Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Critically Acclaimed Network

Critically Acclaimed Network artwork

We've Got Mail #198 | Movies That Defy Their Reputations!

Nov 6, 20261 hr 13 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Bibbs and Witney confront their ignorance about the SyFy Network's most recent hit TV shows, explore the increasingly common trend of auteur-driven blockbusters, ponder the greatness of TALES OF HALLOWEEN, dig into what makes CLAYFACE really tick (and what makes it tick less than it should be), movies with pop culture reputations that got way out of hand, and more! Subscribe on Patreon at www.patreon.com/criticallyacclaimednetwork to get exclusive podcasts and exciting rewards, like exclusive series, commentary tracks, and much more! Email us at letters@criticallyacclaimed.net, so we can read your correspondence and answer YOUR questions in future episodes! Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[SPEAKER_01]: Hello everybody and welcome back to we've got mail [SPEAKER_01]: There's the podcast where you control the conversation right here at the critically acclaimed network. [SPEAKER_01]: My name is William Bibbiani, I'm a film critic guy, right for the rap and everybody calls me BIMS. [SPEAKER_00]: My name is Whitney Symbol, I too. [SPEAKER_00]: I'm a film critic. [SPEAKER_00]: Ooh, I have right articles for a slash film. [SPEAKER_00]: I appear on the radio.

[SPEAKER_00]: Well, we hear you on the radio and I don't think we'll appear. [SPEAKER_00]: I suppose technically yes, but I believe you're gonna peer on radio. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, they've been kind of an appearance It's in boldalurized. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, a little bit. [SPEAKER_01]: Wait, is that what boldalurized means? [SPEAKER_01]: No I'm off to a bad start. [SPEAKER_01]: This is we've got mail This is the podcast where we respond to your correspondence right here at the critically acclaimed network How it works is you send us an email our email address is letters at critically acclaimed dot net

[SPEAKER_00]: You don't have to type it in that clip to fashion. [SPEAKER_01]: No, I always love that in movies when people were like extra, like we just pronounce the A to like every single syllable. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, I'll get to that in a minute, but let's finish our opening spiel first. [SPEAKER_01]: Okay, but anyway, yeah, it's just fun. [SPEAKER_01]: But, bye, bye, bye, bye, bye, bye, bye. [SPEAKER_01]: That's very mail address. [SPEAKER_01]: You sent us an email. [SPEAKER_01]: We read as many as we can on the show. [SPEAKER_01]: Whitney, what is our PO box? [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, you can send us a physical letter, a postcard, a little bit of fluff in an envelope, whatever you like to, the critically claimed network PO box, 641565 Los Angeles, California, nine to below 64.

[SPEAKER_00]: We don't get so many letters that... [SPEAKER_00]: Physical letters that we have to sort of be choosy about what we read. [SPEAKER_00]: So if you send one in physically, we'll read that Guarantine. [SPEAKER_01]: We don't always have to think about every email, but guaranteed will read your actual physical course Unless it's utterly vulgar or something No, it won't read the whole girl. [SPEAKER_01]: We don't know if we'll read like racist, but like We will read your racist letters vulgar vulgar is a lot of wiggle room in vulgar. [SPEAKER_01]: So like where that's [SPEAKER_01]: You know what, use your best judgment.

[SPEAKER_00]: And if we, you know, we have intelligent listeners, we understand, you understand. [SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for writing in. [SPEAKER_01]: We have very sensitive folks who listen to the show and our other show and our other show and I'm sure we're all very happy about how the fucking election went to this week. [SPEAKER_01]: Woo! [SPEAKER_01]: Well, most of it there's a couple of couple of blips, but we'll work on those. [SPEAKER_01]: But yes, it's I'm in a pretty good mood for once. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm reasonably well slept for once. [SPEAKER_00]: All right. [SPEAKER_00]: Let's kick it.

[SPEAKER_00]: Let's kick it Let's start with our emails Well before we get started. [SPEAKER_00]: I don't want to make a comment about what you were saying about click language Yes, because you're talking about a specific type of dialogue reading that would turn up in movies of like maybe the late 30s Yes, and [SPEAKER_00]: the movies of the late 30s were tapping into a culture that I don't think we really haven't the United States anymore. [SPEAKER_00]: And that is the upper crust America. [SPEAKER_00]: Not just wealthy American, but a certain type of aristocratic America that were came from like long family lines perhaps.

[SPEAKER_01]: Americans didn't have counts and dukes, but we wanted them, apparently, at least the rich people did, and so they decided to put on these [SPEAKER_01]: a dialogue. [SPEAKER_00]: There was an upper-crossed American dialect that is dead. [SPEAKER_00]: Nobody speaks this way anymore. [SPEAKER_01]: We know how to mock it. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: Like, we can do it in, like, we, you'll see it in, like, sketches, a lot of the time in order to sort of connote the Huiti-T-T. You know? [SPEAKER_01]: Oh, Reginald. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: Come over here.

[SPEAKER_00]: I'm bringing the T. Oh, I don't, I don't think I trust him. [SPEAKER_00]: He is new money. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: This is how it really is. [SPEAKER_00]: It was interesting to watch that die out in my lifetime. [SPEAKER_00]: I think it was already dead by the time I was a kid, but I saw the movies, saw the parodies of it, and movies that were coming out while there was a lot, and then it just sort of petered out into nothing. [SPEAKER_01]: You want to know the completely random movie I was thinking when [SPEAKER_01]: I think the time in a movie when I noticed that everyone was articulating very clearly.

[SPEAKER_00]: So what did you do with Carrie Grant, I'm sure? [SPEAKER_01]: No, it was an homage to a previous era of Zinnima. [SPEAKER_01]: It was haunted honeymoon. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, which was from like the early 80s. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, was Jane Wilder and Tom Deloise. [SPEAKER_00]: Tom Deloise was the maid of the female maid. [SPEAKER_00]: Was it a murder? [SPEAKER_01]: Peter's who was in that. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm trying to remember who the feminine was with.

[SPEAKER_00]: I'm sorry to this wife. [SPEAKER_01]: Shit. [SPEAKER_01]: Okay. [SPEAKER_01]: Well, everyone, I need to rewatch this movie. [SPEAKER_01]: I have no, I remember if it's, I don't remember if it's good. [SPEAKER_01]: I just remember people talking like this. [SPEAKER_00]: Anyway, let's get to our, of course. [SPEAKER_00]: So here's some correspondence. [SPEAKER_00]: Let's finally get to letters. [SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for being patient. [SPEAKER_00]: Well, we just just feel a little bit. [SPEAKER_01]: If you want to pause and watch haunted honeymoon and come back, you're more than welcome to. [SPEAKER_00]: It'll be well prepared for whatever comes next. [SPEAKER_00]: This letter comes from Alexa. [SPEAKER_00]: Hello, Alexa. [SPEAKER_00]: Hi, Alexa. [SPEAKER_00]: On a recent episode of episode P, great series by the way, really enjoying it. [SPEAKER_00]: That's one of our new Patreon podcast.

[SPEAKER_01]: Our Patreon podcast episode P is where Whitney and I review the pilot episode of a very popular TV series that somehow we never watched. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, we just haven't seen any other episodes we watched the pilot and judge it just from that. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: Anyway, you guys had a digression about the sci-fi channel. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, because we were talking about Endromeda, yes, where you said that it had fallen out of relevance when they changed focus to their monster movies and the end of Battlestar Galactica. [SPEAKER_00]: I will disagree with this notion as they still put out a lot of successful shows that would qualify for episodes of episode P.

[SPEAKER_00]: The generation immediately following Battlestar Galacta, which mostly was composed of Eureka and Warehouse 13, has been a staple sci-fi reference point for people in my age, and is slowly working its way into the larger sci-fi TV canon as my age group is starting to have, say, in the matter. [SPEAKER_00]: for from there up till rather recently there have been successful show after successful show and the shoot including things like haven the 12 monkeys TV adaptation kill joys and most recently the Chuckie TV show. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh is that sci-fi?

[SPEAKER_00]: I thought that was shudder. [SPEAKER_01]: I thought that was, I didn't know that was sci-fi. [SPEAKER_01]: That's funny. [SPEAKER_01]: Okay, I'll film. [SPEAKER_00]: With the ending of that show I think they have truly cooled off even though they have an interesting programming now it's a single show which the channel which a channel does not make. [SPEAKER_00]: Now, even with all of that, you could say they weren't in the zeitgeist at any of those points, but then we get to the thing that was so successful outside the sci-fi channel bubble that when they canceled it, another big studio picked it up for another three seasons, and that is the expense. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, there's a lot of great and qualifying TV between Battle Star Galactica and now that I have not mentioned in this letter,

[SPEAKER_00]: that are worth checking out. [SPEAKER_00]: But that's not the main point of this letter. [SPEAKER_00]: I will have you guys, I will not have you guys be smirching the lifespan of the sci-fi channel anymore as it is lasted well into the 20s. [SPEAKER_00]: I hope this finds you well, Alexa. [SPEAKER_01]: That's a great point. [SPEAKER_01]: So on the most recent episode of episode P Whitney and I, we were searching for a sci-fi series that lasted a long time that somehow neither of us had never seen and we both really liked sci-fi television. [SPEAKER_01]: So there [SPEAKER_01]: And we we've settled on and drama, though, a sci-fi series that debuted I think in 2000 that was based on an idea by Jean Roddenberry, but it didn't go into production until after Roddenberry died and it went through a lot of mutations and it started Kevin Sorbo and it lasted a hundred episodes or more yeah and

[SPEAKER_01]: I guess it has its fans, but like nobody talks about it and drop it out. [SPEAKER_01]: Like people talk about a lot of shows in that era, but nobody talks about it and drop it out and it was interesting to check that show out, see what it had to offer. [SPEAKER_01]: I liked it more than you did, but I saw a lot of potential. [SPEAKER_01]: I thought I was a neat, neat premise was some interesting characters. [SPEAKER_00]: I love the premise I love all of the setup and I did like some of the characters, but [SPEAKER_00]: I was distracted by its cheapness. [SPEAKER_00]: It's a very cheap show, especially the makeup, some of the characters just looked destructingly terrible. [SPEAKER_01]: The premise of Endromeda was, I'm going to give you like the short referencing another show version, imagine if

[SPEAKER_01]: On an episode of Star Trek, the next generation, the Vulcans attacked the Federation, killed everyone on the Enterprise, except Picard, and Picard got shunted 300 years into the future, and now there's a person in time for centuries. [SPEAKER_01]: And the Vulcans are leading a fascist universe now. [SPEAKER_00]: and he was awakened by like the Machi. [SPEAKER_00]: You know, he was awakened by the crew from Firefly. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, that's basically pretty much. [SPEAKER_01]: And he's so, the car is awakened by the crew from Firefly.

[SPEAKER_01]: He enlists the crew of Firefly to bring back the Federation. [SPEAKER_00]: On the Enterprise and bring back the Federation. [SPEAKER_00]: That's the premise for Andrew Ahmedah. [SPEAKER_01]: That's a cool hook. [SPEAKER_01]: Like I'm with you on all of that. [SPEAKER_01]: That sounds cool clearly. [SPEAKER_01]: It was too fucking cheap But if you want to hear us talk about that show for like a long fucking time You can listen to episode P, but you are a hundred percent correct in that there are a lot of sci-fi shows after Battlestar galactic That you know, I hesitate to say that they got anxiety. [SPEAKER_01]: I think Lexa even said that themselves, but

[SPEAKER_01]: They did last, and of all the shows that were mentioned in this email, the two that I never saw, so they're candidates, and I'm curious, because the whole thing is we can't have seen it. [SPEAKER_01]: It's the feeds the purpose, the two that I haven't seen, and I'm curious if you have, because we'll see if we can do them, were Eureka and the expanse. [SPEAKER_00]: I have not, I know nothing about Eureka. [SPEAKER_00]: I can't, I don't know what the premise of that show. [SPEAKER_01]: I just know small town, a lot of sci-fi stuff happens. [SPEAKER_01]: That's basically it. [SPEAKER_00]: And I did hear that the expanse was this new thing.

[SPEAKER_00]: It was really interesting. [SPEAKER_00]: I knew some people liked it. [SPEAKER_00]: I just heard like, it was the next big sci-fi thing. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, well, I like big sci-fi things. [SPEAKER_00]: Let me rent the first episode. [SPEAKER_00]: I made it maybe 15 minutes in before I had to turn it off for some reason and I haven't gone back. [SPEAKER_01]: Well, was it because the show was bad [SPEAKER_00]: I just got distracted and I never came back and I couldn't say whether I liked it or not it's there was still like setting up this hugely elaborate universe but it was like immediately turn you off. [SPEAKER_00]: So okay so those are at least two shows that we could definitely do in future episode B's but we're yeah I think we said in our andromeda episode though

[SPEAKER_00]: that sci-fi TV is most certainly back. [SPEAKER_00]: It's not like there hasn't been science fiction in the public consciousness since Battle Star Galactic on the thousands. [SPEAKER_00]: It's just that a lot of it has become so high profile and so expensive. [SPEAKER_00]: That only like major streamers kind of forward some of these bigger ones and the bigger ones get huge Thinking of shows like severance and pirabus and silo those are all on Apple TV Foundation that's another one on Apple Apple's Apple is really into dystopias.

[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, they have all of these all of these fantastic high-profile Really well done very ambitious shows That are getting a lot of critical acclaim and getting a lot of awards Except for Adam Scott [SPEAKER_00]: I mentioned it because my wife is like a big bit like the world's biggest Adam Scott fan Sure, and every time Severance comes back he's part of the conversation [SPEAKER_00]: But he hasn't won yet. [SPEAKER_00]: So he's been nominated. [SPEAKER_00]: He's been nominated for a couple of awards and he's always at the award shows and he loses.

[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: It's severance tends to lose just because it's against like last season of success. [SPEAKER_01]: I mean, there's a lot of really great TV on right now. [SPEAKER_01]: The show that I started watching recently that I was surprised to discover had a sci-fi hook or maybe not a hook, but a sci-fi element. [SPEAKER_01]: Have you heard about Cooper Tino? [SPEAKER_00]: No, I don't know. [SPEAKER_00]: Cooper Tino. [SPEAKER_01]: So Cooper Tino is a new lawyer show. [SPEAKER_01]: from the creators of The Good Wife and The Good Fight. [SPEAKER_01]: I never saw The Good Fight. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm still watching The Good Wife. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm catching up with it because it's my girlfriend's favorite series.

[SPEAKER_01]: I have to bother the vampire slayer. [SPEAKER_01]: And it's fucking great. [SPEAKER_01]: But Cooper Tino is a show about a little underdog law firm that takes on exclusively big tech. [SPEAKER_01]: Like the corporations that can basically pay to not have a lawsuit or extended for forever because no one can afford to keep up with them. [SPEAKER_01]: And it's really great, it's really good writing. [SPEAKER_01]: And then I think in the episode like two or three, they introduce something that is totally fucking sci-fi.

[SPEAKER_01]: I want to tell you what it is, it's still relatively grounded. [SPEAKER_01]: But there's like one, apparently going to be extremely important ongoing plot point that is like [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, we're not there yet. [SPEAKER_01]: This is a sci-fi show all of a sudden and they did not advertise it as such and I fucking love that and the possibilities are endless. [SPEAKER_01]: So I'm really doing that, but yeah, thank you for listening to episode P. We hope people are enjoying it. [SPEAKER_01]: We've got some cool episodes lined up. [SPEAKER_01]: And the next one currently as planned is going to be Grey's Anatomy.

[SPEAKER_01]: That's right. [SPEAKER_01]: Which has been on for over 20 years. [SPEAKER_00]: And I've been catching up with that. [SPEAKER_00]: I saw one episode. [SPEAKER_00]: I saw the pilot. [SPEAKER_01]: And I have seen a couple of clips here and there. [SPEAKER_01]: Usually there's some very weird ones that people thought were funny. [SPEAKER_01]: And I did there weren't, but yeah, so we'll be, we'll be watching the good wife. [SPEAKER_01]: Uh, what's up next? [SPEAKER_00]: Alright, here we go. [SPEAKER_00]: Here's an email from Jesse. [SPEAKER_00]: Hello, Jesse. [SPEAKER_00]: Hi, Jesse. [SPEAKER_00]: Hello, my two favorite critics. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, no. [SPEAKER_00]: So William and who's the other one?

[SPEAKER_00]: Oh my god, enough, enough. [SPEAKER_00]: Just, it's okay to say thank you. [SPEAKER_00]: Thank you, I appreciate it. [SPEAKER_00]: Okay. [SPEAKER_00]: In the fallout of diggers strange marketing and subsequent box office failure, I've been reflecting a lot on what actually sells movies. [SPEAKER_00]: Tom Cruise, commonly said it as our last movie star, doesn't appear to have sold an original movie since the 2000s and our highest-grossing actors today are all connected to various franchises. [SPEAKER_00]: We've also seen a wave of studios green lighting movies held by YouTubers, or YouTuber Dylan Clark is directing a new Blair Witch, Spielberg is producing a Mandela catalog movie, Zach Kriger is writing Siren Head, the list goes on.

[SPEAKER_00]: I think what YouTube is doing beyond showing off up and coming filmmakers work is getting people comfortable with knowing exactly who made a particular video. [SPEAKER_00]: The coolest example to me is Markiplier. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, you check out his channel to watch a Markiplier video something you know was created by him which seems to translate well to the theater as he was able to a shoe traditional distribution and leverages fan base and to 4,000 theaters worldwide for the movie was iron law yeah and it didn't very well for independent really well and I was talking about it when it came out it was like back in January or February and I finally cut up with it that movie's fucking awesome

[SPEAKER_00]: It is. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: It's a nightmare. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, it's great. [SPEAKER_00]: YouTube and maybe social media as a whole is teaching us to be fans of creators, the people behind the videos you watch. [SPEAKER_00]: This brings me to Christopher Nolan who's the Odyssey grossed nearly $2 billion. [SPEAKER_00]: The buzz online at least. [SPEAKER_00]: seemed very geared toward experience being, quote, Nolan's vision, which means that his direction is what's getting people into theater, especially in premium formats. [SPEAKER_00]: Post-track surveys said that 51% of moviegoers saw because it was directed by Nolan and just last year 40% of moviegoers saw because it was directed by Ryan Kugler.

[SPEAKER_01]: But center size was over to center. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: I think when we see the video put up by people like Curry Barker and King Parsons, we're learning to be fans of them. [SPEAKER_00]: And we're turning our eyes to more to the director to see a movie. [SPEAKER_00]: I'm curious to see what you think about this idea, because I've loved her analysis on industry trends in the past, all the best Jesse. [SPEAKER_01]: Thank you. [SPEAKER_00]: We've actually talked about this a little bit when it was going on. [SPEAKER_00]: You can find probably [SPEAKER_00]: podcast from over a decade ago, where we talked very much about how movie stars were no longer the draw and it was the characters.

[SPEAKER_00]: We usually had these conversations in regard to the Marvel cinematic universe. [SPEAKER_00]: People were really interested in seeing the fate of Captain America, but Chris Evans wasn't selling tickets otherwise. [SPEAKER_01]: There are very few people. [SPEAKER_01]: There's a lot of people who could open a Marvel movie because they really wanted to see [SPEAKER_01]: whole-red playing ant-man, but they don't necessarily want to see Paul Red do everything. [SPEAKER_01]: They don't necessarily want to see even Robert Denny Jr. do everything. [SPEAKER_01]: When he tries to do other things like the judge or Dr. Do Little, nobody showed up because they don't like Robert Denny Jr. or they do, but they won't pay to see that.

[SPEAKER_01]: They will pay to see Iron Man as played by Robert Denny Jr. And I think big part of this is that [SPEAKER_01]: before sort of the internet and particularly the era of like social media, our access to celebrities was extremely limited. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, we didn't, we couldn't tweet at a celebrity. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, we didn't have them respond. [SPEAKER_01]: We didn't hear from them constantly. [SPEAKER_01]: We didn't hear their general thoughts. [SPEAKER_01]: They were occasionally on TV doing interviews. [SPEAKER_01]: They maybe did like a magazine cover or something in print that you could check out.

[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe they would, you know, be on Saturday night live or something like that. [SPEAKER_01]: But generally speaking, you were looking, you were, if you wanted to see, I don't know. [SPEAKER_01]: I think we're good example. [SPEAKER_01]: If you wanted to see Robin Williams, after he was off TV, your best bet was to pay to see Robin Williams moving. [SPEAKER_01]: That's the most reliable thing you could do. [SPEAKER_01]: And now it's like, we see these people all the time. [SPEAKER_01]: Celebrity is not something you necessarily are eager to pay for. [SPEAKER_01]: I think we went through phase where characters are what people wanted to pay for, and I think we're, I think that's still present.

[SPEAKER_00]: You know, it's present, but we're moving beyond. [SPEAKER_00]: I saw the, the late 2000s and the tens, as kind of like an echo of what was going on in popular media in the 1980s. [SPEAKER_00]: in that it was very commercially ascendant. [SPEAKER_00]: You think of American cinema in the 70s and it's all like adult dramas, studio batch, sometimes big budget. [SPEAKER_00]: But very heavy and vicious films that we're drawing in huge audiences through their high concepts that would appeal to grown-ups.

[SPEAKER_00]: Whereas in the 1980s, there was a change toward the kid friendly. [SPEAKER_00]: And you can point directly to the Star Wars for this. [SPEAKER_01]: Oh, certainly. [SPEAKER_00]: But a lot of special effects started to take off. [SPEAKER_00]: A lot of effects based movies were making a lot more money. [SPEAKER_00]: And films that could strike a broader, what they would call, eventually call a fork, water, and audience, started to become more popular. [SPEAKER_01]: Well, then they come more to your point, they became more defining, you know, when we think about the 80s, yeah, there's some great movies on the days, came out in the 80s, whatever, and like there's certainly a few, which I think are defining films of the 80s, like do the right thing, but when we think of the 80s, we don't necessarily jump to room with a view and driving Miss Daisy, we jump to Ghostbusters and back to the future, like there's a lot of stars.

[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, if I were to say what is Steven Spielberg's best movie from the 80s, people would say, oh, it's either ET or Raiders, probably nobody would say the color purple. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, it's um [SPEAKER_00]: There was a tendency, at least, for my generation, to kind of film someone at home, but screaming in the color purple right now. [SPEAKER_01]: Like, you're one of the people. [SPEAKER_01]: Fair enough, apologies. [SPEAKER_01]: But you know that that's not the typical answer. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: The films that were up for best, like, nominated for Best Picture at the 80s are hardly what we ever talk about. [SPEAKER_00]: It's just the big commercial blockbusters.

[SPEAKER_01]: Raiders was nominated for Best Picture. [SPEAKER_00]: I said, I said, hardly, yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: But when was the last time you heard somebody talk about a soldier's story? [SPEAKER_00]: True, Sophie's. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm going to say we started, we did have some of those fatal attraction was a huge block bustry. [SPEAKER_01]: Now many of the best picture witness was a big block bustier, but yes, agreed, generally it's getting real quick. [SPEAKER_00]: And this was especially true if you look at what kids my age were watching on television when Ronald Reagan got into office. [SPEAKER_00]: There was this kind of unbinding of regulation about entertaining for kids.

[SPEAKER_00]: It wasn't made, it was illegal to market directly to children, but those regulations were kind of being ignored in the early 80s and it was finally just made legal again in 1987. [SPEAKER_00]: So a lot of the entertainment became very commercialized, very art unfriendly. [SPEAKER_00]: It was all about marquee value and characters and toys and the kids ate it up, like it was just singing into their soft brains and I was living a deep brand. [SPEAKER_00]: And I still have that stuff like that. [SPEAKER_00]: That kind of deregulation.

[SPEAKER_00]: I think really Hurt the consciousness of kids in ways that are difficult to define and we still didn't get a lot of the idea But eventually the public got tired of that. [SPEAKER_00]: They could time you look and you look and we get tired of that You mentioned Spike Lee that was do the right thing came out in 1989 But that was actually the flashpoint of like a new movement [SPEAKER_00]: that kind of lasted into the indie movement of the 1990s. [SPEAKER_00]: We started to see a lot of smaller low budget filmmakers come to the fore, a lot of more interesting daring things that weren't being released by major studios, so to get a lot of attention.

[SPEAKER_01]: The 90s had a very huge indie boom and we were all better for it, but [SPEAKER_00]: You know, everyone from Spike Lee to Stephen Soderberg to Quentin Tarantino to Scaven Smith like all this whole new generation of filmmakers sort of came into the four and the big blockbusters of the 90s We might remember them, but we remember them as shit That's not a lot of them were shit. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, but actually some of some of the blockbusters of the 90s 90s blockbusters We're way more varied than the blockbusters. [SPEAKER_00]: We have we're trying out a lot of stuff There wasn't a dominant trend anymore.

[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, like so I feel like [SPEAKER_01]: John Grishon movies were Blackbusters and some of the early ones are very good. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I think the firm and time to kill are very watchable. [SPEAKER_01]: The client deeply underrated. [SPEAKER_01]: Absolutely, the client's all the nominal barn burner of a movie. [SPEAKER_00]: I mentioned all of this to say that I think the 2010s were like the 80s and that it was all about IP. [SPEAKER_00]: It was all about remakes. [SPEAKER_00]: It was all about coming into these movies that studios didn't have to market because they all knew what they were. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.

[SPEAKER_00]: and a lot of them were based on nostalgia for the 80s and 80s and eventually 90s. [SPEAKER_00]: And people ate that up, those things were making billions of dollars, weren't they? [SPEAKER_00]: And I feel like that started to crack. [SPEAKER_00]: uh... just a couple years ago within within the twenty twenty six years like around the twenties i i still maintain that the superhero boom began and earnest with uh... friendly with iron man i think it was the one to punch of iron men in dark night that was like yeah that that year and it's like all of a sudden uh... and there were hits of course before that for ten years before that

[SPEAKER_01]: Superhero movies were ascendant. [SPEAKER_01]: They were very, very big. [SPEAKER_01]: A lot of the temples every year. [SPEAKER_01]: We're superhero movies from Iron Man and the Dark Knight on. [SPEAKER_01]: They were the dominant force. [SPEAKER_00]: For a whole decade, and from Iron Man all the way to Avengers Endgame. [SPEAKER_00]: And after that, it's been a bit spotty. [SPEAKER_01]: It's body. [SPEAKER_00]: I do maintain that Morbius was the moment we realized the door was shutting. [SPEAKER_01]: I think with any kind of trend like that, you know, everyone's like, okay, there's like, okay, third of the dark world wasn't very good, but the next one that came out was, so it was okay, it was kind of a blip, we're gonna look for a little bit of a go.

[SPEAKER_01]: Like, Morbius came on when we'd had like three crappy ones in a row and it just taught everyone these are not sure things anymore. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and sometimes they're gonna suck and we're gonna get a little more selective about what we're gonna pay our money for. [SPEAKER_00]: And I think people sort of lost interest and of course a new generation came along. [SPEAKER_00]: How long do you think people were going to pay? [SPEAKER_00]: Billy, okay, Spider-Man now with space. [SPEAKER_01]: The Spider-Man and Batman will probably always do well. [SPEAKER_00]: But yeah, all of the same audience isn't going to stay there. [SPEAKER_00]: And a new generation is an interesting, interesting.

[SPEAKER_00]: But now we have the 90s again. [SPEAKER_00]: We have this new idea of voices of filmmakers of people with interesting ideas coming in from outside of the system. [SPEAKER_00]: I love that the most talked about movies of 2026 haven't been the big studio tent poles. [SPEAKER_00]: They've been little films like Obsession, like Backrooms, like you can see everything. [SPEAKER_00]: A three hour documentary film is being more talked about than the $2 billion Spider-Man picture. [SPEAKER_01]: I will push back and I will remind you that the Odyssey made a billion dollars.

[SPEAKER_00]: And the Odyssey. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, obviously he was a big one. [SPEAKER_00]: It's a bigger man. [SPEAKER_01]: Spiderman was a big one And I think you're a little divorced from that sort of part of this that part of the year Maybe show guys, but like who generally speaking who directed that film? [SPEAKER_00]: But Watkins was his name? [SPEAKER_01]: That's the um, oh my god. [SPEAKER_01]: Oh, oh my god. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, it's dead. [SPEAKER_01]: Daniel. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, see? [SPEAKER_00]: Okay hang on, Kretten. [SPEAKER_00]: This is a Kretten. [SPEAKER_00]: Thank you. [SPEAKER_01]: Any any did Sean Cheese a good director? [SPEAKER_01]: He's fine. [SPEAKER_01]: Is this a character? [SPEAKER_01]: And that's why we're not an eye for me. [SPEAKER_01]: We're not going to absolutely nuke to the point out that I completely admit people are rushing to the theater because they really want to see a Daniel Cretan move.

[SPEAKER_00]: That's true. [SPEAKER_00]: They're rushing because they want like Spider-Man. [SPEAKER_00]: No, but they're like that actor Spider-Man. [SPEAKER_01]: But to our listeners point, people did go to see a curry bar for movie. [SPEAKER_01]: People did go to see a king Parsons movie. [SPEAKER_01]: People did go to see a goose work movie when [SPEAKER_01]: The amazing little circus to watch, they went to see a Markiplier movie, they went to see a Christopher Nolan movie. [SPEAKER_01]: And I think we're, I think people are excited to see an Ethan Fielder movie. [SPEAKER_00]: I think that's a big part of it. [SPEAKER_00]: A big part of it is also the new generation has grown up on YouTube.

[SPEAKER_00]: They've been watching more YouTube than they did TV or even traditional movies. [SPEAKER_00]: The idea of connecting directly to a filmmaker and this goes to our Jesse's point. [SPEAKER_00]: that a lot of people are used to more directly engaging with the makers of their entertainment. [SPEAKER_00]: I think there are a lot more active and present in the making and presentations. [SPEAKER_00]: So people become fans of the creators. [SPEAKER_00]: I hate to use the term creatives. [SPEAKER_01]: The artists who are involved in telling, sorry, I agree.

[SPEAKER_01]: And I think this is something that because a lot of the fandom as we know it was built on the fandom [SPEAKER_01]: I don't want to say you can send it all the way back or only as back as far as famous monsters of film land But that's a flashpoint on people. [SPEAKER_01]: People like the point too. [SPEAKER_01]: It was just a fanzene about a genre And people got really excited about it and it kind of brought sort of a community together And that became sort of the template upon which Star Trek fandom and Star Wars fandom and other fandoms kind of built But all of those things Connected the audience more to the filmmakers not just

[SPEAKER_01]: The films and I always feel like when I'm watching a horror movie And oftentimes this is because horror movies begin with the exception of some of like the big well-moneyed ones They're very personal. [SPEAKER_01]: They're very small. [SPEAKER_01]: You can see the seams You can see the passion and you can tell this is just what someone really had in their subconscious They needed it to get it out and we feel the deep connection to that and I think that we are seeing some of that [SPEAKER_01]: writ large crystal for no one can do that on a gigantic scale not everyone has that freedom i think for no one is like really rare he is actually sees the exception to all the rules i don't think he's saying i don't think he's so much an exception so much as

[SPEAKER_01]: what a lot of people want for themselves. [SPEAKER_01]: We want people to be excited to see what this filmmaker will do, whatever it is, because they are a storyteller that we trust. [SPEAKER_01]: They've made multiple great films that inspire us, that excited us, that entertained us, and we want to see what they'll do next. [SPEAKER_01]: And we have some filmmakers who are doing that on a big scale, Ryan Kubler is one, Greta Gerwig is one, people just want to see whatever they do next.

[SPEAKER_01]: And any one of those filmmakers is only like two, three crappy movies in a row from losing that faith that audiences have in them. [SPEAKER_01]: But as long as they keep it up, it is a really exhilarating thrill, right? [SPEAKER_01]: And we're seeing that on a smaller level that is actually attainable to a lot of younger independent filmmakers through [SPEAKER_01]: YouTube. [SPEAKER_01]: Now YouTube comes with its own share of problems. [SPEAKER_01]: They run on an algorithm. [SPEAKER_01]: They highlight some great storytellers and bury other great storytellers in that fucking sucks.

[SPEAKER_01]: And a lot of the ones that they elevate, there is not as diverse a crop as it should be. [SPEAKER_01]: As a lot of amazing work done out there, it's a very exciting time, and I agree. [SPEAKER_01]: I think we are entering into a more film maker-oriented era. [SPEAKER_01]: And I think that with AI, generative AI, quote unquote filmmaking, rising, I think we are now hyper-aware. [SPEAKER_01]: list, at least a lot of us are, that when we're experiencing a work of art, what we're really experiencing is the connection between the artist and their audience.

[SPEAKER_01]: And without the artist making those decisions, that connection is meaningless. [SPEAKER_01]: So our awareness of a real artist making real choices. [SPEAKER_01]: They're not always good choices. [SPEAKER_01]: just amplifies our appreciation. [SPEAKER_00]: And I do think this idea that studios are saying, some studios are saying very openly, oh, we're going to use these automatic image generators, these automatic extracurrent generators. [SPEAKER_00]: We're having computers, right, this scripts. [SPEAKER_00]: And I think this is just a sign that people are sick of the commercial shit.

[SPEAKER_00]: They don't want the same e-scripts. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, we can write your favorite superhero money. [SPEAKER_00]: What if I want a film of backgrounds? [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: What if I want something striking that I never would have thought of? [SPEAKER_00]: A.I. [SPEAKER_00]: couldn't have made something like iron lung. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: And I think there's... [SPEAKER_01]: I think it's interesting because there's kind of a dividing line. [SPEAKER_01]: We talk about for quadrants, the traditional definition of a four quadrant film is that it appeals to men and women, and yes, that's a false binary, but that was the idea, and also the young and the old.

[SPEAKER_01]: Yes. [SPEAKER_01]: And I think what is happening to a lot of the mainstream stuff, and we should move on. [SPEAKER_01]: But I think what's happening to a lot of the mainstream stuff is [SPEAKER_01]: The young and the old are interested in different things. [SPEAKER_01]: The people who were super into superhero movies from the 2000s until like the late 2010s, and had a lot of people still are, but they're the old now. [SPEAKER_01]: They're the older, and they have different tastes in life experiences, and those stories don't always speak to those, and they're interested and excited to see different kinds of cinema at least as well.

[SPEAKER_01]: And so a lot of other films are doing well, and then a lot of the young people, like the teens and the early 20s, [SPEAKER_01]: Um, they see a lot, I mean, I'm generalizing, but I've talked to a lot of young people who just, they see star wars and marvel as their parents' stuff or their grandparents' stuff in some cases, and that's fine they may like it, but it doesn't feel like theirs. [SPEAKER_01]: And when you're young and you're getting into art for the first time, whether it's music, comics, movies, whatever,

[SPEAKER_01]: You want your own thing. [SPEAKER_00]: I remember finding out my mom loved Nirvana and I was like, no, I mean, cool, but no, that was for me. [SPEAKER_00]: There's always a little bit of a disappointment when corporate America gets their hands on the stuff you like. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: It'll happen. [SPEAKER_00]: That was mine. [SPEAKER_00]: You're not allowed to have that. [SPEAKER_01]: You know what I always said would be the moment when I would just give up entirely. [SPEAKER_01]: Unfortunately, it has never happened. [SPEAKER_01]: Is when Pearl Jam's Jeremy is in a commercial. [SPEAKER_01]: If that ever happens, I give up.

[SPEAKER_00]: I heard Devo in a Whole Foods, and it's like... [SPEAKER_01]: It's on the radio, that's not so bad. [SPEAKER_01]: But do you hear we're going to commercial it? [SPEAKER_00]: But it's Devo. [SPEAKER_00]: I understand what the message is of Devo. [SPEAKER_00]: I understand. [SPEAKER_01]: But it's still just like, that's just the playlist. [SPEAKER_01]: I think when you're looking at it, we decided to take this song. [SPEAKER_01]: That was any song, really. [SPEAKER_01]: That was this song, was about we're Bellian, and we're using it to sell the McRibb. [SPEAKER_01]: We've lost that art. [SPEAKER_01]: I remember hitting on his lack of respect for it now. [SPEAKER_00]: I've heard, I've got to make you sweat.

[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, the seminal early, 90s hit. [SPEAKER_01]: You're going to have to give me a line for that. [SPEAKER_00]: Everybody dance now. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I'm a bad dancer. [SPEAKER_00]: That one. [SPEAKER_00]: The hook sung by I think Martha Wash was the... Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: That song was in a commercial for medicine that prevents hot flashes. [SPEAKER_00]: Because if you're listening to that song when you're a young person, well, guess what? [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, you're not. [SPEAKER_01]: All right, we should move on.

[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, uh, here we go. [SPEAKER_01]: I was gonna get another letter up here. [SPEAKER_00]: Here's a letter from Anthony. [SPEAKER_00]: Hi, Anthony. [SPEAKER_00]: Dear William and Whitney, this is Anthony, following up, following up with an update. [SPEAKER_00]: A few months ago, I asked you both for film club recommendations. [SPEAKER_00]: I included both your suggestions, Labrante of cinema and a deadly adoption. [SPEAKER_00]: what I've done feature in our group poll alongside Labyrinth of Cinema Paper House and chopping mall. [SPEAKER_00]: Chopping mall on the vote. [SPEAKER_01]: That's fine. [SPEAKER_01]: That's a good choice. [SPEAKER_00]: I will definitely be listening to your commentary track for it to help prepare for our meeting.

[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you both for the recommendations. [SPEAKER_00]: I will write in with a question next time. [SPEAKER_00]: OK. Also, as a quick update, I'm currently making my next horror short film, and you can follow my Instagram for updates at AJ Under Score Drake. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, follow AJ Andrescord trade. [SPEAKER_01]: Let's see what see what AJ's got cooking. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, we love coming out movie recommendations Yeah, I love that that's for recommendations. [SPEAKER_00]: You suggested a deadly adoption which is set of us almost a Not spoof spoof of a Hallmark Melody.

[SPEAKER_01]: I'll make it quick since we talked about it in the previous episode [SPEAKER_01]: at some point in the 2010s lifetime, and they're really quite infinite wisdom. [SPEAKER_01]: Decided what we're going to do, we're going to do our usual lifetime original movie, like a family stocked by their babysitter kind of stick, and we're going to cast in the lead, Will Ferrell, and Kristen Wig, and we are not going to play it for laughs. [SPEAKER_01]: They are going to play a dead series. [SPEAKER_01]: The script is just one we pulled off the rack. [SPEAKER_01]: It was not written for them.

[SPEAKER_01]: and they're going to play it totally straight. [SPEAKER_01]: And it is a surreal watch. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and I chose Labyrinth of Cinema which was [SPEAKER_00]: Nova Hiko Obayashi's final film is three-hour epic about it's like slapstick cartoon comedy epic about how film is responsible for humanities on healthy obsession with war, how it kind of interrogates that through these kind of silent movie archetypes who jump from movie to movie.

[SPEAKER_00]: I love that movie, I have at the best of the year. [SPEAKER_01]: But that's not in a nutshell, really. [SPEAKER_01]: That's basically just randomly distilled into one movie recommendation age, but thank you for writing in. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, keep us updated. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm going to make sure you follow AJ's Instagram for updates on their film. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: Here's our next letter. [SPEAKER_00]: This one comes from Logan. [SPEAKER_00]: Hello, Logan. [SPEAKER_00]: Hi, Logan. [SPEAKER_00]: Good spook evening. [SPEAKER_00]: A bit of somebody. [SPEAKER_00]: This came in from a slightly before Halloween. [SPEAKER_00]: I hope you're both having a spook, tacky little week.

[SPEAKER_00]: I'm writing because I've been a listener for quite some time. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, thank you for that. [SPEAKER_00]: And very much enjoy your podcast especially So for especially so for the fact that you do your letters episodes, which is the reason for my correspondence today Being that we're right in the thick of spooky season. [SPEAKER_00]: My personal favorites We're recording this after we refer to this. [SPEAKER_00]: I'm sorry. [SPEAKER_00]: Sorry. [SPEAKER_00]: So this came in before Halloween, but you know what spooky season is a state of mind You can all watch the horror movie at any time. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah [SPEAKER_00]: My personal favorite season, I was wondering if either of you have seen the Halloween Anthology film Tales of Halloween.

[SPEAKER_00]: I first discovered it back in 2019, when my wife and I randomly came across it on Tobi and absolutely loved it. [SPEAKER_00]: Every segment is a complete success, but I think it's as good as something like creep show or trick or treat in terms of conjuring the spirit of Halloween. [SPEAKER_00]: I have either of you seen it, I would love to hear your opinions. [SPEAKER_00]: If so, thank you for all that you do, very humbly yours, Logan. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm a big booster of tales of Halloween. [SPEAKER_00]: We reviewed it when it came out. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: We are actually on top of that one. [SPEAKER_00]: And yes, I agree. [SPEAKER_00]: There are, there are plenty of horror movies you can watch on the screen.

[SPEAKER_00]: Everybody watches Halloween on Halloween. [SPEAKER_00]: Great, Beck. [SPEAKER_00]: Trick or treat to become a standard as well. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, they're very, [SPEAKER_00]: few movies that actually are not just about Halloween, but really captured the vibe of what it's like to be outdoors and autumn, turkker treating with friends. [SPEAKER_00]: There's like an excitement in the air. [SPEAKER_01]: And there's a ton of films and they've actually distilled it into very easy to copy formulae that captured the feeling of Christmas to one degree or another. [SPEAKER_01]: But a lot of the times in October, we just watch Scary Movies, and that's fine. [SPEAKER_01]: But a movie that genuinely captures the

[SPEAKER_01]: There's one of the reasons why we keep coming back to Hocus-Pocus. [SPEAKER_01]: It's one of the reasons why we keep coming back to trick-a-treat. [SPEAKER_01]: These are films that are Halloween. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: As well. [SPEAKER_00]: And there's a movie that came out that I really wanted to see. [SPEAKER_00]: It was four kids. [SPEAKER_00]: It was called Fun Size. [SPEAKER_01]: Oh, yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: It took place on Halloween night. [SPEAKER_00]: That, I saw previews. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like, this is like getting the vibe right. [SPEAKER_00]: I mean, you get to see the movie. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I remember that. [SPEAKER_00]: So I'm telling you to catch up with that. [SPEAKER_00]: But that was like set on Halloween. [SPEAKER_01]: It had like a kind of like a John Hughesian teen comedy vibe. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that's an idea. [SPEAKER_00]: It's like high school kids. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, but there are so few films that actually do that.

[SPEAKER_00]: There are even some bad films that they're not fun to watch, but they did at least have the vibe. [SPEAKER_00]: I was thinking of the second of the Goosebumps picture. [SPEAKER_00]: Which is very Halloween. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, very Halloweeny, but it's not a Disney original. [SPEAKER_00]: No, it's, yeah, it's not a great film, but it has this, it has a monster's unleashed story. [SPEAKER_00]: The idea is that all of, um, that Aralstein is a real person. [SPEAKER_01]: Right. [SPEAKER_00]: He writes these stories like in New Nightmare, the trap monsters inside the books physically. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and if you open the books, they get out and start laughing.

[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: Fun premise. [SPEAKER_01]: And the original movie is great. [SPEAKER_01]: The first goose bumps movie is genuinely great. [SPEAKER_00]: I like that first goose bumps movie. [SPEAKER_01]: It's more the same, but not as good. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, but there are some great visuals in it. [SPEAKER_00]: Like, they're, I'll say this, it has the best ghosts. [SPEAKER_00]: I've ever seen in a movie, nearly done that, and that it has, [SPEAKER_00]: The ghost you see in the Halloween decoration, it looks like a basketball under a sheet. [SPEAKER_01]: Oh yeah, yeah, love this. [SPEAKER_00]: That kind of ghost is just flying around in a haunted Halloween.

[SPEAKER_00]: So I think that got the vibe right. [SPEAKER_00]: That's another one we've got. [SPEAKER_01]: Another one we have a good vibe. [SPEAKER_01]: And this is a filmmaker who genuinely annoys me now, especially, but he was always been really hit or mess, but Eli Roth had an adaptation of the house with a clock in his face. [SPEAKER_00]: That's a good one too. [SPEAKER_01]: And that's a fun movie, if only because there was a scene [SPEAKER_01]: headbutts a floating jack-alancer and into oblivion and says, I hate pumpkins and it's like, yeah, man, yeah, I'm glad that scene exists, that's we're better for that.

[SPEAKER_00]: But there's also like some profound stuff like she's talking to this kid, it's set in the 60s I believe. [SPEAKER_00]: and um... or it has a vibe of it actually wasn't well it is because he blanched is talking to the kid is talking about how he's afraid there might be monsters or there's something going on and she's like i know what monsters are and you it's kind of subtle but she reaches to get something in the foreground and her arm is out of focus in the foreground with the kid in the back and you'll notice that she has a number tattooed on her forearm it's like oh shit there's like [SPEAKER_01]: You're like, Roth, what do you, you're allowed to play this, put it out, you're not allowed to do something real, yeah.

[SPEAKER_01]: But back to Tales of Halloween, Tales of Halloween is an anthology film that unfortunately got a little overlooked, it is a lot, a lot of Los Angeles, I think mostly it's not entirely Los Angeles based filmmakers who all decided to do an anthology film set much like the movie [SPEAKER_01]: The only real connective tissue is the disc jockey, who I believe is played by Adrian Barbo, and that is able to smooth over the transition from one scene to another because

[SPEAKER_01]: it's a little all over the place and I would love to see different edits of this film where the shorts ended up in different places. [SPEAKER_01]: I know a few of the filmmakers a little because I used to do like this incredibly difficult horror trivia night every month and some of them works there or like did the questions or whatever or occasionally contest and so I know some of them are little but man, [SPEAKER_01]: It tells me how long it has genuinely terrifying sketches. [SPEAKER_01]: It has genuinely hilarious sketches.

[SPEAKER_01]: It has a few that actually feel like why is on this movie. [SPEAKER_01]: The last one about man-eating jackal lanterns. [SPEAKER_01]: That's a movie. [SPEAKER_01]: That should be a movie. [SPEAKER_01]: It's weird that it's not. [SPEAKER_00]: Was that the one that had Friday the 31st? [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that's, I think I don't have it in my favor. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that's where Jason Voorhees like Slasher is like chasing a woman and then an alien UFO flies down and an alien gets out and tries to trick her treat with Jason and Jason doesn't know what to do with that.

[SPEAKER_01]: That's fucking great. [SPEAKER_01]: as with any horror anthology, little hit or miss, but the misses aren't that bad, and because there's a ton of shorts, they're all short. [SPEAKER_01]: So if there's one that is in great, you wait like four minutes. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, how many? [SPEAKER_01]: There was like, it's a ton, 15 different shorts a lot and they feel complete, like they're really, like seriously, Tales of Halloween is, I feel like Trick or Treat is a bit more canonized. [SPEAKER_01]: I recently published an article, [SPEAKER_01]: at the rap, which was the 50 best horror movies of the 21st century so far, and I mostly focused on quality, but there were a few where I was like these have made such a huge impact that's weird to leave them out.

[SPEAKER_01]: So while I kind of prefer tales of Halloween overall, I put trick or treat on there instead, but I prefer tales of Halloween. [SPEAKER_01]: A lot of personal love. [SPEAKER_01]: I would rather watch that again, then I would watch like a couple [SPEAKER_00]: I like them both. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm not going to put one in front of the other, but yeah, but I'm just saying I think on aggregate tell you how the wing is actually stronger overall. [SPEAKER_00]: Now what I want to use to catch up with are those VHS movies. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, you like some of those, you like some of those. [SPEAKER_00]: All right, I know there's like nine or ten of them at this point.

[SPEAKER_00]: Uh, this next letter comes from Brandon, Brandon. [SPEAKER_00]: Uh, Dear Bibbs and Whitney. [SPEAKER_00]: Uh, hello, good morning and good day. [SPEAKER_00]: I'm the big fan of the two of you deeply, but I also love to talk about your clay face review a little more in depth. [SPEAKER_01]: Uh, yes. [SPEAKER_01]: Sorry. [SPEAKER_01]: I don't need anything. [SPEAKER_00]: Thanks for having me. [SPEAKER_00]: This question may come with some spoilers, so feel free to ignore this if it's too early to air all of the DC movies during the long. [SPEAKER_00]: It wasn't a good thing. [SPEAKER_01]: Not good thing. [SPEAKER_01]: Okay, but it's been a few weeks, and I think most people who are really excited about it probably saw. [SPEAKER_01]: But if you, if anyone doesn't want to hear this, skip ahead.

[SPEAKER_00]: Find that answer so. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, it should be fine. [SPEAKER_00]: However, your recent review left me thinking about a few things. [SPEAKER_00]: For the record, I agree with bibs assessment that I quote, genuinely kind of like this movie. [SPEAKER_00]: I have my problems with it for sure, but overall not bad. [SPEAKER_00]: You talked a lot about how the movie obfuscates Matt Higgins passed and how it doesn't address whether or not some of the past accusations that are brought up against them are true or not. [SPEAKER_00]: Then makes a weird complexity where we don't know if he's supposed to be a victim-turn anti-hero or a true villain. [SPEAKER_00]: I also strongly agree with Whitney Statement about how there's no clear movement when he decides to become evil.

[SPEAKER_00]: No, no, no, no, no, no clear moment where it decides to come evil. [SPEAKER_00]: His descendant to evil is more gradual and doesn't have a single scene where it clearly becomes a bad guy. [SPEAKER_00]: That being said, the two of you also talked about how you felt about the movie was missing the moment where Matt Higgins' relationship with the Naomi Akiye character became, quote, real. [SPEAKER_00]: In my mind, this is where the movie justifies itself a bit, because there's no scene where she's clearly into him. [SPEAKER_00]: The Matt Hagen character shows his true colors and quickly falls in love with her, even though she's not reciprocating that energy.

[SPEAKER_00]: In my mind, that's the movie saying, no, we're not going to dive back into the past with what previously happened with this character and past relationships, but the way he's approaching this new love interest tells you everything you need to know about who he is, and who is he a gross guy that gets overly attached the [SPEAKER_00]: The scene early on when he sleeps with the mob boss's partner despite knowing she's probably probably going to have a bad It's going to have bad repercussions strengthens that he knows he shouldn't do this, but it just can't help himself He's just a bad guy.

[SPEAKER_01]: Well, he he you make the point. [SPEAKER_01]: He craves attention. [SPEAKER_01]: He's yeah, yeah, that's a good point. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, he's [SPEAKER_00]: There's a lot of people paying attention to him. [SPEAKER_00]: So I guess my overall point is, I think the movie is written in a clever way where without having to address the huge me too elephant of the room and the movie briefly brings up Matt Hagen's past and then quickly moves away from it, you still get the context that you need and that context then justifies him becoming a fallen villain because there were always hints that it was there. [SPEAKER_00]: Is my analysis wrong? [SPEAKER_00]: I'm giving, I'm giving the movie too much of the benefit of the doubt and seeing things that might not have actually been in the script and or filmmaking.

[SPEAKER_00]: I'd welcome the thoughts on this matter of my two favorite phone critics best, Brandon. [SPEAKER_01]: Brandon, I think you're, I think you're right. [SPEAKER_00]: I think I definitely all decide. [SPEAKER_00]: I think you're right. [SPEAKER_01]: And I would be shocked if the screenwriters at least weren't on that wavelength. [SPEAKER_01]: Because I think you're, you bring it a good point. [SPEAKER_01]: A lot of the elements of this story that Whitney and I felt were lacking or the very least underplayed are technically present. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: And this is where we run into a problem with film criticism sometimes where is the problem what's in the story or is the problem the execution?

[SPEAKER_01]: And I think your critique that was referenced in this email that there needed to be some kind of moment where Matt Hagen, the guy, becomes Clayface. [SPEAKER_01]: Completely turns into a villain like from here on out. [SPEAKER_01]: So you need there's some kind of shift I think that is a storytelling beat that would benefit the film the film still kind of works But I think there's a lot of ways it could work better Clearer and clear isn't always better, but there's a there's a difference between being like thematically ambiguous

[SPEAKER_01]: and just not selling the moment. [SPEAKER_01]: And I feel Clayface too often does that. [SPEAKER_01]: But I do believe yeah, the pieces are here. [SPEAKER_00]: Well, and this goes to an issue you and I sometimes have as critics where we'll kind of dismiss something or ignore something that's actually in the movie that would explain maybe a criticism we have. [SPEAKER_00]: And I want to make clear that often we pick up on that stuff. [SPEAKER_00]: or like, they're not sold well.

[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, technically they're in the script, but it's not an important part of the story because it was not made effectively. [SPEAKER_01]: The thing about it, like music, okay? [SPEAKER_01]: Anyone can sing, I don't know, a Reeth of Franklin's respect. [SPEAKER_01]: You can sing it. [SPEAKER_01]: Can you belt it? [SPEAKER_01]: Not everyone can do that, not everyone has the pipes, and not everyone has the training, and not everybody knows how to really make a song come alive. [SPEAKER_01]: Well, you're doing it, but you're technically doing it.

[SPEAKER_01]: And for some people, that's enough because they like the material, or they like the performers, or they're able to, and that sort of George Lucas watching Flash Gordon cereals in the kid, as a kid kind of way, see the ideal version of this through the people [SPEAKER_01]: tried to make it great, and maybe didn't quite come through. [SPEAKER_01]: But as a critic, we're focusing on how effectively was this conveyed. [SPEAKER_01]: And sometimes we just think it's technically there, but it could be better, and it doesn't sold. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, the prime example I like to point to with this sort of thing is George Lucas' Star Wars films from 99 to 2005.

[SPEAKER_00]: The prequel. [SPEAKER_01]: The prequel trilogy. [SPEAKER_00]: Because a lot of what I want to be in those movies are in those movies. [SPEAKER_00]: This idea of making a character drama about the birth corruption and moral fall of the Darth Vader character. [SPEAKER_00]: It's is all technically in there. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: We do get to see the things that make him turn into sort of a bitter young man into somebody who is eager to commit acts of violence.

[SPEAKER_00]: He always had a little bit of violence in him and is eventually corrupted by this other influence to the point where he becomes this sort of evil warlock and a malnut. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: all of that's in there. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: But it's written so poorly. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: And the filmmaking is paced so badly and it's overstuffed with all this other shit that it becomes a less than effective drama. [SPEAKER_00]: Everything I want is in those movies. [SPEAKER_01]: Technically. [SPEAKER_00]: Except for good filmmaking. [SPEAKER_00]: There's a good writing. [SPEAKER_00]: There was what would make us film's work.

[SPEAKER_01]: There was a clip of an interview [SPEAKER_01]: better Star Wars animated shows and then it's and is now like much more in charge of Star Wars in general along with John Favreau. [SPEAKER_01]: And a lot of people see him as kind of the heir apparent to George Lucas and he was talking about how [SPEAKER_01]: The prequel trilogy tells a story about a kid who's father figure like immediately dies and keeps searching for one and you know all but it all comes down to losing quite kind of the beginning and this clip and I'm not selling it right which is kind of sells my own point ironically.

[SPEAKER_01]: But this clip started going around on people started who really liked the prequels and granted a lot of people really do It's that's C This is why they're great, and I'm like no, this is why they're not great because they've phloony was able to tell that story better in a three-minute clip The George move is did over three movies. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, Dave phloony [SPEAKER_01]: found the character-based thru-line and actually conveyed it and made it through everything felt connected to the actual central arc. [SPEAKER_01]: And George Lucas got really lost.

[SPEAKER_01]: And people will say things like George Lucas predicted the ride. [SPEAKER_01]: So fascism, I'm like, no, he was doing what history did and history is repeating itself. [SPEAKER_01]: But yes, technically that's in there. [SPEAKER_01]: And sometimes [SPEAKER_01]: If George Lucas was a better storyteller in those prequels, if maybe people would have heated those warnings instead of looking at them after the path going, oh yeah, that was there, wasn't it? [SPEAKER_00]: Like, no. [SPEAKER_00]: I've seen so many, and I'm guilty of this. [SPEAKER_00]: If I see a movie that is, I know in my heart isn't good, but I still love it.

[SPEAKER_00]: And there are many bad movies that I deeply adore. [SPEAKER_00]: I will [SPEAKER_00]: to the best of my abilities, find a hook into it. [SPEAKER_00]: Now, I feel like I'm trying to be a wise enough critic that I'm able to sell why I enjoy it while also pointing out the weaknesses that I openly recognize. [SPEAKER_00]: But I can also get a little high-falutin, if I'm defending something I know is a little bit. [SPEAKER_00]: I have read way too many essays about the Star Wars prequel

[SPEAKER_00]: that start to introduce all of these really complex storytelling ideas. [SPEAKER_00]: I learned about the phrase, chiasstic structure from writing one of these essays about the Star Wars prequels and how they mirror this kind of like figure eight arc between the original Star Wars films. [SPEAKER_00]: I mean that's cool. [SPEAKER_00]: A cool fun theory, bro. [SPEAKER_00]: None of that makes these movies any more fun to watch. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, like I'm not getting any more into these movies. [SPEAKER_00]: I'm glad somebody's finding this stuff.

[SPEAKER_00]: But I hate that we've had to spend literally decades digging through these trash piles. [SPEAKER_00]: I feel fine, something of value. [SPEAKER_01]: I feel as though Star Wars is one of those things. [SPEAKER_01]: And it's not alone on this. [SPEAKER_01]: But Star Wars is one of those things that because culturally, we've decided to center. [SPEAKER_01]: all the popular culture around it, or a significant chunk of it, that we keep coming back to whether we like it or not. [SPEAKER_01]: And because we keep coming back to it, we keep looking for more in there. [SPEAKER_01]: And sometimes it's there. [SPEAKER_01]: And sometimes we're searching, and this is just the only text we have.

[SPEAKER_01]: One thing we and I've talked about a lot is how in the movie clerks the death star scene that everybody loves so much, where they talk about how [SPEAKER_01]: You know, two clerks on a really boring day at work are just opining about the politics of working on the Death Star. [SPEAKER_01]: When you're working on the Death Star, are you complicit in everything that the Death Star was built to do? [SPEAKER_01]: You know you're working on a weapon of mass destruction. [SPEAKER_01]: And yeah, maybe you're installing a toilet, man.

[SPEAKER_01]: but are you not responsible for helping? [SPEAKER_01]: And the joke of that scene is that this is all the culture they have. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, they're overthinking these science fiction movies. [SPEAKER_00]: because they are overeducated and they are working shit jobs. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: This is the plight of their generation and all they really have to do. [SPEAKER_01]: They're looking for meaning wherever they can feel it. [SPEAKER_00]: The only thing they can really use to apply their actual intellect is these lightweight films that they saw as well.

[SPEAKER_01]: Two different extent of Phil James Schumbring talks about this a lot and how like people will find deeper meaning in slasher movies or Buffy the Vampire Slayer and [SPEAKER_01]: granted sometimes it's there and sometimes we're the ones looking. [SPEAKER_01]: So we're gonna find it somewhere. [SPEAKER_01]: And yeah, I think we kind of overanalyze Star Wars sometimes. [SPEAKER_01]: And you said it once that [SPEAKER_00]: The joke in clerks was that they were over-analyzing Star Wars and that eventually just became a cottage industry It did.

[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that because there's just things where we live for money everyone did it as a job Yeah, it was just something this is the way we talk about these things now So doing it now, this is all around about way of saying that everything you saw in playface [SPEAKER_00]: was in there and I think that's actually a really good take. [SPEAKER_00]: The fact that Matt Hagen is sort of this so hungry for attention, that he is willing to be a creep in search of it. [SPEAKER_00]: But again, I feel like if that was going to be the main theme, the film could have played that out.

[SPEAKER_00]: And it's a horrible idea. [SPEAKER_00]: It has license to be a direct. [SPEAKER_00]: The main character could have been a little bit [SPEAKER_00]: I like that he's a pretty boy. [SPEAKER_01]: I think that makes sense, but like well for the film I made for sure Yeah, but yeah, but yeah, but at what good points. [SPEAKER_00]: I think we had an interesting conversation about it That's what I [SPEAKER_00]: Here comes a letter from Bob and Boston. [SPEAKER_00]: Hey, Bob. [SPEAKER_00]: Hey, Bob and Boston. [SPEAKER_00]: Hi, Bipz and Whitney. [SPEAKER_00]: As someone born in the late 80s, and very immersed in pop culture, I've long avoided watching many iconic movies from the 20th century, because I feel like I had already seen them without actually watching that.

[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: Maybe I consumed the parody versions in Mad Magazine or the Simpsons, I watched clips of it on cable TV, or listened to people summarized the film, [SPEAKER_00]: VH ones, island V80s, or even later on podcasts. [SPEAKER_01]: Wow, you and I like to call this cultural osmosis. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, you just sort of absorb this. [SPEAKER_01]: We kind of, you, you might never see psycho, but you know what happens. [SPEAKER_01]: So yeah, exactly. [SPEAKER_00]: I finally started working through a lot of the canon recently and have found this theory of redundancy. [SPEAKER_00]: Sometimes affirmed and more often rejected. [SPEAKER_00]: Some films aren't much more than the sum of their plot, their most iconic scene, most memorable quotes, and most are much reader and idiosyncratic than the cultural memory of them.

[SPEAKER_00]: I agree. [SPEAKER_00]: So in that spirit, which films do you think are at least like the cultural short-hand for them? [SPEAKER_00]: Who's that if it's simplified, misunderstood or misremembered in a way that doesn't at all reflects the experience of watching them. [SPEAKER_00]: In the age of letterboxed podcasting, lots of pop culture criticism. [SPEAKER_00]: I see a lot of these films have already been reappraised, especially films with satire political commentary that weren't fully appreciated at the time like Robocop or First Blood. [SPEAKER_00]: But I'm curious about the films that haven't received this treatment and should. [SPEAKER_00]: Thanks so much, Bob and Boston.

[SPEAKER_00]: That's a great question. [SPEAKER_00]: That's a really [SPEAKER_01]: I was tricky because it's for like the last 20 years you and I have been really in it and we're we've been in the thick of things. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, the movies just they come on. [SPEAKER_01]: The movies that were like that for me were movies that were like from the 40s with these 60s, 70s. [SPEAKER_01]: Like I didn't see Wizard of Oz until it was 18. [SPEAKER_00]: But I knew Wizard of Oz. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, you know, I'm the same as me for Star Wars. [SPEAKER_00]: I didn't see the first Star Wars movie until I was 18. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: But I knew all the dot lines of dialogue. [SPEAKER_00]: I knew every scene.

[SPEAKER_00]: I essentially knew all the story beats of Star Wars. [SPEAKER_00]: So watching it felt like a formality. [SPEAKER_00]: And I feel like Star Wars, they got it. [SPEAKER_00]: There was no misrepresentation of Star Wars. [SPEAKER_01]: I would say the prequels are that, oh yeah, I guess so, I think people give them way too much credit. [SPEAKER_00]: But the one that really shocked me, what I sort of had a big sort of lingering cultural memory, a lot of references. [SPEAKER_00]: But when I finally sat down to watch the film for the first time and I was in my thirties. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: I realized this is not what the popular image of the film is.

[SPEAKER_00]: And that film is Saturday Night Fever. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh yeah, that's great pick. [SPEAKER_00]: Sedern and I fever in the cultural memory is the scene of John Colt on the dancefloor. [SPEAKER_01]: It's a joyous dance movie set in the disco era. [SPEAKER_00]: It's just sort of about this young man finding his, uh, finding his, his mojo out on the dancefloor and like leaving an impressive how, uh, home life but finding catharsis through dance. [SPEAKER_00]: that movie is pretty fucking bleak yeah it's actually like much more of a 70s movie and i actually got to talk to and not in like style but in terms of like grit and character based drama right yeah um i got to talk to the director

[SPEAKER_00]: I get to interview him. [SPEAKER_00]: It's a little bit like John Badham, I think. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, John Badham. [SPEAKER_00]: John Badham, great, great feeling. [SPEAKER_00]: And I brought this up. [SPEAKER_00]: I said, I watched Saturday, I fever. [SPEAKER_00]: And I was surprised at how dark it was. [SPEAKER_00]: And he says, this is like one of the most common things I hear about Saturday, I fever. [SPEAKER_00]: It's not old. [SPEAKER_00]: I think his phrase was, it's not all music and ice cream. [SPEAKER_00]: There's sexual assault and suicide. [SPEAKER_00]: The main character is kind of a dick and treats women poorly, and the women in his life are struggling just to sort of get the attention they feel they deserve.

[SPEAKER_00]: There's a lot of hate in that movie. [SPEAKER_00]: It's a serious adult drama, Saturday Night Fever, and the fact that it has a hit soundtrack record. [SPEAKER_01]: uh... and it that represents the score and discover presents like hedonism and joy and drugs and energy so a lot of people assume that center denied fever was like part of that one to be fair that the soundtrack album in a vacuum is a fun album yes if you don't know the context all those songs are great and even in context of the songs don't really directly connect to everything going on with that movie all the time if anything there a note worthy contrast the joyousness of the bg's

[SPEAKER_01]: enjoyed by John Travolta, but it is not actually the soundtrack of his inner life, which is very interesting. [SPEAKER_01]: Now, that's a really, really good pay. [SPEAKER_01]: I don't know if I would have left to that, but you're 100% right. [SPEAKER_01]: Movie, I think about a lot, and this is Citizen King. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I know a lot of people who when they think of citizen came because they haven't seen it, but they know They're probably in the world. [SPEAKER_01]: They probably have all the time. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: They probably have seen like it rift on the Simpsons millions of times. [SPEAKER_01]: A lot of people who could, well, when a lot of people watch citizen came for the first time, if they like, you're in like their teens or 20s.

[SPEAKER_01]: They'll probably be shocked to see how much dynamic and energetic it is, but just like how much of like, without even realizing it, you've seen this movie rift on. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, but yeah, because that is in king people think of it as like this really like gram art house movie or this very like serious movie about man things. [SPEAKER_01]: It's funny. [SPEAKER_01]: It's got a great musical number. [SPEAKER_01]: It is, like, narratively, like, structurally ambitious and exciting. [SPEAKER_01]: It has an energy to it.

[SPEAKER_01]: That as much as I love films when the 1940s, very few films when the 1940s have that kind of energy. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: It is the kind of, like, excitement to be watching and making a movie that people get from filmmakers like, [SPEAKER_01]: Paul Thomas Anderson, or, like, yeah, it's just like, oh my god, they have so many ideas. [SPEAKER_01]: They can put it all in everywhere. [SPEAKER_01]: It's an electrifying movie. [SPEAKER_01]: It is not homework. [SPEAKER_01]: It is fun. [SPEAKER_01]: And you can watch that movie a dozen times and really get into the meat of it and you'll find stuff there.

[SPEAKER_01]: And you can also just watch it as the story that it's telling and the story is a fucking delight. [SPEAKER_01]: And by delight, I mean, it's sad. [SPEAKER_01]: but it's incredibly engaging to watch. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: I think another one that's probably more obvious, mentioned a lot of people are thinking of it, is it's a wonderful life, which people think of as a great Christmas movie. [SPEAKER_01]: It's about suicide intervention. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, it's a pretty dark film as well. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and it's brilliant. [SPEAKER_01]: I love that movie. [SPEAKER_01]: I think that movie is like, one of the great, great, so-called great movies that genuinely earns that reputation and I think still plays really well, even to younger audiences.

[SPEAKER_01]: But yeah, that movie's bleak a shit. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, like it's it really earns the like the ending in a vacuum you just say like didn't you do it like and don't read like celebrating while everyone's like singing Christmas carols and I think through yourself. [SPEAKER_01]: Oh, that's great. [SPEAKER_01]: They had to earn that. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I had to go a long way and yeah, yeah, and here's another one and this this might seem a little too obvious. [SPEAKER_00]: But uh, Star Trek. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I feel like the idea, uh, specifically the character of Captain Kirk. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, the original series of the original series, the way Shatter played him.

[SPEAKER_00]: People who haven't seen a lot of Star Trek have this idea that Captain Kirk was like this reckless cowboy who is always breaking rules and always snog and ladies and punch and guys and ride chop and doing, doing, doing rolls and the, [SPEAKER_01]: Why am I thinking of doing what? [SPEAKER_01]: Doing summer salts like it's like doing rolls, you know, doing rales Yeah, it's a snorten and Dorian We didn't we didn't really get any star trek in the 70s other than the movies We didn't get a really cooked out star trek No, the closest weeks came was uh, Dr. McCoy's disco outfit Oh god boy, that was a funny tree.

[SPEAKER_01]: Let me tell you [SPEAKER_00]: but you actually go back and you watch the original Star Trek episodes and Kirk is actually like an incredibly judicious, thoughtful character, he's actively said and dialogue that he's kind of a nerd. [SPEAKER_00]: He's kind of like a character's describes like an encyclopedia on legs or something like that. [SPEAKER_00]: But he's just got charisma. [SPEAKER_00]: He's got a lot of charisma, but he considers his opinions. [SPEAKER_00]: He does roll by instinct. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, he snogs ladies. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, it was the sex, everyone snogged.

[SPEAKER_00]: But you watch any of the episodes where he kisses a lady and it's never that he's just sort of being promiscuous. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: There's always like a dramatic reason for it and he falls into this idea that he's kind of a judicious character. [SPEAKER_01]: He could probably think of one example where it really didn't serve a function, but yeah, generally speaking. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, generally speaking. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: So I think, yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: Maybe not Star Trek in general, but at least Captain Kirk. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, he's Captain Kirk. [SPEAKER_00]: That's a really good point. [SPEAKER_01]: No, that's a genuinely good point. [SPEAKER_00]: But it's important because when they finally made that movie, excuse me, that Star Trek movie in 2009.

[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, the JJ Abrams reboot. [SPEAKER_00]: That was based on the popular perception of Kirk. [SPEAKER_00]: So when they they played up everything. [SPEAKER_00]: non-trek he's already kind of new about him. [SPEAKER_00]: So in that movie he was, uh, a premise curious. [SPEAKER_00]: He was reckless. [SPEAKER_01]: And he came from openly said he was a Star Wars guy, not a Star Trek guy. [SPEAKER_01]: But if you watch JJ Abrams, Star Trek movies, then you watch his Star Wars movies. [SPEAKER_01]: You'll find in both cases the first one is a lot better than a second, and also that Star Trek is based off of Star Trek vibes, and Star Wars is based off of Star Wars lore.

[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that's a great way to put that. [SPEAKER_01]: You know, like he's he wants to evoke the idea of Star Trek, and that's why I think that movie is actually a very good way to get people into Star Trek, because it's the Cliff Snowd's version. [SPEAKER_01]: Is it accurate? [SPEAKER_01]: But what is accurate? [SPEAKER_01]: Star Trek has been everything to everyone. [SPEAKER_01]: But it gives you the gist. [SPEAKER_01]: And if this is the type of movie you like and this is the kind of Star Trek you like, we can gear you towards Star Trek that is like that. [SPEAKER_01]: There a lot of Star Trek is like that, but a lot of it is. [SPEAKER_01]: Whereas Star Wars, it's like it's all Star Wars. [SPEAKER_00]: I think we have to talk for one more letter.

[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, one more letter. [SPEAKER_00]: Let's see here. [SPEAKER_00]: Here's a letter from, uh, Toroff. [SPEAKER_00]: Oh, hi Toroff, hello Toroff. [SPEAKER_00]: Hello bibs and a Steinmeister Song Discolds. [SPEAKER_00]: Literal German translation of Rockmeister McCool. [SPEAKER_01]: We love it. [SPEAKER_00]: Steinmeister Song Discolds. [SPEAKER_00]: With listening to your end drama to episode, another one about end drama. [SPEAKER_00]: I had a few flashbacks from watching the show in the 2000s, probably starting in 2001 on German television. [SPEAKER_01]: That's awesome. [SPEAKER_01]: When we do episode P, we do ask if anyone knows the show better than we do to chime in, let us know what we got right around.

[SPEAKER_00]: It was always right on after Stargate on a channel called RTL2 in real life. [SPEAKER_00]: It was a Wednesday and I had a friend over most weeks. [SPEAKER_00]: It had Rod and Barry somewhere in the title and us Treckys had to give it a go. [SPEAKER_00]: There were some good times, I remember the show was being quite good, although it might be a case of, is it greater were you eight? [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_00]: Credit to, I'll answer to the rally day for that one, just maybe on its 14 at the time, in a foramblings onto the plot that I still remember. [SPEAKER_00]: Okay. [SPEAKER_00]: The first officer, Garris Raid, came back in two ways.

[SPEAKER_00]: There were a few flashbacks and pretty early on, it might be season one, a whole episode dedicated to him. [SPEAKER_01]: there's a there's a first officer character who betrays the captain on and drama that he dies immediately and we both theorized that's way too big a character to get rid of he's got it so it sounds like he does get okay in that episode it was shown that he actually did kill captain hunt in the pilot and later assumed command of the ship [SPEAKER_00]: He also traveled 300 years into the future and then tried to rebuild the Commonwealth, the same as Huntwood. [SPEAKER_00]: He was unsuccessful and due to some time travel shenanigans, there might have been Trans Gemini, not sure.

[SPEAKER_00]: He was given a second chance to change the timeline. [SPEAKER_00]: After jumping back and killing his younger self, then he intentionally let's hunt when the fight on the bridge in the first episode. [SPEAKER_00]: That's a cool episode. [SPEAKER_00]: This gets really involved, you know, like killing your time-traveled apple-gangers. [SPEAKER_00]: That's a cool episode. [SPEAKER_00]: That's a cool episode. [SPEAKER_00]: All right. [SPEAKER_01]: Neat on him. [SPEAKER_00]: The actor comes back later as a descendant of Garrison Rae. [SPEAKER_00]: That directs that makes sense. [SPEAKER_00]: Neat telemarkas Rae, due to some genetic fluke, something like perfect genical reincarnation or some such. [SPEAKER_00]: That's just that. [SPEAKER_00]: He looks exactly like Garrison, that's his play by the same actor, that's that's that's drama been doing that I know it's soap operas been do that stuff Yeah, after a similar battle on the bridge the two joint forces to uncover some nefarious plot and he later becomes part of the crew

[SPEAKER_01]: Awesome, all right, it's fun. [SPEAKER_01]: Oh, hey, and we've mentioned before how much that and Dramada in its premise is a lot like what discovery turned into after season two, and that's also kind of like discovery, where like these like we bring it back because we're going to future and everything's falling. [SPEAKER_01]: But also like the Michelle Yo's storyline where like they're killed immediately and we become part of the crew anyway because of shenanigans. [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, me. [SPEAKER_00]: Um, tear and assazay the other Nietzschean later betrays the whole crew and as they don't remember why.

[SPEAKER_00]: Because they're Nietzscheans, they're untrustworthy. [SPEAKER_00]: So basically, uh, they basically wrote one Nietzschean off the show and replaced him with another. [SPEAKER_00]: That's fair. [SPEAKER_00]: Didn't that happen on Buffy the Vampire Slayer? [SPEAKER_00]: They got rid of one pompous Brit character and replaced him with another? [SPEAKER_01]: No, no, they threatened to. [SPEAKER_01]: He was fired and then he was replaced by a younger pompous British like mentor, but he sucked. [SPEAKER_01]: And so he lost his job at the end of his season. [SPEAKER_01]: And then he went on to this weird redemption arc on Angel the Spin Off Show.

[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, okay. [SPEAKER_01]: So technically. [SPEAKER_00]: So technically. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: So technically, no, but I see why you thought [SPEAKER_00]: Um, the AI gets an Android body pretty quickly after the pilot saved a bit on the budgeting. [SPEAKER_00]: So they don't have to do that hologram effect on her. [SPEAKER_00]: Um, the thing about, uh, the sun and the magog, the bat guy is that they somehow travel on board a whole soul. [SPEAKER_00]: Travel on board a whole solar system, not sure the details anymore, transfer will of course become more important later. [SPEAKER_00]: She also changes color to a brownish, no, just the purple care.

[SPEAKER_01]: She was a purple, he was a purple lady. [SPEAKER_00]: And becomes a little bit more like a grown-up between seasons four and five, some wild time travel thing happens. [SPEAKER_00]: We're hunt to switch out with another hunt to escape destruction. [SPEAKER_00]: In the beginning of season five, he has the first to find a crew and the ship again, and most of them are pissed as they feel like he abandoned. [SPEAKER_01]: I got wild. [SPEAKER_00]: Just okay, so they're like actually putting some thought yeah, that sounds cool. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, my all of this kind of justifies my take that that show had potential. [SPEAKER_01]: I don't know. [SPEAKER_00]: Basically, I'll like remember about the show maybe someone else can have more detail. [SPEAKER_00]: I guess that's a great way of kind of a guard's tour all.

[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, to the best of my knowledge of the only person who remembered that much who's contacted us. [SPEAKER_01]: I may be wrong. [SPEAKER_01]: I apologize if you have contacted us and I missed that email or comment. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: But yeah, it sounds like honestly, it sounds like a new show. [SPEAKER_01]: Like I was genuinely enjoying and drama [SPEAKER_01]: It's like, yes, it's cheap. [SPEAKER_01]: It's super cheap, but it's like Charles band made it. [SPEAKER_01]: I think we'd all be forgiving and so Why not Shame about Kevin Sourba though. [SPEAKER_01]: I can only stand so much Kevin Sourba Anyway, that's it for we've got mail. [SPEAKER_01]: Thank you, but if it was thing.

[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you for writing in. [SPEAKER_01]: Sorry if we didn't get to your email but [SPEAKER_01]: Keep sending them. [SPEAKER_01]: If anything is time sensitive, please like put like something in the headline so that we know to try to get to its sooner. [SPEAKER_01]: Sorry about missing your Halloween email, but our email address is letters at critically claimed.net with me what is your PO Box? [SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, send us that physical letter if you like to. [SPEAKER_00]: The critically acclaimed network PO Box 641-565 Los Angeles, California, 9W-640. [SPEAKER_01]: Yes. [SPEAKER_01]: Thank you to all of our patrons over patreon.com slash critically acclaimed network.

[SPEAKER_01]: Without your help we couldn't keep doing the show. [SPEAKER_01]: We literally couldn't afford to make the time for. [SPEAKER_01]: They would not be possible. [SPEAKER_01]: So thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you for the bottom of our hearts. [SPEAKER_01]: If you want to help out the show, again, patreon.com slash critically acclaimed network. [SPEAKER_01]: If you can't afford to chip in, there's a free tier where you get a regular newsletter. [SPEAKER_01]: And also you can just leave us a review wherever you find us, you can share it on social media, every little bit helps. [SPEAKER_01]: But seriously, thank you all. [SPEAKER_01]: We hope that you, like us.

[SPEAKER_01]: feel a little bit more hopeful about the future right now. [SPEAKER_01]: Uh, so we needed some figures across something, man. [SPEAKER_00]: We dared to be a little bit optimistic for us. [SPEAKER_01]: We, we, something good happened to listen. [SPEAKER_01]: Let's enjoy it for a while. [SPEAKER_01]: I'll not take it for granted. [SPEAKER_01]: And let's keep this momentum going. [SPEAKER_01]: But it's a exciting time. [SPEAKER_01]: Uh, but seriously, thank you everybody for listening. [SPEAKER_01]: Have a great everything and we'll be back soon with more new episodes. [SPEAKER_01]: Uh, yeah, have a great one. [SPEAKER_01]: sincerely yours, Bibles and Whitney.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Iron List #83 | The Best Sci-Fi Movies of the 1980s!

    Nov 19, 20263 hr 23 minAudio

    Because our patrons demanded it, Bibbs and Witney present their picks for The Best Science Fiction Movies of the 1980s! In the wake of STAR WARS and ALIEN, the 1980s evolved into a big, big BIG decade for science...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Critically Acclaimed #405 | Godzilla Minus Zero, Wild Horse Nine, The Cat in the Hat, I Play Rocky, Jimmy, The Last Temptation of Becky, Soul Patrol, A Dog's Perfect Christmas, Ramayana: Rise of a Legend

    Nov 14, 20262 hr 46 minAudio

    Bibbs and Witney review the new releases (though not as new as they were five days ago) GODZILLA MINUS ZERO, Martin McDonagh's new fascistic bromance WILD HORSE NINE, the new animated version of THE CAT IN THE HAT, the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Iron List #82 | The Best Horror Movies of the 1970s!

    Oct 29, 20263 hr 11 minAudio

    Because our patrons demanded it, Bibbs and Witney present their picks for THE BEST HORROR MOVIES OF THE 1970s! It's an over THREE HOUR episode of THE IRON LIST, dedicated to the scariest and most fascinating scary...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Critically Acclaimed #404 | Clayface, Wildwood, Kung Fu Soccer, Klara and the Sun, Love Language

    Oct 27, 20262 hr 5 minAudio

    Bibbs and Witney review the new DC supervillain horror movie CLAYFACE, Laika's stop-motion fantasy epic WILDWOOD, Stephen Chow's SHAOLIN SOCCER sequel KUNG FU SOCCER, Taika Waititi's sci-fi drama KLARA AND THE SUN, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Critically Acclaimed #403 | You Can See Everything, Crawlers, Animals, Matchbox: The Movie, Bloody Tennis, Sacrifice, Fjord, Trust Me I'm a Doctor, Infirmary

    Oct 22, 20262 hr 23 minAudio

    Witney Seibold is back with [checks notes] NINE movie reviews?! Dear god, and that's AFTER we split the episode in half?! Bibbs and Witney talk about the documentary everyone's talking about (and try not to spoil it),...

    Credit the people on this episode