Episode 32: When the System Looks Away — Doctors, Boards & the Broken Chain of Accountability
54 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail Guest: Emily Brinkman, Esq. - Healthcare Attorney Hosted by: Shannen Reyes-Aguayo & Nyleen Flores IG: @shannensunfloweraguayo | @nyleenfloresfam What happens when the system built to protect patients… looks the other way? In this episode of Credentialing Chronicles, Shannen and Nyleen sit down with powerhouse healthcare attorney Emily Brinkman to dissect how dangerous doctors slip through the cracks - and why the people who could stop them, often don’t. From sealed investigations and “no comment” statements to hospitals paralyzed by politics, Emily pulls back the curtain on a culture that prizes silence over safety. With 20+ years in the trenches - representing hospitals, medical staffs, and even the boards themselves - she exposes the cracks that start small and end in catastrophe. 💥 Inside this episode: The red-flag silence that keeps patients in the dark Confidentiality laws that protect the wrong side How retaliation and reputation shape medical decisions What MSPs can actually do when leadership won’t listen Why transparency is healthcare’s most powerful disinfectant 🎧 “When the System Looks Away” is a gripping look at accountability gone missing - and a reminder that in healthcare, silence isn’t neutral. It’s dangerous. Support the show Resources Mentioned: 🔎 Verify Your Doctor’s Credentials ✔️ State-Specific Medical Board License Lookup: Find your state’s board here: https://www.fsmb.org/contact-a-state-medical-board/ ✔️ Medicare Exclusions List (LEIE) - Check if your provider is federally excluded: https://oig.hhs.gov/exclusions/exclusions_list.asp ✔️ Set Google Alerts on Your Doctor’s Name: Create your own Google Alert here: https://www.google.com/alerts For Medical Staff Professional: ✔️ FSMB.org - Federation of State Medical Boards Physician Lookup: https://www.fsmb.org/physician-license-lookup/ ✔️ Hospital Websites: Many hospitals have public directories listing credentialed medical staff. Look for a “Find a Doctor” or “Medical Staff Directory” page. ✔️ Set Google Alerts on Your Doctor’s Name: Create your own Google Alert here: https://www.google.com/alerts Wanna know if your plastic surgeon is actually board certified? Check for yourself right here: 👉 Verify a Plastic Surgeon Open Payments openpaymentsdata.cms.gov Verify your Nurses' Credentials: https://www.nursys.com/ 🌐 Connection Zone Stay plugged in with your peers, share resources, and nev...
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome back to Credentialing Chronicles, where we spill the doctor's tea hotter than your morning coffee.
SPEAKER_01And give you the insider scoop on the wild worlds of credentialing, provider drama, and everything they don't teach you in med school.
SPEAKER_00I'm Shannon and she's Nileen, two credentialing pros with front row seats to the chaos, looking to make you a part of it. Yes, we want you to engage in spilling this tea with us. We need your love and likes, and we want to know what you think too. Look for us, please, on LinkedIn, Instagram, and yes, baby, even TikTok.
SPEAKER_01Yes, we love to see your love. From fraud scandals to burnout breakdowns, and why your favorite surgeon might actually be banned from five hospitals.
SPEAKER_00Honey, we've got the gossip and the practical advice to keep you out of trouble and ahead of the game.
SPEAKER_01So grab your coffee, your compliance checklist, and maybe a lawyer, and let's get into it.
SPEAKER_00Hey! Welcome back to Credential and Chronicles.
SPEAKER_01Oh my goodness, I'm so excited, Shannon, because we met the most awesome people at NAMS, and we're so excited. Yes, and we got to see all different kinds of roles. And I think that while we love our MSPs, we rely so heavily on a particular specialty other than our doctors to really help us navigate all the trials and tribulations that we run into. And that is none other than our favorite attorneys, right?
SPEAKER_01And our legal counsel. So, Shannon, who do we have here with us today? I'm so excited.
SPEAKER_00Yes, definitely. I'm so excited because, you know, we're peeling back the curtain. That's what we always say all the time. That's our motto, right? And so we're peeling back the curtain on what really happens, you know, when medicine, law, and I guess ethics collide. And, you know, we really do talk about all of the situations. And like, I think sometimes, Nileen, at the end of it, we're like scratching our head, like, what do we do with the fallout? Like, what does it mean, you know? And I think the investigation cover-ups and how did the doctor keep practicing? I mean, I feel like sometimes we leave episodes and we have more questions.
SPEAKER_00I mean, so I'm just excited because today, you all, law and order meets credentialing baby.
SPEAKER_01Hey, that's what I'm talking about. Yes, we're so excited because someone who's seen the chaos up and close is Emily Brinkman Esquire. She has over 20 years of experience as a litigator and 12 years specifically advising healthcare providers and helping them really comply with regulatory issues in the state of California. And Emily does have extensive experience in litigating different types of medical staff cases on behalf of hospitals throughout California, and she really collaborates with medical staff directors and other executives to manage issues regarding physician credentialing and privileging for all of it.
SPEAKER_01And I think you've, even though I know you say you're primarily in the state of California, I'm sure this lovely state of California provides us with a slew of different types of ranging cases from inappropriate behavior towards patients, towards staff, quality of care, disciplinary issues, suspension, termination. So, Emily, talk to us a little bit about you. Give us your disclaimer. I know you're not gonna give us any legal advice, but we are hoping to spill some tea.
SPEAKER_02I can't wait to spill tea. So thank you all for having me and loved meeting you at NAMS. And yes, I am not providing anyone legal advice today. And my experience too is really connected to the state of California. But I also want to throw out that I did work for the medical board for years at the California Attorney General's office. So besides representing hospital medical staffs, I was on the other side of things with the medical board. And even in a previous life, I was a criminal prosecutor. So I've also done the criminal side of things.
SPEAKER_00Oh, you're calling them out of the pocket, Emily.
SPEAKER_02I'll get you covered today.
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes. We're excited, we're excited.
SPEAKER_03Your credentialing solution. In a busy hospital, time is of the essence. But what happens when your credentialing staff is short-staffed and overwhelmed? AQC is your trusted credentialing verification organization. They provide credentialing, contracting, and monitoring services for hospitals, surgery centers, and clinics nationwide. With AQC, you can say goodbye to the stress and uncertainty of credentialing. AQC, your solution for continuous compliance and credentialing verification.
SPEAKER_03For more information, contact us www.aqccvo.com.
SPEAKER_00Tell us, I mean, have you heard of Credentialing Chronicles? How did you get with us? I mean, when I met you at NAMS, I just thought your energy is just so on point with us. I know that me, you, and Nileen had some good banter. And I think, you know, you help NAMS out a lot as well, correct?
SPEAKER_02This was my first NAMS in person. And I loved it. I've been a member of NAMS for a while now, but hadn't been able to attend the conference. So this is my first one, and I just loved it. It really sort of re-energized my love for the work that we do every day and protecting patients and working with our med staffs. Uh, and you know, I got to reconnect in person with some of my clients, which is always really great. But as I was walking around NAMS, somebody's like, there's a podcast, there's a podcast. And that's how I fucked you all out and started listening.
SPEAKER_02And I've been hopped since. I listened, I've been to all your episodes.
SPEAKER_00Oh my God. I'm so excited. I'm so excited. Okay. So I guess let's just get you started. I mean, should we throw something hard at you? Okay, okay. So I guess let's start with maybe what you some would call maybe the silence. You know, a doctor gets arrested, there's a patient type of complaint, you know, somehow, somewhere, nobody at the board or you know, hospital is letting them know for months, you know, and things are actively, you know, happening. How does that happen? How is there, is there, you know, why is there some disconnect sometimes? Even in California, if you just want to talk specifically, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Unfortunately, we do see that happen sometimes. And so there's a lot of different reasons for the disconnect. One is let's say law enforcement is doing an investigation, they're gonna treat that investigation as very confidential. And it's the same with medical boards, they're not gonna start talking about what they're investigating until they have facts and can move forward with the case. And and that's because they don't want to perhaps have evidence get destroyed by a subject who knows they're under investigation. Or what happens if there's nothing there with their investigation?
SPEAKER_02And now they've potentially defamed or you know, ruined a reputation of a provider that that didn't have any you know issues.
SPEAKER_01So the same kind of premise of innocent until proven guilty.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So, but you know, sometimes you do see where something will happen and then they'll say, Oh, this happened. Has anybody else been victimized? You know, they can't, you know, they kind of do publicly. Okay, okay. But then sometimes the license is still active on the board.
SPEAKER_02Right. So, you know, in California, what should happen, particularly when an arrest is made of a provider, that notice of arrest report should be going automatically to the medical board. And the the licensees have an obligation under certain circumstances to report the arrest. But you've been arrested and you're gonna report to your medical boards? That sometimes they don't always do.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, tell them, Nileen.
SPEAKER_01Because whose responsibility, right? Policeman number one arrests so-and-so. When we get arrested, not that we've ever been arrested, but let's just say I get arrested. I'm not gonna get arrested and say I'm a medical staff professional. So when a doctor gets arrested, he doesn't necessarily say, hey, I'm a doctor, right? He may be on vacation with his family, right? So let's say they find out that he is a doctor. Whose responsibility is it to say I've been arrested or this person has been arrested?
SPEAKER_01Is it the policeman's responsibility or is it the physician's responsibility to self-report?
SPEAKER_02So it's twofold. One, the physician has an obligation to self-report under certain circumstances, not always. You know, a misdemeanor DUI, I'm I'm not sure is still reportable in California automatically, but certain felonies are. But I, you know, so there's there's requirements, there's there's differences. But in California, any license
SPEAKER_01I can't, I'm sorry. Wait, hold on. Just wait, let's just say, hold on. I just gotta pause there for a minute because uh if you work at my hospital, you have to report yourself that you had a DUI. I mean, really, for real?
SPEAKER_02I'm just talking about the meta board. I haven't even talked about what your bylaws might require.
SPEAKER_01Oh, okay, by that's right. Okay, sorry. I'm just getting over this. This
SPEAKER_02is for your licensing boards. Now, within the the California, we call it the CLETS program, the RAPSheet program, there's a function where because all the licenses that are issued in the state of California are entered in a database, they they should be talking to another. So when that database knows this pops up that they're a licensed provider, that's what automatically notifies the board. It's not the cop's job to say, oh, are you a doctor? It's part of the function of the wrap sheet program, essentially.
SPEAKER_02I found it didn't always, it didn't always work super well.
SPEAKER_00Well, I I have to say one thing I wanted to say is we always advocate if something like that happens, go to your medical staff professional, the one that you trust the most. If you're at five hospitals, go to the one you trust the most, and that medical staff professional will walk you through that process and help you update all your disclosures, get yourself right, you know, and and it can become a process where we learn from that process instead of we, you know, the provider feels shamed. But I do want to say that the California system, 805, honey, Emily, it is a beautiful system.
SPEAKER_02I love my 805 system, but there are still holes within 805 too. Let me just back up, too, really quick, about your comment on talking to somebody in the med staff about an issue. Let's say you are arrested for a DUI. Yes, go talk to your med staff director, your chief of staff. Maybe this is where we can have early intervention for the physician with the well-being program. Get them through rehab so that it doesn't turn into a disciplinary action by the medical staff.
SPEAKER_02And and so, you know, that also shows some rehabilitation on their part that can help with the medical board and their criminal case.
SPEAKER_00Emily, we do have to understand though, they're gonna be in bed for a couple of days licking their wounds. They feel bad. So, what do you say? Well, I because I would. I'd be in bed, I got tissues, I got some ice cream. I'm calling Nali, letting her know what has happened. Maybe you, maybe I get some advice. And and then I'll so give me the time frame, beautiful. Is it 24 hours? Is it 48? How long can a person lick their wounds and and recuperate before it's like, okay, gotta get up, gotta report, gotta do this process.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so generally in California, it's you've got about 30 days to report. Oh, that is time to you got time to go talk to a lawyer and get some advice. Rap sheets can be updated pretty quickly. So the medical board might be getting information within 48 hours. And and criminal charges may also not be filed right away if it's a misdemeanor. You know, the DA can take time to get drug tests and things like that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, or the medical staff personnel is going on the arrest records every day and finding out within 24 hours, you may not have time to lick your wounds, Shannon.
SPEAKER_02And what do the bylaws say for requirements for notifying? Exactly. So, you know,
SPEAKER_00it's all these different areas that you're a part of each have their own specific reporting requirements, and so you really have to take that in consideration as a provider when you're signing on with all these different organizations, right? And then, because if you don't report, they can report that you didn't report.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. The medical board will definitely go after people for not reporting, they do not like that.
SPEAKER_00Transparency is key.
SPEAKER_02Transparency is very important to the California Medical Board or all of the medical boards in California. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, Nileen wants to talk, I know, about culture, about hierarchy, and all of those kind of things that we were talking about, Nileen, and it's she liked the interpersonal tea.
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, it's just medicine still runs on power, hierarchy, silence. So, really, what is the cost of my friends, my huge medical practice of 20 guys who, you know, is overrunning the one little orthopod down the street. We've got, we're the chief of staff, we're the chair of surgery. What do you think that that looks like and and how can that affect the providers?
SPEAKER_02Well, culture is so key. And and we refer to it in med staff space as the culture of safety. What you want to make sure is that people one feel safe to come and report issues, whether it's to, you know, you've got a nurse that is throwing things, so let's be able to report it to HR, or if it's a physician that is yelling and throwing and sexually assaulting people. You're telling your chief of staff, you're filing those event reports, and that those have some level of anonymity so that people feel that they can do that safely without being retaliated.
SPEAKER_02That's part of that culture is making sure there's a space for that reporting to happen. And then secondly, that people know when those reports are made that they are acted upon. Now, the in the medical staff space in California, it is very confidential. Peer review is sacrosanct. It is, we want to keep it protected from disclosure so that people do feel they can come forward and speak. But if people see that they've made a complaint and the doctor's still there, are they gonna feel comfortable speaking out moving forward?
SPEAKER_02And so you've gotta be able to educate your staff that yes, we're doing something, you may not get to know the specifics.
SPEAKER_01Yes. And what about the role of medical staff leadership? Not the physician side, but the actual office, your director, the people are where they come to us first. The reality is before they go to the chief of staff, their colleague, they're always gonna come to us. How important is the role of a medical services professional to allow this culture to continue in your experience?
SPEAKER_02So important because you are the sort of keepers of the keys to some extent. And you are all in the hospital 24-7, more so than some of the physicians. And so, yeah, you you hear things, and I would say to your my med staff directors, you hear something, say something. And that's part of the culture, too, is that if we don't know as the medical staff, how are we going to be able to get involved and stop it? So if people aren't reporting these problems or we're not seeing any action from the medical board, because there's let's say they're still investigating, they haven't made anything public yet.
SPEAKER_02We're not gonna know from a meds med board perspective. So they're they still show a clean, active license. So you've got to have your people come and talk and and be willing to speak up. And that includes, you know, your med staff building a relationship with people.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I and you know, we really talk about, you know, the medical staff professional, you know, not being treated as a secretary anymore because that's really not the role. You know, the role is your compliance partner, it's your person that's getting you through these really difficult times, taking you through to the next level of delegated credentialing and higher billing, giving you awesome uh compliance programs. I mean, the the the the areas that the medical staff professionals touch, and then to have the respect that is given to that be so low, you know, and not equate what the what they're actually doing.
SPEAKER_00It I think it's really hard because you have these people that notice something, have a feeling, they they going to people, they're going to their CMO, and they're not being listened to. And then what happens? There it's a headline.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00I mean, is there any advice you can give to Susie, John in this situation?
SPEAKER_02First, I want to say we're happy we happen to be recording this on MSP Appreciation Week.
SPEAKER_00Yes, we are, and we are
SPEAKER_02the work that the MSPs are doing on a daily basis is so key because that's how your hospital keeps its licensure, it keeps its accreditation. It's not just about, you know, pushing papers. There is so much involved. Like you gotta know how to when do I report to a licensing board? When do I report to the data bank? Do we need fair procedure for a physician? Are we adding credentials or privileges that you know we got a new robot?
SPEAKER_02How are we getting people to be qualified and competent on a robot? There are so many pieces. It's not just getting an application for membership and verifying they have a license, they haven't had malpractice.
SPEAKER_01But Emily, I need you, I need you for my surgery centers. We need to get this information to the surgery centers. Yeah,
SPEAKER_00to them.
SPEAKER_01Please. I literally am screaming at the top of the mountains.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I mean, in in California, surgery centers are generally not considered peer reviewed bodies. And a peer review body is, I mean, they can be.
SPEAKER_00You would hope that they would want to be. I mean, you would hope that they would, you know, participate.
SPEAKER_02Right, but they are still required to credential and ensure the competency of their providers. So what does that mean?
SPEAKER_01And report to the MPDB.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and and if you're not looking at these credentialing, are they subjecting themselves to a liability for negligent credentialing? Because they have allowed Dr. X to perform a surgery. I'm just, you know, Dr. Dunch-esque that doesn't even know how to do surgery. And they've allowed it because they didn't bother to look.
SPEAKER_00Or layoffs happen and they want to cut out the medical staff first because it's a cost center. How many times do you hear the medical staff is the cost center? Oh, it's okay. Susie could do it. Susie doesn't need the other two people that are helping her. No, Susie needs the team. Susie needs the team.
SPEAKER_02You can't do it with one. And I have seen it happen with my clients. And then what happens is we are not processing applications, we are not processing reappointments.
SPEAKER_00You're setting people up to fail, yeah.
SPEAKER_02We are setting people up to fail. We are setting the hospital up to fail then. If you haven't re-credentialed people, the joint commission or whatever accrediting body is going to come and say, No, you're where are you? We're looking at fines from the Department of Public Health during survey. Like there's there's so many areas that cross over that is dependent upon your men staff. And having that communication with your leadership, with your governing board is also so key.
SPEAKER_02Because one of my one of my colleagues talks about it as a three-legged school between administration, medical staff, and governing board. And if any of those are not right, it's gonna topple. And so let's hope we're all working together to ensure patient safety and quality medical care continues to be provided.
SPEAKER_00Well, and the biggest thing is, you know, let's just throw the word out there, confidentiality, right? You know, confidentiality laws are written to protect, you know, fairness is what they say, right? But I think in the end, they really do protect the wrong people sometimes because these people are doing it again and again. Everybody's protecting, no things on nothing, nothing, not nothing is on the medical board. You know, there's no one place that a patient can go and say, Is Dr. Bob Jones okay for me to go see?
SPEAKER_00And know 100% up to the last 48 hours whether or not he has some pending investigation or she.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and that's sort of one of the things I struggle with. When I started doing the work at the Attorney General's office representing the medical board, I learned a lot about verifying your physician. And let me tell you how many times do I have to tell my mom and dad, have you looked up your doctor? And and a lot of that is on the patient, unfortunately. But you know, are they doing a Google search? Are they looking at license verification? You know, are they board certified? Not that you have to.
SPEAKER_00Listen, Emma Break Men, and she is telling us, telling you. Google. Look it up at the medical board.
SPEAKER_01Well, and for our healthcare facilities, whether you're a surgery center, a hospital, anybody, when you verify best practice, I mean, Emily, really, as an attorney, how important do you think it is for us to teach that we should be verifying all 50 states? Use FSMB, use a verification system where we can verify all 50 states instead. Yes, instead of just the state that they're practicing. You as an attorney, how can that be life-saving for a patient or for a hospital?
SPEAKER_02What I think you should be looking at is where have they practiced, where have they had licenses, and at a minimum, check those states. Maybe not all every 50 states, you know, not all 50 states, because if they've only been in, you know, Kentucky, Texas, and California, I don't need to check New York.
SPEAKER_00But that you have to depend on their disclosure to find them out. The FSMB lets you know and discloses it to you without them even telling you. Yeah, that's the good tool to use. If you're out there, if you have a CVO, you have a medical staff, your people don't want to invest in the FSMB, it doesn't matter. You got to tell them to get it because you find out a lot of stuff. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01This episode of Credentialing Chronicles is sponsored by MedElevate Solutions, your partner in turning healthcare chaos into operational clarity. With deep expertise in ASC, hospital, or physician office operations, clinical workflows, and compliance. Their team helps you work smarter, not harder. Learn more at MedElevateSolutions.com. Simplifying processes, amplifying outcomes. One facility at a time.
SPEAKER_00So I guess you gotta spill some tea, right? I mean, right, Nileen? Should we make should we ask? It
SPEAKER_01is
SPEAKER_00I mean, what? Let's start with what craziest case, most low guy. Creepy is
SPEAKER_01a good idea.
SPEAKER_00Take it back to criminal. I mean, take it to attorney general. Give us one from each time of your life. I I mean, I'm ready.
SPEAKER_02When I was at the AG's office, seeing, you know, physicians charged with child porn, seeing child abuse, sexual assault, domestic violence, I saw all of that, you know, and those were criminal charges. And so when we got word of them, and there's various ways that we got word out of them. I mean, one of them I saw in the news and I looked it up, I'm like, we didn't have a case. I got it open because it hadn't made its way through the arrest notification process.
SPEAKER_02And so in California, we have a way to go in and as a condition of bail, if they are released, that they are not allowed to practice medicine. So I did that several times. And hopefully, you're, you know, your your state, they're working with their the prosecutors are aware of these avenues if they are giving bail to a provider that that not include being able to practice.
SPEAKER_00Well, I I will tell you, Montana is not like that, honey. Yeah, I I'm still going back to Montana not eat. I'm I can't fold on
SPEAKER_01the case.
SPEAKER_00Poor
SPEAKER_01Montana. The doctor still has a license.
SPEAKER_00The doctor's still active kills 10 people and nothing. Still no
SPEAKER_01pause.
SPEAKER_00No pause. And so I mean, again, I you know, they say, you know, California is so ahead of the game or so behind. I don't know what they say, but these things make sense to us.
SPEAKER_02I agree. I it would be really nice to have sort of a a uh clearinghouse for information. I look at privacy issues, but then I look at how long it took us to get in criminal cases, you know, systems that communicated with one another, to know that one state was investigating somebody for rape and sexual assault with the rape kits and another. And so then I think about well, how do we do this on a licensing aspect? And where where are the government priorities?
SPEAKER_02And
SPEAKER_00do the states communicate with each other right now if somebody's being investigated or something?
SPEAKER_02They should be, yes. Oh,
SPEAKER_00it should be happening, okay.
SPEAKER_02But that's jurisdict, that's a jurisdictional issue too, and and medical boards should be talking to one another one another too. When I was at the medical board doing a lot of out-of-state discipline cases, you know, they got disciplined in Texas for whatever reason, but they have a California license, so we're gonna go in and impose our own discipline based upon that. So is there is that happening in in other states? You know, I will say some medical boards are a little bit lenient, more lenient than others.
SPEAKER_00We see that right now. Yeah,
SPEAKER_01we we do see that. Well, you know, especially with like a radiologist are the most easiest to do because they have the most state licenses or like a teleneurologist, you know, you do see that they may have an action in one state, and out of the 40 that they have, maybe only 10 put an additional, you know, action based on the one, and then the other ones kind of just let it go. And it may be something simple as like a$500 administrative fine. So it's not like a full, you know, investigation and rapport, but they do at least put some type of sanction on there.
SPEAKER_01So what's your to as an attorney? I know you've seen it all in crime and all of that, and we're crime, we love crime stories as it as they are. But some of us, as we said, for us the hardest cases are child's cases. And do you see that had that very prevalent? Have you seen it very prevalent? Or is things like more like DUIs and drug problems more common versus like full-on criminal cases?
SPEAKER_02I will say I don't see a lot, particularly in the med staff spaces, where we don't have to deal a lot with those really serious crimes. I think the the plus is when those are happening, I think the doctors realize they need to get out of dodge with their their med staff and focus on criminal cases. But what we see more on the med staff day-to-day front are substance use, behavioral issues, DUIs. And so that's where I think it's so key for your med staff to have a really good well-being committee so that you have a place to provide resources to those providers.
SPEAKER_02And I mean, we all recognize everyone is understaffed, physicians, nurses, we we are in a staffing shortage, we are in an overworked, overburdened healthcare system. So, how do you provide those resources to make sure they aren't burning out? And if they are asking for help, that they can get those that help and get that help without the stigma.
SPEAKER_00And and I mean, really, you know, I mean, not to put the hospitals, the clinics, the organizations on on on you know, blast or anything, but some of the quotas are so high. You got to see 30 patients a day. You know, these doctors now, it's different, you all. You know, this is going out to the patients. These doctors are employed by the hospitals a lot of times. Yes, a lot of times they're privileged in, they have their own clinic, or but sometimes those are related to the hospital as well. And you know, they are measured by matrix, right, Emily?
SPEAKER_00And so that causes burnout.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. I will say in California, we have, and there are a few states like it, where we're not allowed, hospitals are not allowed to directly employ physicians.
SPEAKER_00But Abby, you need to come back, and we just need to do all about the medical staff line. We're
SPEAKER_01learning all kinds of stuff, go.
SPEAKER_00Because maybe a state official is listening and can't we can help and provide some help, okay?
SPEAKER_02I mean, talk to you. You want to you want to improve communication between boards and law enforcement? Let's start changing the law. Let's propose some changes to our local legislators, too. Your state medical board is always working with their legislature with the legislature to improve and change laws. I mean, I will say that's how California specifically passed Business and Professions Code Section 805.08 on reporting of sexual misconduct because it resulted out of really bad, a really bad case in California where patients were reporting complaints of sexual misconduct.
SPEAKER_02The institution didn't handle it appropriately, didn't report it in the way that the medical board felt they should have. And the law directly changed so that within four 15 days of receiving a written complaint from a patient or their representative, that has to be reported to the medical board, regardless of whether there's anything to it.
SPEAKER_00Is anybody auditing that? Are they getting reported? Are there is still delayed notifications? You know, are they they holding to that standard?
SPEAKER_02The medical board takes failure to report seriously.
SPEAKER_00So when it is discovered, it's it's a it's a infarction. And
SPEAKER_02and they have the medical board has very stiff fines from$50,000 to up to$100,000 for failing to report. The license providers, like your chief of staff who has a medical license, can also be separately charged with unprofessional conduct for not reporting. And so that's on their personal license as well. So California takes failure to report really seriously. You know, so again, what's the state, what's the law look like in your state on on requiring hospitals to report?
SPEAKER_02And if it's not great, can we change the law?
SPEAKER_00Well, I could tell you, me and Nileen could tell you. Tell her, Nileen. I mean, from half of these cases when we investigate them, half of them come up still active, no disciplinary actions. And we have cases on them that are out being in the in the court of public opinion, right? I know you know that, Nileen. She does the whole background investigation on them.
SPEAKER_01So since you brought up politics, because some doctors face really lifetime exile, while others they truly get presidential pardons. I mean, how does that play into accountability?
SPEAKER_02It shouldn't. If you've committed wrongdoing and unprofessional conduct, you should be held accountable. Whether that's by your state licensure, whether that's by your medical staff, hospital privileges, whether it's by your employer, you know, no longer fit for employment. Politics shouldn't play an impact, a role in what our decision is. Reporting shouldn't play a role in whether or not we should take action as a medical staff. We need to do what's right for the patients, what's right for the hospital, and what's right for our medical staff.
SPEAKER_02And it all goes back to how do we provide that quality, safe medical care to our patients. And it shouldn't matter whether that physician is connected or not.
SPEAKER_00And really, that's where it says like if integrity isn't consistent, the public stops believing that the system is able to self-correct. You know, that there's going to be players in there that are going to direct the self-correction to happen. And even, you know, just down to you know, floaters in the OR scared to say something. I mean, it's okay to say something. That's how things change.
SPEAKER_02Yes, absolutely. And and it goes back to that culture of safety and making sure that there are safe spaces for people to report something. When you see something, say something. It's just like the airport, you know, right? Report that so that we can, as a medical staff group, take action if we need to, you know, is there an imminent threat?
SPEAKER_01So, Emily, I want to break it down for like new MSPs that are listening because when I started in the MSP world, like I didn't really ever get to talk to an attorney until you get into leadership or you didn't understand why medical staff attorneys needed to get called. And really, what is the role of an attorney other than protecting the hospital? What role does an attorney pay in protecting a physician during a case with a hospital? I am a doctor, my privileges are being taken away. I don't believe that they should. I was in a bad situation.
SPEAKER_01Let me give you I have an example. I have a really good story. So I had a OEGYN who was on call and he got a call that his mother was suddenly on her deathbed. And a baby got delivered, and he wasn't there to deliver the baby, and they took away his privileges. So he's challenging the medical staff. So, what is the role in a case like that where it is a true life real? We have to decide as humans what is more important to us, right? Not that somebody's life isn't more important than my life or my my parents' life, but we're humans.
SPEAKER_01And so the role of an attorney in a case like that, how what how would what role do you play? And what does a new medical staff person have to say? Hey, this is why attorneys are important.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I'm the hospital, I am the medical staff attorney. I do not represent the hospital in California, in part because, again, California can't employ physicians. So I and and how and medical staffs in California are required to be independent in their oversight of physician quality issues. Now they report up to the governing boards, but my role is to advise them we get this complaint in, you know, somebody makes an event safety report.
SPEAKER_02So I'm my chief of staff first needs to assess: is there an imminent threat to patient safety based upon this? Is this a one-off? What is the history with this provider? You know, let's look at the facts as it relates to this case. And so that's the first assessment. And and I hope my chief of staff reaches out to me to ask, what am I supposed to do? So I can lead them through that framework of, you know, is it imminent danger to patient safety that you need to act? If not, what are your next steps?
SPEAKER_02Now I'm gonna look at their bylaws too, because your bylaws should have a whole section on corrective action and hearing rights. And so follow your bylaws. That's your playbook. That's your that's your rule set as a new medical staff provider. Know your bylaws, know your rules and regs.
SPEAKER_00So you kind of like lay out the roadmap for them.
SPEAKER_02I lay out the roadmap for them. And the sooner that you get me involved, hopefully the better it is that we can do everything by the book. Now, the physician who is who who also is being investigated and had their privileges restricted, they have a right to go see their own counsel, and they probably should. I would always advise a provider to go get counsel, and often their medal insurance will pay for some of that too. So they could have coverage for some of this for attorneys to so that depends upon their policy.
SPEAKER_02But they're also entitled to have process where they get an opportunity to be heard. And you know, in California we call it fair procedure, and it's really a different term, basically, for due process. And so we want to make sure that the physician is getting their opportunity to be heard and have a right to present their side.
SPEAKER_01And do you sometimes have to go against then the hospital attorney?
SPEAKER_02Generally, no. Hopefully, we remember. You can bring in your
SPEAKER_00briefcase, slam it on the desk, and say let's go to battle.
SPEAKER_02But you know, there have there are cases, and these are built into the bylaws when you have a joint conference. That's what we call it here in California. When your medical staff and your governing board are at issue, there's a process to have a joint conference where we can basically have our own mini-trial with attorneys to figure out how do we get on the same page and get back to providing quality, safe patient care.
SPEAKER_00So it could get really ugly,
SPEAKER_02it can get very ugly.
SPEAKER_01And y'all, this is not like court. This is not like court, like when we and you go to the court. This is a whole nother world. This is a healthcare
SPEAKER_00court. She said they've got attorneys. Is there does somebody play the role of the judge?
SPEAKER_02Yes. So we hire attorneys that work in this space to act as a judge.
SPEAKER_00Do they get a gavel?
SPEAKER_02No.
SPEAKER_01They don't get a
SPEAKER_00gavel.
SPEAKER_02I could suggest that
SPEAKER_00you're cheating them out of the roll.
SPEAKER_02Now most of our hearings are remote, so it's not even the same. We're not even in the same way.
SPEAKER_01She looked like a little stethoscope or something. I checked.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, do they object and sustain?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Absolutely. That it runs just like what you see on Law and Order, except that it's on Zoom. The judge is a lawyer that we've hired, that likely the MEC is paying for. And our jury, and this isn't a fair procedure case with the physician. So your obguin, Eileen, it gets to have his side heard by a jury of his peer, his or her peers, of a bunch of physicians. So, you know, you get three to five doctors, and some may, you know, you will likely have one obguin on the panel who understands the specifics of the case, but we put it on just like a normal trial.
SPEAKER_02It's just in an informal uh setting.
SPEAKER_00No, but it's like, let's run through the facts, baby. Let's run through these facts. I mean, I I I wish I wish friends took it like that. Look, let's we're gonna set this trial for Friday. We're gonna run it through and figure out, you know, if we can get it to where we're in friends again. That'd be a great idea.
SPEAKER_02There is so much that goes into a fair procedure, and our this is where you really want. I really hope you have a good experience, med staff attorney, because fair procedure is can be very complicated, can be very long, and unfortunately can be a very expensive process for the hospital.
SPEAKER_00Because they're charging by the hour.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I know I we ain't mad at you, Emily, honey. Get your dollars. Okay, let's go back. Let's go back to MSP week. Okay, let's bring it back. Let's bring it back. It is happy MSP week. We might have to release this episode next week. You might just have to jump ahead, Emily. This is such a good conversation. But I want to give the medical staff pros their flowers because let's be honest, right? The most realistic situation that we will hear from all med staff is when the system above them drags its feet.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so again, we're not giving medical advice here, but give just friendly advice. You know, what do they do?
SPEAKER_02They've got to remind the those above them the risk to the hospital, to their licensure, to the accreditation for medical malpractice lawsuits.
SPEAKER_00Document in a meeting,
SPEAKER_02document, document, document.
SPEAKER_00Okay, okay.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I mean, I'm a lawyer, I love a good document. If I got a document, it can make or break a case.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. So basically, the MSP becomes the conscience of the institution. We're reminding you that it exists.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And if you're still getting that pushback, you know, and they and they, you know, I mean, I I just, you know, because sometimes it happens. Let's say they want Dr. X to come on board. They find out Dr. X has something in the background that doesn't align with the credential. There's nobody else to do this. This is a rural hospital, let's say. And Dr. X is the only person, and it took them seven months to find Dr. X.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I I see that all the time.
SPEAKER_00What do they do? I mean, real friendly advice.
SPEAKER_02Here in California, it's lovely because, again, that's a decision that the h the MEC is making. So the hospital conducts the recruiting. They don't maybe know that this guy's got 18 malpractice suits in the last five years, that the quality of care is suffering. They may not have known that during the recruitment period. So that's when your MSPs say, Hey, you aware of this? Let's let's get more information from the provider. I mean, I I teach my med staff directors that incomplete applications are the best.
SPEAKER_02We don't have to process an incomplete application. Let's keep it incomplete. You know, let if as long as it stays incomplete, there's nothing for us to review and make a decision on. But, you know, when you've got the situation where you've got a provider with question marks, it's so act on those red flags. It's much easier to deny an application at the jump than try and terminate them when they've got privileges after the facts. And think about and what is the risk to your patients in that gap.
SPEAKER_02So you've got to you've got to document that to your governing board why the you've made the MEC has made the decision it's made.
SPEAKER_01And Emily, can we just have your two-second opinion of voluntarily withdraw versus deny? You know, because it's a thing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there's still gonna be reporting aspects out there. But does a physician want to have a whole set of documents, a full hearing that has findings of fact with all the bad things based upon a denial, or would they rather have it as a withdrawal within when there's very limited information? Because confidentiality rules don't apply to the medical board. Medical board find gets this report, they're gonna subpoena me for those documents or my my client for those documents, and they are entitled to get that entire credentialing file, to get that peer review file.
SPEAKER_02Does that doctor want that to be part of their case?
SPEAKER_01So there should be a letter in the file stating that the doctor voluntarily withdrew instead of there not being anything at all, or
SPEAKER_02well, you could have it a couple look, you know. A lot of my med staff bylaws say, you know, we've got questions, you've got 30 days to answer our. Questions and until you answer these questions, we're treating your application as incomplete. And if it's incomplete for longer than 30, 60 days, we're treating it as a withdrawal. Now, if they formally, so I'm gonna set that all out in writing. You want to notify the physician every step of the way. And if they now if they decide I'm getting too many questions, I don't like this, and I'm gonna withdraw, then yeah, I'm gonna confirm in writing that you have on X date, we got your withdrawal notice.
SPEAKER_02We're your application is now withdrawn. And it's in the file. Now, is that a withdrawal that is reportable to the databank because they knew they were gonna get a denial? I don't know. Where are we in getting that information back?
SPEAKER_01Hmm, interesting. So let's bring it back to the patients, right? Because we Shannon is a big advocate for patients, and we always talk about how the patients are affected. And the reality is, do patients even know how much of this actually happens and what rights and no rights patients have?
SPEAKER_02They don't. I mean, I had a conversation with my husband last week. We've been married 24 years, and he's like, so he's still got a license? Like, you know, I don't take licenses anymore. Like, my husband still doesn't get it. So, how is the average person supposed to understand what happens in the med space? They don't. And so, you know, how can we as MSPs educate the public?
SPEAKER_02So, you know, I I educate everybody that I come against come up against or meet, like, oh, you're seeing a doctor. You Google them, you looked up their license status. I mean, I have the medical board's app on my phone. I can check a license on my phone.
SPEAKER_00And I strive to be that efficient at this point. I need to get the FSB on my phone, just a little app. It just who do you want me to look up? I mean, it's really where transparency has to involve, right? Because right now, the way it's working, you know, providers feel shamed, and it's not protecting patients. And we want to restore that. We want providers to come to us. We're we're human, we understand burnout is real, you know, things are happening. Let's restore the trust. And I think, you know, I I my philosophy, I guess, you know, in creating the credentialing chronicles, is if we can let patients know more and more that this is happening, then maybe they can be their own advocate and and before they become a victim, you know?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. I, you know, if I I had some notes earlier as I was looking through, I'd listen to, you know, I binge listen to all your episodes and I'm scratching nuts at five. Oh, what about this? And one of the things that really strikes me is when you are a patient, listen to your gut. If it doesn't feel right, it doesn't smell right, get out, get a second opinion, and tell somebody. Because again, we can't do anything with that provider if we don't know about your experience.
SPEAKER_00Emily, I'm sorry, but is this for patients?
SPEAKER_02This is for patients. You
SPEAKER_00from a healthcare attorney lawyer in California, please, patients listen to her. Say it all again, Emily. They they don't know that you're even talking to them.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, if you as a patient feel uncomfortable, think something is wrong, your gut says this diagnosis isn't right, my gut says they're not listening to me.
SPEAKER_00Yes,
SPEAKER_02get out, and then tell somebody, tell the, you know, tell an office manager. Complaints to medical board, you know, the medical board of California, you can file a complaint online, and by law, California is required to investigate every complaint. Now, not all investigations are equal. You know, some cases get closed much quicker than others, and some, you know, the majority of cases get closed without corrective action being taken formally, but report it because a
SPEAKER_00report on record, right?
SPEAKER_02Yes, the medical board has confidential reports that they got it. So if they keep getting complaints to on a physician, that they can then reopen old complaints.
SPEAKER_00And and that has saved a lot of people and has gotten a lot of bad actors out because you know, one person complained the first year, five people complained the next year, eleven people complained the third year. You you understand? And the the medical board says, wait a minute, we didn't listen the first year, but by the third year, fourth year, okay, let's go out and investigate now. It so you know, although it might not be, but voices together, you know, help this whole process be heard.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. And it's the I think the younger generation really has done a good job to say we're no longer gonna tolerate this. Like this bad behavior, bad conduct was never okay. We just tolerated it. And the new, the younger generation is like, we're not tolerating this. And I thank them for that. You know, I'm a Gen X or like just suck it up and be quiet and go about your work. That's what I grew up with. And I appreciate the fact that that's not how the younger generation is doing it, and I think that's contributing also to that culture of safety that we we need to strive for.
SPEAKER_02And I do think there are changes and and systemically I have hope. I there are always, unfortunately, I think, going to be problems, and we'll we'll find cra holes and cracks in the system. But you know, as we educate people to check out their doctor, as we educate our MSPs to also verify, verify, verify, and have staff report that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I I I think I think that's a beautiful place to end, Emily. I mean, on hope, right? Let's end on hope. Because, you know, right, Nileen. I mean, talking about this more, getting these things out. I mean, it's the only way that, and and it is our hope that everybody shares this with everybody because really it's the patients that we want to talk to, like Emily said, and it's you can protect yourself just by getting out. I also seen an article that I was reading, bringing somebody to your appointments, it it holds the doctor more accountable, they they act a little different, you know.
SPEAKER_00I mean, so that's another thing that I was gonna start suggesting as well. Would you suggest that?
SPEAKER_02Definitely, if you feel like you need help and you need you want an advocate, you need somebody else with you to understand, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Or just a witness, right? I mean, just to witness, right?
SPEAKER_02One, always ask for a chaperone, too. If you are if you are having a sensitive service exam,
SPEAKER_00you might ask for
SPEAKER_02that chaperone.
SPEAKER_00You might not want your husband in there, but can I get nurse Jackie in here? So, yeah, yeah. Yeah, good one.
SPEAKER_02So that not only protects you, but it protects the doctor. So doctors should be offering chaperones. That should be happening, whether it's an MA or a nurse or or somebody, whether it's somebody from yourself. Now, one other thing that I've seen recently is a lot of TikTok videos on the patients taking video of what happens in their doctors. There's some liability risks there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we don't want to get into HIPAA violations. All right. There are some laws against that.
SPEAKER_02So, you know, I caution a lot of that when, you know, as a pre patient, if you are recording your doctor's visit.
SPEAKER_00Maybe you should be your doctor, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah,
SPEAKER_02right. That's the other thing, too. You know, if you are so worried that you feel like you're not getting care, let's go find another person. Go find another
SPEAKER_00doctor, exactly.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So, Emily, thank you so much Emily for cutting through the noise.
SPEAKER_00I
SPEAKER_02can talk with ladies for hours.
SPEAKER_00I know, and this is how we were at NAMS, right, Nileen? I mean, we could not stop talking.
SPEAKER_01Yes, and that's why it's so exciting, really. You make law sound like really the thriller that it is. It's just as exciting as MSP.
SPEAKER_00I get to see it through the MSP, something that I love through the eyes of an attorney. And I'm like, dun, dum, I am just there with you, Emily. Like, I would throw my briefcase with you, boo.
SPEAKER_02Come on, come on over.
SPEAKER_00So, share, you have to follow, you have to like. You heard it here straight from Emily. You know, make sure that you're advocating you feel something. What did you say? Feel something, say something, like the airport.
SPEAKER_02See something, say something.
SPEAKER_00See something, say something, yes. But we thank you so much for coming. Nileen, you want to take us out today, my love?
SPEAKER_01Yes. So uh, for everyone that's listening, the next time you see a spotless credentialing file, just ask yourself, what's really missing? So this is credentialing chronicles. Until next time.
SPEAKER_00Bye. Ooh, that was a whole lot of tea. Who knew doctors had more drama than reality TV?
SPEAKER_01And if you think that was wild, just wait till next week. We've got more stories, more scandals, and more credentialing chaos coming your way.
SPEAKER_00And if you love the tea, please don't keep it to yourself. Like to show us you're listening. Please comment and join the conversation. And follow us on LinkedIn, Instagram, and TikTok. Also, share so everyone else can sip with us.
SPEAKER_01Yes, I'll see you next time on Credentialing Chronicles. Stay credentials, not canceled.
Send us Fan Mail One jump changed everything. What happened afterward led Dylan Avatar toward a purpose he never expected. In this episode of Credentialing Chronicles, Shannen Reyes-Aguayo and Nyleen Flores sit down...
Send us Fan Mail Tea dresses, tiny microphones, and a little NAMSS chaos! 🫖🎙️ We’re taking you inside our pink booth at NAMSS’s 50th anniversary conference in New Orleans! This short episode is full of live...
Send us Fan Mail ⚠️ *TRIGGER WARNING:* This episode discusses sexual assault, sexual abuse by healthcare professionals, and child sexual abuse. Although the discussion is non-graphic, these topics may be distressing....
Send us Fan Mail SOMEBODY ELSE'S DEA NUMBER?! $172 MILLION IN MEDICARE FRAUD?! NEW JERSEY, WE NEED TO TALK! 👀☕️ The Garden State is serving up some SERIOUS healthcare tea, and trust us… this episode is WILD! 🔥 This...
Send us Fan Mail New Hampshire’s Healthcare Wake-Up Call A provider can be qualified, credentialed - and still out of reach. A provider’s identity can be legitimate - and still be used to submit fraudulent claims. Who...