justice. Find Gone: The Disappearances wherever you get podcasts. Binge the full season, ad-free, now with a Pushkin+ subscription. Sign up on the Gone Apple Podcasts show page or at pushkin.fm/plus.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Pushkin.

Speaker 2Hey, it's Jake. While we're working on our next season of Deep Cover, which I can't wait to share with you, I wanted to bring you another true crime show. It's called Gone, The Disappearances. Some of our stories on Deep Cover have talked about stolen identities, scams, missing people. But when it comes to a disappearance, how does someone just vanish? On Gone, The Disappearances, investigative journalist Lucy Sheriff unravels eight cases of people who've gone missing. A hiker who vanished

Speaker 2from a mountain without a trace, a young teacher who never showed up for the first day of school, a teenager looking for her father and then turned out not to be a teenager at all. Lucy tries to understand what their disappearances reveal about them, the people left behind, and how, if ever, you can make things whole again. The episode I'm about to share is about Nikki Chang Saley McCain. Nikki was the centerpiece of her family, but after she entered an abusive relationship, she became withdrawn. When

Speaker 2she disappeared in 2024, her sisters were determined to find out what happened and to fight for justice for Nikki. Enjoy the episode and find out more episodes of Gone, The Disappearances, wherever you get podcasts. New episodes release on Mondays, But if you want to hear the full season ad-free right this second, you can sign up for a Pushkin Plus subscription on the Gone Show page on Apple Podcasts or at pushkin.fm slash plus.

Speaker 3A quick note. This episode contains descriptions of domestic violence. Please take care while listening. Sometime in 2024... I heard the story of a mother who had disappeared in a remote, mountainous region of California. Her name was Nikki Cheng Saley McCain. There had been several searches for Nikki, without success, and a family left behind, desperate for clues to what had happened.

Speaker 3As the months dragged on, new information kept trickling out. She was first reported missing in May. Two months later, her story was still in the news.

Speaker 4But yet.

Speaker 3still know Nikki. I wanted to learn more about her. So I reached out to two of her sisters who have spearheaded the campaign to locate Nikki and refuse to rest until she's found.

Speaker 4Nikki was very, she was really strong-willed.

Speaker 3This is Kay Ford, one of Nikki's younger sisters.

Speaker 5Even though she was the third child and the second girl, when we were younger, she kind of led.

Speaker 4The way with a lot of things.

Speaker 5She would be more likely the one to say, well, let's ask if we can go do this today.

Speaker 4You know, and we're like, no, we're going to get in trouble. We don't want to ask that.

Speaker 5We lived kind of remotely at one point with not very close neighbors. And there was a big canyon on the side of the house. We'd kind of ventured down a little bit, but she's like, let's go all the way to the bottom of the canyon.

Speaker 3Chloe Saley, the youngest of the family, remembers Nikki the same way.

Speaker 1She questioned everything. Well, that doesn't seem right. Or, well, you know what? I bet you we can go down on that canyon.

Speaker 3The Salies were a big family, seven kids, all living in Reading, California. They originally hailed from Thailand, and they were tight-knit.

Speaker 5We came to the United States in the 80s when I was about a year old. Didn't know the language, that we were learning the culture. So we bonded over that, just feeling, you know, a little bit more like we were a little different from some of the people around us, from our classmates.

Speaker 4So that brought us even closer.

Speaker 5And then especially as we became adults and the age gap felt a lot smaller, we all became just very close. You know, you just, you always have a best friend. You always have a girlfriend to call. And then the case of being Chloe, since we live nearby, there's always someone to hang out with.

Speaker 3Nikki was a ringleader of the family, the fierce, fearless one. Around 2008, she was working as a cocktail server alongside her sister Kay at a casino in Shasta County. run by the Reading Rancheria tribe. That's when Nikki caught the eye of Tyler McCain.

Speaker 4He was working there, she was working there, and I also was working there.

Speaker 5And at the time, I do remember Tyler had developed a little bit of a reputation, you know, amongst the patrons at the casino as well as the employees there.

Speaker 4He was a handsome young guy and he was flirtatious, very charming.

Speaker 5And he started to pursue her And I do remember kind of warning her a little bit, like, you know, he's got a little bit of a reputation, just be cautious. And she was pretty, she took my advice, but I think it became more of a challenge for him, I think. And so he pursued her even more aggressively than he may have with someone else.

Speaker 4Still, he was charming.

Speaker 3And when he and Nikki started dating, he charmed Kay and Khloe too. Here's how Khloe remembers it.

Speaker 1You know, I was only 18 years old and at the time he, I was really impressed with him. He would pay me to bring my sister over to his house like late at night. And I was so, I thought he was so cool. I was like, who's this rich guy? Like giving me a hundred dollars to drop my sister off there or to go pick my sister up.

Speaker 4She seemed happy. And I think that was important for us.

Speaker 5And even there are other people there who worked with me at the casino at the time that had said he has completely changed. Nikki had really made him a family man and he seems like this is who he's settling down with.

Speaker 4And everyone kind of rallied behind them.

Speaker 5They both seemed like they were on the right path and maybe they just needed each other to kind of get there.

Speaker 3But as their relationship continued, it became clear that Nikki and Tyler were on a different kind of path. And it would all come to a head when one night, Nikki disappeared. Last season, I focused on just one person, Dia Abrams. But in the years I spent reporting her story, I realised just how nuanced things can be when someone disappears, and how many kinds of disappearances there are. When someone goes missing, they leave behind so much. Questions, ambiguity, even

Speaker 3an uncertainty over whether they can be grieved. This season, we're spotlighting eight different stories of people who've disappeared. We've chosen them because they represent something. A community often overlooked, a state of mind difficult to understand, or a battle against the odds to find a loved one. I'm Lucy Sheriff, and this is Gone, The Disappearances, a series where we go beyond the news headlines of people who have gone missing.

Speaker 5Nikki Salee McCain's been missing since May of last year.

Speaker 1She was last seen at the Reading Rancheria.

Speaker 5Despite efforts by the Sheriff's Office and the community to help find Nikki, no new details on her whereabouts have emerged. Breaking news in the disappearance of Nikki McCain.

Speaker 2Tonight, the Shasta County Sheriff's Office, for the first time, is officially calling it.

Speaker 6A homicide case.

Speaker 1Still, no body has been found.

Speaker 5Our family is holding on to hope, and we won't stop until we find her.

Speaker 3What do we want? Justice! When do we want it? Now! What do we want? Justice! When do we want it? In 2016, after dating for a while, Nikki and Tyler got married in Reno, Nevada. The newlyweds settled down in their house in a small community called Happy Valley. And

Speaker 3soon they began a family. Over a fairly short period of time, Nikki gave birth to four kids. On the surface, everything seemed pretty great.

Speaker 4They do cookouts there all the time. They hosted all the time.

Speaker 1Yeah, I was over there every weekend. It was just a, it was basically a dream relationship. They had everything. I mean, they would get into their fights, but it was nothing too crazy. You know, just bickering here and there.

Speaker 3So when did things start to change or when did you get an idea that things had changed between them?

Speaker 4Well, during COVID, you know, no one was allowed to see anyone.

Speaker 5So we didn't really know a lot about what was going on. But during that time, Nikki had discovered that Tyler was having an affair with She felt that there was something going on, that he had been staying late at work too often. So she finally confronted him and said, I know there's something going on, whatever it is, let's work on it. And apparently he had confessed that he had been having this affair with a patron at the casino and she was potentially pregnant.

Speaker 3Chloe took it upon herself to do some investigating.

Speaker 1And I pursued this really hard. I found out who the girl was. I found out who her husband was. And I shared all the information with Nikki.

Speaker 3And how was Nikki feeling at that point? Like, was she thinking, okay, this is salvageable? Was she thinking, I've.

Speaker 4Got to get out? Well, I think he had convinced her that.

Speaker 5She couldn't divorce him because they got married in Reno. She'd have to go to Reno and they don't live in Reno. So it was going to be complicated and she couldn't get the divorce. And when she told me he had told her that, I was completely shocked. I'm like, no, that's absolutely not true. Like you can absolutely get a divorce. And he also told her like, well, you're not, you're not going to get the children because you don't have a job and you couldn't provide for them.

Speaker 3This argument that Nikki wouldn't get custody because she didn't have a job was a point of contention between her and Tyler. She'd taken time off to have their four kids and But to her sisters, she'd been talking about getting back out there and finding work.

Speaker 5Because she's like, I'm ready. The kids are all going to be in school now. I think it's a good time for me to start getting a part-time job. He did not want her to do that. He wouldn't let her go to her job interviews.

Speaker 1And I remember Nikki had always expressed to me that, well, Tyler thinks that women shouldn't work and they should stay home. But I've always mentioned him, well, we all work. His mom has a job. Like, why is it just on you?

Speaker 5And then anytime she would bring up anything about, um, Anything to do with independence. He would be like, well, you don't have a job. And I used to go, I want to get a job. So he did not want to get divorced. He wanted to keep her control.

Speaker 4100%. And he had convinced her that there was no way for her to live. She couldn't do it without him.

Speaker 5And it was all because of him that she was able to have this home and provide for the children.

Speaker 4And I remember having this talk with her that, no, you. You get child support.

Speaker 5And these are things that she just had no idea about because she had been told for so many years that this is how the law works.

Speaker 4And this is, you know, this is America. This isn't, you know, and so she said, well, I don't know. I don't know the laws. I don't know the rules. And they're also under tribal jurisdiction.

Speaker 3Tyler has close ties to the Redding Rancheria tribe. His mother is an enrolled member. The tribe also runs the casino where he and Nikki met. According to the sisters, Tyler would constantly remind Nikki of his influential connections and that if she stood up to him on his home turf, she'd have no chance.

Speaker 5He would throw that in her face too. You know, we don't go through the county court.

Speaker 4Shasta County.

Speaker 5Yeah, we don't go through the Shasta County prosecutors, you know, whatever their law. And he would tell her, I know everyone who runs our tribal court. I know the judge. I know the social worker. those are all my cousins and my family, you know, my, my, they're all in my tribe.

Speaker 4Those are my people. They will do what I want.

Speaker 3How was it for you to, to hear your sister? Cause you, you started by saying she was kind of always like not a rebel, but you know, she was kind of like the leader and now she's been reduced to somebody who is being controlled by this other person. Like how did that make you feel?

Speaker 1During that time? I, I told my sister, Mae, you know, I'm so frustrated because she's fierce and she's so sassy and she does not, she doesn't give up a fight. She always has the last word and everything. And she has to win every argument. And I was wondering what changed. And it was really shocking to hear that someone who had so much confidence and knew so much to feel so hopeless and helpless and to feel so defeated when

Speaker 1that's not her personality.

Speaker 5And it confused me too, because I had no idea that she assumed she couldn't do these things on her own. So that was, to me, also a telling point was you're very much being controlled and manipulated because these things are absolutely not true.

Speaker 4And she didn't think to really seek, you know, otherwise, because that's what she's been told.

Speaker 3Emotionally abusive relationships can be hard to spot.

Speaker 1Even from the inside.

Speaker 3The abuse can creep up on you so gradually that you don't even notice it's happening. And then suddenly, you're in this awful mess. And it can be incredibly, incredibly hard to get out, especially if there's kids involved. Something had changed in Chloe and Kay's fearless, fierce sister. And they were starting to notice it. The cracks were showing in Nikki and Tyler's relationship, too. And what Kay and Chloe would soon realise was that the abuse wasn't just emotional.

Speaker 3Their sister was also in a physically violent marriage. Kay told me she knew her sister Nikki's marriage was troubled.

Speaker 4But for a while.

Speaker 3She didn't understand the full extent.

Speaker 5We knew there had been some incidences and that was also during the COVID time that it really kind of escalated and we weren't, you know, we didn't get to see her. We didn't really realize that these, just maybe some pushes and like getting in each other's space had become very physical. But the domestic violence had gotten pretty bad to where she had been calling the police. By the very time the police came, She didn't want to break the family apart. So she said, no, I'm fine.

Speaker 5That was a false alarm. I didn't mean to call.

Speaker 3I should mention here that there were allegations of violence on both sides. Though Kay and Chloe say that Nikki acted in self-defense.

Speaker 5And after several calls, the police looked around and said, I see, it looks like children live here. If you guys are calling the police this frequently for domestic violence, the children have to be in the midst of this.

Speaker 4So they ended up removing the children from the home. because there had been so many calls.

Speaker 1And what's really, really, really sad was that the day that they removed the children, it was their tribal CPS worker, along with Tyler's mom, along with Tyler's mom's boyfriend, and along with a whole bunch of Tyler's family. So I think Nikki felt very... She.

Speaker 4Was ganged up against.

Speaker 1She couldn't stand a chance. She was ganged up against.

Speaker 3I reached out to Tyler for his account of all of this, but I didn't hear back. According to Chloe and Kay, the kids were initially placed with Tyler's mum.

Speaker 5And Nikki was not allowed to see them, but Tyler would go over to his mum's house.

Speaker 3And where was Nikki staying? I'm assuming she wasn't going back.

Speaker 5She was at her own house and Tyler would stay at his mum's house with the kids.

Speaker 4Okay.

Speaker 5Or like, or would go back and forth to their house and then his mum's house.

Speaker 3So even though the kids had been removed from both Tyler and Nikki, he was still able to see them. And Nikki was heartbroken. Eventually, the kids went to live with Chloe and Kay. But the domestic violence didn't stop. In fact, it escalated. In November of 2023, everything came to a head. According to a report later made with the Shasta County Sheriff's Office, Nikki told police Tyler came home agitated. She noticed a, quote, glazed, scary look.

Speaker 5In his eyes.

Speaker 3The details of what came next are disturbing. Nikki told the police that he physically attacked her, holding her down and hitting her in the face, repeatedly. She told Chloe and Kay about it too.

Speaker 4Had kept her tied up.

Speaker 5Tried to, I think he tried to drown her by pouring water over her face.

Speaker 4And bound her.

Speaker 5And I think she had said at one point that the reason she was able to escape is that he had taken a break because he was tired from beating her.

Speaker 4So she went.

Speaker 5And grabbed her robe because I think she was soaked. Her clothing was soaked. So she went and grabbed her robe and her keys were in there and she was able to drive away.

Speaker 1And she did say that he jumped on top of the hood of her car and she like reversed and like took off.

Speaker 3Nikki fled to a friend's place, then to Chloe's a few days later. Kay remembers how she looked. She had bruises everywhere. She looked awful. And we, as a family, like, take her to the hospital right now. We're calling the police. She's never reported anything. This needs to be reported. So I think that was a big piece, too.

Speaker 5I think she kind of felt like this was very the furthest he's ever gone.

Speaker 1I think that if she didn't get away, he would have killed her that night.

Speaker 4And she said that, too. She said she felt that she was going to die that night. He's going to kill me.

Speaker 3After Nikki's report, members of the sheriff's office took Tyler into custody and questioned him. A detective noted in his write-up that Tyler's statement sounded inconsistent. Tyler accused Nikki of having an affair, but also said they were getting along great. He denied hitting Nikki and also denied seeing any of Nikki's injuries. Tyler was charged with four felonies, including assault and false imprisonment.

Speaker 4This felt like a turning point.

Speaker 3After years of domestic violence, Nikki finally seemed ready to leave.

Speaker 4And she was, stayed away.

Speaker 5We were having more serious talks about what's the next steps. She had reached out to One Safe Place. They help with DV cases. The county had assigned her a victim advocate who helped her navigate a lot of these things. And she was truly on track to, she was trying to get a job again, trying to get an apartment.

Speaker 4Or just a place of her own.

Speaker 1And then eventually getting her children back. and living with her too. And she did text me and say, I'm going to divorce Tyler. And she's never said that before. She's always said, I'm going to leave him. But she's never said the words divorce. And so I knew that she was serious.

Speaker 3Meanwhile, the charges related to the domestic violence incident, which Tyler pled not guilty to, move through the legal system. A settlement conference was scheduled for early June of 2024. But as the court date approached, Chloe and Kay saw less and less of Nikki.

Speaker 5We noticed she wasn't coming around as much, which we all had asked, are they back together? Is she back there? And we found out that she was. And we believe that with the case coming close, he was trying to charm her back and get her to change her mind.

Speaker 3The sisters say that Tyler even bought Nikki.

Speaker 4A truck, which we thought was really odd.

Speaker 1Nikki already had a vehicle. She had a van.

Speaker 4She had it, which made sense. Like the van served its purpose.

Speaker 1And I remembered her texting me. She told me, look, Tyler bought me this truck. And I'm like, don't take it. I thought it was weird. I said, do not take anything from him. Do not accept any gifts. Do not accept anything from him. She's like, But, you know, she didn't think.

Speaker 4And he's trying to make amends and he's trying to, you know.

Speaker 1Yeah, and so she didn't see that.

Speaker 3Nikki told them that Tyler was pressuring her to drop the charges. But in spite of accepting the truck, she seemed to stay firm.

Speaker 5So even in the midst of him being charming and nice and trying to get back together, she's like, no, I'm still going forward with this case.

Speaker 4Like, I'm not, still not recanting.

Speaker 1Like, you did this to me and you need to be held responsible.

Speaker 5Then....

Speaker 3Just a few weeks before the hearing was scheduled, Nikki disappeared.

Speaker 1So the night of May 17th, it was a Friday. Tyler's brother had had a serious emergency. So he was at the ER. And so Nikki had been texting me saying that she was at the hospital visiting Tyler's brother, Brian. And everyone in Tyler's family thought he wasn't going to make it. It was very serious. And so Nikki was there. And we were texting all night. And then I remember at about 1230 a.m., which would make it May 18th, Saturday,

Speaker 1she had texted me and told me that she was she had Jeanette's car, Tyler's mom's car, and she was going to drop off the car back home to Jeanette's house. And so the next morning, it was about 730 and I text her and I asked her, What's the update with Brian? Is he okay? And I didn't get anything.

Speaker 3Initially, Chloe wasn't concerned. But then a short while later, she texted her again.

Speaker 1I didn't get a response. And so I thought it was kind of weird. Usually when you're doing iPhone to iPhone, like the text messages are blue. But I do remember seeing that text message was green. And so I was thinking maybe Nicky's phone's just probably dead.

Speaker 3The weekend passed and still no word from Nicky. there was a growing unease amongst the siblings. According to Chloe, Tyler texted her on May 19th, asking if she'd seen Nikki and that he thought she was missing.

Speaker 1I think by Monday and Tuesday was when we started to really, really worry. And like, wait a second, I haven't heard from Nikki since then. Technically, basically Friday night, but technically Saturday morning.

Speaker 5We did discuss in the group message, like, what is it you talked to? Oh, no, I saw her and mom's on this day. And then my brother was like, oh, you know, no, I talked to her on this day. Oh, mom called her on this day. So by the time we had connected everything, I think it was like Tuesday, we were very much like, we think she's missing. And then we were trying to figure out what to do. Like, what's the next step? And then Wednesday is the night that we made the report. When we made the decision

Speaker 5to make the missing persons report, I told my husband, she's gone and I think Tyler did something with her. That's what I had expressed to him. I didn't get the feeling that she had run away at all. For me, like that weekend, thinking it was Memorial weekend, it was more times wasting either that's extra days that he could be hiding evidence, hiding her, or she might still be alive somewhere.

Speaker 4He has her somewhere.

Speaker 5And these are moments that she could be hanging on by a thread.

Speaker 3And what did you think, Chloe?

Speaker 1I automatically, I just knew because before that she did tell me she wanted to divorce him. And she had always told me before too, after everything was happening, if anything ever happened to me, Tyler did it. And my gut was telling me that He definitely did something to her.

Speaker 3And then something else happened in those days after Nikki stopped responding. Chloe received a text from someone close to Tyler's family. And the message left her reeling.

Speaker 1She said, something's not right. I think something's happened to Nikki.

Speaker 4I just knew.

Speaker 1That just confirmed it.

Speaker 3Still, at that point, they didn't have any evidence. Just a very strong feeling. And what they couldn't have known then was that this was just the beginning of a multi-year effort to find their sister.

Speaker 4More after the break.

Speaker 3Chloe last heard from Nikki around midnight on May 18th, 2024. Nikki had texted to say she was on her way to Tyler's mother's house so she could drop off a car she'd borrowed and that one of Tyler's friends would give her a ride home. On May 25th, Nikki's truck, the one Tyler had given her, was found abandoned near a bridge close to the Shasta County border. Chloe, Kay and the family mobilised. A reward was offered and the community combed the area for traces of Nikki. Local media

Speaker 3covered the search.

Speaker 5Family, friends, and civilians joined Sunday morning at 9 a.m., meeting at the Clear Creek Market outside of the Wind River Casino.

Speaker 3Billboards went up alongside busy highways in the hopes someone might offer a tip that could help find her.

Speaker 5I am out here on a heartfelt mission, and I'm hoping that we're not here looking for a body.

Speaker 3Shasta County is a remote outpost of Northern California. I've been up there many times. What's always struck me is how close to the edge of civilization you are. You can be there sipping a beer in a small bar in a tiny town, knowing that just outside lies this vast, unforgiving wilderness. There are dense woods and weed grows and craggy mountains and bottomless lakes. It's a place where, if you disappeared, you might never be found. When Nikki went missing,

Speaker 3Kay and Chloe's gut feelings were that Tyler was involved somehow. But as the months went on, no arrests were made, and they kept in touch with him.

Speaker 5We didn't communicate much with him, but every now and then, it would just be about the children, and we'd try to keep that cordial and normal. He had called Chloe a couple times about random things, like if a search had happened.

Speaker 3For months, there was no sign of Nikki. But there was a major development as a consequence of her disappearance.

Speaker 5In July.

Speaker 3Her pending domestic violence case against Tyler was dismissed. The key witness, Nicky herself, was missing, and so would be unable to testify against her husband. The irony of this was not lost on me, and it's part of why I kept tabs on the case. It felt like an odd loophole. More than 300 community members showed up to the courthouse that day, holding signs that read, Justice for Nicky. As Tyler walked out, they demanded answers from him. But

Speaker 3he just kept walking, hands in his pockets. Because of Tyler's ties to Reading Rancheria, some accused the tribe of getting in the way of the search. So much so that Reading Rancheria published a press release. They outlined the ways they were supporting efforts, like offering a $ 10, 000 reward and putting up posters, flyers and.

Speaker 4Even a billboard.

Speaker 3They also said they granted access to search parties on tribal lands and were cooperating with law enforcement. Then, in March of 2025, the Sheriff's Office held a news conference.

Speaker 1Nicky's sisters, Chloe and Kay, were there with a heartfelt plea.

Speaker 6Hello, my name is Kay Ford.

Speaker 1And I'm Chloe Salee. We just want to start off by saying thank you for being here today to hear about our missing sister, Nikki Chang Salee McCain, who has been missing for 296 days.

Speaker 3Also there to speak to the press, Tyler.

Speaker 6Hello, I'm Tyler McCain. I'm the husband of Nikki McCain. First of all, I would like to thank Sheriff's Office of FBI for getting involved today. any efforts that might help bring my wife home safely. We miss you.

Speaker 3He appeared nervous, mumbling quickly, and he seemed to realize that.

Speaker 6I don't really know what to say. I haven't been in the public eyes, and I haven't done very well with it. I apologize to everyone, especially my children, my wife's family, mine as well. I'm just here in support, so anything that I can do, I want to do that.

Speaker 3A few days after the press conference, the Sheriff's Office released an update. They were now investigating Nikki's case as a homicide. Though they served a search warrant at Nikki and Tyler's home, that place in Happy Valley, and announced they'd identified persons of interest, they didn't share any names. It was later that summer, in August, that police finally made an arrest.

Speaker 4Tyler McCain. How did that feel when you found out?

Speaker 1They had asked us to come in for a meeting. And I remember it was a Wednesday meeting. And I just remember me and Kay were there and Kay's husband was there. And they gave us this paper of like some of their findings. And then they told us that they were going to arrest him. And I was like, when? They're like, we're going to go do it right now. We're like, what? And I just remember, I think me and Kay were in kind of disbelief in a way.

Speaker 1Because we're like, wait, what did you guys say? And so I remembered scrambling because I was like, I didn't find anybody to cover the rest of my shift. Like, yeah, it was so surreal.

Speaker 4You know, it was a lot of mixed emotions.

Speaker 5And, you know, hopeful that we were going to start getting some more answers.

Speaker 3Those answers would start to come out at Tyler's preliminary hearing in September of 2025. And the details, well, they're hard to stomach.

Speaker 1There was a significant amount of blood found in the truck.

Speaker 4And then like her DNA. Her DNA.

Speaker 5And like oven cleaner, some sheets with blood on it, a mat with blood. So at the preliminary hearing, we found out that there were a lot of evidence in that truck.

Speaker 3Investigators also reported smelling decomposition when they first approached. Other evidence has come to light too. including Tyler being in possession of a half-burned driver's license that belonged to Nikki. In addition to homicide, Tyler was charged with forgery, illegal firearm possession, and those refiled domestic violence charges. He pleaded not guilty to all and was hailed without bail. Nikki is still missing. I spoke with Chloe and Kay ahead

Speaker 3of Tyler's trial, and by that point, there was no doubt for either of them that Tyler was responsible.

Speaker 1There's no doubt in my mind.

Speaker 5Yeah, all the evidence confirms it for me more so. I mean, you can't, it's DNA, you know, you can't really... You can't fight science. You can't fight science. And so, yeah, I think it confirms it for me even more that, yeah, he was definitely behind it.

Speaker 1And I think that he... He didn't think that we were going to go look for her. I don't think he realized that Nikki was communicating with us almost every day.

Speaker 5I don't think they assumed we'd even have a picture of the truck, but we share everything. We share all every, you know, and Nikki took a picture of me and said, oh, here's the new truck Tyler just got me. She drove to my house with it. It's on my Arlo. Yeah, she knew to leave crumbs. And I definitely feel like we will still find them randomly, you know.

Speaker 3They both feel a duty to be at the trial.

Speaker 1We're going there for our sister. And I think that, you know, we are fighting for her justice and Nikki can't be here to speak. So we have to be here there for her. So absolutely.

Speaker 5When I think to the people who are going to be on the stand, like I, I, Whatever they know, I want them to still see, like, you know, Nikki's not here, but you need to tell us what you did. We're here for Nikki. We're not going to forget this case. We're not going to forget what's going on. And we want to make sure that justice is being.

Speaker 4Pursued.

Speaker 5And I think if we're not there to make sure that happens, then who's going to care about it, you know?

Speaker 1Well, and also we represent lots of other families who have been through this. We represent all of the victims of someone that has lost their life to domestic violence. I think that's a really important stand too.

Speaker 3For you guys, your family, for Nikki's kids, like, is there any semblance of closure you think you might be able to get? And what might that look like?

Speaker 1For me, I'm thinking, you know, I watch all these like documentaries and everything, like the 2020, all these crime things. And to put a family through a trial is probably, you know, it's one of the hardest things to watch. And now me going through it, I don't want to go through a trial. I think the best justice is if maybe he would admit to what he did to her and where he put her. I think that would be the ideal justice. but I'm ready. Like if, if you want to go to trial and, you know, put

Speaker 1your hands in the 12 jurors, then, then we're ready. And that would be justice too. But I think the best justice would be for him to admit and tell us where she is.

Speaker 5Yeah. And really we just, we, we, we want a proper, um, burial for her. Um, we have, um, our family have decided that we are, um, her, her soul is ready to.

Speaker 1Uh, move on to the other side and to the afterlife.

Speaker 5So we, um, we have, uh, scheduled that ceremony for, um, next weekend. Um, so, so that, that piece, um, for us, at least, um, we'll have a little bit.

Speaker 1Of more closure. I think the children really need it. They need some closure. And I think this will bring them some comfort knowing that we have, um, we're going to help their mom move on to the other side and also for us too.

Speaker 5And then in our culture, um, the, um, having your, having your soul kind of linger in that, you know, in that in between is, is we kind of see it as, as that's not a proper way to, um, for, for our souls to, to be lingering there for, for so long. So we've, so we've made that decision that it's time to help her, her soul transition. Um, but it doesn't mean we're not still fighting and we're not still trying to find where her, her remains may be. Um, But yeah, but that is great that I feel at

Speaker 5least very, very much like, you know, for our family and for our community, our man community, that is bringing some piece of closure, knowing that her soul will be at peace.

Speaker 3At the time of airing, Tyler's trial has been set for early 2027 after multiple delays, meaning Chloe and Kay will have to wait even longer for the possibility of of getting any answers to the painful question of what happened to Nikki. But what really stayed with me was what they said about finding closure. Whatever happens with Tyler's trial, it won't bring Nikki back. And Kay, Chloe, Nikki's kids, and the rest of her family will still be left

Speaker 3with a huge hole in their lives. Over the next few episodes, we'll hear about more disappearances. People who one day went missing. Some were wrapped up in complicated circumstances.

Speaker 1The young woman was screaming, saying that a man had kidnapped her and had been keeping her in his basement.

Speaker 2This is a.

Speaker 1Person who clearly experienced some terrible trauma in their early life and spent the rest of their life trying somehow to come to grips with it.

Speaker 3Others seemingly vanished into thin air.

Speaker 1I remember the New York Times saying something like, It was as if the city had swallowed her whole.

Speaker 2We had nothing, absolute, not a ski pole, not a gum wrapper, not a boot print, absolutely nothing. You know, to have to tell the family that we can't find them, that's by.

Speaker 3Far the worst. I'll speak to journalists, family members, and friends.

Speaker 7We were constantly told by people, like, she's this county's problem, she's this office's problem. And I kept thinking, like, she's not a problem, she's a person.

Speaker 1I needed to know where he was.

Speaker 4Like, this is my brother. I remember screaming one night, like, you know, where is my brother? Where is my brother?

Speaker 3And at the heart of all these stories, the vacuum that's left, the people who are left to pick up the pieces and find a way to move forward with their new normal, which seems almost impossible when they're still grasping for answers. Gone is hosted by me, Lucy Sheriff. It's produced by Daphne Chen. It's edited by Amy Gaines McQuaid.

Speaker 3Our executive producer is Jacob Smith. Fact-checking by Arnica Robbins. Original music by Echo Shores. Sound design and mastering by Echo Mountain. Special thanks to Karen Shikurji, Christina Sullivan, Eric Sandler, and Greta Cohn. Gone is a co-production of Pushkin Industries and iHeartMedia. We'll be right back.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Deep Cover Presents: The JFK Papers That Weren't

    Oct 19, 202633 minAudio

    "Here it is. The Holy Grail." John Reznikoff makes his living spotting fakes. So when his close friend, a polished Navy war hero, turned up hundreds of secret documents tying John F. Kennedy to Marilyn Monroe -- a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Deep Cover Presents: Switched At Birth

    Oct 13, 202659 minAudio

    What happens when you learn your family is not your own? In 1951, Mary Kaye Miller gave birth to a baby girl. But when she brought the infant home, she suspected something was wrong. 43 years later, she broke the news:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Limits of Manifesting Success with James Forman, Jr.

    Jun 29, 202646 minAudio

    When Keith Giammanco started robbing banks in 2007, he sought to minimize his legal risk. Keith says he never carried a weapon, and he confessed to the authorities the same day he was arrested. But, ultimately, he faced...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. My Oldest, Dearest Friend

    Jun 22, 202627 minAudio

    Mike Walton was shocked to learn his lifelong friend, Keith, had been living a double life as the Boonie Hat Bandit. He’d seen reports about the serial bank robber on the news, but never recognized him. Jake speaks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Release | Episode 6

    Jun 15, 202643 minAudio

    Keith’s daughters, Elise and Marissa, face new trials on their own while Keith serves his time. After decades in custody, Keith nears his release date, and the Giammanco family grapples with the past and the choices...

    Credit the people on this episode