Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Credentialing Chronicles

Credentialing Chronicles artwork

Ep. 14 — SPEAK UP: Dr. Stephen Cohen on Silence, Safety, and the Cost of Inaction

Jun 24, 202541 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail What happens when good doctors stay silent? What happens when hospitals protect patients… and get punished for it? In our very first guest episode, Dr. Stephen Cohen joins Credentialing Chronicles to talk about the cost of silence in medicine. As a colorectal surgeon, educator, and nationally recognized expert witness, Dr. Cohen has seen what really happens when peer review is ignored, when unsafe providers slip through the cracks, and when speaking up becomes a liability. This episode is bold. Because the system is broken. And Dr. Cohen? He’s done staying quiet. 🎧 Listen now and ask yourself: Would you speak up? Support the show Resources Mentioned: 🔎 Verify Your Doctor’s Credentials ✔️ State-Specific Medical Board License Lookup: Find your state’s board here: https://www.fsmb.org/contact-a-state-medical-board/ ✔️ Medicare Exclusions List (LEIE) - Check if your provider is federally excluded: https://oig.hhs.gov/exclusions/exclusions_list.asp ✔️ Set Google Alerts on Your Doctor’s Name: Create your own Google Alert here: https://www.google.com/alerts For Medical Staff Professional: ✔️ FSMB.org - Federation of State Medical Boards Physician Lookup: https://www.fsmb.org/physician-license-lookup/ ✔️ Hospital Websites: Many hospitals have public directories listing credentialed medical staff. Look for a “Find a Doctor” or “Medical Staff Directory” page. ✔️ Set Google Alerts on Your Doctor’s Name: Create your own Google Alert here: https://www.google.com/alerts Wanna know if your plastic surgeon is actually board certified? Check for yourself right here: 👉 Verify a Plastic Surgeon Open Payments openpaymentsdata.cms.gov Verify your Nurses' Credentials: https://www.nursys.com/ 🌐 Connection Zone Stay plugged in with your peers, share resources, and nev...

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Credentialing Chronicles, where we spill the Dr. T hotter than your morning coffee.

SPEAKER_01And give you the insider scoop in the wild world of credentialing, provider drama, and everything they don't teach you in med school.

SPEAKER_00I'm Shannon and she's Nileen, two credentialing pros with front row seats to all the chaos.

SPEAKER_01From fraud scandals to burnout breakdowns, and why your favorite surgeon might actually be banned from five hospitals.

SPEAKER_00Ah, we got the gossip and the practical advice to keep you out of trouble and ahead of the game.

SPEAKER_01So grab your coffee, your compliance checklist, and maybe a lawyer, and let's get into it.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back to Credentialing Chronicles, the podcast where the tea is real, the stakes are high, and we say what everyone else is too scared to say. Oh,

SPEAKER_01and today we are diving deep into the side of credentialing. Most people whisper about weaponized credentialing and how it's turning hospitals into courtrooms.

SPEAKER_00Yes, we are. And honey, for the first time since we're starting credentialing chronicles, we are doing something a little bit different. No disclaimer is needed because we brought the live tea piping hot. We are not alone today. With us today is someone who's been through it, risen above it, and now defends hospitals from the fallout. Please say hello to Dr. Stephen Cohen, MD, MBA, colorectal surgeon, VA general surgery, second-chief, VCU, faculty physician, and national voice for advancing medical, legal integrity, and patient safety.

SPEAKER_01Yes, not only is he a powerhouse now, but y'all, he has got a story for us. Early in his career, he was on the receiving end of weaponized credentialing. And today, he's the guy they call when the stakes are high and the lawsuits are real.

SPEAKER_00Dr. Cohen, welcome to the show. We are honored to have you here. First guest. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_02Looking forward to it. Thanks for the opportunity.

SPEAKER_01And so before we even jump into like lawsuits and MPDB chaos and docs misbehaving, can you tell us a little bit about yourself? So

SPEAKER_02I'm a board certified general and colonorectal surgeon. I've been in practice now 31 years. I trained at Southern California UCLA Medical School, did a general surgery training at Boston University, a colorectal fellowship at the Cleveland Clinic in Fort Lauderdale, spent 23 years in the private sector, but still teaching, training, educating medical students, residents along the way. The last eight years now,

SPEAKER_00I'm at the

SPEAKER_02Richmond VA Medical Center, active clinical practice, uh doing medical legal work for both plaintiff and defense, as well as continuing to teach, train, and educate both medical students and residents.

SPEAKER_01Oh, wow, that's so impressive. Yes, we're so excited. So, in previous conversations, I want to go back. Uh, you said you were once a victim of credentialing used against you. So, tell us a little bit about what that looks like and what we're talking about when we say weaponized credentialing. We've talked about all the good stuff that credentialing has done for us, right? But we also want to know how it can be used against doctors, doctors against doctors. So

SPEAKER_02talk

SPEAKER_01to us a little bit about that.

SPEAKER_02So, early in my career, I joined a hospital that did not have anyone with my particular specialty. And you say, you know, so what? What's so special about you? Well, really, nothing, but as a colorectal surgeon, we do things that other surgeons don't want to do, like a lot of the anorectal surgery, and we do colonoscopy of surgeons, but the GI doctors do it. And the thing that I didn't realize, nor do they teach you in practice, is that the busier you get as a new physician, you are taking away other doctors in that community's livelihood.

SPEAKER_02And when you start messing with people's money, they get very upset. So I got busy in a hurry. And it wasn't just because of Stephen Cohen. The reason why I got busy is I joined a group of two other surgeons in the about 20 miles away from the main office. Patients for decades had been sent to that group. Once they knew there was a new doctor in a different location, that's why the patients got sent right away, because I'm a completely unknown entity, and I get that.

SPEAKER_02Right. No waiting, no waiting. We now have an office in a different location. We want to go see that young doctor. Fine. So in about six months to a year, I became literally the busiest surgeon at this hospital, and it irritated everybody, right? The gastroenterologist, because I was doing a lot of their colonoscopy. I was doing things that the other surgeons had never heard of. And again, some of this is very nuanced, but surgery for chronic constipation, you know, surgery for fecal incontinence, they had never heard of this.

SPEAKER_02They were, you know, older surgeons, you know, bread and butter general surgery. I was

SPEAKER_03bringing

SPEAKER_02new, newer, not new to me, but new concepts to them. I got real busy. They thought I was probably doing something wrong. That led to a lot of peer review. So if there are certain triggers in the hospital that would allow the committee members made up of nurses and doctors, other ancillary staff to make sure everything is on the up and up. It's peer review, right? So if there's an unexplained death in the hospital, if there's removing the wrong limb, I mean, the obvious things, they get reviewed.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we've talked about peer review. What happened was

SPEAKER_02is I was, I was, a lot of my specimens were normal, right? I would take out a normal piece of colon in a constipation. I expect it to be normal. It got peer reviewed. They found it below standard of care. I would open up an anal fistula tract, not expecting to have tissue just to allow premat, I didn't want the wound to close prematurely. That's the way we fix it. That's how I was trained. I've done it lots of times. They said the pathologist looks at it and says, We don't see a fistula tract. Dr. Cohen must have done something wrong.

SPEAKER_02Well, there was lots of these, and and you know, so letters came to me. I wasn't so nice in my response back to them, and I and so part of it was me, and I got it, was I don't, you know, I was

SPEAKER_00young. I thought I knew

SPEAKER_02everything, I know better now, but it escalated to the point is even when they took all of my cases to be reviewed on the outside by a blinded colorectal surgeon, two different surgeons across the country, they found that I did I met the standard of care, I did not breach the standard of care, they didn't care. They were doing everything they could to get rid of me.

SPEAKER_03So, how

SPEAKER_01did what happened?

SPEAKER_00These were going to the committees,

SPEAKER_02we had to hire an attorney, you know, it was a whole thing. It it got to the point that at the very final attorney meeting, they realized they didn't have a case and we were going to sue the hospital for lots of money, right? And and they dropped it.

SPEAKER_01So were there other colorectal surgeons? You said you were the only one in the committee. Were there other colorectal surgeons on the peer review committee or just GI doctors that were in other practices?

SPEAKER_02So the only doctors that were on the peer review committee were the doctors that are at that hospital, which are made up of my competition, the general surgeons, my competition, the GI doctors, uh, their friends, the pathologists. Right. They have known each other for 20 years. Yeah right. It was how dare he's we're losing money. This guy's taking all of our work. And so that was a cascade of events. But once we drop the, we haven't, you know, it cost me a lot of money to defend myself, but I did everything right.

SPEAKER_02Once they realize that this could be a major suit against the hospital, when

SPEAKER_00you weren't gonna back down, right?

SPEAKER_02But it definitely is a thing that can happen. Okay,

SPEAKER_00and so did you, you know, get any of the money? I did not. I took it as a learning

SPEAKER_02experience, and I'm and I'm not so hot-headed anymore that I used to be. So, yes.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay, okay. And

SPEAKER_01what did that teach you? What did that teach you about the power dynamic in a hospital system? And I'm curious to know, was it a not not-for-profit hospital, or was it a for-profit hospital, and was it a community hospital where the community surgeons or the community doctors uh basically took over versus corporate? Right, that's a great question.

SPEAKER_02This was a community hospital for profit, right? So they had a vested interest in keeping their surgeons who had been there two decades busy and happy. And then a young Buck came along and disrupted the cart. Exactly. The power dynamics in the hospital can be significant, and you know, it's made up of you know, your peers, but you got to be on the committees. There's a lot of uh, you know, nepotism going on because I'll do this for you, I'm sending you patients, right?

SPEAKER_02So there's a lot of that goes on that you don't learn as a resident because it wasn't part of our training.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah. Nobody teaches you the politics of it all. So you get in, this all happens, you spend all of this money to defend yourself. Did it almost change your career? Had it

SPEAKER_02gone farther, it definitely would have. I was before they decided to drop it, I was about 15 minutes away from being kicked off the hospital, which is a would be a significant issue reported to the National Practitioner Data Bank. You're right. I would have had trouble. So it would have, it would have been a completely different career path.

SPEAKER_04This episode of Credentialing Chronicles is sponsored by an advanced quality compliance, your white glove credentialing crew. We get it. One person doing the work of five audit season looming, files all over the place. AQC steps in with expert hands and calm minds, digitizing your chaos, handling the details, and keeping you audit ready 24/7. Think less stress, more success with a touch of luxury.

SPEAKER_04No stress, no mess, just AQC White Glove Service. Visit AQCCVO.com to get started.

SPEAKER_01What would you say to a young provider going through this who maybe just got out of school and doesn't have the financial capabilities to defend themselves and knows that they're being bullied by using peer review in the incorrect fashion to not not use peer review in a positive way, but rather to weaponize it?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I would say defend yourself at all costs. I mean, it doesn't matter at that point because had I not have done that, I mean, fast forward 30 years, I would have had a completely different trajectory. I don't know if any academic center would have ever hired me with any of that background baggage. So I would say, you know, documentation is key. You've got to document what you're doing, why you're doing it. And, you know, don't be a hotbed. Be nice to everybody.

SPEAKER_02And, you know, good judgment comes from experience. Experience comes from bad judgment. I made a bad judgment to irritate everybody, which fueled the fire.

SPEAKER_00Yes, that's a good takeaway, the judgment. I love that. Now, let's get into the case that you talked about. A hospital says no to a provider because of his history. You know, this is really a provider with issues. And that provider, let's say, turns around and files a defamation, you know, lawsuit. You know, what what do we even, Nileen? I mean, how are we even asked that question, right?

SPEAKER_01Right. Can you walk us through your role in that and how the hospital handled being attacked for trying to do the right thing?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I was involved in trying to defend a hospital that did the right thing in a provider that was causing harm to the community. And that's a different story. Now, I right it was the other way. This was a provider that had only been working there for about a year and a half, and in a four in a 12-month period, had 14 major preventable complications. Three of them directly led to death of the patient.

SPEAKER_02So, right, so what again, any death gets up to peer, it got up to peer review, the committee met, and they decided to pull his privileges to protect the patients because there was clear negligence. So anytime a provider gets kicked off staff more than 30 days, it's an automatic reported to the National Practitioner Data Bank. So what happened was the provider then quit, tried to get another job, and was being denied privileges because of this issue that was going on.

SPEAKER_02So he felt I need to sue the hospital to try to clear my name. The hospital hired me with a very simple question. The question is: looking at these 14 cases of these complications, was the hospital justified in kicking this provider off to protect the community? That's an easy question. So I went through each of the cases. Yeah, what did you find?

SPEAKER_00Yes, tell us.

SPEAKER_02And, you know, he was deposed about each of the cases, and it was a clear breach in the standard of care. Three patients should not have died, and the excuse was it was the hardest case I've ever done. You can't say that for every case, okay? You can have a case, but every case that's a complication, you cannot say it was the hardest case, right? So it was clear that the hospital was well within the right. The hospital has a fiduciary duty to protect the citizens or the community from bad physicians, right?

SPEAKER_02We're all gonna get complications. But that many short periods of time that was preventable really was the key. And it's very interesting. And the reason why it piqued my interest is because it it brought me back 30 years, because the other his other excuse was they're picking on me. I'm a busy surgeon. Fine, right?

SPEAKER_00I think we need to put a part of our PSA on this episode. Patients, ask your doctor, is this the hardest cake you ever had?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. Ask that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, ask that. Because if they say yes, go find a second opinion, okay?

SPEAKER_01So the diff same scenario, your case, right? You were being quote unquote picked on and incorrectly um using peer review to against you. But in this case, it's all the other cases that we've been talking about, is the hospital was trying to do the right thing and protect the patient. So where's the line between due diligence and that's a great

SPEAKER_02question? But again, I never used the excuse of they're picking on me. I knew that behind, but I was focused on the medicine. Look, you want to pick on my cases? Let's review all my cases. Patient presented with X, Y, and Z. This is the workup I did. I gave her the options of medical therapy, surgical therapy. This was a surgery. None of my patients had complications, right? This was we think you're doing too much surgery, right? Well, okay. I'm getting a lot of patients. Good for me, right? So it's a whole different ball game.

SPEAKER_02The the defamation suit that I was asked again to really defend the hospital was were they justified in re kicking this physician, surgeon, off staff because of what they found? And these cases were reviewed on the outside. They were also found to be below standard of care. It wasn't just me. They had already had it reviewed. It was already below standard of care. My question was: if we find a provider that falls below the standard of care with 14 complications in 12 months, three of them leading to death, did they have the right to protect this citizens that live around this hospital?

SPEAKER_02Absolutely.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. So here's

SPEAKER_01here's the T is does that doc is that doctor still practicing? Does he still have a license? I

SPEAKER_02know that doctor is still practicing, not at that hospital, but somewhere, right?

SPEAKER_00Okay. So yeah, and that's the thing. Yeah, exactly. Did the med that the all the questions did the medical board get involved? You know, because sometimes we see medical boards don't act upon things that exist in

SPEAKER_02the world.

SPEAKER_00Right. The medical boards in

SPEAKER_02general don't get involved in things like this. If now in the state, in the state where this was, but I don't want to say it, but Virginia, in the state where this was, if you have, if you have a if you think three medical malpractice suits, and these and many of these did come to medical legal action on the side, not related to the hospital, obviously,

SPEAKER_03but if

SPEAKER_02you have three in a two-year period, the medical board does get involved. So more likely than not, this particular case,

SPEAKER_03the

SPEAKER_02medical board. Now every state is different, right? Some of the medical boards, you get sued, so what? There's really nothing. The rule for physicians that

SPEAKER_01and

SPEAKER_02I have multiple state licenses because I do telemedicine. If I get sued, I have, and there's a a finding against me, I do have to tell all of my state licenses if that happens. Whether they do anything or not, it's really up to them.

SPEAKER_01And again, you have to do that yourself, right? It's expected that the doctor

SPEAKER_00is

SPEAKER_01to do it

SPEAKER_02yourself. And however, every depending on the state, one, two, or three years, when you if and when you renew that license, that's always a question. The quite because I just read right. It's a since your previous renewal, have you been named, sanctioned? Right, that type of thing. So if you don't do it and you don't answer that question honestly, they can take your license away.

SPEAKER_00Well, I was gonna say the burning question is how did the court view the hospital's responsibility

SPEAKER_02to protect you? Definitely that was the right thing to do for the hospital.

SPEAKER_03Perfect. Look at that.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00So

SPEAKER_01and and in your experience, now that you've been doing this for a while, are you seeing this more often or less? I'm not

SPEAKER_02seeing it that often. I mean, really. I mean, this was a very unusual case of this high number of complications in a short period of time. I mean, you're right. Most of us that operate don't have this much problem. Usually the bad surgeons get weeded out with medical legal cases because you start having multiple suits. But it's interesting in my experience that I've gotten it on my end 30 years ago, and now here I'm defending the hospital for essentially doing the same thing, although it's different, just trying to protect the community.

SPEAKER_02But I we're not we don't see it that much.

SPEAKER_03Exactly.

SPEAKER_02And these are probably two extremes from what I've seen throughout my career.

SPEAKER_00And do you get called in a lot for different hospitals trying to protect the patients in the community? Is that

SPEAKER_02no? I don't see a lot of that. What I normally see more is medical-legal cases of you know, patient has a complication. Was the complication a breach in the standard of care? Meaning what a reasonable, prudent physician would do, and if it was a breach, did it cause harm? But, you know, mo you know, one out of seven physicians are going to get sued. Most common reason we get sued is bad outcome. It's not necessarily malpractice. So I do see it a lot in the VA system I am now, because if there's a complication and the patient wants to sue me, they don't sue me.

SPEAKER_02I'm a federal employee. They sue the federal government. And I and I am on a national committee that oversees a lot of complications throughout the country. It's very common that the committee, our committee's feeling is listen, they're veterans. They want to get some money for a bad outcome. That's fine. So most veterans are given the benefit of the doubt without a lot of rigging role

SPEAKER_03to just

SPEAKER_02give them money because they're veterans, right? And that's so it's so that's the issue.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I I guess really what we could say, because we do have a lot of hospital administrators that listen to us. And so I guess it's good to know that there are physicians out there that also have the legal expertise that can defend you. So if you are doing something to protect your patients and there are doctors and everybody is scared to, you know, blow the whistle, know that there are people like Dr. Cohen that are out there that are willing to step to your aid and look at the facts and be able to defend you in situations like that.

SPEAKER_00Because at the end of the day, that's what the And that's

SPEAKER_02important because I'll tell you why. Because I was the chairman, I've this hospital that they almost got rid of me and I stayed. Became chairman of surgery. I stayed, I was there for 20 years. We we struggled sometimes with reporting bad physicians because we didn't want to get the lawsuit. And we know if we just suspend them for 29 days, that's not reportable to the national data bank. They have no recourse.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I love that you said that because this is totally where it gets messy. Because even the hint of a lawsuit can scare a hospital from reporting to the MPDB. So then what? Dangerous providers just float around?

SPEAKER_02Well, we yeah, I mean, that's a that's a great question, but it it is a real concern for hospitals about getting smacked in that lawsuit. It's costly, it's time, it's depositions. They don't want to get involved. And I and I see their point, right? But certainly we have had bad, dangerous physicians that we didn't care about that we that we pulled the trigger and just did it, right? And I've had these conversations with CEOs.

SPEAKER_00I'm yeah, I can see the point until it's you know your loved one or somebody that's close to you's loved one that's in that situation, and then they're you know, not alive anymore. And and it becomes way closer to home. And then it's a problem like what you see on the on the Texas, you know, the big, you know, credential in case that became national. Um, but it it's when it became close to home, you know, some legal representative's mother that it was like, wait a minute, this is wrong, needs to be investigated.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, I just feel like it we need to create a safe place for hospitals, providers, uh, anybody, you know, an alcoholic nurse that's on the floor functioning, but you could smell the whiskey, you know, to be able to say, hey, we need to have some type of reporting to protect the patient.

SPEAKER_01Right. Are we letting fear override patient safety, right? Is is where the the the scary part is. And so, in your opinion, is the NPDB doing what it is designed to do, or is it failing?

SPEAKER_02That's a great question. I think the National Practitioner Data Bank doesn't really do anything. It doesn't, it doesn't do anything, it doesn't mean anything. I'm on there five times. I've every settlement, I have three settlements. I'm on there, it doesn't stop you from doing anything, right? So if you have multiple lawsuits and multiple reports to the NP, to the National Practitioner Data Bank, it may limit you getting malpractice insurance, but other than that, it really doesn't do anything.

SPEAKER_02All right, because patients can't get on there.

SPEAKER_01Right. Yeah, and we talked about this.

SPEAKER_00Who's auditing it? Yeah. And

SPEAKER_01you know, it's interesting, except if you're in Miami, the half the doctors don't even carry malpractice insurance. So it doesn't matter that they're on a databank$25,000. That's

SPEAKER_02the other thing. Yeah, it doesn't really do anything. I don't know who it's you know, when I'm when I'm opining on standard of care, the opposite attorney will look me up. Oh, okay, sure, I'm on there. Doesn't mean anything, right? So that they use it to try to make me look bad when I'm testifying as a medical-legal case, you know, but but you're right, it doesn't, other than just being it reported, it doesn't carry weight. I think I think a lot of practitioners, and I've given talks to the residents about what it means to be on it, they fear being on it.

SPEAKER_02They feel if you're on there once, you're done. And I say, look at me, I'm still here. You're not done. I'm not done, right? So I think it is fear from the physician side.

SPEAKER_01And well, I mean, it's but it does at least keep uh some type of a rap sheet, right? At least it's it's something that we need to ask about and perhaps lead to open conversations in the medical staff and in the credentials committee so that you know your peers are being able to at least say, hey, what's going on? What's the story behind this? And at least say, Hey, we're we are watching you. So I guess that's that's part of the whole history of why we we needed that repository of where we're holding them to.

SPEAKER_00Well, I think it's, you know, we do have it, you know, and it is a way to maybe catch providers that aren't so quick to self-disclose, right? So

SPEAKER_03I mean that's really yeah, what it kind of does help because a lot of people won't say anything and then you find something on the MPDB. Um, but ultimately I feel like the MPDB has a lot more power

SPEAKER_00to

SPEAKER_03do a lot more,

SPEAKER_00and

SPEAKER_03they're just not using it. And that's right,

SPEAKER_00they definitely said, yeah.

SPEAKER_02And it's uh, but yeah, I definitely think it's fear. And and the other thing I'll mention is that when I was the chairman of surgery and we had a provider that we just did the 29 days, we didn't want to get sued, you know. The CEO said, because I knew the surgeon, he said, Steve, go tell him to go work at a different hospital, or we're reporting, right? So there is a lot of you know, by that time I had been there almost 20 years, I felt a part of the community. Right. So I, you know, and I talked to the surgeon, and guess what?

SPEAKER_02He didn't come back to our hospital. So it's almost like let somebody else have that issue, right? And that's unfortunately a lot of these community hospitals, that's how they think. It's protect us. You know, we don't want to get dragged into the lawsuit.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So have you seen what happens when no one reports and the provider then just keeps working?

SPEAKER_02Well, certainly this, you know, the the bad surgeons or the bad providers will continue to do harm, and obviously it's gonna become a medical-legal issue. Um, there's no doubt. I mean, the good providers will always prevail. The bad providers, just like any other business, anything, pilots, lawyers, nurses, you're gonna have 3% of the people are bad, the other 97% do the right thing. Usually the bad ones, you start getting multiple suits, they wind up doing something else. Or not getting malpractice insurance, getting too many lawsuits, and they have a bad reputation, moving around to different states, right?

SPEAKER_00Something.

SPEAKER_02There's always something.

SPEAKER_00And then that's where the medical staff professionals step in, right? So the medical staff professional, again, we talk about voluntary resignation. You see people moving around, and right here you hear it from Dr. Cohen. That's what you are supposed to be looking for. And sometimes it's between the lines, right? So let's talk about the flip side. When credentialing is used as a weapon to push someone out, you've said you've seen it. So what does it look like when it maybe crosses the line?

SPEAKER_01Right, because from where we sit, sometimes it's not about patient safety. It's personal, it's political, it's retaliation, dressed up as professionalism.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it could be a challenge. Like I said, you know, it happened to me 30 years ago. I am definitely seeing a lot less of that type of thing now. So, what what is the difference? What's changed in 30 years? 30 years ago, most physicians were not employees of the hospital. They're in private practice. They had their I joined two other people. We had a group of nine of us. It was private practice. Fast forward now, 2025. 80, 90 percent of every physician, I don't care what specialty, are hospital employees.

SPEAKER_02There's a lot less of that nonsense. I get a salary. You want to bring another surgeon and do more, take my surgery? Live it up. I'm still getting a salary, right? So a lot of it, right? So a lot of it is based on that. There's there's a lot less competition, I think, now than there was 30 years ago. Because medicine has changed. So I I don't see what happened to me simply just trying to get me to do less surgery because I was taking money from them ever happening again.

SPEAKER_00Have you ever been in a situation where you think, nope, this isn't right? I'm not such a this, I don't, I don't, I'm not participating like in 30 years of practice. Well,

SPEAKER_02I've never said that. I I like seeing people with their pants down too much. I mean, but that's just me. As a colorectal surgeon, I mean, listen, people ask me all the time why I went into colorectal surgery, and I say, I, you know, I don't know. When in med school, when they said I could be doing 36 holes a day, I thought they meant golf.

SPEAKER_00Oh my goodness. That's hilarious.

SPEAKER_01Uh so well, thank you so much for supporting the MSP community and community. You would be an ideal CMO at any hospital. So uh just saying, thank you for supporting MSPs. So, what can you say to MSPs, medical staff professionals who say, Oh, something doesn't sit right? What do you tell the medical staff professional that you work so closely with uh in in your time as a committee chair and on all the other work that you've done?

SPEAKER_00Or

SPEAKER_03or wait a minute, what one other thing, Dr. Cohen? Or what if their CMO just don't listen? They can't get nothing through. You know, what do you tell that MSP?

SPEAKER_02You don't hold it in. You gotta say something. You could be saving somebody's life. I mean, go to the department chairman,

SPEAKER_03yes,

SPEAKER_02go to the CEO. There's other people rather than the chief medical officer that should be the liaison between the medical staff and administration, but you might not get the answer. And we've had that happen before.

SPEAKER_01I

SPEAKER_02mean, chief medical officers come and go, right? But the CEO,

SPEAKER_03the

SPEAKER_02chief executive offer is responsible for the hospital. The board is responsible as a fiduciary duty to the hospital. Tell your supervisor, find the department chairman of that department, whether it's surgery, whether it's medicine, sit down, have a one-to-one. I'm not liking this. What can you do to help with this situation? But but not saying it really will do more harm than good.

SPEAKER_03Thank you.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. So if you had control over this whole system, right? The NPDB, peer review protections, legal frameworks, what would you change to make this process fairer and safer? Yeah,

SPEAKER_02that's a great question. The first thing I would do is I wouldn't leave it to the local, the local hospitals to look at those decisions. It's almost like the medical legal world, right? It you should have a committee, national, local, objective, not emotionally involved. It's the emotionality of it that drives everybody crazy, that people can't think straight. Whether you're you think you're taking too much business away, whether you're being bullied. No, we there's a committee made up of old cranky doctors like me, right?

SPEAKER_02That have nothing else to do to say, I'm not emotionally involved. Let me look at the situation. Just like that case I was involved in. I'm not emotionally involved. This is a breach. You got to protect the community. You're out of here. That's that's reasonable. So that that's definitely what I would do. And I would, and I would give more authority, believe it or not, to the national practitioner data bank to make sure those things, you know, so doctors don't go state to state and nobody knows, right?

SPEAKER_02Unless you ask the NPD. There's got to be more accountability from that organization to protect not just the community that was there when you had a dysfunctional provider, but wherever they're going. Because that that's a disaster.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and oh my God, I just can't. Uh you just said it's so beautiful, and it's just so true, you know. Um, I I I just really want to say from our conversation today, right? It seems that how do we rebuild trust and credentialing, right? It seems like everyone is scared. The hospitals are scared, the doctors are scared, MSPs are scared. You know, um I I don't even know where do you start when there is so much fear in something that should be transparent. Yeah, it's

SPEAKER_02a challenge. But unless you change the system, I mean nothing's gonna change unless we, again, if you could take the emotionality out of it, I think that would be a big start. But

SPEAKER_03yeah,

SPEAKER_02you know, we we try to do that in our system, you know, because again, I'm in the federal system where we look at cases where we're not emotionally involved. I don't review cases of our local hospital. I'll review cases in a different state. I don't know the providers, I don't know the patients. That's not my issue. My issue is did the practitioner fall below the standard of care? Should the veteran get paid for pain, suffering, injury, right? And should the provider be reported to the national practitioner databank? A lot of times we just, even though the veteran gets paid some compensation, we feel it was a not a malpractice, it's a bad outcome.

SPEAKER_02The provider does not get reported to the national practitioner databank, which which is which which is good. For example, let's say during anesthesia, a tooth accidentally gets knocked out. The veteran has successful surgery, they need to go to the dentist afterwards to get a new tooth that costs$5,000. Well, the federal government, I'm on a committee, will say, let's pay for that. Don't make them pay for that. We did it. We don't that's fine. But we decide that we're not reporting that, and that's a known complication, right?

SPEAKER_02So why should that provider get reported to the National Practitioner Data Bank?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, right. So that makes a lot of sense. It I I think the uh the objective kind I think every hospital should be or and surgery centers should be mandated to have an objective peer remote. That

SPEAKER_02would take all the nonsense out of it. He's my friend, I don't want to say anything. You know, he sends me cases, I don't want to say anything. Right. If a GI doctor has a complication that I know, I don't want to say anything, he sends me cases, right?

SPEAKER_01I actually was able to have the opportunity to have a sit-down with David, who's currently the director of the NPDB, and we're looking to do some collaboration. So hopefully we can get him on here and uh I can uh forward your interesting suggestions. So if you could, what part of the NPDB would you reform to make it more practical for medical staff professionals and physicians who do sit on peer review committees to use it in a healthy way?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's a great question. I guess I to say

SPEAKER_01I guess

SPEAKER_02I would have to see exactly what they do and how their organization works. Maybe he wants to hire me. I can definitely help him. I'm fine with that.

SPEAKER_01We'll send them a message. Hopefully he's listening.

SPEAKER_03Financial and Chronicles hooking people up right here.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, why not?

SPEAKER_03But I mean, you know, uh Nileen has about 15 certifications behind her name. And they literally sat down with her and talked to her um about reform. And so it'd be it'd be Yeah, it's

SPEAKER_01collaborate and something. So yeah, I think

SPEAKER_02it's a great idea. And and some some type of national, you know, uh non-emotionally involved way to to get the message out so everybody's on the same page.

SPEAKER_03And that's the that's the stance that they should take, right? Is objectivity. And if you put that in every area, then what can go wrong? I mean, really, because that's what it's needed. I I just have to say, Dr. Cohen, this has been incredible. You have given us legal, ethical, and emotional truth all at once. I don't know how you did it, and we want to include you. You know, we do our PSA every episode, and so today you have to help us with that. Is that okay? Nile, take it away. What would you tell our doctors? And Nileen's gonna bring you through it.

SPEAKER_01Okay, so to our listeners, MSPs out there, we love you. You are the ones making the tough calls and really helping our beautiful doctors, and we're keeping the lights on in this broken system, and we see you. So, MS, what would you say to our MSPs? I know you touched on a little bit, but if you could sit down with all these beautiful uh medical staff professionals that are doing the work, what would you tell about

SPEAKER_02it?

SPEAKER_01Thank

SPEAKER_02you for all you do. Keep up the good work. We need you, the patients need you, the doctors need you. And if you see something, you don't like something, tell somebody. But all your work is very much appreciated.

SPEAKER_03Thank you, thank you. And for our patients, what would you say for our patients

SPEAKER_02to protect themselves? Definitely, you know, when you go to a hospital, bring somebody with you, right? Get second opinions. Don't take the first opinion. I tell my own family members this, right? Right. So have a patient, you need a patient advocate, you know, list, bring somebody to the clinic, to the hospital so you can hear what the doctors, what the nurses are saying, and get a second opinion. Get a second opinion.

SPEAKER_00Get

SPEAKER_03a second opinion, yes. Yes. And then just to, you know, go ahead, Nile, save it for the best

SPEAKER_00and the best, right?

SPEAKER_01To the doctors, to your peers, to all these beautiful, wonderful doctors that work so hard, so many hours, so many years of training, and now you are going into peer review because your case got picked. What are we telling our doctors?

SPEAKER_02That's a lot because a lot of the young doctors will come to me when they get that letter. Is you just have it just because you get a letter from a peer review does not mean you fell below the standard of care. There are certain triggers that you may not know. A normal pathology specimen happened to me, right? An unexplained death. Something's gonna doesn't mean you did anything wrong. Do not be defensive. And I'll say that again because I didn't do that. Do not be defensive when you're answering the question.

SPEAKER_02Just answer the question. It's not an interrogatory, it's not a courtroom. Explain what you did, why you did it. That's all you need to do. So don't be defensive.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I feel like that is the key of our episode today is just take a motion out of it when you're dealing with patient safety, right? It just yeah, it needs. I mean, that that was a lot of tea today. That is all for today. If you like this episode, please follow Credentialing Chronicles on Spotify, Apple, LinkedIn, TikTok. And remember, when the politics get loud, the truth still matters.

SPEAKER_01Yes, share this with all the MSPs you know, all the doctors that you know, because this episode was going to help a lot of credentialing professionals and hopefully doctors that you're listening, you know, uh get involved, support your MSPs, and we hope to hear from you. See

SPEAKER_03you next time.

SPEAKER_02Thank you.

SPEAKER_03Ooh, that was a lot of tea. Who knew doctors had more drama than reality TV?

SPEAKER_01And if you think that was wild, just wait till next week. We've got more stories, more scandals, and more credentialing chaos coming your way.

SPEAKER_03Hit that follow button and don't forget just because they have an MD doesn't mean they have a clean record.

SPEAKER_01See you next time on Credentialing Chronicles. Stay credentialed, not canceled.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Patient to Credentialing Superhero: The Dylan Avatar Story

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 28 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail One jump changed everything. What happened afterward led Dylan Avatar toward a purpose he never expected. In this episode of Credentialing Chronicles, Shannen Reyes-Aguayo and Nyleen Flores sit down...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Live at NAMSS 2026 (50th Anniversary)

    Nov 10, 202640 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Tea dresses, tiny microphones, and a little NAMSS chaos! 🫖🎙️ We’re taking you inside our pink booth at NAMSS’s 50th anniversary conference in New Orleans! This short episode is full of live...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Exam Room Should Be Safe! "I am Jane Doe"

    Nov 3, 202633 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail ⚠️ *TRIGGER WARNING:* This episode discusses sexual assault, sexual abuse by healthcare professionals, and child sexual abuse. Although the discussion is non-graphic, these topics may be distressing....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Spillin’ Tea Across America: New Jersey

    Oct 27, 202633 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail SOMEBODY ELSE'S DEA NUMBER?! $172 MILLION IN MEDICARE FRAUD?! NEW JERSEY, WE NEED TO TALK! 👀☕️ The Garden State is serving up some SERIOUS healthcare tea, and trust us… this episode is WILD! 🔥 This...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Spillin Tea Across America: New Hampshire

    Oct 13, 202640 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail New Hampshire’s Healthcare Wake-Up Call A provider can be qualified, credentialed - and still out of reach. A provider’s identity can be legitimate - and still be used to submit fraudulent claims. Who...

    Credit the people on this episode