Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Crusade with Me

Crusade with Me artwork

Who Gets To Define God? Spiritual Not Religious

Aug 18, 202643 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! What does it really mean when someone says, “I’m spiritual, but not religious”? In Episode 175 of Crusade With Me, Dave and Kat explore one of the fastest-growing ways people describe their relationship with faith - and ask whether spirituality without something outside ourselves to define truth can eventually become a spirituality of our own making. This isn't an argument for religious labels or institutions. It's a conversation about truth, authority, community, surrender, and the difference between seeking God and creating a god who agrees with us. Can we be spiritual without being religious? Can religion itself become empty? And perhaps the harder question: Who gets to define God? Listen. Think. Question everything. The Truth is worth seeking.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

I'm spiritual, but not religious. You've probably heard somebody say that. Maybe you've said it yourself. And I'll tell you something. I understand it. Because organized religion has given people plenty of reasons to be skeptical. Hypocrisy, scandals, money, power. political rules, people

claiming to speak for God while behaving anything like the, or nothing like the God they claim to represent. So I understand somebody looking at all of that and saying, no thanks. I don't need religion to be spiritual. Fair enough. But I got a question. And it's not just for the spiritual.

Not spiritual -minded. It's for the religious crowd as well. It's for Christians. It's for atheists. It's for me. And it's for you. Who gets to define God? Hello, my queen. How are

you? Good morning, my love. I'm super fantastic. Makes me think of my itty -bitty pretty one. That's where it came from. You know, I decided God is... Like, I decide what's right and what's wrong. Right? That's what God does. So if I decide which teachings I'll accept, or if I decide which ancient traditions still matter, if I decide

which parts don't, and ultimately I decide which version of God I'm comfortable believing in, then I've got to ask myself something. Am I actually seeking God? Or have I created a God who answers to me? That's kind of the bigger question, right?

Yes. And preface, most of us, I don't want to interrupt you, I'm sorry. No, no, no. This is a pretty personal episode because we've been all over the map on this. We have a lot of thoughts. I could argue the both sides of this coin relatively easily, right? Well, we've experienced, we've

had a lot of experiences. Correct, yes, yeah. And so... We were so young to have all these experiences, you know, that's what blows my mind. Kind of like last night when you were telling me about that. fighter and you're like, you know, he's an old guy. So I said, well, let me, let me look him up. I don't know who you're talking about. I'm talking about Butterbean. Yeah, Butterbean. So I look him up and I said, he's 60. He's a

year younger than you. Oh yeah. He's a young guy. Isn't that funny when we learn the... how we're gonna regroup people or, yeah. Oh, you're right, that's right. But yeah, I mean, I do that a lot with, I used to think my grandfather was so old at different stages of my life and boy, he was a young man. For a lot of what you were

remembering, I know, I know. Yes, yeah, so. So we're continuing a conversation that started several episodes ago, really. We said reality doesn't change just because we don't like it. Then we ask if something could be true even if nobody believed it. Then we turn the question inward. What if I'm wrong? And now we have arrived

at something even deeper. If there is truth, And if I can be wrong about it, then there must be something outside of me capable of correcting me. So when it comes to the biggest questions, God, meaning, good, evil, purpose, how we should

live, What happens when we die? Who gets the final word? And that's what we're wrestling with today. Now, which religion is best? There's something underneath that. Who gets to define God? So let's

start by being fair. Because it's very easy for religious people to hear somebody say, I'm spiritual but not religious, kind of roll their eyes and dismiss them. I don't want to do that. There are reasons people have walked away from organized religion. Some have encountered hypocrisy. Some

have watched religious leaders preach one thing and live another. Some grew up believing church was mostly about following rules. Some have seen religion mixed with money, politics, power and control. Some have been genuinely hurt by people

who represented themselves as followers of God. So when somebody says, I believe there's something more. I just don't want organized religion. I understand the attraction. Actually, there's something encouraging. buried inside that statement. They're saying, I don't believe the material

world is all there is. And that's worth exploring. So let's explore that. I have been there. Absolutely. We have been there. I must speak for myself because I have made the statement and I think I've made that this statement I'm about to say on this podcast before that Religion is just a vehicle for my faith correct and I think that applies

to the The idea not exactly the same about being spiritual but not religious because churches have failed us personally correct from our youth to Right. Adulthood. Because as you say, men are fallible and that's who run the church. Correct. Right. For our personal experience. You're exactly right. So here's something I've been thinking

about. So when we say, and I say we because we have said this, we probably haven't used that exact phrase because it's been a trigger for me, but what exactly do we mean by spiritual? Right? So maybe I meditate. Maybe I practice breath work. Maybe I spend time in nature. Maybe I believe there's an energy connecting things.

Maybe I read the Bible. Let's get personal. Maybe I read the Tao Te Ching. All right. Maybe I'm Buddhist, Buddhism. I'm laughing at you reading my notes yesterday in the car. I won't go there. Well, your handwriting was very sloppy. I'm sorry. We were bouncing and you know how that works for me. Maybe astrology. Maybe manifestation.

Maybe I pray occasionally. Maybe I take pieces from several traditions. And I keep the things that resonate with me. Okay. But there is a question hidden underneath all of that. Who decides what gets kept? Me. And now things get interesting.

And you shared this, that we've been right here, right? For a variety of reasons. And in a variety of different congregations, Denominations. Mm -hmm. And I would add to that list, different television pastors on TV. Oh, yeah. And again,

who's in charge of deciding which one you resonate with. We're gonna talk about resonating. Yeah. And I'm headed here, right? But yes, so you're exactly right. And I always said if they don't open their Bible and preach from a Bible then they're not for me, correct, correct But there have been some that first of all look They're men they're human beings I Don't want to say

give them slack, but we've got to give them a little They're no different than us. They have chosen a different vocation That's all. However, knowing what they know, I'm assuming they know, and that is even not that our faith is not based on facts and knowledge only. It's not. So here's

some questions I'm going to throw out here for the listeners. that I want you to consider while you're listening to this. What do you mean when you call something spiritual? And here's another one. Where did your spiritual beliefs come from?

And to follow that up. Have you investigated them? Or do they just feel right? And here's the question I want everybody to just set with for a bit. What would your spirituality have

to say for you to reject it? Now I'll jump into that. You know, there's a phrase I just used and we've used it a couple of times. I've used this a lot in the past. I've heard this used all the time, right? The phrase, oh, that resonates with me. And there's nothing inherently wrong

with that. Some ideas strike us deeply. Some wisdom feels like we've known it our entire lives. I've experienced that. But there's a problem with residence. If residence becomes our test

for truth. Because a lot of things that aren't true can resonate with us. And lots of things that are true can make us extremely uncomfortable. Think about the last episode episode 174 What if I'm wrong? If my standard for spirituality

is simply I keep what feels true to me How will my spirituality ever correct me Suppose I read something that tells me to forgive somebody I don't want to forgive. That doesn't resonate with me. Suppose I'm told something that I'm

doing is destructive. That doesn't resonate with me. Suppose I'm told that I need to sacrifice something I desperately want. Nope, doesn't resonate. Suppose I'm told the problem here isn't everybody

else. It's you. I really don't like that one. So I reject it. And pretty soon, I've assembled a spirituality where everything I believe conveniently agrees with me. So think about what just happened.

I just, I started searching for something greater than myself. But I reserve veto power over anything that challenges me. Guilty. So it reminds me, I don't know where I first heard this. It was probably you preaching a sermon about the Ten

Commandments that talks about you shall have no other God before me. And at some point, we make ourselves, we break that commandment because we make ourselves God. Correct, correct. And that right there reminds me of that. So we become God. We're gonna talk about that. You're exactly right. No, that is exactly right. We will eventually end up back in Genesis chapter three, I think. I don't know how we can do this episode without

getting there. But I think you're right. I think I know you're right, as far as that goes. So it's not a conscious effort. That was a homily done several times, several years in a row following the one year lecture. So it's not a conscious effort, like I'm God, I'm this, I'm that. But the patterns and the behavior says that. Correct. Or makes it so. Well, and I want to be clear this is not as I said in the beginning this is

not just for the yeah I'm spiritual crowd only right? This is not It's for all the choices that all of us make a small ones The medium one is that they just stack about I mean, you're right Here's some more questions for the listeners and for us to ponder Does your spirituality ever make demands of you? Or does your spirituality

ever tell you no? Does it ever require you to change? And does it ever confront something about yourself that you would rather leave alone? And here's the big one. Can your spirituality ever tell you that you're wrong? Because if the answer

is no, what exactly are you worshiping? You got to do a little bit of John Cougar, Mellencamp. And I know he changed his name or whatever, but every time I... We don't like the word authority, right? It makes me think of the song, I fight

authority and authority always wins. I'm pretty confident that was John Cougar, right? I don't know. I don't think he changed his name. I think he dropped John Cougar, Mellencamp. I think he dropped it. Yeah. We like freedom, independence, choice. I'll decide for myself. That's very American,

right? But everybody has an authority. The question isn't whether you have one. The question is, what is it? Maybe it's scripture. Maybe it's science. Maybe tradition. Maybe your parents.

Maybe your political tribe. Maybe social media. Maybe your feelings. Sorry. I know my feelings. Maybe your experiences. Maybe your favorite podcast. Maybe it's simply I trust myself. But something

eventually sits at the top of the pyramid. Something gets the deciding vote. And here's where spiritual but not religious can become problematic. Not because meditation is bad. Not because ancient Eastern wisdom has nothing to teach us. Not because

everyone needs to belong to the same denomination. The problem appears when I become the final authority. I determine good and evil. I determine which teachings are legitimate. I determine which traditions are outdated. I determine which concepts of God I'm comfortable with. And whenever God disagrees

with me, God gets edited. Now, here's where religious people should probably stop feeling smug about now. Because we do this too. Christians can say the Bible is my authority. Until we get to the

part we don't like. Then suddenly we're remarkably creative. We explain, we rationalize, we interpret. We find somebody on YouTube who agrees with us. We find another church, another teacher, another translation, another explanation, anything except

considering. Maybe I'm the one that needs to change. I say that just to say, this isn't religious people good, spiritual people bad. It's something much I'm more uncomfortable. Every human being is tempted to create a God who agrees with them.

It's like picking out. Remember the magnetic dolls? You probably don't, but you had sisters. So it was like. You mean the paper dolls? No, but they had different characters. It was like a, it wasn't even magnetic, but it was kind of some kind of thing that stuck. But you had all these different outfits with this character,

or girl, boy. We were poor, so my sisters used the Sears and Roebuck catalog and cut the people out and used those. Okay, well what I'm thinking of is a little bit different. It had like a black. background and they just kind of stuck and you could peel them off but they were reusable. Anyways. Not related to scratch and sniff. No. Sorry. No. Anyways, so you could, you changed outfits and you picked a hat or you took a purse and

shoes and a skirt or jeans or a top and whatever. So it's like that's what we're doing with. I smell what you're cooking there. Yeah. So we're doing this with God. That's dangerous. That's your right. This is what we like. This is what we don't like. And you're right. And that's where this gets interesting, right? Because what we're talking about, this isn't a modern problem. There's

this ancient story about human beings being placed in a garden, right? Right. Most people know at least part of it. Adam, Eve, a serpent, a tree, forbidden fruit. And that's what we reduce that story to. God told them not to eat something and they ate it. But there's something much deeper

happening. The tree has a name. The name of that tree was the tree of knowledge of good and evil. Think about that. Good and evil. The temptation

isn't merely about fruit. It's about authority. Who determines good and evil? Does humanity receive that definition from God? Or do we seize the

authority to determine it ourselves? That's ancient. But tell me that's not modern. We don't need a serpent. We don't need a tree. We don't need forbidden fruit. We just need four words. I'll decide for myself. I'll decide what's good. I'll

decide what's evil. I'll decide what's true. I'll decide which God makes sense. I'll decide which teachings apply to me. And suddenly an ancient story doesn't seem quite so ancient. anymore. Maybe Genesis isn't describing something

two people did a very long time ago. Maybe it's describing us. Maybe that's the temptation every generation faces Not necessarily. I don't believe in God. Something much more subtle. I believe

in God. As long as I get to define him. Guilty. Well, just... like them chasing, Adam and Eve chasing the knowledge. They wanted the same knowledge that God had. So they could hold the power to

make the decisions. And that is us. As your favorite book says, there's nothing new under the sun. So that's why we are here. Sorry, what did I say? You just entered my favorite book. Oh, sorry, I didn't say it. Yeah, Ecclesiastes. So that is us. Exactly. That is us. We still want that knowledge, the same knowledge of God, to define Him, to be Him. Correct. Correct. And some tiptoe

to want to even not be obedient to Him. I want to be obedient to the God we created which is us. Yes. Yes. So here's some questions. Write them down. Make a little note. No, I'm sorry. Who was that, Randy Travis? No, it's more current than that. I don't know. I don't listen anymore. It's not that current, honey. This was back during... Oh. You and What's Your Face saying that? No.

Oh, I'm sorry. Maybe you didn't. I was thinking about the one about the road and the fence post and the... I'll be going your way, you'll be going mine or whatever. Anyway, sorry, I'm not aggressive. All right, here's a question. Have you created a version of God who suspiciously agrees with you about everything? Or does your God dislike all the same people that you dislike? Does he share the same politics? Does he approve

of all your choices? Does he require anything from you that you don't want to give? And if God never disagrees with you, is it possible you're not following God at all? Maybe you're following yourself. So where does all this leave

us? Right? Because I don't want you walking away thinking I'm saying spirituality is bad, religion is good. That's way too easy. Religion can become another way of avoiding the very God it claims to worship. We can inherit beliefs we've never questioned. We can repeat words we've never really

considered. We can perform rituals while remaining completely unchanged. Can I interrupt right there? I have, I admit very embarrassingly. I have used my religion to what I thought was trying to rectify

a relationship and yet I used it very wrongly to Control? Well. Direct, get it, get it. Direct, I wanted to heal a relationship, but it was coming from a point of I'm so right and you're so wrong, and I tried to back it up with scripture and

verse to show I'm so right and you're so wrong. Correct. And it failed miserably again. Shocking, right? Shocking. Again, I tried to. I tried to play God. We've all done this. We do this a lot. Very embarrassed now. Experience of maturity. It just took a lot longer for that relationship to heal because I decided to cut the main guy

out. But again, in my religion, I thought I was doing the right thing. Same idea. Even in my religion, I was manipulating. Exactly what we're talking about. Yes. Right. I just wanted to add that. Sorry. So, you know, Jesus encountered people like that. Everything we just talked about. People who knew the rules. They knew the traditions.

They knew the arguments. and somehow missed God standing right in front of them. So maybe the dividing line isn't between the religious and the spiritual. Maybe it's between those who are willing to seek truth and those who already decided that the truth is what the truth is allowed to

be. That's uncomfortable. Because it puts all of us in the same place. Me included. I don't get to define God. Neither does a spiritual teacher. Neither does a pastor. Neither does a denomination.

Neither does a culture. Neither does an ancient institution just simply because it's ancient. If God is God, our job isn't to invent Him. Our job is to seek Him. And seeking means being willing

to discover something we didn't expect. Something we don't completely understand. Maybe even something we don't particularly like. Because the moment that I insist that God conforms to my expectations, I stop seeking. I'm starting to edit. And maybe

that's the question that's worth carrying out of this episode. Am I looking for God? Or am I looking for the confirmation of the God I've already decided must exist? But that leaves us with another problem. If I don't get to define God, and you don't get to define God, and religion

doesn't get to simply invent Him either, then how can we possibly know anything about Him? Think about that. If God actually exists outside of us, how would creatures like us ever figure Him out? Through nature? Reason? Consciousness?

Ancient wisdom? Scripture? Religious traditions? personal experiences? Or would God somehow make himself known? Because maybe the biggest question isn't. What do I believe about God? Maybe it's...

Has God ever told us who he is? And that's where we're going to go with the next episode. So. Can you be spiritual without being religious? Sure. That's not really the question thing. The

better question is, who has authority over your spirituality? Because if spirituality means I get to construct a belief system from everything I already like, if nothing outside me has authority, if nothing can tell me I'm wrong, If nothing can demand that I change, if I get to redefine

God whenever God becomes inconvenient, then I'm not sure I've escaped religion. I maybe have simply created a religion with one member. And I'm the pope. I'm the theologian. I'm the council.

I'm the congregation. And conveniently, I'm also the god. And that's worth thinking about. But before the religious group, celebrates too much. We need to ask ourselves the same question. Have I spent my life seeking God? Or have I simply

inherited a version of Him that I've never examined? because ultimately neither spiritual person nor the religious person gets to decide what is true. If God exists, He is who He is. Whether I like

it or not. Whether you like it or not. whether anybody behaves or believes it or not. And suddenly we're right back where we started this whole conversation. The truth is worth seeking even when it doesn't agree with us. This has been

Crusade With Me. We were asking light's deepest questions. Not because the questions are the destination, but because sometimes they're the road that leads us toward truth. Questions... Question what you've inherited. Question what the culture hands you. Question religion. Question spirituality. And don't forget to question yourself. Because the truth isn't ours to create, it's ours to seek. Keep asking, keep seeking, keep picking them up and putting them down, and as always, keep crusading with me.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What If the Supernatural is More Than Superstition?

    Nov 19, 202647 minAudio

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Haunted houses. Demonic possession. Exorcisms. Voices from beyond the grave. For centuries, humanity has been...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. What If You Don't Have To Earn It?

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Better Than I Deserve - A Thanksgiving Conversation About Grace What if you've spent your entire Christian life...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. What If Christians Lived Like Warriors Again?

    Nov 12, 202636 minAudio

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! What happened to the warriors of Christianity? When did following Jesus become something comfortable, convenient,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. What If Communion Is More Than Remembering Jesus?

    Nov 10, 202653 minAudio

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! What if the most extraordinary moment in Christian worship is the one we've learned to take for granted? What if...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. What If God Isn't Who You Think He Is?

    Nov 5, 202627 minAudio

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! What if the God you've spent your entire life believing in - or rejecting - isn't actually who you think He is?...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode