🎖️ Getting promoted into leadership can create an unexpected pressure: suddenly, you feel like you're supposed to have all the answers. So some new leaders compensate. They talk more. Control more. Make every decision. Avoid admitting what they don't know. And sometimes they become so focused on looking like a leader that they stop developing into one. In Episode 2 of Command 2 Corporate, I explore the difference between confidence and competence, and why insecurity can sometimes show up disguised as authority. This conversation isn't about becoming less confident. It's about developing a confidence that's grounded in competence, humility, self-awareness, and the willingness to keep learning. 🔑 Key Takeaways: 🔹 Authority comes with the position; credibility must be earned. 🔹 Confidence and competence are not the same thing. 🔹 Overcompensation can turn uncertainty into controlling leadership behavior. 🔹 Saying "I don't know" is sometimes more credible than pretending. 🔹 Leaders don't need to be the smartest people in the room. 🔹 Asking better questions develops stronger teams. 🔹 Listening and changing your mind don't diminish authority. 🔹 Leaders who own mistakes make accountability safer for everyone. 🔹 Competence grows through feedback, experience, mentoring, coaching, reflection, and deliberate practice. 🔹 Mature confidence is often quieter than performative confidence. 📌 Pinned Comment New leaders: did you ever feel pressure to prove yourself after getting promoted? Maybe you talked more, controlled more, avoided asking for help - or felt like you suddenly needed to have every answer. Experienced leaders: what helped you become comfortable saying, "I don't know"? Share your experience below. Someone stepping into leadership for the first time may need to hear exactly what you learned. #confidence #competence #leadershipdevelopment #leadership #leadershipmindset #mentorship #command2corporate
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00So you finally get the promotion. Now you're the leader. And suddenly you feel this pressure that nobody really talks about. You think you're supposed to have the answers, you're supposed to sound confident, you're supposed to make decisions quickly, and you definitely don't want your team figuring out that there are things you're still learning. So, what do some new leaders do? They talk more, control more, decide more, and sometimes they even become a completely different person.
SPEAKER_00Like you don't even know them anymore. But here's the irony the harder you try to prove you're the leader, the more you may expose that you're not yet confident in being one. Today we're talking about competent confidence versus competence and why some new leaders overcompensate. Welcome to Commander Corporate. So, why do new leaders feel like they have to prove themselves?
SPEAKER_00So this is your starting point. You know, yesterday you were part of the team, today you're responsible for it. Somebody may have wanted your job, so they may have been gunning it for them for themselves. Someone may have more experience than you. Someone may be older than you, which happens quite often. You may now supervise former peers. And you're wondering: do these people actually see me as their leader? Which there's plenty of times that they actually don't.
SPEAKER_00That uncertainty can create pressure to demonstrate authority. So instead of allowing credibility to develop, some new leaders try to force it. More directives, more meetings, more control, more decisions, more talking. A title gives you authority immediately. Credibility takes long, much longer to develop. And that's where confidence and competence start getting confused. So, what's the difference between confidence and competence?
SPEAKER_00Confidence, belief in your ability. Competence, demonstrated ability. So you can have either high competence with low confidence. So high competence with low confidence. So you're a capable leader who constantly second guesses themselves because you don't have any confidence. You can have have high confidence and low competence, potentially dangerous.
SPEAKER_00You know, they don't know what they don't know. So very confident, but you're low competence. So again, you don't know what you don't know. You can have low confidence plus low competence developing leader who needs support. So you you you just don't like where do I begin? You can have high confidence and high competence. That's where you want to move to. But here's another component specifically tied to that humility.
SPEAKER_00The strongest combination may actually be competence, confidence, and humility. I know what I'm capable of, I know what I don't know, and I'm comfortable with both. The problem starts when we try to hide the gap between where we are and where we think a leader is supposed to be. So what does a leader, what does leadership over compensation actually look like? So it can look like micromanaging, talking over people.
SPEAKER_00How many people have been in the meetings where it's like you start talking, and because they want to show boat and they're you know what they say, you know, uh spotlight seeking, they talk over you and just try to, oh, what they mean is, and they just start speaking over you. So everyone, look at me, look at me. Don't have time for that. Constantly reminding people who's in charge. I've encountered those people that say, Oh, I'm the boss, I'm the boss. We already know that. Making every decision, so it always has to come from them, changing things immediately after taking over, huge mistake.
SPEAKER_00You need to listen and learn. Rejecting ideas too quickly, refusing to admit mistakes, they won't even acknowledge that they're wrong. They take credit, huge one. Now, now definitely make note of those people that you think or know that fall into this bucket. Taking credit for someone else that are, don't even want to involve other people that did the work. It was all the Mr. Me show. Blaming others, overexplaining, becoming unnecessarily aggressive, pretending to understand something you don't.
SPEAKER_00Excuse me, I've had that happen. I had that happen not too long ago where I sent uh uh someone above me a message is like, hey, can you click uh complete this form for me? They give me a response back, and I'm like, what are you talking about? You have to complete the form before I can move on, and then they respond back, Well, I'm new to this, I don't know, I've never done this before. So I'm thinking, so what did you just tell me? Where did that come from?
SPEAKER_00If you don't know what you're doing and you've never done it before, how did you respond? Like, what was that based on? So pretending to understand something that you don't know? Why didn't you just say, help me to understand the process? I'm not familiar with it. You just make up something, and one that's especially important, having to win every disagreement. If you're the leader, why do you need everyone in the room to know that you're the smartest person in it?
SPEAKER_00You don't, but so many people, no matter how far they go, how far they've reached, where they are, they're still doing that. Look at me, talking over people, taking credit, you know, pretending to understand something you don't, and just with confidence, just throwing out stuff. And if people don't know better, you don't know what you don't know, that sounds amazing. You're doing such a great job, and they haven't said a damn thing worth anything, but because it came out so confident, you're like, wow, they're all over it, and that can pull the wool over so many people's eyes, and the next thing you know, they're on the ladder like this crazy, and underneath a lot of those behaviors, there's usually something else happening.
SPEAKER_00Is overconfidence sometimes insecurity wearing a leadership title? Let me ask that question again. Is overconfidence sometimes insecurity wearing leadership title? Overconfidence has done thrown on a Superman cape and they flying all over the place. Be careful not to make this universal. Not every confident or assertive leader is insecure, but overcompensation can absolutely be a response to uncertainty.
SPEAKER_00A new leader may think, if I admit I don't know, they'll lose confidence in me. So they bluff. That's dangerous. Your people generally know when you don't know. I mean, and that's I mean, how many of y'all have had a leader say something so confident and you sit there and you look over the other person like, yeah, right. They know they full of. You know that's a lie. They'll know, but you think just because you said it so confidently, and then you go in the room, you're like, Whew, I made it.
SPEAKER_00They all out there know you're full of crap. All of them know it, they just don't say it. Saying I don't know doesn't destroy credibility. Pretending you know when you don't can destroy your credibility. You can add, I don't know, but I'll find out. Or I don't know enough about that yet. Walk me through it. No, maybe I can help you through this, we can come up with something together. Those are leadership statements, and that leads to one of the hardest lessons for new leaders.
SPEAKER_00You don't have to be the smartest person on your team. That's why you hire people that are subject matter experts. That's why you hire people that are experts in certain specialties. You know, you want you have a department that has multiple areas where you want to hire someone that knows more than you do to be successful. And if you want a high-performing team, you want high performers. They very well may know more than you. You shouldn't be intimidated to hire someone because they have a stronger background in something.
SPEAKER_00That's what you want. But you're gonna lead and bring all of those pieces together to make you know the pie, the the puzzle. You're gonna put it all together where it's magnificent. That's what you should be striving for. So, what if your employees know more than you do? Good. That's an opportunity. Imagine leading engineers, accountants, technicians, project managers, cybersecurity, AI experts, all of this stuff. The leader shouldn't necessarily know more about every specialty than every specialist.
SPEAKER_00That's why they're a specialist. How can you know everything? You're gonna know in-depth knowledge about all of these things, all of these areas. How is that possible? Your responsibility as the leader is different. You set direction, you set, you connect priorities, remove obstacles, make decisions, develop people, manage conflict, allocate resources, protect standards, create accountability. But all of those things you have to do it as a leader.
SPEAKER_00You have to understand your role, know your role. Those items are in your lane, own your lane, step up and do those things. Own it. Leadership isn't knowing more than everybody, it's knowing how to get the best out of everybody. That is key. Leadership isn't knowing more than everybody, it's knowing how to get the best out of everyone. How do you get the best out of everyone? How do you get everyone to be cohesive, a strong, unified team, and put their best foot forwards most of the time?
SPEAKER_00That's not to say that there won't be disagreements, but how do they handle disagreements? You won't agree, how do you settle disagreements? What is the approach to all of that stuff? There's conflict, how do you deal with that? There's a fire, how do you put it out? That's how are you getting the best out of everyone? You have to become comfortable asking questions and setting direction, setting expectations. You can't be afraid to do that.
SPEAKER_00Why are questions sometimes more powerful than answers? New leaders often believe leadership means providing answers. Experienced leaders increasingly learn to ask better questions. So instead of here's what we are going to do, try, what are we trying to solve? What aren't we considering? Who sees this differently? What could go wrong? What would you recommend? What information are we missing?
SPEAKER_00Now you're using the intelligence and leveraging the intelligence in the room, and you're teaching your people how to think. And it's not to say that someone might not might not ask the same question or throw out one of those questions as well, or those questions spark other questions that the team needs to consider. This connects directly to the previous episode. Stop solving every problem yourself. You can't do that.
SPEAKER_00You're not the individual contributor, you're not going to be that bottleneck. Don't be that person. The leader who always provides the answer eventually teaches the team to stop bringing ideas. Because guess what? Well, you're going to have the answer anyway. Or if I do bring it, you're going to shut it down and provide what you want to provide. So I'll just leave it to you. But asking questions requires something else that insecure leaders sometimes struggle with. Listening. Listening.
SPEAKER_00I remember when I was in the military, and it would be opportunities where we were given a task, you know, come down from you know the chain of command down this section, and we got a task, a mission that we have to go on. And if time permitted and we had the flexibility, I would ask, I would have my whole section from the lowest ranking person to the highest person below me, and said, here's a task. What do you think would be the best way to go about this? And this was years ago. I was probably early 20s as a leader.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'd say, how old was I? Maybe about 25, 26. And I'm asking these questions at that time. I was a staff, staff sergeant military in the army. And so I listened to everyone throw out an answer. And I'll I'll never forget this. I listened to everyone throwing out an answer. Well, I think we should do it this way. Okay, that's great. What do you think? What do you think? How about you? Ask everyone, the lowest ranking person, newest person in the section.
SPEAKER_00He came up with a great idea. And I said, you know what? And I'll forget his name. We're gonna do pro what private so-and-so said, we're gonna execute what he said. What did that just do to the team? The team is like, wow, he evalues anyone can come up with an idea. He's willing to listen to our ideas, and he may actually implement one of our ideas. So then the next go round, they're really thinking about how do we attack this problem, thinking through suggestions and willing that someone's idea may be considered.
SPEAKER_00Now, that's not to say it's gonna happen all the time. Sometimes there's no asking questions, there's just we need to execute this based on the mission. But when the time permits, I want the team to have a voice. Now, what did it just do for that lowest ranking person that probably thought is thinking like I don't know when I would be able to, you know, even share an idea, being fairly new, first duty station, and my ideas being implemented. Now, that's not happening everywhere.
SPEAKER_00You know, people might say, Well, damn, no one ever asked me my opinion, you know, and and I was just different that way. But that, and I got that from the leaders that helped me, where they valued my opinion and asked to try to get me to think, but also you know, getting the team to collaborate and and you know, voice things, you know, they can also think through things themselves. You know, why not? Can you be confident and still listen? Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00In fact, listening can signal confidence. You don't feel threatened by another perspective. I sure didn't, because you know what, as a leader, I may not always have the right answer. Now, depending on the situation, especially in the military, you're gonna, and if it's, you know, you know, prior, you know, whatever the mission is, but it's too time sensitive. We need to act now. Hopefully, you develop where you're gonna take, you know, through your training and everything, come up with the best solution at the time, maybe not.
SPEAKER_00But, you know, you gotta do what you gotta do. But you can't be threatened by another perspective. And so many people, I think, in the civilian world, civilian sector, are. You don't have to defend every position. You can change your mind, you can say that's a better idea. It's nothing wrong with that, you know. And I think it also builds a team that would want to collaborate by doing that, to saying, I like someone else's idea, I think we should go with that.
SPEAKER_00You know, showing that humility that I don't know everything. And you would hope that when the time comes, it's reciprocated back because you're almost teaching people how to behave, how you want to work together, so you would think that it would come back. Doesn't always happen. Um, but to say that that's a better idea in a public space, imagine the impact when a leader says that publicly, like the example I gave of my team.
SPEAKER_00Think about a round table of other leaders, and you're willing to do that. You know, I would think some people would be like, Man, that was really, really, really nice of you to do that back there. That's really great. Um, but again, you'd hope it'd come back around. You know, it doesn't reduce authority, it can increase credibility for sure. That's 100% positive. It can increase credibility. You don't lose leadership points because somebody else had the better idea. You don't, you know, it can happen.
SPEAKER_00You're not always gonna have the best idea to think that you are sending yourself up for failure, don't do it. And there's another phrase new leaders sometimes struggle to see. Say, not see say. What happens when a leader says I was wrong? Now, first of all, before a leader says I was wrong, or what happens when they say they're wrong, how many leaders would even say that they're wrong? I had a leader, basically, I was out working on a project, and uh I knew my role and responsibility.
SPEAKER_00I've been going for months, I was sticking to it, providing all feedback, documentation, everything. I was out, some people threw me under the bus, basically said, Oh, it's all his fault. People concurred. So then my boss, without getting any facts from me, came to me and basically said, Hey, you're gonna get written up. And I'm like, Wow, really? I'm calm and cool. I said, Okay, please explain to me what I did or didn't do to warrant a write-up.
SPEAKER_00Oh, I can't believe you're even asking me that question coming from the leader. I said, Okay, well let's let's back up a minute. I said, What did I do or did not do that warrants a write-up? Long story short, there was nothing. I started dropping facts. It was right before a weekend. He said, Okay, you know what? We'll pause this, pulled in HR and everything. We'll pause this. Why don't you get your facts together? Send it to me. Roger that. I sent three pages worth of documents.
SPEAKER_00I sent Gantt charts, timelines, emails. I had all my ducks in a row. I said, okay, so now tell me in this whole scenario where I was at fault with anything, and please go forth and take this to the powers that be and concur with every single detail I have in here because I'm not missing anything. Comes back, yeah. You know, yeah, I think we got it all cleared up, yeah, you know, um, and just moved on. No, my bad.
SPEAKER_00Sorry about that. I was wrong, zero. Just move past it. So it's just like, okay. So what happens when a leader can actually say I was wrong? You know, it deserves time. Some leaders think admitting mistakes make them look weak. But teams already know when leaders make mistakes. So in my case, I knew you're I knew you were gonna be wrong. I knew you were gonna be wrong, but you didn't come back and like own that you were wrong.
SPEAKER_00You don't come in hot without getting all the facts. There's always two sides of the stories. I don't care if it's 30 in the people, 30 people were in that room, all 30 were wrong. Sometimes you might say, well, if everyone's saying the same thing, it must be right. Or they're all wrong. And in that case, they were all wrong. You think every anyone came back to me? No. Leader has to own that stuff. So compare weak accountability. There are some communication issues versus leadership accountability.
SPEAKER_00I did not, I didn't communicate clearly. That's on me. Here's what I'll do differently. So many times they've glossed over things. So again, weak accountability. There are some communication issues. The team are thinking communication issues with who? Us or with y'all? Because y'all the ones that seem to not get it together. When I say y'all, the leadership. So there are some communications versus I did not communicate clearly. That's on me.
SPEAKER_00Here's what I'll do differently. If you start off the bat that way, oh, you're off on a good foot. Very different. Accountability creates permission for accountability. If leaders hide mistakes, employees learn to hide mistakes. If leaders own mistakes, employees learn that mistakes can become learning. And they will own it. I've seen this happen with team members, people that I've supervised myself. They won't own it. They won't be afraid to share that I made a mistake.
SPEAKER_00So if confidence isn't pretending to know everything, where does real leadership confidence actually come from? How does a leader actually build competence? This is the mentoring portion. Confidence comes through experience, repetition, feedback, mentoring, coaching, reading, training, observation, failure, reflection, taking a look inside, and deliberate practice.
SPEAKER_00But feedback and failure, and some people don't want to hear feedback. They don't want to hear, you know, that wasn't good, or you know, they just don't want any adverse feedback at all. But it's part of the job. You will get it, and you have to learn how to embrace it, make notes, listen, learn, move on, course correct, all of that, and move on. So you ask your manager, what's one leadership behavior I should improve?
SPEAKER_00Ask your team, what's one thing I could do differently that would be help you succeed? And I've done that. I've asked my team, how can I what can I do to improve? After difficult situations, ask yourself, what did I handle well? What would I do differently? And write it down, be honest about it. That's how competence compounds. And eventually something interesting happens. You stop needing to look confident because you're actually built confidence, you've actually built the confidence.
SPEAKER_00So, what does mature leadership confidence look like? It becomes quieter. You don't need to dominate, you don't need constant validation. I hate that. I hate that. You don't need credit for everything. Why you you shouldn't? You don't need every every idea to be yours. Let me start over. Let me start over. Y'all need to get this. What does mature leadership confidence look like? It becomes quieter.
SPEAKER_00You don't need to dominate, you don't need constant validation, you don't need credit for everything, you don't need every idea to be yours. You can around you can surround yourself with brilliant people without feeling threatened. You can say, I don't know. Help me to understand. I was wrong. You were right. Great job. What do you think? And still make the hard call when necessary. That's important. Humility doesn't mean indecision.
SPEAKER_00Listening doesn't mean consensus. You still lead. You can listen to everybody and still be responsible for making the final decision. It doesn't hurt. Leadership Marathon. I want you to think about how you show up when you don't know the answer. Do you get quieter and curious or louder and more controlling?
SPEAKER_00When someone challenges your idea, do you explore their thinking or defend your position? When somebody on your team knows more than you, do you leverage their expertise or feel threatened by it? Here's probably the hardest question. Are you leading from confidence or performing confidence because you're afraid somebody might discover what you're still learning?
SPEAKER_00Let me repeat that. Are you leading from confidence or performing confidence because you're afraid somebody might discover what you're still learning? Leadership challenge. This week I want you to practice three sentences. I don't know. What do you think? I was wrong. Look for the appropriate opportunity to use at least one of them this week.
SPEAKER_00One of them. I don't know. What do you think? I was wrong. And pay attention to what happens. You may discover that admitting that you don't know every answer doesn't reduce your credibility. It actually creates trust because confidence isn't convincing everyone that you know everything. Confidence is being secure enough to keep learning. When you first become a leader, you may feel like you need to prove you're ready.
SPEAKER_00You don't. You need to become ready. Build your competence. Ask questions. Listen, make decisions, learn from mistakes. Surround yourself with people who know things you don't. Because confidence might help you walk into the room, but competence is what earns the room's trust. Again, because confidence might help you walk into the room, but competence is what earns the room's trust.
🎖️ Every person you lead has an invisible trust account with your name on it. Every promise you keep makes a deposit. Every commitment you ignore makes a withdrawal. Every time you listen, give credit, admit a mistake,...
🎖️ Every decision comes through you. You're copied on every email. Your team constantly asks for approval. Problems wait until you're available. At first, that might look like strong management. But it may actually...
🎖️ You can make the right decision and still get criticized. You can do great work and someone else gets the recognition. You can have good intentions and still be misunderstood. And sometimes, the person who gets the...
🎖️ Getting promoted into leadership should be exciting, but it also requires one of the biggest professional shifts you'll ever make. The skills that made you a great individual performer aren't necessarily the skills...
In this episode of Command 2 Corporate, Larry Perry explores why leadership can feel lonely, how isolation quietly impacts decision-making, and why every leader needs trusted mentors, coaches, and peers to stay...