Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! New Zealander Warienna Wright was a beautiful, kind and caring young woman, who like many young people her age, was trying her luck with dating on the Tinder app. There, she started chatting with Gable Tostee, a young man who she would later tell friends was the Australian version of the TV show Supernatural's Sam Winchester. As fate would have it, Warienna was due to go to a friend's wedding on the Gold Coast, Australia - which is where Gable lived - and the two made plans to meet up. Warienna would not make it out of that date alive. What happened on that August 2014 night in a Gold Coast apartment left a young woman dead, a family in mourning, shed a harsh light on the seedier side of dating and left a country divided on what really happened. Join Belinda over a cuppa or two as she dives into the tragic tale of Warienna Wright and the date that cost her her life. 🛒 Strong Coffee Company - Protein Coffee 💰 Get 20% OFF | Promo Code: BELBEANS https://promocode.to/strong-coffee-company/belbeans-kpk
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
On this episode of Crime Scenes with Coffee Beans, the story of a young girl who went on a Tinder date and never came home. Coming up right after this. Hello, hello, hello my true crime friends. Welcome to Crime Scenes with Coffee Beans. I'm your host Belinda Brady and welcome guys, welcome to my One Gal podcast where I talk about true
Australian murders while I am drinking coffee. Now straight up, what am I drinking while I'm talking to you lovely people today? I'm drinking a McDonald's Cafe latte coffee. It's not too bad. They've done better, but still it's drinkable and it's given me the caffeine that I need so can't complain and straight off the bat guys where where are you listening to me from so we've got Denmark we've got Japan we have Sweden and
we have my Scotland listener who reached out to me via YouTube I love that and I can see Denmark and Ireland are still hanging in there too so I love that love that you guys are listening to me from all over the world that's awesome Thank you so much. Now, you know, you can subscribe to me for bonus episodes. You can support me monthly for as little as three dollars a month. You can buy me a coffee. And I also have some books out in the wild. One, a collection of spooky
stories and one, a story about a little monster who's too scared to go to school. They're both up on Amazon. If you Google my name, you'll find it and however you're listening to me guys whether you're walking running gymming settling down for the night starting up for the day listening to me at work listening to me while you're doing the dishes however you're listening to me thank you for thank you for choosing to listen to my podcast and let's let's dive on in so for those
who are new i am a one gal podcast i do all my research recording and editing um and yeah again i just really appreciate you even listening to me even if it's just for a minute i love that thank you all right let's get into it so my sources for this episode are abc .net .au news .com .au stuff .co .nz and theguardian .com now dating or casual hookups with someone you've just met
is nothing new it's been around forever casual hookups have been around for as long as we have. Only the method we use to do such a thing has changed and it is much, much easier to do the hooking up. Before, back in the day, we'd have to get dressed up, have a night out, go to a bar or a club or a party and meet someone where you actually like physically meet them and get a general feel for them. And you can do that still. 100 % you can still do that you know and
if things go your way you'll end up spending the night with that person but with phones and dating apps now a huge part of our lives it's possible to meet someone you've never actually physically met and hook up and all you need is a phone and an app you can just talk to them few messages few swipes bang they're on your doorstep or vice versa all you need is a dating app and a profile and and that is it and there
is a plethora of potential hookups at your fingertips with real life people just around the corner that you can meet, hook up with. Now just like the hookups of alt not everyone is as they seem and there is always that that threat that that guy or that girl you're about to hook up with is not the nice person you think they are. That is true of the bar party nightclub hookup and it is true of the tinder plenty of fish other
dating apps hookup that none of that has changed just the method of how we're meeting these people has changed and that is the cold hard reality and it's the risk that you take with either going out or with dating apps and dating apps sadly have not erased that risk if anything it's made that risk more of a real life possibility because it is on our phone 24 -7. We can get that risk
delivered straight to us anytime we feel like it. And sadly a young woman named Marina Wright found this to be true. So please settle in. get comfy, get your caffeine, whatever you're drinking and let's get into the episode I've titled Date From Hell The Death of Warina Wright. Now Warina Wright was born in 1988 in the Philippines to her father Warren and his Filipino wife Merzabeth.
She had a sister And when she was three, the family settled in New Zealand, where her and her sister attended a seventh day Venice primary school. She went on to secondary school where she was a good performer and she was really smart with technology and English and she was known to be quiet and shy. But she also didn't back down from an argument and she was very strong and very, very. and she was very strong in her beliefs and she had a strong motherly instinct
where she wanted to help those that she felt she needed to help. She worked in a bank hall centre in Wellington and on the weekends her and her friends loved to play computer games in the home that she shared with her younger sister Marisa in Lower Hutt, New Zealand. She loved taking photographs and she loved drawing and she loved Hello Kitty. She also loved animals and was a fierce animal rights activist and she was beautiful. She was blessed with high cheekbones, big brown eyes and brown hair and after splitting
with a boyfriend, like many of us, like many young men and women all over the world, she turned to Tinder in the hopes of meeting someone new. Now we all know how Tinder works. You see the profile and if you like what you see, you swipe right and if you don't, you swipe left. And many, many relationships have started this way. I know people who have gotten married after meeting on Tinder. I know relationships who are still going strong years down the track. And I also
know of many, many hookups. That is the beauty of this app. You can use it for whatever you want it to, but whatever you want. Now apparently Marina had started seeing a guy she had met on tinder But they had a bit of a fight so in what some friends say may have been an act of a bit of an act of defiance She logged back on to tinder and she connected with a man on tinder and the two exchanged messages and In August of 2014
she was due to take a trip to the Gold Coast for a friend's wedding and a bit of R &R and the man that she was talking to who she actually started talking to in July of 2014 just before she took this trip happened to live on the Gold Coast so naturally the two were going to try and meet up. Now the man that she was talking to was a man called Gable Tostey They were talking in around July and one of the messages he sent to her was you look delicious I want to do dirty
things to you Now before I go any further who was who is? Gable Tostee well At that point in time when he was talking to marina on tinder. He was 28 years old not bad -looking and he was a player There's really no other word for it He had slept with over a hundred and eighty women and he kept a log of the names and the dates He was also described by a psychiatrist as partially
disabled due to his personality problems and he was in trouble with the law a lot Now he lived on the Gold Coast the Gold Coast is also surface paradise and it's a Mecca for Aussies who have finished school a Mecca for young Australians who have finished school and Schoolies week is a week -long party at surface paradise full of booze drugs and sex think of it as the Australian version of spring break where the youngsters
Cut loose before heading off to work or travel or university or whatever their next path is and Gable having grown up there knew that there was money to be made from this party atmosphere as To be able to legally get into a nightclub or a club in Australia You have to be 18 a lot of kids finish school at 18 or 17 So if you finish school and you're at school is with your friends and they're 18 and they can go to the clubs and
the strip clubs and you're too young to go partying with your friends you're missing out. So this is where Gable saw a bit of a business opportunity and he and his two mates got into the business of making and selling fake IDs to these 17 year old kids so they could get into the nightclubs and the bars and the strip clubs. with their friends. When they were eventually caught they had made around 30 grand. Now when the case went to court the judge weighed up the psychological
assessment of Gable. Now he was described as a man who was ill -equipped to deal with people socially and that he had an autistic spectrum disorder best described as Asperger's, a disorder that can manifest manifest as someone who can't display or hold empathy or severe OCD. So no conviction is recorded but this incident leaves him shaken and he cuts ties with those mates
eventually becoming a bit of a loner. In 2004 he gets into bodybuilding. In 2009 he sees a psychiatrist for anxiety OCD and depression which often go hand in hand and in 2010 he bumps into an old friend and realizes just how much he has missed going out and being around mates. Soon enough he's back on the party scene he's hitting the town with the friend and they pick up some girls and he ends up sleeping with one of them.
But he needs to in his mind He has to go pick up another another woman just to make sure it wasn't a fluke And soon enough two turns into three and the next thing he has slept with over a hundred women and he's keeping Record of these conquests now. He is also in online forums saying he just wanted to get to a hundred and in order to do so he had to drop his standards to make that happen but he only sleeps with women who
he rates as an 8 .5 or higher. Now someone on one of the forums points out that dudes that quote tap a lot of arse tend to be insecure and narcissistic and Gable agrees saying he realizes his efforts to bed as many women as he can is an attempt to boost his self -esteem. Now despite this moment of self -reflection he still continues to be a womanizer and by 2013 he actually ends
up getting banned from many of the nightclubs around the Gold Coast with one manager describing him as creepy but by this time he didn't care because Tinder was on the scene and he didn't need to go clubbing to pick up any women he could get the girls to come to him. Now he interacted with over 250 women in one year and went on to a forum to moan about how Summer After more than a quick hookup oh the horror and he actually
wrote sick of time slash money -wasting Bitches. Now he wrote this in September 2013 and he was sick of totally frigid women. Every girl has a Tinder now and none of them are down to fuck anymore. Now on top of this his binge drinking is out of control but instead of trying to help himself he for some reason sets up cameras around his house and records everything. He has a recording
app on his phone and he even records his nights out in case he forgets. He gets pulled over for a DUI in 2011 and then he gets done for speeding and another DUI in 2014. So he had form. None of it good. None of it was appealing. He is your classic womanizer, player, the guy who only cares about bedding as many women as he can. to feed his ego and the kind of guy you would warn your friends about. But unfortunately for Lorena,
Fate and Tinder brought these two together and she didn't know who she was talking to, she didn't know the kind of guy that she was talking to and when she arrived in Australia, when she arrived on the Gold Coast on the 7th of August 2014, her and Gable met up, they met up in person. So it's around 8 45 pm when the two meet in Cavill Mall which is a shopping mall in the main drag of Surface Paradise and the two share an awkward
hug. Now Gable is huge compared to the tiny Worina he's 188 centimeters tall and approximately 90 kilos. Worina on the other hand is tiny only 162 centimeters and weighs around 57 kilos. Now they have their awkward hug they then walk into a nearby bottle shop where Gable buys a six pack of beer Now 15 minutes later they enter the complex of his apartment building, which is a building named Avalon in Surfers Paradise and at some
stage in the next four hours they have they have sex now Afterwards they take a bunch of selfies together and Marina posts on her Facebook page that she's met the Australian Sam Winchester. Now quick note Sam Winchester is one of the brothers off the TV show Supernatural, very popular show I for one loved it. 4 .56 a .m. Gable hits record on his phone on that recording app that he's got. and the recording which is titled Session
24 captures the activity from there on in. Marina who normally drinks beer shares vodka and moonshine which Gable has made with him and around five minutes later she declares she is psycho drunk. Gable then proceeds to pour her three more drinks. Now the pair descend into drunken convo where they talk about God and they muck around with a bit of Mai Tai, a bit of funny muck around
wrestling. At this point Gable tells Marina that she's being a bit violent. Now she wants to leave at around 1 .35am and accuses Gable of stealing her phone, telling him she will destroy his fucking jaw if she can't find it. At around 2am they struggle and you hear her say that really hurt my vagina and this is followed by Gable saying ow. At 2 .12am she tells him he looks like Sam
Winchester and they struggle again with Gable telling her she has worn out her welcome and she is not his kind of girl. Gable's tone changes then from patient too menacing and he tells her she has to leave. Lorena responds with, okay, it's good. It's all good and her voice sounds like it's been obstructed. Now prosecution believe at this point Gable had pinned her to the carpet
and was pressing her face down into the carpet. Gable calls her fucking insane and tells her she's a psycho bitch and she's lucky he hasn't thrown her off his balcony. Marina can be heard panting here like she's struggling to breathe and gable taunts her with what what got something to say marina says is your sexist in which gable shoots back i am the one who is injured you don't have a goddamn scratch on you he then tells her
you're not going to collect any belongings or anything you're just going to walk out and I'm gonna slam the door on you you understand if you try to pull anything I'll knock you the fuck out there is another struggle and Marina is clearly scared at this point you can hear it and she apologizes there is gurgling and a rasping sound where prosecution would later allege that gable is choking Marina and she manages to grab the
clamp of a telescope that's nearby. She is heard struggling to breathe and the clamp of that telescope drops to the floor. At 2 19 am what sounds like the balcony door being unlocked is heard and Marina screams the word no 31 times in 46 seconds. Nearly every single second in that 46 she is screaming no. Gable can be heard amongst her
screams telling her to shut her fucking mouth and this is all on recording you know. Now while this is going on two floors down Nick Casey is visiting a friend when he hears Marina's screams. He and his friend come out on her balcony and look up to see Marina standing on the concrete ledge on the wrong side of the glass balcony so she's actually climbed over to the outside
of the balcony glass on the outside of the building he hears her say she wants to go home he tells her you can't get down this way go back in he sees marina twist to try to twist turn around and lower a leg off the concrete ledge like she was trying to get to the balcony below sort of like she was trying to see if she could get from that balcony to the one below. She then stands
back up she stiffens and then she slips. Nick then sees her terrified face fall from the balcony. He heard her make a noise as though she was trying to say something as she was falling and he saw her fall to the ground and hit it with a sickening thud. This was at 2 21 a .m. And in Gable's apartment. He's recording The recording on his phone picks
up her last desperate screams. You can actually hear her screaming as she's falling on that recording Now Gable doesn't rush rush out to check on her nor does he call triple -o He calls his lawyer his lawyer doesn't answer. So he leaves his apartments building via the fire escape and walks around Surfers Paradise for around 45 minutes trying to call his lawyer again. He tried to call him twice more. He realises he has Marina's phone
and at 3 .10am he grabs himself a slice of pizza from Cavill Avenue and from there he can see the police at his apartment complex. He also knows that Marina has no ID on her, nothing, and he knows that he has her phone. They don't know who this poor girl is. and rather than go back and help he disappears. Now police quickly work out where Marina had been before she fell from that balcony and they worked out the apartment
and who the apartment belonged to. They checked the apartment building CCTV footage and they saw him sneak out and they also saw him buying pizza in Cavill Mall. They then went through his info and discovered that he'd actually been on a Tinder date that night. one he had referred to as Cletus which was Marina and they found the 199 minute recording of Gable and Marina's date and not only that but her last moments alive
all captured on his recording. They found DNA around her wrists which suggested he had physically restrained her and toxicology results showed marina's blood alcohol was 0 .156 which is really high now a few days after marina and i died gable took to social media posting i've been advised not to go into details but all i want to say is that i absolutely did not cause this girl to fall and i am devastated about what happens
to her Marina's sister tells the media through tears my sister was the most important person in my world and While her family were coming to terms with the devastating loss of their daughter their sister and their friend Gable was put on strict bail conditions, which included no tinder or social media No alcohol and he had a night curfew and he had to live with his parents His
parents had to post a $200 ,000 surety to secure his release from prison but he couldn't help himself and while on bail he was involved in a high -speed police chase in a neighboring state in New South Wales. I will get to that in a little bit but based on this chase alone police Had what they needed to arrest him. They arrested gable toasty at his parents house on the 15th
of august 2014 Where they also charged him with rarena rights murder So they claim he the claim was that gable had scared her so much She had no choice but to try and escape from the balcony He told them no she was threatening him and he was scared for his life and that is why he locked her out on the balcony and as you can imagine this was this this case this death was a media
saturation it was there was so much coverage so many opinions and a lot of people really did think he he killed her a lot of people did think it Now Gable Tosti's trial began in October 2016 which all of Australia and New Zealand was watching and like I was saying public opinion was divided people thought he was Innocent people thought he was guilty One thing was certain though when
his behavior he's you know keeping score keeping Points keeping a journal of his sexual conquest and how he wouldn't sleep with women He counted, you know, he didn't rank higher rank, you know higher than 8 .5 Public opinion was this this is not a nice guy. He is he is not a nice person So the prosecution had to prove that even though he didn't push her, Gable had scared Worina enough
to make her risk and ultimately end her life by falling off that 14 story balcony and he was the only person responsible for that. Now the recording of the date they had together that he recorded was played and it was put to the jury that Gable had pinned Worina down in a choke hold and that could be heard with her panting and the gasping. Now the defense argues that Lorena, the aggressor, and was throwing decorative
rocks at Gable and hit him in the head. And apparently she hit him in the head with a telescope clamp. Now they argued he had locked her onto his balcony to protect himself and to keep them separate. And it was Lorena's choice to climb over the balcony that night. Now the jury of six men and six women spent four days deliberating and on the 20th of October 2016 they found Gable Tostee not guilty of both murder and manslaughter. Under
Queensland law they agreed that Gable could not have foreseen Lorena trying to climb off his balcony that night. Now immediately after this verdict coroner Terry Ryan reopens the investigation into Lorena's death. Meanwhile, remember that high speed chase that he was involved in just before he was arrested and charged with Wariana's murder. He is sentenced to 10 months in jail. So the crime, this crime happened three weeks
before the death of Lorena. He was drink driving. and he was speeding he was doing close to 200 kilometers over the speed limit and was coming back from a music festival in New South Wales which is a neighboring state to Queensland. Now because he was free in Queensland he wasn't charged with murder or manslaughter so he was a free man he then had to go to New South Wales to serve his sentence which he did so he did end up in
jail just not for murder or manslaughter. Now meanwhile while he was in jail for the high -speed chase after carefully reviewing the case the coroner determined that a new public hearing wouldn't shed any light on the case because there was no new evidence and Australia has a double jeopardy law meaning you can't be tried for the same crime twice and there was no new evidence to to warrant a retrial. Now in 2016 Gable Tosti
was paid by a Australian current affairs program called 60 minutes He was paid a hundred and fifty grand to tell his side of the story which led to massive public outrage and It also drew scrutiny from the police saying it was morally repugnant and it was there was no need to give this guy any air time and there was no need to pay him 150 000. We saw what he's like whether he's responsible
for her death or not which the court ruled that he wasn't. He is not a nice guy we don't want to hear from him and he did nothing nothing for his reputation when he was asked in this interview why he called his lawyer instead of the police or an ambulance he replied what had happened had happened and there's nothing an ambulance could do to change that. Now Gable Tostey stayed
on the Gold Coast and he ended up changing his name. to Eric Thomas and he got himself back on the dating apps where a few women quite rightly so freaked out after discovering who they were really about to date. Now in 2022 security staff were called for a room in the star in the star which is a casino on the Gold Coast where they found Gable fighting with a woman who claimed he had strangled her. He was slapped with a domestic
violence order and given a lifetime ban from that casino which he tried to fight on the grounds of discrimination because he said that he was being discriminated as Against because he was a man who got attacked by a drunk woman and if it was the other way around it wouldn't have happened but That was refused now A lot of women's activist groups went after him and they went
after him very viciously. They were very aware that he was on public, that he was on back on dating apps. They were making his new profile very well known. And you know, I think when you've got a man like that on a dating app, definitely knowledge is power and you need to be aware that, you know. He's out there on these dating apps now Now in response to what happened to marina
tinder introduced some new rules, so They they've now required that you have to give photo ID to sign up There is an Australian safety center which carries a quick reporting feature and a help hotline if needed which apparently is just a quick button press away and a panic button badge where if you can't actually call and talk to somebody there's like a panic button built in within the app and there's also an online
code of conduct for dating now we're never going to be able to weasel out the bad people it's a sad factor of life and this is true whether you're on tinder or whether you're out in the bar or a nightclub but if we can take more and more steps to protect ourselves and if women can spread awareness about hey this guy he's got history he's on tinder just be aware you know to me it's no different to back in the day when a friend would say hey don't get involved
with him he's a bit of a dick it's no different and this time we're just we just have social media to help help push that along meanwhile marina's family been mourning the loss of their daughter and sister in dignified silence. At the time they refused several interview requests but they expressed their disgust over the release of the audio tape in which you can hear Marina's last terrifying moments. Her mother Merzabev
said of the release, I asked not to release the audio tape yet as and I was overruled by the judge. I do not want to remember her like that. I feel my family has been disrespected by the judges ruling to release the audio tape to the media. Lorena's family are still in New Zealand quietly getting on with their lives but they will never stop mourning the loss of their beautiful daughter and sister and I would like to express my deepest sympathies to Lorena's family over
the loss of their beautiful daughter, sister and friend. I am so sorry for your loss and may her memory be a blessing. And for those of us in the dating world, whether it be on Tinder or plenty of fish or whatever other dating apps there are out there. And if you're going out into the bars and the clubs and nightclubs and the parties, please just be careful and please let's have each other's backs. If we know somebody's not a great person, if we have a feeling. let's
let's protect our friends and let's protect each other and even protect strangers like we have that at our fingertips now we need to we need to be able to help each other out if we can have fun with it guys but please be safe and be mindful and that's it guys another episode of crime scenes with coffee beans done and dusted thank you so so much for your company you're all amazing and until next time stay safe stay cool stay caffeinated
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! It's a sleepy early morning and a family is asleep in their suburban home in Victoria, Australia when an armed...
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Matthew Wales enjoyed a life of privilege. Thanks to his mother's inherited wealth he enjoyed private schooling,...
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Caroline Grills was the kind of woman who looked like she'd give you a big hug and wipe away your tears. With her...
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! It's the 26th January, 1966, and it's a stinking hot summer's day in Somerton Park, South Australia, and hundreds...
Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! It's the 29th January, 2009, and four year old Darcey Freeman is on the way to start her first day of...