Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

CINEMA GEEKS

CINEMA GEEKS artwork

Hitchcock Retrospective: Strangers on a Train

Feb 22, 202547 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Today on Episode 208, The Cinema Geeks continue their trek through the filmography of the iconic Alfred Hitchcock. This time they look at, Strangers on a Train. One host discovers that the entire movie does not take place on a train while the other has a re-watch thirteen years removed. How will this one stack up to the previous films they covered? Tune in to find out! Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on X! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark! #UNLEASHTHECINEMAGEEKINYOU!!!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello discerning podcast listeners. This is Tom Kenny and you are listening to the geek cast radio network Hello and welcome to episode 208 of the cinema geeks I am one of your cinema geeks optimist solo and joining me today as usual is the comic concierge Hello, Dan. Hey, how are things? Things are going well, a little crazy,

but going well. I feel like this time of year, it's always a little crazy as you get after like the, the post holiday slash. I don't know what it is like between the Superbowl and like weather and different things. I just feel like January, February is always a little bit crazy. Um, at least for me, I don't know. How are you doing? Better now we had to skip we were recording a week late because of me excited the flu My household

my kid got the flu and strap and then I eventually got it as well. So that was not a fun time I'd had like no voice to even record. So it was like well, that's not happening but Luckily, but somehow my oldest son was unscathed. But you know Wow, well either he was patient zero and everyone else got sick or he's just All those vaccines worked. I don't know. Right something something I'm just having to be able to breathe again. So that's good, right? There's been a lot of stuff going around since the beginning of the year, too I think that's added to stuff because

we were all sick like the first week of the year basically spent New Year's Eve sick and like a lot of my People I know at work have been sick and it's just been it's been a thing lately. So hopefully yeah Hopefully it'll get better here soon so everybody can get back to normal but We're here today to continue our journey through the Alfred Hitchcock filmography We're covering 10 Alfred Hitchcock films today marks number four on that journey So we're at the 40 % mark see the mass easy when you just do 10

I can do that all day So today we are covering the 1951 psychological thriller film noir entitled strangers On a train and I know we talked about it briefly at the end of the episode last time dan But just in case people didn't listen to that one. What is your history background with strangers on a train? This was one I had watched before it was I realized it was before letterboxx even existed. So it was like, you know 12 13 years ago, but I had I had this was a rewatch

for me Which I definitely realized as I was going through it that I that i've seen this before Would did you remember a lot of it or was it a little bit foggy for you? I remembered like the tennis piece like our energy remembered like the the overall plot of it but like I I completely forgot how it ended like the the carousel sequences of like that that I can't remember but I just The beginning it just felt familiar. So gotcha. So as we said, this is obviously directed by Alfred Hitchcock It says a screen plays by Raymond Chandler and I'm not gonna try to pronounce that

name Senzi I guess I am going to try to pronounce it, Senzi or Mond, but according to most things I'm reading Raymond Chandler really didn't have much to do with the final product. He did not get along with Hitchcock. They had a falling out and he was replaced, but he still got credited. So I'll take that for what it is. Starring the likes of Farley Granger, Ruth Roman, Robert Walker, Patricia Hitchcock, Alfred Hitchcock's daughter, Casey Rogers and a few other folks. Obviously

one of those folks is someone who we just talked about when we talked about rope Farley Granger had played Philip in that film the not as dominant main character Killer, I guess you could call him in rope and now he plays the main good guy in this film guy Haynes opposite of Robert Walker's Bruno Antony and This film is about two people who meet on a train as the title alludes to which

it was interesting for me because this is a complete first time watch for me and I don't know why but for The better part of my life. I thought the whole film was going to take place on a train and I quickly found out that that's not what this is about But not that that's a it's not a negative about it or anything I just I don't know why I thought the whole thing was going to take place on a train But obviously these two guys meet on the train They have some discussions which one of them is obviously taking way more serious than the other the idea of exchanging murders comes up where one person can get rid

of somebody that's a pain in the The other person's behind and then the other person can reciprocate that favor for him and then it kind of goes down that path as the one of them is obviously trying to actually act out on this Exchange where the other one wants nothing to do with it guy novel. He's an architect in the movie He is a tennis player. So we also get something that I I'm not saying this is like the earliest because there's a lot of films that come out before 1954 1951 excuse me, but it's one of the earlier instances

that I have seen a movie of that you could almost like Qualify half of this film is like a sports movie maybe not half but like there's definitely more sports sequence than I was anticipating as well and it's kind of interesting for me because 2024 which just ended obviously had the the movie entitled challengers, which is about tennis players. And so there was a lot of parallels that you could draw between the two as far as how they're shot when it's the actual tennis sequence, which I found somewhat interesting. But what was your initial take here on Strangers on a Train on

this rewatch? Going back to it, rewatching it, one thing I think we talked about with Rope last time, how it premise of it like kind of didn't work as in that kind of hindered the overall enjoyment. I really love the premise here. I think this is like, you know, it is one you you can understand nearly everyone's motivation and understand like usually when someone doesn't go to the police or something like that. It's

kind of like why wouldn't they just do that? But here it all makes sense because it is this happenstance that makes you wonder like how much of this was planned by By Bruno is he just like this and you like he clearly he sought this out and just the machinations of how it undergoes the Like Robert Walker's so good in this like I think he he was good in rope too, but like He's charming at times. You mean Friarly Granger

or Robert Walker? Friarly Granger was the one in Rope. Robert Walker is the guy in this one. I'm sorry. Yes, sorry. Robert Walker. Both were really good, but I thought Robert Brunow, who played Brunow, Robert Walker was especially really good in this because you could see him be a bit charming, but he seemed, let's underline, just a bit of sadistic at times in a way. I really appreciated how you had a lot of scenes that just took their time. You know, you have the

carnival scene that leads to the first murder and it really makes you wait for it. You're anticipating it that even gives you like a nice fake out is in the first when they're like going through the tunnel. You hear the scream. You're like, oh, that's when it happened. But when you found out it didn't occur. But I thought it was really good. I really enjoyed just. The concept of it how it all came about and the only thing that lost me a little bit was like the finale of this

the you know, the Sequence with the carousel. I don't know. I just at times it felt like I was like is this meant to be Funny yet like I almost felt like there's a bit of comedy there that I didn't know if it was intentional or not intentional Because it's you know, it's on a carousel and it just seems like a really random place to have this you know, massive showdown or whatever you want to call it. But beyond that, uh, I thought there's a lot of, uh, interesting ways that approach the story using the backdrop

of tennis. And you can see a lot of that playing into the plot as well. Like this, this can just send back and forth. Yeah. There's a couple of things here that I just felt like we're done to a more effective manner. You brought up rope and I feel like one of the things that for a rope didn't work for me is that it's a quote unquote suspense or thriller that I didn't feel any suspense or thrill from in a lot of ways. I'm not saying it was completely amiss, but like it just wasn't maximized. And in this one, you get that like in spades like there's. From the

initial meetup between Bruno and Guy, you're wondering. First, you're wondering like how serious is Bruno, right? Like you kind of have a feeling that he's not all Don't know if not all there is the right term but like that there's something amiss right? Like there's some yeah off with him in the same way that you see from the characters in rope But then you were trying to the ones in rope There's no suspense because you just they commit a murder immediately, right? So like there's no like are they just talking about it?

Or are they gonna do it where you have a little bit of that here where you're like, okay This guy's a little off. But is he how you know, how much is he how far is he gonna push this? Where is he gonna go with it? And then you have a little bit of suspense with guy because you're trying to figure out if he's gonna Intentionally or unintentionally become a part of this like is he gonna come around because there is definitely a sequence in the first third where guy is Because well, let me back up at first in the train You're

you're clearly seeing a dichotomy of like one person that's a little crazy and the other person wants nothing to do with him and you're like there's no way he's going to willingly go along for this, right? He's going to humor the guy and be polite because they're on the train and then he's going to like find a way to get away from him. And that's going to be the end of his interactions with him. Like if you take this into like a real world setting, but then there's a sequence in that front third where guy has a meetup with his current wife. And I feel like that's such a intelligent and important sequence

and scene. To include in the movie because there was definitely times during that sequence where I was. Rationalized in my head how this guy is going to. Say yes or like how he's gonna like be a willing participant in this nonsense that they were talking about on the train like there's a split second or at least a few moments where I'm like oh he he might actually. Get involved more than I think he's going to now he doesn't ultimately. But there was at least that moment

where I'm like, he might actually participate. So even from the premise and the onset, I feel like there was a little tension and there's a little suspense that's built in immediately, which I definitely appreciate how this one starts in respect to how Rope started, because it just builds it in more. And then I feel like you get a lot more of that than throughout the rest of it, because then we're introduced into this situation where he's not a willing participant, but there's

going to be a number, like a series of things that Bruno is going to be doing to try to force him to be involved, right? Like there's lots of little different ways that he's interjecting himself into the guy's life, sending him things. um you know putting more evidence out there that's going to eventually possibly force him to take an action what that action is where that's the suspense but so i feel like they handled there were just these like little moments built in throughout that like really aided the suspense

part for me how about you yeah i think you make a point regarding like making you wonder like how much would guy actually buy into it because you know clearly He doesn't seem like someone that would murder anyone, you know, right? Yeah, just because but he's also in a situation where he has no escape from and this guy is making good points like this this, you know, can he be tempted? You know, he and I think that's something that this had was you had those characters that

had the opportunity of being tempted in this case guy and even you know his his His new relationship as well and you kind of see them kind of get sucked into that world trying to in one of those things Where you know, you try to escape, you know, like quicksand, but the more they do the more they get sucked in so I thought that was very effective and How it approached that just like this unnerving? aspect of it where you know it It felt good where you had characters that would talk to one another. Yeah, and it wasn't

always I feel like sometimes they're There's a show we watched called from and I like the show but it's uh, like one of the biggest things about it is that no one like so many problems could be solved that people just had a conversation And this had all those conversations, you know, like, you know guy talking to his I guess I guess you wouldn't say girl. I don't know how what her relationship was but um, just like she figured it out and you know rather than him denying it they they kind of had that it felt kind of like

oh good, they're not just like they're people are acting normally and yes, which felt was outside of Bruno of course, who's a little crazy, but you kind of saw that like he had that he felt like a Hitchcock character, right? Because he has we as you mentioned, you brought up many times regarding how Hitchcock loves characters that have clearly weird relationships with their mother. That's that's definitely Bruno. But but yeah, we get a couple of those things we get like the relationship with his mother. We get

the person that is innocent that is not necessarily on the run, but like in a defense mode where we're seeing, you know, that's obviously what we saw in the 39 steps specifically. So like we definitely are seeing a lot more of like the Hitchcock aspects, Hitchcockian aspects in this. I agree. But I think what you and I'll let you continue. I didn't mean to cut you off. But the other thing that you said, like these people are. It's not just that they're having conversations, but they're having real conversations. Like they're having conversations that you believe the everyday

person would have in these situations. So it's not where they're either number one, just not talking or number two, where they're like having these like. And I'm all for like some clever dialogue in movies, like I love that in situations, but like this doesn't call for it. And so they're like having real conversations that you can picture like. friends or family members having if they're in this situation or as they're trying to work through this so it made it it added a sense of realism that otherwise you could have gone like you could have really amped this up in this film and made it just like completely like I don't

know like gone too far with it to me in a way that it wouldn't have felt real and I'm I appreciate like the restraint that he had to not do that here yeah there's there's restraint all over the thing that's a good word because A lot of like the you talked about this had a lot of suspense to it as you'd hope for a thriller and a lot of that just happened in a lot of scenes where there was that restraint like when you had guy going into Bruno's home and it's just him walking down the stairs that thing goes on for quite a while and Not a lot of conversation. You know,

it's just like is he gonna do it like it right? I did a really good job of just letting that play out to eventually where it comes to its conclusion. And I think that in, like I mentioned, too, in the first carnival scene, which one? I want carnivals that have boats like that, like where they can go on a boat and like you just go out into a little island and stuff like that. I don't know if I need them with the Cupid dolls, though. That's true. That's true. Maybe you wonder. It's like, yeah. Although he never got the prize for hitting the hammer all the way up. He immediately

show him in the next sequence and he's not carrying around the creepy doll. Just I guess gave it to a kid or something. I don't know. Maybe the kid that he blew he Popped a balloon of with his right But yeah, so that I think restraints a good word because I think there is a lot like We're hitchcock just allow scenes to play out and like gives them time and I think that was very effective here yeah, and I think another thing too you mentioned I'm glad you brought

it up because I There's a couple of sequences here where yes, you know the movies from 1951 a lot of people have seen it this that the other But I think it did a good job too of not necessarily for a first -time watch not telegraphing What and it's not like the whole game where like you're trying to predict what's happens And if you can predict that it's bad and if you can't it's not you know Or whatever that type of thing is but but there's like legit moments in here where you as a first -time watcher for me I wasn't sure which way they were going like I wasn't gonna predict the the events that happen when

he visits Bruno's house. When he goes to, not like, I don't think he had been there. Was that the first time he was there? Was he only there once? I think so. So when he goes to that house, I'm not predicting what's gonna happen when he gets up. you know, up to the top of the stairs. And I'm also not going to I wasn't able to predict what was going to happen when he's going down those stairs. Like there was multiple points in there where I'm like, which way are we going here? And is it going to happen like this or is it not going to happen like this? So there was like suspense within that, too. That was

like it helps. It helps when you have little moments like we talked about before that are just naturally adding suspense. But then when there's situations here where you're legit, like not seeing what's coming, like that adds another level of suspense. So I feel like You know, that's all over this place. I think all the I think restraint is a good word to a point Because I think he shows a ton of restraint through like 90 of this movie And that's like he was showing so much restraint that he just had to like let it all go. Yeah The final sequence like amanda

has been watching all of these films or most of them with me And that sequence happens in like we're just like oh, we're oh, we're going we're going there. Like this is happening Like what is going on? It's a little off the rails, crazy and no pun intended, I guess. But yeah, there's one moment where he doesn't show restraint. Yeah, because it starts with a cop just shooting into a crowd of people, which and then kills the guy operating the carousel, which also makes you wonder like they made a carousel go that fast. But I'm like, I guess it's the fifties

and have the regulations they do now. So it seems like a bad design. Yeah Like that's what I did feel like at times like that scene was meant I don't know like I don't know if it was meant to be as communicate as it came off at times like Sometimes it was because you had the police arguing because you just have this old guy just nonchalantly Going under this speeding carousel, which apparently he really did. Yes. I read that too. Yeah And then the police are like, you know, you want to stop him? He's like, I'm not doing it But it was just every time they cut to that

guy, though, I just felt really funny because it's just like he was so unmoved by it. He's like, I guess I got to do this now. Right. And then I feel like the people at that time, though, probably didn't find it as comedic as we might now. Maybe. Yeah. Yeah. Because I was feels like it could have been like an awesome power scene because they're on a carousel and like fall off. It's like two feet. I guess I guess they're going maybe if they're going super I don't know how fast I've never seen a carousel go as fast as that thing seemingly was going No, no. Yeah,

I that that's the one part where I'm like, all right this felt like you know that We get to the Marvel movie where it's like the unnecessary just way too long Final battle sequence that goes on forever. I mean definitely that version of it for that time Oh, you have this crazy, you know carousel thing. I mean it was like exciting I guess and entertaining but it did go and then it it's destroyed. I don't know. I was I was wondering too speaking of the ending if Maybe

his cock originally wanted maybe a darker ending and it has because it like it hints that it's gonna end up pretty You know, like everyone loses in the end, but it doesn't go that way. I almost makes me wonder if like that was what he wanted to do with the movies at the time. Couldn't exactly do that. Yeah, I could see that totally because there is a lot of writing on this film about how like they're really trying to make these two characters talking about Guy and Bruno as a lot more similar than you would think on the

surface level. Like just that the way they shoot this and everything, like especially the introductory sequence where they're showing, you know, they're taking the same path onto this train. You know, yeah, they might be wearing different shoes to like differentiate the two of them. But like there's a lot of like showing these two. I don't know. I read somewhere that they even use the word doppelganger, which I don't know about that because they don't look alike at all in my opinion. But like there were some things that were trying to like get them to to be seen almost as very similar. even though they're obviously very different

individuals. So like I could see that being something where he was going to let them all, you know, come to a grave end. What did you think of the so obviously he has, I guess you call it a love interest that is not at the time his current wife. So I don't know if it's his mistress, his love interest, his future wife, whatever you want to call it. But he has a relationship with her and that character's name is Ann Morton played by Ruth Roman and then there's Barbara Morton,

which is her younger sister who is Patricia Hitchcock That's Hitchcock's daughter and then the senator there their father Leo Carroll What did you think of the three of them as kind of like supporting characters and and what they added? To the film and did those characters work for you? I didn't know those just got started. That's interesting. But it also kind of makes sense because she was the one kind of you know going in and Almost explaining what was happening, pretty verbatim. Right. Just pointing it out. I thought his love

interest is, you know, his future wife. I thought she I liked I really liked her character because it was good seeing someone who was able to put the pieces together and figure things out on their own. You know, seeing for now act the way he did connect the dots. But at the same time. Also still trust guy like it wasn't it didn't like artificially create like this Separation like you know, yeah, like awesome. I hate you. Yeah. Yeah that she kind of she believed him Which I guess I guess there's different ways

of taking that but I really like their character because I thought it It made the story That going back to like I said like the conversations feeling like all these are type of conversations You always want these characters to have she was a big part of that. How about yourself? Yeah, I actually did enjoy Patricia Hitchcock as well. I thought that she added, like yes, she is doing some explaining of different things in that manner, but I thought she added like a little bit of

levity to some dark themes that we're kind of going through. And I thought she added, not necessarily from like a comedic standpoint, But I thought from a levity standpoint, like just lightening the mood a little bit helped out a little bit. And I thought that. The senator, too, like it was believable, like I don't think that was overplayed. I think there was some restraint shown there, too, like he is a senator and he does like try to help out in the ways that you would expect somebody of in a position of power to help out.

But it's not like this like. Untouchable, like he can do anything he wants. He's just going to save the day type. depiction of a senator as well. So like I kind of enjoyed the the trio of them and they all bring like a little bit of a different aspect to the film, which I appreciated. Yeah, yeah, I that little that whole family. I think it was really important for the story to work as well as it did. Yeah. And then you have Casey Rogers, who plays his current wife, who I thought did a good job of of coming across

as unlikable from go. Like that whole sequence at her workplace or whatever it was was like, oh, this person's like despicable in a way, like not in the same way that obviously Bruno is. But Miriam's definitely not a likable character, which I think added a lot because that was helping you to like see like a strand of or like if you follow this one strand, like how this could impact guys decision making for the rest of the film. Or at least from the that first part of if he's

gonna decide to like join in on this or not so I thought like I don't think they're as Fun as the side characters that we got in the 39 steps But I don't think they needed to be I think they were They added stuff so it wasn't like just characters that I didn't care about like which we saw Well, one of my complaints and rope was that some of those characters at this party? Really added nothing in my opinion to the overall

plot or the overall feel of the film where I feel like each one here does even the detective or police captain or whichever I don't know what his rank was but the one that's Kind of tailing them and following them and they all know that and they're like riding together in the cars and stuff like that like I thought even him like Added a little bit of something to the film where it's like yeah, he's i'm not saying like any of them are like these standout like knock them dead like steal the show type supporting characters but they all had a purpose and they i felt like they all added something like even you could

go as far as like there's a i don't know if it was a party or what was going on what the occasion was or what the reason for the occasion was but they're at an event basically at I'm assuming the Senator's house. I'm trying to remember specifics about the movie, though, where there's a lot of folks there that Bruno kind of crashes. And he's talking to, you know, a number of women, like older women and stuff like that, and having fun and trying to like, you know, really chew

on that scene a little bit. And then there's leads to him actually pretend choking one of them. Even those women, like I felt like they were well done and well placed and like added something to like the How you can be close to this individual and let him in and like lower your defenses to the point where he's literally almost killing one of them on the on the couch. So like I appreciated that. What about you for some of these other like supporting cast? Yeah, I thought the castle for all was pretty strong, even like in also played a big role. You go back

to the carnival. You know, I I. Like how you little scenes that ended up coming back is you have when bruno ends up making that murder you have this guy that spots them and sees them and you want him in or if you know any clocks and we wonder if that's gonna come back again and it does and that's something i think hitchcock is really good at is like foreshadowing or kind of leaving those seeds or having his little pieces of trinkets that come back like you know this time being a lighter like he likes using lighters

a lot i don't know why but yeah. I did I did feel like the lighter was a little bit of a I don't want to call it a MacGuffin necessarily But it was like a little bit of like a stretch like we're gonna plant this one lighter and that's gonna mean That you're gonna be found guilty because nothing's gonna happen to that lighter and then somebody's magically gonna find it Give it to the police like I'm like, okay. We'll just go with it Yeah, and of course he's gonna drop it in the drain and you know, you have to there was you know, it was a bit much Yeah, we're gonna

Yeah, yeah, that's definitely you know Hitchcock it likes to you know Although that like the the the script I think the overall creation of the story was good There were those moments where it's like, okay We got a we got to like throw some stuff in here that may be a little bit too much But you know, I was I was and I was in for the ride there. But yeah Yeah, absolutely. You you mentioned like the the tennis sequences and how there's you know Seeing how did you think overall? Obviously, they're not a huge part of the story except for the ending where obviously,

you know You have the tennis game and it's yeah building tension overall. Like how did you feel those were we're we're done because it's You know, this is the first time we've gotten a Hitchcock film where you have, you know, right sports being playing such a danger role Yeah, I wasn't not only was I not expecting it but I wasn't expecting it to last as long as it did like they actually stay with that for quite some time it feels like Which I guess is like trying to add to the tension because you know He's trying to win this game like as quick as possible and obviously it doesn't go his way because he's being distracted and

you know it's affecting him but I thought like from a from the way it was shot it was done fairly well and from the Decisions to either have the I guess he I guess Hitchcock went to like a tennis tournament and like film some stuff from like Far away type things to get some realistic stuff. Then you have obviously the use of like showing the crowd and showing them following the ball back and forth, which seems like a really boring thing, but it somehow works at times as long as it's done right. And then seeing the folks

in the crowd that are just following it versus those that are maybe distracted on other things, which is where I got the parallel to the challengers from 2024. But I thought it was done well. It helps that the one guy playing opposite of him is a tennis professional. And I guess he was used to help coach I'm gonna forget his name, but Guy is the actor that plays Guy Haynes. He helps coach him and then plays the other part. So I think there was enough there that made it work. I was glad it didn't go on any longer.

I thought it maybe had overstayed its welcome at one point, but I was pleasantly surprised for someone that's not like a, you know, I know what tennis is and I... I've played it in like gym class, but I'm like, not a tennis a Christian. I was still like, yeah, it's and if they didn't really, and it was interesting too, cause it didn't like explain it at all. It's like you kind of, you know, in a sense of like who was winning and that was part of like the game. I thought that was interesting. One of my favorite shots in the entire movie was at, was not the final. tennis game but the you know in the in

the middle where you have we're now showing up to the tennis match and you see everyone's head moving back and forth with the game him like like just looking straight on i thought that was really effective like that felt like one of those iconic pitchcock moments and i think that's something that this had uh on a on a number of occasions that being one of them that something you know rope i felt like didn't so yeah i agree with that i think yeah i think it worked i do have to comment like I don't know if they ever explain how far apart these two places are like

the place that Bruno is from and the place that guy is at with his uh with the senator and all that stuff but this Bruno guy is getting to and from places with no problem like it's it's I know it's a movie and it has to like work that way but there's a couple times where I was like How far away is this? Cause we had like the long train ride, but then this guy's going back and forth with like seemingly ease. Like it's like next door. They must have a lot of, I mean, I guess they did have a lot of trains back then,

but they still seem to have a lot of trains. Right, right. Um, so this one obviously got, uh, is, is well received when it goes, I don't, I didn't do as much of looking at the actual time, the, like the Contemporary reviews of it while it was out. I don't know if you did that or not for this one As far as like overall Rotten Tomatoes, I think it has like a 98 % Obviously, it's it's well received as one of One of the films that makes Hitchcock, you know the iconic director that he is known to be Roger D recalled

at one of his five best films It's on like a billion list, so I'm not going to list them all because it's just, you know, all the different lists like the movies you need to see before you die and the all the greatest lists. So it's well received. It was actually one of his first box office success films is what I read. How do you feel like once all is said and done, like this stacks up with, you know, the ones that you've seen before, at least the ones we've covered here before, like I had a feeling. Because I

was I was really torn on this one at one point and I'll try to explain why but the first third maybe of this film or the first like quarter of it. I had this overwhelming feel of like we had leveled up. Like. I have nothing against the films that we have watched previous to this, but it seemed like not. I'm not saying like overall it was better or worse, but I felt like from a filmmaking standpoint. from a production standpoint, from like all the things that Hitchcock is known

for. I was like, oh, we are like on another level now. Like we've arrived at something different. And I was like really hooked in from the beginning because I was like. I don't know, I just felt like we had gone up an echelon or something like that. Now I don't know if it's as rewatchable as or if I like. Had as much fun with it as I did with maybe a couple of his other films But I'm not saying that makes it a worse film I'm just I'm really torn on how I like come down and rank this film amongst the other ones that

we've talked about Not that I want to give away like every time we talk about a film where we all rank it all and then you know We get to the the final of this retrospective there won't be any suspense, which would be ironic, I guess but How did this one work for you overall? Did you have a feel that this was like on a different level or made in a superior fashion compared to the others or did it just kind of fit in with everything we've watched? I think it I don't know if I said it leveled up completely because I It's interesting looking at what we've seen so far because you look at something like I'm

not broke but the movie before and which felt like a notorious which was at the Time people were serious it was more of a relationship drama where this to me felt like when like Hitchcock when you think Hitchcock you think thriller and this felt like Hitchcock just felt like the type of atmosphere you'd want from him as I mentioned like those number of scenes where it you had great amount of tension just because he was allowing those scenes to play out so I think in the sense

of Just on a thriller aspect or you know feeling like you're getting that guy that kind of commands the screen Makes you nervous throughout that definitely felt like the most that's Just so far. This is a movie that has done that the most um now overall quality wise or you know, I or you know general story I don't know if i'd say leveled up compared to some of the other stuff But on the sense of like exciting um Moments or scenes like this to me had the most thus far,

but I think notorious was a very different film I showed a very different side of him. So I think this this to me is getting in more into like That what he's down for type deal. Yeah. Yeah So obviously both of us do some reading on the films beforehand was there any little like bits of trivia that you had come across that we haven't you hadn't had a chance to share yet about this film and then I had a couple and then a couple more questions for you as well Only thing I really saw and we talked about already was how in that final casino in the Sequence at the end where

the guy was really crawling under the actual Carousel and how that you know wasn't so that that I didn't know that was interesting, but that's the only thing I saw regarding Yeah, and apparently Hitchcock said that that was the most dangerous stunt ever performed under his direction and that he would never allow it to be done again, so I guess it was Somewhat scary for those people that were involved with it as well Um, I didn't know this was a thing, but I read that there's a sequence basically between Ruth Roman and Patricia Hitchcock. Those are the two sisters at the tennis

match where they give and show an actual real U S $10 bill. Um, I did not know that that was illegal unless you got permission from the U S treasury department. Uh, and it wasn't until like eight or nine years later for psycho that they had removed that like legality. But apparently back in the day, you couldn't show real money on a film. So that was interesting to me. This was the last completed acting role for Robert Walker, who plays Bruno Anthony. He dies eight months after filming from an allergic reaction

to a drug used to treat his alcoholism as one version of the story. But there seems to be multiple versions of the story that say that it was, uh, that there was maybe something else involved. It's kind of a whole little mystery and some suspense, I guess, about how he died. But the interesting thing and the reason why I brought it up was because he does have another film. and I found it interesting that there's a film called My Son John that came out in 1952 the next year that he had filmed some stuff and then they had to like try to figure out how to finish

it so obviously they rewrote part of the script they did different things but they actually use outtakes from this film and like put it in their film with Hitchcock's permission in order to like complete the film so I've never seen my son, John, but I'd be interested to see that and see if you could pick out like which parts were actually from Strangers on a Train instead, just to make it work for that. Like that's kind of interesting. And then there was two other ones that I wanted to mention. Casey Rogers, who is the one that plays Guy Guy's actual wife.

And there's a thing there between Casey Rogers and Hitchcock's daughter, Patricia, where they're both wearing like very thick glasses, like almost like those Coke bottle glasses. And apparently Casey Rogers has like perfect vision. But putting those on made her completely blind. So like that she had to have like all kinds of assistance and be guided when she was wearing those to like help make sure she didn't like have accidents fall over. And I guess if I was to rewatch it, they say you can watch the sequences she's in.

And there may be a couple of times where you see her like running her hand like along a table or a wall or a chair or something. Which was her doing it on purpose to try to like make sure she knew where she was and like not run into things and stuff like that So I thought that was kind of interesting and then one of the older ladies that's on the couch I don't know if it's the one that gets choked or if it's just one of the ones that's sitting next I didn't do enough research on that But this was her final film. I find this crazy though So this actress had an 18 year career in Hollywood or in film. She

appears in 77 films 65 of which she's uncredited in, including this one. So 65 out of the 77 films she doesn't get credit for. I mean, I'm sure now that she's listed, I'm sure they picked her out and like she's on the IMDB for just as uncredited. But like that's crazy to have that long of a career and only have 12 of your appearances out of 77 actually have your name on the film. So the other one, which is the one I wanted to ask you a question about because I didn't. necessarily

pick up on this, but we did mention it when we talked about Rope. I don't think we talked about it with Notorious or The 39 Steps, but I did read one trivia bit that says Alfred Hitchcock and Robert Walker, who plays Bruno Anthony, worked out an elaborate series of gestures and physical appearance to suggest the homosexuality and seductiveness of Bruno's character while not getting caught by like the censors of the time. Did you pick up on any of that when you watched this or did you sense like I know we kind of did a little

bit with Rope, but did you sense it at all when you were watching this one a little bit like or I think mostly kind of a little bit with this portrayal or at least In the way that I feel like people viewed homosexuals at the time and like in this relationship with his mother I felt like that was kind of you know, how I don't know and how he felt very antagonistic against his father so I didn't I felt like if that was if those pieces were meant to end that like, you

know, maybe his father his issues with his father because Perhaps that's a reason it wasn't as I think as overt by any stretch of the imagination as a rope was but I could As you say that looking back on it I could some things are starting to click a little bit Yeah, and then last question for you if you had to choose One if you had to choose either Bruno's mom in this or the Villains

mom from notorious to be your mom Which which would you choose? Um, I well, I guess you gotta give Bruno's mom the credit for trusting her boy, right? I mean, yeah And I guess her hobbies are just painting. She's not like plotting Death and yeah destruction She's not a Nazi. So I'm gonna go with her. I guess that's a good choice That's gonna that's gonna give her give her the

win So and then last question before we round this one out What's the over under on how many more people we have six films to cover still the over under on how many? Instances of strangling we're gonna see for the rest of the way out six films Man, I would put the over under at six point five at least one point Want one per movie so he likes to strangling that's for sure Hitchcock is a point that a lot Well, I did forget to that I think there might have been an instance where

we would have also had a Hitchcock blonde in this film but apparently he was Ruled against he didn't have any choice on the it seemed like he didn't have any choice on these Casting for Ruth Roman who plays the like the love interest because at the time you had to basically choose actors or actresses that the studio employed, which seems like something that's so far removed from today, obviously. So they basically had

to use an actress or the studio basically forced him to use it. And I guess he was very vocal about not liking her and not wanting her as a part of the film. And there's a few actors that were involved in the film that basically said that Like he did not treat her very well on set, things of that nature. So I wonder if that's where he wanted like another one of his Hitchcock Blondes. That's that's a complete inference. I have no idea if there's anything to that. But I did find it interesting, too, because they did get permission to borrow. I guess is the term they used one of the other actors. I think

it was. The Robert Walker character, Bruno Anthony, I think he was borrowed from another studio, but it's just kind of a crazy. Studio system that was existing back in the the 50s. Were you aware of that before? Yeah, yeah, just okay just from reading different things and so like either movies or story or books that took place during that time that whole studio era and you know, you especially like Judy Garland and those stars

and Like yeah, they had these crazy contracts and that's who you worked for that's who you were signed with and you know, it was It's almost like It was more akin to like the way sports stars are treated now, you know, you would sign with a franchise they'd have like people they try to bring up and you know Start them, you know put them in different, you know movies to help forward their career and then try to make them into Massive stars. Yeah, it would like the whole studio era is crazy good and bad. It's just there's a lot of interesting documentaries

about it. So All right any final thoughts on strangers on a train No, it just makes you realize don't talk to people you don't know on trains because which they do show you at the end of the film Yeah, it's better to just walk away into the other card. I guess the other car Don't dine in somebody's personal car. Like you have to go to the dining car or wait Wait the 20 minutes until it's available You can't do this movie now because like people don't use public transit as much and when they do they're on their phones or so. Yeah It wouldn't. It would have never

have happened. I did. That was that was also, yeah, like I completely didn't see the whole thing happening with the guy that like he's using as his witness. Like, yeah, I didn't see that coming either because I didn't realize how inebriated I guess he was at the time when he's watching all of that. That's not going to work. So. So, yeah, another interesting chapter in our Hitchcock filmography. Next time we're going to be going a few years into the future. I think this one was released in 1951. We're going to move. to 1954 for Hitchcock's Dial M for Murder. Dan,

I know we do this every time, but have you seen Dial M for Murder before? I have. I actually realized because I had like I wasn't a box set, but it was like a DVD set of like Hitchcock movies and Dial M for Murder, as well as Strangers on a Train was on both. So that's how I watched both of them. Nice. It'll be a first time watch for me So I'm looking forward to it to see like where we go from there and see if we get anybody strangled on that one or not As far as how people can stay in contact with you with you reach out to you get questions or see other Content that

you create Dan. How can people do that? I just search comic concierge on all the different platforms Facebook Twitter. I talk Instagram threads blue sky. There's so many so many things. So how about yourself? Yeah, you can search out either optimist solo for my Twitter and and that type of thing or if you want to See some of the other nerdy content I put out you can search out the geek showcase There's a bunch of different types of stuff there that maybe you will find interesting You can also search the show out at the cinema

geeks. You can search cinema geeks on all the different social medias Well, maybe not as many as Dan just listed but as far as the main ones and then you can also stay in touch with the website that we're hosted on the geek cast radio network where they do a lot of other content along the world of geekdom, cartoons, video games, and all kinds of other stuff. So that does it for this episode of The Cinema Geeks. Tune in next time for another chance to listen to more Hitchcock Talk from The Cinema Geeks.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Western Retrospective: The Outlaw Josey Wales

    Nov 16, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Halloween Special: Rocky Horror Picture Show

    Oct 31, 202641 minAudio

    Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Halloween Spotlight: The Exorcist

    Oct 29, 202642 minAudio

    Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Halloween Spotlight: Carrie (1976)

    Oct 26, 202639 minAudio

    Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Halloween Spotlight: Texas Chainsaw Massacre

    Oct 24, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...

    Credit the people on this episode