Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! What happens when our pursuit of understanding God begins to interfere with simply trusting Him? In this deeply personal episode of Crusade With Me!, Dave makes a confession. After reflecting on recent episodes, his spiritual journey, and decades spent studying theology, Scripture, Hebrew, and Greek, he's beginning to wonder whether his relentless search for answers has sometimes made faith more complicated than it needs to be. Joined by Kat, Dave reflects on their journey through different Christian traditions, the Lutheran distinction between Law and Gospel, and a powerful illustration from Pastor Alistair Begg about the thief on the cross. A dying criminal had no theological credentials, no impressive record of good works, and no answers to complicated doctrinal questions. But he had something far greater: the promise of the man on the middle cross. Together, Dave and Kat wrestle with some uncomfortable questions. Are we studying God to know Him better, or sometimes to maintain control? Can our desire for certainty become an obstacle to faith? And what happens when we finally accept that salvation is God's gift, not something we can earn or intellectually master? Drawing from Luke 23:39-43, Ephesians 2:8-9, John 5:39-40, and Mark 9:24, this honest, occasionally humorous conversation returns to one simple prayer: "I do believe; help my unbelief." Maybe faith isn't about having every answer. Maybe the promise really is enough. Crusade With Me! - The Truth Is Worth Seeking. Let's keep walking.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
I wanted to start this episode with, for lack of a better term, an apology. I actually listened to several episodes that we've done in the recent past, and too much of a good thing can still be too much, you know what I'm saying? And I feel like it got rather repetitive just because I enjoyed where we were at. And I had something
happen to me a week ago. I went to my one of my great, my great niece's weddings. And you, if you've listened to crusade with me from the beginning. And when I say from the beginning, I mean, going back to January of 2025. This great niece is the daughter of my nephew and niece
-in -law, I don't think that's a word, but my niece, she married my nephew, and she had a medical condition prior to us beginning this journey of crusade with me, and she's still recovering, she's still on that journey, but it's a blessing, and it was truly a blessing to watch her walk
down the aisle with her daughter on her daughter's day of her life to this point. And my nephew was the officiant for that ceremony. And my niece, my great niece had asked me to say the prayer at the reception for the food. She asked me if I would do it. And I said, certainly. And I said, are there any requests? And she said, you know,
yes, I would like to, you know, for there's a bunch of people that will not be there. great -grandparents and so forth. And her husband, now her husband's father had passed last year. And she said, but don't name anyone specific, just... And I said, oh, okay, I can certainly do that. She said, oh, isn't that, we trust you. I said, okay. I did a prayer and after the prayer,
I had written the prayer out. And after the prayer, I had walked over to the table where the bride and groom were and I handed that. the prayer that I had written out. And as I'm walking back to the table, my nephew stops me and says, did you notice that most of the ceremony came from crusade with me? And I had thought because Kat and I numerous times see things on social media
or read things on the internet that seems to consistently coincide with one of the proceed with the episodes either we've just done or did some previous time. And I truly thought that's what it was about. But when he said that to me, it struck me. And I won't tell you my first thoughts, but as I thought about that over the weekend, I thought I have to do a better job. So I've been a little introspective anyway. And so I
wanted to apologize to all the listeners out there about being repetitive. That's not my intent. And I apologize for that. And I've had some other thoughts. We'll get into those and I'll get to my confession. This is Crusade with me. Hello,
my queen. How are you? I'm super fantastic. We're having a lot of technical difficulty today. I can't hear anything in my headphones. Nothing at all. No, I can hear, I can hear in one side, and it happens to be the side that I think I lost most of my hearing in. So maybe I should turn the headphones around. So the bear, the
bear, the, the, the, the bear is the question, it's not your ear? Right. Okay, so is that better now that you've turned it around? You're pokey poking it? No, that did not help. During sound check I was singing you a lovely song. And I could only hear it in my left ear, which now I can only hear in my right ear. I went to the deep recesses of my mind. So I'm just relieved to know it's not my hearing. It's actually the headphones that I didn't lose my hearing in my
right ear because now I've switched my headphones and I can hear fine in my right ear, it's just there's nothing coming in my left ear. You're still playing. I'm not gonna fix it. Well, we're on me. No, no, we're on the air, right? Yeah, you're just where's our on -air sign? Right, right. I used to have one I taped it on the door when your mom with us remember Yeah, that's when we had all this in the bedroom That's true Boy
things have changed. We need to go back to that. Maybe no, we don't know we know this is much more comfortable. Yes And you fought me, tooth and nail on this, I don't know why, but I mean the day she moved out, we came back, our daughter had helped move her in, and man, we came straight home and her and I got busy. Right. Moving all of this in. Right. I mean, because our bedroom was a little crowded. It was, it was. And then I had my crusader, the Templar flag in there.
Flag, and it did not speak romance whatsoever. Oh, I find it very erotic, but anyway, that's me, a little goofy. But no, I've been doing a lot of thinking lately and look, we've been doing this for a year and a half, over a year and a half. Almost two. Almost two years. Now we took a break from January to May of this year. And
you did a different podcast. I took a break. You took a break. I took a little bit of a break and then I started another podcast and that fizzled even more so than Crusade with me ever fizzled. Yeah. And this is, I think this is truly my heart sitting here with you. And obviously this is something I have a lot more to say than I did talking about. I'm just not a very good life
coach. We've figured out a couple things in life. One is I'm not a very good pastor. We've tried that route, right? And we were not successful in planting a church. That is not true. In Flippin, Arkansas, and I'm not cursing, that's the name of the town we lived in. Flippin, Arkansas, home of the Ranger bass boats. They're boat boats. Used to... It was hard to get stuck behind a
holler, a semi -holler of Ranger boats on those winding roads. Correct, correct. But we are proud of that though. But I had heard something on the internet, and I had heard this before, and this is, and I'm going back years, decades. And I used to listen on the radio. Ooh, I got a little
twing in my. I heard the crackle. Yeah. I got a little, anyway, sorry. He's a pastor from Scotland. And I don't know if he lives in Scotland still. I don't even know if he's still alive. For some reason, I don't know. I should probably research that. Don't spread rumors. Yeah. You know me, asking questions. His name is Alistair Begg.
And I don't know what type of tradition he comes from, but he gave this very emotional rousing. And it wasn't Alistair Begg on social media. It was somebody else showing this old video, which I'm quite confident was VHS tape. of Alistair Begg giving the story that we can all read about
in Luke chapter 23. And I mean, I could read it. I don't know that we need to. Luke chapter 23 is Luke's rendition of the crucifixion. And in verses 39 through 43, that's the conversation that Jesus has. with what we have known to refer to as the Thief on the Cross. And Alistair Begg
gave a sermon and a great rendition and artistic creative license in expanding that story of the Thief on the Cross. And when he did, he talked about he wants to talk to the gate attendant
that was there at the pearly gates to receive the thief on the cross, to know how that conversation, how that dialogue went down. And I could only imagine, and I think he does a wonderful job, and he says, you know, well, we're glad you're here. What church did you attend? And the thief,
I didn't attend the church. Ah, okay, okay. Well, we don't need your baptismal certificate, but you were baptized. No, I wasn't baptized. Well, there's no test to get in, but I'm certain that you understand justification, right? And the
thief's like... I have no idea what you're talking about. And I could see the attendant be very, very confused. Perplexed, yeah. Like, I have to get my manager. Right. And the manager comes over and says, you haven't attended church, you're not baptized, you don't understand the doctrine of justification. How did you get here? And then
the thief says, the man on the middle cross said I could be here. And that made me think, that hit me. And especially me, because I spent a lot of years studying theology, comparing traditions, examining Greek and Hebrew, and occasionally
discovering that all of this searching has truly made it harder to trust a promise. And that's what we're talking about today, right? Trusting a promise. In the tradition that we follow, there is a term called law and gospel. And I'm embarrassed
that crusade with me has not been balanced very well, and we have given a lot of law. So that's made me think and wonder, what do I Why do I need, and there's scripture written to me. All
right, now read that shortly. There's scripture written specifically to me, but why is it that I want to know answers so deeply? I want to get the full embodiment of the story. I want to understand the Greek word or the Hebrew word so I can know.
So I've been wondering, is that about trust or control? Because when we talk about law and gospel, you know what the gospel teaches? It says, I cannot save myself. That's truly what the gospel
teaches. Ephesians 2, 8 and 9 says that for by grace you have been saved through faith and that not of yourselves, it is the gift of God. Let
me read the next one too, just because I... I wanna make my Lutheran friends happy. Not as a result of works, so that no one may boast. Right? And I wanna be clear, I'm not making this episode to say I am not, I no longer want to be Lutheran. That's not what I'm saying at all. I just truly want to spend some time and devote
some time on the next, and this episode is about my confession. But in the upcoming episodes, I want to commit a promise to all the listeners that I also want to be much more balanced between the law and the gospel. And Kat, I don't, you know, I was thinking about this too, driving home from work yesterday, and I was thinking, you know, about this episode and wanting to do
what we're doing right now. And I was thinking, you know, I don't want to apologize and then say, but, But here's my butt, okay? We talked about that last episode. Correct, correct. Maybe your why. It is absolutely my why. And you know this, but I'm just sharing this with listeners.
We did not grow up in the Lutheran faith. We grew up in a faith that was... really a Campbellites, we were Campbellites through the churches of Christ. And as adults living in a rural community, we wanted more for our children. So we left that tradition and went to a Christian church. And
we've talked about that at Langston on the 2025 episodes of Crusade With Me. And that evolved over time. still Christian church, however, it was much, to where it evolved into a praise band and so forth and assistant ministers or associate
ministers, I can't remember what their title was per se. A senior pastor, a senior pastor, praise band, music minister. Correct. And things fell apart tragically. And one of the people, you know, there's only a few men in my life that I consider to be my pastors. And Pastor Dave is one of them, and he was a senior pastor there.
And knowing, coming out of the tradition that we came out of, Pastor Dave is the one that introduced me to the Nicene Creed. Because he had us do that at a worship service, the entire congregation. one Sunday, and even though I was young and dumb, I was still inquisitive, so I had to research what is this Nicene Creed thing, because out of the tradition we grew up in, we knew nothing
about that. We had heard creeds, that we don't have creeds, I just didn't know what any of them were, right? And then there was Pastor Mike, who's actually been on Crusade with me, he was on the episode of From Scoundrel to Shepherd. See how God was weaving Lutheranism in our life. And we didn't even notice it. And then there was Pastor Jared, who was the Lutheran pastor
that catechized us. Okay, speed dial. It was the Evelyn Wood. And that was really our fault or my fault. It's not his fault. And I'm just glad he did. There was a time in between there, not in between, but we've generally always been
pretty involved in the church that we are members of. Matter of fact, you were a secretary to the pastors at the Christian church. And so you get to know all the dirty, when I say dirty, and I don't mean dirty dirty, but it's just business. that ended in church is business. Don't know how else to say that. There's no avoiding it. And it's just the less than, and then when you
get people with different motives. So anyway, it was a whole lot of gospel and no law, which is also seems to provide everyone with a lot of license, if that makes sense. So being raised, how we were raised, it was a lot of law and not a lot of gospel except the week of EBS. And then we left that and went to a lot of gospel and
not a lot of law until we settled in the Lutheran church and it's a little bit more balanced. That's how I see it. No, I think that was beautiful. I think that was, and you're right. So then I was thinking, well, let's just jump. because this is John writing to Dave McKee. John chapter five, verse 39, starting at verse 39 and 40.
And tell me this is not John writing to me. You search the scriptures because you think that in them you have eternal life. It is these that testify about me. This is Jesus speaking. And you were unwilling to come to me so that you may have. life. So as I read that this week,
that's why I hope. Has my study of theology, has my study of Greek and Hebrew, is it an issue of trust? Is it an issue of control? Is it an issue of faith? So Kat, do you think, my question
to you, I'm going to get you talking here so I can stop. Do you think I sometimes make my relationship with God More complicated than it needs to be I will say that you are an analytical person and I think things that are that deal
with feelings Give you the dick Yeah, that's accurate You 40 years at this right? You know me well, and I think that the gospel some of the You and I are yin and yang. We got the tattoos to prove it. True, true. And I think the Gospel, some of the things deal with feelings. The F
word, I know. And that's why I like to hang in the Gospels. But you are very analytical. And so do you abide there because of avoidance? I don't only you can answer that. I have my own I guess I could I could say Yes, that's what I was asking you. So yeah, I I I mean, I'm just
guessing sure but I my guess would be avoidance because you just Don't you avoid feelings? I mean that was Yeah, but I also know you love to study. I mean you like you like to find You like you always say do a deeper dive do it today. I mean I kind of like when I have a question I'm like Because you like to do that stuff, right?
I like to have answers. I just don't like to do the deeper dive so But I mean I think it's a great question I'm glad that you're because there's gonna be growth here Yeah But I think that it's, yeah, it'll be profitable for you. Again, the whole, what I was going to say earlier when you were talking about it is, you know,
the whole, one of the benefits of being Lutheran or the thing that was appealing, you know, is that there's, and that's hard because that's not about being Lutheran. There was nothing that we could do to earn Correct, correct. Our salvation. That's hard. I mean, that's hard. It is hard.
Exactly right. Again, that's not a tangible thing. Well, it also could, I understand what it, it doesn't do this for me, but I can understand people hearing that. And then their mind says, so I can do whatever. Right. And that's not true either. Correct. And that's the interesting balance.
Right. For those who, you know, want to do good things or do good works or stuff like that, that's not what's going to earn you. No. But a strong faith will produce those things. Right. Exactly. So, I do know of another scripture that popped into my head. Okay. And I think it's applicable here. And at least one portion of this scripture
truly speaks to me today, this mindset. I'm in the Gospel of Mark, chapter nine. And I'm not gonna read the entire, all of the text, but starting in verse 16, Jesus and the disciples see a large
crowd around them and some scribes, Pharisees, I'm assuming. The guys with the big tall hats. Are arguing with the crowd. And they're like, what's going on? And this one guy says, look, my son is demon possessed. He's mute. And sometimes
when the demon possesses him, it throws him on the ground and he foams at the mouth. And the man had brought the child to the disciples to exercise the demon. but they couldn't. So Jesus
says, Oh, unbelieving generation, how long shall I be with you? How long shall I put up with you? Bring him to me. He's talking directly to his disciples. They brought the boy to him and when
he saw him, immediately the spirit threw him into a convulsion. And falling to the ground, he began rolling around and foaming at the mouth. And he, Jesus, asked his father, how long has it been happening to him? And he said, from childhood. It was often thrown him both into the fire and
into the water to destroy him. But if you can do anything, take pity on us and help us. And Jesus said to him, if you can, all things are possible to him. who believes. Immediately the boy's father cried out and said, I do believe,
help my unbelief. And when Jesus saw that the crowd was rapidly gathering, he rebuked the unclean spirit and saying to it, you deaf and mute spirit, I command you come out of him and do not enter him again. I just want to focus on the Father's
reply. I do believe. Help my unbelief. And so that's what I'm confessing. I'm wondering, is that me? I have to study more. I have to do the deeper dive. I believe. Lord Jesus, help my unbelief. I think that has to be all our prayer. But that's
where I've been thinking. I don't know what you think. I think you're just thinking too much. Could be. I think you're thinking too much. I think you're just studying too much, questioning too much. Maybe just a little too legalistic. Well, that's what I don't want to be, right?
And we came out of legalistic tradition. Just trying to break every single thing down and... Again, I don't want to throw caution to the wind and say, it's a free for all. No, I get that. You know, that's the thing. I don't. But maybe it's just not as difficult as we are trying to make it. We as humans. Or in me specifically,
that's what I'm saying. That's why I asked you that very pointed question. Am I making this more complicated? Right. Because Jesus is trying to make it uncomplicated. Correct, correct. I mean, He took 10 commandments and turned it into two. Correct. Unlike the fish and the bread. Yeah. You multiplied. And I'm all for Jesus taking the lawyers and getting them out of business, but anyway. Anyway. All right, no thank you love.
So I must confess, I don't have all the answers and I probably never will, but perhaps the most important thing I can learn isn't another Greek word or another theological explanation. Perhaps it's learning to trust the words Christ has already spoken. Because when everything else is stripped away, the question is whether I understood everything about the man on the middle cross. It's whether
I trust his promises. And today, that's where I want to rest.
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Haunted houses. Demonic possession. Exorcisms. Voices from beyond the grave. For centuries, humanity has been...
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Better Than I Deserve - A Thanksgiving Conversation About Grace What if you've spent your entire Christian life...
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! What happened to the warriors of Christianity? When did following Jesus become something comfortable, convenient,...
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! What if the most extraordinary moment in Christian worship is the one we've learned to take for granted? What if...
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! What if the God you've spent your entire life believing in - or rejecting - isn't actually who you think He is?...