Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

CINEMA GEEKS

CINEMA GEEKS artwork

Western Retrospective: The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance

Apr 10, 202651 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Today on Episode 237, the guys continue their Western Retrospective with their final John Ford film, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. Where will this film rank amongst the other two John Ford-John Wayne team-ups? Tune in to find out! Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on X! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark! #UNLEASHTHECINEMAGEEKINYOU!!! #CinemaGeeks #Westerns #WesterRetrospective #TheManWhoShotLibertyValance #JohnWayne #JohnFord

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hey guys, this is Rob Paulson, and you're listening to the GeekCast Radio Network. Hello and welcome to episode 237 of the Cinema Geeks. I am one of your Cinema Geeks optimists, Solo, and joining me as usual is Dan. Hello. Hey, how's it going? It's going well. We are back in the Wild Wild West. I feel like I should put a Will Smith sound

clip here, but a different Wild West, I guess. We're back talking more John Ford today. So we've started a Western series a few episodes ago. If you haven't caught up with the other episodes, we do have an episode on Stagecoach and an episode on The Searchers, which are both John Ford films. And now we are covering our third. And final, I believe final film for John Ford, which is 1962's The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. Before we get into the facts about this one, Dan, what

are you thinking after the first two John Ford films? What's your history with The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance? And set the stage for us a little bit here. Oh, yeah. So Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, as we talked about previously, was one I had seen before. The Searchers was the stagecoach. Oddly enough, stagecoach, the earliest one was one I had not seen. But it has got me actually kind of intrigued, similar to how Alfred Hitchcock got us into watching more Cary Grant films. I've

actually started watching other... gone ford movies a few other ones but i've overall enjoyed it even if i haven't loved all the movies i think you know if with stagecoach i think i ended up enjoying that more than i expected searchers i think i like more than you but still had some issues with it and going into a man who shot liberty valance i saw it i saw previously it's been About a decade or so. I honestly didn't remember much about it. Outside of the ending.

Which I actually knew before I ever saw it. Because it has a pretty. I mentioned previously. There was a special I was watching. That brought it up. The ending. Because it has a pretty famous tagline. Regarding when the legend becomes fact. Print the legend. And it utilized that. It was basically a TED talk before TED talk. So. Going into this, I was like, I didn't remember much beyond that. But now also being able to watch many more Jimmy Stewart films and stuff like

that. So I was thinking, wow, Jimmy Stewart and John Wayne, they're just so different figures. And I've also been reading more about both of them. So I was intrigued with that back knowledge of going into this and interested to see how that would shape my experience with it. So I was intrigued. But I believe this was a first -time watch for you, if I'm not mistaken. Yeah, this is another first -time watch for me. I was intrigued now seeing two John Ford and two John Wayne films before that. Also having some knowledge,

obviously, about a few Jimmy Stewart roles before that. Trying to see how those two would kind of interact and mesh together and how that would work was intriguing. But yeah, this is definitely a first -time watch. I also want to get out of the way here out front. This is... almost a 65 year old film so there may be some spoilers uh that come up We're talking about the ending and things of that nature. We probably will touch on that at some point. So if you have not seen The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, pause this, go watch the film, and then come back and listen. Because it's 65 years old, and I feel like we

should just have free reign to talk about anything and everything when it comes to that. So before we get into all of that and our thoughts further, we're going to let Dan set the stage with some facts about The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. We're going to watch the film and come back and discuss. So we'll be right back. I shot the sheriff, but I did not shoot Liberty Valance Pilgrim. But the question is, who did? As we conclude our John Ford block of the Western retrospective with the man who shot Liberty Valance from 1962. In the film, Senator Ransom Rand Southerd, played

by Jimmy Stewart, returns to a small town of Shinbone with his wife, Haley, for a funeral of a little -known man, Tom Donovan, who was played by John Wayne. When reporters ask why, such an important man would attend, Star Trek reveals his real story of his rise to fame. Star Trek tells the story of arriving as an idealistic lawyer, but running into Liberty Valance on his very first day and being beaten nearly to death. Sardard attempts to make a life out of his new home as Tom Donovan questions his fortitude for

survival. Sardard and Ransom have a bit of a rivalry, but they both agree the need of their territory to become a state, which raises tensions with Edward E. Valance and the ranchers that hired him to quell those attempts. After Liberty Valance nearly kills Dutton Peabody, the owner of the town's newspaper, Stoddard finally faces Valance and shoots him after being injured. The achievement makes him an instant folk hero, and the town uses that status to propel his election to ensure statehood. Stoddard feels uneasy about using a murder to gain political power, but at

a rally, Donovan reveals the truth. Stoddard didn't actually kill Valance. Donovan secretly shot Valance from the shadows to save him. Donovan sacrifices his own happiness and future, including his chances with Haley, to ensure Stoddard can become the symbol the town needs. We didn't go back to present day as Stoddard reveals the truth to the newspaper who prompted this trip back to memory lane, who then tears up his notes because when the legend becomes fact, you print the legend in the old west. This is an adaptation of a 1949

short story by Dorothy M. Johnson. It's also the first occasion of John Wayne calling someone Pilgrim. Despite that historical fact, upon its release it was not well received, perhaps because it was more of a downer ending, maybe the limited sets, whatever the reason, throughout time it has garnered more and more respect, often being listed as one of John Ford's best and best American westerns. So where do Kevin and I stand? Are we more aligned with the contemporary reviews, or do we find ourselves finding that this has

aged well? Back to Kevin and myself to discuss. Thanks, Dan, for setting the stage. So now we are free to kind of unleash here a little bit. I wanted to give you a question and then let you kind of give your initial thoughts here. One thing that I was kind of... intrigued on early on is this is a 1962 film we've spent a good portion of the last what feels like two years watching classic films we've talked about

it ad nauseum probably at this point the hitchcock the carrie grant and now you know a few john ford films and we've seen a lot of black and white we've seen some color we've seen some different stuff so obviously there is a an choice made here that were in 1962 to film this in black and white and there's a lot of talk and a lot of different sources cite different things i think i've heard like six different reasons for why it was shot in black and white which all conflict with each other and some of them make like the studio seems to have one inclination

for why that is john ford seemed to have made some statements as to why it was A few different people involved have made different statements. What did you think about their choice to film this in black and white, both good and bad? And then what was your just kind of initial thoughts and initial take 10 years later watching The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance again and kind of after we've seen the previous John Ford and John Wayne collaborations? It's interesting because when you said 1962, because when I wanted to go watch this, I didn't even look at... the year it was made like okay let me go watch the man

who shot liberty valence and i was going back and i was like looking at it i'm like wait this was 1962 that's crazy and then realizing that both like john wayne and jimmy stewart were more to the like i thought they were being like aged up for you know the the more present day scenes well i can obviously not john wayne because he's not in the more present day scenes but i thought jimmy stewart was being more aged up for the present day scenes but realizing that it was more of the opposite because he was like in both of them are in their in their 50s at this point

um so i was actually surprised by that so i do feel like within keeping it black and white it does it feels more in this like time period wise, like it exists along the same side as, as something like the searchers. And I know like similar to you, I saw like some of the people mentioned some of the reasoning was that it allowed Jimmy Stewart to play younger and John Wayne to play younger because Jimmy Stewart's meant to play this younger individual who is just graduated

from being a lawyer. So like trying him to do that in more of a, being in color at that time, maybe it wouldn't work as well. I actually think it was the right choice because thinking even back to the searchers, we talked about like how that part of the issue is like how sometimes the showcase of time there wasn't as effective sometimes because of it was, so obviously maybe it was a bit too much. Here was obviously two distinct periods, so it was a lot easier to pick

up on. If it was if it was more, you know, if it didn't have the sheen of black and white to hide behind itself, like we saw, I think sometimes in some of the classic films we watched, even some of the Hitchcock films, when they try to make some individuals look younger or older, doesn't always look great. So I think, you know, whatever the reason, I do think ultimately it makes it a better film. I think it especially because this is a movie. So it is. designed to

look back at a younger america like it's all about looking back at the past so having it within that black and white feel i think makes it allows that viewpoint to stay i think more accurate i guess not accurate but i feel i don't know i think it's the right choice ultimately um so yeah It was interesting because, like you said, there were some statements about the aging process and making that easier in black and white. I know John Ford made a couple different comments

about how he had a deeper appreciation for the art of making something in black and white and that there was more artistry in it, trying to play and deal with shadows and what they can do. I know there was a mention that the shootout sequence towards the end of the film, some people said, wouldn't have worked in color. yeah as far as that goes but then there was also quite a few folks that said that none of that had anything to do with anything and that it was the studio that like basically didn't give them enough funding to do anything else and they're like that it was do this or or don't make the movie so i don't

it's hard to say like who's who's right or wrong i mean it does force john ford to do something i guess i haven't seen i've only seen these three films obviously of his but it seems like one of the things that his trademark was you know these great shots of of the west right like a lot of his films are in the monument valley and really kind of taking in the scenery of what makes a western film and obviously doing something more in black and white takes away a little of that ability but i don't know if this film necessarily needed that based on you know what we get here

it's clearly adapted from a short story they they film this completely what seems like i think completely on sound stages in in hollywood And it does remind me of what we were doing with a lot of the Hitchcock films where you could clearly see this being portrayed on a stage. Just because, you know, outside of a couple brief things, you basically have... a couple sets right like you have a couple different rooms that we're we're in and you can definitely see this happening

on a stage with people coming in and out of the doors and switching only a couple times so like i i don't feel like we needed the western expanse necessarily and the scenic shots in this one so i'm fine with the black and white i also do think it clearly had to help a little bit since these two are both you know in their mid 50s during this and they're not playing characters in their 50s like granted we do see that there's different cites citations as far as how much time passes I know Wikipedia says that this is a 25 year flashback but I also read something that if you read up on like the listing that

they give for Jimmy Stewart's characters and the different positions that he holds that it comes out to be more in the 30 like 31 or 36 years based on all the different things so like we're dealing with a quite a large time jump here we're not just going five ten years you know into the past or into the future however you want to look at it but you know we're talking about a significant like a third of somebody's life or a fourth of somebody's life into the into the future so i i kind of get that as well what was your overall take you know watch you said you watched this 10 years ago you didn't remember as much except for the end as you watched

it did some more of it come back to you and kind of what was your initial take on on how much you liked it this time so i think Some of it did come back to me, like the structure of it, obviously, Jimmy Stewart going back, telling his story and going through. And it was interesting going through this and watching the two John Ford movies before this with the mindset of the elements of what hasn't worked for me with John Ford up to this point. Like some of the humor

of John Ford didn't necessarily work for me. But honestly, a lot of the stuff. that hadn't worked for me in the past did work here. And a lot of things that he was known for, obviously, with Searchers and Stagecoach, we had those. You mentioned how this is very much on a stage. It doesn't have those scenic scenes. It is not within the New Mexico scenery. It's not on location. It doesn't have those insane stunts or anything

like that. It's much more low -key. But I think within that, it ends up being a much better story in a lot of ways. And I think it helps that you have someone like Jimmy Stewart. I think he brings a lot to this in a lot of ways, his presence. And generally the story of like, there's, I think, an intriguing conflict here. And there's some things I'm still working out because there's part of me wondering, like, do I ultimately agree with what it's trying to say? But, you know, this idea of. Because you do see this kind of

this battle of almost like, you know, masculinity within this because you see Jimmy Stewart being, you know, coming out into the West with his ideals of law and order and being up against this Liberty Valance individual and thinking he can use that to try to take him down. But obviously, John Stewart, not John Stewart. a different person John Wayne you know his Tom Donovan telling him he needs a gun and and him like kind of having to kind of go down that route and it's it's interesting

because it's like you know what's what's the right path and then the idea but I do think it's interesting because it's like everyone here is like living within the lie and I think it does talk about a lot about kind of how much about the America facade is, is built upon a lie, but it kind of doesn't have to be, you know, a bunch of this is about, it's built on the fact that this is, I don't even know if they even talk about what territory, I know it's, it says they're trying to get statehood, but I can't even remember if they even specify what state they're even in. No, it's, it's not, it's not mentioned. So,

it's, in order for them to get statehood, they have to kind of build this lie, which ultimately they need to do. It's, it's, it's in the betterment of, of everyone for it to become a state. And in order for that to happen, it's kind of you're utilizing what is ultimately a lie for that. But is that okay? So I think there's just an intriguing dilemma there that's a little bit more complex than what we've gotten so far. You also don't necessarily have the amount of racism that we've dealt with in the past. So that's

also helpful. And also, I think Lee Marvin is fantastic in this. He is that great bad guy. really want to hate him he he's got a great presence to him and he does like him and like john wayne have a good balance i think the the three -headed monster of himself john wayne and jimmy stewart like do work well again like i there are some things i i struggle with because it is interesting it's like the way they kind of um got to like under jimmy stewart and like you know you see

that john wayne is always you know kind of uh always kind of coming about on top but ultimately he doesn't in the end and i do question like would he make that sacrifice would he do that and that that's something i i i've wondered as well but i do like i am there's a lot about this i really like and a lot about i'm super intrigued by and like i said i think it asked really interesting questions even if it is a much more like stripped

down movie and maybe because it had to be at the time because like you mentioned with the studios or whatever that may be which is interesting because you know John Ford was like the golden boy at the time and maybe he was like you know as things things change and he was it was time was running out whatever it could be but ultimately that I say all that to say I rather really I really enjoyed this I think even with some of my quibbles I felt like it um it offers a lot to think about and it is I think hoisted in the

things I mentioned that I had issues with, even some of the comedy, like Andy Dufayne, I thought his comedy work, it was a good balance. Like he gave, he added a lot of character, had one of my favorite lines about like the jail, like how he was like, you know, we only have a jail, one jail, it has one room, doesn't lock. I sleep in it. And it's just like the way he kept going, the way he just kept going with it. It was kind of funny. I just, I don't know. I just had a good time with it. And I thought it, it had a really strong cast and yeah, I don't know. I've been, I've been kind of a labyrinth, but how

about yourself? What did you think of this one? Cause I know you have even very mixed on them so far. So did this change your mind at all? So, I mean, I'm overly, I feel like I was generally positive with. stagecoach like yeah it's true there's some there's some blatant racist nonsense in there that you have to like yeah true but but like overall i feel like it was a solid film i did have some issues obviously with the searchers um with this one though i feel like it's a weird dichotomy because it feels like it's i think

you use the the phrase stripped down or somewhat more simplified when it comes to the actual movie making part of it And then on the other hand, it's the most complex one of the bunch when it comes to how many different themes and questions and I guess thematic elements it weaves in and out. And I don't think it does it to a point where it's overstuffed. I'm not saying that. It gives you a decent amount of different aspects

to really chew on and dig into. I think one thing is... Obviously you mentioned there is this masculinity, I guess for lack of a better term, pissing contest almost that you would have throughout the film, right? You definitely get these three characters that are trying to decide who's going to have the most control over the area, who's going to wield the most power, and things of that nature.

So you have that string going. You also have this string going of... Jimmy Stewart and his I guess you could call it like this crusade to enlighten the community that he has found himself in whether it be teaching them how to read and teaching them rules about voting and America just in general and is that a positive is that a negative obviously like we can have ideas as far as present day and like you know democracy and things of that nature but like in this situation

is he disrupting the apple cart is it is the stuff he's doing worthy is he going about it in the right way so you got kind of that as an undertone i also think you have this what i find i guess the most intriguing out of all the different through lines is when you have what's coming across as somewhat pure or ethically morally upright individuals that are balancing the need

or the idea of resorting to violence in order to overcome this obstacle that's in front of them and i think that's interesting because we anyway it's not obviously the first film that does this it's not the last film that does this and and i think though it is an interesting way to kind of build that setup between and specifically like the difference between Jimmy Stewart doing

something in this or John Wayne's character Tom Donovan doing something in this to like resolve the problem that is Liberty Valance in this community right and how does Jimmy Stewart navigate that and still stay true to his morals or his you know sense of right and wrong and what does he resort to in in order to try to like do what he feels it's ultimately right for this community like at what cost and that kind of goes back

to like what i think what you were mentioning too with like america in general right like we might have like these has i don't mean we like dan and i but like as a country like we may have had ideas of where we wanted to get to and and what is right when it comes to freedom and rights and democracy and all this other stuff what were we willing to do along the way to get there and which of those things are justifiable and which ones are like a horrible like i i think that's a very interesting thing to tackle within this

film um and it was one that kind of had me intrigued throughout like i i feel like i knew what the ending was going to be the whole time for the most part like i don't think that's necessarily something that's difficult to figure out even if it wasn't spoiled for you like At one point, I think the biggest twist to me as a one point, I thought they weren't going to do that. And I'm like, wait, I'm like, I was convinced that Jimmy Stewart's character was going to think he had done something that actually John Wayne's

characters had done. And at first I'm like, Oh, are they just actually going to let Jimmy Stewart's character do that? And like, we're going to stick with that. And so I, that's the only part that kind of got me guessing is I thought that I knew how it was going to happen. And then. I wasn't convinced that it happened like that at first. I was like, Oh, they didn't do what I thought they were going to do when in fact they did. Um, and I'm talking in code, I guess, but, um, so, so that was something that I did find interesting, but what other thought, what did you think as far as like this balance between being the upstanding

citizen and, and resorting to violence in order to try to solve the problem of this state or this community? Yeah, it's, it's a good question. Like to do, do we, do we buy, jimmy stewart's progression to i don't keep saying jimmy stewart but his character's progression to accept the role of like okay i'm gonna make the decision and actually follow through and you know portray my morals and take law into my own hands and utilize this gun and and do it and i think i

think i i do because it wasn't uh an action that he took lightly and it was an action you saw the progression going through. He obviously got the gun and I think ultimately it's just you saw the reasoning before it. I think you saw him be basically almost killed and that's certainly going to push you a certain way. You saw that he was in a situation where He saw what the law

was at that time. He saw a sheriff that, you know, the likelihood of him actually standing up and doing what's right or the capability was limited. So, and then, you know, and then you saw like basically, you know, kind of being laughed at, being full of, and just the insanity of the world that he's living in. Like, you know, everyone's gone crazy, getting tripped and people trying to kill each other just because of a steak dinner. And it's just like going. But also coming to respect this town and the people in it and trying

to make a change. And then also seeing as much as he tries to change it, it gets pared down. And he's making his change. He gets the bar closed when they're voting. But then Liberty Valance is always there. He realizes no matter how many right turns he tries to make, Liberty Valance is never going to... allow him to go the right way. So I do think, and then ultimately obviously seeing his friend basically nearly killed, and

he's like, all right, well, a man can only take so much. So I do like that, the progression of it, because it's not immediate. It's one he struggles with. It's one that he kind of fights through, and he has to go through a lot, even to the point where he gets splashed with paint cans. And the fact that he does stand up for himself on occasion, but in different ways, punching John Wayne in the face, which I know how to feel good. So, yeah, I agree. Seeing him have to make that decision,

but also I think it was a good way of how they went about it. made sense and it wasn't like a decision made lightly i got two other questions specifically that i had for you um about the actual film here a lot of the reviews that i read i tried to read a few that were of the time when it came out and a few more modern ones but one thing that seemed to keep popping up on a few of them was people having different opinions

about the final 20 minutes or so of the film that basically happens after this shootout some people seem to be citing it as a really not perfect but like this this really great film up until that point and then they felt like the last 20 minutes really either dragged on or or undid some of the stuff that the film had done and some people that weren't uh didn't mind it as much like where did you fall on the the final 20 minutes or however long it is basically from

the shootout until the curtain like how did you feel they handled that last act I think that's what makes the movie what it is. Like I said, like, I think that's where it makes it more than just a, just another Western because then it becomes, that's where, you know, the infamous line of when the legend becomes fact print, print the legend. And in a way, you know, we're, we'll get in a retrospective, we'll get to parts of Western or that'd get labeled revisionist Westerns. I think when this came out, that wasn't really even a phrase, but I know this one gets kind

of labeled that by a lot of people as well. And, I think probably when this came out, that wasn't even a thought, but I think you see John Ford, and I don't know if that was the mindset at the time, but I feel like it makes it be more than just another hero story, because now it's like, okay, what do you do? And you can see him struggling with it. It's not like Jimmy Stewart's character. was living a lie he knew. He didn't know. He

thought he did it. But now he's stuck in this situation. Does he tell the truth? To me, it makes it more... Like you mentioned, it adds in all these interesting dilemmas now. It makes it much more complex without it being overloaded. I disagree with that. To me, that extra bit makes it up a whole other level. I think without it, it's fine. It's an interesting movie. You have some good scenes. I think it makes it far better for them to do it that way. Yeah, I agree. I

couldn't, I think it definitely elevates it with that last little bit. I didn't, and that's what I didn't know that last 20 minutes was coming. So that's where I was like, Oh, I was wrong about everything. But I definitely enjoyed, enjoyed that last 20 minutes. The other question I had for you, and it can also kind of parlay into some conversation about the supporting cast and things of that nature. But we do have a number of folks that we've seen already, right? Like we have John Wayne. We have Andy Devine and Vera Miles, who we've seen before. John Carradine shows up in a minor role here. So some of the

people we've seen in the other two films as well. You can speak to any of them, obviously. But I was curious how you thought the whole dynamic between Rance Stoddard, who I'll actually use the character name, that's Jimmy Stewart's name, and then Tom Donovan, who is John Wayne's character, and then I'm going to call her Haley Steinfeld, but it's Haley Stoddard, Vera Miles. who is actually the only remaining living member of this cast. She's the only one that's still alive. She's 95. And how do you think the dynamic between the three of those characters, work, didn't work,

added to the overall effectiveness of the movie? Interesting. Yeah, I was actually going to ask you what you thought of Vera Miles, because she's... Well, first, I want to hire her. The three -person kitchen that they were pulling off. for what seemed like a thousand people and yeah i don't know like they were pretty efficient i know right she's a good waitress uh and without even having the ability being able to get all those orders right without even being able to write them down

that's impressive um i guess when you know everyone it helps but um you know because you know we see like you mentioned we've seen her before and she's you know she has her own psycho that we had during our retrospective on hitchcock she was in searchers and now of course with with this so she's come up a few times um i mean i'm not gonna say say that they're like their dynamic together was like oh my god they like they had so much chemistry it was like it was of the time you know to me it falls in the relationship of of the time like it's like within this type of

film yes like a john ford type of romantic elements like i don't think i've ever i can say ever like seeing a movie with John Wayne. And I've been watching a few others outside of this retrospective where I'm like, wow, John Wayne and this, and this actress certainly have a lot of chemistry together. It always feels a little bit awkward. Like it, and that kind of almost feels kind of like the point. Cause he's that like rugged, like man guy who can't ever let his feelings show. But I think you, at least they do feel like they care like one another. And I do, you

do see how she, her character, how Haley interacts with. Ransom compared to that of Tom. And I do think like. They have feelings for one another in different ways, like it's not like I'm not like the romance here isn't the strength of the film by any chance, but enough is there to make it effective enough. So you understand the decisions. I do think the one area I question the most with the movie, it's like, do I believe Tom Donovan

would make that sacrifice? and like you know give up what seems like be the only person he loves for this lie like does where does that do i does do i do i believe that and that's the one area where i'm like i i'm not saying i don't agree with it i just i wonder and i think about and i'm not sure about but that's the one area where i'm like you know i that i think with the most questions for It almost relies on that one

shot or scene where she's tending to Rance's gunshot wound. Yeah. And she's comforting him, trying to do that. And we have Tom Donovan's character kind of walks in towards the end of that. And I wonder if they had done that slightly different or if they had... made that more of like the character walking in and hearing something out of context that he takes the wrong way and they would have like upped that a little bit

so that it was a little bit more convincing like that that alone that moment like set him over the edge and and made him question everything he had believed but i don't know if they did that as well as they could have um because then all of a sudden he's just like going on a rampage and like burning his own house down and everything everything like that like he kind of goes off the rails but it's like yeah I don't know if I fully bought into what had happened previously leading him to those decisions. Yeah. So I was wondering like if there was a way they could have done that in a, in a more convincing way.

But I agree. That's like the one, one of the one areas where I was like, he just went like insane. And I don't know if I'm understanding exactly why. Yeah. I think, you know, and we're supposed to see that. Oh, he sees that she loves him and that she isn't. Or is that like, okay. He sees that. her life will be better with him than it would be with him. And that I can somewhat understand because like, okay, well, she's going to make him a better person. I'll have, she'll have a better life. So that's what, like that,

is that more of a, than rather, because I never saw it as like that moment. You could see those, they're both in love because I didn't. Right. So that's where I kind of, I wonder, like, again, like, I don't think that moment where he walks in, it's like, oh, clearly he sees them both in love. And I, that, that didn't. as well so yeah I but like I said it's it's there's enough there that it works and but there are some elements where you do see like Tom Donovan certainly does care about like they do have their morals aligned

like he wants statehood as well like he wants he does have respect you know he will kind of you know he'll you know he'll rib him a little bit but he also doesn't he'll he didn't dominate him so like they do have this weird like respect for one another so it's they do have an intriguing dynamic i also wonder if there had been more like you have them interacting right like you have all three of them interacting at times you have different people observing different stuff that's happening you know how she's acting towards one versus how she's acting towards the other

but it all comes across as fairly like i don't know if innocence the right word but but fairly like just normal interactions where i wonder if they would have like dropped more breadcrumbs along the way or if it had been more convincing that there was like this really dynamic connection between them but because i don't know if that really existed for me like i feel like the same thing it kind of like leads it to well it's enough for it to work but it's not enough for it to be like the part of the movie that drew me in as much as the other ones. It all felt very platonic.

I felt like John Wayne and Bumpy had more chemistry than anything. They seemed like they'd be happy together. What did you think of how they handled Pompey's character or whatever his name was? That's as close as we're going to get to. I liked some of the little things they did. There was like the, when, you know, he goes into the bar and there's that little line of like, you know, you can't serve him. And he's like, why can't you serve him? He's just as good, you know? So

I like, I did like they had, they did address it and it wasn't, you know, it was like, they made note of it and it did give you insight to like, cause I was, I was kind of curious, like, what is, what is his role here? Like what, like how was it? What is the relation? Like, is he his worker? But, and he might be, but it seems like, is he his friend? But I, I liked, how it kind of addressed it, but didn't try to like overly romanticize it in a sense of like, so I thought, I thought that was a nice little touch they had to it. Did any other side characters

stand out to you outside of Andy Devine or Divine, however you say that? And, and you know, Briar Tuck there once again. No, like I said, I was a fan of him. I can't, well, the, our newspaper man, I think he plays a, Peabody. Peabody. He, he plays a really important role. he was really good too. He has that great speech at the, at the rally. And of course he plays that, you know, when he gets, he's the catalyst for what really, you know, goes down when he gets basically beaten

to near death. And I would say even, you know, Woody Strode, who plays Pompey, he doesn't. He doesn't say a lot, but he does have a really good presence. And I was like, I know him from something. He's in Spartacus. That's where I know him from. He plays a gladiator in that, too. He was apparently also one of the first African -American players in the NFL. Oh, wow. I did not know that. I could certainly see that. And then Van Cleef is in this. We'll probably see him in a few. He doesn't really do much in this, but we'll see him in some other Westerns

we'll go through. But no one really else stood out to me. How about yourself? I mean, it was fun seeing John Carradine for a split second. I mean, he comes in kind of as not a super important character to this, but he's like that Starbuckle guy who's trying to give the speech at the end. So that was interesting. Obviously, like Andy Devine, I think he's hilarious. Just something about the way he speaks and how he carries himself. He's a fun character to have involved, for sure. um i thought the doc did a decent job too like

i thought he had some cool lines there um when he was asked you know i hope they call me one day to check on you liberty valence like he actually was someone that was somewhat willing to stand up to him yeah and when he dies he's like yep he's dead it's like that that was that was pretty good like i said the humor in this i thought was actually good like the yeah some of the humor in searchers i thought was like really off -putting but here it it hit much harder yeah I read somewhere that this is the first time that John Wayne uses the word pilgrim in a film, and I don't believe

that. Is that actually true? 1962, he doesn't use it until then? It's possible. Like I said, since then, I've watched four other John Wayne movies, and they are before this, and he doesn't say pilgrim. There we go. They said he calls Rance Stoddard pilgrim 25 times in this film. I was going to say, it does feel like it's a lot. It's like, that'll be the day was the other thing. Is that just your thing? He just gets aligned with it and goes with it for a movie,

I guess. I thought just because based on my ignorance on John Wayne that he said that in every film he was ever in. He's got to say Pilgrim all the time, but maybe just this film. I don't know. I thought it was from... I haven't seen it. I wanted to go back and watch the Alamo, which I don't even know if it comes out before this or that, which is where I thought it originated from, but I guess not. um but only interesting which is also kind of interesting not about the movie but it's also like just the like the um thinking of outside the film because you obviously

have like john wayne playing this like oh he's the big bad bravado like he's really what a strong man looks like but also thinking in reality how like when world war ii came he was the guy that like was stationed inside and didn't go off and do anything and there's a lot of controversy regarding why that happened but Jimmy Stewart was actually the guy that did, you know, he flew combat missions. And so, you know, John Ford was also, you know, in the Navy and was at Midway. So was Lee Marvin, I believe. Yeah. So it's just kind of funny where it's like when you kept saying,

like, you know, guys like you. And I'm like, well, actually guys like him. I don't know. It's just like the veneer of it. It just makes you kind of think about things when, like, you know, there's a lot of people that would, like. want to be john wayne and like think that jimmy stewart was the was the um you know the geeky guy but yeah but in reality it's like actually when when the reality came he was the guy that was flying uh flying combat missions and yeah definitely read a bunch more about john ford not necessarily

being the nicest guy in the world during the no and apparently like uh he would uh he would bag on John Wayne a lot about not going over to the... But yeah, it's interesting. I was watching... Side note, I was watching Trumbo, which has someone playing John Wayne, and they make a note of that too. But anyway, I just was thinking... It just ties into the theme of this. I thought it'd be interesting. Yeah, I guess a couple times too, John Wayne was giving Jimmy Stewart a hard time because he's like, why are you the only one that John Ford doesn't pick on during the filming?

And then towards the end, he must have said something that... John Ford said something to Jimmy Stewart and John Wayne was like, oh, finally, you're in the club. You can get picked on too now. I had a question for you, and this is completely kind of, not necessarily, I guess it still is about the film, but I was watching this film and I could not stop thinking of a modern Western, I guess modern, I'm using very loosely, but a Western from our lifetime that seemed to have tie -in after tie -in after tie -in with this film. Did you get that at all? Did you pick up

on anything that made you think of a more modern Western that you may or may not have seen during your lifetime? I couldn't think of anything. For me, this film was screaming a lot of the same elements that I love or that I have noticed, and I've seen this film probably a million times, but Tombstone to me is all over this film. I find it interesting because you have a couple different things, right? First, you have the

good side having to resort to violence to help the area, right? I think you could take Lee Marvin's character of Liberty Valance and Powers Booth character of Curly Bill. There's a lot of parallels between those two characters. Hurley Bill is definitely the same situation where he's the one causing havoc in the town. He's the one everybody's scared of. Not that that hasn't happened in dozens of movies, but I definitely saw a connection

between those two. And then I also thought it was interesting when it deals with the idea of the legend of these different people. Obviously in Tombstone you have Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday, right? They're all about what the legend is about them versus the reality, and I thought that was interesting that we kind of get that same line in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. They even share dialogue, the two films, because in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance that we just watched,

there is a rare passage read from Shakespeare's Henry V that talks about St. Crispin's Day. which is a direct thing that we see doc holiday talk or doc holiday or johnny ringo johnny ringo maybe um who is it no i think it's doc holiday who talks about there's somewhere in i'm getting my things confused here but there's somewhere in tombstone where they they quote the same passage um and i'm trying to remember where it is but

like so to me that there was a bunch of things like they both have the same passage from Shakespeare like that can't be a coincidence right like it's not we're not talking about Romeo and Juliet we're talking about Saint Christmas Day's speech from Henry V like I don't think that's very like that's not one you just go to so like the fact that they have that the fact that they're dealing with the like the legend versus the reality the fact that we have like this this villain character who's kind of ruling the town out of fear the fact that we have like these good characters that are trying to Obviously, Wyatt Earp and

Doc Holliday have already resorted to violence before, but you still get that sense that we have the good resorting to evil tactics to try to win the day, so to speak. How familiar are you with Tombstone, and do you see some of those connections now that I'm bringing it up? You are far more familiar with Tombstone than I am. I've seen Tombstone. It's been maybe once or twice, so I did not make those connections. I was enjoying them as I was watching it. I was like, Oh, there's no possible way that the director

of tombstone or the screenplay person was not familiar with Liberty balance. I mean, I wouldn't doubt it. Cause I know like, you know, Liberty balance is up there as, you know, as a lot of people's favorite Western it's, it's noticed it is noted a lot. I didn't see anything like in, in the, I tried to look up some trivia on Liberty Valance, the managed shot Liberty Valance. I didn't see anything that mentioned Tombstone, but I'd be interested if I went and searched out Tombstone trivia, if I didn't find something that mentioned Liberty Valance, but it was definitely something that I enjoyed as I was watching that.

Cause that for a long time and we'll see what happens after this, this retrospective that we do, but Tombstone for a long time has been my favorite Western. So. I think it's endlessly quotable. I literally have a shirt that has Val Kilmer's character that says, I'm in my prime. Because that's something that his character talks about in Toons Gone, even though he's literally dying. So I feel like me at my age, I can wear that proudly now. But what other thoughts and anything you haven't got a chance to touch on

as far as the man who shot Liberty Val? No, that's pretty much it. Do you want to get into where we're headed next? Yeah, why don't you fill everybody in and what kind of direction we're going to go now that we've covered the three John Ford Westerns. So yeah, so we're just a little bit different. So we're handling our Western retrospective a little bit different than we've handled the Alfred Hitchcock and Kelly Grant, of course, because with those we kind of just went in order. So we did our John Ford block. Of course, we didn't do every John Ford Western because we would be here forever. And we're kind of we're

kind of doing it in threes a little bit. Well, you know, not exactly. But now we're going to switch over to our spaghetti Western block. And as I mentioned in threes, why not start with what is known as one of the greatest movie trilogies of all time with the man with no name trilogy? You know, the good, the bad and the ugly, the few dollars more. And why am I forgetting the other one? fish full of dollars yes uh we're gonna uh we're gonna talk about those uh next

week and then After that, we're going to go into a few other spaghetti westerns, including Django. And then lastly, for the spaghetti westerns with Once Upon a Time in the West, which going into this is actually my favorite western of all time. And I thought, you know, people wanted to follow along. I'm actually going to put up all the ones we have scheduled at this time. I'm going to put a list up on my letterbox, which is actually at Movie Revolt. So if you want to take a look and check out, that will be the ones we've listed so far. links to the episodes and then what we're

planning on. So with it being three films, you know, it might be a little bit longer because, you know, those are three movies and the, you know, good and bad, the ugly by itself is three hours. So, but I'm interested. I'm curious, Kevin, have you seen any of them and what's your, what's your, what's your knowledge of them thus far? I have not seen a single spaghetti Western. I don't believe. i'm not going to say that i've researched to make sure that's 100 true but i don't believe i've seen any spaghetti westerns okay i have seen the first one i actually just

re -watched uh the first one again recently um so but i'm going to go back and i've not seen the second film and i still haven't seen the good the bad the ugly i knew we were going to do this and we've been talking about this i'm like you know what i'll wait until we do that western retrospective yeah so i feel like i i should Definitely check the box for The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly. I've definitely used the phrase The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly on podcasts before and different things. I should probably now finally get around to watching the film that

that's coming from. I will say you probably have seen, you've definitely seen movies influenced by it because I know you're a Back to the Future fan and I think there will be scenes that will become recognizable pretty quickly. Awesome. Definitely looking forward to that. That's what we have in store for you guys coming up. uh hopefully you'll uh join us on this journey through the western landscape of film throughout the years it's going to be a fun and interesting journey that could take a lot of different twists and turns so i'm intrigued to see how this all works out like you go into the hitchcock retrospective

like obviously we hadn't seen all the films but you know like you know the hits right like we knew we were gonna rear window and north by northwest and some of those were probably going to be towards the top like i'm going through this one having no idea how this is all going to turn out and which ones i'm going to go for and which ones i'm not so it makes it that much more i guess intriguing for me so i'm definitely uh looking forward to the the journey so um dan if people want to get in touch with you uh on social media how can they do that You can just go to Comic -Con Chairs on most social media platforms, and I'm on there, except for Letterboxd, which I'm

at MovieRevolt. And you can search me out at OptimusSolo on most things. I think I'm just under my actual name on Letterboxd, so you can search out Kevin Thompson on there. That does it for this episode. Tune in next time for another chance to listen to more of The Cinema Geeks.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Western Retrospective: The Outlaw Josey Wales

    Nov 16, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Halloween Special: Rocky Horror Picture Show

    Oct 31, 202641 minAudio

    Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Halloween Spotlight: The Exorcist

    Oct 29, 202642 minAudio

    Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Halloween Spotlight: Carrie (1976)

    Oct 26, 202639 minAudio

    Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Halloween Spotlight: Texas Chainsaw Massacre

    Oct 24, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...

    Credit the people on this episode