Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Christians have been given plenty of rules about sex. But which of those rules actually came from God - and which came from culture, tradition, fear, or our interpretation of Scripture? In Episode 180 of Crusade With Me!, we ask a question that may make some people uncomfortable: Did God actually put limits on sex? We dig into what the Bible really says, including the often-used Greek word porneia, and wrestle with the difference between sexual desire, sexual immorality, wisdom, commitment, harm, and judgment. This isn't an argument that anything goes. And it isn't another list of religious rules. It's an attempt to ask the harder question: If sexuality is part of God's creation, what was it actually created for - and where, if anywhere, did God draw the lines? No condemnation. No easy answers. Just an honest search for Truth. The Truth Is Worth Seeking. Let’s keep walking.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
All right. I know for the last several episodes I've asked a lot of questions. Where does the fire inside us come from? Why did God make sex feel so good? Is desire something we're supposed to control or something we're supposed to understand? And if you've listened to Crusade with me for very long, you know I like questions. I think questions are kind of important. Questions have changed my faith. Questions have changed how
I understand God. Questions have changed how I understand myself. But eventually, you have to answer some of those questions. And so today, I'm gonna quit hiding behind the questions and we're going to make some conclusions. Did God put limits on sex? Yes. I think scripture makes it clear. But here's the second conclusion I've
reached. I don't think God gave us nearly the bedroom rule book that Christians sometimes pretend he did. Those statements can both be true. There are sexual boundaries that I think scripture makes very clear. And there are other things Christians have treated as God's commandments where I have a much harder time finding God actually saying them. And there are Greek words at the
center of this conversation that we've translated for centuries without most Christians having any idea what that word actually means. Pornia. We're going to talk about that today. We're going to talk about what scripture clearly puts outside the boundaries. We're going to talk about some things scripture doesn't clearly address. We're
going to talk about homosexuality. We're going to talk about married sex. We're going to talk about judgment. and I'm probably going to make people on both sides of the sexual culture war uncomfortable. And I'm okay with that. Because I'm not interested in finding an answer that makes conservatives happy. I'm not interested in finding an answer that makes progressives happy. I'm interested in asking what is true.
Because around here, the truth is worth seeking. Let's seek it together. Okay, let's establish something before we get into Greek words and Bible passages. Sex is good. I think we've established that. If you believe God created humanity, God
created sexuality. He created bodies. He created nerve endings. He created attraction. He created the capacity for arousal. He created orgasms. He created the chemical process that happens in our brains and bodies during intimacy. So none of that surprised God. Sexual pleasure isn't some loophole humanity that's covered in God's design. It appears to be part of the design.
Now Genesis doesn't begin the human sexual story with shame. It begins with a man and a woman together, one flesh, naked, and not ashamed. That's important. But now we have to say the other part. Just because something is natural doesn't mean every possible expression of it
is good. Anger is natural. Cruelty isn't therefore good. Hunger is natural. Gluttony isn't therefore good. Ambition is natural. Destroying everyone around me to succeed isn't therefore good. Sexual
desire is natural. That doesn't mean every expression of sexual desire is automatically good. And that's where we talked about last episode. Desire gives me information. Desire does not automatically give me permission. So, yes, God appears to put boundaries around sex. Adultery is condemned.
Incest is prohibited. Sexual exploitation is condemned. Scripture repeatedly takes faithfulness seriously. Human beings aren't supposed to be sexually consumed as objects. And the biblical vision repeatedly connects sexual union with something much bigger than physical sensation.
Covenant. Faithfulness. Union. One flesh. Giving yourself to another person. That's the foundation. But here's where Christians sometimes make a mistake. We start with things scripture clearly says, and then we keep adding things. We add
tradition, or cultural expectation, or our parents' embarrassment, our grandparents' morality, ideas about modesty. Ideas about what respectable people do. Ideas about what respectable married couples do in their own bedrooms. And eventually all
of this gets put into one big bucket labeled biblical sexuality. Then somebody asks, Where exactly does the Bible say that? And sometimes we don't know. We just know somebody told us it was there. That's not good enough. It's not
good enough for me anymore. If I'm going to tell another human being God said, I better be reasonably certain God actually said it. because invoking God's name to enforce my preference is a pretty serious thing. So let's start with a word that appears throughout the New Testament, a word most Christians haven't heard or if they've heard the translated, but probably never really studied,
pornea, the word we rarely define. P -O -R -N -E -I -A, pornea. And yes, you could probably hear the English word hiding in there. Pornography comes from the same Greek word family. But pornea doesn't simply mean pornography. Depending on context, our English Bibles usually translated something like sexual immorality. And there's
a problem. with that translation. Not because it's necessarily wrong, but because it can become circular. What's sexual immorality? Pornia. Okay. What's pornia? Sexual immorality. Well, that didn't help much. So what did the word actually
mean. So historically, pornea was associated with illicit sexual intercourse and could encompass things such as prostitution and other sexual relations regarded as unlawful. The related word family is connected with prostitution. but by the New Testament period, the term could function
much more broadly. And here's something really important. Context tells us what kind of sexual wrongdoing is being discussed. For example, in 1 Corinthians chapter five, Paul says there is porny among the Corinthians, and then he tells us exactly what he's talking about. A man is involved sexually with his father's wife. Incest.
So there we don't have to guess Paul calls the pornea. Jesus uses the word too. It appears in his discussion about marriage and divorce. The word appears repeatedly in list describing conduct Christians are called to leave behind. So let's be intellectually honest. You can't look at the New Testament and conclude, God doesn't care what anybody does sexually. That's simply not what the text says. Sexual conduct matters, and
here's where we have to be equally honest. Pornia does not literally mean anything sexual that makes Christians uncomfortable. That's not a definition. That is, taking an ancient word and stuffing our own assumptions inside it. And at the same time, we can't go to the opposite extreme and say, well, the word requires interpretation,
therefore it doesn't really mean anything. Of course it means something. The earliest Christians clearly understood certain sexual behaviors as incompatible with the life they were being called into. So the question becomes, what connects them? Why adultery? Why incest? Why prostitution? Why exploitation? Why does sexual faithfulness
matter so much? Maybe the Bible isn't giving us random prohibitions. Maybe it's revealing something about the nature of sex itself. Remember what we've been talking about. Don't fight against the nature of a thing. Understand it. Watch what it does. Watch where it flows. Watch what happens when it's ordered well. Watch what happens when
it becomes disordered. Sex joins. Sex exposes. Sex makes us vulnerable. Sex can bond. Sex can create life. Sex can create enormous pleasure. Sex can communicate love. Sex can also manipulate,
dominate, exploit, betray, humiliate, become addictive, destroy trust, create jealousy, break families, leave wounds that last for decades. That's a tremendous amount of power concentrated into one human experience And maybe that's why
scripture treats it seriously Not because sex is dirty Because sex matters Let's quit dancing around it What can I say first Adultery violates the boundary That's clear why Because adultery
violates covet covet the covenant You gave yourself to one person and secretly gave what belonged within that covenant to another. It breaks trust. It turns one flesh faithfulness into deception. Second point. Incest violates the boundary. Scripture
is explicit about it. Third, sexual coercion and exploitation violate the very nature of Christian love. Another human being is not yours to take. A person's body isn't something you become entitled to because you're stronger, because you've paid.
because you're married, because you're dating, because you want it badly enough. The other person will doesn't matter to you. We aren't talking about love. We're talking about taking. Point number four, turning another human being into a commodity is compatible with seeing that a
person bearing God's image. So that's one of the reasons prostitution and sexual exploitation becomes so troubling. A human body becomes something purchased, consumed, used, and discarded. And then there's something Jesus does that makes the boundary even harder. He takes it into the heart. Jesus talks about lust. And I want to
be careful here because Christians have sometimes interpreted that as, if you notice somebody's attractive, you've committed adultery. I don't think that's a very useful understanding. You have eyes. You're going to notice attractive people. I'm 61 years old. I didn't suddenly lose the ability to recognize an attractive woman because I love my wife. The question is, what do I do with what I've seen? Do I notice? Or
do I begin consuming? Do I recognize beauty? Or do I mentally turn that person into something that exists for my gratification? Attraction and objectification are not necessarily the same thing. And I think that's important. Because
Christianity is supposed to teach us to become less human. It's supposed to form what we do with our humanity. And yes, that brings us to pornography. I'm not speaking here as somebody standing safely above the subject. I've wrestled with pornography myself. I'm not throwing rocks. I'm just asking what it does. Does it train me to see a whole person or a body? Does it deepen
intimacy with my wife or train my sexuality toward endless novelty? Does it make desire easier to govern? or harder. Does it teach giving or consumption? Those questions become uncomfortable pretty quickly and notice something. I'm not just asking, where's the verse? I'm asking, what kind of person is
this forming me into? And that's a much deeper Christian question. So we have boundaries emerging, faithfulness, no exploitation, no coercion, no incest, no commodification of human beings, no allowing sexual desire to become our master.
and a positive vision. Sexuality that honors the person rather than consumes the person. But now we need to talk about the issue that seems to dominate nearly every modern Christian conversation about sexual morality. I'm not going to dodge homosexuality, and I'm also not going to make this episode about homosexuality. Because frankly,
I think Christians have spent an extraordinary amount of energy talking about other people's sexual lives while ignoring what's happening in our own. Traditional Christianity has understood scripture to place same -sex sexual activity outside God's intended pattern for sexual union. That's the tradition I come from. And I'm not going to pretend biblical passage is involved. don't exist simply because they're difficult in our culture. They exist. Christians disagree
today about how some of those passages should be interpreted, their historical context, and how they apply to modern same -sex relationships. Now that is a real debate, but I'm also not going to stand behind this microphone and pretend I'm... I've been appointed judge of another person's soul because I haven't. And neither have you. There's a difference between saying I believe
this action is wrong and saying therefore I condemn you. Those aren't the same thing. Paul asks in Romans, who are you to judge the servant of another? to his own master he stands or falls. That first bothers me in a good way because it reminds me of my position. I'm not the master, I'm another
servant. That person you're looking at, they aren't ultimately accountable to Dave McKee. And thank God for that. You're not accountable to me either. I'm not accountable to you. Ultimately, we stand before God. That doesn't mean truth doesn't matter. It doesn't mean morality doesn't matter. It doesn't mean anything goes. It means
final judgment belongs to God. and maybe Christians ought to remember that more often, because it's pretty easy for heterosexual Christian men to point toward a gay couple and announce sexual immorality while he's watching pornography every night, or sleeping with somebody who isn't his wife, or treating his wife like an appliance that's supposed to provide sex on demand. are
lusting constantly after women online, or carrying on an emotional affair with somebody at work, or simply using people, and somehow, his sexuality gets treated as basically acceptable because he's heterosexual? No. If we're going to talk about sexual immorality, then, Everybody gets to come to the table, me included, maybe me especially.
Jesus seemed considerably more interested in getting people to examine their own hearts than giving them binoculars to inspect their neighbors. So I'm going to seek what is true. I'm going to tell you what I believe scripture teaches. I'm going to try to live accordingly. I'll talk with you. I'll wrestle with the text with you. I'll love you. I'll eat with you. I'll listen to you. But I'm not going to sit in God's chair.
Because there's already someone sitting there. And it isn't me. Now let's turn that question around because Christians can get so focused on forbidden sexuality that we almost forget there is such a thing as good sexuality. So let's
talk about the married people. Two people who have given themselves to one another, love each other, who are faithful to each other, who want to enjoy each other's bodies. What are they allowed to do? Well, here's where I'm going to disappoint anybody hoping I found the biblical bedroom instruction manual. I can't find it. I've searched for the verse that says husbands and wives should only
have enough sex to reproduce. Sorry Catholic brothers and sisters, I can't find it, it's not there. I've looked for the verse that says sex shouldn't be playful. That's not there either. I've looked for the biblical chart explaining exactly what a husband and wife may do with each other's bodies. Haven't found it. I've looked for the verse saying sexual pleasure becomes
suspicious that pregnancy can't result from it. I haven't found that either. In fact, the Bible contains sexual desire that isn't embarrassed about being sexual desire. Read Song of Solomon sometime without trying to turn every sentence into an allegory before you're willing to acknowledge what's sitting right in front of you. Two people desire each other. They delight in each other's bodies, their longing, beauty, touch, pleasure.
The Bible somehow managed to include that without blushing. Maybe we're the ones blushing. So scripture doesn't give a merry couple of catalog of permitted acts. What does it give us? I think it gives us something harder. It gives us principles, faithfulness, mutuality. love, self -control,
dignity, giving, one flesh, care for the other, and yes, delight. So perhaps the mature question between husband and wife isn't, what can we get away with? And it certainly isn't, how little can we enjoy this and still be holy. Maybe the
questions are, does this honor both of us? Do we both genuinely want this? Can either of us say no without fear, pressure, punishment, sulking, or manipulation? Does this deepen trust? Does it strengthen intimacy? Does it preserve the dignity of both people? Does it make our sexuality something we share rather than something one
person extracts from the other? Does it bring us closer? Does it remain within the covenant we've made to one another? either one of us becoming controlled by something that is supposed to be a gift. Those are considerably more demanding questions than, is this technically permitted?
Because now I can't just look for a loophole. I have to love the person in front of me. After almost 40 years of marriage, I've come to believe that sexuality inside a long marriage can actually become deeper as two people become more honest with one another. I'm gonna be real clear. Bodies change, desires change, confidence changes, energy
changes. What feels good changes. What we need from each other changes. And if you're fortunate enough to keep walking together, you have to keep learning each other. Not forcing. Not demanding.
Not assuming. Listening, giving, receiving, sometimes leading, sometimes yielding, sometimes wanting, sometimes simply holding. See, there's a rhythm.
to intimacy. And when two people quit trying to perform according to somebody else's expectation and actually begin paying attention to one another, something can change. Maybe even something beautiful. That's considerably different from the sexual message I absorbed when I was young. I've become more open about sexuality as I've gotten older,
and I make no apologies for that. But more open doesn't mean to anything goes. I've juggled that in my brain, and that's not what I'm saying. I'm saying I've become increasingly suspicious of calling something simple simply because Christians have historically been uncomfortable talking about it. If God prohibited it, I want to know.
If God established a boundary, I want to respect it. But if God didn't say it, I want to be very careful about putting words in His mouth. And that brings us everything together. We've been
asking, what am I allowed to do? Well, maybe that's not the best question because it still makes everything about me. What can I have? What can I experience? How far can I go? Where's the line? Maybe mature sexuality asks something different.
How can I love you well? Now everything changes. If I love well, I don't coerce. If I love well, I don't betray. If I love well, I don't exploit. I don't humiliate. I don't manipulate. I don't
turn the other person into an object. I don't demand that they become responsible for satisfying every desire inside of me. I pay attention. I listen. I respect. I give. I receive. And sometimes I let go. There's strength in that. We spend so much of our life grasping, trying to possess,
trying to control, trying to make life give us what we think we're owed. But intimacy doesn't flourish very well inside a clenched fist. Neither does love. The open hand is different. It can touch without grabbing. It can receive without taking. It can hold without imprisoning. And
it can let go without believing it has lost everything. Maybe sexual maturity looks something like that. Not repression. Not indulgence. Not fear. Not obsession. A powerful human energy brought into harmony with love. And maybe that's why self
-control belongs beside love and joy rather than opposite them. Self -control isn't the destruction of desire, it's freedom within desire. You know, there's one more piece of this conversation we
haven't dealt with, and it's been sitting there since the beginning. Genesis says, the man and his wife were both naked and were not ashamed. We read that. And almost immediately making nakedness sexual. But is it? Is nakedness inherently sexual? Or have we learned to sexualize nakedness? Is
modesty the same thing as shame? Is the human body something that has to be hidden because it's dangerous? What exactly happened when Adam and Eve suddenly realized they were naked? And why was their first response to hide? Those questions aren't theoretical for Kat and I. Because several years ago for our anniversary, my bride and I
did something neither of one of us ever expected we'd do. We went to Arizona and spent part of our anniversary at a clothing option resort. Yep, you heard me correctly. And here's the strange part. What I learned there wasn't primarily about sex. It was about bodies. judgment, vulnerability,
marriage, self -consciousness, and shame. Some of what I expected was completely wrong. And some of what I learned has stayed with me ever since. And that's a story Kat and I will eventually tell together because that story belongs to both of us. And I'm not telling her half without her sitting across from me. But we're gonna get getting
close. And when we get there, we're going to ask, what does it actually mean to be naked and not ashamed? Did God actually put limits on sex?
Yes, he did. That's where I land. Scripture does not present human sexuality as moral -lessly meaningless. There are boundaries. Covenant matters. Faithfulness matters. Consent and the dignity of the other person matters. Exploitation is incompatible with love. Incest is explicitly
rejected. Adultery is rejected. Treating human beings as objects to be consumed runs directly against seeing them as persons made in God's image. Sexual desire is powerful enough that it cannot be allowed to become our master. But here's where the other conclusions I've reached.
God has given us fewer specific bedroom rules than some Christians would like. He gave us more boundaries than modern culture would probably like. Maybe that's because God's goal was never to give us a loophole chart. Maybe he's forming people capable of love. People who don't exploit, don't betray, don't coerce, don't consume, don't grasp. People capable of tremendous desire without
becoming slaves to desire. People capable of tremendous pleasure without making pleasure their God. People capable of looking at another human being and seeing not something to use, but someone to love. And people humble enough to remember. I can seek truth. I can wrestle with scripture.
I can tell you what I believe. I can even tell you that I believe something is wrong. but I cannot condemn you. That's God's chair and I ain't sitting in it. So we'll keep examining my life. You examine yours. We'll keep talking. We'll keep asking difficult questions. We'll keep looking at scripture. We'll keep looking
at the fruit. We'll keep pointing one another toward Christ. And at the end of it all, we'll trust God to be God. Because the truth is worth seeking. I'm Dave and this has been Crusade with me. Let's keep walking like picking them up and
putting them down. And as always, continue to Crusade with me.
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Haunted houses. Demonic possession. Exorcisms. Voices from beyond the grave. For centuries, humanity has been...
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Better Than I Deserve - A Thanksgiving Conversation About Grace What if you've spent your entire Christian life...
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! What happened to the warriors of Christianity? When did following Jesus become something comfortable, convenient,...
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! What if the most extraordinary moment in Christian worship is the one we've learned to take for granted? What if...
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! What if the God you've spent your entire life believing in - or rejecting - isn't actually who you think He is?...