Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Classroom Narratives: Healing in Education

Classroom Narratives: Healing in Education artwork

We Will Always Need Humans: Rebuilding the Bridge Between Teachers, Counselors, and Student Mental Health with Dr. Melodie Workman

Oct 28, 202649 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

πŸ“ Episode Synopsis When schools talk about supporting student mental health, teachers and counselors are often working toward the same goal - but not always together. In this episode of Classroom Narratives, Dr. Melodie Workman shares the findings from her research exploring how stronger collaboration between teachers and school counselors can better support student mental health. Together, we discuss role confusion, communication breakdowns, educator burnout, student agency, and why human connection remains the foundation of meaningful education. The conversation also explores what social-emotional learning looks like beyond core-subject classrooms, why principals play a pivotal role in creating healthy school cultures, and how educators can recognize the difference between supporting students and attempting to become their therapist. Finally, as artificial intelligence continues to reshape education, Dr. Workman offers a hopeful vision for the future: No matter how advanced technology becomes, we will always need humans to teach humans how to be human. πŸ”— Show Resources πŸ“Œ Faculty Q and A with Dr. Melodie Workman at Whitworth University πŸ“Œ Better Than Carrots or Sticks: Restorative Practices for Positive Classroom Management πŸŽ™οΈRelevant Classroom Narratives segments *From Surviving to Teaching: Eleni Webster on Building Safer Classrooms Through Voice, Vulnerability, and Vision *Beyond the Text: Creating Safe Spaces for Emotional Learning with Dr. Adam Wolfsdorf *Leading with Culture: Building Schools Students and Teachers Want to Attend with Shaun Hurtado *Teaching with HEART and SOUL: The HABITS That Evolved Community Beyond Compliance *Teaching with HEART and SOUL: RESILIENCE Beyond "I Can't"

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Melodie: we will always need humans to teach humans how to be humans. And what a great high calling to teach young malleable minds how to use their strengths as humans to be the best of humanity. Welcome to the Classroom Narratives Healing and Education Podcast, the space where education meets resilience. I'm Dr. Joey Weisler, and in each episode, we dive deep into the personal stories of educators, students, leaders, and frontline advocates who are navigating

the complexities within modern education. Whether you're just starting your teaching journey or are a seasoned professional looking for inspiration, we'll explore how to foster meaningful change, prevent burnout, and build trauma-informed communities within our schools. Now, let's take a seat at the front of the classroom as we get started joey: Welcome back to today's segment of the Classroom Narratives Podcast, where I'm delighted to have Dr. Melodie Workman with us today, who teaches at Whitworth's undergraduate teacher education department and has over 20 years of experience

in education, spanning middle school English language arts, high school literature, and college composition. At Whitworth, she teaches courses such as Supporting Multilingual Learners and Children's Literature. And Melodie, you are here today to share with us your insights on counselors and teachers, and we're looking forward to your insights. Welcome to the program. Melodie: Yeah. Thank you. Thank you so much for having me. joey: So we had a conversation a couple months ago, and I was fascinated by the bridges that you are building with understanding the relationships between counselors, teachers, and the rest of how the

school system works with them at large. So let's start there, and tell us about what your research spans and what got you into that interest. Melodie: Yeah. Oh, there's quite a few questions right there at the beginning, but we'll just start with my philosophy of education has always been human-centered. I know a lot of people get into education because they love the subjects that they teach. Mine has always been I love kids, I love teachers, I love principals, I love school figures. And, we're kind of in our society walking away from that human

centeredness with the introduction of technology into our classrooms, and even AI that's happening right now. However, we're still working with humans. And, in our push for academic progress, some of those humans sometimes don't get what they need. And as I was exploring how this is happening, specifically with mental health in middle school students, because we know adolescents have a very high suicide rate, students between the ages of 11 and 15, their second

leading cause of death is suicide. and thinking about that, I just thought how can I make a difference? How can I explore this issue and support middle school students better? And what I've found is that we have a lot of things in place to help students already. There are a lot of supports in place to both identify and support mental health needs within our schools. But we as teachers within schools are overwhelmed by the amount of things that we have to do, whether it is keeping up with trainings or doing the latest

PD or just downright teaching in our classrooms, that it's difficult to identify and support these mental health needs within our middle school students. So as I explored, I came across this collaborative relationship between teachers and counselors, that if we strengthen this relationship, it really could be a pivotal change for our students in our classrooms. And so that's kind of what sparked it. It started with this human interest, and then moved into problem-solving, and then identifying one small way within schools that we could be making a difference

joey: I love that you say that you love school figures because what I've come to learn is that if we were to get into the bureaucracy of how education works, school figures don't really love each other. And there is certainly a lot of politics behind even just different rankings, like how we were even saying that at the university level there are some full-time faculty members who will look at their part-time faculty members and be like, "Why are we in the same room together at this moment?" And there's just such a divide between, again, like counselors and teachers and principals, and teachers

and principals, and students are a whole nother sector to add into there. So when you think about the human center, because again, we are all humans just trying to make the system function. When we think about the human-centered education, and based upon your philosophy, what have you seen about the different ways to just bring humans together no matter what background they're coming from? Melodie: I love that you asked that question. I am fascinated with Bandura's ideas. Bandura talked about one key idea that I'd love if we could find a new way of

saying it so that it would be fresh and new, but there is no new way to say it. We all in our world want agency. We want choice. We want to be- in control of what happens to us, from children who are three all the way to professors who are looking towards retirement in their 70s. Yeah. We all want some type of control over our lives and our choices. And so when you put people in a room together like that who are vying for control when sometimes they don't even have it, like their agency and their control is in somebody else's hands, their choices- Mm-hmm

are being made by another person, I think naturally we are all butting heads because of that, right? Right. But if we can recognize and be on that same level as, "Oh, I see what you're doing here. I see that you're-" Mm "… posturing a little bit because you're afraid I'm gonna take your agency. I'm not here for that. I want you to have your agency." Think about this as in a classroom management perspective. You want this child to sit in their seat, right? Mm-hmm. This child wants agency. They want choice. They don't wanna have to sit in their seat. They want it to be their choice to sit in their seat.

It's not that they want to stand the entire class. Who wants to stand for an hour? Nobody. But they want the choice to be able to sit down. So then being able to frame it in that way and dialogue in that way where we're all vying for the same human element, which is natural, we want choice, we want agency, and finding a way to dialogue about it in a respectful way. I just finished reading a book this summer in preparation for some of my classes called, Supercommunicators, and it explores how we can listen to each other's narratives.

How we can use active listening to let people know that they're being heard, and then make some change, because that's really what we all want, right? We wanna be in a room where people are listening to us and respecting us and not putting us into an out group. We wanna be part of the in group, and we wanna understand that we still have choice. joey: I love that you bring that up because one of the things that I wanted to talk about today is through this new HEART approach, H-E-A-R-T, that I'm using in my own classroom, or rather I have been, and I'm really

now able to actually put a name to it. So when I go back in September, we're recording in July, and when I come back in September, I can actually put my thumb on this and say, "Okay, this is exactly how the classroom should run," and I can be aware of my own systems. One of the systems that I use under this pillar of H in H-E-A-R-T, HEART, is about forming the habits of the classrooms, forming the systems within, where students come in. The only requirement, so you talk about where they sit, the only requirement through the entire day is that they have to sit in my circle.

We all have to make a circle with the desks. You can't be on the outskirts. You have to sit within my circle. After that, you can do whatever you want. You can speak. You can write. You can listen. You can do whatever you want to have your participation and your voice as part of the class. I think about my friend Eleni Webster, who says that as a public speaking teacher, she wants her students to have their voices feel so valued that they will know we will be, like, injured as the professor if their voice is not heard somehow.

But when I think about the system such as the invitational language, students are invited but never required to speak. We have safe moments, safe conditions, but safety is never announced. So we don't say, "This is a safe space," because that definition varies from student to student, but we create the conditions for students to lean into the safety. And then, of course, when it comes to the way that they can do their work, the flexibility, the choice, again, you can do an assignment multimodally. You can adjust the rubric to help you think about what do I want

to gain from this as a student under my instructor's supervision. There are so many ways that classroom systems can be formed to help benefit student agency. What are some that you look at the most, and which ones do you use, and which ones would you suggest? And what are the most successful in terms of getting students to have the most agency in their own learning? Melodie: Let's go back to your example of there's one thing that students don't get to choose, and that's to sit in your circle. But even- Mm … sitting in your circle, you can create choices within that, right? Yes. Where they sit or how they get to the circle. Exactly. Yes, yes, yes. Are we gonna walk?

Are we gonna run? Are we gonna hop? Are we gonna skip? I mean, there are so many choices even within the thing that they're supposed to do- joey: Mm-hmm Melodie: that they can still have. And so, going back to your last question, I would say it depends on your learners. You know, who's in your classroom? Would you know their preferences? And then that will give you more options to create choices for them. But you hit on- Yeah most of them. I mean, even in higher ed, we're still doing those same things. How do you want to turn this in? Here's my line. You know, you have to turn it in by this time, and I want to measure that you

have learned, but here are some options. Here are some choices that you can choose in the journey. As long as we're creating choices that are meaningful to our learners, I think we're doing it well. joey: Definitely. Yeah, like for every paper, so I'm also a university composition and writing teacher, and for every paper that I distribute, I normally have one rubric that can cover multiple different options- Mm-hmm for a paper. So you can do options one, two, three, four, and five. But no matter which ones you choose, the grading criteria, just to honestly make life easier for me when I go grade it in Canvas- I

know … is gonna be exactly the same. I'll still be looking for the exact same components as in, is your argument there? Are you using references? That can all be covered no matter which of those five choices that you use. And even in those five choices, it's still kind of freeform to some degree for the student. Like, I'm not saying it's either you choose this book or that book. It's like, okay, what are you gonna do with whatever content you want to explore? So even giving students agency in how they think is what I find most relevant in for them as well.

Melodie: Sure. I think the key to that agency is still to have expectations. It's not okay just to say, "Do what you want." joey: Right. Melodie: You know, we have to have expectations, and we're still working towards creating goals and turning our students into scholars. Like, that gives them- Right … meaning. joey: Well, then when we think about what our students need, mm, I had certainly noticed- A gap in how social and emotional learning, or SEL, and we spoke about SEAL in our last conversation a couple months ago, on how that is presented across subjects.

And it's not impossible, it's just a very different type of incorporation than, for example, a STEM class. I'd love to learn about how SEL can be shown in algebra II or calculus, for example. And how can we see SEL supported throughout a variety of different subjects as you've seen it? Melodie: So my study explored the domains of teachers and how they can support student mental health within their own classrooms. Mm. And then in collaborative relationships with counselors, and then ultimately using the entire school community.

So these three different categories. And as I was exploring these ideas with teachers about how they support student mental health within their own domain, within their own classrooms, SEL came up so many times. It's what we're doing, we're doing it well. But when we do look at different classes, some of them intrinsically within the curriculum it's just easier to do, right? In ELA, it's easier to talk about social emotional issues because it's in literature, right? Exactly. So we can talk about how this character did this, or even reflective writing.

We can do that as an exercise at the beginning of our classes. In social studies it's actually fairly easy as well because we have these- Uh-huh … characters who have succeeded or they've failed due to these- Yeah … things in their lives, right? So those two subjects, it's intrinsically inside the curriculum. However, when we look at subjects like science and math, immediately our thought is, "I have to get my students to these goals. How do I teach SEL alongside science and math?" And to that I would say it might not be in

the curriculum that you're teaching, it might be in your approach to teaching. Meaning, math is hard. Students recognize it as hard, and while it might be easier for other students, there are some elements of it that are so hard. And explaining that, like what you are doing is a hard thing, and maybe you weren't as successful at it at the beginning, but look what you have done. Speaking into the growth mindset of students is part of social emotional learning, so that is a natural setting for doing something hard,

and keep on doing something hard until you get that growth mindset. Also, creating identities within students, math and science are great places to do that. " Man, this was a hard thing, and it's not because you are extremely smart that you did this, it's because you worked hard and you are a scholar." Using that language to reinforce those ideas and reinforce hard work in order to reach goals is part of the math and the science curriculums. And then lastly, agency. I think we just talked about this.

When we're working in math and science, sometimes it seems- like these are the set things that we have to do. But teaching students how to use their agency and rewarding them, not with sticks and carrots, but with praise or, "Hey, doesn't that make you feel good to have become this person because you made that choice, and that choice was a good choice?" That's all part of teaching students how to maintain themselves and how to work with others as they are working through these really hard subjects. joey: There's so many things I could think about with that, and

I'm gonna start with talking about my friend Dr. Adam Wolfsdorf. And Dr. Wolfsdorf is a high school English teacher for 25 years, plus a professor- Mm … of English at NYU, New York University. And the work that he does talks about distinguishing the therapeutic classroom from one that serves as therapy. Mm. We can have a therapeutic space where students can feel good, especially he is an ELA and he teaches a little bit of history as well. And he says that when it comes to looking at stories, and even history being a

story in itself, right, we miss the boat if we don't address the fact that history is traumatic and stories are traumatic. I mean, the Great Depression, Holocaust, 9/11, those are all traumatic stories. And the paradox that he says is that trauma happens "out there", yet we really try to avoid it when we are "in here", in the room, in our stories. Like, how can you look at " To Kill a Mockingbird" or "Of Mice and Men" and not address the fact that trauma is in those stories? It can't be done. And I think about when I also teach "The Hate U Give" and Elie Wiesel.

You cannot look at those stories and be like, "Oh, nothing to see here, folks." That just doesn't happen. You're doing such an incomplete presentation of the work when we censor the trauma in those texts. So when it comes to ELA- One of the things we look at is that therapeutic divide where we can use stories to help students think about emotion. But the issue happens is when they start to feel it for themselves, in a way that lets it bleed into the middle of the classroom and take over the academic aspect of that. And then my other friend, Rondalyn Whitney, who is a narrative medicine

practitioner, she was speaking recently on the show about how the answer to a lot of our life questions, if you will, do exist in literature based upon how people behave, how we act, how characters function. Mm. And literature happens to be my favorite subject- because I love looking at, and that actually is my final paper, to have students kind of write about their own life experiences based upon what they've learned through a character. Mm. And again, that's one of their choices for a multitude of options that they can use. But I don't tell them which book to go into.

They can choose- Right … whichever of the five books that they can choose. But we look at how characters behave, and it helps us really build this emotional toolkit that helps get answers to our own experiences. And when we look at texts such as "Speak" by Laura Halse Anderson, which is about, a rape, we have looked at "The Glass Castle", which is a memoir by Jeannette Walls, which is about homelessness and poverty. I will now get student papers that talk about their own experiences with rape and poverty and homelessness because of the fact that the academic content led them there.

And then when it comes to our STEM classes, if I were to go back to our HEART framework, that H-E-A-R-T, the R in HEART stands for resiliency, or rather letting students lean into their own emotions. So when we have a science or a chemistry class or an algebra two class, sometimes learning doesn't always feel good. And what turns students off from learning is that deep frustration, that aggravation from not being able to get a concept. And what that R factor resilience is working to explain is that FAIL

is a first attempt in learning. But a first attempt in learning should not have to equal, "I failed." Right. And have students stop there, and finding ways to still find success beyond that. So I think that's how it shows up in other classes as well. Melodie: Yeah, absolutely. I mean, we know that student success depends on two things really. It depends on their belief in themselves and the structure that's happening there, so back to Bandura, right? joey: Mm-hmm. Melodie: And then it depends on can they relate what's happening

inside the classroom to what's happening outside the classroom. joey: Yes. Melodie: Can I take what I'm learning here in my Algebra 2 classroom- Mm-hmm … and apply it to somewhere beyond my Algebra 2 classroom? And some of those happen in more intangible ways, like learning growth mindset. joey: Yeah. Melodie: And it's to the teachers advantage to actually point that out. If you have an athlete in your classroom who you go attend one of their sporting events, and you see them have tenacity and resilience, and you see that same quality inside your classroom, you can speak to that in both avenues, right?

Yes. The bridge here. "Oh, man. I saw you play that football game the other day, and you got knocked down. I saw you get right back up. You know-" Mm-hmm "… I saw you the same thing. You didn't do that great on that first quiz, but look what you did on the second quiz. You are a resilient- Yeah … human being." So helping them see that some of the skills they're building inside your classroom do correlate with the skills that they're going to need to succeed in other parts of their life is to our advantage and to their advantage as well. joey: Absolutely. But what really gets concerning is when emotion goes really unhinged to

the point it can't get reeled back in. So for example, sometimes when I'm teaching literature, and of course, I've mentioned this story several times throughout a thread podcast, so I'll mention it briefly, and I'll do the abridged version to that. When I was teaching a fictional text, I was having students connect to characters in ways that led them to disclose their suicidal ideation, and their depression, and their sexuality. Now all of a sudden- The classroom became this contact zone of student needs, and it was no longer about what's going on in Of Mice and Men with our characters,

but it's like, what does so and so have to say about their suicidal ideation? Right. And trying to understand how to get students to work through that. And then at the same time, I had a student that came up to me when she was dealing with through the reading of that novel and through that activity. And the student said to me, "Please don't send me down to my counselor. I'm just a number downstairs." What do we do as teachers when we see emotion become present and unhinged, what do we do to students who need the help, but at the same time resist

it from somebody who is not us? Melodie: I would say there's always someone. There's always someone. in higher education it is a little bit different, right? Yeah. We're working with adults. Not that students who are not adults, their preferences don't matter, but- As a keeper of students in middle school, it's my job as an adult to understand this is a need that I cannot help. joey: Right. Melodie: This is a need that I am by law required to report. Yes. joey: Yeah. Melodie: So there's- Yeah … that to keep in mind. But also in school structures, there's so many people, even at universities,

I might not be their person. However, the teacher they have next might be their person. So probing into- Right who's your person? Do you have people, or do you have friends? Do you have a counselor? I know you don't like going to see the school counselor, but do you have a counselor outside of school? Just asking questions that would help students push towards the people that they do trust. Have you read the book, "Better Than Sticks and Carrots"? It's, it's a restorative classroom management book. It was written, a decade ago or s-

joey: Tell us about it, and I'll put it in the show notes as well. Melodie: Yes. some of the things in it really apply, and one of them is if you have students who are struggling, having a two-minute conversation a day with that student might just be what it is. Yes. Just two minutes. Yeah. And can you imagine every figure in the school that that person has having a two-minute conversation with that human? And we all strive for agency, but human connection, and we need that human connection. And much of what we're doing in our world today is avoiding human connection. We're doing it over digital platforms and social media and

emails and MTSS documents, but we're not doing it eye to eye. And without jumping ahead, that's what we prefer. Teachers prefer that. We would rather have an eye-to-eye conversation with our counselors than fill out another form to tell them something that we don't know if we're supposed to be reporting it in this way. We want to have those eye-to-eye conversations with counselors. It actually helps us build relationship with our counselors, but it better supports our students because we can speak frankly and openly with our counselors. And students prefer that too.

They don't know that they prefer that. They think they would rather be on social media. But what they need in their worlds is more eye-to-eye conversations with real humans, even if those are adults that aren't always their preference to talk to. So just instituting, "Okay, I know that you and I don't quite vibe as teacher-student, but who do you vibe with? Who is your teacher here that you enjoy talking to? How about we take just a couple of minutes, I'll walk you over to that teacher so you can have a couple of minutes of a conversation with them?" Or maybe it's not the school counselor. maybe it is another trusted

figure. It doesn't always have to be teachers, and I think that's where I would go with, "What about teachers? We're so burned out." Everything does not rest on us as teachers. We're just a starting point. Our domains are that starting point. joey: I'm thinking about a conversation that I had with Principal Shaun Hurtado from California, and Principal Hurtado speaks about what he calls to be the no dot student. For the no dot student, Principal Hurtado teaches at a small middle school, small-ish, less than 4,000 like my high school over here, and he has a campus that enables him to actually lay out what he calls the face sheets of every single

student in the school, grade six through eight, twice a year in the media center. And as the faculty all go through the media center, they put a dot on every face sheet to a student that they have a connection with. And it well beyond, "Oh, I taught them a year ago." It has to be like you gotta know their pet's name. You gotta know what sport they play. If they broke an ankle or if they've stubbed a toe, you need to know that too. And if you know these personal details about students, you put a dot on their face sheet. And by the end of the rotation, they still of course look at the students that are

noted on the face sheet, and I could even say that when I taught the student that I knew had the most crisis situations was the one that everybody knew was the most popular student, had a family member on staff on campus, and everybody knew that the student needed support because they were in a space where they were still overcoming a tragedy from the year before. That student needed a lot of help. We don't forget about them. But what the face sheets tell us- Is that there are certainly students that are

completely under the radar from that, and they need some of our support too. So then the faculty go out of their way to make sure that those students have somebody on campus. And at the same time, when I did go down to my school counselor, again, we talk about just that sense of agency and the butting of heads between people in different positions. When I was teaching middle school and I would go down to my school social worker, my school counselor, and say, "Hey, I heard so and so say X, Y, and Z today. I don't know what to do with it, so I'm just letting you know." The

situation was one student kind of was tongue in cheek joking about being a school shooter, and I brought that down to the school counselor and I said, "Listen, I've, I saw this a year ago as to what happens in Parkland when we do not address these types of things. I'm seeing something, I'm saying something. I don't know what it means, but I think you should do something about it." And her answer to me was, "Well, what do you want me to do about it? I don't see anything wrong with this." And there was so much friction between me and my school counselor because I was constantly bringing things

downstairs, downstairs, downstairs. Like, "Oh, here's Weisler again. What does he got for us today?" And it came to the point where they just started dismissing everything I shared with them. Right. And because I knew that that relationship was very ill conducive to helping the students, I started to go form my village, where I would really lean into my colleagues and say, "Okay, I'm period five, you're period three for this person, and you, you're period four. Let's just make sure that throughout the day, this person knows that they have our… We don't even have to announce it.

Just know internally that we are all here to support this student and form a village for them." Sure. And just get at least somebody throughout the day, through our block schedule, at least one or two teachers every day in the block schedule, to just watch this kid a little bit more carefully no matter where they're coming from. And they think about the village as well. So then with that, ugh, I still get really frustrated every time I think about that counselor. How do counselors want to be communicated when it comes to working with faculty and vice versa?

What kinds of relationships should faculty look for in their counselors, and how can that become symbiotic? Melodie: Well, counselors are busy. Let's give that to them. Mm-hmm. Whereas teachers, we have our people, they might have one or two other similar figures inside the school, if you're lucky. We have counselors who are shared across buildings in school districts that you're lucky if you can get them there one day a week, you know? Um- Audio Only - All Participants: Yeah … Melodie: so counselors are very busy. They're dealing with thousands of students. So I think some of the response that you might have been

getting is that, "What do I do? I already have all of this volume. I'm also," if you're at a middle school or a high school- Mm-hmm … "I'm in control of all of these students' schedules, not just their mental health," you know? And if you're lucky- Right … you can get mental health therapists inside your school too, but not all schools have that. So just looking at it from a counselor perspective, I'll just start with saying, we don't have enough counselors in our schools. Yeah. We don't have enough counselors to support the mental health needs of our students in our schools. We need more support. And what a disservice to make counselors do multiple jobs.

Scheduling alongside helping mental health support, alongside helping discipline issues, alongs- I mean, they do so much, okay? What is their preferred form of communication? We'll start there. They prefer digital, which is- Yeah a contrast to what teachers prefer. Right. Counselors want some paper trail that they can go back to because these conversations- Yes … that they're having with multiple teachers a day, multiple students a day, it's difficult for them to retain that information. So they would prefer us to send them digital communication.

joey: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Melodie: Inversely, we want to have eye-to-eye contact and verbal conversation with- Yeah … our counselors. Why? We already have so much paperwork to do. That's one of the reasons. This just feels like another thing, right? Also, it's difficult for us as teachers to stop what we're doing in the middle of our class or find that time to send that digital communication. We don't have office hours. Counselors have their offices. That's another criticism of teachers of counselors is they're not seen.

They're not out in the buildings often. They're not walking the hallways with the people that they're supposed to be helping. Now, this is not my criticism. It is just the overall feeling- Sure that teachers are reporting. They want to see counselors walking the hallways. They want them to be human, interacting with not just the teachers, but the students as well. The question is, how do we do that? How can we get counselors out of their offices into the hallways where we have access to them as teachers, where students have access to them, and they're not just these figures that I'm supposed to go see who I'm just a

number to in, in students', perceptions? It's a difficult thing. We're understaffed. We don't have the budget for it. So we have to find a bridge. If we as teachers prefer in-person communication and counselors prefer that digital communication, thinking back to some of what I learned in my study, there are natural spots where we can actually bridge this communication gap and preference. One of those is meetings at the beginning of the school year. Mm-hmm. This is where we all are meeting together, and this is a great place

to have some of that eye-to-eye, face-to-face conversation, and counselors can explain what their preference is and why they have that preference. And then we, on the other side, the humans on the other side, can build that empathy for, "Oh- joey: Yes Melodie: I never really even realized that you had that job to do. It makes sense why you want me to email you or fill out an MTSS form instead of coming and finding you" But our needs need to be met as well. So it can't just happen at the beginning of the school year.

We need meetings throughout the school year where we can have face-to-face conversations where we can say, "Hey, this feels off to me, but not off enough to fill out a form about it to go on a student's record." Right. " I just need to have this conversation with you." joey: I feel like what we've established is that there is a lot of needing to chase within schools. Like, we have teachers chasing after students. Yeah. We have teachers chasing after counselors. We have counselors chasing after students. Yeah. And so then when we just think about- The amount of accountability that

exists within those different sectors. My first question is, what are some practices for creating spaces where students can feel comfortable enough to be open in class, but not so comfortable where the teacher is now their pseudo psychologist? And at the same time, what does follow-up and accountability look like where when we do need a student to go talk to the social worker, how can that be done without needing to keep chasing through the paperwork and chasing through the red tape to get that student the help that they need? Melodie: I wanna be clear, teachers are not mental health professionals.

joey: Correct. Melodie: Some of us may have mental health training. joey: Mm-hmm. Melodie: Some of us may have our own mental health experiences, so we may know a lot about mental health. We may even have some degrees in it, but it's still not our job. We are not the mental- Right health professionals in our buildings. However, we cannot abandon the idea that we are frontline workers in this mental health issue for our students. And our domain, our classrooms are the places to identify and

begin support for our students. I compare it to supports like literacy or speech. If we have students in our classrooms who are struggling with literacy, we have literacy supports. We aren't those literacy supports, right? We do what we can do, but we have figures in our school to support literacy. If we have a student who has a speech need, we have speech therapists in our school who can help those students. The question is, how are those literacy specialists or those speech therapists going to identify if the student has the need?

Well, they rely on our domains. They rely on our eyes. And if you think about that through a mental health perspective, we as teachers are not the mental health professionals. However, we interact with these students five hours a week. They're in our classrooms. Or if we're elementary teachers, holy moly, you have them 30 hours a week, right? Yes. So you see them every single day. You know what their baseline behavior is, and you know when something is off. We build relationships with our students because we care about

them, but we do so so we can recognize if there's something off. And when there's something off- We approach them. We talk to them. We say, "Hey, are you okay? Do you need more help?" "Yeah, I really do." Well, that's not our time to take them and be their therapist. That's our time to give them the support by referring them to that support. So while we are not the therapists, it literally is our job to identify when something is off with that student, just like we would do for literacy or speech. So I would say, yes, you cannot be a student's therapist.

However, it is part of your job to recognize when that student has a need, and then to refer them to the support that they do need. joey: Yeah. I think about the teacher's role as, like, the primary physician or, like, the primary doctor, where we are literally primary is in our name. We are the primary teacher. But at the same time, like, if you have a visit to your primary physician, they will look at you and say, "Okay, I'm gonna now refer you after your medical exam today to an ear doctor or an ENT or a neurologist or an eye doctor."

Or a foot doctor and somebody else who after I can identify that there is an issue there, I can then forward you on to the next specialist who can then care for you further based upon what- Yeah … your needs are. Melodie: Yeah, I would agree with that. I think the breakdown is that some teachers don't view themselves as doctors at all. Right. joey: Right. Right, Melodie: right. They view themselves as just content givers, you know? They- Yes … view themselves as teachers. And I don't wanna get ahead of myself here too 'cause I already

know what you're gonna ask about the future of education, but- joey: Yeah. … Melodie: I think essentially we're going to have to grapple with what our role is in education. Mm-hmm. Which I'm not gonna give you that answer yet until we get to the- Ooh … to the future. joey: Ooh, I'm excited though. Well, on the same tabs with that, I really see that leadership really makes or breaks how mental health works in schools. And I mean, when I talk to Principal Shaun Hurtado from the no dot face sheet routine. Mm-hmm. I think about Principal Jeremy Brooks as well, who talks about

safety as a number one priority. There is Mike Earnshaw and of course, there's also Robert Hinchcliffe, who talks about being a servant leader for the community. Principals really make or break the mental health of a school, and how can principals and counselors best collaborate with each other to help sustain the needs of who's around them? Melodie: I would start with principals need to prioritize their own mental health. joey: Hmm. I Melodie: mean, that old adage of it's better caught than taught is- Mm-hmm … applicable here.

If you have principals who are prioritizing and practicing some of the concepts that we teach to students, like SEL- joey: Yeah … Melodie: um, or taking mental health breaks and being honest about that, "I'm taking tomorrow off, and I'm physically healthy, but I need a mental health break." Right. That is also going to signal to their employees, to their teachers, "Oh, it's okay for me to do this, and my principal prioritizes mental health.

So I know- Mm-hmm … I am not in a good space mentally. If I show up to my classroom today, it's also going to trickle down to my students, and we're going to create this culture of poor mental health because it started where? It started with the principals." So to communicate that by prioritizing their own mental health is the first step. And then allow your employees to take that time too, right? That should be the expectation. You should be checking in with your employees the same way that teachers check in with their students.

Mm-hmm. "Oh, I know this about Joey. He looks a little off. I'm gonna go check in with him. Oh, man, I'm sorry that happened to you. Have you considered just taking a mental health day, just take a day off?" When's the last time a principal said said that to you? Yeah. joey: Not any of mine, nope. Melodie: Mm-hmm. So, explaining that in your meetings, explaining that this is the expectation. We are humans first, and I care about you and your mental health and your family health. And yes, this is what we do, but if we aren't our best selves, we can't give our best product and help our students, right?

And then lastly, I would say prioritize those meetings that we've talked about. if principals are the ones to suggest some of these things and to make time and space for some of these things in schools, it will happen. To say, "Hey, I've noticed that this relationship between teachers and counselors could use a little bit of improvement, so here's what I'm suggesting. We're going to do an entire session at the beginning of every single year where counselors can explain their roles, the systems for supporting student mental health, and I'm putting you in charge of that.

And then monthly, you're going to visit every block of students or every block of teachers." Setting up those meetings, prioritizing those meetings specifically about mental health. I'm not talking about- Student counseling, I'm not talking about student behaviors, although behaviors and mental health do overlap some. I'm just talking about mental health, prioritizing meetings about that. It can make or break the culture of a school. And to your benefit, I hear a common thread in all of these principals that you're meeting with.

Yeah. They're doing something. They're thinking about it. They're not passively sitting back and doing nothing. They're doing something. So that's where you start. It might not look exactly the same across every single building, and what might work in one building might not work in another, but do something. Doing something signals to your teachers and to your students that you do prioritize mental health. We are an evolving society, right? Mm-hmm. Most of us are evolving, and I do truly believe we're all doing our best with the information that we have.

And so maybe some principals just don't know yet. Right. Maybe they don't understand the effect of mental health on their building, and their lack of prioritizing or vice versa. But someday I truly believe that they will. I have to believe that they will, and they'll evolve, and things will change. It might just be a little bit slow going. joey: And as you mentioned, we are gonna talk about the future of education as you see it momentarily. But before we get there- … I do want to go back to your research. Building up the suspense. Let's go back to your research for a moment, because I know that you have taken

the time to interview many practitioners across Washington State, for example, as part of your dissertation, and I want to hear a little bit more about the subject of the research that you were going into with them, and what you have learned from those different engagements, if you could share that with us. Melodie: Yeah. So I interviewed educators across Washington State with this focus of how can teachers and counselors collaborate better to support student mental health. Going into the research, the literature review elucidated that we actually know a lot about what does not work in this relationship.

Some of those things that don't work are role ambiguity. Like, teachers don't quite understand what their role is in supporting mental health, which leads to burnout. Like, "What? I'm now in charge of supporting student mental health too? I can't do it all," you know? joey: Right. Melodie: Uh, role conflict where- Counselors may tell teachers, "This is your role," and they say, "I can't do that at the same time as doing this." Um, a hierarchy where sometimes teachers feel like counselors hold more influence over

their own classrooms than they do, and just that power struggle between them. So we knew what did not work. My focus and my research was more optimistic. What does work? Let's get to- Right … the mechanisms within schools that do work. And that elucidated quite a few different ideas. Mostly, like I mentioned before, it was separated into what works inside a teacher's classroom, what works in the collaborative relationship, and then what works in systems school-wide.

And some of them are expected. Like within a teacher's classroom, we understand that they first and foremost build relationships with students. And using some of the mechanisms that we've talked about here, just having informal conversations. Some of them are more formal, where teachers will hand out papers at the beginning of the school year so they can understand who is this student, what is their likes, what is, what are their dislikes. They also use some of this information to gauge that baseline. So who is this student? How do they normally act, and how can I tell when things are really off?

So , this is the major finding-- The collaborative relationship between teachers and counselors does not start when collaboration starts. It actually happens much earlier. If teachers aren't focused in finding or supporting student mental health, it's gonna be difficult for them to collaborate with counselors to support mental health. So when they understand that inside their own classrooms, then they can provide that collaborative experience for counselors. Within the collaborative experience, some of the major findings were the fact that teachers want that in-person communication as opposed to the digital communication.

So when they go collaborate with counselors, they want to do it face-to-face. And then in the school-wide systems, it was more of the fact that There has to be school-wide support for teachers to support mental health. joey: Yeah, yeah. And Melodie: there are many places and figures, like peers, using other students to help support mental health, or using outside community organizations. If there are organizations around your school that can come in, whether it is peer support or mentoring programs, or even mental health therapists, using that outside support inside your school, it makes your

job as a teacher a whole lot easier. joey: My biggest undoing when I was teaching middle school is that when I did see, for example, that one student who was joking about being a future shooter, when I brought that down to the school counselor, she says, "I don't have enough evidence to follow up on that, so we're just gonna dismiss the case." My answer was, "Well, if you're gonna dismiss it, then I will have to do something about it," because like you said, sometimes teachers feel like they have the personal credo because of their own experiences to step into those roles. Right. I said, "If you dismiss this, I will find a way to look into it more."

And she looked at me dead square in the eye. She pointed her finger at me and she said, "You stay in your lane." Melodie: Mm, mm-hmm. joey: And I think because of that, again, that role ambiguity- Melodie: Mm-hmm … joey: I didn't know how to help. They did not want to help, and there was so much friction with that where I was told that the reason, one of the reasons why I was let go, I was actually never given a reason, I just had to deduce from talking to other colleagues afterwards. They said, "You were causing way too much friction with the school social worker, and she was queen of the school. She did not like you stepping into her lane all the time."

Melodie: Yeah. Yeah. I'm so sorry that happened. I'm sorry for your school that that happened. Um, yeah, we gotta learn more. We have to do better, and I would say to that counselor, I hope that there has been some evolution, right? I hope that- joey: Yeah … Melodie: she has learned. I hope that she's read some of the literature about these relationships and how important your job and your role as a teacher is to her role. Yeah. With that reciprocal relationship is important for her own success. So my hope is that she is doing better. joey: Absolutely. Thank you for that.

And I, and I think about these situations that were happening in November 2019, and how education has changed- Wow … in just the months to follow, the years to follow. I would be super curious if I were to go back to that school and just be like, "What is it like now?" And that brings us to our last question. So what a great conversation this has been. And in thinking about some takeaways from today's conversation, what are some points that you want our audiences to look away from? And my special question is, what do you hope that pre-service educators understand about the future of education as you see it?

Melodie: let's start with the future of education- Okay … 'cause that's, that's more in theory. We have AI, right? AI is coming into the world. Even this year Melania Trump has out-rolled AI robots as- I joey: just saw that for New York City or New York State, I think Melodie: educators. Yeah. It's interesting, right? What will society be like in 10 years? We don't know. Maybe society is run by AI, and all problems are solved like the Scythe novel. Who knows? Mm. But what we do know is that we will still be working with humans.

Somebody has to teach humans how to be human. So even if all problems are solved, and students are being taught by AI how to do math, which I don't even, I think that's an oversimplification, right? Our job as teachers will be to teach students how to use math in a human way, or it will be to teach students how to be human altogether. How do you control yourself as a human? How do you find purpose as a human?

How do you find meaning in life as a human? How do you take math that we're learning inside the classroom that AI is now teaching you, and find a direct correlation to what this means for you in your world as a human outside of school? Maybe this is an optimistic point of view, but I don't think teachers are going away, because we will always need humans to teach humans how to be humans. And what a great high calling for our life. What a great high calling to teach young malleable minds how to use their strengths

as humans to be the best of humanity. I don't think there is a higher calling. I think that is what we are meant to do in our world, is to teach humans how to be human, and many of us are already doing that in our classrooms alongside teaching ELA or teaching math. But I do think that is the future of education. Some takeaways for this. I would say that you do have agency as a teacher, and you have a choice whether you will support mental health in your classroom or you will not.

And you are not going to unintentionally support mental health in your classroom. You have to make the choice to do it. You have a choice in that matter. If you are going to choose to support mental health, you have to use other people to do this, and one of those key roles is a counselor, whether we get along with a counselor or not. Some of this we can improve ourselves. We do need teammates in this. We need the counselor to be on board as well. But recognize the differences here in the way that we prefer communication.

We as teachers like to talk through our ideas in safe spaces in person. Counselors don't prefer that. So we can keep butting heads if we want to, or we can find strategies that inside our buildings work. Right offhand, I think some of those are intentional meetings that you as a teacher can start seeking. What are these opportunities that I can intentionally as a group to maximize my counselor's time that we can support mental health by setting these meetings. Another thing is principals.

Principals, you are key roles in supporting mental health in your buildings, and that starts first by how you prioritize your own mental health, the language you use to your employees, to your teachers about mental health, and that will trickle down to our students. Don't give up hope. We are in a mental health crisis still, still in our country, specifically in our middle schools, that if we are going to make any impact or make any change, we are going to have to learn how to work together.

And so I hope some of the research that I provided today and some of the research that I will in the next few months publish will help us as school figures. Some of the best people that I know in the world are you, those within schools. I hope it'll help us support our students a little bit better. joey: What a mic drop. Thank you for that. So that was Dr. Melodie Workman. Thank you for joining us today. As a reminder that the way forward from our school mental health crisis is the knowing that all roles are capable of upholding humanity within our classrooms.

Thank you for joining us today. Thank you for joining us on the Classroom Narratives Healing and Education podcast. If today's episode inspired you or made you think differently, I'd love to hear from you. Drop a comment or review wherever you listen to podcasts, and stay connected with us on the @classroomnarrativespodcast over Instagram and Facebook. Remember, together we can transform our scars into stories in education, one conversation at a time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Different Drummers: Rethinking Inclusion Beyond Labels with Dr. Alice Hammel

    Nov 18, 202643 minAudio

    πŸŽ™οΈ EPISODIC SYNOPSIS What if the student who seems disengaged is simply experiencing the classroom differently? Dr. Alice Hammel joins Classroom Narratives to challenge deficit-based assumptions about disability,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Caring Without Healing: John Whitehorse on Boundaries, Burnout, and the Personal Work

    Nov 11, 202633 minAudio

    πŸ“ Episode Synopsis What happens when caring for students begins to feel like responsibility for healing them? Dr. Joey Weisler sits down with ceremonial healer, teacher, filmmaker, and co-creator of the Natural Trauma...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. From Fragmentation to Flow: Reclaiming Attention in an Age of Distraction (Featuring George Molakal, Bryan Throckmorton, and Professor Lalit Johri of MindSpring Innovations)

    Nov 4, 202658 minAudio

    πŸ“ Episode Synopsis What happens when a child’s difficulty focusing becomes a belief that they simply are not smart enough? In this episode, Dr. Joey Weisler speaks with MindSpring Innovations CEO and co-founder George...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Beyond the Baton: Lessons from the Music Classroom with Dr. David Gregory

    Oct 21, 202655 minAudio

    πŸ“ Episode Synopsis What do students remember decades after they leave our classrooms? According to legendary music educator Dr. David Gregory, it usually isn't the lesson plan. Drawing from more than fifty years in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Showing Up Beyond Good Intentions: Teaching Presence in an Awkward World with Jen Marr

    Oct 14, 202646 minAudio

    πŸ“ Episode Synopsis After tragedy, many people want to help - but few know how. In this episode of Classroom Narratives, Dr. Joey Weisler speaks with Jen Marr, founder of Showing Up LLC, whose work supporting the Sandy...

    Credit the people on this episode