I think we'll have to get used to (and accept) AI generated content. Not to slop though.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Here's a hot take, and I'll explain it. I think we humans think that we like content that was generated by humans, that we prefer that over AI-generated content, but I think that is increasingly wrong. And I'll explain it before you start flaming me. But I had this thought for the last couple of weeks and months, to be honest, and then I encountered this post here by Tim Sweeney, the founder and majority owner of Epic, the CEO of Epic Games,
who recently posted on X. We have a huge pivot underway here at Epic, moving developers around to retool for maximum AI acceleration. The aim isn't to do the same stuff with fewer people, but to enable everyone here to build more and better stuff, and to bring the benefits to all teams using Unreal, the Unreal Engine, that is. Now, naturally, DHH was quite happy about that, and I also agree here. But this is, in the end,
you could say a relatively standard statement, right? A lot of companies are embracing AI. I think a lot of layoffs have been announced due to AI, and obviously, that is a bad thing and not what I like. But what's interesting about this statement, therefore, well, for one, especially that it's not about layoffs, but also that it's from a company, a games company, which is of course all about creativity and the content, the games they build, and naturally, one of the most popular reactions here
is this one at least for me when I view this post: If Unreal becomes an engine where you upload a few pages outlining a game idea, and five minutes later you get a fully playable AAA fidelity game, do you think this would be a good thing for humanity? And obviously, this is a pretty critical comment. And there are more comments like this now. For one, in his post, it's not about giving you something where you just upload a draft and get a finished game, but clearly, of course, the goal is to
develop the Unreal Engine into a direction where you can use it, for example, to vibe code games, if you want to put it like this. And you can absolutely discuss whether these would be the games you want to play or not. But here's the thing. As I mentioned at the very beginning, I think we humans like to think that we want to consume content, no matter which content—if that's videos, if that's games, if that's movies, text, music, created by other humans—and I would have agreed to
that statement until a couple of months ago, at least. And I'm still not sure if I entirely disagree, but I think that we overestimate how important this really is to us humans, and of course, just to be very clear here, that is not a general thing for you. It may be one hundred percent clear that you want human content only, and that is fine. I just think that throughout the ages, how things are built and who builds something has
changed so many times that it's pretty dangerous to keep a hard opinion on this AI content thing, for example, you may have said, let's say, 150 years ago, that you, or 100 years ago, even that you absolutely only want to wear clothing created by a craftsman who really knows their craft, handcrafted in your country, maybe in your city. You want to have shoes that were
created by an artisan in your city. Nowadays, we buy whatever is cheapest, or most people buy what's cheapest, or at least which brand they want, and they don't care if it's manufactured in China, Bangladesh, Italy or somewhere else. Some people care, one hundred percent. Some people care and they pay a premium, but of course not everybody can afford that premium. A lot of people don't care or can't afford it. And you can have philosophical discussions about this: Is this a good thing? Would they care if they could afford it?
Maybe. I just think that with AI, it's kind of similar. And for example, if we take text, which obviously was the first form of AI that entered the mainstream with the release of ChatGPT, it's probably fair to assume that a huge chunk of text we consume these days, at least on the internet, but also outside of the internet increasingly, is AI-generated or at least, to huge parts AI-generated. If you're reading a newspaper article where the first draft was
created by an AI and which was then polished up by a human, is that human generated? Is it AI-generated? You can make both arguments here. And I would definitely make the argument that if a human put a lot of thought and effort into having the AI generate a great article, it is a creative product. It's a product of that human, even if AI was used. A not perfect example is that if you're using a word processor or a tool like Microsoft Word for writing,
obviously it's still written by you, even though you did it on a computer. Now, it's not a perfect example because clearly you were typing every character, but you used a tool to help you to format it in a nicer way to make it more readable. You did not write it down by hand. Again, not a perfect example, I know, but AI is just another tool here—a tool that can help you get that draft based on the information you collected, based on the outline you prepared, maybe also with help of AI. But still,
it's your creativity and it's your decisions that go into there. Now, obviously, that's not true for every piece of text. There is a lot of slop out there, and that probably makes it so hard to differentiate in many cases. With AI, it's super easy to produce low quality products, slop, low quality text, low quality movies. It's super easy. And nobody, I would guess, likes that, myself included. That's not the kind of content I'm talking about here.
I'm talking about content generated by AI or with help of AI, where, of course, you still have the creativity and the decisions of the humans. And I think we need to be more open, or simply be prepared for a future where this will be the norm. And now back to this post here by Tim, where he turns Epic and the Unreal Engine into a tool that heavily embraces AI, and as I understand it, gives developers that work with the Unreal Engine tools
to have an easier time leveraging AI to build their games by building certain AI features into the engine. And I think that's the only way forward. We will not have a future where games are being built by people handcrafting 3D models in Blender, for example. Of course, yes, there will be some exceptions here and there, and they may be successful just because of the fact that they are handcrafted, though. If the game sucks, it will still not be super successful.
But the majority of games, either way, will leverage these tools. I mean, today already, every serious game developer and game studio is, of course, using AI for code assistance for generating code, like every other developer is or should be doing at least. Of course, that will spill over to art. Now, again, here's the important point: you can use it to have generic art assets, to have slop, to have 3D models with lots of little errors. You can do all that, or you use it
to turn your creative vision into prototypes, which you can then polish up and bring into your game. You can use it to quickly explore different art directions by quickly spitting out different prototypes and mockups, just as a developer. Where you can also quickly create a bunch of mockups of a website, and then you can see those different variations and iterate on that. You can use it as a tool, but of course, the result naturally will be AI-generated,
since large portions of it are AI-generated. But it's still the artist, the developer, that poured their knowledge, their expertise, and their decisions into that AI usage to get a great result out of it. And nowadays, I'm pretty sure that is what we'll see, and what we'll ultimately accept. What we'll have to accept that we'll have music, we'll have movies, we'll have games, we'll obviously have software. We already have it. We'll have text. We already have that too. All that generated by AI,
but then we'll have shitty versions, which are just slop, vibe-coded. Which will simply not win in the market on the long term, and will have great results where it's not just one prompt and let's see what we get as a result. But I think we need to be open to say, yeah, it's good that you're using AI. Simply for the simple fact that it allows you to stay in business. If you have a favorite game studio and you want them to stay in business, they need to use AI because all their competitors are moving faster.
So that alone is a good reason. But that's not the only reason. AI also allows you to be more ambitious, and I covered this in other episodes already. But it allows you to iterate quickly to explore, as I mentioned, different artistic styles, and I think these are all the positive sides we can see here when it comes to AI for art and so on. Now, of course, there are many things that are to be criticized about AI, or that can be criticized, and things you can be afraid of. Now, for one, for example, the entire copyright
thing—how these AI models were trained and are trained. Horrible! Lots of copyright infringements here. At least, I guess that's what many people, including myself, feel. Even though it may not be the legal side, or there may not be a final judgment there, but obviously that is not great. Obviously, you can be afraid. We're all feeling this uncertainty because things are moving so quickly. But that does not change that it's here, and that it can,
and that it should be leveraged to build better products. And still, right now, we're in this chaotic phase. We have a lot of shitty software, a lot of shitty products because we're still all figuring out how to use these tools. And frankly, because these tools, they are becoming much better, and you can now create better results with them than you could a year ago. So combine that with that we're still all figuring out part, and here you are in the current situation. I'm convinced great products, no matter about which kind of product we're talking,
will come out because of AI. That includes all sorts of content, including videos. And no, this does not mean that you will only have AI-generated YouTube videos or something like that. But you can have amazing AI-generated YouTube videos, which are not the slop. You can have amazing AI-generated movies. And the slop part, I think, will simply lose on the global market. So, yeah, these are just my two cents on this topic. I guess.
GPT 6 Astra was released. It's a good model, I have to say. Especially for 3D work it seems to be a real game changer. But due to all the hype, you may be disappointed...