Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Dear Sovereign Self

Dear Sovereign Self artwork

Nobody Cares Until Everybody Cares

Sep 22, 202619 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Sometimes the product works. The idea resonates. The problem is solved. And still…we don’t move. Why? This week, we’re talking about the sociology of caring: how other people’s participation changes our own, why some things become socially legible, and what it takes for a universe with a population of one to become a world.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00I'm Ashley, and this is Dear Sovereign Self, my audio journal on the way I walk through life, practicing sovereignty, living from truth, not wound, and choosing alignment over self-abandonment. Here's today's entry.

SPEAKER_01I came across this guy on TikTok recently who is building his own app and he was talking about one of the problems he's having getting it off the ground. And I'm going to oversimplify the product because the product isn't really the point here. But essentially, part of the experience of the app gets better when other people are there. That's not to say that it is a social media app, or I don't know if that's what makes it a social media app. Um, but it is enhanced by a social layer.

SPEAKER_01Okay. And so he was saying something in his video to the effect of nobody cares. Like nobody cares until everybody cares. And I was like, hmm. Because on its face, that sounds like a very normal builder problem. How do I get people to download my app? How do I get people to listen to my podcasts? How do you get people to buy your thing? You know, how do I get people to come to my restaurant to join this community? But I don't think that's actually the interesting question.

SPEAKER_01The interesting question to me is what happens between nobody caring and everybody caring? Like, how does something go from being a thing that exists to being a thing that exists socially? How does the universe get off the ground? And immediately this made me think about something interesting that I've been uh noticing in the data around Dear Sovereign Self, but we'll get to that. Because first I want to stay with his problem.

SPEAKER_01Right? So let's assume I have problem A. And you build something that solves problem A perfectly. The builder's assumption is you have problem A, I solve problem A, therefore, you should use my solution. Except we understand that human beings don't make decisions in a vacuum because while I'm solving problem A, I'm also navigating this whole other set of questions.

SPEAKER_01Who else uses this? Do people like me use this? Does anybody I know know what this is? If I tell somebody I use this, am I going to have to explain it for 10 minutes? What does using this say about me? And where does this locate me socially? And sometimes the answer is nowhere. Nobody I know is there yet, which means you may have solved the functional problem without solving the social problem. The thing works, right? I might even believe that it works, but it hasn't become socially legible yet.

SPEAKER_01And I think that distinction is really important because a product can be functionally useful before it is socially usable. Does that make sense? Because human beings are not just constantly asking, does this work? We are also consciously or unconsciously asking, what happens to me among other people if I do this? And that second question can completely change the adoption of the first answer. Now, obviously, there are a bunch of mechanisms involved in getting anything off the ground, and I think there are at least three layers worth separating here.

SPEAKER_01There's distribution. Do I even know your thing exists? Right? Who knows that his app exists and how is he spreading the word? Okay. Because we live in an absolutely insane information environment, and you could have built the greatest solution to my exact problem, and I may simply never encounter it. Okay. So distribution. Then there's marketing. Do I understand what this thing is?

SPEAKER_01Do I understand why it matters to me? Do I recognize myself as somebody it might be for? And brands have been doing all kinds of sophisticated answering of these questions forever to manufacture or communicate aspiration and identity and belonging, and that is a whole other conversation, right? It is not this conversation because I'm interested in the third layer. It's what I would call the sociology layer.

SPEAKER_01So let's assume distribution worked. The information got to me. Let's assume the marketing worked. I understand the proposition. Maybe I even believe you. Now, do I attend? And actually, I wouldn't define care here. Because this particular creator did not. I assume to know what he means, right? Adoption of his app. But here I want to widen the scope of what I mean by care, because I think it matters for the rest of the conversation. So for the purpose of this entry, care is attendance.

SPEAKER_01So that doesn't have to be physical attendance, but attendance in some sort. Crossing over the threshold from knowing to doing in some med. That's what I'm describing when I say care. Because care is attention, yes, but it is attention that eventually moves some amount of your life force. Did you download it? Did you listen? Did you buy it? Did you go? Did you join? Because I can know that something exists and not care.

SPEAKER_01I can understand why something is valuable and not care. I can literally say, oh, that's a really good idea, and then go about my day. At some point, somebody still has to participate. Somebody has to care with action. So that's the kind of care that I'm talking about. Okay. And once somebody attends, right, then something interesting happens. Their attendance becomes information. Not just the thing exists, but she's there.

SPEAKER_01He uses it. That person I trust likes it. People like us are starting to do this. And I think that's part of why referrals are so powerful. Because if my friend sends me something, I didn't just receive information about the thing. I received information about the person who thinks the thing is worth my attention. The messenger becomes part of the message. And I can start a very strange little chain reaction. What's that? Oh, that's the thing Ashley uses. Oh, a couple of people I know use that.

SPEAKER_01Oh, people like us are starting to use that. Everybody's using that. Wait, you don't use that? And the thing itself may not have meaningfully changed anywhere along that trajectory. What changed was the social information surrounding it, the social cost of attendance to that thing, in this case, his app, changed. And eventually, in some cases, the social cost of not attending becomes higher than the social cost of attending. That too is fascinating to me because now participation itself is producing more participation.

SPEAKER_01Caring converts into attendance. Attendance becomes evidence for somebody else's attendance. And eventually the people become proof of the proposition. And think about it like a Birkenbag, right? We think about a Birkin. Because by the time a social object gets to that level, the Birkenbag level, there is an enormous stack of agreement underneath what looks like a very simple object, a very simple, very expensive object. First, we agree that the object signifies something.

SPEAKER_01Money, status, luxury, access, whatever. Then we agree that the person who possesses that object possesses or at least has some proximity to those qualities. Those qualities being money, status, luxury, access. Then we have another set of agreements about how people who possess those qualities are socially perceived.

SPEAKER_01And then when I find out that you have the object, I can resort you into my internal social map. All from a bag. And you don't even have to care about Birken for that mechanism to work. You can think they're ugly, you can think they're ridiculous, you can think spending that much money on a purse is obscene, but you probably still understand what somebody's trying to communicate when they carry one. Right. That is an extraordinary level of social consensus.

SPEAKER_01And I say social consensus here and not the the term that the creator used of everybody cares, right? Because here we're defining care by attendance, and not everyone is carrying a burden, but everyone is picking up the signal, right? Social consensus is still doing what it needs to do. Which brings me back to Dear Sovereign Self because there's something happening in my own data that I've been thinking about for a while, I guess for you know, these past many months.

SPEAKER_01When people find this show, they seem to listen deeply. Like deeply. Like people go backwards through the catalog, which is cool at like episode seven, but we're in the mid-50s. And I am, you know, very grateful to the universe that I have people starting in the 50s and going backwards through the catalog.

SPEAKER_01They listen to episode after episode after episode, and while that feels great, what I don't see anything resembling the same rate is sharing. And I want to be really careful here because I can't look at podcast analytics at this stage, and maybe not at any stage, but not at this stage, and tell you why a human being did not share something, right? Like that's not information that's available to me.

SPEAKER_01I don't know. But I have a hypothesis that I find interesting, and I was reminded of that hypothesis as I was listening to this creator talk about his own dilemma, and I guess the builder dilemma of build it and then they will come, right? And and what happens in that gap in between. So my hypothesis about dear sovereign stuff that I find interesting as I look at this data is what happens when the material itself resonates, but identifying with the material is expensive.

SPEAKER_01Because listening to Dear Sovereign Self privately is one thing. Sharing an episode called Cut the Strings is another thing. Sharing, are all sovereign people broke, is another thing. But sharing, can I borrow$20 is another thing. Because now I haven't just consumed something, I've potentially told the people around me, this is how I think, this is something I'm wrestling with, this describes something happening in my life, happening in my personhood.

SPEAKER_01So there is a difference between building something people want to consume and building something people are willing to be seen consuming. And sometimes the more accurately your work names somebody's private reality, the more expensive it becomes for them to publicly identify with it. Which creates this really interesting kink in the growth of the thing, because the exact thing that makes the work useful may also make one of its strongest potential distribution channels expensive.

SPEAKER_01And maybe Dear Sovereign Self is a luxury product because it's expensive to associate with. Anyway, but this is where Dear Sovereign Self becomes a slightly weird example because Dear Sovereign Self can solve problem A in isolation, right? You can find this podcast, you can listen to every episode I've ever made, you can continue to listen to every episode I will ever make, you can take whatever language is useful to you, you can change something about the way you think, you can change something about the way you live.

SPEAKER_01You never have to tell anybody you are here. You probably won't. That's what the data is telling me. You probably won't. And if a hundred thousand people do that every week, we have a very successful podcast on our hands. Problem A has been a very high value proposition all by itself. But I think there is a problem B that this work is uniquely positioned to solve. Because the real call to action underneath Dear Sovereign Self has never been think more.

SPEAKER_01It isn't even agree with Ashley. The call to action underneath all of this work is convert thought into action. Take whatever is useful here and commit to building a life that is actually lived according to these principles. And if that's true, right? If that's true, that that has always been the underlying belief, and it is as a creator, it is, then eventually I have to become interested in the world where that life is possible.

SPEAKER_01Where do I safely encounter the other people who think this way? Not even because I need to talk to you about sovereignty. I don't need to have a book club with you, right? I just want people in my world who have made some version of the same agreement, people who are trying to live under the terms of the same manifesto, citizens of the ideology. But they're still the original problem of who all gonna be there.

SPEAKER_01Okay. And I can tell you I'm building a world for people like you. And you can say, okay, but are the people like me actually there? So back to the original dilemma, the original question that I'm chewing on today of what happens between when nobody cares and when everybody cares. And I want to be careful with how I land this because I don't think the sovereign lesson here is be a first mover.

SPEAKER_01Right? Like my angle isn't as the sovereign person be the first to down the lift, like by all means down the lift t today, 15 years later. Like I I don't care. There's no medal for getting there first. I don't think sovereignty means being immune to social information, right?

SPEAKER_01I don't think it means not caring what other people think either, which I've said ad nauseum. And I definitely don't think it means deliberately choosing the weirdest, least popular option available just to prove that nobody can influence you. That is still being controlled by the group. Um, you're just doing it in reverse. But I do wonder if the sovereign person has a different calculus here too, as I contemplate this problem, because we're still solving problem A and problem B, right?

SPEAKER_01Problem A is does this work for me? Does this app, in his case, work for the problem it's designed to solve? Does this solve something for me? Do I find this useful? Do I find this beautiful? Does this make my life better? Right? And problem B, what does choosing this do to my belonging? What does it communicate? What will people think? Where does it locate me socially? And if you've been listening to this show for any amount of time, we have been dealing with problem B bit by bit, right?

SPEAKER_01How do you eat an elephant? So we've been dealing with problem B bit by bit. What does belonging cost to you and how much authority does the group get over your choices? Sovereignty doesn't eliminate the social cost from the equation. It changes how much authority that cost gets in the calculation. So, no, being sovereign doesn't mean you have to care first. The sovereign is neither first mover, last mover, doesn't even matter which number mover they are.

SPEAKER_01They are the community members most calibrated to weight problem A more important than problem B. Does that make sense? They are most likely to review the utility of the solution than they are what the solution communicates about them socially. And so thinking back to the creator who is building his app, sort of lamenting that nobody cares.

SPEAKER_01Nobody cares until everybody cares. Except now I don't think the distance between those two things is just awareness. It isn't nobody knows this exists, and then everybody knows this exists. Somewhere in the middle, information becomes identification. Identification becomes attendance. Attendance becomes social information. Social information makes attendance easier for somebody else. Shared meaning starts accumulating, the thing becomes legible.

SPEAKER_01And eventually, enough people are participating in the universe that the universe no longer needs its original builder to personally explain why it exists. Other people are carrying the meaning. So I'll leave you with this, and this one's gonna be simple. Where do you think happens in that space between nobody cares and everybody cares about a new product, a new person, a new anything?

SPEAKER_01Let me know.

SPEAKER_00We'll close the page here for now. Until next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Fate and Free Will

    Nov 16, 202612 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail If something is destined to happen, why would you need to force it? Why rush, manipulate, or compromise yourself to secure an outcome you believe is inevitable? This week, we’re reconsidering the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Visibility 101: Zetsu

    Nov 10, 202619 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail I’ve spent decades learning how to turn my light down. And while I’ve had some spectacular seasons at full wattage, I’ve realized that reaching those higher settings and sustaining them require two very...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. In What World?

    Nov 3, 202610 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail We’re all preparing our children for the world. But what happens when we realize we’re not all preparing them for the same one? This week, I’m questioning what preparation entails.

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. You Can See Most Things

    Oct 26, 202624 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What does it actually take to be trustworthy? And why do we sometimes trust people who give us every reason not to, while remaining suspicious of people who’ve done nothing to deserve it? This week, I’m...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Gaps in Your Resume

    Oct 20, 202616 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Not everyone who leaves your life is eligible for rehire. And sometimes, the position they once occupied doesn’t even exist anymore. This week, we’re borrowing a little language from corporate America...

    Credit the people on this episode