Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

CINEMA GEEKS

CINEMA GEEKS artwork

Hitchcock Retrospective: Rope

Feb 15, 202538 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Today on Episode 207, The Cinema Geeks continue their trek through the filmography of the iconic Alfred Hitchcock. This time they look at, Rope, from 1948. How will the hosts react to this 'thriller'. Will they like Jimmy Stewart as much as they liked Cary Grant in Notoroius? Tune in to find out! Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on X! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark! #UNLEASHTHECINEMAGEEKINYOU!!!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hey, Tara Strong here, and you're listening to the GeekCast Radio Network. Hello and welcome to episode 207 of The Cinema Geeks. I am one of your Cinema Geeks optimists, Solo, and joining me, as usual, is the comic concierge, Dan. How are you doing? Good, good. How about yourself? Doing wonderful ready to tackle some more Alfred

Hitchcock as we are getting our our Way through this Alfred Hitchcock retrospective. We're on our third film now So I feel like we're just like getting into the weeds now like first couple out of the way three out of ten like we're in it now, so What are you what were your thoughts for everybody? That's not let me I'm gonna edit that out So the third film that we are covering as we mentioned in our last episode is going to be the 1948 American psychological crime thriller,

Rope. So Dan, what was your experience? I know you said it on last episode, but those that didn't tune into that one, what's your experience with Rope before you watched it this time? So this was my first time watching this. I thought maybe I've seen it before, but going through it, I clearly have not said to remember anything. So it was a brand new watch for me. It's my first time watch as well. This is based on an 1829 play of the same title, which is possibly inspired by real -life events this is starring the likes

of Jimmy Stewart John doll Farley Granger Joan Chandler Douglas dick a few other people Jimmy Jimmy Stewart's obviously probably one of them the main stars that people will recognize from this one and This is Kind of a noir type film here where we get introduced to An act right off the bat and then the rest of it is somewhat supposed to be I guess suspenseful as to How

the rest of the events are going to transpire? It's also known for Its experimental techniques, I guess from a filming standpoint. It's supposedly I guess as best they can to try to be done in real time. So the amount of time that you spend with them on the movie is about Pretty close to the amount of time that is actually taking place over the course of the movie and then there's also the fact that it's Supposedly like I know it's I think it's 10, but they say it's kind of like four Long sequences where you're following

the camera around the rooms and things of that nature. So it's got some Techniques that had never been done before on this type of stage. So what was your first impression of rope after seeing it? Was it just think is yeah, like you said it like it opens up on a murder it basically hear a scream and Then just like wait what just happened because it's like did that and then trying to like determine What exactly was the motivation there and it was murder for the sake of murder like that? You know, they just wanted the excitement of it, which was not what I expected

at all. I'm like, oh wow, this is Pretty macabre. This is pretty sadistic in a way. Like these people just, you know, it's the perfect crime. It's interesting. Like it wasn't what I was expecting. Like you can definitely tell this is a play because I think this probably would work really well on stage because as you mentioned, it's done in real time. It's a lot of like just straight dialogue. I do think Hitchcock, as you mentioned, does his best with Using the camera to try to go around and like make it feel like you're not

just looking at a stage that you're part of the room To give you an understanding of like the landscape of everything which is important but I was intrigued by it, but I guess Compared to what we went before I was I had trouble connecting it connecting with it compared to what we Previously watched I think potentially because I was so caught up with the machinations the creation of it Within itself. I think it's a well made, but in a way I feel like the you mentioned like it's means it feels like it's done or the trick

here. It's like one continuous shot or Clearly clearly not that and I think every time that would happen because you would have someone walk by the camera it would zoom in and then zoom out and like, you know continue and clearly that was where a cut was and I think that every time that happened and kind of took me out a little bit I did find it. So I was impressed with the The like the craftsmanship of the movie, but I wasn't as like emotionally invested in this or like the plight of what was on Occurring I

didn't like I felt like for something that should be super thrilling. I didn't have that tension. I thought I might so Interesting I I'm kind of intrigued on your take as well because I didn't know if we were gonna line up together or if we were gonna be at odds on this one and by at odds, I mean just like having different takes on it. And this was one that I've always wanted to watch. This has always been on one of my top films on my bucket list of blind spots that I

need to watch. I don't know why, but I was always wanting to watch this one. And then we started with The 39 Steps and Notorious. And I was like, oh, this is going to be a great ride. This is going to be a Tarantino retrospective where just every film is just getting knocked out of the park or increasingly better and better. And so perhaps I got my anticipation too high or my hopes too high or I don't know what it was, but this film did not work for me in a lot of ways,

I guess. I do agree with you that it does 100 % come off as something that was based on a play. If you ever go to the live theater and you're seeing anything in the murder mystery slash suspense genre, It plays just like this. It seems like like you can see this type of thing where we're all in like the same room or like couple rooms where it's a very limited cast, you know, all that kind of stuff. Like you can definitely tell you're dealing with that type of thing. And I

do think, you know, I guess there is some props to give because I guess they had like a lot of the walls and different things were like on rolling structures so that as they move from one room to another, they could pull back a wall so the cameras could get through with no interruption. And then the camera would You know go back and the wall would come back. So there was a lot of stuff going on from that and I guess you know from a What I was reading is from a carrot like the actor standpoint There was a lot of choreography that had to happen to make this all work whether

it be avoiding stepping on chords or you know like I said walls changing places and you got to be aware of that or Trying to make sure sense stuff is moving back and forth that when the camera is coming back that it's all how it was before And I don't know if that like somehow translates into the performances or it just translates into the overall effect of the movie. But I feel like it took for me it like you're saying it took me out of the movie time and time again to where I just wasn't invested like the what

I really was not anticipating and enjoyed on the thirty nine steps notorious was that they both had me from go like they hooked me like within the first Say five maybe ten minutes like I think the first five minutes of both of those films I was like I'm ready for this like I'm into this I'm watching the whole thing and this one definitely did not do that like we start with obviously like you say like there's a murder immediately and it was kind of like I don't know it took me a back a little bit about how they were setting the stage for this and So I wasn't

invested right away and I found myself wanting to be and trying to be and they just never did like throughout the entire I think this is like what an hour and 20 minutes like I never got hooked to the entire time And I will dig into a little bit of more of like a why that may be as well before I go back to you though I wanted to bring up the fact that it seems I Guess that both of us are a little bit more in line with like the contemporary reviews that happened when this movie came out Which is not usually the

case always like sometimes stuff gets reviewed in the moment and then over time like completely changed But the contemporary reviews were not necessarily overwhelmingly positive for this film even some of the people involved with this film Hitchcock and Jimmy Stewart both in some ways have alluded to the fact that they weren't huge fans of this film and then it seems though like as time has passed it's gotten this like really overwhelmingly positive I guess critique

because it's got like a 90 395 percent on Rotten Tomatoes and I was looking at like letterbox at to like a lot of the people in our film circles or you know film Twitter or whatever, you know people we've met and along the way when we've done this podcast and they're over almost overwhelmingly positive and I'm trying to figure out like what I missed or like why it doesn't work for me and we'll get into that as we kind of continue through this discussion, but What's your take on kind of like the the reception that this film had

originally, and then how it's evolved over time. Yeah, I guess after looking at like its contemporary reviews, I think a lot of people took issue with the fact that, you know, it was people almost celebrating murder. Like these main characters, their drive is like they wanted to commit the ultimate murder. And I think that turned some people away because I'd also think at that time Hitchcock was never really a huge Favorite for a lot of critics because he dealt with a lot

of like yeah taboo subjects so and this was dealing with that to an nth degree plus As mentioned it it was different because it did feel like a play It was a lot of and he moves the camera around a lot and I think for a lot of people that was maybe too much I think on a technical level Like I said, it's, it's well made and it's even like the, the map they use for like, cause you know, it's like an apartment and you see the background of New York city or I believe

it's New York city. Um, like, like in the use of lighting, especially near like the, the, the climax of the film. Oh, great. I think that like, that's all well done. So, and I think. that probably is something that a lot of people appreciate and I even I do like I appreciate that aspect of it I guess like for me it just I struggled with like you said connecting with anything that was here I It was this obviously cat -and -mouse

game which they call out and I guess I didn't really care if the mouse caught the cat because that's what my problem was Yeah, yeah, so it's like, you know, I just want them all to fail Not that like like ability isn't like a requirement, but I think I don't know it almost felt like I Wanted to say anti -intellectual, but it felt like certainly Hitchcock obviously this isn't his original creation But it felt like it was almost It didn't seem like a critique of the

that like those intellectual, you know those college circles those type of individuals who have this kind of high mighty type of um or about them, but in reality like they they lack kind of the basic morality of humanity because like they they don't see people as equals kind of showing that the economy of that I think Um again like those pieces I did it just like I don't know. I just like you said it's only 120 minutes It doesn't waste any time but I at the end of

the day. I was just like, I don't know what i'm supposed to beyond just the Watching it all take place. Yeah, it was just events happening I wasn't I didn't feel like a story was being told per se and and i've Long time been a fan of like the theater and i've been involved and i've gone like i've had different you know, subscriptions like annual, I don't know, season ticket holder or whatever to like different things. So I've seen a number of these on the on the stage. And I think what always has worked for me in those

types of thriller suspense. In a way, mystery plays is a couple of different things. Number one is. That the thrilling aspect or the suspense aspect or the mystery aspect like I was vested in as far as like I cared how it. how it resolved itself. Number one, and I didn't hear like I didn't care if they were caught or not caught in this at all. Like I was never vested in that.

And then I think the other thing that a lot of those films do or plays do well is in the journey of going through that suspense. A lot of them go one way or the other. One way they they tend to go is a comedic route where there's lots of funny aspects as we make our way through that. And the other side of that coin is they have these intellectual or thought provoking, provocative conversations, discussions that make you think with clever dialogue, clever thought processes

and things like that. And for me, this film did neither of those things. So not only am I not caring about the resolution of the suspense, but I'm not necessarily entertained in the journey as we go from one to the other. And like half of me thinks like. I would have rather them started talking about the fact that they had killed their classmate. Or talking about the idea of it without showing us that they had actually done it. And

like building in suspense on did they really do this? Is he really in this scene the entire time? Like maybe something like that where I don't know that it's already happened. Might have helped. But I don't know like from a character standpoint, like the main two guys, which is brand their characters names are Brandon and Philip. I found neither one of them. Likeable, I didn't find either one of them. Somebody that drew me in that I cared about like obviously

Brandon comes across as he's supposed to. I get it, but he comes across as kind of a despicable human being, right? And. Phillips not quite as bad but like neither one of them has me like they're not like commanding a commanding presence on the stage or in the film in this standpoint. That's like There's no Like we just watched a movie with Cary Grant Like they don't have that, you know what I mean? And I'm not saying that it was intended for them to have that obviously they have Jimmy Stewart playing a different character and that's kind of where they were going for that but like these other films that we talked

about 39 steps notorious like There was a lot of side characters, especially in 39 steps a lot of side characters that I cared about or that were entertaining or funny or that I enjoyed I don't care about the dad in this one I don't care about the sister -in -law, which to me is just weird that that's The other person involved in here um, and I didn't care about this for some of classmates Like the the janet character somewhat works for me Like I found her intriguing

and the fact that she's dated a couple of these guys and she comes across a little bit more magnetic a little bit more interesting at least to me and maybe mrs wilson who I guess is Made I don't know if it's 100 defined but she's basically taking care of the house and and fixing the dinner and stuff like that like Those two females I think did more for me than any of the other characters in this film Did any of the characters really work for you? I'll say I I actually I did like

the performance of like the of My goodness, I can't think of Brandon yeah, Philip and Brandon I thought like like Philip was like in the sense of like he was a good villain like I thought he did He was smore me. He like he the way he reveled like in what was happening. Like he was he was good at you can like, you know Twisting the knife like he felt like it's gonna be a weird comparison, but like one of those Belli TV show

characters were like they're they clearly brought on because they know how to create drama and he Definitely felt like that type of personality right in that sense of his ability to pray drama or like, you know, I Don't know like his if I'm a director though, like I don't know like if I watch this film I don't know if I'm ever calling These two guys as agent and like casting them in my film. Maybe I'm being harsh I don't know. I I didn't have an issue with their performance I thought their performances were fine. Like

I thought you know a little you know a little bit Brandon was a little baby a little bit much like his and a little bit also inconsistent and I felt at times where it was very kid, you know when you get to the end and it It became a bit redundant. I think the last act which is really maybe what soured me because we have this climax with account mouse game It seems like he basically admits that they killed him But then they also step back and say like, you know Just trying

to really like calls bluff or not. And it just it felt like we were that last ten minutes just Kind of circling the drain in a way where I was like I just get to it like I get like you're Like the back and forth it just felt like, you know It wasn't it's more annoying than like intense which was probably like it again I like I liked it on a technical level but in the sense of Like the suspense that wasn't there maybe because we're coming back coming going off to movies

which were super suspenseful compared to right but I felt here but yeah, I I do feel like the parents, the one mom who was really in the horoscopes and things like that. But it's not even the mom. Isn't it introduced as she's the aunt? She's the sister -in -law or something like that. I'm like, what are we doing here? I was trying to figure out the dynamic, like you said with... With miss mrs. Wilson. I first I thought the

place was her place, which really right like so that's that I mean, that's not Important, but I just felt like wait, it's his look. I wasn't sure who was who um, but it kind of makes sense through the end Uh, but like I guess like in the sense of the characters Like I didn't think they were badly performed. I just felt that I got it like it just felt like a lot of like it felt even though this is like 80 minutes it was a lot of repetition a lot of just like going

through the same and you know sometimes it's probably it's probably not as much the actors faults either i think like i don't think they're given a lot of like great stuff to chew on you know like even even jimmy stewart who's amazing i this isn't one of his best roles right like this is like His character confused me the most out of all of them like because there's a conversation that's surrounding murder and like and basically

how they're kind of both for in a way but then at the end he has this like aha moment where you know he's like well this isn't really what I was and it felt very to me it didn't ring true because I It seems like like oh you're twisting my words and i'm like not really They kind of they kind of just they didn't really twist the words. They kind of just did what you said That's exactly what you said. So it felt in a way like this character is supposed to have like he's supposed to be the The hero per se like oh look at him like he's putting them in their place

But like he's kind of just as he seems like he's more upset that they did it and he did it like Right, right. Like that's what like felt like his character felt like That conversation around murder is where it started Souring me a bit because it just like wait why like what it felt very What they were trying to say and I like it. That's where I thought like is this Hitchcock just basically kind of cask and dispersions against like The the intellectual elite or intellectual early,

you know that type of yeah Many of which tend to look down on his work. So I thought maybe that was part of it. Also, there's definitely like We're definitely saying that Philip and Brandon are gay, right? Without saying it, like that seems like very. Yeah, I read into that a little bit. The play, it's blatant in the play that it's based on. It's blatant. And it's also in the play, Jimmy Stewart's character is older and has had a relationship with one of the boys at some point. Like, and it's definitely much

more like out there. I think they were. Because this is 1948, I think they were. Not. Yeah, they're not saying it, but they're not saying it. It's certainly, it's certainly coded that way. Cause you know, just in the performance, like, you know, they're growing up, it definitely felt, you know, as close as you can get to you for that time, which also kind of just maybe soured me a bit. Cause it's almost like, is this what you're saying? Like, you know, people, you know, gay people are like, I don't know. Like, I don't know if that's taking it too far, but it felt,

I don't know. That might be. Yeah, I also feel like they had opportunities there like because there's so much dialogue like as you you brought up like this whole conversation about murder and Like I was when that starts like that whole sequence starts. I'm like, oh we're about to get some of this like more clever provocative like a conversation where at first you think you're gonna be Like easily on one side and like through the conversation you're starting to see like both sides type like that type of like Discourse

where you're like, oh wait a second like he had he makes a couple good points, but like it didn't do that It was just like just like it's good to murder folks. And I'm like, I can't I can't go there. I'm sorry I don't know like that was a little tough for me as well It's a movie that's built on dialogue. That's you know, that's where you know, that's the car you're all in one room It's all about conversation and I think in order to do that, you need to have really strong. Yeah Activating conversation and performances behind

it and I thought like we didn't really like the performance is like I said weren't bad I thought at times they had moments but nothing up like, you know, nothing about any of the characters here I felt super compelled by yeah or like the diet like any dialogue sequences where I felt were even like when we got to The you know where we're eventually getting to like this cat -mouse game I didn't feel like there was much of a cat -mouse game. It was just like oh he found the hat You know and like that was that kind of clued him in and like, you know, you see the gears,

you know, the little clue is adding up but I thought even it The middle section for the like the majority of that dinner You know, I felt like it should have been more suspenseful than it was like I didn't ever feel Any sense of danger or any sense of like they're close to like there's a body in the room Should be yeah, it should be built in right there. Like I don't yeah, so it just I get maybe like you said maybe it was just because it I've heard like you like you

have heard so much great things people loving this movie and I'm which is great. I mean I mean Maybe if I saw it again, I would enjoy it more I don't know and like I said, I think technically like the ability to use location and the construction of that location all great, but I I just felt like I I could tell this was all I didn't feel like the the one Long shot didn't movies any favor and like I mentioned the big thing is like every time where it was You know, we we saw that

break in action when it was clearly like ending one shot and going to the next Every time that happened any like any tension that was being built kind of just got deflated because it just reminded me i'm watching a movie and it just became aware of the filmmaking, which I think is You know to me like for a one, you know a one shot or it shouldn't take you out of it And again, it's just my experience with it. It did so that's that was more my bigger issue than necessarily the performances when you have a

film that starts off with a murder that we see on screen and then you have two guys that are going to be as bold and audacious to like put the body in a piece of furniture and then have a party with a bunch of people around it and I'm more fascinated or interested in figuring out, like, the dynamics between Janet and the guys that she's involved with. Like, that's problematic. When I stop immediately caring about the main crux of this film, like, I don't know. Like, it doesn't seem like it's doing it a good thing. But yeah, like I was I don't know. It just did

not work for me overall, especially as I went towards the end. If you compare this like the lifeboat, which is another Hitchcock film all taking place on a lifeboat. Love that I guess that's maybe I do love and and this is right up my alley like this is the type of film I like like I like a limited cast I like, you know, very limited set like one location to location something like that like a movie built around dialogue like all of these things check all my boxes and I Don't know. I feel like it makes me want like let's add lifeboat to it and compare

it because I'd be interested to see if that works better for you because I It's been actually checked letterbox. Like when did I watch like boat locks? It was 10 years ago. It was 11 years ago But when I watched it 11 years ago, I loved it. So I yeah So again, I think maybe it was perhaps building up too much. But like I I didn't hate the movie I didn't walk away like angry or like thinking no. No, it was just The power of expectations it just wasn't to me. Yeah, compared to what we've more of a head scratcher. It wasn't it

wasn't something that got you angry. It's more of like a head scratcher. Like what what did everybody else see that I missed type thing? Yeah, it's like I would wish I enjoyed it more. That was like a thing. It was just it was more disappointing because it's like I wanted to like this more and I didn't. And, you know, especially with a suspense film, it's hard to go back and try and watch it again, because if it didn't work for the first time, I don't see the suspense probably won't come the second time. So right. Couple interesting things as well. Well, before I get to that, I do find it interesting that

as meticulous as they're clearly trying to be about the choreography, about who's standing where, about where the furniture needs to be, and this, that, and the other, there was just like some blatant, and I know this isn't like big, this is more nitpicky stuff, but there's like some blatant things that you notice as you're watching. That's like, did nobody pick up on the fact that, for example, the guy cut, the guy breaks a glass on his hand. bleeding all over the place and like seconds later his hand has no sign of a scratch no bandage no anything

and they do a close -up of his hands okay I thought I was confused by that I'm like oh maybe he didn't scratch it that bad that's what I was a little confused like wait he has hand and then that was a little bit confusing because I thought that was gonna I thought that was gonna be coming to play more like it's like oh is he got you know he got blood someplace but it just One of the things where you cut yourself with glass and especially in the hand It doesn't you know, it takes a while. But yeah, that was a little weird. It was like, okay, I'm fine now Yeah, it just seemed a little weird there was the rope

that was clearly all the way in the piece of furniture and then it was like Almost all the way out like that was there was just little things that I'm like, oh, okay I guess I'll just like carry on like it's not important. Just keep going with it But how about a couple interesting trivia pieces the the first of all the guy that gets strangled at the beginning and screams I've never heard someone getting strangled be able to scream So that's interesting, but I know you have to do it for the effect of the movie, but that was his last film role. Oh Jesus I did last time He did seem old like we only see him for a brief

second and like it's like he that's what he seemed like he was bald and like he didn't seem like a young person which also can feel like it was like wait their classmate and then That doesn't make sense because he doesn't he looks so much older than them like that's just a crazy thing like hey my last role was I was Was killed in the first five minutes of this film and that was how I went out my my swan song in hollywood It was also the last film role for the girl that played janet jone chandler She didn't she I think she only appeared in like three films total which I was kind of surprised about because I thought she did have a little bit of Yeah factor, but

I thought that she was at least a little bit dynamic on on camera and I I looked her up because I was like oh what else did she do that I might find interesting and it was like two films before this and that was it maybe she maybe she did more Broadway and stuff like that yeah possibly a couple other obviously we talked about this a little bit I think at the end of last episode this is the first Technicolor film for both Hitchcock and Jimmy Stewart I believe if I read what I read correctly. There was a kind of a neat caveat

or like I guess moment in this one since we're going through a filmography. I don't know why I'm thinking. What the heck do they call those things? Easter eggs. Yes, Easter egg. A little Easter egg for us because they're talking about other films at one point and the lady, the mother -in -law or whatever and This that this is a couple of good moments by that Joan Chandler the Janet character because the way she's smiling and kind of laughing off and playing along with like this crazy lady that's all about her astrological

signs and trying to remember movies that she just can only describe as something someone and You know just vague words, but they're clearly talking about notorious at one point Which is kind of interesting because they've mentioned Cary Grant Ingrid Bergman and stuff like that. So I thought that was kind of an interesting little nod to one of his previous films, which just happens to be the last one we watched, which was cool. And they were also trying to reference something that Jimmy Stewart did, too. Like, I thought there was something I was trying to I wasn't trying to figure out what they were referencing, but I could. Yeah, there was a couple

of those. And just to kind of go back to what I was talking about with with both Hitchcock and Stewart. So found one quote from Jimmy Stewart that said, quote, The really important thing being rehearsed here is the camera, not the actors. Then he said it was worth trying nobody but hitch would have tried it, but it really didn't work and then Hitchcock basically said that the reason he did all of the long takes and and that was basically because he was trying to build the framework of a stage play and Trying to keep

the actors like present and alive within the scene like a play So those are all things we kind of picked up on as well any like Tidbits or other things that you picked up on the film that you haven't brought out yet Um, no, I only think that we talked about briefly was the you know The matting that they use in the background to kind of show the landscape of New York I love how like, you know, it was clearly like a painting but they also clearly had like vents or something like that like to like show Where it's like smoke coming off of it and stuff like that and how

it also when it would Came night and it would change over like that that piece I thought like those things were I thought were really quite I think I read that it was the largest backdrop Ever used in a film or something there was something about that backdrop. Like there was something significant about like the size or the Complexity or something about that. I think it's on I think I saw that somewhere on like IMDB IMDB on the trivia section Yeah, I was interested because I found myself looking at it a lot and there's

also like weird cloud formations and I guess that's what we smoke I don't know, but I thought that was pretty cool. Like I thought that was a good way of like the lights the lights at the end can what was your take on the red and Location nearby either like a restaurant or something

or something like a sign that was causing the lights Okay, I was trying to decide if it was like something if it was supposed to be like in Suggesting that the police were on their way and that it was like something to do with police lights I was really thrown off because it then also felt like it was coming from the inside which Yeah, I think I think it was just it was just coming from meant to put you in the plate because now it's nighttime and you're at the city so now Places are putting their lights on and it was just it was a way of like, you know clearly was meant to increase the Yeah, the tension

but it was yeah. Yeah trying in name. I had a question for you in 1948 That you know 9 -1 -1 didn't exist So was opening a window and shooting three guns into the three shots of your gun into the air was that like the 9 -1 -1 version of 1948 I thought that's pretty funny, too, because it's also like you hear the crowd and like, oh, we need to call the cops. And I feel like if that happened today, I would not get that reaction. It's like, all right, we got to we're going to go away now. And all three of them would have been sitting in that room for a long time. So

it's like, it's like you shoot a gun like that in the city. I don't like it's going to be hard to pinpoint the exact location it came from. Right. Like, I know there's a phone. They used it earlier in the movie. Yeah, I get it. I get it's like for dramatic effect, but I did think that to him like that seems I did love the final shot though, like of him sitting, you know, you see his back and You know one was on the piano. They wouldn't like drink it like I thought that was like again technical standpoint though the way it ended I like I like the framing It's Hitchcock,

of course So, of course like when it comes to you know framing scenes that they're great and I did like the way it ended on that final shot So obviously we don't have a couple of the things that we have seen in a few of the other films like there was no mother Relationship that we see here. There's no like Hitchcock blonde that we're talking about here. There is They continue some of the stuff though that we've seen as far as like the audience knowing what's happening like we know the whodunit of it and like so like Having that information and and going along for

the ride. I guess it's something that we've seen here a little bit Although it wasn't somebody that was like we saw in the 39 steps where it's somebody that's not guilty That's trying to get out of it, which I think is more of the Hitchcock theme so we'll have to see like I don't know if there was a lot of stuff here from a Storytelling standpoint that was Hitchcock Ian It was more so the the camera work and some of the physical aspects of like the creation of the film I think that we get a little bit more of his signature on it. Did you pick up on anything else? No,

I didn't pick up anything else so Alright, so I guess a lukewarm response for rope from 1948 from us Which I wasn't sure I wasn't sure if you're gonna go for this or if you're gonna be like me I was worried that I was gonna come on here and be like the negative Nancy So I think I definitely liked it more than you, but I didn't like it as much as I was hoping I would gotcha So next time what we have is we're gonna go three years into the future for 1951's Strangers on

a Train. So I have never seen that one. It's going to be another first time watch for me. Dan has seen this, but about how long ago was it, do you think, Dan? Oh, 13 years ago. I think the letterbox I can see it was 13 years ago. So there we go. So not a first time watch, but a first time in a long time watch. So and also on the backdrop of watching three other. Hitchcock film. So we're gonna see where strangers on a train takes it takes us Dan How can people keep

in touch with you or share some opinions with you online? You can check me out at Comic concierge. I'm on all social media platforms this guy threads tick -tock Hopefully gonna be started doing more YouTube video soon. So check that out. I'm a concierge on YouTube You can get a hold of me at Optimus Solo on most of the social media platforms, and you can get directly in contact with the show by searching out Cinema Geeks on the various platforms as well. Or if you want to get in touch

with what else is going on in the Geekcast Radio network, you can just search out geekcastradio .com and see all the other geeky things that the network puts out. So that does it for this episode. Tune in next time for another chance to listen to more Cinema Geeks.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Western Retrospective: The Outlaw Josey Wales

    Nov 16, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Halloween Special: Rocky Horror Picture Show

    Oct 31, 202641 minAudio

    Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Halloween Spotlight: The Exorcist

    Oct 29, 202642 minAudio

    Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Halloween Spotlight: Carrie (1976)

    Oct 26, 202639 minAudio

    Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Halloween Spotlight: Texas Chainsaw Massacre

    Oct 24, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...

    Credit the people on this episode