#113 - Tired of High Tax Bills? Bitcoin Could Be the Answer! πΈ βΏ
54 minAudio
Join Matthew's Crypto Collective community for FREE and kickstart your crypto journey! How to retire early & wealthy, how to navigate crypto, how to convert your Super to Bitcoin and expert strategies from a multi 7-figure investor: π https://www.skool.com/matthewfraser In this episode of Crypto Collective, host Matthew Fraser welcomes Simon Ho, the SMSF Head at Coinstash, to discuss the intricacies of self-managed super funds (SMSFs) and their role in cryptocurrency investment. Simon shares insights on the challenges of finding knowledgeable financial advisors in the crypto space and the importance of understanding the legal and tax implications of incorporating crypto into an SMSF. The conversation also touches on the pressing topic of unrealized capital gains tax, making this episode a must-listen for anyone looking to navigate the evolving landscape of crypto investments and retirement savings. Disclaimer: This video is for general information and educational purposes only. It is not financial, legal or tax advice. Neither Matthew, Simon nor Coinstash holds an AFSL, and none of them is providing financial product advice. Simon is sharing personal views only and is not recommending or endorsing any financial products or strategies. Nothing in this video considers your personal circumstances. Always seek advice from a licensed professional before making financial decisions, especially regarding SMSFs or crypto. π COINSTASH: #1 Australian Crypto Exchange for your SMSF Sick of your super sitting in stale shares and managed funds? With Coinstash, you can take control of your SMSF and invest directly into crypto. Get $100 free Bitcoin when you open a new SMSF account: π https://coinstash.com.au/auth/signup?a=cryptocollective π COINSTASH: #1 Australian Crypto Exchange for personal use Just getting started? Open a personal Coinstash account, make your first deposit, and youβll get $20 in Bitcoin to kick things off. π https://coinstash.com.au/auth/signup?a=cryptocollective π π£π₯π’π§πππ§ π¬π’π¨π₯ πππ§ππ’ππ‘ - ππ₯ππ ππ’π‘π¦π¨ππ§ππ§ππ’π‘! Stop worrying about the security of your Bitcoin and let the cyber security experts, The Bitcoin Way, take the stress away. Book a free 30-minute consultation here: π https://bit.ly/TheBitcoinWay-Schedule-a-Call π πͺπ’π₯π πͺππ§π π¨π¦. Collabs, sponsorships, and cool stuff, hit us up at: hey@vibezcreative.com Avoid fakes- Follow the βrealβ Matthew Fraser: https://www.instagram.com/immatthewfraser/ https://www.tiktok.com/@immatthewfraser https://www.facebook.com/immatthewfraser/ https://x.com/MatthewFra87388 https://bit.ly/MatthewFraserLinkedIn Follow Simon: https://www.linkedin.com/in/simonhocs/ Timestamps: 00:00:00 - Introduction 00:00:33 - Host Introduction and Guest Welcome 00:01:46 - Benefit of professional advice on SMSFs 00:02:26 - Cryptocurrency Exposure in SMSFs 00:03:13 - Long-term Investment Strategy with Bitcoin in SMSFs 00:04:15 - Volatility and Long-term Holding in SMSFs 00:05:15 - Trading Bitcoin within SMSFs 00:06:21 - Risks of Trading and Long-term Holding Benefits 00:07:18 - Bitcoin Exposure in Superannuation 00:08:07 - Combining Industry Super Funds and SMSFs 00:09:35 - Typical Journey to Bitcoin Investment in SMSFs 00:10:58 - Financial Pressures and Superannuation as a Capital Source 00:11:44 - Importance of Insurance in SMSFs 00:12:47 - Professional Advice and Administration in SMSFs 00:13:41 - Challenges with Financial Advisors and Accountants 00:14:57 - Education and Self-learning in Cryptocurrency Investment 00:16:03 - Personal Journey and Distrust in Financial System 00:18:22 - Financial Advisor Limitations and Self-education
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
It's one of the few ways in which you can get exposure to cryptocurrencies. You cannot buy Bitcoin or cryptocurrencies in your traditional industry If I wanted to get Bitcoin exposure in my portfolio and I go to speak with a financial advisor, 9.9 times out of 10, the financial advisor will turn you away. Not all accountants are crypto savvy. What a financial advisor can advise you on is whether or not a self-managed suit fund is the right vehicle for you. What they can't advise you
I'm Matthew Fraser. and this is Crypto Collective. After making millions with Amazon and e-commerce, I realized that if I was starting again today, crypto would be my first choice. I'm here to help you take your first steps and build real wealth. Ready to set yourself up for life? Let's go. Hey Simon, well thank you so much for joining me on Crypto Collective. It's really great to have you here. I appreciate you taking the time because you've got all this experience, you are a lawyer, you've got a law degree, and you've also got a tax degree,
I would say. You're a tax specialist. Yeah, the two evils. The two evils. But this is not going to be a boring conversation. Because people will think from the outset, ah, law and tax, we're going to switch off now. No, this is going to cut to the core of a lot of topics that are happening right now, including I'm going to drop it, unrealized capital gains tax, we're going to touch on that. And I also want to talk about, of course, SMSF, why it's important for people. Of course, you know that all of my SMSF carries
Bitcoin, so that's going to be a big topic as well. So I guess starting off, Simon, why should people have an SMSF or why should they consider an SMSF as a part of their, I guess, Yeah, I think self-managed super funds Do give people a lot of control definitely, it's not a Light decision to make when you set up a self-managed super fund or you if you want to set up one up Definitely need to get professionals involved see a professional advisor or
a tax agent to help you get set up properly so then you can Worry yourselves about the investment decisions as opposed to all the housekeeping of bookkeeping, but definitely SMS F's do give people more control It's one of the few ways in which you can get exposure to cryptocurrencies Yes, I think that's a big ones So I'm just let's just expand that for one second because people who watch who are new to this They may not realize this and that is that You cannot buy Bitcoin or cryptocurrencies in
your traditional industry super fund, right? You can only That's correct. Not many retail or industry super funds that I'm aware of have Bitcoin on their approved product list. So if you want Bitcoin exposure in your retirement portfolios, then a self-managed super fund I talk about Bitcoin all day, every day. Tell me, I guess, or to the viewers, why should people consider having
Bitcoin in their superannuation portfolio? Yeah, that's a really good question. So if you consider Bitcoin as a long-term investment a super vehicle like a self-managed super fund is meant to be for long-term investments and Also, I'm not sure many people know this is when she reach a certain age and Any profits or gains in your self-managed super fund to become tax-free? So especially if you think that because gonna go from no hundred and hundred K us it
is right now to maybe 500 or a million dollars depending on who you listen to or even if it's 150 K as a modest Price and that's this cycle though, right? I don't know. We don't know, but that's the talk, right? Exactly, that's the thing. With super, with self-managed super funds, you can take like a 10-year, 20-year, 30-year time horizon. Over time, those lumps, those bumpy moves should even out and go in the direction that you think it will. So,
A self-managed fund helps people be more disciplined so then and trade those ups and downs and chop themselves up in terms of you know gains and losses and just just to pull you up there what you were meaning then is if people expose themselves to Bitcoin Bitcoin traditionally has some volatility and while it's in an SMS F fund or some vehicle as you put it and there's less likely they're going to try and time the tops and the bottoms of the market that is going to hold it for the foreseeable future,
essentially let's say until they get to, is it called preservation age? Yeah, So yeah, it forces people to take a long-term view on the assets that they're investing in. Because you can't take those assets out. You can't sell it to cash and then take $5K, $10K out. You actually have to think about what 20, 30 years down the track, depending on how old you are, where the asset's going OK. That's interesting. So what you're saying
then, Simon, is that if you have Bitcoin, we'll just talk about Bitcoin as opposed to all cryptocurrencies, If you hold Bitcoin and you think that it's a peak in the cycle, let's say it gets to 150 and you think, you've done some research and you think this could come back down to 100, are you saying that you can't sell it at that point and then keep it in, for example, a stable coin within your SMSF, or you just have to You can. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, there is a, you can sell, but you can trade, so to speak, in a self-managed super
fund. But because it is meant to be a retirement vehicle, the sole purpose of setting up a self-managed super fund is for your retirement. then Naturally, it just forces people to take a more long-term view as Because of course that comes with more risk. Correct? Yes. Yeah, and I guess the the the least riskiest thing to do Yeah, and something like 80% to 90% of
people who trade end up losing money. And there is asset guidance out there that says, particularly for CFD providers, that somewhere between 60% to 70% of people who use CFDs, which are very similar to perpetual futures. What's CFDs? CFDs contract for differences, right? So 70 60 to 70 percent of people who use CFDs or trade CFDs end up losing money So that's why CFDs which are very similar to perpetual futures Very Yeah, I guess the same thing can be said to like if people have money in an industry super
fund They're not watching what their allocation is every day and selling it trying to tell it sell at tops and buy back in the bottoms, right? So it's the same kind of of mindset, right? Yeah. I think sometimes the Yeah. And just sit and hold. Yeah. Now, I say at this point, Simon, that the risk for people right now is having no exposure to Bitcoin. Now, I have an online community. I show people how to move from an industry super fund to
an SMSF. Not that I'm a tax advisor or a financial advisor or anything like that. It's just that I just show them the steps that I took. And then it's up for them. I actually show them where to go and find the guidance, where to go find an accountant, where to go to find financial advisors to help them on that journey. Now, what we found though is that there's different ways to structure this as well. So just explain to me too, would I be okay if I was to say, look, I want to keep a portion of my funds in an industry super fund and take a portion out
There are some people who do that and there are pros and cons and I definitely think the best advice I can give is to see someone who can have a holistic view of your financial affairs and your goals. Because, for example, and this is not advice, but for example, it may be sometimes worthwhile to leave some funds in the industry superfund because of the insurance policies that are there. And one of the things you need to consider as a self-managed superfund is whether or not to have insurance. So
there are a lot of complex... It's So Simon, for someone who, I guess, is not fully committed to Bitcoin, but maybe they're thinking, I need to have some exposure. I've got an industry super fund and I want to maybe pull 20 to maybe $50,000 out of that industry super fund into an SMSF and then expose that to Bitcoin, right? Would that be a legitimate step,
you would say? Because I also note that sometimes you've got to bring through your other half, whether it be your husband or your wife or what have you, right? Because sometimes when you're on the journey yourself, you get the conviction, right? Because I know in my personal journey, there was a point where I said to my wife, baby, we're going to move all of our super to Bitcoin. Now, that wasn't day one of me learning about Bitcoin. I didn't just watch a YouTube video like this and just say, that's it. All of it's going. It was a progression. In fact, the way it
started was my first purchase was probably, I think, $100 in my personal name. But then very quickly, I decided to use a lot of my company funds and set up a company account. And then it probably was about a year, I would say, at least, maybe 18 months of doing a lot more research, me putting money into the investment, that I then said, OK, I'm now ready to move over into Bitcoin, my industry super fund. And of course, by that stage, my wife had sort of followed along
the journey as well. So I'm sharing the information with her, right. I'm just interested from your side of things, the sort of clients that perhaps you might know of and their journeys and how it sort of plays out. And is that taking a portion out of the industry super fund, if you don't have full conviction like me, a legitimate method? That is a very typical journey that I see. So people, they've purchased crypto in their personal names, a company vehicle or a trust vehicle or even in their business. And then
I don't want to bet my house on Bitcoin. So they're saying they don't have Yeah. So it could be because with living pressures these days, rent, mortgages, school fees, electricity prices, all things going up, people actually have less disposable income these days. to invest in crypto unless you're a very high income earner. So naturally, if you don't want to bet the house on it, then naturally people think, oh, where is the next pool of capital that I have? And usually super, whether it's
in a self-managed super fund or an industry or retail fund, super generation is typically people's second largest asset that they have. So people's minds start to turn towards okay How else can I get exposure to Bitcoin and naturally people think about super when they get to that stage? So your story is Yeah, I did see as an unfortunate people should just listen to this very carefully because this is so important you touched before Simon on insurance and And unfortunately, someone that
I know, what they did was they moved their industry super fund for the husband, kept the wife's in the industry fund or the retail fund, as you would call it, and moved it all over to Bitcoin. Now, they realized at that point, though, that any insurances involved in the industry fund were now finished because they closed that account. They failed though to re-insure outside of that fund within their SMSF or even just personally, because you can do it personally as well. And
unfortunately, what happened was they knew to do it, but they kicked the can down the road a bit. And unfortunately, that person had a very serious medical condition, which actually has put them out of work. And so I think it's really important just to tell people that this is something that's going to happen. And to take action on it because you never know when things might happen. You know, don't kick the And when it comes to sub managed super funds, people are very headstrong. They see an asset they want to buy. It's like, I just want to buy it. And they're going to
use the self-management fund to do it. They'll make it happen. So that's why it's so important to balance that headstrong attitude, mindset, with someone who can take a step back, professional advisor, a tax agent, or a special assessments administrator. They can take a step back and say, hey, have you considered this? Have you considered insurance? Have you considered these other aspects? To be honest, administration and all the intricacies involved in managing your own super is an afterthought. And
it shouldn't be because in that situation with your friend or your acquaintance, it can have quite unexpected consequences, especially if they dive heads first without seeking So tell me then, because I've had other people come and talk to me about, you know, seeing a financial advisor or they went to their accountant and said, I'm going to set up an SMSF and I want to buy Bitcoin. And the accountant says, oh, that's a terrible idea. You shouldn't you
shouldn't touch that. Now, I would say that that's probably because the accountant doesn't know what they're talking about. And I don't want to broad brush all accountants, because I've got a very good accountant who actually has his own Bitcoin and crypto portfolio as well. So when I talk to him about this, it's like another day at the office. But there are people who are still, I think, stuck in the olden days, don't realize that cryptocurrency, and particularly Bitcoin, is here. It's here to stay. And therefore, they're actually doing their clients a disservice. So
what should people do then, Simon, if they're listening to this video, And they're like, you know, I'm gonna go set up an SMSF and expose a portion of my funds to Bitcoin and they go to their accountant or or a financial advisor and they and They're given a very negative message This is a huge problem in the industry if I wanted to get Bitcoin exposure in my portfolio anyway my portfolio and I go to speak 9.9 times out of 10, the financial advisor will turn you away. Because
I don't want to touch it, my insurance doesn't let me advise on it, so please go see someone else. What that means is that people who actually want advice, they're out there on their own. So they have to go to find their own accountant, find their own Education find their own material and sometimes that material is not from a reliable source, right? so I think the best thing to do for someone who's being turned away from the furniture advisor or Can't find the right person is to Really
read up and just educate themselves. There's lots of education courses out there around self-managed super funds there is a lot of information out there on the ATO website and There's a lot of information just by speaking with accountants. But you're right, not all accountants are crypto savvy. And I think that is something that a lot of industry bodies in Australia, accounting industry bodies in Australia, should really get on the bandwagon, I suppose, is to really upskill the
I'll just share with you a story, Simon. My next door neighbor, who's in my commercial property, About a year ago, they were setting up an SMSF, and they went and bought, like most people thinking, I'm going to buy property. So they went out and bought two residential properties. Now, side note, I would never buy a residential property for investment ever again. I would delete that. And people are going to be like, what? This is the Australian way. I won't go into it, but I would never do that anymore. I may still consider commercial,
but I'm even selling off my commercial properties now and putting more into Bitcoin. But this is what they did. They bought two residential properties. A year down the track, I spoke to her literally on the weekend. She says, Matthew, it has been a nightmare. And I thought, oh, geez, what happened? And I remember at the time, I'd also spoken to them about Bitcoin. Now, they were new to Bitcoin, so I wasn't expecting them to just run out and start buying Bitcoin in their SMSF. But I sort of planted the seed and showed them where to go to find some information. She said, it's been a disaster. One of the houses OK, the
second house, tenants not paying rent, trashed the property. They can't kick them out. She's been to court. There's all these things. And I'm thinking, jeez, you don't have that with Bitcoin. You don't have that. And so she said, I said, actually, what happened with Bitcoin? She said, look, we went and saw our accountant. And he's an older guy. And he sort of just said, do not touch Bitcoin right it's bad, you know, he doesn't know anything about it now in hindsight the property was actually the bad decision Right, but he didn't advise them not to go buy the
property, you know, so I think it's really important that people get advice by people who are just educated in the space even if someone's educated and says I think the right approach Simon would be it's a volatile asset as long as you know what you're getting into maybe if you if you're new to this only allocate a portion of your super not the entire amount unlike me That might be the way to go. So where else can people go and find then, Simon? I mean, yes, they can come to my online community and
I've got guides there. But I'm not a financial advisor and I'm not sitting down with people looking at their finances, right? Who can they go and see? Do you know of people particularly that they can go and see who can give the right advice on crypto? On Crypto and Bitcoin. And Bitcoin. That's a really good question. For me, my personal journey is that I was self-taught. Right, OK. Self-learned. And I actually do think that is where most people currently get the information. And in
saying that, there is, sorry, I'll take a step back and say that investing in Bitcoin in your self-managed super fund or anywhere is a very personal choice, I think. What I'm trying to say is that unlike some other asset classes where you may rely on a financial advisor on price targets or they'd write a research report about Bitcoin, I still think these days When it comes to Bitcoin and the values and
the reason why it exists in the first place and the whole investment thesis behind Bitcoin, it really stems from a distrust of government. Yes. And the financial system that we currently have. So one of the Hallmarks of the current financial system is commissions So naturally you have people like advisors who are spruiking certain assets because they're commissioned exactly Yes, so behind that backdrop it kind of forces people to not listen to other
Yeah advice This episode is brought to you by CoinStash, the crypto platform I use for my SMSF. End of financial year is the perfect time to simplify your crypto super. CoinStash offers same-day setup, Aussie-based support, and access to Bitcoin and over 1,000 digital assets. Right now, CoinStash is offering up to $200 in Bitcoin when you make the switch and make a deposit before end of financial year. It's simple, compliant, and 100% Australian owned and operated. Hit the link in the show notes and book your free call with
the CoinStash SMSF team today. Back to the episode. I did this video recently and it got a truckload of views. And what I did, I got on the video and I said, this is on one of my social media channels, and I said, listen, you're supposed to actually go see a financial advisor about whether you're going to invest in Bitcoin. Now, whether that's to do in SMSF or not, right? And I said, why would I go and see a financial advisor? Now, I'm obviously doing very well, I'll put it that way. I'm trying to be modest. And when I'm going to go see this financial advisor who's probably making like a hundred grand a year, he's
struggling to pay the bills as well. Like he can't afford the mortgage and he can't afford to put kids through school. And he's going to tell me about finances and how I should allocate my investments. I said, no freaking way. I'm not going to listen to them, right? But I also believe in taking responsibility for your own actions. which is kind of what you touched on before is that you got to do your own research and understand it. I'm going to put a caveat in there though, Simon, is that some people are not financially savvy at all, right? So they would, they
kind of need the financial advisor You know fools, you know because otherwise they would just they would just go bankrupt because they just simply don't know what they're doing Right, and I put myself in a category of I feel like I have more announced than the than the average Joe, right? so So exactly exactly and and if you if you don't feel confident if Perhaps, like you said, it makes sense to limit
your exposure to the risk by only putting a portion, a small amount into something that... What about though, this is another question that comes up, you know, you go set up an SMSF and they say, look, you're only going to put $50,000 in it and it might be all exposed to Bitcoin, right? And they say, well, it's not going to be worth it because the fees are going to outweigh the return. When you're setting up a self-managed super fund, you do need to consider the fees. So if
you have 50 grand or 100 grand or something in that vicinity, that's what I call like a low balance. Yes. SMSF. Because The average is? The average Self-Managed Superfund balance per Oh, Self-Managed Superfund balance. Not superannuation balance like a retail or industry. Yeah, yeah. Self-Managed Superfund Got it. So the 50 to 100 K is on
this on the lower end of that and I Think the main if I can talk from a tourist attacks agent point of view. Yeah The main the main issue that the ATO has around these small balances is the fact that people are maybe tempted to take some of those funds out. Maybe you're... You mean for personal use? For personal use. So for example, like I'm short on my pay this week. Maybe I'll just take 5-10k out.
Actually, it's not fine. It's not fine. So We typically these smaller balances. It's from younger younger younger trustees or people who've Hasn't necessarily been in the workforce for very long for whatever reason So these are typically higher risk cohorts. Right. So particularly when it comes to $50,000 to $100,000, if you're paying, say, a $4,000 setup fee plus a $2,000 or $3,000 annual fee,
plus you're not getting the insurances that you would typically get in the industry retail super fund, I definitely think it's Take a step back and consider whether it is the right choice for you. And what a financial advisor can advise you on is whether or not a self-managed super fund is the right vehicle for you. But what they can't advise you on is whether crypto should be in it. Yes. Although I think I'm seeing some financial advisors start to turn
their minds towards this. But it's definitely 9.9 times Because I would be livid, Simon, if I had went to a financial advisor and said I want to expose some of my superannuation to Bitcoin and then 10 years later he said and they said no. And I said, oh, OK, well, you obviously know what you're talking about. And then 10 years later, I look back and think, you know what? That $50,000 I could have poured into Bitcoin is now worth $10 million. And he said not to do it. I would be pissed to do that. So
now that is a risk, I think, for the financial advisor. Because could you imagine the backlash? It'd Yeah, it would be. And advisors dislike being- Losing. Yeah. They do dislike that. But it's lost opportunity. They may have said, look, keep it in this fund over here. You're getting 10%, so shut up. But I could have been getting more over here. What would you say then, Simon, if you
do the numbers, and let's say you put $50,000 into this SMSF, you bought Bitcoin. And I understand some people are saying, look, the fees are going to be too much. But I think what's happened is they're only looking at the fees compared to what it would be sitting in if you were getting 10% on average, not if you're getting 50% on average in I do think when you set up a self-managed fund, you've got to think about what you want to invest in. And with any asset or investment, there carries risk. But
higher the risk, the higher the opportunity. And as we know, Bitcoin has very high volatility. So therefore, the risk of the upside plus downside is... But only if you sell. Yes. But you can't really sell in SMSF in Yeah, yes, but you may have unrealized losses. So for example, God forbid, if MicroStrategy gets liquidated or for whatever reason, they have to sell all the Bitcoin holdings and Bitcoin crashes down from like 100k
to 10k or 20k. I'm not saying that will happen. That's like a 90% loss in the self-managed super fund. And on someone who's who's got 100K, can they stomach a drawdown from 100K to 10K? And I don't necessarily mean to point out Bitcoin, but as you go on this journey, what people typically do is that they start with Bitcoin, they get a bit of interest, move to the altcoins, and then they go full risk on and say, oh, I'm going to go into this pump. Yeah, exactly. But then If
they still have capital when they go down that path, I guess people come back to Bitcoin at the end of the day. Right. I think that's what most people have done. But it is, particularly when it comes to self-managed super funds, it is something you Yeah. I mean, people ask me all the time, about whether they should buy altcoins. I won't call them shitcoins, I'll say altcoins in an SMSF. And I just say, look, what I've done, I don't expose any of my super to
altcoins. It's all Bitcoin. And you know what? I actually sleep with peace just knowing that it's sitting in Bitcoin. I'm not worried about any other altcoins because I've also seen, I guess, in my very short time in the crypto space, that altcoins, they come and go. They're not sort of all there and I always say to people There's no nation state or major institution. That's that's Falling over themselves to buy the fart coin, right? They're all buying Bitcoin. So what does that tell you? It tells you
that the asset and of course we know that Bitcoin is also now in the u.s At least considered a commodity not a security and of course the regulations around it, you know are all looking for Bitcoin so I didn't know that Simon that that people obviously are thinking about going more down the risk curve within their SMSF I sort of thought I guess I just think that people think like me so I'm just going to expose it to Bitcoin because why would you not though Simon? Bitcoin's already doing on average let's say 50% compounding growth
Exactly, exactly. And have you seen the chart of Bitcoin and the M2 money supply? Yes. It tracks it very closely. And if you do think that Bitcoin will follow that chart, M2 money supply is going right up at the moment. So perhaps it's a I think it is. Let me pivot this a bit because you mentioned before about Something which is I guess comes to the core ethos of of Bitcoin, which fundamentally comes from the distrust of
government institutions, etc. And I want to lead that into what we've now got on the horizon as far as a new tax policy, which is Labor's unrealized capital gains tax. Now, I've been known to call it a theft of retirement savings. Other people see it as a good thing, and they see that SMSF holders, and this has got nothing to do with whether you hold crypto or Bitcoin in SMSF, this is just in general. There's some people in the community that are saying, well, if you have an SMSF, you're bad, because
you're simply taking advantage of discounted tax rates yes within the within that but i would say you know for me let's say i i've just simply moved my super into bitcoin through an smsf now if it grows over time to i'm expecting it to be just based on 50 let's say or even 30 it'll be somewhere like 100 million plus dollars it'll be it'll be substantial probably more Why should I be penalized for taking the risk on Bitcoin? And others have
the opportunity, yeah? Why should I be penalized? It's not like I've actually put an asset that's worth $300 million into the SMSF, it's just that it happens to have just grown. So why would I be penalized? And maybe you can talk broadly about the unrealized Yeah, so I think the two main issues with the unrealized gains tax that are causing people angst is firstly, people who are most impacted by this, apart from the super wealthy and
We'll just stop you there. What is super wealthy? Is there a parameter that is defined by the tax office? No, okay, It's a perception. Yes, so it's relative to When So to me it means someone who's gonna be captured by this by this time Okay, so what we're talking about then is those who hold three million minimum in us in a SMSF Yeah, if just so, you
know, I know you know, but so others know if When this comes in July 1, I think it's going to be backdated to July 1, once it passes through legislation in the Senate, the Greens are pushing for a $2 million cap. So more people will be captured into this. But so let's just say that for today, super wealthy, which I don't consider super wealthy $3 million, but let's say that's I'm using that phrase, yeah, from the perspective of the people who are being upset about this. Yes. Sorry, not upset about this, but captured in tax. The
main thing is that it's a tax on unrealized gains. So what that means is if you bought the property, say, 10 years ago for 1.5 mil in your super fund, And over 10 years proper prices more or less double You've got maybe three mil or potentially even more sitting in your self-managed fund at the moment You're going to be potentially impacted by this tax Particularly if this property continues to grow into the future. So
for example, it goes to four mil or five mil and But the property is a very illiquid asset. You can't sell a brick. You can't sell half property. You can't sell a portion. You've got to sell the whole thing. So this unrealized tax component of it means that if you have a large illiquid asset, in order to pay your tax that's levied on the balances above 3 mil, or the earnings above, proportion of earnings above 3 mil, is that you've got to fund it either through more contributions,
savings, or you just go sell the asset. And some people don't want to do that, because perhaps they've bought their retirement home in their self-managed super fund. The second reason why it's causing a lot of angst is just from a tax policy perspective. I've personally never seen an unrealized gains tax. So it's always been realized. So even with capital gains, it's always about realized capital gains. If you're sitting on a 100k gain, that gain could dissipate in
two or three months because of something that happens. So while it just does not, to me, make sense to tax. or Correct me if I'm wrong, Simon. This type of unrealized capital gains tax has never been implemented in Australia at all, Not that I know of. I mean, you could argue, if you're a tax academic, you could argue that you have unrealized gains when it comes to shifting assets. Or rates. Rates. Sorry. I remember someone just
recently on one of my Social said rates could be considered an unrealized tax. You're being taxed on the value of Yeah. Yeah. Well one another example is if you moved assets from your personal name into a company name like a Change in the investment structure if you're sitting on an unrealized gains sometimes that transfer from your personal name to your company name could trigger a a tax on all those unrealized gains. It's good market value substitution. So I guess if you're
an academic, you can make an argument that there is a mechanism to tax unrealized gains, particularly in transfer between entities. But this is something totally different. This is taking a little bit step, in my view, a little bit too far and sets a Look, even Paul Keating has come out and he said he is and he was the instigator of superannuation Australia. He is opposed to it. Even he's saying this is the most ridiculous tax he has ever seen in the history of taxes. I want to know is that. Is there a way, and everyone's
going to be thinking this, is there a way that people can get out of this tax? Or can they minimize this tax, if you've thought about that? Obviously, the first thing is you can say, well, just don't have your assets go above $3 million. That would be a way to go. Is there anything else? Have you looked I still think that The super vehicle, whether it's an industry retail super fund or a self-managed super fund, is one of the most tax-effective vehicles that we
And can I say this, though? The reason why- Even with this 15- Even with the tax. 15% tax. The unrealized capital gains tax, right. And is it going to be at 15% or It's 15% on the proportion of earnings that are above, that are attributable to the balances above three mil. So for example, if you have a four mil balance in your self-managed super fund, the balance that's above three mil is one mil. So a quarter of your earnings gets taxed at
the, with the additional 15%. And what's important to say is that the 15% is, is a tax that's delivered on you individually. So it's not actually a tax on the super fund, it's a tax on you personally, but Yeah, okay. Look, I think it's an absolute insidious tax. It's a sinister tax. And I think it's going to really put a downward pressure on the economy. I think it will stuff things up, to put it
bluntly. I've heard that other countries like Sweden and Norway either did have a unrealized capital gains tax and have since removed it, or they still do have one. Any case it hasn't worked out. Well a lot of capital like capital flight out of the country to other jurisdictions other nations So what actually happened? I think it was Norway where they expected to have I'm just rallying off a number here five billion dollars worth of extra Tax revenue turned out they got negative 1 billion dollars of tax revenue because everyone just said look we're out of here Yeah,
we're just gonna take our capital elsewhere. I think I will say you are right that the SMSF vehicle or superannuation vehicle is still the best place to put assets for retirement, yeah, for taxes, if it's tax is concerned. The thing is though, I think why people are pissed off is because the governments for a long time now have tried to incentivize people
to put funds or grow a wealth of whatever that's done through bonds, through shares, through properties for retirement. And now what's happened is the government has said, this is the Labour Party right now, has said, well, if you've got $3 million in this fund, you are now considered rich. And therefore, we want to take from you. Now, as I said before, I consider it theft. If people want to go to my TikTok and join in the conversation there, they can do so. It's heated
stuff there, I can tell you. It's very heated. There are people that love it. There are people that love the fact that people who have more than them are getting taxed more and having part of their retirement savings stolen. And there are people there who are completely opposed to it, even if they don't have the $3 million of super yet. There was a study done recently. I can't remember the name. It was, I think it was a, it could have been a bank study. And it showed, or an industry super fund study, that showed that even people in their 20s now, by the time they get to their 60s, will have well over
$3 million in their super fund. So they will now be taxed because the tax is not indexed. So it's not increasing over time. And of course, if the Greens come in with their $2 million tax, then there's more people brought in. I want to say one more thing, Simon, before you finally say. The issue I see, too, is that this opens the door to more unrealized capital gains taxes. Because I think what the Labor Party is going to say is, you know what, we've got a budget that we've got to pay for all these unfunded promises and ongoing expenses, welfare,
et cetera, et cetera. And we have to find money from somewhere. So what we're going to do is because this tax has now been put through on super above $3 million, let's now drop it down to 2 million and then a year later let's now drop it down to 1 million and because their whole their whole mission statement is we have to make the system fairer right which is not trying to prop people up it's trying to bring everyone down to the lowest common denominator then my fear Simon you can comment on this after is it'll spread to um
Other assets are the vehicles now. Do I I don't think so. I don't think so I do find it funny or interesting that Apart from yourself. You're very early to call out the unrealized gains tax But apart from yourself and maybe a handful of others, but there was not too much media attention on this proposal from the government before the election. I think maybe it's because people thought
liberals were going to win and that Albanese didn't have a chance to get reelected. For whatever reason, maybe people got scared of Trump or whatever, and then the rest of the world wanted to balance it out. Who knows? I don't know. The fact that there's so much media attention now on this unrealized gains tax, a lot of people talking about it. You're talking about it again. I'm talking about it. The media is talking about it. Even some of the largest asset managers in the world, in Australia, sorry,
I've seen Jeff Wilson. Yes, Jeff Wilson. So if anyone who's listening, Jeff Wilson, go to his website. Is it Jeff Wilson Asset Management or something? Wilson Asset Management. Wilson Asset Management. Go to his website and Yeah. There's a petition against it now. So I still think the tax is going to go through Parliament, both the House of Reps and Senate, if I was a betting man. But what it means now is that now that there's so much talk about it, No one can really complain and say I didn't know about it. I didn't know how it applies I
don't know how it works. So if I got my tinfoil hat on I think this is all part of the Part of the government strategy to educate people about what this tax means how it works And it's working really well and people talking about it. So if that leads to further taxes down the road on shares or any or any other types of investments then I jokingly said the other day, Simon, that what happens now,
does the government, does Labour Party come in now and tax my unrealized death benefit? It's a benefit that I'm going to have, or my family's going to have, when I die. Right, so I haven't actually realized it until I die, so they come in and now put an unrealized gains tax on that. I mean, the whole tax is preposterous and I just think it really has to be shut down. I really think it's terrible, not just for people above 3 million, right? It's just terrible for everybody. For those people who have got, who have basically got maybe $50,000 in
their fund, they're equating people who have got $3 million or $5 million or $10 million to those who may have, you know, like a billion dollars, right? That's how they kind of think of it. If you've got a little bit more than them, it seems like a lot. Like if you've only got 50 grand in your account and someone's got 3 million, you think they're loaded, okay? But they're putting in the same basket as Elon Musk. When really, those who have three million are far closer to the guy who's got 50 grand. You know what I mean? And that's the issues. Let me change tack for a second and just ask you a little bit more about end
of financial year things. You're a tax agent, so you know, sorry, a tax advisor. And so what are some of the things that people can now do in the lead up? We're only very, very quickly coming to the end of financial year. What are things that I guess people maybe don't do, but they should do? How could they can minimize tax illegally this coming financial Yeah, that's a really good question I think with Bitcoin above 100k a lot of people if not everyone are sitting in profits so tax only becomes an issue if you're profitable if
you have gains and I'm sure maybe, you know, two years ago or in the middle of the bear market, people didn't care so much about tax because, you know, people weren't making And just before you continue, your rich man's problem, I love that. Before you continue, just clarify, is Bitcoin, does it have capital gains tax applied to Bitcoin or is there some other type Yeah, so one myth I do really want to dispel is that capital gains tax is not a separate tax. It's not a separate tax on
a particular asset class. It's not a separate tax under the tax code. What it is is just, it's actually Any gains from capital gain, your capital assets, get added on top of your marginal tax rate. So for example, if you're on 150 grand per year salary, and you make a $100 gain in your shares or Bitcoin portfolio, that $100k gain gets added on top of your $150, so your total income is $250. So the difference between
the 250 and the 180, which is where the marginal tax rate kicks in, the highest marginal tax rate kicks in, that gets taxed at the highest marginal tax rate. So one of the myths I do want to dispel is that capital gains tax is not a separate tax. Yeah. Is there capital gains discounts though, if Yes. So one of the unique aspects of the capital gains tax regime is that if you hold an asset for more than 12 months, you get a 50% reduction in
how much of that gain gets added into your income. So I think discount is a bit confusing terminology, but it is the Fisher terminology but actually what it is, it's a reduction in the gain that gets added to your income. So there's no specific tax for And of course, this is only going to apply to people within this financial year who have sold Bitcoin. Yes, it's what I want to confuse the two right I
want to say all this this unrealized couple guys This is just this financial Yes for people who have sold Bitcoin And now there will be a tax that will be applicable Correct and go back to your original question about how we can save how people can save tax first and foremost is Do you have losses from prior years? It's very tempting for people to, if you made a loss in years, like, oh, don't worry about it. I know I made like a 10K loss here, but I'm not going to be paying tax on it anyway, so
Why would they do that though? Is that because they don't know that they can reduce their Probably make sure like if you if I put up my phantom wallet with the where we trade meme coins I'm probably a bit ashamed of that as well Put ten grand and nothing nothing nothing's come out of it But it's actually really important that if you if you know, you've made a loss in prior years But it's not recording your tax return or you haven't disclosed to your accountant then go back and to
your accountant and say, hey, these are the records. I actually made a loss in prior years. So then this year, if you do plan on selling this year, then you can reduce OK. I've got another question for you because I know this is going to be on everyone's mind. They're sitting on altcoins. Altcoins haven't done too well in the past 12 months, basically. Not even for myself, I've got some altcoins sitting in my company fund, or my company vehicle, and a lot of them are red. I'm not ashamed to say, guys, some
of them are even negative 80%, right? Now, for me personally, just so everyone knows, The majority of my funds are in Bitcoin. Right, I'm talking like 80, would be probably closer to 90% of my funds. So when I've got altcoins, they were just like gambles and I knew that going in, okay. But the question is, Simon, should I sell those altcoins now, realize the loss, take it off my taxable income, Or should I just sort of sit on it and then hope for
Yeah, so unrealized losses have no use to you. If anyone's listening, you need to realize those losses. So I need to sell. Exactly. You need to sell those assets in order to trigger a capital gains event. And that crystallizes the capital gains loss, which you can then use to reduce your capital gains in the future or in the current year. So definitely, yes. If you're sitting on these coins and you don't think there's any hope that they'll go up in value, sell them. Crystallize the loss. Reduce your current year tax. If
Yeah, I guess if you do think that it will potentially have a revival, then you can consider buying back at a later stage. So yeah, there's nothing stopping you from buying back the asset after you've sold it. So I guess the point then is that if you want to realize a loss, reduce your taxable income, if you think that if the altcoin is never going to come back again, and you think now's the time, probably before this end of financial year would be a time to sell it, realize a loss, and
And when it comes to capital gains losses, they can only be used to reduce your capital gains. So if you've- Not your day job, essentially. Essentially. Oh, yeah. Okay, but you but you added on though for the When you're working, yeah Yeah, so it's it's it's one of those Ways in which the the tax laws gets you So I just want to make that clear to people listening if you've got a capital gain
The gain is added to your taxable income. Let's say your PAYG job if you're an individual and then you pay Tax on that portion overall, right? That's the short version. But if you make a loss, they don't say, well, you weren't $150,000 through your day job. You made a loss of $50,000. So now you only have to pay tax on $100,000. That's Oh, they've got us. It's not the most intuitive way
that the current law applies. But it is what it is currently. That that's why I think I think getting Getting really good tax advice. Yeah as well Here's another myth that I think people have is that I don't want to go to an accountant now This is regardless of crypto or anything, right? I just I don't think I want accountant to do my tax return because it's gonna cost like I don't have much of this these days It's like 500 bucks for an average one or something. Is it something like that? Yeah 500 Why
If you've made money in crypto in the last 12 months, and you've made a lot of it, and by I mean a lot, I don't mean like hundreds of millions, I mean even if it's like 100k, And you're sitting on unrealized gains. Or you've got a day job that's very well-paying and you want to reduce the tax that you have. Having a really good accountant, whether it's crypto or otherwise, can pay its own dividends. I'll give you an example. So, there
is a rule in the tax legislation that lets you roll over your gains from your individual trading or investing into a company and pays, essentially defer the tax. In order to utilize that, there's very specific But say for example, you're sitting on a million one million dollar So sorry 100k unrealized gain
on Bitcoin and you're trading in and out of it and you're you know, you think that you know, you can grow your 100k gain to 200k 300k 400k because you found this amazing trading strategy or this alpha that you have and Then potentially it's worth moving that trading into a company structure Because a company tax the company tax rate is somewhere between 25 and 30 percent depending on the type of entity resin individual name it can go as high as 47 percent including Medicaid levy So,
and there are ways to transfer your trading and your personal name into a company without triggering any of those intermediate taxing Yeah, yeah. Well, that's amazing. And I think basically what you're saying is you should spend the money to go see an accountant because ultimately they can save you money. So I just want to say we're running out of time. I'm going to have to get you back on another episode because there's so many other things I want to talk to you about, including
what's a really big topic right now. And this is probably coming off the back of unrealized capital gains taxes. Should we set up a bank account in another country and pay zero tax? Is it even possible? But I'm sure you can answer that into the future. I want to say, Simon Ho, thank you so much for joining me on Crypto Collective. It's been an absolute pleasure. And ladies and gentlemen, if you've got any questions for Simon or myself that we didn't cover today, put them in the comments, and we'll get to those later. And I look forward to seeing Simon in a future episode. Thank you, Matt. Thanks for having me. Cheers. Thanks for tuning in to Crypto Collective. If you've enjoyed this episode, the
best way to show your support is to leave a five-star review on Apple Podcast or Spotify and make sure to subscribe to the YouTube channel so you don't miss an episode. You can also find more of me at I'm Matthew Fraser on all
Build sovereign wealth, join Australiaβs Fastest Growing FREE crypto community π https://www.skool.com/matthewfraser π TAKE ACTION: Borrow against Bitcoin (no selling): https://learn.ledn.io/collective Australia's #1...
Build sovereign wealth, join Australiaβs Fastest Growing FREE crypto community π https://www.skool.com/matthewfraser π TAKE ACTION: Borrow against Bitcoin (no selling): https://learn.ledn.io/collective Australia's #1...
Build sovereign wealth, join Australiaβs Fastest Growing FREE crypto community π https://www.skool.com/matthewfraser π TAKE ACTION: Borrow against Bitcoin (no selling): https://learn.ledn.io/collective Australia's #1...
Build sovereign wealth, join Australiaβs Fastest Growing FREE crypto community π https://www.skool.com/matthewfraser π TAKE ACTION: Borrow against Bitcoin (no selling): https://learn.ledn.io/collective Australia's #1...
Build sovereign wealth, join Australiaβs Fastest Growing FREE crypto community π https://www.skool.com/matthewfraser π TAKE ACTION: Borrow against Bitcoin (no selling): https://learn.ledn.io/collective Australia's #1...