Today on Episode 211, The Cinema Geeks continue their trek through the filmography of the iconic Alfred Hitchcock. This time they look at, the other of the two highest acclaimed films of the legendary director, Vertigo. Vertigo typically gets ranked higher than Rear Window on many all time lists, such as AFI and Sight & Sound. Are these lists spot on, or have they gotten this one wrong over the years? Tune in to find out! Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on X! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark! #UNLEASHTHECINEMAGEEKINYOU!!!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hi, this is John Delancey and you are listening to the GeekCast Radio Network. Hello and welcome to episode 211 of the Cinema Geeks. I'm one of your Cinema Geeks Optima Solo and joining me today, as he usually is, the Comic Concierge. How we doing, Dan? that are you Maybe tap it
a little bit to the left for the next shot. But she was doing this real interesting thing where like she would set the ball at the top of the ramp and then she would back up a step. And for someone who's never seen like Dragon Ball Z, she was she was summoning some type of power from somewhere with both hands and then would like do like a walk up and then hit the ball very softly and then it would go down the ramp and do its thing. So the first time she hit Two or three pins and you would have thought she
would have just like won the world series she was ecstatic so that was worth it so Today we are back at it making another step through our Alfred Hitchcock retrospective We just covered rear window last week and we are now on number seven of the films We've covered in his filmography and today we're dealing with the 1958 american psychological thriller which i feel like the descriptions for his films are not that there's no point. They're they're all similar genre right
like they're all some type of thriller or suspense so this one is vertigo obviously one of his most famous films. I'm based on nineteen fifty four novel as a lot of his films were based on novels or plays or things of that nature. The novel in english was called from among the dead. A screenplay by Alec Koppel and Samuel A. Taylor, and this one stars Jimmy Stewart, which we've seen before here a couple times as a former San Francisco police detective who has retired after an incident in the line of duty which caused
him to develop an extreme fear of heights accompanied by vertigo. He is hired as a private investigator to report on the strange behavior of an acquaintance's wife who was played by Kim Novak. As we talked about in episode 210, Dan, this is a re -watch for both of us. I believe there's only two of the films we're covering this entire time that are rewatches for both of us. That would be Rear Window and Vertigo. So why don't you reiterate or tell the listeners again what your experience is was with Vertigo and kind of how that led into your impression this time on the rewatch.
Like you mentioned, I did see it before, but it was over 10 years ago. It was quite some time over a decade, probably 13, 14 years ago. When I mentioned last time when I first watched it, you know, I I didn't have it didn't hit me I didn't walk away like odd By it like so many people are you know, it's it's tough So it was weird going into it this time because on one hand I have my past experience where I had mixed feelings towards it on the other hand You obviously have this is what a if I stop movie of all time.
It is loved by so many So it's like I had competing expectations going in it going into it Be watching it. Uh, I will say be watching it a second time I definitely enjoyed it more this time around than the first time I think for I didn't remember much of it. Honestly, like I like watching it It was almost like watching it the first time because there was very little that stuck with me for whatever reason but You know going through it. It was interesting like going through this retrospective because There's so many movies.
I try not to do it, but I keep comparing it to other films but going into this and with those expectations, those mixed expectations, there were elements certainly that I appreciated with the movie. I think I can understand where so many, especially directors, love this film because I think Hitchcock is doing a lot of interesting things here. We can get into that. But my apprehension or the thing that stopped me from loving it or
or having that same type of admiration. The center of this movie, it's a love story really, a weird love story, but a love story nonetheless. And that love story between James Stewart's character and Kim Novak, it is the driving force of the film. And I never connected with it. And the movie I kept going back to was notorious. And I found I saw a lot of comparisons with those two films because Like notorious you have a character
who has a job to do and during that job he ends up falling in love with the person he's supposed to be you know protecting or whatever you want to say and similar situations here Where I found the love story notorious very captivating and felt like the chemistry was there Here it just felt awkward and I know maybe that's part of it because it is an awkward situation and like the convoluted nature of what's really happening, but I never really I Don't know. I understood James Jim Stewart's or Jimmy Stewart's like admiration
for her but like that I never felt that returned and Beyond, you know, appreciating it on a technical level, score is amazing. It's so strong. I was actually listening to watching this in the living room and my son came out and said, can you turn that down? The music is making me so tense. I can't, it was bothering him so much. And he wasn't watching it. He just heard the music. And I think it was, it was very effective score, but I don't know. I didn't, I couldn't connect with it. I,
I, to me, you know, I don't want to say this is the worst movie we've seen in this retrospective. I don't think there's a bad film yet, but I didn't walk away from this thinking this is, and this is a bad thing to put on anything, like one of the best movies I've ever seen. I can understand there's some impressive use of the camera, some interesting techniques that Alfred Hitchcock is using, but I was never wowed. I was never enthralled. And this is a thriller, but I don't think I was never thrilled by it because I just couldn't get invested. In its central romance.
This is the central narrative that was driving it and maybe you have to let that go But I couldn't so because of that I walked away a bit mixed All right. So like you I had seen this before a little bit longer of a time stretch in between because I want to say this is probably close to At least 20 years ago when I saw it the first time as I talked about this is one of the ones that I actually watched with my mom which we didn't watch a ton of movies together like in my Teenage to adult years like we watched obviously
a ton of films together growing up as a youngster But we didn't do a lot of watching films together As we were both adults, I guess you could say so we decided to go through and we watched, you know quite a few old classic AFI Films that reached its top 100 this rear window citizen Kane 2001 a space odyssey we watched Philadelphia story, you know a couple a couple like that. I'm missing a few um, Chinatown, et cetera. And like you,
I had very not negative reactions from the first time I saw it. It was more of a confused reaction, I guess, because when I watched it the first time, I, I didn't understand the love. I understood the like, I understood it being revered as a good film. that I would never take question with. But at the time, I didn't understand why it was ranked as high as it was on so many different
lists. So I was underwhelmed, or I guess, or maybe the expectations were just too high for it to meet on the first watch. So I was very interested coming into this with having much lower expectations now because I knew I hadn't really gone for it hook line and sinker the first time. So I kind of came into this, the bar was lower. So I thought, Having that, you know, it might be very similar to What I experienced with the rear window in a way where I actually really
enjoyed that film the first time but even so watching it the second time within this retrospective having the conversations with you looking at it as we went through some of this other films like it got elevated even more for me when we watched it last week and so I was anticipating or curious if vertigo would do the same thing for me on a second watch and Unfortunately, if we have any listeners left, we're probably going to make them mad because it didn't work for me this time either. I agree that there's, I don't,
I would never call this a bad film first off. So if I come across in any way negative during this record, I'm still not saying this is a bad film. Like you said, I don't think we've seen what I would call a bad film in this journey. Maybe it's rough because I We just covered her rear window last week and I just go for that one so much that it was hard to come right after that one. But I respect the camera work. I respect
the filming of this story and how all the technical aspects are done. The score is good. I think the acting performances are for the most part great. I think. Jimmy Stewart in this is. I don't think there's many things you could say bad about his performance here. I definitely would prefer this performance over his performance in Rope. I don't think I would take this performance over his performance in rear window, but I think he's
good. I think it's like that's like a one A1B conversation as far as like his performances go. I think that's great. I think Novak is actually really fun to watch and interesting to watch. Especially with what she's tasked to do in this film, which is like almost play three characters in a way so like I not like literally but like there's definitely like three different parts of her character and I think it's very interesting how she takes that on and That I think she's
pretty successful with that There was definitely some moments about the story that I had forgotten when especially when it came to her character that Had forgotten and were like new to me again on this rewatch most of the other bits and pieces I had remembered there was just a couple things that Came about that. I was like, oh, yeah, I forgot they did this or something of that nature. What? Makes it not work for me overall though as far as like on I say not work I mean like not work as like something I would put as the
best film of all time and that in that like framework number one is And maybe it's because we've just covered a number of Hitchcock films and and most of them are thrillers or suspensions as we mentioned like I don't think we've watched one so far that is not considered with one of those two words and What we really talked about especially with 39 steps notorious like the first like Two three four films that we covered. I think we mentioned it a number of times in those episodes. We may
not have mentioned it as much in the more recent episodes, but that doesn't make it not true. But in those first films that we covered, I think we both really enjoyed how the pacing worked and how it seemed like there was not a dull moment. There was not a lull. Not saying that movies can't have those. Like sometimes you need that to like digest. You need that to like ponder on what the movie's saying and things of that nature. But I felt like in this film, more than any of the other ones we've watched, there were
some moments and times throughout the movie that we were going at a slower pace and I don't 100 % know if it was necessary or that there were certain things that lulled me almost out of it didn't take me out of the movie I don't I think that's too strong but just like made me appreciate how much I liked the pacing and like the the lack of wasted moments And again, wasted is probably too strong of a word too, but I think you get
what I'm saying a little bit. Like I just felt like there was moving, it was moving at a brisk or pace or at least at a giving us scenes and moments that all felt like they were important. Like when you go back through some of those earlier films, there's, and if you were tasked to like do like a re cut or a re edit it, like I don't think there's many moments you take out of any of those films. I'm not saying I, I'm not saying I can key in on moments that I would take out of this film. But I just got the feeling that there was something with that. It was making it drag for me a little bit. Did you have that effect at all on you? None. No, I can see where
you're coming from, because there's a lot of silence in this movie, like even more so than like rear window. There's like there's because, you know, Jim Jimmy Stewart, it's cameras following him. He's following her. And it's a lot of him driving. And there's a lot of shots of him driving and all the focus is completely on. Him and it's a lot of them just going around him observing and it's interesting watching this right after we're window because there's there's so much observation within this compared to Along with
with a rear window. I think the difference here though is there's not as much happening in that observation because you're Yeah, that person and it's in those scenes like it is there's it's a lot of like, you know That's what we're gonna drive over here Go to the cemetery, go to the flower shop and it becomes a bit repetitive. Uh, so I could, I, I do think those scenes, the sense of like, you know, editing, uh, today compared to back then, like it, or even some of the films that we've gone through so far, he did allow
those scenes to just kind of have just a steady flow to them where we're going to watch this car go from point A to point B and that's it. That's going to be like a good, a good drive up and. Uh, so I I do think and i've mentioned before I do appreciate his patience as a director because I don't think people talk about that a lot and we we've seen it with rear window and we saw it here, but I guess What the difference is here, I guess And there isn't as much I think
in the sense of what's within that patience Like not much is happening. It's a lot of just watching this woman and I think you know, the point there is obviously you're trying to Show that obsession. So he's slowly kind of being captivated by her. Yeah. Like, but, but when, for me, when not like not buying that relationship or like just feeling it almost more awkward than anything, it, it didn't lead to it. It didn't lead to anything
grandiose or where it felt like it, I don't know. I could understand. Cause like you said, it, it definitely takes time, but I don't feel like it ended up. getting any place eventually that I was all that enthralled with compared to past films. And I'm not saying I need something that's like going a mile a minute or action upon action. It just felt like there was some moments where I didn't understand why we were, I guess, pausing as much. I mean, I know some of it's intentional. Well, I mean, all of it's probably intentional, but I get like some of it makes sense and some
of it adds to some of the feel of the film. And it's not that it was slow. It was just like it. it felt slow. Like there's a difference between being slow and feeling slow to me. And I'm actually with you 100 % on the relationship between Kim Novak and Jimmy Stewart's character. Like I guess I had forgotten a little bit of how that comes about in the film. And I was watching this with my wife and I literally leaned over to her as soon as he, as soon as I think they, I don't
know if it was when they kissed for the first time or whatever the case may be, but I leaned over to her and was like, oh, well, I guess they've fallen in love really quickly and oddly. It just seemed like I didn't buy the lead up to it. Yes, he was watching her and things of that nature, but there wasn't enough to me interactions between the two that... Developed that enough for me to buy it and then I didn't think the chemistry Was there as much as I've seen with some of his
other characters in their relationship, so I'm with you a hundred percent on that that Didn't work for me either And it kind of and I get like kind of it makes sense because obviously she's playing a part She's supposed she wants him to fall in love with him. So that's part of it It's like that's kind of the whole plan, but then she was supposed to also actually fall in love with him Right now within that and I don't know if it's just maybe like if it's just Looking through it too much with modernized, but it's also like no she's in her early 20s here. He's 49 It's also made me feel really old because
he's 49 talking about retiring. I'm like that's one definitely lives in a different economy than we do but uh But yeah, it's interesting though because in rear window she's this there's a similar age difference, but it doesn't yeah come across quite the same Yeah, I think to that that relationships were in better because we talked about like just you know it one they have better chemistry and I think I don't know like I'm not gonna say but you know Jimmy Stewart had a bad performance, but I'll be even like going back and reading
some of the Reviews because when this first came out, it actually was far more mixed It was one of his more mixed films and throughout time like in a sense of like reaction from critics and then as time went on it became It became more lauded and things like that So I mean, you know, we're having a similar reaction and looking at some of those people did say like Jimmy Stewart in some places He acted really big here in times and I don't know if that always worked per se I can see that So there's another thing too.
Like I know everybody always says it's the what is it? It's the the how It is not the what it is or whatever the the Ebert quote Siskel or Ebert quote is that it's not necessarily you shouldn't get stuck in the details of a film or some of the you know plot holes or different things like that like you're supposed to feel and like enjoy that and I understand that to a point however I do have a problem when there's some things within the storytelling or plot mechanics to me that just when they don't make sense it
it in this case it does take me out of the film a little bit so and we're going to refer to a couple different things here, but the main one, which is the exact and I even knew it was coming and I still had the exact same reaction. So they open this film up. With his. Telling or kind of a replaying of what is causing him to have this extreme fear of heights and vertigo, right? Like they they they lay the groundwork for that perfectly. I'm fine. I'm there 100%, right? Like I feel that. the tension, I feel where it's coming
from, I buy why he's having this dilemma and this situation from a mental and physical aspect, right? Get all that. Then they have a sequence in his friend's apartment, I believe it is. I'm gonna get the character's name wrong here. Midge, is that his friend? Marjorie or Midge, right? So then there's a scene between her and Scotty here, and they're, they're discussing this vertigo
and the dizziness and whatnot. And then they're talking about taking these little steps, right? And he's stepping up on a step stool that has three steps, I believe. And he's talking about being able to do it little by little and he steps on the one and then he steps on the two. And then he gets on the third one, gets a little overconfident immediately the vertigo and the dizziness kicks in and he's basically falling off of the step stool or having an episode, right? And I'm buying it now even you know, I'm still with it. Like I understand why it happened I'm
seeing it them showing it like how much it's gonna handicap him and how much it's gonna restrict his abilities and I'm there for all of that and Then they immediately well, maybe not immediately but like within a very short time have sequences where he is going upstairs or Looking over cliffs and doing all this other stuff and there's no sign of him being scared or having vertigo or anything else and It seems like it's very convenient
for me when they play that note and when they don't and I don't understand why they don't play it at every instance not because it would become repetitive but because Like we've we've laid the groundwork that he can't even go up three steps on a stepladder So there's moments when he's way higher than that and It's not affecting him and that bothers me. It takes me out of a film in that respect because now I'm Anticipating it happening every time he puts himself in that
situation and when it doesn't It doesn't make sense to me from a story standpoint. I know that's getting like really like bogged down in the details or like Letting something that shouldn't bother me bother me, but they do it almost immediately and then they do it like two or three more times Yeah, I didn't have an issue with that because I I took it as it wasn't the three steps of the step stool It was he got off the three steps and then it caused him to look down Outside the window and it was looking down outside the window
would cause the right but there's another there's another situation where he goes up to Up another couple flight of stairs or something. I don't remember if it's the same sequence or like a little bit later, but he's he's on like a second third Fourth floor of whatever a building at some point. I can't remember if it's an apartment or if it's one of the other buildings But he looks out of a window down towards the cars below and it doesn't happen Yeah So like it was times like that where I can get where he can like trick
himself into like oh I need to go up these stairs because of something tense or something like I feel like there's some like he does towards the end like he's trying to go up the stairs because not the end I guess the the first time you think it's about to be the end when he's going up the the stairs at the wherever the farmhouse or whatever you want to call that like he has moments where the pressure or the the suspense of the moment or the the dire need of the moment will will require him to do that and he does it in a way like that he's triggered into doing
it without remembering that he has the condition and then he'll look down and then and they do show that at times where all of a sudden once he realizes what he's doing or where he's at or how high he is it happens But there's other times where he's going up that way and then even looks out windows down like a couple of floors and there's no sign of his dizziness or vertigo. And for some reason, that's a big hang up with me. I don't know why. I honestly didn't notice it. It wasn't. Gotcha. The other thing that bothers me in this one is I feel like there's very convenient
times where certain characters are either completely dropped from the story or picked up with like It seems like specifically Midge and Gavin. So Gavin is playing Kim Novak's husband and Midge is playing John Ferguson or Jimmy Stewart's, I guess, former relationship slash best friend, we could call her. And I didn't understand or
100 % get on board with how much of those guys, those two characters come and go. to the point where we have a scene or a sequence where Scottie has basically had a breakdown more so than he was already having, like when he believes there's something tragic that's happened and he's basically in a, I would call that a psych ward or maybe not a psych ward, but you know, some type of
medical building where he's trying to recover from his depression or kind of like almost like a catatonic state. And at that point, they decide to bring Midge back into the story. She's been gone for a while, but they bring her back in the story. She's caring for him, like meeting with the doctors, trying to make sure he's okay, like doing all of this stuff, like going above and beyond to try to like help him recover from this. And then after that sequence, we never see her for the rest of the movie. And it seems
to me. weird Like I don't know if there was a sequence I got cut that was supposed to be in the film later but it's it's weird to do that and have her like Putting forth all that time and then it's not like they don't have a they don't have a blowing up They don't have a like a difference of a they don't have falling out. They don't have a There's nothing after that Like we immediately switched to a sequence where he's recovered apparently from all that and she just is gone from the movie Yeah, I guess I didn't
yeah, go ahead but no go ahead I To me. I just took that cuz she asked the doctor how long it's gonna take six months to a year I took it as maybe she just at that point is like she she was there dropped him off, but it wasn't necessarily Her role to stay there the entire time. So I just took it as you know I can see that she's I kind of wish they would have done something then like something to like show like maybe on her way out or like something that signified that she was wiping her hands of it or giving
up on him or something, even though I don't 100 % buy that her character would do that, because we really get the feeling that she's hook, line, and sinker in love with this guy, in a way. Whether it's romantic love or just a caring friend love, she definitely goes out of her way to try to help him in multiple points in the movie. Yeah, I guess to me I just I get it but I also don't know if like that scene would really add anything to me like I don't know if I get actually to me it was like it was let's get to what the movie
is what what the focus is and at that point it's all about his obsession and I think the fact that he is not even like inclined to Reach out to anyone else or have you know, or have relationship with anyone else is I think more right of the fact that he's not If anything, he's not fully recovered. So yeah, I get it. Like I get like, it is, it is convenient, but I also think just the sense of, you know, sometimes it's like, does it really get you anything that you, you need for the story? And I don't, I don't know
if it would per se, but at least for me. Yeah, no, I get it. Um, another thing I wanted to get your opinion, like when he's going up the, the spiral stairs or whatever in that building to try to. Get to her before she gets to the top which is gonna ultimately lead to Her quote -unquote death sorry for the spoiler alerts for a 50 some year old movie, but Did you at all get a chuckle or a laugh at how they filmed the body flying
out of the window in that situation? It was pretty funny and I First I'm like wait was it a dummy and like we knew it was that was I know there was a twist I remember the twist I'm like, oh, maybe it was that it's a dummy but then I'm like I saw people that are people that were there Yeah, I thought it was I let it I mean obviously it's you know technology of the day But yeah, yeah, I'm not fault. It was it was it was pretty funny. It was it was and it was one of those
things where like almost like, Austin Powers asked her something like that. I think it was the timing for me. It's the timing from the point she would have taken her first step to the top level to the point where the body's already flying out of the window was like a half of a millisecond. And it was just like, it was very quick. So my wife and I were like dying for a second on that one. Yeah, not fault in the movie. The scream also, because the scream, it was one of the,
it was, it felt like it wasn't the Wilhelm Helm scream, but it was, it felt like one of those like really classic, you know, so yeah. Did you, did you, so the second time they're in that room, we'll say the tower or whatever. Did you buy the fact? Granted any nun in the dark is coming at you is probably scary But did you buy a hundred percent like that sequence of events when the nun appears and then we have our second? tragedy
in that tower I Don't know I'm conflicted on it cuz at first I'm like did she think I thought maybe in her mind She was seeing the ghost of the woman. She killed was that she I don't know like I wasn't fully Clear on like what where that reaction came from? I didn't at that point. It didn't seem like she was wracked with guilt or regarding what happened Yeah, it was a moment that I was confused at for like a couple seconds
like Wait, I missed something Yeah, I did think more could have been done to that because at that point it doesn't you know, perhaps you could say she's guilty because she's trying to make up for it regarding a Getting his love back, but it felt like she was guilty. She felt guilt regarding what he did what? What she did to him, but the wife that they murdered like that was that she seemed to like not even that even Really pass her by at all. It wasn't really something
that concerned her. So yeah that I mean, I guess it's at this point, you know I don't know if you spoil a movie that's older than almost, you know Forever you're sold. But right when that happened when she made that jump. I was like wait, did she think? She was being I don't know. It didn't work for me. That was part of it, too It didn't work for me because number one like you're saying it has to be there either has to be more guilt about what has happened or they have to Because for a long time they're playing
the fact that this character is being controlled is not the right word, but like almost like hypnotized through this real life person that she's related to. And that it's like this out of body experience that she's being drawn to these different places and like really affected by this, like almost like a supernatural presence. Right. And, but you lose any part of that when You learn the first twist and the fact that she's literally
just playing a role in all of that and it's all fake But I feel like if they would have like planted some seeds that like in the process of doing all that that she was like somewhat affected maybe by that maybe I would have bought more into like even even if they try to play it up as if like Somehow that connection was still Haunting her or bothering her in a way, but they don't do that either because they've basically like completely cut that off of the film because It's it's all a ruse that they're you know artificially
doing so I'm like if you don't have the connection to that and you don't have a sense where she's just like riddled with guilt and if the scares not Like if she wasn't in a precarious enough position for just a startled action to like Cause her to do what happens. So like I couldn't buy it I was trying to find a way to buy it like I literally was thinking about it for quite a few moments after the film like Which way do I need to interpret this for it to work for me and I couldn't find one yeah, I understand the poetic nature of it and like again, like how
it how it ties in to like, you know thematic resonance of the film, but You know the narrative piece the logic of it even like, you know, and if I was More with the movie at that point if if I was more engaged with it I could probably I into it more but it just felt like another situation where things were happening that seemed to happen and Not in ways that felt Organic enough for me in a way in a way that made me feel like
okay this makes sense regarding decisions people are making Yeah, like to me like they almost have to one way would have been to tie it back into like i guess the sequence where she jumps into the lake or something like that but like at that point we know what she was doing was you know intentional so like it's hard to make that tie in work anymore so i don't know any other like parts or side characters or anything else that you um that caught your attention or you wanted to discuss that we haven't had a chance to yet Yeah, so I mean I feel like I want to talk about some things I did enjoy we mentioned
the camera work But didn't get into it a lot, but I'd one thing I did like even those scenes we talked about where not a lot was happening I I did find the cat like how It's got use this camera here It was actually very similar to that aware window and he just the way he would track individuals and track a scene loud to play out I found that interesting and also A random thing I thought was really great was actually Mitch's office. I think it was her office and How it would use you mentioned like seeing a lot of heights but like what I noticed was you often
would see that like her window was wide open and You know, there was always that There is a lot of shots of the horizon in the distance and I thought that worked well with the movie in general like there's so many things like you could just not that making screenshots of a movie makes it good, but I could see which is why I understand why so many directors of this film because like the cinematography, you know, how it's, you know, utilizing that obviously to tie into the idea of vertigo. There's so many things you can point to and it's gorgeously made. But
within that, it's like getting, you know, a gorgeous package that is fantastic. But then you open it and like what's inside is a bit empty. And that's kind of what I felt like watching it. But I did appreciate that. I actually did like the character image. I thought she had a good balance. I honestly felt like her connection with Jimmy Stewart was much more, I felt it much more than elsewhere. And I got that more. But outside of that, there really weren't that many of the characters. She did create one of the
creepiest paintings, though, I've seen in film. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Then she's like so mad at herself for doing it. And I was like, well, you did that. That's like, how did you think that was gonna go? Also too, like the whole, the Gavin character, you don't get much about him, like he wants to kill his wife, but I don't know. I feel like too though, like, I feel like in that situation
I somewhat appreciate it though, because I feel like even though we don't get a lot about his situation and his wife, the the and he likes
his wife he just doesn't like this weird person who keeps flipping into so like I do appreciate the fact that like they don't really give you any breadcrumbs for that because I think so many films like to do that and it usually becomes too obvious but you're right like we don't get a lot with this character and he definitely does like like Mitch come in and then disappear and then like randomly come back in and like there's a lot of like bringing in those two characters in and out The plot they come up is pretty impressive
like all those the machinations they come up with in order to He's like, you know, he's like a super villain with everything he does So yeah, definitely commitment. I don't know big -time commitment on both people to pull this off It was interesting too. When like Kim Novak shows back up at first I'm like that's not the same person like I don't look anything. I like I'm like, oh they didn't like because I didn't remember what happened and I'm watching it I'm like you think they would at least get someone that actually looked like him know that for this part and then not And I'm like, oh, I'm an idiot. That is sir.
Like I didn't get but I think it was eyebrows Just threw me off. Yes. Yes Apparently in the 50s, they were way better at changing someone's hair color 100 percent, like very quickly than I feel like they are even today, because usually it's like a whole long process you have to go through. And it's like stages. They're just like, nope, immediately back to blonde. Probably probably the chemicals were a lot worse for you. More effective. Right. I do, though. That's why I give her character some credit, even though I don't feel like she had the same chemistry with Jimmy Stewart, as like we said, with some other
characters of some other films. the fact that she's playing the the wife and then she's also playing the wife that is crazy and then she's also playing this other character that's pretending not to be the wife like it was an interesting like yeah whatever whatever dichotomy is with three is that a trichotomy I don't know I'm making up words here but like it's like an interesting thing that she's tasked with and I think she does do a good job of that because like you I was completely questioning whether that was actually her or not Yeah, I think I don't have an issue
with her performance alone. It's just them and together Yeah, no, no, I agree and like and I like I said I know that's kind of part of it because it's It's because where she's supposed to be playing a part and then at the end that's all it's meant to be awkward but it just I was like, what am I investing in in here? And I like you said it's not what it's about. It's how it's about but the how it's about didn't necessarily Right all me as much and so again like we mentioned it. I'm looking at this picture in the sense of trying to understand it in the in the grand
scheme of what we're looking at Hitchcock wise and You know isolated obviously it's a well -made film. That's no question about it But I don't have the admiration or the it didn't have the impact on me personally as Even some of them most the movies we've gone through so far, right? How did you like the last thing and then I'll kind of get to some of my final thoughts But how did you like the I don't know what you would call it the like the sequence where it was like the animation slash. Like that that came out
of nowhere, but I kind of liked what they did with it. I like the ambition of it. I'll get like I do think there's a lot of ambition in this and that I appreciated. I don't know if it like I don't like the. Became a bit psychedelic in the second. Yes, that's the word I was looking for. Yeah, so, you know, hey, man, and wasn't quite the 60s yet. So I don't know if that helped, if that helped lead into, you know, what came first with that or like you saw, or what came next. But yeah, I did like the approach of it.
And I think it came at the right time. And it did give it a little bit of a different flavor as it entered into that third act. Yeah, I agree. I wasn't expecting it and I was like, oh, Alfred Hitchcock's like doing something new here. Like I haven't seen anything quite like this. Like I guess we got the flash camera sequence in rear window, but this is a whole different thing. Was there any other like trivia bits that you didn't get the chance to share or any final thoughts that you want to give for Vertigo here? The only other trivia bit, because I didn't know this beforehand, but apparently Julie Stewart wears
a toupee. I had no idea and I was and I was amazed by that because like in this he's like grayish hair but I guess he means that he went he started going bald during World War II and he was wearing it the entire time because I was always impressed with his hair because it's so like perfectly you know uh it's just like it is it's perfect it doesn't move but that's because he has a toupee which I just thought was rather I don't know it was interesting seeing that because I never would have guessed that so I wouldn't look at no impact on the quality of the movie or anything
like that was just It I watched it through prime and sometimes it shows up in that like trivia thing. Oh, I gotcha Yeah, I don't like I tried not for that to pop up, but sometimes it does I came up and I'm like, oh, that's Yeah, I didn't get a chance to watch any like the special features on this one, unfortunately But I did just because we've mentioned it in a few other ones just like rear window It does have a perfect score on Metacritic It does actually have a lower score on Rotten Tomatoes than Rear Window. I think Rear Window
was at 98 % and this one's at a 93%. But this one typically gets ranked higher on a lot of those AFI slash, you know, other publications that put out like the best of or the best films of all time. I feel like Vertigo always seems to score better than Rear Window for some reason on that. My thoughts, I was looking back through some of the comments, especially like the contemporary Critics and things like that and one of them kind of summed it up for me This was one of the
reviews that got posted in the New York Post originally and it said let's admit it right now Itchcock surfaces are so smooth. He thinks he can get away with murder in the logic and realism departments If you want to tear your vertical apart, it rips easily on the other hand There's no denying that James Stewart's unactorish acting carries a heavy air of reality into the picture and Kim Novak's Somnambulistic behavior called for by the script is something she can do to perfection It's doubtful that vertigo can take equal rank with the best of the Hitchcock studies It has too many holes and then it goes on to
say some other stuff. So obviously he's wrong because it does Get ranked as one of the best Hitchcock films But I do like I do agree with him that like if you want to tear vertigo apart, I do think it rips easily I do think there's some holes in there and but It's Hitchcock. So there's a lot of other good stuff that kind of negate this. I don't think this is a bad film in any way, shape or form. I think it's a good film. I think it's worth watching. I think if you haven't seen it, you should watch it. Probably not after this review because we've spoiled everything for you. But outside of that, I don't go ahead.
I just don't think I can put it like it's not going to rank in one spoiler alert for when we do our awards. It's not going to be in my top three. Yeah. I think it's movies any movie fan should see definitely But again, it's not I don't have the admiration for it. Like it's not like I'm a queer window I feel like after it like I could watch that again. Yes this one I I didn't necessarily feel that way. It's just like I'm I'll probably be good for another ten years or so Yeah, it's not one of those that I would watch
and say like I'm never gonna watch this film again like there are some times where I rewatch a film and It's either it either like I think the second watch is important. I don't know I was thinking about this the other weekend I don't know if I shared it with you or not, but I feel like the second watch is like where Where you determine if something's gonna be like in a regular rotation with you or if it's gonna be the last time you watch it like Yeah, I'll watch anything the first time and then the second time is I think where I don't watch a lot of movies a second time But if you watch it the second time, I think
that's where I usually make a decision where I'm good on that one Like hey, I should watch this every couple years or I need to show this to somebody next time I hear somebody hasn't seen it or something like that. So Yeah, maybe another another decade or so. I'll give it another shot but that does it for this review of vertigo we have three left to cover and that would be 19 I think it's 59 is North by Northwest and
then we have psycho from 1960 and the birds from 1963. Dan, North by Northwest, what's your experience? What are you walking into it with as far as baggage goes? That's what I have seen. It's still been a while. I think I, the first time I watched it was when it first came on Blu -ray and I bought the Blu -ray and I really liked it. Another one I really enjoyed. I remember thinking it was more of a like word. Vertigo or suspension. It's
just my taste I can't even say words But it definitely felt more like the summer blockbuster Alfred Hitchcock because it's there's a lot of big set pieces And so and so it felt almost like more bombastic, but it was a lot of fun So I'm interested in going back like you said that second watch to see like does it hold up? And you know, it was one of the first his cock films I saw though can looking back at what we've done so far would it and where will where will rank or like how does it hold up that i don't know so i'm really
excited to go watch it again and this will be a first watch for me as will the remaining films so i'm interested to see all of them this is also kind of interesting because starting with vertigo we are actually watching these like these are the these four films were released in order like there's no other films that he's releasing in between any of those it goes vertigo north by northwest psycho and the birds like That's his filmography one one right after the other. So it's gonna be kind of interesting to watch those in that respect as well So if you have any thoughts or feedback or want to let us know
why we are so wrong about our take on Vertigo Which I'm sure there will be plenty of people that think that there's a couple different ways that you can get into contact with us You can search out Dan and all of his other content by searching the comic concierge on most social platforms Just put that in there and I'm sure you'll find him He does a lot of great comic content, uh on a regular basis and what number are you now on your on your are you at 500 already? Oh for my your my yeah, i'm for uh at twitter I track and well all the social media is what
i'm reading. Uh, I am at like for the year 684 comics I was gonna say you made that goal of 500 and I could tell after the first month that that was gonna be uh annihilated Yeah, there's like there's a trend or hashtag on social media. My 500 comic goal. I don't know where it started from, but I was doing that this year so. So what is your actual goal now? Are you trying to hit like 2000? I don't know. I don't really have one. I just I'm just I like. Yeah, I just I'm
just reading I I'm crazy because I actually I do that and I actually have an Excel spreadsheet where I track all the comics I read by John and so it's But then I can get a pivot table and check to see like what are my most love it, right? I don't know. I'm weird like that, but it's like it's I appreciate all of that It's like it. It's like a dopamine hit. I don't know why it's like, you know after a long day at work and listen to podcasts while Tracking my comics is a good way to like, you know settle down for the night I'm here for it. If you want to search out any
of my content, you can search out either the Geek Showcase on YouTube and see some of the content there. Hopefully there will be some more content added soon. And you can also search me out on the social media for at least for Twitter, Facebook, and I think I have an Instagram. That's at Optimus Solo. You can leave us comments as far as the show handle, which is the Cinema Geeks, or you can check out all the other Geek Cast. radio network stuff by going to their website or searching them on their social medias as well. So that does it for Vertigo. Join us next time
for more Alfred Hitchcock content with the Cinema Geeks.
Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...
Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...
Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...
Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...
Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...