Are we teaching the next generation how to think, or simply teaching them what to think? In this episode of Commander's Intent, host Derek Oaks, retired Air Force colonel, fighter pilot, and leadership mentor, welcomes Marshall Carter, Head of School at Atrium School in Massachusetts, for a powerful conversation about developing confident, independent decision makers and future leaders. Marshall shares how critical thinking, problem solving, resilience, and learning through failure help young people develop the confidence to make decisions, overcome challenges, and discover their own paths in life. Explore why traditional education often emphasizes getting the right answers instead of encouraging creativity, curiosity, and independent thinking. Discover how experiential learning, healthy risk taking, and intrinsic motivation prepare students for real world challenges. Derek and Marshall also discuss the importance of parental involvement, educational leadership, emotional intelligence, and building trust between parents, teachers, and school administrators. Whether you're a parent, educator, executive, or leadership coach, this episode offers valuable insights into developing the next generation of confident thinkers, compassionate problem solvers, and effective leaders. Great leadership isn't about making every decision for someone. It's about preparing them to make great decisions without you.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Have you ever frozen in the key moment of making a critical decision? Whether it's in business or in life, it can cost you everything. Commander's Intent will teach and inspire you how to lead with clarity, courage, and purpose. So here's your host, retired Air Force Colonel, fighter pilot, and your leadership mentor, Derek Oak.
SPEAKER_02What happens when you're responsible for developing young people when they come from backgrounds where they already have a lot of advantages? Sometimes we mentor kids, we work with kids that come from highly successful families or grow up in environments where they see all the opportunities that are out there, or a lot of the opportunities. They have parents who are very, very successful. And so they have of understanding all of that. And it's a very different demographic than, say, a kid from a tiny little town in West Virginia that only knows coal mining or only knows, you know, working on cars or truck driving or something like that.
SPEAKER_02When you have kids that have a lot of opportunities and maybe even a lot of expectations, how do you manage them? And how do you teach them? How do you take that young person and help them to develop and develop their own vision of what their life needs to look like instead of just following in their parents' footsteps or instead of just following the checklist of well, everyone around me gets straight A's, so I have to get straight A's. So how do you teach them how to make good decisions when nobody's standing over their shoulder and good decisions that help them forward their own vision instead of the vision of expectations that's all around them?
SPEAKER_02So today for our show on Commander's Intent, I've brought in Marshall Carter, who's, you know, full disclosure, he's a family member. He's my wife's cousin. He is a longtime Bostonian or New Englander, and he is the headmaster of the Atrium School in Massachusetts. So he works with youth. It's K th, correct me if I'm wrong, it's K through eighth grade. Pre-K through eighth grade. Yeah, pre-K through through eighth grade, of some high achieving or kids who come from high achieving families and a really good environment. And I want him to talk a little bit about, as an introduction, about his job and some of the challenges and what he loves about it.
SPEAKER_02And then we'll get into a couple of questions. So I turn it over to you, Marshall.
SPEAKER_04Thanks, Dirk. Good to see you, Rob. I promise not to talk in any kind of Boston accent. Don't come by it naturally. So, yeah, so my current role, which I've been in for a decade now, I'm going into my tenth year, is as the head of school at the HRM School, pre-K through eight. It's in Watertown, Massachusetts, just in that first ring of suburbs right outside the city. But I have been a career independent school educator. And you'll hear me use private school, independent school, sort of interchangeably within the industry of private schools. We tend to prefer the term independent because it speaks to the fact that we are accountable to our own board, accountable to our regional accreditation standards, not publicly funded.
SPEAKER_04And that gives us autonomy and agency as a school to determine, you know, in the marketplace of schools, what our focus is going to be. But I didn't know that I was going to become an educator, didn't know that I was going to become an independent school educator. I was largely public school educated. But my senior year in college with a double major in English and history, people started asking me, including my parents, so what are you going to do, teach? So I started to teach a volunteer in a local middle school in coastal Maine, late 80s, early 90s, and really loved it. And so became a middle school teacher and didn't actually aspire to leadership.
SPEAKER_04Although my wife is very good at pointing out that coming from a line of military and corporate leaders, the kind of the just really almost what you were speaking to, the implicit expectation that leadership would come down my path or I'd seek it became pretty apparent about 10 years in and took a middle school division headship and then ran the K-8 as part of a larger K-12 school, and then have been, after a couple little interstitial gigs doing different things, landed at Atrium. And I would say that the most compelling and enduring challenge, you know, people say that the two things we care about most are our kids and our money.
SPEAKER_04And independent schools, private schools are where you send both of them. And so that challenge of doing your best with every kid in as many moments, as many days as you can to both challenge them and also support them towards what's emerging in them and what you know that they need to know and be able to do in the world. That's a really heady responsibility. I always tell our parents at our school that I'm grateful and honored to be charged with this task of educating their kids, because to send your kid all day and to send a significant portion of your paycheck is a real, real commitment.
SPEAKER_04And so the internal challenges, I think, are common to many other leadership fields. You have the task that you're trying, you have your mission and the tasks associated with that that you're trying to carry out every day. And then you have teachers who have a wonderful array of opinions about how they're going to go about the work with kids. You have parents who, and I don't think it's just influential or well-resourced parents today who have strong opinions about their kids. I think you get that across it's sort of part of this era of child rearing that we're in, that parents are sometimes less ready to hand over their children to experts, right?
SPEAKER_04And want to be more involved with some of the decisions. So that's a dynamic that is true today. You know, choices about curriculum and then the financial realities. You know, we are nonprofits. My particular school right now, we just actually reached the point where we were able to achieve an endowment. It is not skin of the teeth, and the wolf isn't out of the door financially, but we have tight budgets to manage because we are tuition-driven, and tuition doesn't actually cover the cost of educating a kid. So there are a lot of those internal dynamics. And I would say right now, the biggest challenge we face externally, I even read an article recently that says that the family size is declining in Utah, right?
SPEAKER_04Demographics in most parts of the US, people are having smaller families. The generation coming up underneath us is sometimes opting to have zero or one kid. And so public schools, independent schools, parochial schools, schools of all kinds across the nation, there are fast growing areas, right? But by and large, we're facing a shrinking school age population. So for us, I think of myself as being like a small business owner in that I have to think about the half dozen or so other independent schools around me. Where do we overlap with them? But where do we really need to articulate our special vision, our mission to continue to thrive and attract enough students to keep the school solvent and vibrant?
SPEAKER_02Thanks. As you were talking and talking about the challenges, and I want to shift the conversation a little bit. And I love you talking about it. It's a nonprofit, but it is still a business. You still have to make payroll, you still have to pay your bills, and you still have to meet the organizational mission, which is educating kids. And that's that's what we're gonna mainly talk about a year about what that looks like. And I think of pre-K to eighth grade, and when you're educating kids, and you're more of an educator than I am, but having raised four, you there are core principles and there are core skills that you want to teach them.
SPEAKER_02Like, you know, Rob and I both went to the Air Force Academy and they force fed us a ton of math and a ton of science and a ton of engineering and a ton of really a ton of everything, and somehow fit it into eight semesters, but you have core skills that you want kids to know. I think you have to know a certain level of math. I mean, just to manage a household, you have to have a certain level of math. You have to have a certain level of communication skills and certain level of just government and societal social studies, I will call it, understanding to function.
SPEAKER_02And then you want to tease them and you give them enough opportunities where they start going, hey, I really like that. I really like that. You want to expose them to those different things. So it's almost like you have two roles. You want to not force feed them, but to get them through and to get them to understand and incorporate into who they are those core skills that everybody needs to have just to function as an adult. But then you want to give them autonomy and flexibility to start thinking for themselves and thinking, what is it that I want to accomplish?
SPEAKER_02And I know that a lot, I mean, my dad was in the military, I joined the military, I really didn't think of doing anything else. It wasn't until I was retired from the military that I went, hmm, what do I want to do when I grow up? And I know had my dad not been in the military, and I loved what I did, but had my dad not been in the military, I don't know what I would have done. I don't know that I would have ended up in the military because that was what was staring me in the face, that kind of an environment. So you have corporate leaders and accountants and you know, guys who work on in businesses and the parents, you know, and the both parents are maybe working and they're doing those kind of things, and you have kids, like, well, that's what I see.
SPEAKER_02How do you expand them to figure out what it is that they want to accomplish so they don't get to age 35 and go, you know, I really hate my job.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And because they were just locked into doing what their parents did. So how do you help them develop their own vision while you're still cramming all that core into them?
SPEAKER_04Yeah. What's funny is, I think every society has asked this question through history in some way, shape, or form, which is how do you bring up your youngers, right? It's no doubt it is a balancing act every day, right? So on the one hand, you've seen this sort of movement in recent years around free schooling, right? Feral kids, like let them do what they want and they'll discover what they want. And on the other end, you know, because we've become much more adept at generating data and therefore being pretty focused on data, on having schools nationally over-measure the outcomes that can be measured, right?
SPEAKER_04And then, you know, we all know as parents and as people in the world that it is critical to have some of those things that can be measured. I do want to know what kind of progress each of my students is making on literacy, on math, but those are not the goal in and of themselves. It's the way in which those kids are going to apply those with judgment, with compassion, with discretion to solve problems that are in front of them. So, you know, I go back to a couple of sort of seminal moments in my development as an educator. One was an informal conversation, and the other was a session at a national conference.
SPEAKER_04In the informal conversation, the veteran teacher, towards the end of his close to his retirement, said, Listen, we don't know what kinds of problems our kids are going to have to solve in 20 years. We can't even anticipate what those problems are going to be. So the number one responsibility we have is to teach them to be good problem solvers, right? And then the second, a few years later, I was down in New Orleans at the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics conference. And in a you know, conference room of 3,000 people, the keynote speaker whose name I'm forgetting now, the title of his talk was Why Kids Like Video Games More Than Math Class, right?
SPEAKER_04And that's a pretty provocative title, but we all filed in and he said, Let me tell you how this goes, right? The kids file into math class and they know a couple things. They know that the teacher already knows the answer. They know their job is to get to that answer that the teacher already knows, and they know that they'll be marked down for making mistakes, right? And contrast that with a video game, right? They don't know what the outcome is gonna be. And their choices drive that outcome, right? They don't know what mistakes they're gonna make, but they know they're gonna make mistakes.
SPEAKER_04And we actually reward that because you get four lives or you get five lives, right? You can actually sacrifice a life in a video game to learn around what's around that corner and then use that knowledge applying forward. So mistake making is rewarded. And ultimately, how are you rewarded? It's not that you've got the highest class in the grade. You're rewarded with the next level of difficult challenge. You have to go to the next level. He said, so we never really understand that that's what education in school should be like. We should be giving them hard skills, right? But not that's not the goal in and of itself. It's the application of those hard skills to novel situations that will turn them into critical thinkers.
SPEAKER_04And you know, the motto of my school is excellence with joy. And I'm often sort of coy with families and prospective families to say the most important word in there is with. It's not joy over here from learning and excellence over here from striving, right, for achievement. It's the sort of virtuous cycle between those things that when students are feeling joyful, right, they lose some of their self-consciousness. And when you lose your self-consciousness, that's when you're willing to take some more risks. And when you achieve excellence, when you break through individually or with a group of people through a problem, a novel problem, or more importantly, a dilemma that doesn't have an answer so much as an elegant solution, then you feel a kind of joy, which is its own reward and motivates you to learn more.
SPEAKER_04So, you know, at the end of the day, when I went to grad school nearly 30 years ago for education, I'd been working as a teacher in the summers and as a camp counselor, camp director, or wilderness leader in the summers. And one of the things that I observed is that kids were pretty uninterested in doing interesting things at school because of the setting and the culture of school, but they'd happily do pretty unpleasant things at camp, right? And I started to wonder about what that was all about. And where I sort of landed, and the thing that I think about a lot is, and this sort of gets back to your original question, kids will do things when they are extrinsically or externally motivated by the excellence of their institution, by the expectations of society or their parents, but they may end up performatively doing very well, but not learning what drives them.
SPEAKER_04And when you are intrinsically motivated, right, then you will pretty much do some pretty unpleasant curiosity-driven things that will lead you to new experiences, build your confidence, build your skill set, reduce your fear of the unknown. So for me, having clear external expectations, but in which kids understand there are multiple pathways to those, they're going to need to interpret it on their own, and they're going to need to really develop that intrinsic motivation. That is so important to me. One of the things I really value about my current school, you know, in one of my previous schools, which was one of the sort of more famous, you know, Ivy League-bound schools, we used to joke that our kids soared like eagles because our admissions process admitted eagle eggs, right?
SPEAKER_04My current school, we have eagles. We have kids who go on to the top prep schools and who go on to the ivies, but that's not what we exclusively focus on. And that's not what sets the norm and the standard at the school. We have kids who will go on to arts academies for high school and art school for college. We have all kinds of birds. I call the school an aviary, right? So, you know, that penguin may not learn how to fly like an eagle, but if the eagle needs to learn how to swim, it's going to refer to that penguin because it's particularly good at that. And when you create kind of a pluralistic environment of different types of students excelling at different things, not all to one standard, right?
SPEAKER_04Then you're more likely to produce, you know, wonderfully divergent learners who understand that what's within them is really important to listen to. I recently read Jim Collins, the Good to Great Guy. He has a new book out called What to Make of a Life. And he uses this idea of encodings. They're not skills, they're not passions. They're like things within you that you need to answer to, that you need to express in some way. And I really have been thinking this summer about how to think about kids in that way. What is the sort of constellation of stars inside them, right, that is unique and distinctive to them and can be cultivated to bring that kid drive, agency, initiative, and a sense of gratitude, a sense of gratification and satisfaction to live in the world.
SPEAKER_04What's interesting, Marshall.
SPEAKER_01I just get, you know, I've always thought about this myself. I had this kind of thought epiphany, if you will, years ago. And my thought was the way traditional schools have been set up, they provide education like they provide school lunch. They may give you the basic food groups of reading, writing, arithmetic, but they give you no appreciation for fine dining or good food, right? So I've seen that in the past. It sounds like, you know, you and your approach is more of kind of the how do you awaken those interests inside a child themselves.
SPEAKER_01And it's interesting that you mentioned video games. I had a great argument with one of my kids' principals. She made the statement that video games are horrible and should be done away with, and there's nothing good that can come from them. Well, I was trying to explain to her how I was teaching my kids geography through playing pirate games in the Caribbean or all of these things. There's a game that I got my son when we were in DC that is a space simulation program. And it's got a little green man that, you know, there it's Kerbal Space Program. It is physics-based space simulation.
SPEAKER_01And if you really get into it, like I had to go back and dig through my notes on my astronautical engineering course to figure out how to play the game because from college. And so how do you, you know, you still have those standards, those core standards that, you know, whether your state or your nation or your families, how do you kind of weigh that balance between, you know, your joy and your, you know. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Well, it's interesting. That's actually ultimately one of the reasons I chose to stay in independent schools, right? Because if one of the primary challenges that public school principals, superintendents, uh teachers face is the these uh sort of curriculum standards that have a tendency to favor content knowledge over skills, right? Mastery as opposed to what you're gonna do with that, that stuff that you know. My school calls itself a progressive school. And that word in this context goes back 120, 130 years to a group of educators that were sort of reacting to sort of the industrialization of education, right, in the late 19th century.
SPEAKER_04John Dewey is one of the names for the people most associate with this. And uh, his sort of famous phrase is that, you know, a child is a flame to be lit, not a vessel to be filled, right? That we're not here to fill them up, but rather to help them sort of find that fire. And, you know, to say we want to help children find their fire can sound a little loosey-goosey, right? But it actually is an act of that takes a lot of discipline and a lot of structure. So at my school, we have frameworks and curricular guidelines for every grade, right? You may go in and you may see, you know, first, second graders playing with Legos, right?
SPEAKER_04More than you might see in a public school where they're trying to move them beyond play and do more intensive literacy, sometimes actually ahead of the curve of the child's development. But what we know is that if three kids are playing Legos, right, together and they're doing something that fills the whole floor of the classroom or a part of the classroom, there is a lot of negotiation and social skill development going on between those kids. They have to take divergent visions and create a shared vision, right? They have to figure out what the resources, what the materials can do and won't be able to do.
SPEAKER_04And then if they're short or abundant of supplies, they're gonna have to figure out how to do more with that. Now, that to me, not that we're trying to get them on career tracks, but that to me sounds a lot like what a lot of people do. How do I collaborate with these divergent-minded people with materials limitations in order to achieve a task that isn't just art, you know, that, but that actually carries something out, that achieves something for others. That to me, you know, there's this old idea that play is work for very young children. When you leave kids to their own devices, they tend to occupy themselves pretty well if you curate the materials and the opportunity in front of them.
SPEAKER_04You know, we try to carry that through with our older kids too. So one of our hallmark projects is called the Crossroads Projects, and it's in seventh grade. And every time when I interview eighth graders as part of their high school selection process, I say, what was the hardest thing you did here at Atrium? And about 60% of them say the Crossroads Project. They're in groups of three or four. They're given a problem. This specific island has rising sea level. And how are you going to work with the people of that island to build new buildings that fit in with their architectural vernacular and meet the needs of that community? So they have to understand the science behind why that sea level is rising.
SPEAKER_04They need to understand the math of geometry to build an architectural model. We bring an architect in to work with them on that. They need to understand the history and culture, right? So the social studies is pulled in. And then they're writing about their math. They're writing captions for the whole thing. And in groups of three or four, they're inventing a building. They're designing and building a building because they build scale models that has never existed before. And that to me, it, you know, it looks like play. It actually looks like what a lot of kids seek out in summer programs, right? But that should be happening in school because the answer is undefined.
SPEAKER_04And therefore the kids know that they have to invent the answer, not just get to it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, maybe we should have freshman congressmen for the U.S. Congress go to your school and have to work through a problem like that with people from congressmen from different parties from across the country, and they'll learn how to play nice together and actually solve problems instead of what they do right now.
SPEAKER_04I had a grandfather visit last fall, and he had just retired, was trained as an attorney, but got into sort of materials manufacturing and supply lines and everything, and you know, worked government contracts, private contracts, military contracts over the years. And he came in and he watched our kindergartners having this conversation about, well, if we do it this way and if we do it this way, and he said, Could I have some of my senior executives come in? Yeah. But I, you know, I think, and listen, I've worked in different types of school. I have a very high-achieving daughter. And again, this is the beauty of independent schools, is that there are all kinds, right?
SPEAKER_04And they tend to be parent and educator driven. But I believe in the beauty of that sort of wide array and that eclectic array of kinds of schools. And I have no problem with schools that are sort of content heavy, right? Because I think there is a value to that. I'm intrigued by the sort of, and a lot of this is happening in Western states. There's a re-rise in classical education, right? I'm fascinated by that because it's an innovation and it's answering a need we have in this moment. Curriculum has gone in so many different directions. How do you re-center it and make sure that kids have some foundations?
SPEAKER_04It's not my bag, but it's fascinating to me that it's happening. And I think that's also something about independent schools that's really interesting. You know, I'm now on the board of our regional accreditation organization, Association of Independent Schools of New England, but they're the ones that we answer to, right, in terms of accreditation and accountability. But it's really, I have the opportunity as a leader in my organization to see what the kids need, right? See what's changing about that, right? A lot of things have shifted sort of following the pandemic, right? Because so many things sort of broke apart and had to come back together then. Kids are different today in some ways.
SPEAKER_04We understand a lot more about how kids are developing. But I get to observe all that, work with my colleagues to understand it, mirror it with my board, right? Make sure it actually will attract students to our school, and then communicate it to parents that we need to evolve. And we don't need to wait for the state or the federal government to say, evolve your school in this direction. And that's kind of scary, right? But it's an incredible opportunity. Again, it comes down to sort of the small business model that we can continue to evolve pretty rapidly in order to meet the kids' needs in front of us.
SPEAKER_02I love that. You know, let me throw out an example. As you were talking earlier about the kids doing that problem solving exercise. I love flying airplanes. But if you put me in an airplane and say, hey, just go out and do loops and aileron rolls and do maneuvers, I bore really quickly. And yet. There's a science to it, there's a precision to it, and there's a beauty to it, but I'm not really interested. But I can do those same maneuvers when I'm doing air-to-air training or when I'm you know doing an air-to-ground, a specific mission, and I'll do that all day.
SPEAKER_02And I love it because it's maneuver with a purpose. It's the math with a purpose, it's the physics with a purpose. And so because I see the purpose, I get really excited about it. Because I often ask myself, I love flying an airplane. I love being up in it. Why do I bore so quickly when I'm doing maneuvers that are, you know, to many so exciting? And I think it's that exact reason from an education perspective, is that's just the way my brain works. I don't get that excited about the math and the physics from a sterile perspective. But the application of it to a defined end is pretty exciting to me.
SPEAKER_02And I like that your students get to do that. So it sounds like the I already know the answer to this one, but I want to ask you a question. Is failure part of the curriculum? You know, because in I interview, I've worked with youth for many, many years, and where I have regular interviews, and I ask one of my questions that I ask them all the time is, you get straight A's. And most of them will say, Yes, I said, you know, it's okay to get a B. Don't tell your parents I said that, but it's okay to get a B. Meaning that it's okay to challenge yourself in an area where you may fall short a little bit because there's actually more learning in that.
SPEAKER_02And so explain to me how failure is part of the curriculum.
SPEAKER_04I mean, not only is it important, it's got to be central, right? And you know, one of my favorite stories to tell kids is, you know, nobody knows what Formula 409 is anymore, right? But you know, you can show them a bottle of Formula 409 and ask them, you know, why is it called this? And they go off to the internet and they come back and they say, well, there are 408 formulas that didn't work before they settled on this formula that had the right balance, you know, it's like the sticky note thing. It was an intentional failure. There's so many things that happen when you set situations up where kids are meant to fail and therefore they can embrace failure, right? So they're happening at the learning level, right?
SPEAKER_04If you say, you know, here are 20 popsicle sticks, and we want you to arrange them according to the graph we're showing you, the shark, the illustration we're showing you, we want you to build them that way, and then we'll be able to put a one-pound weight on it, and those popsicle sticks miraculously will hold up that one pound weight, right? And that's an activity you can do with first graders with eighth graders. And then the kids will they'll learn the right answer that those popsicle sticks can be arranged, right, in such a way as to hold up the weight. But if you go in and you give them 20 popsicle sticks and the weight and you say, design a structure which will hold up this weight, none of them are gonna get it right on the first time, right?
SPEAKER_04They're gonna have to hassle with each other and squabble with each other productively for different ideas. Well, if we do it this way, they're gonna learn that the center of the popsicle stick is the most vulnerable part, right? They're gonna have to learn how to cross brace, they're gonna have to experiment with a lot of different things. And, you know, I love walking into a classroom where teachers are doing an activity like this. And what you hear is laughter and right when the structure collapses, right? And then what you wanna see is the kids immediately say, okay, this time we need to, right?
SPEAKER_04They become engineers, right? And this is why engineering and STEM type activities are so great with kids is the iterative cycle between trial, error, trial, error, failure, rebuild is what leads you to success. And so the kids at the end of all, it's gonna take you 10 times as long to do that as it would be to say, here's how to build the structure, right? A successful structure. But next time they do a task like that, they will say, okay, I learned some principles from that. Not because I was asked to memorize three principles, but because I learned them from my own observation and they stuck more and they velcroed to my brain as opposed to sort of, you know, just being, you know, can blow away in the wind.
SPEAKER_04And next time I'll be able to apply that. So I think we have to be really patient and we need to bring more failure into the classroom. Because again, you know, what I often ask parents is, you know, if you showed up at work every day and your boss already knew the answer and your job was to get to that answer, how is work exciting for you? You know, what's the drive in it? So I think that kids learn the content, right? How to use materials, what the qualities of materials are in an activity like that. But they learn a modality of how to be, of how to learn, which is I'm probably not gonna get this right the first time.
SPEAKER_04And when I hit that moment of failure, right, that's gonna excite me, right? That's gonna drive me forward as opposed to discourage me. And, you know, we're talking about the kind of what I would call sort of inconsequential failures, right? We're not putting kids in, you know, cars before they have licenses and say, learn how to drive, right? You're setting, you're curating, you're setting up sort of careful thought experiments in the classroom that and setting the parameters in ways that they will figure this out. But that I think the failure is really important. You know, at my school, because we're very small, we've got 110, 115 students in the whole school, the social options are somewhat more limited, right?
SPEAKER_04So there's a kind of a social success and social failure. We don't have seven kids who you know form the basketball team and they all will sort of hang out together. We have to encourage kids to take social risks to find different types of people be their friends. And every friendship offer that is made to you that you make to another person isn't always greeted receptively right away. You have to work through and develop a kind of resilience. So, you know, I think, you know, and again, having worked in some very high-achieving schools and having access to that world as well, what I've observed is that when you hothouse kids, right, when you helicopter parent them, right, when you snowplow parent them, all the different terms we have, when you remove an element of risk and effort in order to guarantee the GPA and the high SAT scores or the ACT scores, you are almost guaranteeing that those kids are going to hit a wall in their early 20s because they will have been performatively doing very well, but they will not have developed the internal skills or the resilience of the social emotional intelligence, the self-awareness to meet actual challenges when they come their way.
SPEAKER_02I completely agree with that. I've used this example before. You go to the movie Honda with John Wayne. Yeah. You talk about not letting a kid, six-year-old, drive a car, you know, before they're ready, but allowing them to be in environments where they fail and they have to work through what failure looks like and how to overcome failure. John Wayne's fishing with the kid on the side of a river, and he says, Fish are going to be over there over in this shadow next to on the other bank. And the kid says, Well, how do I get over there? And he said, Well, just swim over there. The kid says, But I don't know how to swim. So John Wayne grabbed him by the pants and threw him in the river. And the kid flailed for a minute, went up and down, and then finally he made it over across the river and he said, I made it across the river.
SPEAKER_02And that's an old school way of teaching in a harsher environment of the frontier. But I think sometimes that approach has to be there to where people can grow and they don't reach those blocks where my mother is not here to save me. My mother is not here to have this conversation with the teacher. I have to have it myself. And that leads me to, that's a great discussion. And that leads me to another question I had of, and I see it with my educator daughter, who sometimes it becomes adversarial between the National Educational Association and the public school apparatus and parents.
SPEAKER_02And there's always going to be some of a friction, but it should not be adversarial because the focus is the kids. It's not a business we're running, even though you talk about a business. I'm here to educate the kids. The whole mission is to educate the kids. How can I best do that? And parents are stakeholders, teachers are stakeholders, and there are different levels of responsibility and expertise. The thing I like about what you're talking about with a private school is parents have, because they're you know writing a significant check that they actually have to sit down and hand you rather than through taxes, they're more concerned about things being done according to how they want it done.
SPEAKER_02So, how do you work as parents, teachers, and administrators and coaches in a way where the students' long-term well-being is never out of the picture? Yeah.
SPEAKER_04It's a great question. And I would have answered it very differently eight years ago when I was sort of just arriving at my school or sort of just getting getting into the position. Now entering my 10th year, there's only a half a dozen families at the school that predated me, right? And so I've now been in a 10-year relationship with many of the families at our school. And it's being a small school, I'm out there most days at drop off and pickup. I'm a very visible leader in classrooms on behalf of the school in different settings. And what that all gets to is this idea of trust and community building, right?
SPEAKER_04Relationship building. You know, a year and a half ago, we started, we put a shovel in the ground to rebuild our campus landscape. We had some engineering problems, we had to solve some drainage issues, and we also wanted to make a special space. You know, I'd raised a million dollars to do it along with my board members and my development people, but people felt very, very disrupted, right? We had to park differently, the kids didn't have very many places to play, and we had to sort of abide that for six to eight months. Never would have done that in my first year, right? But was able to go to people in the community, say, listen, let me articulate for you why this is gonna be good, let me articulate for you why it's gonna be amazing for the kids, right?
SPEAKER_04But always putting the kids center in terms of why you advocate or argue for something or uh, you know, push something forward. And you know, just like other things we've done before that seemed hard that we now love and take for granted, we're gonna get through this, right? And again, that's a minor interruption, right? I mean, you're talking about kids with lots of access to advantages and all and being disrupted at for play for six months. That's definitely a first-world problem, as they say. But the idea that I was going to people who I was already in relationship with, had built trust with, that to me is the critical thing. And again, that's one of the things that I prize about being in an independent school and in a small one, which is, you know, my constituents, my clients, they show up every day and they're little, right?
SPEAKER_04And, you know, the people I fundraise from are not people I'm sending annual appeals to. They're dropping their kids off at school every day, or they have graduated from the school. There is an intimacy to the constituencies that, first of all, is just really right for me as a leader. I don't think I would enjoy leadership in a setting where my people were at a distance, right? Or I wasn't in a long-term relationship with them year upon year upon year over something as important as their kids. So, you know, I think it's like anything else in any other kind of leadership, which is when you arrive at a big decision moment and a leadership moment, if you haven't done the work before that moment, that's why it's going to go poorly.
SPEAKER_04But if you are, yes, cashing in some of the social capital that you've built, if you have worked hard to trust people and to ensure that they trust you by behaving ethically and responsibly and predictably in all the right moments and inspired and unpredictably, you know, for other important things. That, I think to me, is how you avoid that type of conflict, right? You're never gonna completely do away with it. You know, as we were talking about before we recorded, the idea that it's important to be, you know, in debate and discussion with people you disagree with, right?
SPEAKER_04And if school isn't a place where kids and teachers aren't debating and discussing over disagreement, then they're not learning. They're not learning those critical thinking skills. But if you as a community aren't modeling, you know, common purpose, unity of direction, and the wrangling and squabbling that gets you there and the trust building that happens as a result, then you're kind of sunk. That's where decisions go wrong, I think. It wasn't that it was a bad decision. It's that the faith and trust in the community was not mutual between the leaders and the community to move something forward.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I love what you said, that if you get to a hard decision and you haven't done the work beforehand, then you're gonna fail. And really, that relationship, that constant back and forth, that constant face-to-face interaction, which is something we lost with COVID, and we lost with remote relationships, that daily required friction to be able to get to that decision. Because when you have that daily required friction, you have a level of trust that isn't there if you boil it down to a spreadsheet and you boil it down to my wants, their wants, and the other folks' wants.
SPEAKER_02And it becomes an across the table thing instead of a holding hands side by side kind of a thing. That's my frustration with what I've seen of the public schools. It's an adversarial relationship, and the kids end up losing out because you have these red-herring arguments or arguments that mask your true intentions instead of when you're sitting next to somebody the whole time, when you're working together the whole time, you know what the other side wants. And you know what the other side needs. And you're actually going to be working to help with, you know, get them what they need instead of just focusing on your particular needs.
SPEAKER_02That's the problem with it.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. And that's, you know, I like to think about my school. We're, you know, in the middle of Metropolitan Boston, right? The greater Boston area. So we're not a small town. But I like to think of the obligations that we have to each other, the frequent recurring different types of interactions we have with each other as being the building that sort of social net for all of us. And, you know, parents are increasingly seeking, because we're missing community in other ways right now, in this sort of moment in American history, parents are often seeking as much a community for themselves in their child's school as they are just a place for their kid.
SPEAKER_04And, you know, you got to be careful of mission drift. You can't say, well, we're going to be serving parents as much as kids. The core has to be serving the kids. But, you know, on the it takes a village idea, a community of healthy adults that are respectfully moving forward with common purpose, but different visions of that sometimes. That at the end of the day is one of the most important things we do for the kids, which is to model the kind of adult behavior we want them to emulate of civil discourse, of compassion and care, of have it bringing a measure of justice to the way you live for others. And that to me, that's the matrix around all the academic skills.
SPEAKER_04Because, you know, going back to early, like doing those loop-to-loops in the air doesn't excite you. But I bet if, you know, there were some people in southern Utah who needed some resources because of a fire, you'd get some buddies together and you'd load up whatever you could in the cargo base and you'd get there. And that's not about how to fly, that's about how to live. Flying is the vector, right? And that's how I think about education, which is the daily curriculum, right? The daily skills and content we're teaching the kids are only the building blocks for them to then take and assemble into a meaningful and useful life that serves themselves and their communities and serves others.
SPEAKER_02I love that. So I'm going to close, or maybe not close, but my final question, a real question here is as kids graduate from eighth grade at your school and you're looking at your measures of success. We talked about what do we measure, but your measures of success, how do you pat yourself on the back or you know, give a big group hug, well done to your administration and your teachers? What skills do they have that make you say we won? That make you say we succeeded with this kid? And obviously, as a 14-year-old, he has a long way to go, or she has a long way to go before she embraces or is able to gain real success.
SPEAKER_02But what is it where you say we did what we were supposed to do?
SPEAKER_04You know, there are definitely some academic and social emotional markers that we teach towards intentionally and that we look for, you know, more than adequate, ample progress on each kid in their own individual way. I think at the end of the day, but to your point, they're not done yet, right? And I particularly value a school that ends in eighth grade because at our school, the kids have such divergent and wonderfully different pathways ahead into different types of high schools. I think it's a great moment to change ovens to finish baking the cake, if you will.
SPEAKER_04But I, you know, I think for me, I mean, this is really a question about, you know, what do I as an educator value most, and then how have I worked to instill that at my school? You know, we talk about creating lifelong learners, right? So it's not that I don't want kids who are knowledgeable and have mastered the different elements of our curriculum. It's mostly I want kids who continually display openness and curiosity to learn more, right? So instilling in them that lifelong love of learning, that lack of being satisfied that you did something because you're ready to do the next thing.
SPEAKER_04I want to make sure that kids are each in their own way on the pathway to learning not just how to feel compassion, but how to express actively compassion towards themselves, towards others, those in their immediate universe of obligation, you know, their family and their friends, their neighborhood, but also who have a sense of abstract compassion, right? That people everywhere need care and need to be on our minds. And then they're figuring out some ways to express that so that as they gain new skills and learn how to drive, go off to college, that's deeply imbued in them, right?
SPEAKER_04On the one hand, they're not done at 14, but on the other hand, you're never going to get to be four to 14 again, right? Those are ages where the values and some of the patterns, the ways of being are really set. And I think this is not often a word which is associated with kids graduating from private schools, but to me, humility is really important. And I think of humility as a particular kind of confidence. I also think of it as a particular kind of self-knowledge. One of the things that I'm really proud of about our kids is the feedback we hear from the various high schools they go to is kids really want to learn. They're not just doing it for the assignment, and they know who they are, right?
SPEAKER_04And that's a pretty exceptional thing to say about a 14 or a 15-year-old that they know who they are. But we really have worked with, you know, a kind of faculty who values that, who themselves know who they are and can model it. And we work to really inculcate it into kids, yes, in the academic curriculum, yes, in the social emotional curriculum, yes, on the playground, right? So the kinds of conversations you hear between kids, between kids and adults at my school, are hey, are you aware of what you added to that situation? Step back, take a perspective, see how other people would see you, right? That perspective taking.
SPEAKER_04We do a lot of that. And it's timely, it's time consuming, right? But again, it pays off in the end because our kids are able to see themselves as they are seen, not just as they see themselves from within. Um, and I think that, yeah, lots of philosophers, lots of educational thinkers have talked about that, that knowledge of the world, knowledge of self is really the most important thing to blend as you live and expand your life. I think we also, and this is about something earlier you said, Rob, about sort of comparing school lunch to education, right? We don't expect them to be cookie-cutter versions of each other, right? We really do encourage them to be quite different, not for the sake of being different, but because they're naturally different and they're coming to express themselves.
SPEAKER_04And for some kids, that looks very conventional in terms of the educational path they'll choose. For some, it looks very unconventional. You know, we had a girl a few years ago who was very smart, very capable, did very well. Academic high school just didn't seem to be her thing. And so she went to one of the very good local, what we used to call a vote, right? But a technical school. Two years there, she had learned some things, but then she actually started self-directing her education and she got her GED and she went on to a very highly commended college with a lot of self-direction.
SPEAKER_04And she's doing great because she's driving every step of it. And I think it is our responsibility to guide them and to give them clear directionality about what the array of possibilities are, and it's also our job to empower them to really explore those possibilities. And as a parent and as an educator, it can be painful because you know, if sometimes their failure is not the failure we want to see. But if we can help them process that and absorb that and take lessons from it, then the risk they took, the agency they expressed that led to that failure, that's gonna be the durable stuff.
SPEAKER_04That's gonna be the residue that will be with them for a very long time.
SPEAKER_02I love that answer. It's to your point about their failure is stressful for parents and teachers. It's like a chest tightening because we don't fully trust their answer. We don't fully trust where they want to go. And I think if I would answer that question, you know, and I look at my own kids and I haven't always been good at it, helping them to make good decisions for themselves, helping them to figure out number one, know who they are, know that they're capable of making those decisions, and then making good decisions for themselves. And in today's society, sometimes that sounds selfish, but it's not.
SPEAKER_02It actually, I have to make decisions for myself. I have to put my own oxy mask on first before I can help anybody else. So helping them make good decisions for them helps sell. So I have to help them develop their own vision, develop their own values, develop their own confidence in who they are, and so that they're able to say, you know what? I don't want to be a doctor, even though both my parents are doctors. I don't want to be a doctor, or I don't want to be a corporate executive, I want to be a teacher. And there are a thousand different examples of, and it's nothing wrong with following your parents' footsteps, but you have to follow in your parents' footsteps because that's the right answer for you.
SPEAKER_02For you. So help helping kids come up with that answer. So I really appreciate your insight and your it's been educational for me. And I don't say that pun intended. I just, it has been educational for me. I love the discussion about how you train our replacements. You know, Mimi used to say that all the time. How you train our replacements so that when we're old and in a care facility or, you know, having our kids come over and feed us breakfast and take care of things for us that we're comfortable with what they're doing in their lives, or they have the capacity to both take care of themselves and take care of us and take care of the world around them.
SPEAKER_02Those are all challenging, challenging things. And they're up to the task. We just have to help them realize they're up to the task. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04I had a graduate school professor, the course was called curriculum design, but it was really about philosophy. And on the first day of the class, you know, 60 people in there, he said, if you're here to figure out how to write a curriculum for your school, you should walk out now. This is going to be much more esoteric than that. He said, To me, education is the process by which we the elders prepare the youngers to be okay without us when we're gone.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_04And so why would we want to pre-program them? Why wouldn't we want to turn them into the most capable, compassionate problem solvers that we can? Because we won't be here, you know?
SPEAKER_02It's really exciting when, and your kids, I would say they always need you, just like I need them, but it's really exciting when you watch, you stand back and you watch your kids and go, they're doing it all on their own. They're making decisions, they're making life decisions, they're paying their bills, they're doing it all on their own. I must have done something right, or in spite of all my efforts, they figured it out on their own.
SPEAKER_04And I got off a train in Fez, Morocco a month ago, and with all kinds of worries about whether my 19-year-old daughter was going to be okay there for the summer. And I walk out, she gives me a big hug, and then I just started following her. She's negotiating in Arabic for the cab, she's telling me where we're going to go, and I am just along for the ride. And it was really important because having that experience, which I've had other versions of along the way, you know, and we'll have more versions of to come with her. But having that experience as a parent reminded me that as hold as tightly as we want to hold on to them, our job is really to let them go with the skills and confidence and compassion that we need them to have, and they'll figure it out and we'll be able to follow them.
SPEAKER_02You're right. And that doesn't just apply to our kids, that applies to everybody we supervise. Everyone we supervise, if we don't have the mindset of I want to give this person enough experience and confidence so that they can replace me, at least in in components, they can replace me, then I'm not doing my job as a leader. And so I need to help them to someday replace me. Marshall, thanks a lot for being here. Thanks everybody for listening. If you liked it, please like, make a comment, and share it. And join us next week where we're going to become better decision makers.
SPEAKER_02We'll continue to become better decision makers for better results. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00So that's it for today's episode of Commander's Intent Podcast. Head on over to Apple Podcasts iTunes or wherever you listen and subscribe to the show. One lucky listener every single week that posts a review on Apple Podcasts or iTunes will be entered in a grand prize drawing to win a$25,000 private, exclusive leadership coaching package with Derek Oakes himself. So head on over to Commanders Intent Podcast.com and pick up a free copy of Derek's Leadership Guide and join us on the next episode.
What can an aviation artist teach us about leadership, creativity, and making better decisions? In this episode of Commander's Intent, host Derek Oaks welcomes renowned aviation artist Rick Herter to explore the power...
What happens when measurable goals create the illusion of success while the bigger mission fails? In this episode of Commander's Intent, retired Air Force Colonel and fighter pilot Derek Oaks shares powerful leadership...
When making tough leadership decisions, should you trust the facts or protect people's feelings? In this episode of Commander's Intent, retired Air Force Colonel and fighter pilot Derek Oakes shares a powerful lesson...
What does it take to make the right decision when the pressure is on and everyone is watching? In this episode of Commander's Intent, host Derek Oaks, retired Air Force Colonel and fighter pilot, welcomes Steve Young,...
What if the biggest threat to your organization's success isn't your competition, but how you treat your people? In this episode of Commander's Intent, host Derek Oaks, retired Air Force colonel and fighter pilot,...