Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Credentialing Chronicles

Credentialing Chronicles artwork

Still Practicing: The Doctor Who Wouldn’t Stop – A Helena, Montana Scandal- Current Event

Apr 8, 202541 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail How is this even happening?! In this episode of Credentialing Chronicles, we uncover the shocking case of a doctor in Helena, Montana, with a history of serious allegations - still practicing, still seeing patients, and still flying under the radar. From patient complaints to jaw-dropping board decisions (or lack thereof), this story will leave you questioning the very systems designed to protect us. Join Shannen, Nyleen, and the team as they pull back the curtain on how credentialing loopholes, board inaction, and oversight failure can put real lives at risk. 👀 Who’s watching the watchers? 🎙️ Who’s protecting the patients? 🩺 And what can you do to protect yourself and your loved ones? This isn’t just another headline - it’s a wake-up call. #ScalpelsAndScandals #CredentialingChronicles #MontanaDoctor #StillPracticing #ProtectPatients #MedicalBoardFailure Advanced Quality Compliance & CVO Credentialing. Contracting. Compliance. Handled. Completely. Concierge-level credentialing, payer e MedElevate Solutions Bridging the Gap Between Software and Clinical Reality E.L.E.V.A.T.E.™ your healthcare experience. Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you. Support the show Resources Mentioned: 🔎 Verify Your Doctor’s Credentials ✔️ State-Specific Medical Board License Lookup: Find your state’s board here: https://www.fsmb.org/contact-a-state-medical-board/ ✔️ Medicare Exclusions List (LEIE) - Check if your provider is federally excluded: https://oig.hhs.gov/exclusions/exclusions_list.asp ✔️ Set Google Alerts on Your Doctor’s Name: Create your own Google Alert here: https://www.google.com/alerts For Medical Staff Professional: ✔️ FSMB.org - Federation of State Medical Boards Physician Lookup: https://www.fsmb.org/physician-license-lookup/ ✔️ Hospital Websites: Many hospitals have public directories listing credentialed medical staff. Look for a “Find a Doctor” or “Medical Staff Directory” page. ✔️ Set Google Alerts on Your Doctor’s Name: Create your own Google Alert here: https://www.google.com/alerts Wanna know if your plastic surgeon is actually board certified? Check for yourself right here: 👉 Verify a Plastic Surgeon Open Payments openpaymentsdata.cms.gov Verify your Nurses' Credentials: https://www.nursys.com/ 🌐 Connection Zone Stay plugged in with your peers, share resources, and nev...

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Credentialing Chronicles, where we spill the Dr. T hotter than your morning coffee.

SPEAKER_01And give you the insider scoop in the wild worlds of credentialing, provider drama, and everything they don't teach you in med school.

SPEAKER_00I'm Shannon and she's Nileen, two credentialing pros with front row seats to all the chaos.

SPEAKER_01From fraud scandals to burnout breakdowns and why your favorite surgeon might actually be banned from five hospitals.

SPEAKER_00Ah, we got the gossip and the practical advice to keep you out of trouble and ahead of the game.

SPEAKER_01So grab your coffee, your compliance checklist, and maybe a lawyer, and let's get into it.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back to Credential Chronicles, the podcast where we uncover the hidden dangers in the medical field and hold the system accountable. I'm Shannon, and as always, I'm joined by my co-host Nileen.

SPEAKER_01Hey, thank you, Shannon. I'm so excited to chat this week about our favorite topic, doctors. But first, Shannon, before we dive into the tea, can you give our little disclosure?

SPEAKER_00Yes, definitely. As a disclaimer, the cases we will be sharing with you are all available through public court documents. We promise we are not sharing any privileged or private information. And we have never personally credentialed any of these practitioners. We will not release the names of the practitioners, but we will give you all those juicy details.

SPEAKER_01Thank you, Shannon. So hey everyone, today's episode is another shocking one. We're diving into the case of an oncologist from Montana whose medical license has been renewed and is renewed multiple times, despite mounting allegations of misconduct and patient harm. So the hospital said that this doctor over-prescribed narcotics, gave chemo to patients who didn't even have cancer.

SPEAKER_01That's just some of it. So the hospital finally took action on his privileges, but the state of Montana is still renewing this guy's license. So, Shannon, tell us a little bit about there.

SPEAKER_00You know, I couldn't believe it because this is one of the recent cases. So when it came to our attention, I said, oh my God, this is literally what we're talking about happening in real time. This is recent as of this week. This is 2025 that we are talking about. This is happening. So the state of Montana, we're not talking about a couple of minor infractions that are happening. This is some serious allegations, including over-prescribing narcotics.

SPEAKER_00With everything going on, he's over-prescribing, administering chemotherapy to patients who didn't even have cancer and a pattern of patient harm that rises, raises the ultimate question. Should this doctor still be prescribing? Should he still have a license? Are the patients safe? Who was going to him, right?

SPEAKER_01Right. So let's get into the details of the teeth. And we're gonna go through the story. And this is gonna be a really good episode because we're gonna talk about what we're gonna do about

SPEAKER_00it.

SPEAKER_01And we're gonna really, yes. So in 2020, the hospital went ahead and terminated this doctor, apparently, right? So he had over-prescribed narcotics, and then, like we said, he was giving chemo treatments to patients who apparently didn't even have cancer. Not only is this illegal and fraudulent, but it's just bad medicine, right? You just don't do it. So here's the highlights of where patient harm existed and then questionable medical practices.

SPEAKER_01First of all, he extended misdiagnoses and harmful treatments. There were patients who had not one year, not two, you're talking about decades of chemotherapy for cancers that apparently he never had, and he suffered, and then he ultimately died because of

SPEAKER_00this.

SPEAKER_01Okay. So was this done intentionally? So, like, does he want to kill the person?

SPEAKER_00The doctors charge him Medicaid or Medicare or the insurance all along.

SPEAKER_01So we're getting into fraud, right? So you have financial incentives and overutilization. So you have Medicare and Medicaid fraud.

SPEAKER_00You hear that all the time.

SPEAKER_01Maybe he was

SPEAKER_00just sick.

SPEAKER_01I don't know. Then obviously, there's a thing called, for all of those of you out there, it's called an RVU, right? So it's a revenue, the revenue units generated, the doctors get basically paid off of these RVUs, right? And so the money that they make are is linked to the volume of the services that they build.

SPEAKER_00That they provide right in the hospital systems. Right,

SPEAKER_01right. Especially if they're employed. Like if you're private practice, obviously, you know, you're only gonna get paid whatever you work, but especially if you're an employee of a of a group or whatever, they're gonna look at your RBUs to justify your salary.

SPEAKER_00You have to keep it up. If you're not if you're not performing, they're not keeping you.

SPEAKER_01Yes. And I just also want to disclose that ProPublica did an exclusive great article on this, uh, which is where we got the majority of our uh information and data besides the board website. So just heads up, we're gonna put that information in the show notes. Then the hospital really delayed it, delayed doing anything about this, right? Because you have to do an internal investigation. So they found out about it long before 2020, but they just waited until 2020 to actually terminate his employment.

SPEAKER_01Other issue is there were regulatory oversights. So Montana has continued to renew his license after 2021 and 2023. So again, what we talked about the last two times, two separate processes, right? Board is not finding out what the hospital is doing against them.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. Unless

SPEAKER_01somebody tells them.

SPEAKER_00Then he's renewing, you know, three cycles now. 2021, he's on the odd year, 2023, and then now 2025.

SPEAKER_01And so

SPEAKER_00they're not even looking at what people are saying in the evidence that's stacking up, the pattern of behavior. I think I'm gonna say that every episode now, Nile, now that you've

SPEAKER_01Absolutely, yeah, absolutely. And one of the main reasons, right, hospitals don't report and don't want to open the can of worms is because the doctors can sue. So this has gone to court because, according to this, the Montana Supreme Court upheld the hospital's decision to fire this doctor. So apparently there's some litigation that the doctors must have sued the hospital because he got fired for doing something illegal.

SPEAKER_00Well, remember the other episode where you kept talked about the hospital politics? It sounds like behind the scenes right here is hospital politics are going on. So we don't even know what what the whole story is, do we? I don't feel like I do, do you?

SPEAKER_01No. I think that what really triggered them the hospital to finally act is the suspicious deaths linked to his patients.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01So when a doctor all of a sudden gets all these patients dying, now, don't get me wrong, oncology, you got a lot of people dying,

SPEAKER_00right? You say you got cancers expected that

SPEAKER_01the patient is gonna right, but it's suspicious. You know what's going on. These doctors, there's something weird going on. Yeah, what's even more disturbing is that the Montana Department of Justice has now launched a formal investigation into his actions. So now law enforcement is stepping in. So one of the big questions I really want to dive into is are we criminally prosecuting doctors for practicing medicine arbitrarily?

SPEAKER_01Meaning doctors are just practicing. They can get a lot wrong, right? A C also graduated medical school. So we have to analyze the intention, was the intention to, on purpose, right, hurt these patients, treat them, give them things that they do not need just to get a financial gain.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. So well, you know, when you have 10 suspicious deaths that have been linked to your practice, what is the magic number, right? What is the magic number of suspicious deaths needed for the board to say, hey, maybe we should look at Dr. Smith over here and see what he's doing? You know, it's good that we're gonna break down this case, right? And we're really gonna reflect on the system as a whole. What failures allowed him to keep practicing and mostly continue practicing as of today?

SPEAKER_00You can literally go see him today. Whether patients can truly feel safe in Helena, Montana, because this is where this is going on in Helena, Montana. And, you know, the patients there need to be on the lookout. Again, Google your doctor. Nileen said it. Go to the medical board. I'm just gonna throw that in before we start talking about this. But if you are in Helena, Montana, please listen to our advice and Google. Okay, right, Nileen?

SPEAKER_01Yes, absolutely. So the Montana Board of Medical Examiners, which is what they call their medical board, is supposed to be really the defense for protecting patients.

SPEAKER_00Their job

SPEAKER_01really is to vet, monitor, and hold doctors accountable. But in this case, I don't know. As we have reiterated in the past episodes, is this because nobody's reported him to the actual board? Like we have to wait until he's criminally prosecuted for the board to do something.

SPEAKER_00But my question is why? The hospitals know they're supposed to report. The fellow doctors that are around know that they're supposed to report. Maybe the patients don't, because patients, I mean, unfortunately, are ignorant. And I hope that this credentialing chronicles brings education to patients all over that hear this, that know, oh my goodness, I have a duty as well in this relationship with the doctor. You know, we've seen cases before where a medical board drags its feet or mishandles disciplinary actions, but what is happening here in Helena, Montana is egregious, is just crazy.

SPEAKER_00And again, the patients need to Google. If you are there in Montana, in the state of Montana, make sure you are Googling because again, this is something actively he is practicing actively. And how does a doctor with the trail of patients' harm continue to be licensed year after year to go ahead and continue to harm Nylene?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and this isn't even an isolated case, it happens more than you think. We're gonna mention a couple cases here just as a quick highlight, and we can get into them more as we make other episodes. But why don't you make a

SPEAKER_00lot of people?

SPEAKER_01have to argue to

SPEAKER_00say maybe not put more in there, right? We had to say no more cases. You know, the first one, case in point, a neurologist was convicted of sexually assaulting multiple patients despite complaints piling up for years, you all. He was still practicing in multiple states before finally being convicted. And you had more, right, Nileen? I mean, talk about the next one.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, then there's of course the famous Dr. Death, which definitely doesn't

SPEAKER_00he

SPEAKER_01have

SPEAKER_00a Netflix?

SPEAKER_01Netflix. Yes, he has the whole Netflix special. Not that he needs to be more of a self-serving narcissist, but whatever.

SPEAKER_00Exactly.

SPEAKER_01So he was a for those of you that for some reason have not been around, he was a neurosurgeon. Exactly. Actually, no, it was Peacock. He was a neurosurgeon in Texas who left a horrifying trail of botched surgeries, paralyzed patients, and killed people. And it took multiple reports and years of investigations before his license was finally revoked.

SPEAKER_00And my question is, how is Baylor doing? How is the hospital doing after that? Because they were the one credentialing. And I will always say, you know, if you guys need to outsource, please look us up because we would have caught that so, so good. Because he had that trail back in Tennessee, you know, that he was hurting people back there. These cases have one thing in common, right? Regulatory systems that fail to act fast. And that's exactly what's happening again with this doctor in Helena, Montana. The question is, how many patients have to suffer in Helena, Montana before action is taken, right?

SPEAKER_00I mean, really, because this is their neighborhood that they're hurting.

SPEAKER_01So Department of Justice now's gotten involved. So now he's criminally, right? He has a criminal action. So we want to. Do you think they talked

SPEAKER_00to the medical board and said, hey, we're investigating. Well, they are.

SPEAKER_01They have to. They have to. They have to. At this point, they have to talk back to the medical board because now he is being criminally prosecuted. Now, how long that's gonna take, I don't know. But for all the doctors out there, for all the credentialing specialists, I want to go through the process the medical board follows to take action on a physician's license because it involves multiple steps, which explains why it takes so long to get this process going.

SPEAKER_01So, how does this happen? Doctors, pay attention first, the board has to get the complaint or the allegation, right? Somebody has to say something. That's the first thing that has to happen. Who can this come from? It can come from the patients, like we said before, it can come from another doctor, it can come from the hospital staff, it can come from an insurance company, which derives from maybe a malpractice case, right? Complaints to the malpractice for negligence, unethical behavior.

SPEAKER_01So the board has to find out, right? That's number one. Then they go into a preliminary review, and then after that preliminary review, which is done by a committee or staff to try and like, oh, this is frivolous, this is just somebody, you know, picking on a doctor, whatever. So it kind of gets vetted, right? Then it's gonna go to investigation, right? They're gonna start an investigation. What do you think are some of the things that they have to gather in order to do this investigation, Shannon?

SPEAKER_01What do you what do you think are some of the things that they need to get?

SPEAKER_00I'd say first, you know, the complaining person, whatever that person has, or the hospital, or the, you know, the patient. And so, you know, they're probably gonna see what evidence they have first, right? And then kind of after that, the medical records, you know, expert opinions, interviewing other people that have been in the room with them, other physicians, other circulators, you know. And I'm sure, you know, to be honest, it can probably take months to gather all that. What do you think?

SPEAKER_01Of course. And remember, we're dealing with government workers, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. So

SPEAKER_01everything is gonna move at the pace of a cog and a wheel. So that's gonna take months. All right. So now, if the investigation uncovers sufficient evidence of wrongdoing, then the medical board is going to go ahead and file formal charges or an accusation against the physician.

SPEAKER_00Oh. And this

SPEAKER_01sets the stage for formal hearings. The physician is notified of the charges and provided a copy of the findings. It is very important to know this verbiage is not for the criminal prosecution. This has nothing to do with criminal. This is medical side or legal. This is just medical.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_00Now, do they have a burden to tell the police, hey, we found this, doctor's been doing this, we want to let y'all know?

SPEAKER_01That is a great question. They're getting probably the notification from the legal in this case, right? If he's being criminally prosecuted, you know, I that's a great question.

SPEAKER_00Because how does the public how much I think?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think that's what happened. And please don't quote me. And so I'm sure you guys will hunt me down if I'm wrong, but I think that's what actually happened in Dr. Dunch's case, is they got the board is the one who finally notified the police.

SPEAKER_00And

SPEAKER_01it did work in that way. We need to update my information on that. But this is the other way around. So the board has been notified of either a criminal proceeding or a complaint. So in this case, the board would already know what the police have and handle it with the physician's license situation. So, just like in the regular court system, the physician then has a chance to respond. So they do have a chance to respond to those charges. They can admit it, deny them, or they can provide a defense or an explanation.

SPEAKER_01At this time, okay, what happens is the board can offer a settlement and can impose certain restrictions like a suspension, a probation, or additional training, CMEs, courses without a full hearing. Okay. Very different than a trial. Very different than a trial.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it sounds different.

SPEAKER_01So then we have, let's say we gotta go to a formal hearing because the physician doesn't settle or agree to the resolution that the board proposed. Correct. Then they schedule a formal hearing. Now, this hearing involves a hearing officer, an administrative law judge, presentation of the evidence by both the board and the physician. So this is the medical board. This is again nothing to do with the criminal proceedings outside. Here they would also call testimony from experts, witnesses, and the physician.

SPEAKER_01The hearing is similar to a trial, but it's not going to have a jury depending on the jurisdiction of it. Okay.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01Right. The judge. So now they listen to the evidence and both sides make their statements, and now there's a decision on the board, the medical board. Right. So the board deliberates and issues the decision after the hearing. So what are the things that can basically, instead of like jail time, you know how like

SPEAKER_00you

SPEAKER_01can get like probation or jail time when you go to like criminal court? So in medical board court, you can get your license suspended either temporarily or permanently. They could get probation. He could just get like a reprimand or a censure, which is like a restriction, he could have a restriction to his license. They his license could be completely revoked, which take completely taken away.

SPEAKER_00Okay. And

SPEAKER_01then on top of that, he can be imposed fines or sanctions. So that's what they

SPEAKER_00can do. Those are their decisions.

SPEAKER_01Correct.

SPEAKER_00So

SPEAKER_01this is just starting now with this guy from Montana. So I'd love to like do a follow-up and see what the board actually decides because board actions are public information, just like court records. So we can access them and find out what the board actually decided against the doctor's license once this process has actually taken place. Now, similar to criminal court, what do you think that the doctor can do after the judgment has been done?

SPEAKER_00Appeal.

SPEAKER_01Exactly.

SPEAKER_00Oh my goodness.

SPEAKER_01So they generally have the right to appeal the decision to a higher authority.

SPEAKER_00It's a lot, yeah. And they have to get through all of that, right? And then finally, maybe they'll do a public disclosure, right?

SPEAKER_01Correct. So after the decision is made, the medical board is gonna publicly disclose the outcome, like I just said, depending on the severity of the violation. Now, this is often done through the public website announcement or, you know, other channels to ensure public transparency and safety. So there's different varying levels of

SPEAKER_00the case. They don't want to put it on the nightly news. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01No. Now, something interesting is if the physician's license is placed on approbation or if there are continuing conditions, such as like further education or drug monitoring, the board will monitor compliance and will ask for feedback from the physician.

SPEAKER_00Okay. And

SPEAKER_01the physician may be required to submit regular reports or undergo additional evaluations to make sure that they're meeting these standards.

SPEAKER_00Okay. And really the

SPEAKER_01point is this

SPEAKER_00every state that does this?

SPEAKER_01Right. This is like the general process, right? So we're everything's gonna be a little nuanced depending on the state and how they handle certain things and what they define as certain things.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01But this is just like the general practice because we want to have make sure doctors are aware, like if something happens to you, this is what can happen. This is what you're gonna expect. And credentialing people, this is the processes. But the

SPEAKER_00nitty-gritty could totally be, you know. Yeah. I mean, what roles do medical boards such as the Montana Board of Medical Examiners play in ensuring that patients' safety and what are the potential challenges they face in making decisions about license renewals, especially in cases involving serious allegations, right? I mean, criminal versus medical. Medicine is a practice, remember that. But now, more and more, we are seeing that physicians are being criminally charged.

SPEAKER_00And it's sad that it has To get to that, but sometimes if you're practicing, right, and things are going really bad and you keep practicing, and you know it's just not getting better. Somebody has to step in. I mean, what are some of the reasons that a doctor can be criminally prosecuted, Nileen? What have you heard about?

SPEAKER_01We want to make sure that we understand doctors are humans and they make mistakes, which we've said, right? Yes.

SPEAKER_00We're talking more of the bad actors, right? Isn't that what you're like? I'm

SPEAKER_01talking about correct. The bad actors are people who are intentionally doing something to fraud the government or fraud their patients.

SPEAKER_00And we really ought to talk about them because it adds light to them so that you see it's not the whole profession, it's these specific incidences. And the ones that are amazing and are beautiful and healing doctors, those are the ones that we want to protect from the bad actors, right, Nile?

SPEAKER_01Right. And those beautiful, wonderful doctors can, you know, make a mistake. They they could read something wrong. So we're not gonna automatically judge, right? They are practicing. All right, so let's talk about criminal negligence, right? So medical malpractice is usually handled through civil lawsuits, and in some cases where the doctor's actions are deemed grossly negligent or reckless, then criminal prosecution could occur. And that's where that falls under that category of criminal negligence.

SPEAKER_01So, what are some of the examples of that? A doctor performs a surgery under the influence of alcohol or drugs leading to patients' harm or death. What's another example, Shannon, that you could think of?

SPEAKER_00Really, a physician, you know, doing the same thing over and really ignoring standard medical procedures that his colleagues are practicing, leading to patients' severe injury or death, right? You know, and where the other colleagues would say, I would never do that.

SPEAKER_01Right, exactly. And perfect case is Dr. Dunch, right? He was 100% criminal negligence. Number two, what is another reason we can criminally charge a doctor for practicing medicine? Fraudulent billing.

SPEAKER_00Big one, right?

SPEAKER_01You cannot misrepresent information for financial gain. Can't say you did an injection and you didn't even take out a needle.

SPEAKER_00Uh-huh.

SPEAKER_01Okay? Or you did an

SPEAKER_00injection on somebody that didn't need the injection, like this doctor in Montana.

SPEAKER_01Correct. So you cannot do that. There's a fraud, waste, and abuse section of Medicare. Like you cannot. You can be permanently banned. And if you are permanently banned, no bueno, right? So we cannot do that. The other thing which is interesting is participating in a kickback scheme where the doctor receives money or gifts in exchange for patient referrals or prescribing certain drugs. So I wanted the

SPEAKER_00anti-kickback law came into effect and everybody remember everyone signed the attestations. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yes. So this is so important because I want the general public to know doctors do not get a kickback because they gave you that new drug. Okay. There is a huge outcry out there that people are like, oh, the doctor just prescribed it because he gets paid by the insurance company. Like, no, this is why the law came out to make sure that that's not happening. So they cannot be getting direct kickbacks for prescribing a particular drug over another.

SPEAKER_00And the word direct is what is use loosely used for the ones that do that.

SPEAKER_01Correct.

SPEAKER_00The direct part of it.

SPEAKER_01What's another reason that they can be criminally prosecuted, Shannon? What's another one?

SPEAKER_00Substance abuse or addiction, right? I mean, if a doctor misuses or legally distributes controlled substances, we've seen a lot of that coming out of Florida. They can be criminally prosecuted for drug diversion. I mean, what did they say? They were running the opioids on the I-95? Oh my

SPEAKER_01goodness. Yeah, that was crazy. Yeah,

SPEAKER_00I don't know what they were doing. And, you know, that's prescribing the narcotics or the controlled substances to themselves or others. Even things like Ambion. I've been, you know, in credentialing situations where, you know, the doctor had prescribed himself some ambion and, you know, fell asleep and things of that nature. And using their medical license to illegally obtain prescription drugs also, and then distributing them for non-medical use, that would be something that's very huge that falls under the drug diversion with the DEA.

SPEAKER_01And then we have obviously, if you have sexual misconduct or you assault somebody, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01If you can't be touching a patient inappropriately, uh, because any of that misconduct is a sexual assault. Um patients

SPEAKER_00or staff, there are other

SPEAKER_01people.

SPEAKER_00Or

SPEAKER_01staff. Non-consensual sexual acts during a medical examination. We are at our most vulnerable with our doctors when they're we're being examined or when we're under anesthesia, and we want to ensure that this is not happening, right? And so they can be criminally prosecuted for doing that. They can be criminally prosecuted for sexual harassment, which everybody can, right? So that's like a no-brainer. They can be criminally prosecuted for impersonating another medical professional.

SPEAKER_01So, like a physician associate, which is their new term, can't say they're a doctor. You can't do that. You can't say you're a doctor because you're not a doctor. You can't, you

SPEAKER_00definitely can't. And then, you know, the other thing too is you know, I've seen a lot of cases where a provider has passed away. You know, now they have this social security death database that you go and you check, is this actual provider alive to try to really combat some of that fraud because they would just continue practicing as Dr. Smith and with his credentials.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, these are real things that are happening, guys. The other thing they can be criminally prosecuted for is in many cases, doctors are required by law to report suspected cases of child abuse, elder abuse, or other forms of neglect.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, they are.

SPEAKER_01Right? You have to hold

SPEAKER_00reporters.

SPEAKER_01Correct. So if a doctor fails to report, which then leads to further harm or injury of a child, which I understand could be hard to prove, but you can be criminally prosecuted for that. So that's just some of the reasons. Can you think of any other ones?

SPEAKER_00Really? The big one is what this doctor is doing in Helena, Montana, right? The performing unauthorized or unnecessary procedures. And that's classified what I had learned when I did our research for this as criminal negligence or battery on a patient. And it really is when a doctor performs procedures without proper consent or necessity. And that's what we're talking about because the patients think they need the chemo, but they don't need the chemo, you know, and he's giving them the chemo, saying it is of necessity, but it's not, you know, particularly if the action leads to harm.

SPEAKER_00And so again, we're talking 10 suspicious deaths have occurred in Helena, Montana from this. And so there lies your suspicion. And they could be charged with criminal offenses such as battery or criminal negligence. And I just I had to bring that one up to you, Nileen, because I know that that's literally what's happening right now in Helena, Montana. And I'm glad that the Justice Department is looking into it.

SPEAKER_01Right. So that leads to a criminally negligent homicide or manslaughter. Like he could be charged with that, right? And he's making an error, but like, I don't know. We'll see what happens.

SPEAKER_00And they're gonna be so mad that their loved ones have passed away and have a chance.

SPEAKER_01And everybody's

SPEAKER_00talking about what's going on.

SPEAKER_01Yep. And so this is only one of the processes that the doctors deal with and have to go through. And then you have medical staff processes, right? Dictated by policies, rules, regs, bylaws of each facility. Should they take action? Because once that board takes action and then that's published to the license, then you're gonna have the other effect go. So is everybody else going to be notified? Is the board action gonna tell, hey, you have to notify every hospital that you got a board action on your license?

SPEAKER_00And yeah, but my question, and I'm always gonna err on the side of the patient, right? So why did it take a media investigation and law enforcement stepping in for this now to be investigated? I feel like the medical board should have acted long before it got to this point with two, three suspicious deaths, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's the real question here. The system depends on medical boards to protect the patients. But when I why

SPEAKER_00is there a board if nobody is boarding, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, the patient's already been harmed and the lives have been lost, and the trust is basically it's gone. So let's talk a little bit about what we can do, right? So let's just wrap this up and like, okay, what are some of the things that credentialing processes can do to kind of help weed some of this out or at least give a nudge to the board and say, can you kind of look at this? It's kind of weird.

SPEAKER_00And I mean, we're gonna say shout out to our medical staff professionals as we do on every episode, but we're really just gonna get into a really difficult part right now because, you know, are you allowed to report, right? That's another question. You know, you see this is happening. Are you allowed to say something? How effective are current credentialing and oversight processes and identifying and addressing these systemic issues, like over-prescribing narcotics, administering inappropriate treatments. I mean, you guys are out there mandated to do OPPEs, you know, FPPEs, and these are out there to catch things like that, to spot trends.

SPEAKER_00Is it a pattern? Are these things happening? Right, girl,

SPEAKER_01those are focused reviews and ongoing reviews for all of those.

SPEAKER_00The patient, I'm sorry, the medical staff people knew what I was talking about.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, but for our friends out there, those are focused and ongoing reviews, and yes, we subject our doctors to that.

SPEAKER_00It's just so passionate. It's a it's you wait credentialing people are so passionate about the patient safety aspect, right?

SPEAKER_01Yes, we are, we are. So really take a look at that. And so, what improvements can be made to communication and collaboration, right, between our medical boards and our hospitals and then our law enforcement agencies. Like these are three entities that do have to talk to each other. And like I said, we're not gonna go ahead and say, oh, the doctor made a mistake one time, you know, and he prescribed me the wrong medicine and I had an anaphylactic reaction, but you never told the doctor that you were allergic to XYZ.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we're not talking about that.

SPEAKER_01We're not talking about that. We're talking egregious situations, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So what you can do is well, we need to talk about establishing clear communication standards between these three bodies. And this could involve maybe creating protocols for reporting concerns, ensuring that allegations of misconduct are swiftly communicated, and that there is a shared understanding of how each entity is responding to the situation involving a physician.

SPEAKER_00True. Yeah, I think you're right. And you know, really asking what reforms do you think are necessary in medical credentialing systems to prevent providers, practitioners with questionable practices from continue to operate under a valid medical license, right? I mean, I feel like that's really what you're asking if we had to ask in a technical term.

SPEAKER_01Right. So you have to have ongoing monitoring and auditing, you have to offer education and have ethical standards. Doctors gotta do CMEs all the time, every two years. They have to meet a certain number of CMEs. Like, there's a CME for abuse and negligence, right? Like they have to take a CME on this.

SPEAKER_00Self making self-reporting okay, right, Nile?

SPEAKER_01Correct. Correct. You

SPEAKER_00know, making self-reporting okay should really be where it starts, right?

SPEAKER_01Right. Advocate for policy and procedure reforms, right? The medical staff could collaborate with other healthcare institutions and regulatory bodies to advocate for the policy reforms and improve medical credentialing practices. And this could include supporting more stringent criteria for license renewal, maybe establishing clear guidelines for responding to allegations, encouraging a review of state and national credentialing standards. I mean, this is what our organizations like NAMS are working towards and really

SPEAKER_00and

SPEAKER_01NCQA and all the accrediting bodies are working so hard to make sure that we are holding our standards to the highest level, and that these people who are doing this job are true professionals. You have to know what you're talking about when you're working in these departments. And so we see you, we understand, and we want you to advocate with us. So we have a little PSA section, public service announcement for our patients. What do we want to tell our patients, Shan?

SPEAKER_00Well, basically, what do we say every single episode, right? Research and verify a doctor's credentials through state medical boards or online databases, even as simple as doing a Google search and checking the first, second, third page and making sure that you're looking. You know, seek a second opinion. If they say, hey, you have you have some cancer, you might need some chemotherapy. Go and see another doctor. I know it might sound crazy, but if things seem questionable or aggressive, you know, that's something that you want to investigate because that's kind of where people are getting into that unnecessary billing and things of that nature.

SPEAKER_00You know, you want to ask questions, right? You want to ensure that a doctor provides clear, understandable answers about diagnoses and treatment options. Show me my x-ray, show me my CT, show me my stuff, show me what a normal something looks like and why mine looks like that. I mean, it's okay to ask that. I mean, we would ask that about buying a new car. Right. We would ask that, you know, show me the punch list for my house, right? No, show me the punch list for my body. Show me what I need on my body and what I don't have, and I need to see it. Okay.

SPEAKER_00And report, right? I need to say it again, again, and again. Report any suspicious or ethical practices to medical boards, hospital administrations, or law enforcement. If you wake up out of your doctor's office, your top is off, your pants are undone. Go to a law enforcement professional at that point. You know, don't go stop home and call Susie. No, go straight there. If something has happened, I don't feel right, I need to make it a report. Right, Nile?

SPEAKER_01Exactly. So PSA to our doctors. Doctors, we love you, but please maintain transparency and openness with your patients. Ensure they understand their care options and risks. Engage in continuous learning to stay up to date with all the ethical standards and best practices. Be responsive to concerns and questions raised by patients or your colleagues and be aware. Look at your colleagues, how they're behaving, see what they're doing, like just report it, right?

SPEAKER_01We want to report this behavior so that you don't want to ruin your profession because you're friends with so-and-so, and you know he was doing coke last night. Like you can't do that, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and now he's operating on the spine today. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And then credentialers, right? I mean, you know, shout out to medical staff professionals, the OGs, the new G's, the mid Gs, the people that are going out to get their NAM certifications. You know, you guys are the true MVPs. Verify and continuously monitor the credentials of the healthcare providers. I mean, that's what you all are doing every day. I would say do not depend on web crawlers. Do not depend on the big softwares that are telling you, oh, we could do it all this way. Once in a while, do a manual audit.

SPEAKER_00Make sure that things are actually working as they say that they need to be working. Strengthen communication and collaborate with medical board, law enforcement, and hospitals to address concerns swiftly. So if you see something, say something, just like Nileen is saying to the doctors. Educate your hospital healthcare staff on ethical practices. A lot of times, medical staff will be responsible for the medical executive committee, the credentialing committee, and really, you know, if they have a little onboarding part of their onboarding process, really use that time to talk about what you do as a medical staff and reiterate self-reporting is important.

SPEAKER_00Reporting something that you see that's not right is important. Do not be afraid to speak out. That is important for you to understand. You are saving a life if you're speaking out and you're telling something that has been a pattern of behavior. You're seeing it doesn't mean it's the first time it's happened, honey. It's probably happened a thousand times before. And then keep yourself up to date, right? I mean, what do you think, Nileen?

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Absolutely. You hit the nail on the head. So we want to take it out to you guys. Should doctors with a history like this oncologist ever be allowed to practice again? Should the medical board system be overhauled? And how does this happen?

SPEAKER_00Exactly. It seems like we always leave you with more questions than what we answer, right, Nile? But let us know your thoughts. Send us a message on Instagram at Craig Chronicles or email us at credentialing at credentialing chronicles.com.

SPEAKER_01And if you want to check out your own doctor's backgrounds, we're gonna drop some links in the show notes, teach you guys how to do this.

SPEAKER_00And make sure you're checking in Helena, Montana. I'm gonna put you on blast until you guys actually research and do something with this doctor. But that's it for today's episode of Credentialing Chronicles. Thanks for listening, and we'll see you next time where we'll expose another shocking reality of the world of medical credentialing. What do we say, Nileen? Stay credentialed, not

SPEAKER_01canceled.

SPEAKER_00Whoo, that was a lot of tea. Who knew doctors had more drama than reality TV?

SPEAKER_01And if you think that was wild, just wait till next week. We've got more stories, more scandals, and more credentialing chaos coming your way.

SPEAKER_00Hit that follow button and don't forget just because they have an MD doesn't mean they have a clean record.

SPEAKER_01See you next time on Credentialing Chronicles. Stay credentialed, not canceled.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Patient to Credentialing Superhero: The Dylan Avatar Story

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 28 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail One jump changed everything. What happened afterward led Dylan Avatar toward a purpose he never expected. In this episode of Credentialing Chronicles, Shannen Reyes-Aguayo and Nyleen Flores sit down...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Live at NAMSS 2026 (50th Anniversary)

    Nov 10, 202640 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Tea dresses, tiny microphones, and a little NAMSS chaos! 🫖🎙️ We’re taking you inside our pink booth at NAMSS’s 50th anniversary conference in New Orleans! This short episode is full of live...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Exam Room Should Be Safe! "I am Jane Doe"

    Nov 3, 202633 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail ⚠️ *TRIGGER WARNING:* This episode discusses sexual assault, sexual abuse by healthcare professionals, and child sexual abuse. Although the discussion is non-graphic, these topics may be distressing....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Spillin’ Tea Across America: New Jersey

    Oct 27, 202633 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail SOMEBODY ELSE'S DEA NUMBER?! $172 MILLION IN MEDICARE FRAUD?! NEW JERSEY, WE NEED TO TALK! 👀☕️ The Garden State is serving up some SERIOUS healthcare tea, and trust us… this episode is WILD! 🔥 This...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Spillin Tea Across America: New Hampshire

    Oct 13, 202640 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail New Hampshire’s Healthcare Wake-Up Call A provider can be qualified, credentialed - and still out of reach. A provider’s identity can be legitimate - and still be used to submit fraudulent claims. Who...

    Credit the people on this episode