Corporate Venturing Insider #107 with Angela Lee from Columbia & 37 Angels ===
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Welcome to the Corporate Venturing Insider series! Where I interview top practitioners in the CVC world and learn with you the best practices and golden nuggets that they have accumulated over their careers. This week, you will be hearing a conversation I had with Angela Lee, Founder of 37 Angels and Professor of Venture Capital at Columbia Business School. Angela could you take a few minutes to share your story and how you got to where you are today?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Yeah, so my journey has been one of a path of happy accidents. So I was a founder first. I went to UC Berkeley graduated during the first Dot Com boom. And so of course started a company because that's what you do. And then went on to be a product manager. And then I thought I was gonna stay an entrepreneur forever.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: I went to Columbia Business School for my MBA, and then I graduated and became a McKinsey consultant because that's totally the same thing as being an entrepreneur.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: And then reentered the entrepreneurship space a little bit later. I was an angel investor first. Started 37 Angels, which I could talk a little bit more about.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: And then maybe eight years ago, a venture capital firm started reaching out to say, you've been doing well as an angel. Would you like to join VC as a venture partner role?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: But very much not intentional.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Happy accidents, like you said. Actually, I think you're the first one to mention you graduated during the Dot Com boom. So maybe you can share a bit of context. Everyone reads about it, but what was it like graduating during that time?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: So I think the pros were that it really felt like the world was full of possibilities and, literally the internet was being born and new ways of shopping and discussing and interacting with people were changing on, a monthly basis. And so it was a really great time to be working and starting companies in such a time of possibility.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: On the other hand. There was no roadmap of how to do any of this. How do you fundraise? How do you build a pitch deck? How do you build a an MVP? None of that existed, so we were all figuring out on our own. And it was a lot of the blind leading the blind. And so I'm really grateful I started my first company when I was 19 because I feel like I had the exuberance of youth to not realize I had no idea what I was doing.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: It was me and three co-founders, all from UC Berkeley, and we knew we were very young to be starting a company, and so we had three sets of business cards. I had a business card that said I was the Director of Marketing, VP of Marketing, and Chief Marketing Officer, which all of which were true.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: 'Cause it was just me running marketing. And the more senior, the client, the more junior of a card we would hand them because if I handed someone the CMO card, they'd be like, you should not be the CMO of anything. But if I had the Director of Marketing card, they'd be like, oh, well then my assumption is that there's somebody managing you.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: And it was one of many things that we did which were very silly. But again, we were learning by doing, learning by throwing spaghetti against a wall.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Actually, that's a cool hack.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Yeah, I don't recommend it.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Very nice. Then you moved into angel investment and- what I mean, clearly you met entrepreneurs and I think you were 10 years in the bay area, so clearly you were exposed a lot, but why angel investments? What was a trigger for you to get started and maybe some success, maybe some failures?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Yeah, so I wrote my first Angel investing check in 2008, which was a really fun time to start angel investing. I wrote a $5,000 check and it was to a very good girlfriend of mine. She had made a movie that promoted the awareness of mental health in the Asian community. Asians don't talk about mental health. They're like, you're just sad. Get over it. Right?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: I did not know the term angel, angel investing. I didn't know anything about venture capital. I knew nothing about the space, and I wrote the check, lost all of my money. But then all of a sudden I was a quote unquote angel investor and people started finding me and reaching out.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: And so for a period of maybe three to four years people would send me their deals and I maybe look at 20 deals a year and I'd maybe write one check per year. And most of those early checks were not successful. And then in 2012-2013, I realized that people need to learn what this meant. And I had learned a lot of this through my own mistakes.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: And I said, I'm gonna get together a group of my friends and teach them what I've learned. And that was the start of 37 Angels.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Okay, very good. And then you started 37 Angels, so maybe you can describe what it is and why you started it. It.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Yeah, so I started 37 Angels with two goals in mind. The first was education. Especially in 2012. Nobody, knew what these terms meant. So I would go to these conferences and I would literally come home with pages of notes of terms I didn't understand. And I would go home and I would just Google everything.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: I would talk to everybody, I would ask all these questions. And I very quickly realized nobody knows what these terms mean. And nobody really knows. How do you diligence a company? How do you value a company? So I said, I'm gonna try to teach again a group of my close friends, how do you actually do this?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: And so that was the first problem I was trying to solve, which was how do I shine a light on the black box that is startup investing? And then the second thing is I wanted to close the diversity gap. When I started Angel investing, I was fairly young to be doing it. I'm an Asian woman and I would walk into rooms and people would quite literally ask me if I was lost. Or they would ask me.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Things like, where's your money from? Is your husband aware of what you're doing? And just all these crazy questions. So I said I wanted more people who looked like me to be investing in startups. And so 37 Angels we activate new diverse investors through education.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Okay, and why is the number 37?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Yeah. When we started, only 13% of angel investors were women, and we wanted to close the gap from 13% to 50%.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Oh, that's a good number. Okay, now I get it. And
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: talk about the performance of 37 Angels. How many investments, what was the returns over time?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Yeah, so every year we look at about 2000 companies to invest in 10, and so we've invested in about 115 companies over just over 11 years. We have had over 50 investment bootcamps that teach people how to do angel investing. We have had three IPOs and 16 acquisitions, and our portfolio internal rate of return is over 20%, which is in the top decile of performance.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: So our requirement to invest is that you have six months of customer data. It doesn't always mean revenue, although usually it means it does mean revenue. But so that tends to be seed stage. Although we do a little bit of pre-seed, we do a little bit of Series A, but the fat part of our bell curve is in seed stage.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: And we developed our diligence rubric of what we look for. We have the four P framework; people, problem, progress, and price.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: And there are a lot of folks out there who are raising who maybe shouldn't be raising, angel and venture capital or who aren't ready yet, and so it takes a lot of No's to get to that yes.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Okay.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: So maybe it's a tough question now. As you are invested from 37 Angels, if you had seen yourself when you started at 19 years old, would you have invested yes or no, and why not?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: A hundred percent no. And the main reason why is 'cause we were a services company. So we were essentially an outsourced tech consulting firm. We were helping people with Java programming and Oracle DBAs. And so because we were a services based company, we were not scalable and so was not venture backable, nor did we try to raise venture funding at the time.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Okay. I understand.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: And it's interesting I would argue 20 to 25% of the companies that pitch us, what I tell them is, this is a great company. Go and run it. Don't raise any outside capital own a hundred percent and just go build a really profitable company. You don't need to raise outside funding. You can grow through customer revenue, you can grow through grants, you can go through debt. There are so many alternatives to angel and VC funding.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: It's a golden nugget and I love it because I keep saying it to many entrepreneurs I meet, including from France, where I said, unless you're planning to go very fast and you want to grow fast and you want to be very risky, but potential, very high outcome don't go for VC money. And it's always surprised I'm coming from a VC to tell them that, but I think there are many good companies, very good business models that are just not venture type returns.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Absolutely.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: So what is your own bias as an investor? Clearly you talked about people, problem, progress, pricing, so that's built into your bias.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: But when you meet the team, what it is that you're watching out for.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Yeah, so I think we have different biases by the different Ps. On the people side, I have a real bias towards data-driven learners. And I think another bias I have is I didn't come up with this, I someone else said it, which is like, hustle, not hassle. Which is, I like good salespeople and all, investors want that found and team to be a good salesperson.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: But I do think that I have a visceral reaction for people who go too far down that 'salesy' path. And sometimes they are fantastic founders. I also think, do I wanna, work with this person for the next decade? Yeah.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Okay. This is really good.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: You're looking at a proposition and decide if it's going to fit or not. And we talked about your bias for people. When you look at a deck, what is your biggest bias? So you haven't met the people behind it. You just look at the deck, what it is that is like, no way.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: And it's like, whoa, okay. I want to deep dive.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Yeah, so the first thing, it's such a basic thing, is literally do I understand the deck? And I know that sounds like such an obvious thing, but I am shocked at how many decks I get, where I read and I'm like I don't know what this company does.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: So that's the first thing is just literally do I understand what they do.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: The second thing I look at is the team page. Is this the right team? And then I look for traction, right? So I am looking for rapid growth. And then I would say finally I am looking for a deep understanding of the customer.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Like a unfair advantage from like the founder market fit concept.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: So some it, it's just something unique, right? It could be that they have strategic partners that are gonna help them to penetrate this market better than anybody else. It could be that they grew up in the industry and so they know everybody in the space and they're gonna be able to sell into their first hundred customers really easily.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: It can be that they have some interesting distribution channel that no one else has thought of. Like, I don't care what the unfair advantage is, but there has to be something that the team has that is going to let them win in the space. 'Cause if it is a good idea, I've been pitched that idea 10 other times.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Yep. Yep. And that's very fair.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Now let's talk about your exposure to corporate VCs. And I've heard you talking about corporate VCs, but you probably were exposed to them both as an entrepreneur angel investor, and of course you meet with them I'm sure, in your class as your students. What's your view of corporate VCs and how do you think they are evolving over time?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Yeah. So, corporate VCs are in about a quarter of all venture deals. And so it's important for all of us to understand because whether or not you work at a corporate venture capital firm or not, you will invest alongside them. So I think we'll start with the pros and then we can talk about the cons.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: So the pros of corporate VC is strategic value add, right? So if you are, like, I'll give you a great example of ZX Ventures, which was AB InBev's corporate VC arm. They don't exist anymore. But they were really good at helping beverage companies with licensing and distribution, which is very difficult in the US 'cause it's all mandated on a state by state level and it's expensive.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: There was another one that they actually would help you. It was a life science VC and they would help small companies get access to a wet lab, which is also incredibly expensive. So there's so much strategic benefit that could help. On the corporate VC side. The other thing is it can open a lot of doors for strategic partners, right?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: So if you, they have relationships with Fortune 500 companies that can open a lot of doors and that could be fantastic. So I think those are the pros of corporate VC.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: The cons, the biggest con I hear is speed which is that corporates tend to not move at the pace of VCs and entrepreneurs. And so sometimes they can hold up deals. That can be one. And then the other thing is it could constrain your future fundraising and exit paths.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: So if a corporate VC does lead your series A sometimes in their term sheet they can put in like a first write of refusal, which means that your series B has to be led by them and maybe from an exit perspective, they get to be the first ones to put an offer on the table. And so you're like really getting in bed with the corporate in the long term.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: And that could be an another downside.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Yeah. So first I think the conclusion from what you just said is, yes, Mr. Entrepreneur does do look into corporate VC because they bring some value, but be mindful of what you're signing up for.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Absolutely.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: And you mentioned right of first refusal, which I think was something that quite a few corporate VC were asking a while back.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: I think it's decreased, but it's probably not zero. Can you share why this is so dangerous to have this? Because sometimes I hear, yeah, but they're getting value. So the entrepreneur is getting a potential exit. The mothership is getting some guarantee's. A win-win. But I think it forgets both the entrepreneurs and the other investors who are investing.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: So can you share about the right of first refusal and why this is so problematic for corporate VC to ask for that?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Yeah, if you're at a point where you're ready to be acquired, right? It's very dangerous to have any whisper of acquisition value out in the market. And so, you hear like, oh, whatever this corporate VC is valuing them at a hundred million dollars.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Right? That can really taint other acquisition offers that you might get. That's one. And then I think that there's also just like a feeling of, oh, if they're connected to this corporate VC. Then sometimes a different corporate can almost start to see them as competitive. We had a portfolio company where a corporate VC led their series A and their series B, and when it came time to exit, it felt like that was became the only option of who could acquire them. Thankfully, it was a good outcome, but I think as an entrepreneur, you want options and having a corporate VC have a first rate of refusal, it constrains your options. And that time of exit, that can mean lower exit valuations. Or if that deal doesn't go through will, now you're in a really tough spot because it would've been harder to talk to other people.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: And I like it takes time. Right? Like it's not like. You have a conversation and you find out in a day that it's not gonna work, that could waste three months, six months of your time, and that is a long time in a startup lifecycle.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Yeah, especially if you discuss it when you have six months run rate left and it takes three months to get an answer, then you end up in a very tough spot.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Absolutely.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Now, apart from right of first refusal, is there anything that you would say, some corporate VCs have misbehaved and they should stop.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: I dunno about misbehaving. I do think that a lot of corporate VCs and like corporate accelerators, I would lump into the same bucket. There's gonna be like an overpromising where they will say, look, if you come join our accelerator or you take money from our corporate VC arm that we're gonna give you, all the strategic help.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: We're gonna open all these doors and then when those things don't come through, I think that can be very frustrating for the founder. And I think that happens a lot over promising.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Yeah, I think setting the right expectations, not overselling. It's very hard because you do intend to bring all that strategic value. Whether you can deliver on it that's sometimes, actually, probably all the time outside your control.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Yeah, I do hear whispers about like corporates doing it as a way to steal trade secrets. I don't see that happening a lot. I feel like founders are very afraid of that. Luckily, I've seen very little of that play out in the real world.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: I actually don't think that's true, and if it's true, it's gross negligence because the risk to the mothership is so high.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Totally agree, but I find that founders are very afraid of it, but I don't
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: think they
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: no, I understand the fear, actually. I can imagine if you're very secretive of your project and you're talking to the CVC of a mothership that could compete with you in the future, you sharing with them is just, yeah it's, it feels dangerous but it practice. In our case, we have a clear chinese wall. And I keep explaining to the mothership, the reason we have a Chinese wall is to protect you mothership. Because if you end up getting trade secrets from what we learned from startups, you are the one at risk and you have to prove a negative in a court. You have to prove you didn't have the trade secret in the first place. It's very hard to prove a negative in court.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Yes.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Now what? Is there any CVC that you've worked with or you met, which you thought, wow, they have a good design. This is something that others should learn from?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: So the CVCs I think do a good job. They're very clear on their value add, right? So they were like, we will help you with distribution and licensing. I think, Salesforce Ventures, there is a pretty clear path to M&A, so I think that about a third of what they eventually end up acquiring comes through their corporate VC leg.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: And they were explicit about it.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: It's very explicit. Yeah, so I think it's just very clear like the purpose of our CVC is to find acquisition targets or the purpose of our CVC is to make money, which is what I would say Google Ventures does that very well. I think the ones who do it poorly are, they're like, we do all of these things, but they do everything a little bit.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Setting expectation is critical.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Now you teach venture capital, so maybe I should ask this. What is a myth of your students believing something is true? And then when they go through your class, they're like, oh, wow, this is not what I thought.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: So one, the first one that comes to mind and I feel like I should come up with a more interesting one, is that being a good VC is about picking really good investments. And while that is true, it's really important to source good investments. But if you don't have good deal flow, you can be the best picker in the world. If you're picking amongst garbage, you're not gonna get great stuff.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: I think another one would be that competition is bad. I think founders are really afraid of competition. Investors can be very afraid of competition, and I think one thing that we teach in our class is to have a much more nuanced view of competitive landscapes.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: There are markets where you can have a lot of winners.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: So like understanding competitive dynamics is really important as you're thinking about what is a good venture outcome in this space. And it's not just like competition is bad, I think is something I try to disavow my students of.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: That's a good one, I think, and it goes with market size. If the market is huge versus small. It's where the competition doesn't matter as much. I think it was Lei Jun, the CEO of Xiaomi, saying something about "even pigs can fly in a tornado", which I think basically means if the market is huge, you will be able to do well. But if you pick a market that's that's very, very small, then there's so little you can do.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Now let's talk about decision making, which hasn't come through. It's clearly part of diligence, but there's still a point in time where you need to decide to invest or not based on the diligence, and there will be times where it's not quite obvious. You could decide, yes, you could decide no.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: What advice would you give for, especially corporate VC where the decision making is typically very different consensus based, lot of data here, typically, especially in seed or Series A, you don't have as much data and maybe consensus is not going to help as much. So how, would you advise a corporate VC that's being designed right now to think about the decision making of an investment.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Yeah, so I think you have to very clearly define 'who', 'how', and 'when'. So who is, I think you need to constrain the 'who'. I think there is a instinct with corporate VC that we're gonna have everyone make a decision. And I think that, Amazon has the two pizza rule, which is they don't try to have working meetings with more people than can be fed by two pizzas. And I do think that having 25 people try to make a decision is near to impossible. And frankly, I think leads to worse venture outcomes. 'Cause it means that you're going to probably invest in the more obvious, less kind of innovative thing.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: So constraining the 'who' and like being very clear, like we are deputizing these five people max, right to make a decision.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: In terms of the 'how', I do think it's important for everyone to have some sort of rubric, right? So these are the 14 things we care about, and we're gonna give each of them a score. And I would really encourage your score to be like on a scale of one to four, not like one to five. And the reason why is 'cause it's one to five. It's too easy to give everything a three, but if it's one to four, then it forces people like, do I like this or do I not like this?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: And then have rules, right? So if any, if more than one metric is below a two, we can't invest. If the average is below a 3.2, whatever, it's like having some sort of clear thing. And then recognizing that sometimes you throw the rubric out, right?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: So we have our rubric and we do try to have that, but I would say that-.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: So we write 10 checks a year, one check a year I'm like according to what's on this piece of paper, I either shouldn't be investing or I should be investing, but I'm gonna make the other decision. 'cause that's what my gut says. And so allowing yourself the freedom to say that sometimes my gut is gonna go in a different direction and I'm gonna have the confidence to stick behind my gut.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: But you can't throw out the rubric all the time, right? So saying but every year I get to make two, two dumb decisions. it's fine. But every decision can't be made off of gut.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: I really like it that makes sense. What would be, and that's my final question and maybe it's helpful, which is. What do you think is the role of corporate VCs to help entrepreneurs being more successful? What should they focus on to help entrepreneurs unlock value to society?
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: That's a big question.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Mm-hmm.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: I would say that one is to share the wisdom of past failures. I think a lot of the times people talk about sharing best practices. I think sharing past failures and mistakes is so much more useful, especially for a founder. So that is one. And then I think the second is making expensive things less expensive by giving them a playground.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: The corporate VCs that do a good really job is when there's something that's very difficult for a small company to do. So maybe it's access big data. Maybe it is too do like something that involves like a physical lab. Maybe that's something that involves doing a pilot with their customers. 'Cause the power of corporates is scale and just massive access to resources. But the power of startups is this like nimbleness and this agileness. And if you're able to marry those two, magic is truly created.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Angela, thank you so much for your time today and I think we touched many topics, but I think there was quite a few golden nuggets for the podcast audience.
Nicolas Sauvage | TDK Ventures: Thank you.
Angela Lee | Columbia & 37 Angels: Thank you so much for having me.