Today on Episode 217, coming off of the heels of viewing Suspicion the guys turn there attention to a very similar film, 1943's Shadow of a Doubt. Will this one be an upgrade from the previous film? Where will this one land in the Hitchcock rankings that we will do at the end of the series...Tune in to find out! Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on X! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark! #UNLEASHTHECINEMAGEEKINYOU!!!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
I don't know what to say, the monkeys won't do! And I also don't know what to say about those crazy producers from the Geek Cop Radio Network! They're driving me crazy! And welcome to episode 217 of the cinema geeks I am one of your cinema geeks optimist solo and joining me as Always
is the comic concierge. Hello, Dan. Hey, how's it going? It's going well. We're into I guess the summer months in Florida and that means it's hot so I Tried to mow the yard the other day and got about halfway through mowing the yard and like trimming and Weed whacking or whatever you want to call it in Florida. I have found is like a three day process you can do like half of your yard one day half of your yard the other day and then you can trim a completely separate day but doing them on the same day is not ideal
the only benefit i have is when i'm done and there's sweat pouring out of every pore in my body i can just belly flop into our pool and it's like the most satisfying thing you would like on the planet so that's that's good i guess and i look around at all the the people that are much more well off than than we are that have people that come and do all of that stuff. And I'm like clinging to like the fact that I still mow my own yard and hold out as long as
possible. Yeah. So anything new? The kids were just about done with school, I would imagine. Yeah. Yeah. You know, near the end of that. And I'm in Maryland. So it's not as hot as Florida, but it's It's stickier, you know, Maryland is, you know, it's the, basically most of it used to be a swamp. So it's, it's like walking, you know, when it's midsummer, it's a, like walking around microwave cobwebs. Cause it's just like, you're always feeling gross. So yeah, I can imagine.
Baseball season is in full swing. I only bring that up because I had predicted that your Baltimore Orioles would be much better than they are. Currently, oh there's baseball season this year So the Cubs however, which is my team are actually doing pretty fantastic So I guess we'll ride that wave as long as we can See where that's going. I think I think the NBA finals are happening So it's a lot of sports stuff happening right now, but we're not here to talk about sports We're here to talk about movies and like we've done for
the last what 12 or 13 episodes. Let's see This has got to be episode 13 in this series, I believe, of our Alfred Hitchcock retrospective. We are moving on. We did Rebecca and Suspicion were the last two that we did in kind of our bonus territory of the, as we decided to extend this filmography look. And now we're into 1943's Shadow of a Doubt. Before I go over Some of the information about the movie just to reiterate what we talked about at the end of last episode Dan Neither one of us has seen this and you have no knowledge
of what the movie was going into it, right? Yeah, I knew nothing about it going in I never watched it before so completely fresh for me. All right so this is a American psychological thriller film noir if you want to believe the All the descriptives that Wikipedia gives it I should definitely find a different source that like narrows that down because I feel like sometimes they just like throw as many genres and subgenres as possible but this is obviously directed by Alfred Hitchcock starring Teresa Wright and Joseph Cotton among some other folks this came out like
I said 1943 and this is about a small town I guess you would call it a small town outside of New No, they started in New Jersey. They end up in Santa Rosa, California. And this movie is kind of depicting that town of Santa Rosa and definitely a more of a Andy Griffith style town, you know, a small town situation where they're going to look at that a little bit. And we're going to follow the tale of two Charlie's. We have a uncle Charlie, who's obviously an older,
not older, but like a middle aged gentleman. And then we have a younger female. Charlie, who is his niece, to try to make that as confusing as possible as we talk through this and probably use the word Charlie as many times as they did in the movie, which I think was like 171 I saw somewhere. So this was released in January of 1943. It had 108 minute runtime. The reason this one made it into our bonus coverage was a couple of different reasons. Number one, this is one of those rare films that actually has a 100 percent
on Rotten Tomatoes. So that was interesting or intriguing, I guess, as far as that goes. And then it also had one Academy Award nomination and it showed up on almost all the different lists I looked at. It was ranked number nine by independent, ranker Den of Geek, number eight by IndieWire, number five by Taste of Cinema and number 11 on the screen rant list. And also this was said to be Alfred Hitchcock's favorite film. So we thought If it's his favorite film,
if it's a hundred percent in Rotten Tomatoes, if everything that is written about this film seems like it's positive, we should probably take a look at Shadow of a Doubt. So with all of that lofty expectation and kind of rhetoric around this film, Dan, what was your take? And I cannot wait to get into this because I think this is going to be the one. But what was your take on Shadow of a Doubt? It's interesting watching this after suspicion, because there's a lot of similarities with These two films obviously suspicion
The big difference is with that. We don't know the answer, you know, it's all about This fear of guilt of the sphere of understanding like what is this person doing? Are there sinister actions and seeing of those? Be discovered cuz like you know, that's where the suspense is coming from here It's the opposite where we we know more more than most of the characters. We know this guy is guilty we know he is certainly running from doing some awful things. And of course now he is within this family that seems like it is
like the picture perfect type of household. Like you mentioned, Andy Griffith, it's a good comparison. You know, this is in the forties. It seems like it's kind of representing the ideal of what the American family could look like. But underneath you have this ugly underbelly that is potentially Going to rise up and destroy it from within which is interesting comparing considering this is coming out in 1943 and during you know, the I don't say height of war war two, but certainly that's in the background. We see it a little bit Uh throughout and I didn't know all the praise
of this going into it Like I knew I know like some of it like I knew like obviously it's his cock film. It's obviously praise, but I wasn't sure where it felt on the pantheon of movies and I think there's a lot I really like about this but I don't like you mentioned it being his favorite film uh you know some people rank it near the top I felt like I wasn't I didn't have as much suspense with this compared to that of what we just went through with suspicion and
I was trying to figure out like why that is exactly like there's I see so much praise for this film as I after I watched it to see like, you know, there's there's a lot of admiration here and especially for the actors and like how well it's put together and I think certainly I do like the disposition of like this idyllic household and Seeing that kind of crumble because you know, it's it's kind of a facade and see that going through but I think it also has similar issues to like The what we had with grope where you
have like just a lot of like the parade characters that were hard to invest in This at least we had the the girl Charlie who obviously was like the innocent the the person trying to figure it out but I I don't know like it I struggled at times like I wasn't as You know, like this is a movie that is a thriller at heart and really until There are some moments that worked for me. There are some I think some brilliant moments from Joseph Cotton Like there's a moment where
he talks about kind of his hatred of women which I thought was like rather chilling and like it's like wow He must go for Chan message boards because it seems very similar to that but as an overall like Clearly a well -made film, but if I'm comparing it to what we say before I don't like it's not my favorite Hitchcock film I don't I didn't walk away from it as With this admiration I had for some of the other films we've done so far so I guess I'm a little bit more in the middle with it compared to You know some of the other films
we've reviewed Dan how long do you think do you have any clue of like the first year that we reviewed a movie together? Oh Man I want to say 20 2011 2010 so it's I mean we're we have to be getting close to 15 years like Yes, there's been breaks and there's been years whether we've covered more films than not and maybe some years that we didn't cover any films. But I feel like we've been reviewing films or talking about films for a long time. And you have a I feel like you definitely have a good sense of the types of
films I go for and things of that nature. And I have a little bit of, you know, obviously a sense of what you like and stuff like that. And when you're going through an older filmography like Alfred Hitchcock filmography, that's, you know, we're going from the 1930s into the mostly the 40s 50s and 60s it's a little bit different because it's not something modern and it's not something that relates to like some of the stuff that you're covering when you're trying to cover all new films like we did for many years so it's a little bit harder to predict and every time I feel like we're we finally approached one where
we're gonna have like completely different opinions on it I let you go first and you shock me because we're almost always in lockstep like there's some films that you've clearly liked a little like a different maybe a little bit better or Some films that you've not liked quite as much, but I don't I feel like it's just like Degrees at that point. It's not like you loved a film and I hated a film type thing And I just find that kind of interesting I thought for sure that this one might be the one that we we differ on but it's not sounding like it's gonna be that
way I have a lot of problems with this film. I do, like you said, let's start with the positives. I do think that the idyllic American town slash American family is definitely well depicted. And I think it's a good job by whether it be the screenwriter or Hitchcock in the direction and whatever, setting that up and really showing us how that looked. in a way that seemed sincere
and authentic and still was kind of like a time capsule of a certain time and place. And so I really enjoyed that. I also come from a very small town. Like we didn't have stoplights in my town. My graduating class was like 60. I was like in the most Caucasian part of a state that you could possibly be in and just didn't have a lot of diversity of raised cultures or anything so like I can relate to some of what we're seeing
in this film and I think they do a very good job of depicting that. I think we do get some good performances from the cast and I do really love a couple of the supporting characters and before I get into overall thoughts I do want to correct myself because last episode I looked at the cast list and I basically said like there's nobody I know in this cast and there's nobody that I recognize there's no names that are recognized so I'm not only going into it blind from a plot standpoint but I'm also going into it blind from
any expectations from the actors and actresses and I just didn't realize that I just didn't recognize some of their names but I definitely recognize some of their faces as far as what they've been in like Teresa Wright who plays the the younger Charlie I mean she's coming off of three Academy Award nomination films in a row right before this so if you've seen stuff like I've seen her in like the Pride of the Yankees was the one that I most remember I haven't I don't think I've seen Mrs. Miniver or the Little Foxes but she was obviously very well received
coming into this film Joseph Cotton who was a little bit more known by the time this film came it came out was clearly in Citizen Kane so I feel bad that I didn't recognize that from the get -go. And I believe Hume Cronin was a name that I just didn't see the first time going through the cast. This is his first film, and that's a name that I recognize. He did a lot of stuff in TV and films afterwards. So there's definitely... Oh, and the angel from... What's the Christmas
movie that has the guardian angel? Wonderful Life? Yes, it's A Wonderful Life. The dad is the guardian angel from A Wonderful Life, I'm pretty sure. Um, so there was some people that have definitely done some stuff. This isn't like a, I didn't want to come across as I was saying, like it's a bunch of nobodies or people that nobody knows. Like I was just ignorant to the names on the list. So I did want to point that out. But overall, I think you, you nailed it on the head when, and I don't know if it was just like unfortunate that we, in a way that
we watched this right after suspicion. Because I definitely do just like, you see a lot of the parallels between these two films and it's tough. coming off of that one to see this one where I feel like a lot of the things were done better in suspicion. And I know some of that is just how it's set up. Like you said, in suspicion, we're not sure, right? Like we're playing the we're walking the line of not knowing if Cary Grant's just coming across as somewhat despicable or if he actually is despicable. And if he is
like, what level is it? Is it just kind of like some juvenile or like meathead frat boy type? Despicable or is he an actual murderer, right? Like so we're balancing that line a lot with suspicion and I feel like this one I feel like it wanted to do that, but it didn't because I don't know if it was intentional or not Like rope is different rope. We see the murderer right or we see the The act right at the beginning like there's no doubt we know and I'm not sure
if this one was trying to do the same thing where we know Like you said more than the characters and we know for sure whether he's guilty or innocent right from the beginning or if it was trying to do what suspicion did and then just did a poor job of it. I'm kind of wrestling with myself a little bit about that because part of me was kind of coming out of this one and saying, you know, Joseph Cotton, as well as he performed in this and whatnot is not Cary Grant. And what I mean by that is like Cary Grant because of
his charisma and presence and whatnot, I feel like was able to pull off the fact that you're in one seat, like in one second, you're despising him. But in the next second, you're believing that somebody could fall for him. And you're kind of going back and forth because of who he is as that actor. And through his performance, I think he's balancing that line in a different way. And in this one, and it's written that way, I'm sure, and directed it that way. But Joseph Cotton is There's no doubt when he's bad and
to what level that he's bad. Like you said the speech that he gives about women There's a few physical moments where he's like actually hurting Hurting the younger Charlie by the way, he grabs her and things of that nature There's a different look in his eye that is definitely evil if you look at the movie poster of this film like it clearly is showing him as evil in the The shadow depiction of like what he looks like in the background So I don't know I so part of me was just thrown
off by that because I was I couldn't determine if they were Intentionally telling us that he was bad or if they were trying to balance that line and just doing a bad job of it You think they were intentionally letting us know it was bad Yeah, I think because in the beginning we see him running away from the police like he has that little internal monologue where you know, he's like Saying that like they they don't have anything on him I think like we know he's running away from something and when he cuts out the the article from the newspaper Clearly
they like try to hide what's happening. I think it's pretty clear like I think you know, we're supposed to know There's he's like he's he's this killer. He's who they're looking for you know his refusal to get pictures taken he would hate today man cuz like gonna go anyway then it does like you say kind of go back to that rope situation then where we're supposed to be in a suspense that we're the only ones that aren't in a suspenseful position and to me i don't know
if that works for film like i maybe if it's done in a certain way but it really takes me out of the suspense if i know that he's bad from go and to me there was no doubt in my mind as i'm watching it that he's bad like i was never questioning like well maybe it's just something that's being looked made to look a certain way. And then at the end of the movie, they're going to like pull the tablecloth out from, or whatever this phrase is, pull the rug out from underneath us. And we're also going to be like, oh, they, they tricked me and he's not bad. So I just thought it was
very obvious that he was bad. And I don't know if that helped me. And then the other thing that was, I feel like was a mistake maybe in the screenplay, but I don't know how you'd have to completely rewrite the movie and it'd be a completely different movie. So I don't know if that would work, but he is introduced as Uncle Charlie to this family, right? And we have the young Charlie, who is his niece. And then she has an additional younger brother and younger sister, and then her mom and her dad. So we have a family of five here. And they definitely depict her as the one that
is very much in favor of her uncle. Like she is in his camp at the beginning. She, it's like the uncle that you wish visited more. And when they finally do like you're jumping up and down and you're excited or that family member, whatever that case may be. Like she's definitely. I don't want to say, I don't want to make it more incestual than the movie did, but she's, she's like head over heels about this guy coming to her family. She feels like her family, like she's bored of, of Mayberry and she wants something to shake
it up. And I think she sees that as a way. And then obviously she must have some type of previous positive experience with him. Yeah. And not saying that anybody else in the family is not excited. Obviously the, the mom, uncle Charlie's sister is excited, but they really play it up with her. And then I feel like because of that, it's almost a mistake that she's the one that knows he's bad first and throughout. majority of at least the second half of the film because I feel like
it would be much more effective if the family is the one that is seeing the little seeds of something or her younger siblings or or the detectives or somebody and that's trying to convince her and she can't see it because she's you know so enamored with this with this relative and that it takes like some type of dramatic event towards the end that finally gets her to see the light or something of that nature and instead they do the flip and she's the one that knows that he's bad so it kind of deflates all of that excitement
and it's more about whether she she's going to tell the family and things of that nature so that that like part of it for me felt like it was a miss i don't know like what did you feel about her being the one that knows Then her relationship with the rest of her family and her not wanting to like let anybody know besides herself and the the powers that be I thought it worked because to me like the reason why it works is because she she There's a cure. She has the innocence
to her right where it's like she has this admiration and also there's also the fear becomes She she if she does discover that What happens next? Yes, like you mentioned, there's no suspense because he's bad. But I guess to me, the question was, well, what is his level of the privity? How far will he go to protect himself? Will he hurt her? And that was a question that was looming. And then we start to see that, yeah, he will go that far, when he cuts the step. And that,
to me, became kind of captivating because you see here go through this System of like, you know now he's fine and that development Me worked because it was the other way around too, especially with like the mom character and the dad I think I don't know. I don't know how that would lay out in the sense of them trying to convince her especially because the mom seemed more Yeah, I don't think it works with the parents I was thinking more like the siblings or the detective or one of her friends or or something like that I think I just mom's gonna gonna believe him
no matter what I'm almost They had the strongest connection so Attacking that you know making making her have to reconcile with that feeling because it made the most sense that she would Try to find every way out that it's not true and then having to deal with it being true like I thought that was one of the more compelling parts of the movie and then that's really where it's it started to pick up with me because it's you saw that you know once once he realized that she was no longer trusting him, like he started
to, you know, go out and basically, you know, kill her too. Cause you saw that, like that it was almost, almost, it was completely like gone. Where it lost me a little bit, that was where we suddenly get this random love story with the police officer. Like that like felt very tacked on that kind of goes up and then never really comes back again. Uh, but I thought like their dynamic to me was. that was the strongest part of the film. And that worked for me. Yeah, I do think their dynamic worked. I just was wondering
if there was a way to get more tension out of it, because I think the only tension for me comes towards the end when you're trying to figure out if is he going to be successful in his attempts to kill her? First, if he's going to go that far, and then once he does, like, is she going to be able to escape these attempts? Is she going to survive? you know, you're going to get caught. Like that's where the tension comes in. Like maybe that last quarter or last third, which I do think is somewhat effective in the way they do that. It does beg the question though, because from like a plot standpoint, like going into
a third act, you typically have like your main character that has to make a decision on something like they have to make some sort of decision. And obviously her decision is whether she tells her family or tells the police or tells, you know, everybody else what she has already figured out. And I feel like it approaches that question like three or four times and every single time she's pretty adamant that she's not going to tell anybody. And she tells him that at least on three different occasions. And it becomes questionable why he doesn't just leave. Like,
I feel like at one point she's. You know, he's tried it multiple times. She's very sincere that she doesn't want her mom to be, you know, broken by this. She's not going to tell anybody. And he has an opportunity to leave and just get away with it and continue his run. And he decides, I guess that's kind of going into the psych, say, psychoticness of his character, because we're definitely supposed to think he's a, a psycho, a, you know, a madman that's been afflicted from a young age, et cetera. So I guess that goes into like, he has to have some type of power
reason to continue on. and stay there versus leaving. But just to go back to your detective situation, I thought that was a problematic scene as well, because we have like this this montage of her and the detective going out and. Enjoying a night or an evening together, even though we're set up to believe that he's mainly trying to get information out, but it clearly becomes more than that. And then like without any sequence to set it up whatsoever, it just cuts to her.
accusing him of being a detective with like no reason for that like there's it doesn't show any like breadcrumb to that it doesn't like set that up at all like to where she would think that but she completely comes to that conclusion out of nowhere out of this montage and then it's like oh well you're a detective and and now I'm angry at you and things of that like there was some weird dynamics between her and the detective which I forget the character's name but I'm definitely with you on that what did you think about The uncle charlie not leaving It's interesting I
felt I did wonder about that. I think part of it like you said was that element where I think he liked that conflict like it does seem like it's something he this was a challenge for him and that's something he He saw plus. I think he likes this opportunity that he was in because he knew that there were some some widows nearby that he can take advantage of and I think he felt kind of safe and protected because he can have this uh you know this idea of a family man
or being a part of this family so i think he that might be why like i don't know i think it's a valid point saying like it seems like when he gets to the point where she knows she's talking to detectives logically you'd want to step away but perhaps he also thought if he did go away then it would become He'd become a bigger suspect and then we get that little bit where they supposedly catch somebody. So it's like, okay, no longer. He's maybe that's, you know, at least some, they at least did some recognition of it saying, okay,
we, we need something here. And when he's no longer supposedly, you know, when they catch the guy they're looking for and he's no longer having to worry about it. Okay. Maybe that makes more sense, but yeah, I could understand that flaw, like where that comes from, but. it's also definitely a little bit of a time capsule because you have this situation where there there's one person that went that ran to the east and one person that ran to the west and they're trying to track down both of these individuals and they're trying to get a picture of him so that they can
then wire the picture to a witness in another area of the country get confirmation that it's like it's so like of that time like it's kind of fun to think about like the logistics of how things happen prior to the time we live in, where obviously none of that would have been necessary. So it's definitely interesting. It's also interesting that the detectives like their whole game is to follow him all the way to Santa Rosa, California.
And then instead of just going in like questioning him or arresting him or anything like they pose as what was it, a newspaper or magazine? Yeah, they were doing an article about like the like, you know, the average American. Yeah. Yeah. So they're going to like get in the house and take pictures and then like mysteriously or slickly take a picture of him. And like, I have never seen detectives detectives act like the two detectives in this story, but I guess that's what the plot needs. Yeah. I mean, they were creative, I guess. They got the job done. They got the picture.
And then he had the little Slate of hand with the film, you know, I guess yeah, I do have a couple other things I know this is like it's completely nitpicky, but There's a sequence when he gets to this house I don't know if it's the first night that they're the first dinner or the first night that they're together I can't quite remember but one of the first times that the he's with his you know reacquainted with his family and we have like what you mentioned the newspaper which is on the on the table dad's newspaper, right and there's an article about this killer and Uncle Charlie loses his mind
right and he has to do whatever he can to get this newspaper hidden so he like Tears at it creates a what did he create a house or a farm or a barn or something out of it for the kids which was interesting I was I was there for that. I was trying to see what he was gonna create but To me that whole thing Makes zero sense because there is no picture of him in this newspaper because nobody has taken a picture That's why the detectives are here to try to get a picture of him So there's nothing in this news article that's gonna implicate him to anybody Like nobody
in that family is gonna read that article and then look at uncle Charlie and be like Hey, there's a killer Like he was freaking out for absolutely no reason which was somewhat problematic to me because it's a big part of this plot Like they follow this newspaper for scenes like there's two or three scenes that include this newspaper. She goes in to try to find it She has to go to the library to see what was on it. Like, it's a big deal, and it made no sense for him to draw attention to that newspaper whatsoever. He was not a very slick, psychotic killer. I will say
that much. I think that is part of the guilt or the fear, though, right? It's where he's worried what it could lead to, because there is... indication of a deaf person's on the run he suddenly shows up and he starts putting all these things in his head and and even like the opening scene you could see like he clearly was Paranoid and you know in the sense of people were after him because they were actually after him because he murdered people But I think that I agree like logically doesn't make sense, but I think for
that character it's mine Yeah, because it as we in it's a one accuses into Where he is as a person he he he is super protective of everything like he is overprotective Yeah, um the point of where it makes it kind of to his detriment So I think it was consistent with the character even if it wasn't logical Yeah, he definitely wasn't like the he wasn't the slick killer. We'll say that no He does a number of things that the slick killer would not do like he gives her a ring that has the murder victim's initials on
it And I love how they set it up. They're like What did he say? Oh, there's like a faint inscription or engraving or something. And then they show the ring and there's nothing faint about this inscription. I know they have to do that because it's the camera and we need to see what it says. But I was like, my dude, I think you should have taken a second look at this ring before you gave it. So he freaks out about the paper. He gives someone a ring with the initials of the murder victim. He's not a slick killer. We'll say that much. He's a downright narcissist in the sense
of like, He does all these things and he wants to in a way kind of brag about it, but you know Like he's he wants to show but in the way he like when he goes into the bank and he's open with like how much money he's putting in like he in a way like he certainly Like you said, he's not slick, but he he he had to me he is he's he's a stereotypical narcissist where he's wants wants everyone to see him in a certain light which I think kind of gets into like why he hates these widows because Again, it's his
eyes They are where they are because of just because of who they married and they don't deserve it and he feels that he does and that's kind of his I think there was there was a bit of like In a sense of I think there was some subtlety there compared to something like rope like bashing on a movie, but But where there wasn't that that was kind of lacking for those characters here. I thought I don't know I did like his character more as it went through because I agree as some of those decisions early on seemed a little bit questionable but as we learned more about him
I thought it all kind of made sense and understanding of like where he is and just kind of the uh the odd fellow he turned out to be and I think they do do a good job I appreciate that they do give the backstory of him Having the injury as a child on his I think it was a bike injury or something like that and obviously this story if you do the research and look at the trivia like this is based on a real -life murder and That person similarly had you know an injury in his youth and I guess the only thing that is somewhat questionable
about that back So I do like it because it shows him more as a psychotic individual or a narcissist or different things like that He's he's clearly got something wrong from a mental standpoint. This isn't just someone who's trying to get away with murder because whatever, like the guy in rope, for example. But it's not a leisure activity for him. Right. But I do think like, I guess you have to then also accept the premise that he has been removed from this family for quite some time, because it would be rare for someone to have that injury as a child, go through the
steps of becoming a psychotic individual and never have anybody close to him. See anything that's a little questionable. Yeah, like the way that this family is just head over heels about him and inviting him It's not like hey Uncle Charlie's come in You know if he says anything funny just ignore it or something like there's nothing like that It's like this guy is like the the best family member in the history of family members And yeah, I don't know He must have hit it really well for the the rest of his life prior to this But it's not fair to critique
the movie on that because we don't get to see what happens, you know prior to the Plus, the family is a bit weird themselves. You have the father and the other character that love discussing murdering each other openly all the time. Which, by the way, are my two favorite characters in the film. Yeah, I really thought that was coming to play more. I was waiting for those mushrooms to show up someplace. Or them to solve something or see something. I guess he does help a little bit, the neighbor does, but I just thought the
dialogue they give those two is hilarious and what they're kind of going back and forth and trying to one up each other. The only thing that was really disturbing to me was how the neighbor would just show up. like there was just not a knock there was no doorbell dude was just in the house with you yeah turn the corner and be like oh there's there's dude i don't know what his name was uh neighbor did he have a name what was his name uh herbie herbie herbie yeah yeah he was like showing up he was like the uh a bad
sitcom neighbor, but not in the movie, you know, like that trope, like the Urkel or the, you know, what was the character's name at Full House that was just, it was always there. Oh, I know who you're talking about, Kimmy? Kimmy, yeah. It was, you know, he was that character, but I guess, I don't know if you'd say he's annoying, but he certainly was an odd duck. To me, he was more like the guy from Home Improved that was on the other side of the fence, but instead of being on the other side of the fence, he's in your house with you without any knowledge of how he got there. He's just there. Trying to come up with ways to murder you. I wanted to get your
take on a couple other characters because we do obviously have the family, which we just talked about. We have the neighbor, Herbie, which we just talked about, obviously the detective, which we've mentioned. We haven't spent a lot of time on the two siblings and then her classmates slash friends. And I kept waiting for something to tie in. those characters more into the story. So we have her sister and her brother, her brother likes numbers and counting and doing all that
kind of stuff. And her sister likes reading and comes across as, you know, fairly intelligent, that type of thing. But to me, I thought they were going to like do something so that those characters became more important to some aspect of the plot. And the more I like digested after the fact, I don't know if those characters served a purpose in this film. Like I feel like outside of adding to the family dynamic and like the ideal life that we're portraying here, you could
take the brother and the sister out of this film and it has no consequence on the film. Unless I'm just missing something and even more so with her friends. So they come across like three of her friends, two of them we find walking together. a couple different times. And then one of them is maybe not a friend, but a, a classmate that serves them in the cafe bar, restaurant, whatever you want to call it. And they make a point that, you know, all of these people have relationships with her and things of that nature. But then the same situation, like, what was the point
of drawing that connection that they know each other and that their friends or classmates outside of just, I guess. Painting a picture of a small town where everybody knows each other But none of those four or five characters did anything for the actual story to me unless I'm missing something Did you pick up more on something on on those side characters? I I think one I think it is part of just showcasing this town understanding like the community they're seeing because Where people are at because you obviously have Charlie that the parsing that you mentioned and then
the person that's working there that you clearly The different path in life and also to get some insight and Charlie in like what people view her as because He says like I never thought I would see you here. So it's clearly like she's someone that people view a certain way The younger daughter like I think she provides some key like pieces of information about the library and like just like, you know Where the newspapers are and I think partially to I think she's there a little bit for comedic relief But I don't I don't think their purpose is necessarily more so for the overall narrative just as you say
more representation of as it was trying to kind of capture what life like what an average life was like and in this time in order to set the stage and what happens then when you take that average life and you bring in someone who suspected for murder and giving like What would be the average family something to relate to maybe putting in that headspace? But when they're seeing this they're you know, they're able to maybe try to partake, you know Have more of a connection to it because they can see their town their life
and suddenly now there's their their their brother -in -law, whoever it is Yeah, but like the the friends and stuff like that. I don't think they're necessarily You know, like you said, you could remove them narrative wise. It doesn't change much I think it's more of a representation of Like the world building that they're doing. Yeah. I guess world buildings, they're wrong. But the picture they're painting, I guess, of the town. So I think overall, from a positive standpoint, I like the time capsule of it. I like the way that they're painting the picture of this town
and then they're bringing something like Uncle Charlie in to disrupt it. I kind of like that all as a setting and a setup for it. I did like the father and the neighbor and kind of their banter back and forth. I enjoyed that. I do think the performances are fine between, you know, especially like you said, the two Charlies, I think work well off of each other from an acting standpoint. And he definitely is able to give like some some psychotic eyes and some things that definitely worked. The other thing that I think worked for me was kind of that last little
bit where we get like a series of murder attempts from him. So we have the stairs. That he's going to sabotage we have the car in the garage That he's trying to trap her in and then we have obviously the the last sequence with the train How did those three sequences work for the those three attempts work for you? And was it enough to kind of give you some suspense at the end and was there anything else that you were positive on on this film? I like those scenes. I think like I said, that's where it started to come together where it's like, oh, he's willing, he's willing
to go all the way with this. Like he's willing to take out his knees to protect himself. And I think it, I really liked that bar scene too, where you see him kind of confront her. And I wondered like, is it, are you going to have this mystery where she's that her finding out is the climax. But I did like the fact that she, she learns it and she discovers it. And suddenly the conflict becomes, does she say anything because she knows Saying something would destroy your family like would completely wreck her mom and
it would kind of break Them from the reality that they know like what it would like so now she has this skills on top of everything So I thought that was an intriguing dynamic uh, and so those scenes did work for me because I think it It it that's when I really started getting invested in the film for the most part And I think the performances overall like like you mentioned, um, which Joseph Cotton specifically if that was really good and Trisha Wright of Claire like who I didn't honestly like the films that she's known for I have not seen so I have
not a lot of exposure to her but I thought she played that role really well and I especially when she starts kind of to take charge and she you know, she where she tries to turn it a little bit where she doesn't want to be the victim anymore and I thought that's something you did not see all the time and films like during this era, so That was something a little bit different that that worked. Yeah, I agree. I think there was pieces of this film that worked that make it overall not like something that I would keep
away from. You know, I wouldn't dissuade someone from watching it. I don't think there's anything that's terrible about the film necessarily. I don't think the suspense worked as well for me for the first. two -thirds probably as I would have hoped did just because of how it's set up and I thought there was a little some problematic things throughout but like overall I think there's enough to like pick up or something I don't know how it has a hundred percent like that's a little bit baffling to me And I don't know how it's Hitchcock's favorite film. Obviously he knows more because he's behind the scenes and doing
everything. So maybe it was just about the process and the different things that kind of played into that. So I don't know if I'm as high as everybody else in the world is on this film. But I don't think it's a terrible film. I did find a couple of things interesting. Films back in this day, obviously we don't have TV yet and we don't have Internet and things of that nature. So the way that they would. give you another chance to experience this was they would put on radio plays and things of that nature. And I did find it interesting that in one of the
radio plays, they actually had Cary Grant play the role of Uncle Charlie. So yeah, so and it was Cary Grant and Betsy Drake apparently played the other ones. And then most of the other ones, Joseph Cotton came back to play the the other character. But Appeared in a bunch of different radio plays so that people could see it It didn't get a good reception at first like from a box office standpoint and a review. I think people were Somewhat down on it at first, but what it's gotten from like the modern Day critics and you
know since Rotten Tomatoes and those types of websites exist has obviously been overall very positive Was anything else about this film that you didn't get to touch on yet or something else that you want to bring up that you either like to dislike? We didn't mention the the Hitchcock cameo he is and then he's on the train holding at first I like he was holding there's you know, the the Basically holding the entire deck and and the idea was that he's holding the entire deck because he's the director I'll be honest I didn't I thought it was supposed to be like
a joke that he was cheating because he has all the cards, but it was supposed to be a reference to it So but yeah, you know that was Uh the one big cameo and the other hitchcockian pieces. I don't know like, you know, this one doesn't have someone's wrongly accused Not necessarily like I guess it has a little bit of the Is he guilty? Is he not? I mean they they establish it right away that he is but at first it is going to be like From the characters that are in the film not from our standpoint. They don't know that he's guilty So I guess that still exists
in some way shape or form in this one Yeah, that's true And then I guess you have a mom. It's not the, it's not the main character, like the main male's mom, but there is a mom involved in like what her reaction is going to be to all of this. It's, uh, I don't think it's at all what we've seen from other depictions of moms throughout Hitchcock's film. This is a much different, uh, there's not anything abnormal about the relationship in this one. I don't think with the mom and any
of the characters just playing a pretty straightforward standard. You know what I mean, like a small town mom, so I don't get anything from that. Did you pick up any other Hitchcockian aspects? No, that was pretty much it, which is interesting because you mentioned it being your favorite film, but a lot of his key, now, trademarks aren't here. Maybe that's why. I don't know. But yeah, that's all I found. It is interesting as we're kind of going through that there seems to be a lot of pairings that you can do with Hitchcock
films. whether it be, you know what I mean? Like there's just like certain ones. Like we talked about the 39 steps and North by Northwest or, you know, different things that we've kind of been able to. And it seems like there's a lot of times there's something that he does earlier on in his filmography that then he like revisits in a slightly different way later with maybe more success. So it's kind of interesting how he kind of goes back and revisits certain. uh tropes or certain things that he's tried and then just kind of does it a little different or whether he's trying to improve on it or something
but I think it would be interesting once you've seen them all like how many you can kind of pair up or match up as it's like well these this is the early version of this movie later on so yeah I find that somewhat interesting all right so that is 1943's Shadow of a Doubt um middling review I guess but not Not terrible, not probably going to end up on either one of our top film of the Hitchcock filmography. I think that's safe to say for the most part. So next up is
going to be 1944's Lifeboat, which is a limited setting film that, Dan, you I believe this one you have seen before. I have seen it was about. 10 years ago, so I don't remember much of it. But yeah, I have seen this one before. So you're going to come out come in with at least a little bit of knowledge or maybe some things will refresh your memory as you start watching. I have not seen Lifeboat or know anything about it outside of. what you've talked about throughout our filmography episode. So it'll be interesting to get into
Lifeboat from 1944 and see how that kind of compares to what else we have talked about. Dan, if people want to get in contact with you or figure out other stuff that you're doing on social media, how would they do that? Just search Comic Concierge and all the different social media platforms you'll be able to find me there. All right. You can search me out at Optimus Solo or you can search the show out at the Cinema Geeks. podcast or we have a X page and that's about it for the social media for the show but you can definitely get in contact with us there or you can check out all the other things Geekcast Radio related
on the Geekcast Radio network as far as all the other content, podcast, articles and videos that they put out on that website. So that does it for this episode. Tune in next time for another chance to listen to more of The Cinema Geek.
Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...
Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...
Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...
Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...
Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...