In the episode of Comms Leaders, Greg is joined by Andy Wilson (CityFibre) and Mike Korkidakis (Planet Technology) to discuss two big channel themes - changing conversations in the connectivity market, and the need for joined up industry thinking around sustainability.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome to this, the latest episode of Comms Dealers, Comms Leaders, a platform that lets us sit down with those in the channel to discuss some of the industry's burning topics. Once again, two fantastic guests. It's my honour to welcome to the pod Andy Wilson from C Fiber. Hi Andy. Hello, how are you doing? Good, thank you. How are you? Yeah, very well, thanks. And Mike Kokidakis from Planet Technology. Hi Mike. Hi guys, you're right. Hi Mike, you're right. Yeah. Good to see you. Thanks for having us. No, great to have you both on. Um Mike, this is our first time actually meeting in person. It is. A nice, informal, natural way to do it.
SPEAKER_01Um how are things with you? What's new and interesting with yourself and planet technology?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, oh yeah. A lot lot's happening, I think. So I mean Planet as an organization is is still quite young. So we just hit sort of year three of trading. So a lot of exciting things happening, a lot of growth, both internally and with customers. So quite an exciting time for us at the minute.
SPEAKER_01Fantastic and Andy. Uh obviously met a few times, but it's been a little while.
SPEAKER_00So it's probably um Challenge Champions, last time I saw you. It could well be.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it could well be.
SPEAKER_00Um City Fiber, um, I think headlines, um, everything's going really well. Um, we've hit our millionth customer on the platform, um, which is a serious milestone. We're all we're all really proud of, and we celebrated it recently. Um, and cons uh sort of consolidation MAs are our sort of target outcomes now. So yeah, it's good.
SPEAKER_01Congratulations, both of you. Yeah, to have someone else who's come sat down and gone things are terrible, really needed this. It doesn't go that way, does it? Yeah, um with the formalities out of the way, not to sound too much like an American torture host, I've asked you both to bring a burning topic to something wrapping around in your brain, uh, something you want to dissect in company and and and give some air to. Um, Andy, can we come to you for your burning topic first, please?
SPEAKER_00Yep, sure. So um, yeah, I I went up, I was on holiday when well when you sent the note in, and I was like scratching my head as to sort of think what sort of things do I want to discuss about, whether it's sort of generic to the channel or it's sort of more specific to city fibre, and I've defaulted as you'd be shocking to you to defaulted to a city fibre answer. Um, but I think I've been reflecting. If if I'd sat here sort of 10 years ago, then um my burning topic would all be around fibre build. We've got no fibre in the UK, the the UK's drastically behind on a on a European and global scale in terms of its infrastructure, we've got a serious problem, two incumbents are happy sat on legacy uh networks and and what we're gonna do about it.
SPEAKER_00Um and that's what we did in terms of city fibre. If I roll forward now to today and I look at what is my burning topic, we've pretty much completed the fibre build rollout, is pretty pretty much there. Um, you know, in terms of where the UK sits now, we're we're actually in a really good spot from fibre availability. But what's burning me now is it's gone from a an availability or a build thing to a um uh um an uh adoption. How are we adopting full fibre?
SPEAKER_00How are we using full fibre? And how is the channel, both from a sort of environmental and and an economic basis, taking advantage of what is a£40 billion investment, 35 billion from private equity,£5 billion from the UK government. But what what are we doing with it in the B2B channel and how are we going to leverage it? And what are the opportunities to leverage on that? That's my burning subject today.
SPEAKER_01Fantastic. Our first question, I guess, would be uh if you look at that shift from homes past to homes connected. Yeah. Um I think it was the UK Fibre Summit about a year ago we started talking about that shift. Um in terms of how quickly we had to get from, as you said, to incumbents to where we are now with a load of challenges. How do you think that was dealt with in terms of process for thinking of that next phase? Is there were there any mistakes made? Do you think are we in a good place when it comes to starting to rapidly up adoption?
SPEAKER_00Um I I think that the there was the natural assumption that that adoption would happen at a rapid pace, given the fact there was so much noise coming from the markets about we've got rivers connectivity and sort of and no doubt from your perspective where you're selling applications and services on top of connectivity, it wasn't fit for purpose historically. So the the assumption was is that because you now got this amazing infrastructure and everything will work on top of it, it would just it would just take off. And don't get me wrong, as I said, we've hit our millionth customer, we're doing really well, but it it's still lagging behind uh in terms of adoption.
SPEAKER_00Um, and I think some of that's more around sort of education and use cases. We've got to come off the the the thought process of uh is it available, how much does it cost, and what speed can I get to to more of a sort of subject around uh you how how how do I use it? Yeah, what's it what's its user um you know, what's its capability, what's it can be used for? It's more outcome-based, is where we should be looking at. So I think that we've there's a there's more of a role that we've all got to play in the channel about educating the ultimate end user on what this technology can do for them now and in the future, and what is their sort of um digital roadmap in terms of what type of organisation do they want to be in 10 years?
SPEAKER_00And we talk a lot about AI, but AI workloads take a help a lot of bandwidth. Yeah, so are we are we selling on that on that future of if you've got an AI strategy, Mr. Customer, you're gonna need really good up and downstream connectivity, low latency, zero packet loss for this to really work for your organization.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. Mike, in in terms of the planet perspective, how do you see fibre as an opportunity for your business?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well I suppose I guess leading on from what you said, I think it's kind of like the transition from the traditional, you know, X amount X amount of gigabytes, megabytes, whatever for X amount of cost, right? It's about I guess taking to your customers like a smarter connectivity approach, essentially. Right? Like the connectivity, you should be approaching them with probably like the connectivity architecture is about you know keeping you secure, keeping you resilient, keeping you, you know, I mean, like, you know, active and and in and keeping the business operational.
SPEAKER_02Um, it's probably moving away from that sort of traditional mindset of how we've approached selling fibre products or you know, connectivity products in the past, I think.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I tot totally agree. I think that the the successful channel partners in uh you know uh moving forward now using this technology, but we're the ones that are looking at outcome-based conversations with their customers, as opposed to, as I said, sort of availability check speed cost. Yeah. Because everybody's got access to good pricing, yeah, good availability, good bandwidth, but what's the differentiator? What is the real reason for the what is the use case for that connectivity? And you know, dare I say it, not all fibres equal.
SPEAKER_00So even though we can assume everyone's gone out and roll full fibre footprints, you start getting into technology types of you know, XGS POM versus PON. Yeah. And then what does that mean in terms of future proofing architecture? What does that mean to the customer? So from that, so yeah.
SPEAKER_01And Mike, in terms of looking at the range of providers, uh somewhere in the channel, as you said, what what we're talking about now, maybe a hundred altnet still, maybe eighty to a hundred if you start to take that sort of long tail and sharpen it a little bit. But do you generally have a sort of I don't want to call it a trust issue, but you look at that range of providers and do you think a lot of these are new guys, might not exist for a long time? Who are you choosing or thinking about choosing when it comes to connectivity?
SPEAKER_02That's a good question. And I'll be honest, it it is hard because as a starting point, I think being an MSP and being a provider, firstly, they're all banging down your door, right? You know, the the the channel's always been probably the most successful route to market for connectivity providers. So it is really, really tough. I mean, we always do try to look, you know, we do have a I guess a relatively vigorous vetting program. Um, and part of that does look in, you know, we do try to look at the bigger picture as much as possible, right? You know, the breadth of the network.
SPEAKER_02But as importantly, I think for us it's a lot of the sort of the aftercare stuff as well. Like understanding the organizational dynamic, understanding what support they can give us, you know, when we're delivering this to the end customer, right? Because ultimately, you know, our our biggest, I guess, criteria is a partnership that takes responsibility, and that's what we want when we're delivering something to our end customers, right? If something goes wrong, who's gonna take ownership of that? Who's gonna make sure that gets followed through? And that's a really tough thing looking at all the various different providers. So sometimes, you know, the scale of the provider comes into effect, or you know, what the future plans are, what that resource looks like.
SPEAKER_02There's a lot to it, to be fair.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, picking up on a couple of points there, um, we're a whole we're a whole City Five has started its journey and will continue its journey as a wholesale operator. Yeah. Um, and and the reason is because we absolutely do recognise that the power of the channel and how you know what what market share the channel represents in both from an Ethernet and a sort of broadband perspective. But but I think what you've got to look at there is how does this market consolidate? Because it there's there's no way that it it makes um sort of economic or even logistical sense for planets to onboard the hundred or so alternates that exist in the UK.
SPEAKER_00I mean that's a that's a it's a big job in itself. So what we recognise as City Fibre is the opportunity now for us, as and I touched it at the beginning, is all around MA. How do we take our platform and then start to um ingest more availability into what's already been built out in the market, and that that is one core component of our strategy, and then that makes it easier for our suppliers, uh our customers rather, which could also be a supplier to you, yeah, because it's a multi-tiered channel ecosystem who have access to City Fibre and much wider alternate footprint.
SPEAKER_00So we're we're sort of consolidating the market, I suppose, is the point to make.
SPEAKER_01Well, if I could ask that sort of crystal ball question when it comes to the connectivity market, I think a lot of people are surprised that that market hasn't consolidated quicker. We've been talking about waiting for the starting gun to fire for a very long time. As I said, we're still talking about maybe a hundred hundred providers there. Yeah, a couple of big deals, some going through CMA at the moment. Um why has that gun taken so long to fire? And who's been pausing on the trigger?
SPEAKER_00I think um it's a it's a it's a complicated question with a more fusset answer. I think you've you've got uh a few dimensions here. You've got the economy itself, the cost of money, the cost of debt, it's expensive. If you've borrowed a lot of money to build something, it's gonna cost a lot of money. So I think that that's put a lot more pressure more recently on a lot of the uh you know, as I said before, it's 35 billion pounds of inward PE investment that's come into the UK to build full fibre, and that's representing itself as debt and shareholder value.
SPEAKER_00So shall that you know that's gonna create pressure on on the adoption rates of those networks. Where those are Altnets have not been successful at that adoption rate, that's gonna put pressure on the market uh for people's need to sell. There's been a few transactions recently have started to throw a few like question marks over what is the value of my business. So if you were if you were selling an AltNet today, you you're not just gonna go out and sell to the highest bidder, or the first bidder rather, you're gonna look at who are the bidders, what does the ecosystem look like?
SPEAKER_00So I think that's put so thrown some questions and delay into the market. Um, because sadly, it's not just City Viber out there looking to consolidate the market, there is a few of the players looking to do that. So it so it is a competitive landscape. It ultimately will happen, I think, quite quickly once all those stocks start to fall in place, but but it's created a little bit of uh of delay in in the short term, I'd say.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Thank you. And to pick up on something you said earlier, Mike, you were talking about partnerships, how you choose partners, and you said responsibility was a big part of it. And I'm gonna sort of loosely use that as a segue into your burning topic, which has a little link, I think.
SPEAKER_02Okay, yeah, I mean, I guess if we if we're gonna route to my burning topic, you know, my burning topic, I think, is I mean, it's quite topical in our industry, and that's around sustainability. Um, but I think for me it's about looking at the collective responsibility. So where I see there being, I guess you could call it like a slight gap, is you look at our industry and we have everything from you know manufacturers to carriers, vendors, MSPs, and end customers. And sustainability whilst being heidi topical, it's not really measured in any form of way, right?
SPEAKER_02There's not like a collective measurement or governance sort of criteria for our industry. You have everybody, you know, all you know, MSPs or customers or any of those carriers, we're all doing our what we think is our bit, right? We're all writing our sustainability reports, we're all, you know, you know, promoting that, you know, we're we're looking at that, and it's important to all of us. But I think the the kind of the burning issue is that, as I said, there's no collective way to measure that. So, you know, you have everybody doing that as individuals, and I think the risk to that is that a customer ultimately doesn't really know what good looks like because everybody's using different criteria to measure that, and that makes it really difficult.
SPEAKER_02You know, what I think we kind of need essentially is almost like a way to govern that, where there's a a collective measurement, and that, you know, transitions across the entirety of the industry. And I think the bigger picture to that is I guess what we do with that. You know, as we already said, the channel represents quite significant buying power, realistically, to carriers and vendors. Um, but you know, if we are actually going to measure that, you know, who's then gonna be held to account, right? Are we gonna actually hold vendors and carriers to account?
SPEAKER_02Are we gonna start procuring, I guess, you know, I want to say, I don't want to say ignoring margins, because that's certainly not what not what I'm saying. But are we gonna start procuring based on responsibility and not just margins? Um and then, you know, exactly that, you know, if if we do have a measured form of how we monitor that, you know, what are we gonna do with that information if people aren't you know adhering to it, I guess essentially? That that would be my burning topic at the minute.
SPEAKER_01No, I think I think it's a great topic, and yeah, that joined up thinking, joint accountability, both of those pieces are critical. I I wrote a report recently um just talking to some MSPs on the individual things they are doing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um I I think I called it to B Corp or not to be corp, something really that's sort of the closest I could find in collective efforts. Yes. Uh you've got a Red Squid, IT naturally, a couple of others will have sort of thinking sessions together where they come together and talk tendering and uh and where where they are with efforts. But as you said, it's once you get past the scope one, scope two conversation, when it comes to scope three and supply chain and holding others accountable, that is where the problem is. Um yeah, Andy, what what are your thoughts on on this as a concept?
SPEAKER_00So well, I mean it's it's extremely important, right? Um I think from a city fiber perspective, we we have a plan. Um we have a you know a net zero target by 2030. So we're on with that, you know, and and we are we are very much heavily looking into supply chain in terms of uh you know, look at all of our vehicles who are electric now as just an example. Um but we're quite proud of the fact that what we've actually done in terms of from a full fiber perspective actually um indirectly or directly links completely to the agenda because it uh full fibre is 95% more carbon efficient than than traditional copper services.
SPEAKER_0095% more efficient. Now the the challenge we have, and it does links back to my point earlier, which is that the the both the sort of environmental and economic benefit of of full fire uh of uh uh doesn't lay in the cable itself, it lays in the actual use and adoption of the cable.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00And then when you start to roll that forward and say, well, what do we mean by that? We mean by well, you know, full fiber enables true hybrid working. So by by enabling true hybrid working, you're naturally knocking on the effect of trap trap, you know, travel for no reason, etc. etc. So it it has its use case from its own power consumption um opportunity, but it but by using it to its maximum effect as a technology means that we become more environmentally um impactful uh as a as a society, as a better UK benefit than just being the cable itself.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And and Mike, in terms of collective accountability uh and pitching this across the channel, do you think the appetite's there in in terms of MSPs? Do you do you think that other than uh you know the I hate to use the term greenwashing, but in terms of those actions taken, do you think there's enough companies out there who actually have that up their priority list high enough?
SPEAKER_02I think I think they do. I think, you know, overall, I think the channel does have, you know, they they do have quite they do pin a lot of importance on it, but I think it's just more about how we measure it. But I would say ultimately, I think anybody would be silly not to, and the reason I say that is, you know, you're seeing that more and more that it's moving away from end customers, right? Previously, if you're responding to things let's say like an RFI or an RFQ, that that seemed previously to be kind of like a tick-box exercise for them, but now it's becoming more vitally important.
SPEAKER_02They're actually doing a lot more governance and a lot more due diligence surrounding what you're actually doing as a business. They're looking for certain, you know, B Corp's a classic example of that. They're looking for certain accreditations, they're looking for certain things that they want to see. So to be honest, I think if it's not up your priority list, you might be in a bit of trouble moving forward.
SPEAKER_00That that extends to private equity as well and investment. The criteria from private equity firms, it one of the main criteria is that sustainability um position as well. So ESG is right up there in terms of who they choose to invest in, and then I think so. I think that is flowing through into the market in that way as well.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, I think it it it has to, though, doesn't it? And I think for me it's just about taking a step back to understand, I guess, collectively how we do measure it, how we take that you know collective responsibility and turn that into sort of collective action, I suppose, and collective influence. So it's just for me, I just think that the industry probably needs a way to govern and measure it in like one collective fashion that transitions from your you know, your manufacturer, your vendor, your carrier, your MSP um all the way through to end customers.
SPEAKER_02It's a universal standard. Exactly that, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Like an MPS score.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, or you know, anything like Ofcom, you know, I almost think it needs, you know, if I'm being honest, I think it needs, you know, maybe like a you know a an impartial governing body of sorts. And I think that's where the big challenge comes in, though. It's you know, and I'm not saying that if vendors and carriers didn't adhere to that, that you know, we'd all sort of walk away from them. But I think it just goes back to my point of understanding are we willing to procure from a responsible point of view and not not just purely a margin point of view, right? Like any carrier or vendor you're working with, I think right now these things might be high on your agenda, and you know, maybe you're mentioning it in a review, maybe you put a little pressure on them to do better, but you know, ultimately, if that's not being measured in some factor, you know, how do you know they are?
SPEAKER_02And you know, what actions are you going to take if they're not? And I think that's the point we really need to get to. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and there's a lot of talk about uh shrinking vendor basis for MSPs, trying to have less vendors. I guess having uh a metric to measure by if you're uh a more climate conscious MSP is a big differentiator when a lot of the times the product can be quite samey at that level. So it's I guess yeah, really, really important. But uh I mean we know what collective effort in this industry can do. We've got 101 initiatives that have made serious positive change. But yeah. Uh the the last thing I'd like to get off you guys. Um I just based on either your experiences or today's conversation, one last topic you'd like people to to have rattling around their head after they're finished listening to the podcast, an action, um something to consider in their their everyday business life.
SPEAKER_01And who do you who should who should I pick on first? Um Mike, I I think you actually responded in your email with a nugget of of information.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, I think my I think mine just goes back to exactly what I was saying, and and I think that's we just can't undervalue, you know, the collective influence that we can have, right? Those small changes that we can make, you know, it it's really easy to sort of sit back as one organization and say, yeah, we're gonna try and do this, we're gonna try and do this. But if we all take that collective initiative together, as you already said, there's been so many initiatives that have influenced some serious positive change. And if we can do that collectively, it's exactly that, right?
SPEAKER_02That that influence that we all have as a group is quite substantial, and I think we can influence some serious change there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. And Andy. Um I come I'll come back to my really super simple point, which is I think the channel has a fantastic opportunity. As I said, huge amounts of investment in full fiber, it's what we all ask for, it's what we have. Um, it's now we've got to take a step back and stop selling from a availability speed and price, and actually start to look more about adoption, education, and outcomes. And I think that that for me would be the the call out. That's what that's what I think we need to do. But we have a role to play in that.
SPEAKER_00We need to support on, especially on the education point, is to where full fibre fits. Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Lovely. Well, I really appreciate you both taking the time out today to to sit and chat. I mean, yeah, some critical things about stopping and thinking before we just press on the accelerator. I mean, I I can't believe neither none of us have really said it other than a little bit at the beginning on AI, you know, in terms of the impact that's gonna have on sustainability and the need for faster bandwidth. Um whereas everyone's slamming on the the gas, it might be time to just stop and think how will this affect us sustainability-wise, uh, and how do we uh change that education piece when it comes to fiber. Um but yeah, in terms of looking at metrics, stopping and breathing, I think it's been a really interesting session.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. Thank you as joining for having us. Cheers guys.
In this episode of Comms Leaders, Greg is joined by Raza (Virgin Media Business) and John (Contingency Networks) to discuss why connectivity is becoming critical infrastructure for AI, cloud and data centres, and why...
In this episode of Comms Leaders, Greg is joined by Tom O'Hagen (Entanet) to discuss the connectivity aggregator's vision for wholesale market transformation and the entrepreneurial journey of building, selling, and...
This episode of Comms Leaders brings together Beth Hooper (Uplands OneTelco) and Paul Gibbs (Vela Networks) to discuss two big channel themes - battling commoditisation by changing conversations, and the importance of...
This episode of Comms Leaders brings together Dave Ferry (ITS) and Dean Giblin (TalkTalk Business) to discuss two big channel themes -the rate of technology adoption in the channel and the over-corporatisation of the...
This episode of Comms Leaders brings together Adam Zoldan (Knight Corporate Finance) and James Banks (Charterhouse Group) to discuss two big channel themes - the impacts of uncertainty and the changing status of the...