Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Comics For You

Comics For You artwork

Sara Phoebe Miller - "You Can Just Write Something That’s Fun"

Feb 25, 20261 hr 1 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

On this episode of Comics For You, Matthew is joined by Sara Phoebe Miller! Sara is a writer and editor with over a decade's worth of experience in the comic book industry. She worked at DC Comics for 13 years, most recently as the editor of DC’s Books for Young Readers line of YA, middle grade, and early reader graphic novels, and is currently the Editorial Director of BOOM! Studios. You Belong Here with artist Morgan Beem is her first book. This is an incredibly enlightening chat about Young Adult content! What is YA? What are the major genres? How is the budgeting and pitching different from adult fare? How can you get started writing or editing YA work? Learn some tips and insight from Sara! Support the show! Read Matthew's newest webcomic, Sight Rhyme, for FREE on Tapas: https://tapas.io/episode/3624503 Crashing by Matthew and Morgan Beem: https://www.amazon.com/Crashing-Matthew-Klein/dp/1684059879 For more, follow Matthew on Instagram and Blue Sky Pick up a copy of Sara's debut YA graphic novel You Belong Here Follow Sara on Instagram at @saraphoebee

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

for another episode of Comics For You, the podcast all about the making, marketing, and selling of comic books. I am Matthew Klein, your host. My day job is selling comic books through comic book shops or Penguin Random House, but I'm also a writer. My graphic novel, Crashing, from IDW Publishing is available wherever comics and books are sold, if you feel like vetting me. Think Grey's Anatomy meets The X -Men, a super -powered medical drama with art by Morgan Beam, who's killing it right now, over on Author Immortal from Image Comics. The book is colored by Treonna

Farrell, lettered by Eisner Award winner Hassan Atmany -Elhaw, and edited by friend of the show, Heather Antos. I also have multiple webcomics about a Philly P .I. named Mason Rhyme that you can read for free over on a site called Tapas. It's written by me, they are drawn by Rich Wazicki, and lettered by Nick Philpott. All of us met, slinging comics at Forbidden Planet New York back in the day, and it's a fun world we like to revisit from time to time. The link for all of these, if you want to support the show, will be in the show notes and on my socials. But today,

we have one of the coolest chats yet, as we enter year two of comics4u. My guest is Sarah Phoebe Miller. Sarah is a writer and editor with over a decade's worth of - of experience in the comics industry. She worked at DC Comics for 13 years, most recently as the editor of DC's Books for Young Readers line of YA middle grade and early reader graphic novels and is currently the editorial director of Boom Studios. You Belong Here with

artist Morgan Beam is her first book. and out now wherever comics and books are sold. So you will hear a bit of a Morgan love fest on this. Morgan, if you're listening, enjoy this. Sarah is gonna be on here talking all about young adult content. So what is YA? How do you define this section of storytelling? We get into things like how old can the hero be of a YA story? How long does it take for a graphic novel to get made as opposed to a monthly comic? Is there a difference in terms of how artists and creators get paid?

aid, what type of YA stories are selling, what genres, what authors, and where is the marketplace going, and who is reading these stories? So much more. It's an illuminating conversation about an area of comics I'm still eager to know more about, and I hope you will enjoy it as much as I did. Thank you for making the time to be with us. If you wouldn't mind, please just take a second. to like, subscribe, rate the show five stars, write a 10 word review even. They go a

long way to getting the algorithm to like us. If you're here for Sarah though and you like the interview, hey. Check out the back catalog. We've got episodes of the likes of Chris Condon, Stephanie Phillips, Jorge Corona, and we've even launched a bonus segment with guests called Fave Five, where folks share their top fives for things like their favorite comic runs, their favorite writers of all times, the superpowers they wish they had, the holy grail items they want for their collections. But we are going and growing here at Comics4U, and you can help us expand. by doing all those things or you can even come

over to Patreon if you want to take it one level further. Patreon .com slash comics for you for as little as just one dollar per month. It's less than what you pay at the dollar store these days. The normal disclaimer still applies. All opinions expressed on here are strictly my own and they do not reflect my employer, Penguin Random House, who is also hilariously also Sarah's employer. We get into that a little bit. So with all of that, let's talk to Sarah Phoebe Miller about why comics are, in fact, for you. Sarah

Phoebe Miller. Welcome to Comics For You. I am so excited to have you on here. We have shared an artist. on our creative endeavors. It's a lot of fun. We are essentially, we're in -laws as far as that. We're like creator in -laws. With Morgan Beam on your fabulous debut graphic novel, you belong here. And you also have enjoyed working with the manic pixie dream boy that is Isaac Goodhart. I adore Isaac. Isaac, shout out. You don't listen to the show, but maybe one day you will. Maybe because you're on here, Sarah,

we'll finally get Isaac to be a listener. He'll listen to this episode. I'll tell him we talked shit about him. He won't be able to. So you are a very important person. in comics right now, and I'm so excited to have you here. Please, for the dear listeners, tell everybody what your current role in the comics industry is. Not just a phenomenal writer with a new book out, but what is the day job? Oh my gosh. Well, first of all, thanks so much for having me. Really excited to chat with you about all the fun things. My current day job is I'm the editorial director

at I love a director. What a look. It's so fancy. I'm at Penguin Random House. I'm still in the manager echelon. So like I'm told one day in the 15 year mark, I might move up to like assistant director. So I'm really, I know. The air is different up here. So just kidding. It's exactly the same. No, you and I just met. at New York Comic Con. We had never gone back and forth and we met at the Blu -ray. So give me a little bit for our

listeners, talk a little about your comics origin story specifically into editing. Oh, man. Okay. So I started as a summer intern at Vertigo. Of course, DC non -superhero, mature line of comics. I was going into my senior year of college and I didn't really know if comics was Because for me, I didn't have a vision in mind to get into comics professionally, but I got the opportunity

to intern for Vertigo. I took it. You know, it was obviously such a creative place to work. And as far as the comic book industry goes, really hit a lot of my interests as far as being an English and creative writing major in college and wanting to work with cool stories and cool talent. And Vertigo was obviously the place to be for that. So Will Dennis and Mark Doyle gave me my first opportunity in the industry and I

like to say I stayed ever since when after my internship ended, the DC offices were in New York city at the time and I was going to college in New York city. So I got to stay on as a temp in the fall. And then an assistant editor job opened up that January. And I obviously, you know, applied and was sort of in the right position at the right time to. just continue that journey.

And so I became the Vertigo assistant editor, which was a really cool time to be at Vertigo because it was the last of the New York City era. So that was very exciting. But once, when DC moved to LA, I started a new position as the talent development manager. So I worked as, or I ran professional development. artists and writers workshops with Bobby Chase. And we also did professional

development workshops at conventions around the country, which was also really exciting to be doing that as a writer. And like I said, someone who was an English and creative writing major was so amazing to be bringing that like workshop environment to DC Comics. And I also learned a ton from a craft perspective because I got to sit in on three years of artists and writers workshops led by, you know, industry icons like

Scott Snyder, Klaus Janssen, Andy Kubert, others. That was awesome. I would have, yeah, really proud of that program and what we're able to do and the talent we brought on board with it. But around I guess like 2018, I... was starting to get the itch to return to proper editorial work and DC had was creating the young reader line of comics and graphic novels. So I also

happened to be getting my MFA in writing for young people and screenwriting from Antioch University in LA because I was starting to work on my own YA graphic novel at that time during my MFA and was interested like I had kind of I identified that oh actually I think I really love kid lit and young adult literature and would love to work more in that field both for myself as a writer and maybe one day as an editor. I actually for a while thought I would maybe have to leave

DC to do that kind of editorial work but the again sort of like timing aligned and DC was interested in bringing that to the company those types of books for younger readers and I was able to get it on the ground floor with that. So I became an editor in the books for young readers department. and did that from 2018 until I left this past June and became Boom's editorial

director, where I'm mainly overseeing the kids' NYA imprints, Boombox and Kaboom, but also supporting editorial and all the other imprints. So yeah, I think in comics, especially working at, I was at DC Comics for 13 years and I really, I somehow always avoided the mainstream superhero comics, but it was an amazing place to begin and grow.

Also, can I pause you real quick? Cause now my cat is scratching at the door and she won't stop unless I let her in. So I'm going to go let her in. Please let her in. I was trying to. Okay. No, I am a former cat. So all cats are welcome on this podcast. So it's a, it's a really fun journey to go like summer internship. Then you get out and it does sound like, to your point, like so much of, you know, career paths are is like right place, right time being prepared for

that opportunity to take advantage of being in the right place at the right time. Um, I also think of it as thought it's a hundred percent bad. and I think about that a lot, but it's also identifying what your particular interests or passions are within whatever place or end you find yourself and like taking control of that wheel a little bit and being like, oh, actually like over here looks ending or I'd really like

to find a way to carve out this path and being able and then like... Being at a place that is sort of supportive of that slightly more journey. And I'm curious. So, so what was it about kids lit that really attracted working in this space? Young adult has always been my bread and butter in particular growing up. Can you define young adult for listeners? Like you're, you're the first young adult editor I've gotten on the podcast. So I really sort of. dive into like, what is

young adult? How do you define it? How do you differentiate a pitch for young adult, middle grade? Like, let's get into all of it. Give me the YA Ted Talk, basically. Oh my gosh. Exciting. Uh, let's see. So young adult is typically for readers to 17. That's like the industry age range, although It can skew a little younger, skew a little older, depending on the story, but typically the sweep spot is into 17. It's often defined

by the protagonist being a teen and experiencing like themes that are relatable to what teens go through. It's not the teen experience from an adult perspective, but it's the teen experience from the teen perspective, which I just love because I think being a teenager is fascinating and teenagers in general are just fascinating and I love that the things they go through when

I love that when they go through things it's often the first time they're experiencing something and so the emotions are so heightened and it sort of feels like you know in the grand scheme of things like It might not be a big deal, but in that moment in time or in someone's life, it is the biggest deal. And so I think like those issues, teens experience should be taken very, very seriously in young adult literature. Middle grade in comparison is typically ages eight to

12. Again, some title skew you a little younger, some title skew you a little older, and it's a little more... It can sometimes have similar themes as young adult literature. Like I actually think a lot of Reina Telgemeier's work, the creator of Smile and Drama and Sisters, Guts, only like some of the biggest graphic novels in all of publishing, which is awesome, can deal with similar YA themes as far as like friendships and boys

and your body changing in some way or again sort of like experiencing me for the first time but it's a little middle grade is also defined by being just more age appropriate and being really oh you have to be a little more aware of like might be considered appropriate or not because middle grade books are bought by the adults but YA books can be bought purchased by the teens themselves. So I think you have a little more wiggle room to still be appropriate while, again,

sort of like reflecting those issues teens experience in the most realistic, relatable way possible. When you get into the age ranges is also what I have heard. and you're here to dispel the myths, is like some of it also has to deal with the age of your protagonist in there, right? Like I had always heard if you're writing, if you're writing for middle grade, the protagonist could be 13 to 16. If you're writing for YA, the protagonist should be 16 to 21 top sort of thing. What is

it about that age range do you think that resonates with that age of an audience member? Industry knowledge states that readers read up. So a 12 year old wants to read about a character's 15 and a 15 year old wants to read about a character who is 18. I think there's a lot of truth there, but it's not always the case. So yes, middle grade books, the characters can be in middle school, they can be even in high school. maybe

sometimes it's even there are silly adult characters but like there's always some child who is relating to the adults if the book features more adult characters like a book I edited for DC called Dear Justice League is a good example of that. That's a middle grade graphic novel written by Michael Northrup and illustrated by Gustavo Duarte and it follows the Justice League members as adults answering fan mail from kids. So they

find themselves answering very silly kid -like questions, but in a way that is really like playful and fun while still feeling true to the Justice League characters. So I think there's a little more wiggle room for who the characters can be in middle grade. They can be animals, they can be monsters. It's a little more playful, a little more fun, more adventurous. Humor is always a big theme in middle grade books. And then in

YA books, it's hard to get around a young adult book where the protagonist isn't a teenager or that 18 to 21 age range. That's technically... called New Adult, which is a fairly newer category. I feel like every three, four years, they throw a new subcategory at us and that we just have to like, new adults just got on my radar like

six months ago and I'm like, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. What book talker came up with this, please? I would like to be aware and go spam their account. It's actually not. a book talker's fault, it is the industry's fault, but it's sort of become more popular or taken more seriously because of the rise of Romanticie and like which is I think driven in a lot of ways by book talk and sort of those like there's some YA Romanticie

that skews older but so it's really interesting and I actually like the new adult category because I think there is a gap between like books about being in high school and then books about being in college or like being a new adult in the sense that you're maybe you're like first job or your first apartment or like some of those older firsts you experience in college or post college that may not really feel right in the young adult

space or or for like high school students but is a close relative like we are because we both worked with Morgan Beam. So I think it gives a little, I like that it's being considered in the end because I think it gives a little bit more. flexibility and a little bit more of a transition between young adult and adult literature or comics or graphic whatever. By opening up sort of a new category do you think this creates a new pipeline for those types of stories? Maybe

I think it more just keeps certain stories from being pigeonholed or like having to um potentially age down something or be concerned with some sort of appropriate level. I think especially in the world of book bannings and certain books being judged unfairly, that new adult category can make it so it's like these younger characters

are maybe experiencing more adult themes. It doesn't get stuck being just for teen readers in the way that folks who like to ban books and things like that are like how could you give this book to my teen it's got like cursing or sex or you know queer themes and things like that and you don't want to cater to those people ever but it just I think it gives a little bit more breathing room. There is a book that still

feels sort of like young adult as far as not being adult or opposed to just straight up adult. So I'm curious now to backtrack a little bit. Let's go to sort of the start of the process. How many folks are with you at Boom and Kaboom in the editorial department? So I currently have two editors working with me exclusively on Boombox and Kaboom, Kids and YA, comics and graphic novels, Lily Kessinger and Elizabeth Bry. They're awesome. So it's really a team of three at the moment.

And how many projects do the three of you tackle at various stages of development? Oh my gosh, that's such a tricky question to answer because it can feel like just everything all the time. But if I could put a number on it, I'm like trying to picture on spreadsheet and things. I think we have around 12 books a year, 12 like graphic novels a year or 12 titles. But so like in 2026,

we're planning for around 12 graphic novels to come out into the market but in 2027 we've got like another 12 and we're kind of working both simultaneously but then in terms of single issues we are we probably have about four to six no six to eight that sounds better six to eight single issues um like different titles but the kaboom imprint in particular hasn't had as much

attention as some of the other boom imprints over the past couple of years, so we're really working on rebuilding those programs and reimagining them for both the book market and the direct market and how to sort of take advantage of both, especially now that we are under Penguin Random House. Yes, for full disclosure, there's technically both Sarah and I are employees of Penguin Rantos, but we are speaking here. personally on ourselves.

As I say in the opening disclaimer, all opinions are expressed are my own. So you've got 24 graphic novels that you're working on various stages of from pitch to getting the final artwork in to working with production to comics giveaway day spotlights. And then you've also got six to eight more comics projects. You're talking about three people juggling 30, roughly 30 different projects. on any given day at various stages of development. That's a lot. I will say the

majority of those graphic novels at the moment are where are reprint or I'll say are. Um, new additions of our backlist material. So it's not all original material or original content, but it's still redesigning the cover, redesigning the back matter, reviewing the interior pages. A big thing I'm doing has been an app about it is that we are resizing. We're rebranding in

a lot and resizing a good amount of our Kaboom backlist material in a new five and a half by eight trim size that aligns more with the middle grade graphic novels that are in the market, which Boom has never done before. So I'm super excited to be doing that. So in the fall, in fall 2026, we'll have two Garfield graphic novels in that trim size. Actually, we're going to have three Garfield graphic novels. One is new content

to our backlist. We're going to be resizing Goldie Vance. We're actually rebranding and resizing Goldie Vance, which is one of our beloved series by Hope Larson and Brittany Williams into the five and a half by eight trim size for the middle grade book market. a couple other titles in that space. Similarly on the boombox side we are resizing a lot of our backlist into a six by nine trim

size, which Boom has done before, but is more standard, but hasn't done for everything and is more standard in the book market. So we'll, in fall 2026, we'll be resizing Fence into, which is another beloved series, Queer Sports Romance, Incredible, by CS Picat and Joanna the Mad. So that will be coming out in a six by nine graphic novel format for the first time, as well as a number of other titles. So at the moment, the

bulk of our work is that type of work. But there are, of course, a couple of new series and original projects in the pipeline. I've sent you a pitch for writers who are looking to sort of get into the YA and middle grade and early reader or, and even the new adult space, when you and the team are looking at pitches, what are some of sort of the green flags and what are some of the red flags? Like right off the bat, when you're

skimming it and you're just sort of reviewing it, what are sort of those definite yeses to say, okay, let's look at this further. And then what are those things that make you immediately go, look, we got 50 of these on the pile. This is an easy one to say no to right off the. We didn't even talk about the early reader category, which is a whole other thing. We need another hour for that. So you'll have to come back and that'll be next time. Yeah. Um, okay. What do I look for in a pitch, especially for like young

adult or well to start off and really this goes for any type of, but when a pitch has a unique voice, it's really obvious in the best way. Like it really stands out. when the pitch itself feels like not even a unique voice but a very confident so sometimes there are pitches that can be a little more meandering a little like you can tell it's kind of trying to figure itself out as it's being written it is it's obvious especially

when you've read enough to know and then a voice a pitch with a confident voice and vision is very obvious as well and it's hard to really define it except for a couple of possible things like I do typically like to see some sort of log line or high concept where it's like this pitch is a I'm just going to use fence as an example because I just we just talked about but like a queer sports romance about two rival private

like boys private schools that um compete with each other a fencing tournament and there's love triangles and um you know all sorts of exciting things that readers love in that genre. That's probably a bad example but you get my point where it's like it knows what genre it is it knows the audience it's catering to and then maybe it even knows some comps like this is um I don't know I'm actually, I was going to use an example of something I'm working on, but I'm not, I don't

reveal that. Let's see. Like the Grinch meets home alone. I don't know. I don't know what that would be. It's, it's the holiday theme for when we're working, because we're recording this. So that's very, I like where your head's at. Thanks. The Grinch is home alone is actually kind of sad. Yeah, no, you've got, you, you just got my, my wheels turned in for a second. So see, like, or, you know, obviously you can also like, it doesn't just have to be film. I think it can sometimes be really easy. Film or TV shows

because they're often known and folks can like get the idea just from that. But you could also use other comics or literature, but it must be something that is widely known. Like there's sort of a couple different types of comps and these and a comp is um short for a comparative title comparative comparative comparative tomato tomato i'm gonna go with whatever you pronounce oh no it's a comp it's a comp it's a comp maybe

this is why they shorten it to comp i don't like i don't know if i've ever said that out loud kind of thing and i'm guessing myself i'm also from long island so I sometimes pronounce things a weird. That's I'm from downtown Philadelphia. So my W's, my D's, my L, like a BL is the worst sounding thing you've ever heard when I have to pronounce it. So I understand. So you're looking for you're looking for like a log line that helps identify in terms of a pop culture thing. What is the tone you're getting at? What are some

of the tropes? What is the genre? What is the audience that you're looking for? I'm really curious to. like is there a length for a pitch like ideal like I've heard so many different things over the years of like okay you have to have a one pager and then you can have an outline but the outline can't be more than one page well that's not true if it's really good and they want to read it it can be up to three or four pages so and then I know some creators who like will send their editor a 17 page brain dump right?

And just be like, you figure it out. So what is what is for you and Lillian Elizabeth sort of what are your preferred formats and lengths as it were for a pitch? In an ideal world, I think a pitch would be four to five. And the shorter the better. And I think going back to the whole confident idea, the shorter it is, the more confident the idea most likely is. But with that said, not so sure that you don't give enough info. So One page probably isn't enough.

If it is, awesome, but most likely it's not. So as short as you can make it while still presenting all the info necessary for the editor to understand what this story is all about. So typically I find that sweet spot to be around four to five pages. I'm so sorry. It's like six pages and now I feel bad. Oh, I mean six. you know four to five pages six is not gonna offend anybody

um ten like ten pages i think above eight pages. I probably don't want to read. I feel like at that point you're almost stress testing the editor. Like the longer your pitch is beyond that, the less they want to like it. Like they start acting the same note at that point. I don't actively dislike it. My brain just can't retain it. I actually like I actually stop at five pages no matter what. I was like, if you cannot get your

point across in that length of time, clearly something's wrong. Exactly. And that's kind of the thing. Like I should really know if I'm on board by the first page and then I want to keep reading a couple more pages to like get the rest of the info I need to then kind of pitch it myself internally because Not only are you pitching to an editor, the editor is pitching to the company. So you're, you can also think of it as you're giving the editor all the info they need to then

go out and convince a committee of other people that they should give the editor money to give the talent money. And I'm curious when it comes to, to that, cause you've worked, you know, working at Vertigo, you worked on a lot of adult stuff now. you know, then you moved over to the YA and middle grade and early reader space. And you've seen this sort of industry evolve in these. What have you been in the industry now? What, 15 years? I was trying to, like, timestamp it. When it comes to budgets, what do YA books get

versus adult books? Really varies, but... The main difference, I'm not sure I'm at full lip too. I want numbers. Yeah. But it does vary and it kind of depends on the project and what type of project. Sure, Raina Telgemeier is going to make a million dollars. Yeah, that's talent attached. All sorts, there are all sorts of factors that go into it. But like the main difference is that an original graphic novel, creator will often

be paid an advance, which is an advance sum, usually split in a couple of installments, maybe three to four installments, kind of also depending on the type of book and the schedule and all sorts of other things. And that advance is its definition of advance, Sarah. Come on. It's different from a page rate because it's one of the things like, how do you explain? The color of the sky is blue. Well, well, I'll give an example. So

like with a page rate, you know, I, when I was working on crashing at IDW, I would only get paid once the script was final and I thank you. per issue, right? So for an original graphic novel, does a writer or artist have to hit a certain amount of pages turned in before they get it? Do you pay a lump sum upfront in advance of the page that you go from there? How does that work? Yes, thank you. I'll compare it to a page rate to better define it, where a page rate is often given to creators doing single

issues. Sometimes in a company like C Comics or maybe Marvel, where the company is more just like built for that kind of rate uh someone on the creative team might be given a page rate for a graphic novel but it again it kind of depends on the creators and the type of book but anyway a page rate is where you're paid per page so you have a rate per page whether it's script uh art lettering, colors, whatever it is, and you get paid once you turn in that art or that

work, but as you turn it in. So you might be paid like five pages or 10 pages as you turn in the work. Again, differing depending on how each company is set up. And then in advance is more of a lump sum where you might be given like a quarter on signing, a quarter when half the script is delivered, another quarter when the other half is delivered, and then the final quarter when the full project is finished. Or again,

however the breakdown makes the most sense. So you are paid. you're paid in advance of turning in the work, but also in larger sums of money as the process unfolds. And for an original graphic novel, how long is that process? Typically three years, give or take. And that is not only because it can take longer to draw 120 pages, 200 pages, 250 pages, but it's all created. It has to be

final. around a year before the actual pub date or so because of the amount of time it takes to print, which can sometimes be six months. And then there's also some like promotional stuff that happens a year ahead of the book's pub date. So the bulk of the material you want be done for all of that. So in my experience, three years is like really good four to five years when you're getting up to those like 200 page books, 250

page books, five maybe a little excessive, but it takes a very long time to draw a graphic novel. It does. It takes a very long time to draw a graphic novel. I was I was on with uh Michael Walsh uh his episode's about to drop when you and I are recording and he was like as somebody who wrote and drew comics, it will take an artist five times as long to draw a 30 pages of story versus writing the 30 pages of story. Kind of

break it down. I think like typically, and this is super like generalizing the process, but like a writer might take two weeks to write a 20 page script. and an artist, it takes a month to draw a comic. So multiply that by five or more. So I know we're already like only a few minutes away from the time that I promised you I would keep it to, and we barely scratched the surface. Like there's so much more. But I've got three

questions I really want to ask you. One, what is the best advice you've ever received? Two, What is the best advice you think you can give to somebody starting out in editing for Kidlet? And then three, where do you see the opportunities in YA graphic novels? Oh, my gosh. That's one of those questions where I feel like I'll be in the shower later and like something will hit me. I'll be like, I wish I said that. We can just say, Matthew, we got to record again. I

need five more minutes. Yeah, a little. bonus section. The best advice I've ever gotten, honestly, as a writer, a friend of mine gave me this advice once and it really helped which was, you know, you can just write something that's fun. And I think sometimes it feels like as a writer, creative person, you want to like tackle that subject that feels really meaningful and like a deep maybe dark complicated complex kind of

way but sometimes you're like working on that thing and it just makes you kind of sad and so reminding yourself that you can just write something that's fun especially these days is I think very valuable Oh my gosh, someone interested in getting into editing this kind of, I'm going to do a couple of quick pieces advice. One would be read as much as you can in the industry. So read as many middle grade, YA graphic novels and novels

and prose novels and like whatever it is out there, don't limit yourself to one thing. Read very like widely, but become an expert in that specific area. and hopefully like be passionate about it because i think it's hard to to become an expert if you're not passionate about a thing although i bet it's but maybe a little more pain goes back to it's fun and then i'll also say don't be afraid to connect with the editors you

admire so the editors who create your favorite books i don't know follow them on social media message them say hey like I really like these books you edit. I'm interested in doing this kind of thing too, would just like love to connect. Don't expect anything from them, don't ask any of anything from them, but just like tell them why are there and like make your presence known. I've connected with quite a few, not only like aspiring editors, but writers and artists, colorists,

letterers just reaching out and saying like hey I love the stuff you work on and I'd really love to work on that too one day. Not even asking you for anything but that putting them on their rate my radar and maybe they write something that pops up and it does happen or even LinkedIn. Personally I don't use LinkedIn as much anymore but I've done my own like what? Me neither. Yeah, it's become I get notifications all the time and it's just I I'm scared of it now. I'm just like, no, no, no, leave me alone. Same, same.

But I did like I would or I like to say, you know, if you maybe try to connect with 50 people on LinkedIn and 10 people accept your connection and then maybe five respond to your connection, like those are pretty good odds of making a meaningful connection and is kind of worth. putting yourself out there. 50 people might be a lot. I was just a clean number. But when you connect, always be sure to say why. Don't just connect cold and

expect them to know something about you. Really put yourself out there by saying why you are making that connection. You never know what can come of it. I think it's really great advice. This is one of those things. Reach out to the people who are doing the kind of work you want to be doing. ask for, like I was always taught like ask for advice. Advice is cheap. People love giving you the benefit of what they've learned and to sort of like, be like, hey, avoid this mistake, avoid that mistake. Don't forget to do this. It costs you nothing. And as you say,

you get on people's radar. So I think it's wonderful advice. The last thing I just want to add super quick. aspiring editors is don't be afraid to find a job that's like adjacent to editing. You don't have to start out in editorial and a lot of editors don't like don't be afraid to apply to a marketing position, a publicity position, some other assistant position or or any position really like while getting as close to the thing you want to edit as possible because having that

experience is so beneficial in the editorial department and it's a good way to get your foot in the door and learn an adjacent skill that can only make you more valuable and more like uniquely qualified for it. I think it's incredibly good advice because I do feel like there's this this feeling of like this is the job I want and so therefore this is the only job I will go after the only job I will take and it's and you do sort of like well you you don't understand necessarily

yet how everything is connected to everything else and that it's going to benefit you getting relevant experience even if you don't even if it's not to the t the exact job description You want right now it may use it may get you there and you don't even realize it like I knew nothing about sales Sarah I was just like I was just a dude that slung comics in a shop Because I needed a job while I ran a theater company when I was 22 like I didn't know anything My off -broadway

job paid me sixteen thousand dollars a year. So I needed something and a director I worked with was like I've just started dating this guy who runs a comic shop, if you need something, part -time, and I was like, hell yeah, I do! Thank you! And then somebody was like, hey, they're hiring for a sales position at a publisher. I'm a writer. I want to write. I have no interest in being in sales or marketing. I was trained. I have my MFA in theater. But I was like, well, it's probably paying better than what I do at

this comic shop here, and I'll get to learn a lot more. So I faked it. I lied. so much upfront, Sarah. It's not even funny. Making it to you make it like could be a whole nother topic we should talk about one day because there's something to that that people don't talk about enough as like being a like gross or disingenuous way. But there's a real like skill there that doesn't have to be so taboo. But yeah, and then not to

mention, like as a creative person like also getting close to what you want to do creatively and learning another side of it like for you being a writer and knowing sale like comic book sales is super valuable for me you know being an editor and and gave me like a really really important perspective when pursuing writing i mean at the very least you learn what pitches do and don't get greenlit so i i learned formatting i learned what the keywords were i understood

Also, I understood that an editor has to sell this to the sales and marketing team. What in my pitch can I give you to help make that attractive to the team? Every time I pitch to an editor, I go, how am I going to make this editor's job easier to get this thing greenlit? That is always my goal. I would not have understood that had I not gotten an adjacent career path. to what it is I'm trained to do and is my first love.

So I love that advice. I think that's phenomenal. And then my last question to you before we wrap up here is sort of what are, to your mind, where do you see the gaps in the marketplace in terms of what is out there and what is in the pipeline? What are the stories that you feel like still have a place that we have not gotten the most out of in the YA space right now? That's such a good question. I'll start by saying I don't think there's ever enough romance in YA books,

comics or graphic novels. I think, not that there has to be, but I can personally never get enough of it and then whatever type of romance you want to tell, tell it. plug Boombox in particular because I think I'm really excited to be at Boom in general, but Boombox in particular I think has been the home for queer comics since its inception and I love that about the imprint and

we definitely want to continue in that wonderful tradition. I'm very happy to be inheriting that and I feel very um protective of it so so that's that's just a little plug for us there but so and whatever romance can't get enough and and then whatever like genre plus romance um i'm personally just like a contemporary romance kind of gal when it comes to young adult stories but

that's that's just me personally you know i love like anything Mariko Tamaki touches in that space. I think there's a lot of contemporary romance in YA novels, but the YA graphic novel market is still growing and hasn't quite exploded the way the middle grade graphic novel market has. But, um, you know, I think sometimes when you're doing a graphic novel, there's a feeling that

like there needs to be something unusual visually, but I think contemporary stories can still be told very effectively. Visually, you just have to tap into something a little different that you might in a prose novel. So there's that. The other thing I'll say that like, I'm not quite sure answers your question, but I want to explore it a little bit, which is that middle grade. graphic novels are huge, but it seems like the middle grade readers are going, the middle grade

graphic novel readers are going from middle grade graphic novels, your dogmans, your telgemeier, your big nate, investigators, like whatever, all those amazing books and they're aging up into manga, which is awesome. Manga is great. We love manga, but I'm personally wondering like how to keep them in American comics and graphic novels because there were in the industry is in this like really unusual position for the

first time in many decades where there are so many young graphic novel readers and we're just starting to watch them age up into other forms of literature so how to keep them in the American comics and graphic novel space is a question I've been chewing on and I think we're only just starting to like figure out a way to answer that question. I think the genre makes sense though

because what is so insanely great selling in manga? Romance. Romance is pretty amazing, right? All the boys love, girls love. titles out there that are really fantastic, what then do we not have a ton of when it comes to, you know, new adults and adults stuff in comics especially? Not a lot of romance. I mean, you've got your Chainsaw Man, you've got your Jojo's Bizarre Adventures, but that's also because of the animes that come in with it, right? So you have a media,

you have a media cheat with a lot of those manga especially, but for a lot of people that are just pure manga readers, it's romance. Like, and as you say, it's romance plus something, but romance and horror, like, which is another, that is something I want more out of the YA and middle grade space, quite frankly. Like, give me, give me some more, like, kids like horror. I don't know why we've gotten away from that idea that kids don't like to watch scary movies

that their parents don't want them to. My nibbling when they were like 12 told me that their favorite movie was Scream and American Psycho. Wow. Hardcore. Love yourself. Hope you're listening. I watched Scream around that same time and I was starved for life. Absolutely. And then you keep watching it, even though you're starved for life. That's part of the fun. Exactly. It's part of the rite

of passage. Darn it. As you transit. That's actually like, you know, part of these newer categories, like early reader as well on the younger side, quickly to find that's usually for ages seven to eight or so, or, or no, sorry. Seven, five to eight. I always heard it was like five to eight. Yeah. Yeah. I don't know why I said seven to eight, five to eight. Five to seven is what I mean. And then the new adult category on like the upper older side is I think when we've really only had like middle grade and young adult it

did get a little like crunchy as far as how um I think especially in comics and graphic novels actually because you can only get so spicy visually in like a visual medium and still have it be like appropriate for teens, but sort of having these like a slightly older, slightly younger category, like. I was saying in the beginning kind of leaves a little more room to explore some of that stuff and not feel so like boxed

in by the guidelines or the sort of quote unquote rules that a publisher might want to follow. But yeah, because like on the you know, I don't know, there's a lot of interesting stuff happening there that I think hasn't been. There hasn't been as big of a restraint in manga and manga and other types of stories like that. Specifically, we're talking about romance, comics and graphic novels. But I think the American industry is starting to have a little more space for those.

Agree. I agree wholeheartedly. It's interesting. It is. I agree. I think we're at a really interesting moment for comics in general, for the American you know, type of storytelling within this format. I think there's a lot of a lot of really exciting opportunity, quite frankly, right now. If you can get out there and seize it. There are so many ways to engage with comics and graphic novels these days that were not around when I was a

kid, even if we talk about webtoon, webcomics. people posting on social media and like all sorts of places to engage with the medium that it only makes room for more. And I think that's really exciting and it's a really exciting time to be a part of it. What a lovely note to transition off of. Sarah, first off though, before I let you go, I have two questions I ask every guest. One, how do you stay sane? and B, what is something

that you want to recommend? And then you and I have not even gotten into You Belong Here and what it was like to work with our artist in law. I know. We need a part two. I'll do a two part. We need a part two and a part three and a part four, I think, Sarah. So we'll definitely have a part two. But I want you to plug You Belong Here because it's absolutely gorgeous. It is a beautiful, beautiful coming of age story. I can absolutely tell your roots in New York. um what in in the island when you were in reading this um but please plug you belong here but then

the other two questions are again how do you stay sane what is your self -care regimen how dare you ask me this um okay i'll plug you belong here first you belong here contemporary young adult coming of age graphic novel i wrote illustrated by the incredible comparable morgan beam um can't say enough good things about her. honestly we could spend an hour talking about Morgan. she just to continue for another second longer she works traditionally with watercolor and it just

gives her works a gorgeous organic quality that I can't get enough of. but our book Like I said, it's called You Belong Here. It's about a senior in high school. It very much follows the main character, Essie Rosen, through all the fun, terrible, unexpected times of like being a senior in high school. the that like special time where you're you're on the precipice of adulthood but you haven't quite escaped your childhood yet

and figuring out where you belong while you're like where you belong and how you belong to your hometown and where you grew up and that helped raise you while also figuring out where you belong next so check it out it's available anywhere books and comics are sold great gift for your the high school senior in your life or the high school junior or just the nostalgic adult that's to remember the pains and pleasures of that time

period because there's graduation gift good graduation gift too Good graduation gift. Yep. What you'll be buying those people, dear listeners, is you'll be buying, oh, the places you'll go and you belong here. That's your two punch combo. I love that combo. Wow. That is so cool. It is. Oh, the places you go is like the most popular try in April. Yeah. Every year. Yeah. No, that makes so much

sense. It's incredible. I love the idea of those two things bundled together. That makes me actually happy. I'm pitching that to comic shop snippets. Please do. Yeah, that's great. I might do that as well. I'm going to steal that. Of course. Of course. Remember, disclaimer, I'm on here personally as Matthew, not as Matthew. So disregard that comment I said. I'll be pitching that to Matthew at Penguin Random House. Sure. You Belong Here is published by, for their, I mean, published graphic novel. I felt very lucky to work with them. And then your self -care regimen. I like

to dissociate in front of reality television. Does that count for some? Absolutely. I mean, honestly, often like writing feels like self -care for me. So I don't feel. like myself if I'm not writing or if I kind of fall out of my writing routine. Other self -care tips. Sunshine. I'm trying to like absorb more sunshine during the day. That really helps a lot. As it's getting dark at 4 p .m. Luckily I have four cats and

they love to go outside and we give them like supervised outside time, but it also helps me have supervised outside time. So it, it goes, we, me and the cats try to get out in the sun. One of my best friends is editor Heather Antos, who has also worked with Morgan a whole lot because she was, she was our editor on Crashing. But I asked her once and said, hey, bud, how many steps a day do you get? She's like, I get about 20 ,000 because I walk two dogs about two miles per day. And I was like, there is something to

having a pet forces you to get away from the desk at times, which is lovely. And then. And then my last question is, what's something people should be reading that they aren't currently? Graphic novel, novel, webcomic, manga, anything. What's a Sarah recommendation? Oh my gosh. Well, I talked about Mariko Tamaki. She doesn't need my plug just because her books are well loved and she's a huge success. But, you know, I always love to recommend This One Summer or Laura Dean

Keeps Breaking Up With Me. I actually think Laura Dean Keeps Breaking Up With Me is a perfect graphic. novel especially if you're interested in like young adult graphic novels but not even just that in that category alone just from beginning to end the writing the art the lettering the color the packaging like all of it together is in my opinion a perfect definition of a graphic novel so um i think that's a good recommendation coming out of this conversation if you haven't read it yet That and of course that's written

by Mariko Tamaki and drawn by Rosemary Valero O 'Connell who's uh having having read it yes go read this dear listeners it's phenomenal and then uh what what else should people be keeping a lookout for and where can they follow you on socials to stay up to date on all things for you Sarah? Yeah you can follow me on Instagram and TikTok at Sarah Phoebe s -a -r -a -p -h -o

-e -b -e -e, like a bumblebee. And I'm mostly on Instagram these days though, but trying not to be as much, and I am gonna be spending the holidays working on the second draft of a middle grade graphic novel I'm writing with a writing partner which is not officially announced yet, so I can't say too much about that but stay tuned for more details when that news drops very excited

about that and excited to be working on the working on book two. And otherwise, keep an eye out for all the exciting new books coming out from Boom, Boombox, and Kaboom. We've got, especially on the Boombox and Kaboom side, we've got early fun slate planned for fall 2026. So keep an eye out for the new books coming down the pipeline. Very exciting. Also, because I'll get yelled at if I don't ask this question, what are the

names of the cats? Thank you so much for asking. Mickey, Beyonce, Nora, and Grayson. Dear listeners, you can follow me at MatthewKline316 on Blue Sky, TikTok, and on Instagram at MacTheKnife1116. You can always support the show and help us continue to go and grow as we are entering year two of Comics4U at Patreon, patreon .com slash comics4u. And I am so honored, Sarah, thank you so much

for giving me so much of your time before you go out and dissociate in front of some reality TV as you very much deserve to do. This was great. You've got to come back. We have barely scratched the surface. Truly, I cannot wait. And dear listeners, I hope that you've learned a little bit more about why you belong here and why comics are, in fact, for you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Fave 5 - Christina Ward

    Nov 20, 202621 minAudio

    Superstar scribe and artist Christian Ward is back revealing his Fave 5 runs, artists, writers, Batman: The Animated Series episodes and dropping some insight on his influences. It's a great bit of insight into the mind...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 45: Joe Annabi - "Is It Fixable? Did We Lose Money?"

    Nov 11, 202656 minAudio

    Joe Annabi, manager of Golden Apple Comics in Los Angeles is here for the first of a two-parter! Joe talks about Marvel Midnight, Absolute Batman, and what else is selling in the shops. He also gets into what incentives...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 44: Spencer Cushing - "One Action Per Panel"

    Oct 25, 202650 minAudio

    Episode notes Senior Editor Spencer Cushing of Dark Horse Comics joins Matthew on this episode. Spencer deeps dive into his childhood love of Calvin & Hobbs, his fandom of Dungeons & Dragons assisting him with editing...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Fave 5 - Jorge Corona

    Oct 21, 202619 minAudio

    Time for more of your favorite comic creators' faves with superstar Jorge Corona! The current Lobo artist talks his favorite writers, artists, first reads to recommend, and Batman: The Animated Series eps. Make sure you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 43: Hive Mind - "We're Here To Haunt You"

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    From Hive Mind HQ Matthew is joined by the duo talk all things Dungeons & Dragons from Dark Horse Comics, You'll Never Leave This Place Alive from IDW Publishing, how they juggle eight different projects in different...

    Credit the people on this episode