Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Community IT Innovators Nonprofit Technology Topics

Community IT Innovators Nonprofit Technology Topics artwork

AI for Nonprofits Now, with Brenda Foster

Nov 13, 202627 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Carolyn Woodard catches up with Brenda Foster, Senior Vice President and Chief of Innovation at Vanguard Communications, a year after Brenda shared her five-question framework for thinking through nonprofit AI adoption. Most nonprofit staff now use AI, but much of that use happens quietly, one person at a time, with no guardrails. Brenda explains why not having an AI policy is itself a policy, and why the policy Vanguard wrote at the end of 2024 already needed a rewrite. Her team started that rewrite by interviewing staff, without judgment, about how they use AI, what they want from it, and what worries them. Brenda and Carolyn also take on the concerns nonprofits raise most often: confidentiality and AI note-takers, fear of staff replacement, and the future of entry-level roles. Brenda makes the case that refusing to use AI does nothing to slow data center construction, and that nonprofits can bring their advocacy skills (and AI tools) to push for more responsible data center siting and design. She closes with practical advice for the year ahead, from workflow-based guardrails to 24/7 chatbots and multilingual support that expand what nonprofits can offer their communities. This episode covers: Why AI policies need a fresh look every six months, and why staff conversations are the place to start Moving from individual AI workarounds to shared team workflows with clear quality-control rules Using AI to add capacity rather than cut staff, and rethinking what entry-level jobs could be Environmental concerns about data centers, and where nonprofit advocacy can make a real difference Chatbots and translation tools that reach people after hours and across languages, with honest limits Resources Mentioned: Vanguard Communications Lost in Translation, Where AI Falls Short on Culture, Vanguard Communications How to Nonprofit AI with Brenda Foster webinar, Community IT AI How-To for Nonprofits with Brenda Foster podcast, Community IT Template, Acceptable Use of AI Tools in the Nonprofit Workplace, Community IT AI for Nonprofits Guide, Community IT _______________________________ Start a conversation :) Register to attend a webinar in real time, and find all past transcripts at https://communityit.com/webinars/ email Carolyn at cwoodard@communityit.com on LinkedIn on reddit/r/nonprofitITmanagement on the Community IT website Thanks for listening.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Carolyn WoodardWelcome everyone to the Community IT Innovators Technology Topics podcast. I'm Carolyn Woodard, your host, and today I am so happy to welcome back an old friend of the pod, Brenda Foster from Vanguard Communications. So, Brenda, would you like to introduce yourself?

Brenda FosterWell, I'm really glad that you're having me back. I love talking about this. It has become my passion over the past couple of years. Um, I'm Brenda Foster, and I'm the senior vice president and chief of innovation at Vanguard Communications. And we are a full-service PR firm that works on causes. And uh and AI has become one of our biggest causes, making sure that it's um adapted ethically and that the tools it can bring to nonprofits are, you know, are good for them and good for the world.

Carolyn WoodardSo, Brenda, we last talked about a year ago. You were on the podcast talking about a process that you were urging nonprofits to use to think about AI as they were uh implementing it. And so I wanted to revisit that. And I wanted to ask you, as an early adopter and that you use AI, I know a lot in your work. What are you using AI for now that you weren't a year ago when we last talked?

Brenda FosterIt's a really good question. And I think it's less about what I'm using and more about how I'm using it. Um, I think I've become, and and I've talked to so many people in our office and and others, uh clients who have become better at a workflow, right? So here's how I'm gonna use AI to kickstart my brainstorming, here's how I'm going to use it to maximize a product that I did in one way, and now I can give it to a nonprofit in two more ways, you know, in a way that I wasn't able to before.

Brenda FosterSo I think just really finding a real workflow has been great for us. But I will also say that in that time, you know, we wrote our AI policy uh in the at the end of 2024, and we revisited it a few months ago because we had some questions. You know, the tools are really advancing, and everybody's so excited to tell you, you know, you've been using this tool for years, and now we have an AI component, right? And and so suddenly we realized we were behind because something that was written at the end of 2024 has no bearing on what's happening right now at the end of 2026.

Brenda FosterSo we're in the middle of actually rewriting that policy. And the way that we're doing it really reflects what we're urging other organizations to do, which is to talk to your employees and really sit down and talk about how they've been using it on their own without judging how they've been using it, right? Um, how they want to use it, what they're worried about, what are their worries, right? What are they afraid AI is going to do or that, you know, we're gonna, they're gonna, are they worried about losing their jobs?

Brenda FosterAre they worried that we're having too big of an impact on the environment? And sort of find that out. So we're we just finished up those interviews this week, and now we're gonna go back and take a look at our policy and say, okay, we have employee input over here, we have Vanguard values in the middle, and then we have all of the new things that have come up. So, how do we make that go back to those five questions and make it more um more in line with where we are now? Um, and we also realize we have to look at it every six months.

Brenda FosterLike there's just no, there's no question, right? Because something new is gonna come up or some terrible thing's gonna happen, and suddenly you're like, oh, we shouldn't do that anymore.

Carolyn WoodardHow did I interested to hear you talk about that process because that is what we have also been urging our clients to do is have either have that as a big open conversation, a project that you're gonna write your policy or rewrite your policy, or even just institutionalize having open, transparent discussions kind of weekly or like mini discussions, because you'll just find that 20 different people at your organization are using AI in 20 different ways.

Carolyn WoodardAnd there's a lot of risk in that, and there's a lot of like missed opportunities that you're not, you know, kind of seeing what other people are using it for. But we're finding there's um considerable reluctance to do that because I think some people are worried about like opening up a can of worms. You know, there's one person on your staff who just doesn't want to use it at all, ever, for anything, and is adamantly against it. And if you start having these open conversations, then the people who love it are like, it's hard to, you know, like that's a work colleague and you have to get along with them.

Carolyn WoodardBut we've just still been urging people to have those conversations because you want it out rather than swept under and invisible.

Brenda FosterThat is absolutely I so I spoke at Netroots uh this summer, and that that was the overwhelming conversation I was having with people, right? Because look, still only about half of nonprofits have any kind of policy at all. Okay. However, um, what they don't realize is that not having a policy is in and of itself a policy. Yeah. But what you're allowing people to do is sort of do it on their own. So what they're finding is that 92% of people who are working in nonprofits right now, 90, 80, 90, you know, are using AI.

Brenda FosterBut 81% of that group, it's individual heroics, right? Meaning I figured out a way to do this faster. I'm not gonna say anything to anybody. I'm just gonna hand them the product and look at me, how great I am, right? But that doesn't really work for an organization if you have a set of values you want people to work by. And then on top of that, the data and privacy risk is enormous. Um, I mean, there have been a lot of situations where you've got people who have had, you know, you're putting information in, people don't necessarily know um what is private, what is confidential, what is a risk at uh copyright, right?

Brenda FosterLike putting something in that's copyrighted that needed to come back, right? Um, and so without those conversations, that fear that you're talking about, you're really just shoving all your problems. I mean, the can of worms is open. It's open, right? Uh when Chat GPT launched, that is that was literally when the can of worms opened. Um so I do think that, you know, what we're seeing, the biggest concerns we're seeing from nonprofits.

Brenda FosterNumber one, this is gonna be, I think this will be a funny one. Note-taking and meeting recordings. They do not want to use it for that. Um, they have they feel like they're having confidential conversations and that there is no place on earth that they trust enough to allow to do that. I find that important, an important conversation to have, right? Because how do you make sure that that, you know, there's a tool out there that you could actually use for that? Because what you're also doing is you're denying a level of employee any advancement because they're still hand-taking notes.

Brenda FosterAnd so you have to figure out so where are my ethics here, right? I want to make sure everything is confidential. I want to make sure that, you know, that nothing leaks out and that it's captured correctly. Um, but I also want to make sure I keep my employees happy, right? So that one's hard. Um the staff replacement issue is certainly one, right? Um, one of the things that are you um well, you know, I'm seeing a lot of concern about it. Yeah, right. A lot of concern, but I think I'm not seeing it in nonprofits because look, there's there's look corporations, they need to save money.

Brenda FosterAnd if they can find ways to save money, then they're going to do that. But they've always done that. AI is just another tool for them to do that. But in the nonprofit world, we've just never operated that way, right? So I think if we can look at it as a way to add capacity, meaning these are people you were whatever you're doing with it is was never going to be done by an employee. It's just now you can do it, right? It's some, you know, to make the work more satisfying for your employees, to add value to what you give to your audiences, to increase your reach and impact again in a way that you would never have done any other way.

Brenda FosterUm, and then finally, you know, I know nonprofits care about this. They're going to prioritize human talents. They just are. And so I think sometimes those fears of, you know, oh, I'm gonna be replaced, I think in this particular sector, I really don't think that's an issue. Yeah. You know, people are so cautious. And and it's good for them to be cautious for sure.

Carolyn WoodardI agree. I think I'm I do think that there may be something to the idea that the entry-level jobs are threatened by AI. And but for nonprofits, that's like, did you have the budget to hire a junior, you know, assistant? No. So, and were you gonna get that budget? No. So I think it'll be interesting to see long-term the pipeline and pathways into nonprofit work and philanthropy work, uh, if those, you know, kind of entry-level jobs are more difficult to come by.

Carolyn WoodardUm, but also I see the same thing. It's like you see the layoffs or by Microsoft just announced they are going to do these voluntary buyouts worldwide because they want, you know, to spend more money on AI and less money on salaries, and that just isn't that doesn't hold for nonprofits for sure.

Brenda FosterNo, it really doesn't. And I think, you know, one of the things about the entry level that we're I feel like I'm noticing is, you know, I'm of a certain age where everybody said to you, if you want to get your foot in the door, just be ready to pour coffee for people. Yeah. Let's be honest, pour coffee for men. But anyhow, I'm of that age. Um, but in the end, that was not a satisfying job. It was just a way to get your foot in the door to maybe eventually have a satisfying job.

Brenda FosterI think if we're finding that we don't have the space for an entry-level employee anymore, we were looking at their job wrong in the first place. Because why were they your main note taker? Why was that their whole job, right? Why was their whole job putting it together agendas? You know, no, because they when they get out of school, that's when they're most excited about the actual work that you're doing. So put them into situations where they can manage small projects, right? Where they can you can gather that enthusiasm because you don't want to beat that enthusiasm out of them for two or three years while they're doing the coffee pouring and the note taking and all of those other things.

Brenda FosterSo I actually see this as an opportunity to look at entry-level jobs very differently and maybe just stop calling it that. Yeah right. It is a job that does X and you are qualified because you just got four years of training, or in many cases, people are coming out with masters. That's you know, I'm seeing at American (University) people who are going right through to their Masters (degrees). Look, the stuff that they're doing is more sophisticated than a lot of people have access to at nonprofits.

Carolyn WoodardYeah, and send them out in the field. Like that's something that AI can't possibly do, and you get so much experience interacting with people.

Brenda FosterThat's right. That's right. That's exactly right.

Carolyn WoodardYeah. So I think I okay, you're you're you're changing my take on that.

Brenda FosterWell, and I also think if we're worried about it, like as leaders of these organizations, then we're probably not gonna do it. Yeah. Right? Again, this can't be, this is not a way to save money. This is a way to meet all of our goals. And if we can look at it that way, I think it's gonna it it's gonna do what we want it to do. I also go ahead. I I think one thing that I really really want to talk about though is the environment piece. Okay, because what I'm seeing um is just abject fear, right?

Brenda FosterAnd just so people are very concerned, and they should be. So I live near Loudoun County, you know, the data center capital of the world, out the county next to me has built so many and they build them so fast, right? These data centers. And so people are very, very concerned. But what's so interesting about that is that not using AI isn't gonna make any difference at all. And so now I keep saying to people, you have a couple of options here, right?

Brenda FosterOne is you're a nonprofit, you know how to fight. So make data centers your issue, right? Make sure that the people that you're trying to help are not further impacted by data centers. But stopping using AI isn't going to help that. In fact, you'd be better off stop using Netflix, right? Like, you know, I mean, there's certain things, of course, right? If you're gonna look at like the levels of things, using it for videos, that's a pretty big impact, right?

Brenda FosterSo don't do that. That's fine because that's human creativity. Let's let the humans continue to be in videos and make the videos. But but I think also use AI to help you fight the data centers because why not? And you know, think about how you can get messages out in a way that you didn't have the opportunity to do that before. Um, how can you empower people at the grassroots because they're ready. I've seen a couple of studies that show that people are more against this than they were about nuclear power plants coming in, yeah, which is huge.

Brenda FosterSo I do think nonprofits, and that's probably the number one thing that I see. Um the uh progressive communicators of DC listserv. I'm uh uh co-founder of that, right? And so I see we we will have an eruption, I don't know, once a week, once every couple of weeks, where somebody says, Have you thought about this AI tool? And then we have a long conversation about how terrible somebody is for using the AI tool, right? Totally reasonable. That's what everybody's concerned about, and they should be.

Brenda FosterI'm totally concerned about it. I'm really excited I happen to live in a small community where we couldn't fit a data center if we tried, you know. Um, but I have a cousin who lives out in um near Galax and Hillsville, Virginia, and there's a lot of land there and it's gorgeous. And right now that's where the data centers want to come. And so I'm helping her with the tools and the conversations and that kind of thing. Um, but but you know, that that to me is how we have to use our power now.

Brenda FosterAnd stop not using Chat GPT may feel like a protest, but it's actually not, it's not really helping at all.

Carolyn WoodardYeah. No, I I mean, what is the nonprofit sector is less than 10% of the GDP in the United States. So that build out of those data centers for AI is all corporate. Like the entire nonprofit community could stop using AI tomorrow and it would not change at all the amount of build-out that they are planning. And you're right, like the fancy lobbyists that they have going into these little town meetings and talking to the planners are using AI for their talking points, you know, so you're cutting yourself off from one of the tools that could counter those movements.

Brenda FosterYeah, yeah. It's it's um it's very difficult to get to to wrap your mind around that. And it took me a while as well because the guilt was just so heavy. I spent my whole life working on environmental issues and, you know, protecting public lands and all of these other things. And finally, I was able to figure out for myself that this is it, it's not even an equal conversation, right? It's it's not a trade-off. It has, it has, it's not even related.

Carolyn WoodardYeah, yeah. No, I I agree. Thank you for saying that because it is, I mean, it's hard because, like you said, it's valid to want to live your values and to not participate in a system that is so power-heavy, that is so environmentally unfriendly. Um, but yes, it it's those tools, there's such an opportunity there too.

Brenda FosterYeah, yeah. And I mean, I'm not telling anybody that they have to use AI, but I think what's happening is that nonprofits are avoiding having the conversation about the policy because they don't want anybody to use AI. And actually, they're making it worse because they put no guardrails down on how much AI is used, what it's used for. You know, maybe you've got a budding movie producer in the back of your office who's, you know, producing commercials every day with AI and you have no idea. So, you know, just putting we cannot put our heads in the sand.

Brenda FosterWe really have to look at this and say, it is here. I don't like it, but I I have to face it now. And I am seeing more and more people. Like I said, when I did the Netroots thing in June, that was more of the conversation. That was, you know, it was a lot more than it was before where people were like, yeah, we're just not going to use it.

Carolyn WoodardAnd I think in that case, particularly with the environmental concerns, looking to what environmental nonprofits are doing and thinking and putting out their thought leadership on how to use it, how to advocate for where the data centers are sited. Um, you know, like it makes a difference. I mean, yeah, Loudoun County has so many of them, but it's very different uh in places like Loudoun County where there is water versus you know, citing a data center in Arizona somewhere where they've had a severe drought.

Carolyn WoodardSo choosing your battles, figuring out where you have um that agency. And I mean, all of the citizen upright uprising around the data center issue. It's exciting. It's the we have an agency, right? That's exciting. Organize people, yeah.

Brenda FosterThat's right. Well, and the other thing that I think hasn't been part of the conversation, and I did a a lot of research on this, is you know, that the way that they're being built, it's being done that way because again, they did it silently for a decade before we noticed, right? I remember 10 years ago, the Loudoun County people saying no data centers. And I was like, what are they talking about? What are they talking about? I know now. Um, but part of the problem is that you know, the faster you can come in and build these and say nothing to anybody, the more you can do it efficiently for yourself, for money, right?

Brenda FosterSo there was no incentive for the past decade to do anything creative, to do anything better for the environment, to do anything because nobody was paying attention. So now let's do it as cheaply as possible, right? But now people are paying attention. They are communicating effectively. So now we know that there are ways to do this. You can do it underground. You can do it where you're recycling the, you know, the amount of water that you use for cooling. There's so many different ways to do it, but we never, we never looked at that.

Brenda FosterWe were never forced them to look at that, right? We never, for years, clearly, we haven't even forced them to pay their own electric bills. Right. So now we can. I mean, that is really part of advocacy and this agency that we have. And we cannot back down from that agency. And I think, like I said, every nonprofit, I think there's a role for every nonprofit to play, to, you know, to make sure that how we go forward with this technology is as responsible as possible. And I think we're the only ones to do it.

Carolyn WoodardYeah, no, you gotta rely on the it's especially those environmental nonprofits that are really heavily involved in it. Um, do you have advice for nonprofits um going forward? Like I feel like in the past year or so, maybe a year or two ago, there were lots of nonprofits that knew what AI was, but weren't using it. And as you said, now it's like 89, 92% of nonprofits are using it, usually in this very ad hoc way. We're not seeing a lot of our clients that are being really intentional about it.

Carolyn WoodardSo they're just kind of adopting it uh often without policies, often, you know, different staff are using it in different ways. So for those nonprofits that are now getting their feet wet with these AI tools or thinking about policy or kind of really realizing what a tool it is, do you have advice for them for, I don't know, the next year or so? What should they be doing and thinking about?

Brenda FosterYeah, I mean, I think the first thing is if you don't have a policy, it's time to take a look at that. And um, and it doesn't have to be complicated, but at least needs to help come up with some guardrails. And the way you need to look at, I think the most successful way for nonprofits to look at AI going forward is workflow, right? What is the team workflow? How does this flow into anything else? So for example, you know, nothing goes out of our office without it being QC'd, right?

Brenda FosterAnd that is for grammar, that is for the style of the client, that is for whatever. That is part of our workflow. And so if we allow, say, AI for brainstorming, we allow it for, you know, for um uh regenerating something into another format, for example, what are the rules behind doing that? What's that workflow look like? Yes, you can brainstorm. No, you cannot cut and paste an entire op-ed that AI wrote into this and make an op-ed for a client.

Brenda FosterLike, first of all, it's not going to be good, it will not be good. The New York Times says they can tell a mile away how many, you know. And so, but what can you do and how should you be doing it? That workflow piece is really important. I think governance needs to become the standard, just like anything else. If you don't have an AI policy, then you're basically saying you don't care about any of the issues you actually care about that have that you've avoided for all this time. I do think taking a look at how it can expand your impact for your current people, for your current audiences, right?

Brenda FosterAre there one of the things that I have found so exciting is these chat bots that can give people 24-7 help in a sector where that doesn't exist. I spoke to a bunch of uh public housing directors earlier this year, and we talked about this very thing. You know, we do not have the money for calls to be answered on basic things. And so I want to know something about my bill, but guess what? I work the day shift, and that's only when that's the only time you're open.

Brenda FosterImagine being able to get that caught that answered in those 24 hours. Imagine something that is triaging. Oh, my toilet doesn't work, right? Something that's triaging it that does not, you don't have a person there anyhow. So here's a chat button. Something that can help, I have to fill out a form for Medicaid. And I want somebody to help me through that. So those are the kinds of things that I think expand your capacity to help your audiences in ways that maybe you hadn't thought of before.

Brenda FosterAnd I think that will make you feel better about it, right? Because, oh my gosh, I can I can do this, I can do that, I can add value. And so to me, those that's really the direction I think that, you know, when we're looking at this this next year, how can we use this to expand what we're able to do for our communities? It's the most important thing.

Carolyn WoodardYeah, I heard someone talking about the languages issue and how you know that you have people, if English isn't their first language, they're taking your FAQ from your website, if they can find your website on their phone, and they're putting it through a translator so that they can understand it. And what if you move that into the tool itself? So they're asking the question in their language and getting the answer that's vetted by you, your FAQ, back to them in language that you know is a correct translation.

Brenda FosterYeah, I mean, that possibility is incredible, right? Um, if you're serving 11 different languages, but you only have capacity to really give bilingual materials in two, yeah, right. Now, I will tell you, um, we've actually done a couple of uh blogs and things on this. It's not great at translation. That should not be your be-all and end all, right? But if you had nothing before and you now have something that you can offer people that shows honestly that you that you know they're there, you know something about them, and that you are trying, it is it's a way forward for us to take a look at how do we improve these tools so that they become better at languages that clearly are very good at English.

Brenda FosterThey're very good at English. So, how do we make sure it can't be that hard? That to me is an investment that needs to be made. How do we do this in all sorts of languages and make sure that you know we can provide that kind of help in every language possible?

Carolyn WoodardYep. Well, Brenda, I want to thank you so much for your time today. I always learn something when I talk with you, not just about AI, but you have just been using AI for for so long and you have so much experience with it and expertise with nonprofits using AI. So thank you again for coming on the podcast today.

Brenda FosterI love it. I'm so excited, and uh and I'm really glad to have caught up with you. Thank you, Carolyn.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Should Your Nonprofit Use AI? pt 1

    Nov 20, 202633 minAudio

    In the first part of this two-part conversation, Carolyn Woodard is joined by Steve Longenecker, Director of IT Consulting, and Nuradeen Aboki, Senior Consultant, both of Community IT, to take on the hardest AI question...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Nonprofit AI: Policy Meets Culture

    Nov 17, 202633 minAudio

    Carolyn Woodard spent three days at #TAG2026, the Technology Association of Grantmakers conference. A few years ago AI was a handful of sessions there; this year almost every session was about AI. In this episode she...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Nonprofit AI: Midterms and Data Centers

    Nov 10, 202618 minAudio

    AI can feel like a tidal wave washing over all of us, impossible to resist and hard to opt out of. But last week’s U.S. midterm elections told a different story about citizen power and data center regulations, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 10 Cybersecurity Essentials for Nonprofits with Johan Hammerstrom

    Nov 6, 202632 minAudio

    Carolyn Woodard explores the cybersecurity essentials every nonprofit needs with Johan Hammerstrom, CEO of Community IT. Cybersecurity can feel technical and intimidating, especially for operations staff without an IT...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Nonprofit AI: Women in AI, AI Authority Bias

    Nov 2, 202621 minAudio

    Even with a human at the helm, how much are you, as the human, actually deciding? Carolyn Woodard looks at new research on how easily experts defer to AI, why polished answers are so easy to trust, and practical ways to...

    Credit the people on this episode