Conversations with Institutional Investors

146: JANA's John Coombe 2026 – Active Management, AI and The Rise of TPA
After posting an archived conversation with JANA Investment Advisers' Executive Director John Coombe, our listeners requested that we ask him back on the show to see if his views have changed since the 2019 interview. This time, we discuss geopolitical chaos, the impact on markets and why John sees today's AI boom as fundamentally different from the dot-com bubble. John also shares some frank views on active management, which he argues has faced an unprecedented decline as shrinking investor time horizons push money toward passive strategies, though he sees it surviving with a different clientele of longer-term, mum-and-dad investors. We also touch on the total portfolio approach, portfolio resilience and DAA as "tinkering at the margin". Enjoy the show! __________ Follow the Investment Innovation Institute [i3] on Linkedin Subscribe to our Newsletter Explore our library of insights from leading institutional investors at [i3] Insights __________ Overview of John Coombe Podcast 08:30 I'm not one of those people who believe a conflict with China is inevitable 14:30 Inflation's resting rate might be structurally higher 20:00 Does the current AI boom have similarities with the tech bubble of the 2000s? No! We are overweight US equities. 25:00 AI might turn out to be like the airline industry, where consumers get to fly everywhere while the underlying airline never becomes profitable. We get all of these beautiful AI tools but we are not paying for it. So who is? 35:00 Baillie Gifford article: AI isn't coming for your job; it is coming for your mind 38:00 AI has changed our investment process; it used to take us hours to go through notes of manager meetings, but now Claude can do that in seconds. 43:00 I've never seen the demise of active management to the extent that we've seen it in the last five years. You look at quality as a factor, it has been dreadful. 45:00 We've seen the demise of value, growth and quality managers. 47:00 Timeframes seem to have collapsed; there is a lot more trading these days. If you can lengthen your timeframe. 48:00 The days of active being in the big supers are gone, but active in mum & dad portfolio is alive and well 53:00 DAA and the total portfolio approach 56:30 While we have Choice (legislation), it is pretty hard to say you are doing full TPA Full Transcript of Episode 146 Wouter Klijn 00:19 Welcome to the I3 podcast. I'm here today with John Coombe, who's the Executive Director at JANA Investment Advisers. Now, we recently put out a archived interview with John, and that sparked some interest from our listeners. So we are now updating that edition and see if things have changed because it has been quite a different investment environment. The previous interview was done in 2019, and so since then we had COVID 19, which sparked a rethink in supply chains in manufacturing. We've had a lot of geopolitical turmoil with wars in Ukraine, Iran, in Gaza, and this has caused also sharp movements in energy markets. We've seen spikes in oil prices, in gas, and yet equities have been shooting the lights out over the last three years, as if nothing has happened. So, John, welcome to the show, and what do you make of all this dichotomy between strong equity markets and a chaotic backdrop? Has that changed your ideas about strategy, asset allocation? What do you think? John Coombe 02:30 It's very interesting if you look at long-term data and you're a bit of a history buff. Most geopolitical events don't actually affect the stock market much at all. These short-term blips, you know. I think when the Kuwait War was on, I think the market was down for a week, and then it was back to where it was, you know, a month later or something. Look, the reality is is that analysts. and and investors look at earnings and look at are the earnings being disrupted by this event? If not, then why are we reacting to it? And I think you know in looking at the biggest event that's happening right now, which is the AI revolution, and the amount of money that's flowing in through earnings into those companies and into the broader ecosystem. Because I read today that SpaceX generated $500 million worth of revenue for the four five big banks in the U.S. who have increased their profits by 39 per cent So no wonder the banking sectors, like in the United States, is up. It it is really interesting that the market is focusing back on what it really should focus on most of the time, which is the earnings ability of a company, and then the ability of that company to turn that earnings into profits and into dividends to shareholders. Now, part of what we're seeing is this massive increase in in earnings. The next part of this magic show is basically: heck, can they turn that into profits and into dividend streams for investors? Because at the end of the day, we're all going to have to live off the you know the earnings of these companies through our superannuation, so I think that's the real interesting part in markets at the moment is just this fascination with you know projected earnings going forward. Wouter Klijn 04:57 Let's delve into AI a little bit later. But if I can push a little bit back on sort of the geopolitical view, and I think John Peace is also quite famous for pulling out a graph where he shows major geopolitical events, and there basically are blips on on the on the chart of of stock returns, but there is sort of also the argument where okay, these events might not have great impact, but there is also a structural change happening at the same time, and it is this idea that we are moving to a multipolar world where you know we had the Great American Peace, Pax Americana, that period is now over, and we're moving to a different period that is inherently more volatile, more conflict around, and that this changes the structure of markets as well. So the previous period was quite a long period, and and so maybe that doesn't show up in the graph as a change, but if we move into this multipolar world where there's, you know, more actors that can disrupt the flows of the economy and the markets itself, could this change the the markets more structurally in a fundamental way that that hasn't happened before? John Coombe 06:21 Well, in a multipolar world, a place like China, being the other part of that world, its its size in the global markets is not reflected today. You look at its weight in equity markets, in Bond markets, the fact that it hasn't got a free float currency, even the size of the economy-you know-it's the second largest in the world. It is definitely not the second largest stock market in the world, right? So there's a mismatch in the financial world between this bipolar world, I'm a bit of a I like history. I can't name a conflict where China has been the aggressor, and yet we, the Western world, expects China to be the aggressor. And part of me goes, well, we can have a bipolar world where everyone gets on famously well, as long as you don't push the, you know, the boundaries too far, and and people don't overassert themselves in terms of land grabs. It's generally land grabs that cause conflict. Let's be honest. Yeah. And if I'm the leadership in China, I've got 1.6 billion people that I've got to manage and meet their expectations. I'm not certain that most Chinese have an expectation that they want to go to war over Taiwan or they want to go to war over anything; they just want to get on with life and and have a much better life than their fathers and their grandparents did, etc. So I'm a little bit more. I'm not one of these people that just see conflict with China as inevitable. I think you push them too far; it will become inevitable. But I don't see in their history, and as we're witnessing today, like we wouldn't have a conflict in the Middle East if certain powers had not decided that they were going to attack another country. So it's this tension between: Are we going for big bang sort of? It's ours. We've got to keep it, etc. Or are we going to live in a world where two can prosper and three can prosper, etc. I am, I am half full all the time, so I'm going for the let's frost it together. So, but but in talking about geopolitical risk, there is no doubt that the regulator wants trustees today to have a view on all of these matters and to at least have thought about it in their planning and their risk programmes, in terms of the possibilities of conflict, the possibilities of you know extended periods of delays on the Strait of Amor, etc. You know, continued conflict in the Middle East for say another year or so; those things should be in the planning of a fund executives to give to their trustees to to show that they've thought about it. I think the real issue is that the the the structure of the bank. System and other things have changed over the last 10 or so years, and as you become a bigger player in it, like Aussie Super and ART and or the Big Five, right? They're big players in the derivatives markets. They're big players in the in the cash market. They're big players in the FX, etc. So that causes the regulator to think of them differently and their impact on liquidity in the market. If we got into a stress situation, so I understand why they're concerned and why they want trustees to have thought about all of those issues, and I think it's important that we that we have like the trustees and others have thought about their role in in this. But I wouldn't over over-dramatise it because let let's hope that it's all theoretical and that like we don't have a banking crisis because we know banking crises are terrible on the broader economy. So, but but we do have to think about it and we do have to plan as though bad things can happen, we can't just sit in our, you know, sit with our investments and hope that everything goes well. Wouter Klijn 11:29 Yeah, no, for sure. So geopolitics don't make much of a difference, but John Coombe 11:33 well, they do. Sorry, sorry, sorry. They have because we've seen governments changing supply lines, whether it's fuel, whether it's manufacturing, etc. We're starting to see governments encouraging build out of of more expensive inflationary manufacturing within their own borders to ensure supply of essential services. Now that is why you know a number of commentators who look you know 10 years out, etc. five to 10 years out, are talking about a higher resting rate for inflation than we've historically had. We may have, and history tells you that the U.S. grows at about 2 per cent even with all its technological booms and everything. 2 per cent the average, right over the whole of its sort of latter history. So, if it's growing at let's call it one half to two, and inflation's still around two or to two and a half, we've still got pressure on wages, on real incomes, etc. And at the same time, we've got new technology that's eating away at traditional jobs, etc. etc. So this political pullback, where we're seeing the far right, the whinges, you know, the ones that are always pointing out that everything was better way back in time, and etc. Those parties are still going to have a platform because all of the thing is pushing for the haves to keep having and the have-nots to to miss out. All of this technology chain is really hurting lower pay positions, and if we have robotics coming, as you know, if you read some of the books, then like that's more jobs lost, right? Wouter Klijn 13:48 Yeah. So where do you sit in that debate on inflation? Do you think that we've moved to an environment where we're basically going to see structurally higher inflation for the coming period? John Coombe 13:59 It's going to be high, but it's nowhere near what I grew up through the Wouter Klijn 14:04 double-digit inflation John Coombe 14:06 70s, 80s child. You know, when I started in investments, you know, inflation was 6 per cent or 7 per cent in Australia. So, yeah, look, it could be fundamentally a little bit higher. It may be around the three mark instead of the two and a half or whatever. It could be a quarter of a percent higher or a half a percent higher. It's not going to be twice as high as it as it could be, right? It's there's just too many negative forces on on wages, etc. That that are going to impede you know having a massive spike in inflation unless our supply chains really get screwed up by some event. Wouter Klijn 14:53 In the in the 2019 interview with Daniel, you sort of revisited a decision. You made in in the tech boom, where I think you were advising Wesfarmers and Michael Cheney, who was the CFO at the time. You basically called them up and said, "Get out of U.S. equities." John Coombe 15:13 Correct. Wouter Klijn 15:14 And and basically, there seems to be some similarities with the environment we're in now. There's a lot of questions about. No, John Coombe 15:20 it's a lot different, way different. Wouter Klijn 15:24 Walk me through John Coombe 15:25 it. In fact, we're overweight equities on a global. That's our advice to clients today to be slightly overweight. the The big difference was Walter that there was no earnings. Wouter Klijn 15:39 Yeah, John Coombe 15:39 There are similarities, though, and I and I had this debate with at an IC that I sit on. The real issue, what back in the tech boom was, it was in the tech, it was in the telecom companies. So the telecom companies were basically spending capex like there was no tomorrow on rollouts of you know all of the fibre and and cable and you know mobile, and it had got to extremes, right? Like where you know they were poaching other clients, and and fund managers were actually looking at just how many clients were coming on board onto a to say Vodafone's platform, and they were pricing it off the number of new people coming onto your platform, and so there was this race to unprofitable clients happening right like people were putting on you know data deals for clients that economically made no sense right so they were in loss making they might have had revenues but they were loss making but then you had the other parts of the market they weren't even making a profit and we're coming on at massive prices today because they've been in private equity for so long. Some of these companies are profitable. They've got enormous cash flows, so it is different in that respect. Now SpaceX might be a bit different to that, but there are revenues within that company structure, but fundamentally, that is the biggest difference: is that there there's earnings in these companies. They've stayed private for longer and been able to get their business models, whereas back in the late '90s, people were just coming to market on a on a thesis without even a proper bit, you know, a business. So it was it was different. Wouter Klijn 17:54 Yeah, there is though the argument that there is some circular financing going on. John Coombe 18:01 Oh, we're shut over there. Wouter Klijn 18:04 Yeah, without doubt. So, are you concerned about that? Because that can make look, you know, revenues more solid than they really are. Because you know, they're funding their own sort of profits. John Coombe 18:16 Look, at the end of the day, my fundamental question with all of this is who's paying, who's going to pay, because at the end of the day, it's usually the consumer that pays or a business pays. So the real question is, how are they turning these dollars that they're investing into revenues either from business that are going to cover the costs and the interest costs, etc. of all these capital works that you're doing, and at the moment, in my mind, that is quite unclear. I know that I can pay, you know, a tiny bit of money if I want to use some of these AI tools, but most of us are getting it thrown in as part of our phone deal, or you know, Apple's got AI on it, or Gmail's got AI on it. Like, well, am I paying any more to to Google? This is the real. I don't know the answer yet, and I haven't read anything that really has sort of said to me, "Well, this is how, in the longer term, this get gets paid. And at a particular meeting, I was the one I was talking about. We actually looked at the airline industry as a as a anecdotal sort of look at thing. It's very interesting, you know. It's one of the worst markets that you could ever have invested in the airline industry. It still goes on today, but most of the major players in the U.S. have either. Disappeared or gone broke or into bankruptcy at least once. The consumer has never paid up for the privilege of flying, so business, you know, business flights pay a fair bit, but it's clearly a broken model because the consumer has been the beneficiary. We fly more. We've gone on hot, great holidays, etc. and we haven't been made to pay for it to keep the airlines profitable. This this could be the same with all of this: is that we get all of these beautiful tools and wonderful things that help our daily life. You know, oh, book me a trip to Spain, and the way the machine goes and searches for the cheapest deal and comes back and gives it to me, but I'm not paying for it. Who is? Yeah, and that's the question I keep coming back: is how are the revenues going to be generated in all of this, to pay for all of the data storage, all the technology, the chips, everything that's going into everything. Now, maybe you will pay for it with your phone because you'll pay an extra maybe 100 bucks for an AI chip or something like sitting in your phone, but besides, I just I'm I'm I'm perplexed. Businesses, like businesses, are paying some fees to use anthropic and other things and all that sort of stuff. Is it enough to pay for all of the R and D and everything like that. Wouter Klijn 21:42 It's it's a very interesting question because I was also reading recently about the idea that AI is is very hard to make exclusive. It's it's almost like a commodity because you get this race for developing better and better models, and once in a while, it's you know OpenAI, then it's Claude and Entropic, but there's also you know this whole market, and especially in China where they sort of take these models and they get close enough, maybe 80 per cent there, but then undercut the price significantly. So the amount of tokens that are being used for by users has risen dramatically in China, basically on the back of some of these really cheap AI models. John Coombe 22:31 They could do to AI what they've done to EVs, and to solar panels and to wind farms because they have the manufacturing grunt to produce stuff much much cheaper, so we might not have inflation. We might have deflation. It's possible. You know, they they exported deflation around the world for 10 years. You know, producing TVs cheaper, computers cheaper, cars cheaper. So it could be that we've we've misdiagnosed the whole thing, and that China starts exporting IT deflation because it's cheaper, does the same thing and uses less tokens. I mean, I mean, although having listened to a podcast yesterday about EV cars and how the government should be stopping the sale of Chinese or thinking about stopping the sale of Chinese cars because the Chinese government could could you know take the whole fleet of Australian cars over because the chips in them. I thought to myself, the conspiracy theorists will never let it happen. Wouter Klijn 23:55 Yeah, exactly. And at the same time, I mean, you know, we all use Google for free, at least the search engine, and and that's one of the biggest companies in the world at the moment. So maybe it's the the the usage that's not making the revenues, but there will be some side activities like advertising or marketing that that John Coombe 24:16 There was a really interesting quote in a article, and I can't remember who it was, but it was one of the emerging market managers that I read, and he was looking at AI and basically saying the Chinese are building AI to make manufacturing and other parts of their life better, whereas the Americans are making AI to do what? Wouter Klijn 24:45 It's a consumer tool. John Coombe 24:47 It's a consumer tool. John Coombe 24:50 So is a consumer tool more important than an industrial tool that's better? I don't know. My suspicion is the latter, but well, Wouter Klijn 25:04 It is interesting because you mentioned robotics earlier as well, and there does seem to be a clear overlap where the innovation in robotics has been accelerating because of AI and because of machine learning, because you can suddenly make them much more autonomous and safer as a mobile robot compared to you know just a factory tool, so I think to to a degree we might not know yet where it will lead to you know productivity increases and and advantages because the technology itself is certainly very yeah interesting. John Coombe 25:39 The thing I think is really interesting with ageing populations and a lack of workforce in healthcare and other areas. If you can create robotics that really assist in that area, that that's a big issue for China, right? And so, what's a big issue for China becomes something that we all benefit from because if if if they see it as an issue, they'll overbuild, they'll overcapitalize the whole area, and and we are the beneficiaries of that usually because it they make too many units, they have to sell them on the on the world market, they sell them at discounts, and and and we get them. And you know, with all of the talk about you know migration globally, you know, and and cutting down migration. I mean, the only answer is a robot if you haven't got any growth in your population, if you're in Japan and you've got negative population growth or zero population growth, and an ageing population, you've you've got an issue. Australia's got an issue, right? We we're going to have a million retirees or something. Yeah, absolutely. You know, in two years' time, I'm going to be one of them. Wouter Klijn 27:05 Yeah, fair enough. And it's a it's a complicated question because I was actually recently speaking with an Australian robotics company, and I asked them the question: "Is like, do you ever get accused of stealing people's jobs? And they say, "Well, not really, because, and and this might be particularly their robot, but they said it's not really scalable. Like we have a number of robots, but we make money of like renting them out and people using them. But we're not a mass producer of robots because you can't really do that. It's too complicated. So there might be some natural number… John Coombe 27:36 And they're making them for specific tasks. Wouter Klijn 27:38 Yes, it's John Coombe 27:39 almost like personalised robots. Wouter Klijn 27:41 Yeah, John Coombe 27:42 that sounds stupid, doesn't it? But it is. It's personal. It's it's sort of specific tasks. Wouter Klijn 27:49 It's single task robots. Yeah. Yeah. John Coombe 27:51 Or it could be multitask, but it's but it's programmable and repeatable, like cleaning a room in like one of the research firms up in Asia, when they go off on their trips into China, they take a whole lot of photos and they they put them up as part of their travel trips. And one of them was, you know, the robots in all of the different hotels cleaning the rooms, giving keys out, all that sort of stuff, repeatable things, but doable by a machine, not by a person. Wouter Klijn 28:26 Yeah, yeah. And this company that I spoke to, they're doing incredible things with the robots, but but essentially they said we only have two robots: one that drills holes and one that paints lines, and they use it for many many different applications. But that's essentially what it's doing. So that was very fascinating. So when you sort of look at AI from sort of a bit of a distance, are you in the camp that this is a new industrial revolution in the making, or do you think this is just incremental progress? John Coombe 28:57 Oh no, it could be fundamentally different because I don't know whether you've read this book, Walter. Wouter Klijn 29:03 Which one is it? John Coombe 29:04 If anyone builds it, everyone dies. Wouter Klijn 29:08 Okay. Yeah. John Coombe 29:09 The case against superintelligent AI. If you read this book, anything's possible. Yeah. Right. And I've read the book, so I'm in the camp of anything's possible. If if a computer can learn to teach itself and then get better and make things better, anything's possible, isn't it? Really? Wouter Klijn 29:35 Yeah, and and I think it's also the the wide range of applications because I've been talking to people that work in schools and how they deal with AI used by students, and I was sort of expecting the conversation to go in the direction of like they're cheating on their tasks and things like that, but it actually turns out that especially in sort of universities. People use these chatbots as basically a learning device, where some people might find it hard to read like 100-page report from beginning to end. They just upload it to the chatbot and then have a conversation with it and learn as they go along. Of course, you need to verify and things like that, make sure that the facts are correct, but you can have a much more conversational style of learning and ask questions. You don't have to worry that you ask too many questions or that other people listen to your questions. You can ask as many questions as you want, basically. And so, it seems that it promotes, you know, the accumulation of knowledge much quicker than maybe the traditional model, so that's a benefit that you probably don't see initially show up in the economy, but it's certainly helpful. John Coombe 30:51 Although I don't know whether you've read the Bailey Gifford article, but it's a fantastic article, and everyone should read it, particularly those who have young people who they're training at work. Wouter Klijn 31:04 What's the title? John Coombe 31:05 AI isn't coming for your job; it's coming for your mind. Wouter Klijn 31:09 Okay, it sounds slightly scary. John Coombe 31:12 There's a lot of medical science and testing that's been done on some of these things. It's a fascinating article in how we learn and how our our work practices change and how our brain changes to to adjust to those those environments. What was scary to me in the whole thing was that if you don't actually go in and do some research of yourself, and you just use AI. You have forgotten it within two or three days, Wouter Klijn 31:48 Right? John Coombe 31:49 So you haven't learnt. Wouter Klijn 31:51 Yeah, yeah, you don't retain it. John Coombe 31:52 You haven't learnt. You haven't retained anything. You you just used it as a tool. It did the task for you. You forgot everything about. You might have even checked that it was factual or whatever, but you didn't really research the topic itself to get a better understanding in your own mind, and so you forget. This is, to me, that's a real worry for the next generation because we've already seen what social media does to to people. This is another type of that here, but it's in the work environment as well. Wouter Klijn 32:31 Yeah, that's interesting because I think there was recently also an article that explored the idea that people coming out of universities now because they have used AI so much and haven't retained it, they they call that they basically come into the workforce illiterate because they haven't really acquired our skills. John Coombe 32:50 Yeah, and and for an employer, right, that that's problematic because so this person's got great AI skills. So what? Like I might get the machine just to you know intelligently learn it upon itself to do that without having to hire that person. So I do think. Look, it's we're in a brand new age of of us. learning how to use machines and and technology in computer programmes, we haven't. In my humble opinion, we haven't done a great job on social media, so let's hope we do better here. Wouter Klijn 33:37 Yeah, yeah. So does that change? You think the investment process, and especially sort of the way investors research and maybe put governance processes around their research as well, because I can already see people sort of using AI as almost like a data science team, and they develop their own programmes. That comes with a whole range of issue of you know, is the data that you use in a safe environment is it protected or has it a chance to escape? What are your assumptions? Are you actually checking your code yourself if you don't really understand how to code? Do you think it will change the investment process in that way? John Coombe 34:20 Well, I can tell you, it's changed ours. Wouter Klijn 34:24 Yeah. John Coombe 34:24 Um, in that it's super powerful when you've got a database going back 30 odd years of meeting notes and other things that you've collected off investment managers, and you've kept it stored in your own databases for years and years and years, and you know used to take us, you know, hours to go back and look through meeting notes, and now we can get Claude to do it in, you know, seconds. And even even doing our meeting notes, we can we we're getting you know using technology to get better meeting notes. It doesn't mean that our researchers aren't putting their own stamp on it, but it basically is doing the grump bit, and then it allows the researcher to check and and put their own view basically in on that. So it has its its good things, but you just got to be aware of you know. Don't become 100 per cent reliant on it. Would be my words of advice. It's like all technology. If you think it's the panacea for everything, then you're you're sadly mistaken because there's human emotion involved in investing. You know, there's there's the mum and dad investor that doesn't use AI when they go out and and hear a story from the cabby and go off and buy a gold stock or as we saw last year line up in front of the gold store in Martin Place because you know gold was on a run and everyone wanted a piece of gold and and I don't know whether the queues. I don't think they're still there. Wouter Klijn 36:24 No, no, they've gone. John Coombe 36:25 They've gone, but they they were there last year because I definitely went there and had a look just to see what it was all about. But so it'll be a a tool that people use to to try and get an edge on timeliness of on data and other things like that, whether you do really the other thing that I've sort of looked at the we've been doing a lot of work on the market structure and it does look like there's a lot more trading happening in the trading the volumes might not be massive, but there's a lot more shorter-term holding of positions rather than long-term, you know, investing as I I would call it. So, look, maybe you know if you've got patience as a long-term investor. it will pay off in spades in a world where you know everyone's trading too much and giving the brokers you know a fee for for very little insight. Wouter Klijn 37:41 Yeah, yeah, that's interesting. I had yesterday a conversation around there was a British fund manager that basically announced that they were going to change their investment style, and they were historically a quality focused manager, and they said we're going to add momentum to it because in the current market, it's almost impossible to ignore momentum. Which I sort of thought that opens up a whole kind of worms around style drift and you know your your portfolio construction process and how your blend manages. John Coombe 38:17 I'll be controversial. I'll be controversial here, Wouter. Wouter Klijn 38:21 Go for it. John Coombe 38:22 I've never seen the demise of active management like we've seen in the last five years. It's almost become a sideshow. Wouter Klijn 38:32 Right? John Coombe 38:33 Beta is everything. Alpha seems to be. I'll get it out of my unlisted market, and I'll just tolerate beta return out of equities. And and when you look at the results, you talked about quality as a factor. It has been dreadful. Wouter Klijn 38:55 Yeah. What do you what do you think is driving that? Because there's a couple of I think reasons why active management hasn't performed as well. I mean, there's of course the market concentration. I think the drive to passive is also in Australia at least partly regulatory driven. And then there's of course then the you know the huge amounts of data that is now available, which seems to make it harder to get an edge, or at least an information edge. So, what are you doing different than than the market or in the next? John Coombe 39:29 I think what it's done is it changed timeframes. Wouter Klijn 39:32 Okay, John Coombe 39:33 So historically, we would look at active managers that were rolling three year periods. I always used to say to my friends in the market, "If you show me a five-year number that's under the benchmark, I'm telling you, you're losing thumb, right? Whereas if we go into the unlisted space and we go into infrastructure and. And private equity, we've got 10 year, 12 year, infinite timeframes. If we own an airport that's generating a a cash return of 7 per cent per annum, right? Like, so to me, it comes down to what's my time frame and what's my tolerance for underperformance? And there is no doubt that because of the changing market structure and the increase in AI and technology and the boom in in that sector, we've basically seen the demise of both growth and value and quality managers, because whether they didn't pay enough attention to the index or whether their style forced them out of it, out of the stocks because they're too expensive or whatever, they've missed, and so investors who are measured against benchmarks have gone. Well, I just got to go shorter, and and the shortest you can go is go passive, because every day you're meant to line up to the index return, right? So, I I put it down to timeframes, and I think Investors' timeframes now, whether it's legislative as we have in this country, or it's just an intolerance for underperformance, we've seen timeframes collapse. I think we see that in the trading as well. All of the everything points to people's time frames have got shorter and shorter and shorter, and maybe it's because we're older, and as old people, we've got all the money, which my younger colleagues keep telling me, because we're closer to death, we want to you know our wealth to spiral, and so we want to steal off the next generation's returns by having excessive returns out of stock markets and and other markets. I mean, it's really fascinating when you look at some of the charts out of the U.S. Like the cash level in the U.S. is for retail investors is probably the lowest it's ever been. The gearing in the market is as high as it's ever been. Right, like we are all being really greedy, and our timeframes are short. And so, my my word of advice is like think about your time frame, and if you can lengthen it, because you'll miss all. You may have fun, you know, fear of missing out. But by God, you're going to sleep better at night, not trading around and getting on the next fad or the latest fad. Wouter Klijn 42:58 So, so what does that mean for the future of actors management then? Because I know you know China has always been firmly in the camp of active management, but it seems that you have some doubts about the sustainability going forward. John Coombe 43:10 No, no, no. I think active management is alive and well, but at a reduced level, and the clientele you're going to have is different. The days of being, you know, in the big supers is gone. The day of being in the mum and dad portfolio is here and alive. And as long as you know the mum and dad investor has a time frame that sort of is longer, the more active they'll have, the more they'll think about. Well, you know what? Small caps is where all of the, you know, you get the big return out of small caps and other things like that if the if the company's in the right area, etc. So, you know, they might go into small caps, mid caps. They, you know, under the new taxation laws, you know, they might want franking credits more. So they'll have an active manager who who wants deeds and franking and and things like that. So I just think the constituents are going to change, and it and it's logical because when you think about the large supers, if I'm a really big one and I want to have an active manager, I've got to put $10 billion with them, right? Like, and that makes it really, really hard for that manager to add value, and even if they do, I'm growing so quick that that $10 billion might start off as a 2 per cent weight in the overall fund, but when he gets the return in five years' time, he's only 1 per cent Wouter Klijn 44:59 Yeah, that's true. But it also seems that you know, in in good markets, it's it's hard for active managers to to outperform. But in in crises and in in down markets, they they tend to make more of a difference in not for much to protect a bit on the downside. John Coombe 45:17 So particularly if they're very disciplined in their process. The your story of a manager wanting to put momentum gives me the heedy duties because that's the last manager I go to because he's changing his process at a time of business hurt, yeah, right. He's not doing it because he believes in momentum, he's doing it because his business is going out the back door. Well, no, he's doing it because his business is going out the back door, and that is the wrong reason to change your investment approach. The best thing to do is to go around every one of your clients and explain why your approach in the longer term is going to deliver, and it's just a matter of timing. As I said, it's timeframes again. It's just every everyone has their day. I always say about value, guys. It's about once in five years, but you have your day, right? And as long as you stick to your processes, you basically get there. Wouter Klijn 46:28 Yeah. Although with value as well, there seems to be almost no deep value manager left anymore. So they're not always have their day. John Coombe 46:39 Yeah. Says something about the market, doesn't it? And the and the market dynamics that we all want instant gratification, and none of us are willing to sort of. A lot of us aren't willing to sit around for the long term returns. Wouter Klijn 46:56 Yeah, John Coombe 46:56 Except in our private assets, where we do sit around for a long time waiting for the return. Wouter Klijn 47:03 So, is is long term investing still possible in public markets then, or has that just gone? John Coombe 47:08 Oh, it is absolutely like my own self managed super is invested with managers who I think take a longer term view, and I'm happy to wear you know 234, years of underperformance. As long as they stick to, you know, the what what they've sold me is their approach to investing. So look, it comes down to individuals' timeframes and your and your willingness to accept 7 per cent returns instead of 10 per cent returns, but the 10 per cent might come in a volatility, high volatility range, whereas the seven might come nice and smooth. Wouter Klijn 47:55 Yeah, yeah, sure. I wanted to briefly touch as well on asset allocation. John Coombe 48:00 Yep, Wouter Klijn 48:01 I was looking back at the interview from 2019, and you sort of told this story around making big calls early on in in your career. One of them was where you basically went out of U.S. equities, and then Choice came. John Coombe 48:21 That was John Nolan. Wouter Klijn 48:25 That's that's true. But then Choice came along, and along with it, like all the different investment options, and it made it much harder to to make sort of these these type of calls. Now, that that situation is obviously still there, but at the same time, we've seen sort of the more funds doing more active stuff around dynamic asset allocation and trying to use that, yeah, and try to use that as an alpha driver. And as you said, that that then feeds into the whole total portfolio approach as well, which has been very popular these days, but within a super innovation context, it's much harder to do that in in a way that a sovereign wealth fund can do it. So it seems that there is some extra incentive as well to do sort of these calls at the total level. What's your sense of that? Is is you know these asset allocation, these big walls. Is it coming back, or is this just tinkering in the margin? John Coombe 49:25 Well, it's always going to be tinkering at the margin because once you put a product out in a product disclosure statement, you've got guidelines and ranges, etc. around that. So you you you in its purest sense of TPA, right? Which I would argue back in the early days of super, we were doing TPA because we didn't care whether we were in property or in equities or in infrastructure or wherever, as long. Who gave a better return than the other asset class? But they were single funds, single balance funds. Once you go into these ranges and you've promised things to people, and you've got ASIC looking over your shoulder, you are limited as to how far you can push that envelope. So yes, you can use derivatives and other things within your DAA processes. You can even do things within asset classes. You know, underweight U.S. equities and overweight the rest of the market if you want to do that as a TPA call, right? But equity bond risk will always happen in a sort of DAA adjusted process because of the ranges that you're in. The the other things will be tinkering within the asset classes to to say well you know five years ago we were looking at at putting in property debt instead of property equity because property debt was paying more than property equity and the downside was less. Right now you're reversing that because probably the opposite's true. You've got more upside on the on the property and you've got a flat yield on on property debt. Those sort of calls have always been in the DNA of the funds that that I've worked on. So I think it's it's it's TPA, but within the guidelines that you can operate under, and and everyone will do things to try and get that one basis point of that half a basis point extra, running our cash harder, running our derivatives book better. You know, all of that sort of stuff will get done. But while we've got choice, and you've got those hard guidelines, it's pretty hard to say that you're a full TPA approach, and I don't think like if you talk to Andrew Fisher and others around and Alison up at QIC State Investments and others, they talk about a form of TPA within the guidelines that they can operate, and we all know that, like, once you start having large allocations to unlisted assets, and they've got such long timeframes to say that you're doing TPA and changing your view on that, well, I think that's really heroic because the reality is the transaction costs are high to trade in those particular markets, and changing course takes years, not days. Wouter Klijn 52:52 I think one of the arguments to to adopt it as well is that there seems to be a little bit of a convergence of asset classes going on, where you know you take the example. I think this is best known example of data centres. It can show up in your infrastructure, can show up in your property, can even be in equity, can be on the debt side, and so the idea that you have to be at least aware of what's happening in asset classes outside of your own is driving part of this adoption of TPA. John Coombe 53:21 Look, I think resilience of your portfolio is super important. Knowing the risk that you're running is super important. I was talking to an equity manager the other day, and and they were talking about you know how that sort of lost their way, and one of the reasons was basically they lost their their view on the interconnectivity of different parts of the ecosystem, and so thinking that you had you know a data centre that wasn't linked to something else was crazy, right? Or thinking that you had a company that wasn't linked to oil prices over here, or something like that. Those linkages are super important to understand. You are going to take on risk. How much of it do you want? I've got China risk. How much do I really want? You know, I've got China risk in Australian equities. How much do I really want? You know, all of those sorts of questions we're much better at today than we were 10 years ago or 15 years ago, we we we had in our minds some linkages, but we didn't know. We couldn't mathematically give you an idea of what that was. Today, we can give trustees an idea of the. Linkages and the and the risks you're running at a much more granular level than we ever could before. I mean, the the last area is probably bonds, where you know those linkages we can sort of get it in the corporate area, but government bonds are you know still a like is Australia risky or not risky? Wouter Klijn 55:27 Depends on where you sit as well, I suppose well, I suppose. John Coombe 55:28 Yeah, and depends on your ESG view, right? So, those things we we do much better today, but you've got to understand the linkages. Wouter Klijn 55:40 Yeah, absolutely. So it's more a form of risk management. It's an John Coombe 55:44 absolute form of risk management. Wouter Klijn 55:46 Yeah, yeah. John Coombe 55:47 You can't have a resilient portfolio if you don't know the risks you're running. Wouter Klijn 55:52 Yeah, no, that's very true. That's very true. All right, John. I think we might leave it there because we could talk for hours. But thank you very much for your time. Much appreciated. John Coombe 56:03 It's always a joy. Thank you. __________ [i3] Insights is the official educational bulletin of the Investment Innovation Institute [i3]. It covers major trends and innovations in institutional investing, providing independent and thought-provoking content about pension funds, insurance companies and sovereign wealth funds across the globe. The [i3] podcast is available on iTunes, Google Podcast, Spotify, Amazon Music, Stitcher or your favourite podcast platform.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
