Kat Calamia and Phil Falco join Matthew to discuss the ins and outs of crowdfunding comic books on Kickstarter. Hear how they forged a path as creators that essentially didn't exist and have successfully made over thirty campaigns for their LGBTQ+ titles! This is an amazing how-to guide for writers and artists looking to get their work off the ground. And check out their latest campaign for their new wholesome queer romance title Rainbow Canvas: Valentine's Annual 2025 - BL & GL Webtoons!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome, everybody. My name is Matthew Klein and we are once again having a brand new episode of Comics For You, the podcast that explores a new topic with a new guest about how comic books are made, marketed, and sold for you. I want to first say thank you to everyone that's listened, downloaded, liked, subscribed, and left a five-star review to our debut chat with Alex Segura. After we recorded, Alex actually got announced as the writer for the brand new Star Wars ongoing comic series coming out in May. So first and foremost, I want to give a big congratulations to Alex. And that solidifies we are absolutely going to invite him back for a future installment. If you haven't signed up for Patreon, either make sure you do and get the bonus content that you know what I may just be putting out there anyway called Off Panel. If you haven't listened to that main content though yet, please go check it out wherever you get your podcasts, Apple, Spotify, Google, all that good stuff. This week, we dive into the crowdfunding side of the comics market with guests Kat Calamia and Phil Falco. So through Lifeline Comics, their company, they currently run an average of two Kickstarter campaigns per month.That's insane. That's an incredible amount of work. You'll hear more about just how much work that is and how they try to stay sane with such a busy schedule. Their latest campaign, Rainbow Canvas, Valentine's Annual 2025, still has about two weeks left and is nearly 90% funded as I'm recording. So go back it ASAP. Make sure you are the one that gets them over that 100% funding line. It was a really cool chat. It was a really enlightening one about their journey, how they got into crowdfunding comics before it was a really viable path for creators to do so, all the lessons they've learned on how to run successful campaigns and what it's like now that so many creators are using that as a way to get published as opposed to going to a more traditional, more physical publisher routes that you would typically that I did with Crashing. So I really hope you dig this episode and if you do really dig it and want more, you can sign up for Patreon at patreon.com slash comics for you. And for as little as $1 per month, you can help this show go and grow. Please also take a moment, leave a five star rating and review. It makes a massive difference in choking the algorithm, kicking the algorithm over into our favor. I'm sorry, y'all, I'm having a trouble putting sentences together after three insane days in LA for Comics Pro, but we're here. We're making it happen. I'm so happy you're here. As always, though, I want to give a very quick disclaimer. While my day job is selling comics to hundreds of comic book shops for Penguin Random House, the opinions on this show are wholly my own and do not reflect PRH at all. All right, let's roll up our sleeves and dive into what it's like crowdfunding comics with Kat Kalamia and Phil Falco.
Phil Falco, Kat Kalamia. Is it Kalamia? Kalamia, how do you? It's Kalamia. It's Kalamia. Yeah. Oh, wow. Wow. I really started the episode off just just sinking myself here. She's heard worse. Don't worry. I've heard Kalamari. Kalamia was pretty bad. Oh, that's not bad. Oh, I was like, that's not it. Like you're adding a lot of letters on that one. Yeah, I don't even see where that the correlation. Your pronunciation at least had all the same letters. I did.
I tried. I really tried. I get Matthew Clean a lot, a lot of which is fascinating because my last name is spelled exactly like Calvin Klein, but nobody calls me Klein at all. It's always Mr. Clean, how are you? And I'm like, let me keep my hair for a little while longer. I don't need that comparison. You should maybe do a different job and start getting into the cleaning business. I'll say that someone named Brawny. Oh, very nice. Brawny would be great.
Me and Mr. Windex will be partnering up. Well, now that we've started on that note, thank you both so much for coming on. This is Comics for You. This is the podcast all about making, selling, marketing comics for you dear listeners. I am so excited. You two are inspirations to me for what you have built for yourselves. It is something that I am absolutely trying to emulate with a project like what we're doing right here. So thank you for being an inspiration to people trying to build a brand like myself. No, I think a lot.
So let me get into sort of your origin stories a little bit. So we're here today to talk a lot about your crowdfunding campaigns and the methodology and the wonderful path for creators that have. Because it used to just be, OK, you're stuck waiting for a rejection letter from a publisher. But now I feel like there's so many avenues and so many ways to make and get your work out there and build a following. And I really feel like you two have perfected the blueprint to do that. So Phil, let's start with you.
What was sort of your origin story into the world of making comics? I was a lifelong comic fan I've been reading since regularly since high school. And then I started dipping my toes in in middle school. And I always really loved writing. I did mostly prose writing in high school and college and a number of classes on that and didn't actually get into comics until 2020. I published my first book on Kickstarter and largely this will segue into Kat's origin story largely because Kat and I were already friends, completely divorced from comics.
But I was a fan of her books like Follow Like Daughter and The Dancer at the time. And I saw how she was publishing through Kickstarter at the time, working with a publisher and told her how much like, you know, I really love comics, I love writing, I'd love to get into that. And she was like, oh, you should do it. And that little push was all I needed. And then we could talk more about our actual partnership after, but I'll let Kat do her origin story. Yeah, no. I started writing comics and publishing comics in college.
I wrote a screenplay that was a superhero screenplay. I really liked it. And then I was doing comic reviews at the time. I still do comic reviews on my YouTube channel, Comic Uno. And I was like, let me try finding an artist. Like, that's where you have to at least start. So I made a video and the publisher I worked with for like five years saw the video and said, hey, do you want to work together? And they taught me a lot about how to make comics. In the long run, I wanted to do independent stuff. And we went separate ways, but you know, still love them and love what we ended up doing
there with Short Fuse Media. Yeah, I made like Polly Daughter and The Dancer through them. And then I started doing my own thing. And that was around the time Phil was starting to make comics. So we'll go to... We kind of ping ponged a little bit there where, you know, Kat was working with Short Fuse and then I, without a publisher, did my first comic. And then, you know, we kind of compared notes. And that was around the time that Kat was starting to kind of branch off onto her own too. So we kind of got to learn a lot from each other at the time and figure things out together. Going into like how we started to work together more regularly.
Like I said, we were always friends, but it all started with just a simple one shot, a crossover between our two biggest books at the time, My Book Hunting. Much near our audiences, you know, as a marketing thing, but also like that could be fun when you like each other's writing. Yeah, and it started as a joke. We were at like a Halloween party, like virtually because it was during COVID. Everyone was wearing costumes and we were like, I would be fun. What were you dressed as? What was your costumes? I was the big bad wolf grandma. So she had like the little outfit on and the wolf ears and all that.
I was Jenna Marbles, I think. Nice. That's how long ago it was. Anyway, we were just kind of like joking around like, oh, what would this look like? And then we had already been planning when conventions started back up to table together. We were like, oh, it'd be really cool if right in the middle is like a crossover book so that like someone could support both of us. And it was probably the easiest thing we'd ever written, collective, like individually, because we found we worked together really well and we really loved the story. And we just never stopped working together after that. We put together Slice of Life after that, our webtoon.
We wanted to do a webtoon either way. So we were like, oh, wouldn't it be fun to work together? And then that did really well. And we're like, oh, and I think all around that time, Bivisibility was happening too. So that did really, really well. That changed both of our careers because before like our highest was probably 500 backers. And I think that was the crossover. And then Bivisibility got over a thousand backers, a lot of people's eyes. And I was like, okay, that's kind of cool that that happened. From there, Slice of Life came right after and a lot of people came from Bivisibility
to Slice of Life. So it's the snowball effect really. The more you do, the more people find you, especially when you're doing different things. And it helps being two people. It does, and sometimes that doesn't even feel like enough. That's true. How many people are involved on any given campaign that you're doing? Honestly, two to three. So it's me and Phil, making the campaign, the actual page, me and Phil, and then his brother helps us put rewards and add-ons and does a lot of the copy and pasting stuff that
we don't have time for. But that's kind of it. We really do it all ourselves. So you're doing the videos, you're doing the graphics for it, you're doing the descriptions, everything of that. That's all YouTube. The graphics I'll give Brant to, but we've kind of brought it all down where it's just headers now. We used to have big, big graphics, but Brant got all of those headers. I'm not an artist, but I do a lot of the little design things, like making the little reward images and the bigger graphics on the page. And then we use Brant for anything that requires more talent than I possess.
And then on the fulfillment side, when we're actually shipping out our books, we have more people involved in that. We have family and friends who kind of round out our team. But in terms of actually building the page, like Kat said, it's she and I driving it, my brother doing some of the helping, copying, paste grunt work and working with our different designers where necessary. I mean, when I was looking it up and doing a little research on your Kickstarter profile, Kat, I saw that you had started 31 campaigns. Isn't that crazy?
And that's not even all of them because the Short Fuse Media campaigns, issues one through four of I Follow Your Daughter were not on my page. And the trade, right? And the trade were not on my page. And I don't think we ever did a dancer campaign. So four of five projects were not on my page and they were on their page. For somebody doing their very first crowdfunding campaign, what are sort of the birds and bees that you would sort of tell them right up front in terms of building the collaboration, figuring out what the project is going to be and sort of the timeline that you would
have for putting it together, promoting it and fulfilling? That's a lot I just thank you. So we'll take it in pieces and everything. But sort of what was behind the inspiration for you two deciding, okay, now is the time for us to do our first crowdfunding campaign? For me, it was the only way I knew how to make a comic. And that was even like Kickstarter comics was not even popular when I was doing it. It was 2000 and 15, 16, 16, 16, because we graduated in 16. I want to say it's 1514.
It's like 2015 14. No one was really doing this. So I did it because Veronica Mars said like a Kickstarter, I was like, oh, they made money through it. So why not just try this thing? And then it made enough money where I was able to make this book possible. So I was like, okay, that's kind of cool. And back then, I thought it was just a stepping stone to make a comic to like eventually work at Marvel or DC or like making a pitch a book or whatever. And I didn't realize it could be a thing where you could make money. And then as time went on, especially when we started working together, you know, like
probably daughter was making money, but more through conventions and more through like the aftermath of Kickstarter, like Kickstarter at the time was just paying for the book. Since we started working together, we figured out how to make profits off of Kickstarter and also like make that move and also building an audience. I think, you know, at the time, I don't think that there was much thought about like, you know, organic growth through Kickstarter, finding your readers through there. I think a lot of people at the time were looking at it like, oh, this is where I'll raise money. Like you said, got to kind of take it somewhere else. But there's a whole ecosystem that you can find through Kickstarter.
And then also, you know, you can craft your own audience. You collect all the people that you meet at conventions or, you know, from previous Kickstarter and they kind of just become your audience who continuously will come back for you. It's very much like an organic thing that kind of built itself, which is really cool. And again, we didn't really have a history of anyone else doing it besides Pat Chand. Honestly, I was the only person who was doing it to the extent we were doing it. And, you know, obviously the other players too, that just don't do as frequently, but like Charlie Stickney or Grant Bowler, like they all do like projects and they had big
projects, but like not to the consistency we were doing. Honestly, the only other person we had was Pat. And we exchanged notes because we were the only two people who were just like doing it to the extent we're doing it. Yeah, that was also interesting. There was no map and that's something that we really wanted to do. And what we do with like our newsletter is that we always want to be helpful to people. And like, and why we do a podcast like this is that like we want to give you the rulebook. Like it's not a secret. So what are some of the lessons that you really took from those first couple campaigns that
you were like, ah, okay, we make this tweak. If we, is it time of year or was it the reward tier? Don't be scared of December and January. I think that was something that we learned really quickly was that those months, there's total fables of being like, they're the worst months. And honestly, some of our best campaigns come from there. And a lot of people say like October is the best month, but for the past three or four years that's always been our worst month. And most people say it's their worst month. So that's interesting. What is your best month?
January. Yeah, we do a lot of yearbooks. So June is probably big for us. Advice for people making a campaign at the most simple level, there's no overstating the importance of your title, your subheader and your thumbnail. That's the first thing anyone's going to see if they decide to click on it. So engaging thumbnail, put your buzzwords in your title, use different words in your subheader. I've seen, you know, books that have the same title and subheader, which is just not telling anything new. Same thumbnail across projects. That's one of my one of my biggest pet peeves where it's like, oh, this is your opportunity
to show something different. Maybe someone wouldn't have clicked your first thumbnail, but then something in the second thumbnail, different art style, different background, different situation attracts them. And then also this goes beyond your first campaign, obviously, but each new issue, you know, try something a little different. This was something that took us a few years to figure out. I'll use my horror book as an example. I used pretty much the same subheader for the first three or four issues. It was always just like haunting a supernatural horror comic, maybe like one or two words differed. And then in like issue five or six, I was just like, oh, let me throw like zombie into
the title because the book always had zombies, but I always emphasize the ghost angle on Kickstarter. And then I got a whole bunch of people are like, oh, I love zombie comics. And I'm just like, oh, one one little word can attract and I've had zombies in the thumbnail for that cover for that Kickstarter. Excuse me. And it's just like every new campaign is a new opportunity to sell your book to both your existing audience to reengage them, but also to new people. Something we learned from, we were just like practicing yesterday. We're doing a new campaign like mid January. I think we, we announced it's a little mermaid and we're doing a safe for work version and
a not safe for work version. So all day yesterday, me and Philip figuring out how do you make the rewards not confusing because you have a lot of repeated rewards because they're the same, maybe a different variant cover, but it's the safe for work version. But you know, there's like, you're going to copy and paste your, the similar reward like six times. You're like, that's confusing. So what we did was we're like, well, how would an audience member look at this? We pretended like we weren't the creators. You're like, how do you make this the least confusing as possible? And it's something that I think a lot of new creators don't do to make, not even to the
rewards because again, ours is a special case of how confusing it can be. Even just the writing where people are like, oh, you know who I am. Like I don't know who you are. Tell me who you are. Tell me your story. Tell me your pitch. Pretend like no one has ever heard of you because most likely no one has even, you know, us who has a big Kickstarter audience. There's definitely people who find us for the first time. I saw somebody, we did like a survey and somebody said that they found us through League of Comic Geeks and we're like, they found us through there and they're like, I don't want to support Kickstarters, but I'm like, want to support your website.
Can you make it easier to tell us when your new releases are on the website? And I was like, oh, I didn't even think about that because that was just like, I think about like the Kickstarter audience more, but you finding us through League of Comic Geeks and then going to the website, then liking a book from there is interesting. Well I'm also curious, Kat, how big of a benefit was the YouTube channel for you in terms of establishing yourself and helping build and find that audience? Because you're at what? You're over 5,000 videos now on Comic Uno. You have over 18,000 followers that you've built up over the years.
You're still posting weekly at least. Was that another sort of tool in the toolbox that you had to help with it or did you not see as much crossover initially? There is, but like the people, like if I'm reviewing a Marvel OBC, a lot of them are not going to convert to our audience, but I've seen them. I remember I was doing a review for something and this person said, oh, I really like the Yuriko doll, which is a character from Slice of Light. And they just thought I was a fan of the comic. And then they later found out, I'm so stupid.
You're the creator of that comic? That's so good. Yeah, I am. And they were like, oh my God, I can't believe it. And I was like, oh, that's funny. I'll say for the YouTube channel, the top 10 Kickstarters has been so tremendous. I go to shows and there is not one show I go to where people are not mentioning, oh, you shouted me out or like, wow, I found a new favorite Kickstarter because of that. This is such a valuable tool. Yeah, I don't know if the weekly Marvel DC reviews is always the most perversion, but also we've gotten some great cover artists because of it.
I don't think we would have made a predisposition more if I didn't talk about comics. Yeah, exactly. Like all those people because of the comic reviews. Gail Simone? Gail Simone is another great one, yeah, who wrote a forward for one of our anthologies. I think everything cumulatively contributes obviously to success. And I think a big part is just engaging with the community. I think to use myself as an example, I wasn't really very active on social media before I started making comics. And Kat was like, you got to get on. Kat, who's been on YouTube for 15 years or however long was like, you got to get on Twitter
at the time. Now Twitter is obviously what it is, but you got to get on Twitter. Loots guy. Loots guy. And now we're on that. We're on to the happier place. We're on to the Loots guy retroactively. But you have to be on social media. You have to talk about, when you read a book that you like, talk about it. Talk about your own books and engage in the community. And a lot of people, if they don't already have an active platform, whether that's a social media platform or YouTube channel, are a little resistant to that. They're like, oh no, my idea will sell by itself, but that doesn't really happen. But how does anyone find that idea? How does everybody, yeah. So working on the distribution side, there are so many great books out there that no
one will ever buy because no one ever hears about. And it has nothing to do with the quality. It has everything to do with the ways that you message things out. So I wonder for a campaign, because what a Kickstarter campaign lasts about 30 days, is it still 30 days? And you have to hit your funding goal otherwise you don't get any of the cash. What have you found to be the most successful in terms of scheduling messaging during the campaign, before the campaign? How early before do you announce it?
What is your posting schedule like before and during a campaign? That's so tough because I think for us, who has a built-in audience, it's different than someone who doesn't. And we also do the monthly launches. So we have a more condensed schedule. Ours is, we usually will announce a pre-launch page, like a follow page for the campaign two weeks before. And then we kind of spread out promotion throughout. We'll do a big email blast on launch day and then we'll update related projects. So if it's an issue six, we'll update the last three issues on those individual projects,
spread out, and then somewhat tangentially related projects. So that way, the mid-campaign always has little plugs going in. And then we'll do another big push at the end, is our model. But like Kat said, if starting out, I think we have a longer pre-launch period for our projects because we need to have us pack the schedule. You want to get that follow count as high as you can. You want to build excitement. I'm sure there is a sweet spot because you also don't want it to become old news by the time you launch. Well, that's an issue too. I see people promoting their Kickstarter six months in advance and then it launches. I'm like, this didn't...
I forgot all about it. Yeah. Or I thought it would have launched already. I'm like, oh, I already know about that project. Or yeah, there's so many different reasons not to do that. I think a sweet spot for a new creator, the longest I'd ever go is a month. I even think that's too long, but I think a month is the longest I'd go. I think two to four weeks is probably where I would land. I think for a first ever project, maybe three weeks is a good sweet spot. Try to share it in different places. We'll share books on Reddit and you will hit different people on Reddit, like particular
subreddits on Facebook groups that relate to a particular property or a particular concept that this book revolves around. Then obviously just a general posting on our profile on Instagram or Blue Sky or threads or whatever. Just put it in as many places as you can and use those few weeks before you launch to get people primed for the book. When it actually launches, treat your launch day like an event. Try to really explode everywhere and be like, oh, this is live now. You can finally get it. I know you're excited. Also use your time to support other people's KickStars and talk about them. I was about to ask.
Yeah. Yeah. Because so many people say, oh, I went on social media, I did Blue Sky, nothing worked. I'm like, because no one knows you. So you probably have no engagement. But if you interact with other people, then you're going to get a little bit more engagement. One of the things that I've heard when I've done previous research into Kickstarter projects, I've run a couple of them for audio dramas, but never for comics yet. Dear listeners, stay with me. But I was curious about the perception out there that after you hit your funding goal,
you actually get a bigger swath of people because they know that the project is going to come to fruition. So it doesn't feel like a risk anymore. Have you found that to be the case? Do you set your funding goals as something that's attainable that you can hit really fast to build consumer confidence, but also to help spike the algorithm in terms of awareness? Or do you have a very, your funding goals vary sort of like, nope, this is exactly what it costs to make the book and what have you. For us, it's exactly what it costs because I think it also gets hard to stretch goals
because you also don't want to be like, oh, here's all these stretch goals and you can't afford them. We don't want to give willy nilly stretch goals when we haven't even paid for the book. I see where people are coming from there because yeah, people want to know that that book's happening, especially if you're a newer creator. Yeah, I think it's a sweet spot for sure because you also see if you're really close to a funding goal, people want to push you over that edge. Sure. I think like Kat said, I think there is a sweet spot because I do think there are people have been burned by Kickstarter creators who are bad faith actors in the past.
It's hard to rely on just someone's word if they don't have a track record. For a first project, first of all, don't make your first project like a graphic novel. So many people want to jump right to their OGN right away instead of doing single issues and collecting them later. Do a single issue so it's cheaper and affordable. Try to estimate what your actual budget is and then have a dialogue with yourself about what is a realistic goal. I can only speak from my own experience. My first project was probably one of the only projects or the only project that I set a
lower goal than I actually needed because I wanted to make sure that I could reach it. From there, we built our audience with each issue. You had a big issue one because let's also add that you had it during the pandemic when complex stores were not... I launched, right when comic book stores closed. For perfect timing. It was the only good thing to come out of the pandemic because a lot of people were coming to Kickstarter because they're like, oh, I usually read comics. Let me back something. That helped me have a really good launch. I was very thankful for that one bright spot of an otherwise difficult time.
In terms of setting your goal, I set a goal that covered the bulk of my costs but didn't cover everything and I was able to hit it and then make back the loss on that first issue over the next two issues. Everyone has a different model. I think you just have to be realistic with yourself. Look at similar projects. Always study the market. If you're planning a campaign, I would look at Kickstarter daily or at least weekly for a few months leading up and see this is the first project from someone who doesn't have a profile.
How is it doing? Back those projects too. Oh, and back them. Right. No, back them. I can talk about them on social media. Like connect with your- Build the community. Right? Yeah. Help build the community and become part of the community so that the community is like, oh, they're not just here to make the money and run. They actually are involved in all this. You talked about the starting of the single issue as opposed to starting with a larger cost project like an OGN. Have you found a sweet spot for the pricing for single issues?
For example, on Kickstarter, there are lots of different price tiers that you can do anywhere from a dollar to however many. But generally speaking, when I was doing some research on this, there was always a recommendation that there's one particular tier that is the sweet spot that you want the most. You're expecting the most amount of backers to hit. You have to be very mindful of what that tier pricing is going to be. For single issues, have you figured out what that pricing really is? I'll say I don't think that there's a one-shot answer. I've seen people price at different levels.
I think obviously your page count, your budget in terms of how expensive is it to put together your book with your art, your colors, your lettering, et cetera. We typically for a 22 to 24 page book will price it at $10 for a new issue. There'll be some variability. We do some books that are 40 pages, some books that are 60 pages, some books that are- And you're getting digital content. Because I know if you're a direct market person, that's like 10 bucks for a 20-some page book. That sounds crazy. That's just about to say, yeah. Yeah. But the reason why, obviously you're helping our Kickstarter, but what we like to do is
that you're getting other stuff with it. If you're getting the physical book, you get the digital book. You're getting digital prints. You're getting free independent comics from other people. You're getting $10 worth of stuff. We're not just making it $10. Any stretch calls as well, which often include art prints, additional comics, et cetera. In terms of a sweet spot, quote unquote, or an average pledge, yeah, I think usually when you're first starting out, you probably want to aim for your physical tier because that's a moneymaker, but not too high.
Then as you establish yourself a little more, you might set something a little higher where maybe it's your book plus a sticker, or your book plus some trading cards, or a variant cover that you price at a particular level. We saw a gradual increase in our average pledge over time. In the beginning, our most popular pledge would be just your cover A, which did say- It was like $12 or $15, I want to say, was our average pledge. Exactly. It goes up over time as you work with bigger artists, artists who have very big followings that come out for them, or as you develop an audience that has a hunger for the more
premium items that want the things you add to your library. A good example, we just added acrylic standees. That was something we never sold before. We have a bunch of enamel pins. They're not cheap, our enamel pins. No, they're not. The only nice thing about... I won't say the only nice thing. I'll say one of the nice things about them is that they don't take up as much space as comics do. Sure. As we built up our library, it's nice having a little corner and then comics are the rest of the room. The more you make, the cheaper they get. That's true. You get that price break.
In terms of reward tiers, have you figured out how many rewards is too many rewards to offer? Because I look at somebody like Ryan Brown, right? Ryan Brown, it feels like has 20 different rewards per campaign and they're all the craziest sort of things. Like, oh, I will print this version upside down. There's all sorts of fun things. But for you, what if you feel like you have found a good amount of rewards and a good variety of them? What would that be? It really depends on the product. Is there a sweet spot? I don't know.
I'll say yesterday, like Kat said earlier, we had a big discussion about rewards because for our Little Mermaid book, it was like, oh, we have all these safe and not safe versions. We ended up probably just going in the direction of like, oh, we're just going to list the tiers twice and in the survey they can pick which version they want. So that cut out half the rewards that helped. But then you want to make sure you have creative tiers. So if you have an issue two, you want to make sure that people can catch up on your book physically and digitally. And also, we like to do a variant catch up where it's like our most popular variant for issue one, what you anticipate will be the most popular for issue two.
Those always tend to do really well. I'll say I think most of our campaigns right now have probably in the like mid-20 number of tiers. But then some of them will go up over 30 a little bit. And most of those are like shared universe books. We have our ever after verse where there's like three soon to be four titles that are all taking place in it. Those tend to have more tiers just because there's more options to catch up on the other books because we always want to get fans of one book into the other book. So I also imagine there's a value perception there for somebody pledging to write.
You're getting a lot of content for your pledge to that into because you talked about sort of like the digital bundle with other creators books. How did that come about? Because I love that aspect of your campaigns. I know that it's been adopted a little bit more. But how did you first stumble upon being able to do that? I don't remember the first time we did it. But I know other people. It's not like we didn't create it. So we other people are doing it, people ask for our books or like, oh, yeah, this is a great idea because then you get to give your kickstart backers who already like Kickstarter
an opportunity to read other people's books. So honestly, just like, yeah, maybe one of the most brilliant natural conventions that has kind of like popped up in in indie comics because it doesn't cost a creator anything to give a digital copy of their book. We've had people like when we'll talk about collecting books for an indie bundle, sometimes you'll have people to be like, oh, you want to just take my book for free? That's wrong. I understand that perspective because like historically, you know, people are very afraid of being exploited ourselves in entertainment because it's also hard to say and Lenny agrees
my dog is going crazy today. You explain why I put her somewhere else. I don't actually know what Kat was going to say in that instance. But I was going to say it's hard to explain that we're not actually making money off of it because you make it a dollar because you have to but you're not actually making money off of it. Every backer for as low as a dollar gets like the whole bundle of books. So sure. You get like 10, 12 books for a dollar, which is incredible. Yeah. The goal is never to profit off of other people's book. It's to give more value to the backer while also giving them books that they can check
out that also probably will crowdfund on Kickstarter or release through some other indie avenue that you could check out. And like Kat said, we love to give our books to other people's indie bundles as well. We think we're very happy that it's something that's caught on over time that more people are doing because it really does benefit everyone. The person giving the book, the reader who gets more content, and the person who's running the campaign because they get to get more content. I think it's absolutely tremendous. And from a community building standpoint, from, as you say, getting exposure to other people's audiences that maybe are like, oh, this is a really good issue.
I've never heard of it. Do they have their own campaign or how can I go get their book? Like everybody wins. And it's really good faith relationship building, it feels like. And so many people have contacted us and said, oh my God, people came to me and said, your campaign helped bring eyes to my book. That's what we want to do. That's what us getting into the industry, we didn't know how to do it. Because that's the whole point we did Kickstarter is like, well, we don't know how to get into the floodgates. Let's do it ourselves. And we want Kickstarter to not be a place where people feel like they can't break in.
Let's give opportunities to people to make it a little easier. And that's across everything. We just try to tell people about great books that way it could be on people's radars now that we have an audience to do so. In 2014, 2015, there weren't that many people in the space who were going really hard on crowdfunding and saying, no, no, no, this is, we're not trying to get published by Marvel and DC. We are going to make our career here through crowdfunding and brand building and DIY it. As you see more and more and more creators entering the space, on the physical retail
side, there's always the worry about over saturation. Too many books, too many publishers, too many choices on a given Wednesday, right? For people, because their budgets don't go up, but the amount of choices that they have do. Have you ever had concerns about that in the space as more and more and more people are crowding it? Tough questions. I think yes and no, right? I think I was going to say I'm of two minds there because I think most, not most, I shouldn't speak for everyone. I'll say I think our findings and one that we've heard repeatedly in the community is
that like, oh, it's tougher right now than it was a couple of years ago. A million macroeconomic reasons why that could be. One of it could be an explosion in the number of available projects. I think at any given time, there's probably hundreds of projects now compared to dozens a couple of years ago. Or social media is very different than it used to be. Social media is incredible. Yeah, maybe you're not getting the reach. The algorithm isn't highlighting the content as much as anymore. Economically, we're not in a great place right now. There's a million different factors.
I wouldn't categorically rule out more cooks in the kitchen means that the general average pledge will go down or the consumer dollars will get spread out a little more. This was our best year yet. We've only grown. Again, I know that's not for everybody, but we've been doing pretty well. I think though that you brought up really good points earlier and it's something that I've seen with people who stick with it. Even if your first campaign doesn't do amazing, do the second, do a third, do a fourth.
It's like compound interest. The more you do, the more you put in over time, the more return you get on the investment. But you've got to have a plan. I always think of it as like, I don't plan on doing one Kickstarter. I plan on doing five Kickstarters. That's actually how I will plan out the entirety of the project is to look at it not as one campaign but five campaigns. That's 100% the right way to do it. Like I said, my first project was a loss. My second project I think was exactly breakeven, so I was still carrying a loss.
I want to say you had like 100 backers. You had more. It was right below 200. I had exactly 100 backers for my first campaign. Yeah. Obviously, you were also working with a publisher at the time. There was a lot of slices of the pie that had to go out. We weren't getting anywhere near the numbers we are now, but you just build your audience. You find new people each time. You work with other people too. You like the anthologies we've done as health. Let's interact with people. No, that's a very good point.
I think connecting with other people either just organically through at conventions or on social media when you talk about their books or back their books, but also actual partnerships. Kat and I did a crossover book, which was obviously a lot of effort like any project is, but at a micro level, if a friend of yours has a project live at the same time and you think there's overlapping audiences, coordinate a print that backers get if they support both projects. I love that. That's been really valuable for us working with other people. Mr. Kanekai and Tart just did their trading card unique Kickstarter.
They have such cool audiences and such loyal audiences. I can only imagine how well that did for both their audiences. Get creative. Don't be afraid to get creative because there's a million different ways you could collaborate with someone. You could do digitally. I know early on with a friend of ours, I think we did an initiative where we had two campaigns live and we were like, oh, if you back both of them, we'll give you two free digital comics that are unrelated to this from our libraries. Again, it goes back to digital costs nothing and it makes people feel like they're getting more for their backing, but also you might get people into another book that's completely
unrelated. There's a million different ways that you can engage people to work with your peers to check out multiple projects and become fans of multiple projects. I'm curious when you were first starting out and how has it evolved to presently in terms of were you paying the artists and colorists and letters upfront before the project went live or was it strictly profit sharing? Do you still do a version of profit sharing or are you now at a point where you just pay creators their upfront fees? How on the back end do you sort of divvy up those costs for getting the books made?
We always did, here's the money you asked for, here it is. Especially when we started too, we always finished the book before and now we still do too, but sometimes you have lettering or coloring that you have to do while we have such a strong production schedule. We always had those books really, really completed done, literally mostly printed at that point because we were just starting so we wanted to make sure like, hey, look, you can trust us. Yeah, we did the upfront payments. That's just A, we saved to have the capital to do that at the time and reinvested what
we would make on the existing projects, but B, that's just at the end of the day, it's a comfort thing. That's how we prefer to operate. We're already two people kind of collaborating, so it helps us to kind of have a set budget rather than having to do the profit sharing. And when we have a big campaign, we do profit sharing, but our first ever afterverse campaign, Beast in Snow, made probably like four times what we thought it would make. So we made stretch goals to build in, that way we would pay her more. That's how I would categorize more profit sharing.
And then also with our anthologies, the same thing, when Transphoria, our most recent anthology, did really well and we had like two stretch goals to pay the whole team more. That way you can profit share success, encourage everyone who contributes to continue sharing and get excited about doing well without the scary, oh, you get paid if it does well on the backend from the set. That way you're guaranteed a payment and then hopefully you get more if it does well. I understand the other way too. I get why people do it. Because I mean, you're talking what? Let's for argument's sake say your artist is $100 a page, your colorist is $70 a page,
your letter is, if you can get them $15 a page, 22 pages, what? That's $2,200 for the art alone. I mean, you're talking about roughly- It could be $5,000. Yeah, $5,000 to $6,000 with a small print run. And that's without printing costs. That's without the printing art prints or stickers that's before shipping. That's not even including if you don't have an editor for the entire project. The editor is a whole other cost to it.
Assuming you're only one writer and you don't find that you're getting paid at all. Absolutely. Yeah, that's right. If the writer forgoes payment, because you are the writer, I'm writing this if I was making a project. So that's a lot of capital to put up front and to say, okay, my first campaign, my goal is 10 grand when I'm nobody and I don't have a following yet. That's a really scary sort of financial risk that you are putting into that first campaign. Yeah, I will say if you have no audience and never done anything, I don't think I'll ever,
ever, ever suggest a 10K campaign. Right, exactly. What would you suggest for somebody in that situation? Would you do a thousand, two thousand? I would do a little higher, I'd do like 2,500. That way you're making money off of it, but you'll probably fund. You want to be really crazy. You really want to make your money back and the book looks great. You have a good Kickstarter page, maybe 4,000, but now even these days, honestly, it's very hard to make that. I'd say 2.5 is probably what I do. Well, that's assuming too, you're working with an artist that maybe has a following
maybe, you know, and those artists are going to cost more per page. They're going to build, they're going to, you make it bigger returns, but you also have a bigger expense coming out of it. The math is tough sometimes. And there's a million different setups that you could use. Like we said, we prefer kind of the more traditional, like, you know, agree to the rate and pay it out beforehand. But like plenty of our friends, I have like more of a direct partnership where, you know, writer artists co-own a property and they engage in profit sharing in whatever form
that is, whether it's 50-50, you know, 60-40, 70-30, et cetera, et cetera. So there's no one way to do it, especially- Much easier if you're one writer. Exactly. So yeah, there's no right way to do it. I think whatever works for you makes sense. Just be realistic. Do you see it thrown around a lot? Like, oh, when this turns a profit, everyone will make money, but like there's no guarantees of anything. So I think if you go in with like, all right, we're going to set a realistic goal. And the goal is, you know, maybe we'll turn up, maybe this first one will blow up. It's unlikely, but we can always hope for that.
But then like if it's successful, people like it, maybe the next one will blow up or the one after. And eventually you'll get to that point. But I think as long as you're not going in with very unrealistic expectations and everybody who's involved is prepared for that, you know, there's no wrong way to do it. I've had clients who are like, I'm going to sell like a hundred thousand comics, right? I'm like, oh, what are you, Spider-Man? He's so convinced by it too. He's like, I'm going to show you. And I'm like, okay, show me. She's had clients who are like, oh, I'll buy a comic printer to print all the books that I'm going to print.
And she's like, maybe like make a comic first and then you can buy a comic printer. Or don't do it at all. I mean, one idea that I've had while you were, you know, because you talked about the conventions also, but like being able to make a certain amount of money from the crowdfunding campaign, but then be tabling at events and have a different version maybe that you can sell there to help get those costs back on the first one or two, where maybe you are going to take a loss on the Kickstarter campaign, but finding those ways outside of it to make up on the backend.
Because once the book's made, the book's made. I was curious too with timing, because you had mentioned before when you were starting out the books would basically be done. And that's something that I've heard also as a sort of a recommendation so you could fulfill as quickly as possible. For someone starting out, how fast would you recommend being able to fulfill once the Kickstarter is over and it's met its goal and you're ready to go? Is there a timeframe that it's like any later than this, you're in trouble? For your first campaign- I wouldn't do a year. I was going to say six months, I think would be my cap because I think if I'm a backer
looking at you've never made a campaign and it's more than six months away, I'm like, I don't know if I'm ever going to get this. I think if I was transported back in time, I think four months would be my sweet spot where it's enough time for things to go wrong because things will go wrong. There's always delays. You have to figure out how to ship. Fulfilling a Kickstarter is its own- Talk to me about that. Oh God, I know we're going to be running up on time. We're going to have to come back and do a part two. What are the fulfilling operations for you two? Oh my God.
We'll talk about what it was in the beginning. Sure. In the beginning, Kat used to like to say, oh, I sit at my kitchen table. I copy and I buy it. I walk over to my printer, I print it out, I come back, I pack this package and then I start over again. It was my exercise. It was your exercise. Now we have campaigns that have over a thousand backers and packages to send out. We have campaigns that we do twice a month. Multiple campaigns. We've had to make more of a actual operation out of it where we have our team who comes in and helps us out and we're still drowning with it a little bit.
It's tough, but going back- Every week we're discussing, yeah, we're discussing, all right, how do we streamline this? How do we streamline this? And making sure you have all the materials you need, bags and boards, your label printer, your Gemini mailers, et cetera, et cetera, your bigger boxes for packages that don't fit in the Gemini mailer. So there's a lot that goes into it and you have to learn it on the fly. There's not really a reason for it. The first time I did a campaign, I remember I had no idea how to do international shipping. I had like, which was so stupid of me. I had just kind of made up a number. I was like, oh, I know how much it costs to ship in the US. I'm going to charge like $5 or $4 at the time.
And then international, $10 sounds about right. Let's do that. I think I saw one campaign charge that. And then I started looking into international shipping. I'm like, oh, each package is going to be like $30. And then you find different platforms where you can maybe cut deals when you- I remember when national shippers were starting to get upset when you gained it higher in the next campaign. It was so cheap last time. What happened? And I was like, I'm sorry. I was cheap because I was stupid. But no, the reality is like we were saying, you kind of have to anticipate that you're going to learn things after your first campaign.
You have to kind of anticipate things going wrong. And I recommend talking to people. I had talked to that. And at the time we were both still learning things. Especially about shipments. Especially about fulfillment. Because at the time, I think short feuds have handled the fulfillment for your campaigns. Yeah. I didn't have to do it. Because what? There are services out there now that sort of like fulfillment services. What have you found to be- Really expensive. They are like, especially for how much we have to add-ons. What was it? It was like a- $4 and change a package, I think was the cheapest we saw.
Oh gosh. That's going to wipe out any profits. Sometimes we've talked to people who use the services and obviously they're very professional. They get the job done. Sometimes you don't have the space for it. You don't have the space to store comics, to kind of set up the shipping operations. Some creators don't really have a choice but to use that service. And obviously I'm not saying they're overcharging necessarily. Their fulfillment is a real hard job. No. You have to buy the materials. It's a very, very difficult job. I'll say fulfillment is something Kat and I talk about weekly as like a hurdle.
We're still trying to overcome. And it's a great problem obviously. If you're fulfilling a new, successful project and people want your book, we try to remind ourselves like, oh, have the gratitude for that. Even when we're drowning a little bit in packages. Yeah. Because obviously we want everything to be on time too. We made it timeline wise that we've been lucky that everything's gone out on time and we work really hard to do that. And yeah, we're just figuring out every day how to streamline it and make it better because greatly our campaigns are continuing to do really well.
And now we're doing more Etsy packages and more packages from the websites that's added on top of that. How many campaigns are you doing now? What is your current rate? Is it, yeah, what's your current schedule? Is it two a month, one a month? Mostly two in a month. Yeah. That's incredible. That is incredible. Congratulations. Thank you. And it happened gradually too, we should say. Right. We're like, oh yeah, we want to do two a month. It's just like, these are projects we have and end up being two a month.
I think that started like the tail end of last year. But prior to that, I think we might have been at one in a month before that. And then before that, it was like kind of every other month. So, don't walk before you can run, obviously. I might just start with like two a year. Yeah, that's a good start. I think two to four a year is a great place for someone to start. There you go. I think if you do one a year, it's a little bit of a lot. And obviously, resources, obviously. I'm not saying, tell yourself to do campaigns. I think two is a good sweet spot because right when someone might be like, your comic might
be fading from their memory a little bit, it's like, oh, they're back. Now I remember how much I like every six months. Well, thank you so, so, so much for doing this. This has been absolutely amazing. We could talk more for hours because I'd love to talk more about sort of like the differences on this side versus traditional physical retail. We just scratched the surface, I feel like. So I hope you'll come back. My last little bit I like to do here is a self-care safe space. So how do you two stay sane? Hard, yeah.
Some weeks are great. Some other weeks are bad. But honestly, in all honesty, because that is a big conversation we have all the time is like, I want to be sane. I want to be healthy. It's friend time. It's a lot of like, let's not talk about work and like actually be friends and have fun. Last night we had to do that. So that was nice. Yeah, it was nice because we had the productivity. We did like, we were working on a new project. We worked on that for like five or six hours and then we like went to dinner and like watched YouTube videos and it was really fun. And then the other space is to like actually have time to zone out and do nothing. You could fill up the calendar very quickly with how much we do.
But there's days where like, no, let's mental health wise, let's just take that night off or let's end early. So you're not working and going to sleep. I think honestly, I think you covered all of my big pain points. I think obviously like it's great to have a lot going on and a lot to keep up with. But also you just got to remind yourself, oh, you deserve time to have a little fun and you also deserve time to literally do nothing. And you know, there are going to be some weeks where there is no time for that. Like you have a convention this weekend, you have a million things to do this week, but when you're not at that point, take the time and don't feel guilty about it.
And yeah, be kind to yourself. I think that's something I'm personally trying to learn a little more in 2025 is like be kind. If you, if you were as, I always say if I was as mean to myself as if I was to other people, that would be bad. Oh, wow, you're really a bad person, that person. But no, I've been trying to be better at like being kinder. I think that's a great, great segment on there. The last thing, last two things. One what is a book that y'all are checking out right now, a comic that you are would
recommend that people should be other than what you've written something else. What's a good recommendation? I really like exceptional X-Men right now. I'm a huge Kitty Fried fan and I think it's a love letter to Kitty Fried and it's the book I get most excited to read every month. I just saw her original art from that book. Yeah, I'm gonna share it on my Christmas gift. I'm still I'm still in Halloween mode. So I've been reading horror books. When we were putting together our top 10 lists, I was catching up on series that I had always been meaning to. So I really have been enjoying witches, Scott Snyder's book from like probably over a decade
ago at this point. So I think there's a show coming out like really soon. There is. Yeah. I don't think there's much details on that, but I'm looking forward to it. I really like it. I know it's animated. That's cool. Yeah, I don't know that actually. I knew that's really cool. Do you want to do want to hear a quick funny story about witches? I do. Um, so I was working in Forbidden Planet in Manhattan and Snyder would come in every now and then and say hello to folks. But he would be like meeting like Charles Soule or something in the city. He lived out in Long Island at the time. Yeah, he came in and he was very smart because he would interact with all the staff and just
give us all like a handshake and how are you? What are we reading? How are things going? And he literally pulled me aside one day and said, hey, do you want to see my new image book? It hasn't been like it's going to go on FOC soon. I was like, sure. So I literally just read witches number one off of his phone at the register. Like three weeks before the book hit FOC, which was hysterical. And also that is really smart. I think that I want more creators to be that way because Scott Snyder in particular, I think is a great roadmap and I'm sure he's doing it not just as a marketing strategy,
but also like because he wants to do it. But if you're kind to the people around you, either if it's retailers, be like, hey, check you want to check out my book or let me promote this project or let me just be, you know, give information to new creators like that. That goes a mile. Like, you know, for you, that's a great memory for Scott Snyder. So if you, you know, see his book, you're going to push a little harder. If you do that to critics, same thing. Like, you know, do it out of kindness of your heart, but do it because it's a great marketing strategy. Well, part of it is they're, they're not just investing in a story. They're investing in you, right?
Like it's not, you're, it's not just simply a project is something that they read on a page. They are investing in, in you as a person, you as a creator, you as a professional. Well, again, thank you so much for coming on today. Looking ahead, is there anything that you want to be plugging around the spring? At the UBURY, we will have Brimbo Canvas, I think. So it's a second volume, this is announced technically for the first time here, but it won't be, I guess, announced. It'll be announced. It'll be old news when this airs, but it's the first time we're telling.
It's our webtoon anthology. I'm leaving that in no matter what we air, because now I just want people, I just want to feel special. Yeah, you are. You're allowed to keep it in. Matthew Cleen is very special. Thank you very much. So, uh, Brimbo Canvas, it's a webtoon anthology. So like existing webcomics that publish on Webtoon Canvas, like new stories from them each four pages, and it's like very wholesome and sweet. It's like queer romances without like the dreary darkness that you often see in queer romances, including some of the queer romances, the cat and I, right?
Because like sometimes it's nice to just be fluffy and, uh, and we're not all the time, not all the time, but here we are. So there's 11 webtoons that are featured in there. We're really excited. Some really cool gets in there. Some of the art is really phenomenal. So the first one did, oh yeah, I'll continue to say it's Valentine's Day themed. We're launching, I think, like 10th. So it's a, it's Rainbow Canvas, like Valentine's Day edition. So we have a few stories that are themed to that as well. So and then where can folks find you too on a social media if they want to get more updates,
um, and, and follow along with what's going on? Um, at Comic-Gunno for me, and now we have a website. That's the newest, uh, edition since, uh, near Comic-Con times. And we are so happy. So go to lifelinecomics.com, find everything you ever could. We have like our newsletter on there, all the stuff that you need to find on there. Yeah, our store. Yeah. So that's lifelinecomics.com. Um, our stuff, our newsletter is a good place to get updates from us. So that's also just called Lifeline Comics. And then I'm on pretty much all social media platforms at Phil Falco writes. Well, listeners, thank you. You heard it here first, even though it'll all be ready to be live.
Most likely by the time this comes out, but thank you so much for lending us your ears for about an hour here. Thank you, Phil and Kat for coming on and spending a little more time than we had planned. You make this possible, dear listeners. So please, if you haven't already, head over to patreon.com slash comics for you. If you haven't signed up, you can sign up for as little as a dollar a month. You get some extra content, you get shout outs. Uh, but every little bit helps to keep this thing going and growing. And I hope you have enjoyed learning how comics are made for you.
Superstar scribe and artist Christian Ward is back revealing his Fave 5 runs, artists, writers, Batman: The Animated Series episodes and dropping some insight on his influences. It's a great bit of insight into the mind...
Joe Annabi, manager of Golden Apple Comics in Los Angeles is here for the first of a two-parter! Joe talks about Marvel Midnight, Absolute Batman, and what else is selling in the shops. He also gets into what incentives...
Episode notes Senior Editor Spencer Cushing of Dark Horse Comics joins Matthew on this episode. Spencer deeps dive into his childhood love of Calvin & Hobbs, his fandom of Dungeons & Dragons assisting him with editing...
Time for more of your favorite comic creators' faves with superstar Jorge Corona! The current Lobo artist talks his favorite writers, artists, first reads to recommend, and Batman: The Animated Series eps. Make sure you...
From Hive Mind HQ Matthew is joined by the duo talk all things Dungeons & Dragons from Dark Horse Comics, You'll Never Leave This Place Alive from IDW Publishing, how they juggle eight different projects in different...