Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

CINEMA GEEKS

CINEMA GEEKS artwork

Western Retrospective: High Noon

Sep 6, 20261 hr 7 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Today on Episode 253, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up is Gary Cooper in High Noon. At the time John Wayne and Howard Hawks really didn't care for High Noon but many critics loved it and found Cooper award worthy. Will Kevin and Dan align with the critics or will they be more in the John Wayne/Howard Hawks camp? Tune in to find out! Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on X and Blue Sky! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark! #UNLEASHTHECINEMAGEEKINYOU!!! #CinemaGeeks #Westerns #WesterRetrospective #HighNoon #GaryCooper

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hi, this is John Delancey and you are listening to the GeekCast Radio Network. Hello and welcome to episode 253 of the Cinema Geeks. I am one of your Cinema Geeks Optimist Solo and joining me as usual is the Comic Concierge. Hello, Dan. Hello, how are you? I'm well, I'm doing good. I'm ready, excited to talk about another of our

Western films and our Western retrospectives. So for those getting whiplash, it's not Planet of the Apes today. It is Western talk. So we're going to be continuing our run through kind of a second classic Western block that I believe you've seen. Have you seen all four of these or is there one that you haven't seen? Not seen Rio Bravo. that's the one i which we'll be doing next so i haven't seen that but i have this was a rewatch for me and how long had it been since

you watched it the first time oh more than one time yeah it's this is only the second time and last time was like literally like 15 16 years ago so interesting interesting okay and all four of these are blind spots for me as most of this retrospective has i think we're going to eventually get to some here in the later blocks that i've seen uh that i'm coming with some some ammunition for but uh definitely not these 1940s and 50s westerns uh blind spots all the way through so very excited to kind of get into this discussion on the the heels of red river and and all the

other ones we've talked about but before we get into our thoughts and opinions of our watch and our rewatch of this film. Dan's going to lay the groundwork for us. So take it away with some facts for High Noon, Dan. Anybody know what time it is? Because this week we are continuing our Western retrospective with a look at High Noon from 1952, directed by Fred Zimmerman, starring Gary Cooper, Grace Kelly. Thomas Mitchell and Cady Gerardo. The film takes place over the entirety of one morning and early afternoon in a small

town in New Mexico. Will Kane, played by Gary Cooper, is the town marshal, and he's just married Amy Fowler, played by Grace Kelly, and they're preparing to leave town to start a peaceful new life. Kane has retired from his job as Marshal, and everything seems settled. He's cleaned up the town quite well, and it's a peaceful location compared to other similar locations in the area. But then Kane receives devastating news. Frank Miller, no, not the comic book writer and artist, but a notorious killer whom Kane arrested years

earlier, has been released from prison and is returning to the town on the new train. Hence the name. Miller and his gang intend to kill Kane. Although Amy desperately wants to leave town immediately, Kane ultimately decides they can't simply run away. He returns to the town and begins looking for people who will help him defend himself. This is where the film becomes increasingly tense. Kane goes from person to person asking for assistance but almost everyone

refuses some are frightened some resent kane and others simply don't want to get involved it's not their problem not their fight even people considered friends to kane and former allies find excuses to stay out of the fight as the clock approaches noon kane becomes increasingly isolated the town is gradually emptying out while miller and his three accomplices wait for the train at the station. Amy, meanwhile, insists that she will leave Kane because of this. She's a pacifist. She's a Quaker. And because of her

past history, simply does not want to be involved in violence. But eventually she returns as well. And as the gunfights begin, Kane is forced to face Miller almost alone. After a tense series of shootouts in that deserted town, Kane manages to kill Miller and his men. Amy ultimately helps Kane during the final confrontation despite her background and her beliefs. The townspeople emerge only after the danger has passed. Kane though

is disgusted with their cowardice, throws down his martial badge into the dirt, and leaves town with Amy as credits roll. One of the most interesting aspects of High Noon is how its own narrative is reflected in its own creation. That's because during its production, writer Carl Foreman, who was previously a member of the Communist Party, was called before the House of the Un -American Activities Committee. That's a name for you, but he refused to go. As pressure on him increased, he began to see parallels between his own situation

and that of Will Kane's predicament. Everyone around them No, something terrible is happening, but refuse to get involved, they're too frightened, and don't want to stand with them. Foreman incorporated those feelings into his screenplay. He later said that some of the scenes within the film were essentially drawn from his own experience with friends, colleagues, and businessmen that refused to be associated with him. Gary Cooper, who by no means was a communist sympathizer, in fact was politically conservative. Cooper was willing to testify before the committee himself.

Despite his political beliefs, though, he did not believe that Foreman should be removed from the film simply because of his history. When there was pressure to remove Foreman, Cooper apparently, based upon his own daughter, indicated that if you kick him out, Cooper was going to leave as well. That's not something that John Wayne would have done, and that's not really a knock on John Wayne. I guess it is a little bit, but John Wayne was one of the people who strongly objected to High Noon and its political implications. He regarded the film as un -American

and disliked the depiction of the townspeople abandoning their marshal, but also didn't like the idea of the marshal going around trying to ask for help. He felt it made him look weak. Despite some high -profile criticism and some early screenings that did not go well, when it was released in 1950, It was largely praised by critics and won a few Academy Awards, including Gary Cooper for Best Actor, Best Film Editing, Best Original Song, and Best Score. It was nominated for Best Picture, Best Director, Best Supporting Actress for Katie Gerardo, and Best Screenplay.

Hey, look at that! And Best Cinematography, so... At the end of the day, I guess it all worked out. And it was a success at the box office as well, earning over $750 ,000, which was a nice profit for United Artists. But where do Kevin and I stand? Are we with John Wayne? Are we with Gary Cooper? Someplace in between? Back to us to discuss. film it is now time to turn our attention

to our opinions on the film dan i have a couple things i'm going to throw at you and i'll let you kind of react to any or all or however you want to take it but i have a couple different thoughts that were kind of initial thoughts that kind of went through my mind as i was trying to kind of think of of a way to kind of sum up um high noon as far as like a kind of a jumping off point for here and i i think you can view it a little bit in two ways i don't I guess the same way, just different perspective. But to me, the central point here revolves around either

what happens when a town or a community or a group is not willing to stand up for what's right and kind of take the necessary action. Or I guess you could look at it in a little bit different way of kind of from a specific individual situation, which is. How does one individual handle the fact that he's alone in his convictions or how

does he stand up when nobody around him will support or join him? So I think that's like one thing that I kind of went back and thought about a little bit with this. Another thing that kind of triggered in my head was, you know, we recently did for the website a countdown of like our little voting method to give us our top 100 animated. series of all time and we've done similar countdowns with animated movies and a variety of different things tv series etc and a lot of times in those

discussions we have debates or conversations revolving around something being classic being first being influential in that respect where it has an influence on a lot of stuff that comes after that versus you know something that may not may not have as much of an influence on that stuff that comes after it but it's just very well done executed put together etc and then obviously like the the unicorn or the perfect storm where it does both right where where it's

both a mastery in execution or craft but also influential whether it's a timing standpoint or just like changing something within its medium or genre and i'm wondering where you feel kind of high noon falls on that and then the kind of the last thing again take take any of these with whichever way you want but we obviously started with some classic 1939 uh from the stagecoach and we had you know some 50s films and things of that with like the searchers the man who shot

liberty balance and then we kind of went away from that we did our spaghetti westerns we did remakes versus originals we did some overlooked westerns and now we're kind of going back into that earlier time period with classics and i'm wondering doing it that way versus potentially covering this like as our second or third film in this right like it could have easily been the second or third film we covered instead it's like number 17 and i'm curious how that impacted your thoughts or were you thinking about a lot of the other 16 films that we've covered as you

were watching high noon did you see it more of kind of a separate like out on its island or did you see a lot of like the connections between high noon and some of these other films we've watched or vice versa um so kind of what whichever way you'd like to go with that dan like what what's your initial thought yeah yeah you turn to page 17 if you choose uh if you choose the one direction otherwise it's page 28 i always would try to read ahead so i didn't pick the wrong page and end up dead and then it would never work out uh so i i guess i'll go with like you know washing this and being part of the retrospective

what was i thinking of other films and certainly ones came to mind the one that i think came to mind the most was probably the original 310 to yuma because both kind of center on a very simple idea really you know 310 to yuma is like we got to get this guy and of course both revolving around trains you know 310 to yuma being this sequence where you know you have to get this guy to the train and here where we're trying to create a posse because someone's coming from a train and they have similar i think concepts

in the sense of or themes where you know it's about you know doing what's right and the cost of it and the challenge to find individuals that are willing to do that and so i i definitely feel like it certainly falls into that line and i looking at this looking through these retrospectives i think some of the bass are the ones that have really kind of Straight line narrative of what it's trying to accomplish. And this certainly is that. It's very simple in what it's trying to deliver. But I think there is some poignancy

within that simplicity. Because clearly you see the allegory that it was designed to be. There is no qualms about that. As mentioned within just the facts. The idea of people being unwilling to help others. in fear of what it might do to them or the you know they could see what's the injustice happening but not willing to stand up because of whatever reason they can come up with so i think it is effective in that manner how it's able to exist within the western genre

at the western time very much being speaking to to the day in which it was made Which is not necessarily always easy to do and do effectively and not super heavy -handed. It's not subtle, but it's also not so direct in what it's trying to say politically. And I think that obviously caused some stirs with individuals who weren't huge fans of it. But I did feel like it was in that realm. Is it a situation where high noon is going into this? We know it's really highly

regarded as one of the best Westerns ever. I think that's always a hard thing to place on anything, but I do think it's very effective in what it's trying to do. I do think the performance is strong. Gary Cooper, he has a presence to him, but it's a different type of presence than what we've seen previously compared to like a John Wayne that's like, you know, take no prisoners. Like he's the tough, gruff guy that's going to do it all where there's a bit more empathy. I feel like his character is a bit more, grounded and realistic in that manner uh so i i found

you know this being a rewatch i had some idea but i legitimately forgot like it's been so long like i didn't know how exactly was it gonna end like i had a few ideas like i think it ended this way it didn't think it ended that way i wasn't i wasn't fully sure exactly it's like did they all come back at the end and like actually you know change their mind i couldn't remember but i found it very effective in that and i thought it was really well done and what it was trying to accomplish and the way it went in accomplishing

that goal and just how it's almost done in real time. It's like 24 before 24, but without it being overextended and going on for way too many seasons. But I was curious what you thought. You clearly have a lot, I feel like, based upon those questions, perhaps some conflict in what you thought of it or maybe you're not sure. I'm curious. well it's it's interesting because i did the same thing i did with this block that i did with the last block just for you know fun

yeah i i because i keep telling this uh ai chat like what my reactions are of the movies we've watched and then i haven't tried to try to predict what i'm gonna like and you know see whether it it's successful or not and so i gave it these four films right uh red river high noon shane and rio bravo And it was convinced beyond a shadow of a doubt that High Noon would be by far my favorite. Unfortunately, it was wrong. I don't

hate High Noon. I'm not going to say that. I'm going to get that right out of the bat. I just think watching this with the retrospective that we've been doing may have hurt it a little bit for me. And I'll kind of try to tell you why, and we can kind of go talk about a few structures and elements of the film that worked or didn't work for me. Because I do think you made some good points, and I do agree with a number of

points that you made. I just have some qualms about some other things as well. So for me, it does come down to, is this one just so highly regarded because of when it came out and how it influenced? other films that came out after it or because i'm i'm not seeing exactly what everybody else sees uh in this film as far as like for me it's hard because i feel like a bunch of films came out after it that clearly maybe have taken influence or notes from this but it's

hard when they all do it better so that's that's kind of like my biggest qualms so uh It was interesting, too, because we talked a lot about music in Red River, right? And the music in this one is done by the same individual. And the score and the song were at least nominated for Academy Awards. They may have won, both of them. I'm trying to remember if they... I think the song may have won. I don't remember if the score won as well. But they were both nominated. Same person that did Red River. I was gushing about the music

and the soundtrack and everything in Red River. And I had a very opposite reaction to this one. The song in the beginning, for me, just doesn't work on a lot of levels. It literally tells you the entire movie in the words of the song and takes away any hints of mystery or anything from tension. It literally tells you the whole plot.

The beginning, the middle and the end. Maybe not like every single detail, but it basically tells you everything that's going to happen. And like, to me, that was, I know it's a minor detail, but it, and I guess in the screenings, they like had the song even more in the movie. Like it's in there a couple of times, but I guess they had it all over the place. And like when they were previewing the film and it was getting to the point where audiences were actually even laughing at the song, which told them, Hey, we need to like scale back, like how much we're using this song. um minor detail not why i not

why i have some issues with the movie but it did it didn't help that they're just like literally telegraphing everything the other part with me is kind of how this whole thing and you kind of touched on it right like the whole structure of this film is a countdown and it's like a real -time countdown for most like all intents and purposes it's almost like we're we're having a real -time countdown from that you know they keep showing the clock you see how far it is from noon the the movie's titled high noon you know the train's coming at noon like so it is

a countdown to that time which can naturally provide a lot of tension and a lot of suspense and escalating danger and things of that nature i think we get that with the original 310 to yuma i think we get that with some of the other films that we've seen But for me, it didn't provide any tension in this film because it was very telegraphed, everything that was going to happen.

You know Miller is coming. You know Kane is going to stay. That's never a question. They say it in the song before the movie starts. You quickly get the feeling that nobody's going to help him. It feels like they try to go to that note. 17 times. And I get that there's different reasons why they won't help him. And it's supposed to be like building that, like he keeps striking out with everybody. But for me, it just became repetitious. Like I know nobody's going to help this guy. Like that's what, this is what the

movie is. I know there's going to be a gunfight at noon. I know it's going to be him against this, this group. Right. Like, so I didn't feel the tension in that. Like 310 to Yuma for me, the deadline in that film actually created new complications, changed character decisions, and and had an impact on how much you were bought in and how much you were like felt kind of into the movie and bought into all of that magnificent seven for example the threat continually evolves

because we're having a relationship build between the villagers and the gunfighters and everything that's happening there's you know the the man with no name trilogy finds a way to build that tension even though you know it's ending with a showdown of some sort and depending on which film we're specifically talking about and here once you have the townspeople start refusing him it's just like okay well how are we going to go to the next person who's also going to tell him no so is the movie building suspense or is it just stretching out an inevitable conclusion for me and that was one of my major problems

with the film is i just didn't ever feel any of the suspense tension or like nervousness about anything that was happening yeah but i guess you could say like like why would you ever have tension for a james bond movie when you know he's gonna win in the end so i guess like you're it's It's kind of discounting a movie for its concept before it even like it's, you know, I, and I think, but we've seen, we've seen other Westerns that have done that and, and I would say they have been able to do the tension. Yeah. I think this one was effective and I do think it is able to, cause this is a movie about morality

and a movie about, you know, what it means and like, what does your legacy mean? You know, what does it actually say? But there's no, but there's no arc in that. We know what he's going to do from go. It says it in the song. It says it in the opening song. The line says, I do not know what fate awaits me. I only know I must be brave, for I must face a man who hates me or lie a coward in my grave. We know what he's going to do. There's no arc in that. We know he's going to stand there. We know he's going to turn around and go back to the town. We know he's going to fight the guy. It's not his arc. It's everyone around him.

It's his wife's arc. Nobody else has an arc. His wife is the only one that has an arc in this film. She does, and so does his deputy as well. and his struggles and what he's facing. And I think it's people don't, they say no from go. Some of them do. It's not like there's one guy that says yes at first and then says no. But why did they say no? Because they're all cowards. It's, it's, it's the opening song. Is it just that though? I mean, each one has a different reason. Like they're, they're trying to pose it like 16 different ways for you, but I didn't

find any arc in anybody, but, but Grace Kelly's character. And I guess I would give you the deputy. yeah again but like i think you're like what is this movie trying to do it's trying to say like what i talked about like will one man stand up when nobody else supports him or if you look at it from the other perspective what happens to a town when they're not willing to stand up for what's right like it's one of the two depending on what your viewpoint or a combination of there can be both at the same time they're not mutually exclusive i think it's trying to be a critique

of the way in which individuals are for granted the structure that's around them and like what, what, what it's awarded them. And I think it's very effective in that. I think it's, it's not, I don't think it's a movie that's necessarily about a shootout or a movie about like, you know, this man's going to die. It's more of a movie about how people take for granted. what individuals

who sacrificed you know have gritten them and like how they're they're the selfish nature of humanity which at this time in 1952 i think it was maybe i've become numb to that man i live in i live in 2026 i know i'm not convinced like today that that's that's the normal reality uh but i think it you know the you know the 50s and the the it was very much Not that. Think of a lot of the Westerns we've seen. You don't

see a lot of movies that are very critical of the individuals within the town. They're always the victim of anything. You have the bad guys and things like that. Well, not in Magnificent Seven. That's their cowards at the beginning. They're painted in the same respect. They're not willing to stand up against the mob. They're looking for somebody else to solve their problem. But they have arcs. They change. Throughout the film. And become able to be brave. I get it may be saying that. I just didn't find it as interesting. Because it's like. Tell me something I don't know. I think it was trying to tell people. Something

in the 1952 that they didn't know. I can't put myself into that. That mindset I guess. I understand if you're. Yeah. I guess I don't agree. I think you're looking for something. This movie is not giving you. which seems to be the case in the sense of... I was looking for an arc for Kane's character or for not necessarily everybody in the town, but for a few individuals or something, and I just felt like I didn't get it. You get

kind of a weird arc with his wife, which we can get into in a little bit, that I still think is somewhat problematic, but at least you can see that there is an arc there. There is a difference between her at the beginning of the film and her at the end of the film. I don't see a difference. in Kane's character at the beginning of the film and at the end of the film. Outside of the fact that in the beginning of the film, he does have more support from the town towards the end of the film before the actual final gunfight. He does not have that support. But that's more about the town and less about him. He's still the same

person that's standing up for justice, being the marshal, being the one who's affecting this town. putting it in a good spot he's that he's that person in the beginning he's that person at the end i don't think he's that person at the end i think his last action of throwing the the um the the star or whatever the badge on the ground was retiring in the beginning and leaving he was retiring in the beginning because he was done with it there's a difference between retiring and and giving up or I don't think he

was giving up. I think he said, look, I did one more thing for you, and I'm leaving just like I did in the beginning. I didn't take it that way. In that way. I took it in his action, the way he dropped it. I took that as him giving up on the town. In a way. Him indicating that. He's, at that moment, a broken man. He's walking away, but he's... he's forever uh shamed or like

disgusted by the town that he helped build well i get that i think i think like his arc i think you do see an arc there who he is at the beginning this man of like you know proud marshall who's respected and feels like he is you know he's built something that matters like that's a big thing about like then they they they harpen upon that a lot about like right how this town is different how this is an example of individuals who were able to get out all the riffraff and

all that stuff and all the work he put in. At the end, there's no pomp and circumstance. He does a deed, throws it on the ground, he leaves in disgrace. Not disgrace, but he leaves disgusted. You see it when he's writing his will, the frustration he has. you know he it's coming to terms with his own legacy and what that means it's not direct you don't see him have a large silky about which

i'm glad i wasn't yeah yeah um but i i think you know that that those final moments it like who he is at the end is is very different than who he begins with he's he's not you know he the futile nature of heroes and i think is is seen within that moment because he's you know everything he kind of thought he did was really something that you know the people he counted on weren't there so i i don't necessarily think

that he doesn't grow at all it's not like i grant you it's a pretty sharp decline it's like it's a shade one shade of gray to another shade of gray like i don't know i would i would say it's a completely different person because at one point like he he is your typical hero and the other one he is jaded cynical he didn't have that type of cynicism beforehand and just with that one action that this town is not what i believed it to be i'm leaving you i'm throwing

this on the ground this this you know the badge that represented everything he was up to that point and now it means nothing i i think that that's a pretty stark action for that character compared to where we get to at the beginning. I guess I just, I read it a little bit differently. Like I view it more as like a, I don't know, a championship boxer who is like the hero and all this other stuff. And then there's like this one few that was never quite settled. And even though he's retiring, then the other guy comes up and is like, Hey, I want one more fight. And

he's like, I don't really don't want to do this, but I'm gonna do it. And then he fights the guy he's exhausted afterwards. And it's like, didn't really get him anything that he wanted to. And he's like, you know, it's over i settled the feud i'm out of here just like i was in the beginning but now that's done and i don't even know if it was worth it like i don't like i don't know like it i just had a different reading of i can see your i can see what you're saying like i get like somebody reading it that way i i personally didn't read it 100 that way i can see where you're coming from though i yeah and if you think go ahead if you if you don't get that reaction then

i could see it that it yeah not like jerry cooper i think he's good like i think he i think he does uh show us i don't i wouldn't say it's completely different than at least one of the other like he's a lot like jimmy stewart and who shot liberty valence like it's it's very similar in the fact that it's our protagonist but it's a real person who's sweating and worried and desperate like it's it's not the same character i'm not trying to say that they're the same character i'm saying a bit bit more i think I don't know if confidence

is the right word, but I don't know. Yeah, but I'm saying as far as painting him as he's not the John Wayne swag and danger type stuff. He is more of a person that an everyday person could relate to. You and I could relate to this guy, right? I don't know if we could see ourselves being the guy, but we can see that as a real human, whereas John Wayne is this bigger than... It's a fictional persona that it's probably harder to believe actually existed. Whereas I feel like this character is someone like you, you a hundred percent buy that this is a real person could

have really lived in this time period, could have really done all this stuff. And I think Jimmy Stewart character in Liberty Valance is similar, right? Like it's a, it's another person that you can kind of see. And like, they're not immune to fear. They're not immune to sweating the, the tension that they're supposedly going through and stuff and stuff like that. So I do like that both of those characters kind of. a little bit upend the like typical quote -unquote western hero that that you often see in these

types of films so i do appreciate that i don't know if i would i'm not as familiar with all the films that came out this year like is it academy award worthy winning performance i don't know i don't have anything to compare it from i mean it's it's yeah it's of that i i don't know what he was up against you know i would say it's I mean, at that point, I think he was such a... I wouldn't say it's a career award because he's won before that, but he was kind of on a downward... Not downward spiral, but

this certainly kicked his career back into gear again. I don't know if that happened. It's very of -the -time performance, I would say. It's not... It's kind of... Let's go also to his... to the grace kelly a little bit since we kind of mentioned it before we get into off to another point but we do talk about how you know there is some change from her in the beginning to the end we do and we do have some experience with grace kelly we've seen her you know throughout the um hitchcock slash carrie grant um retrospectives

and some of the films that we've seen at different times in her career and obviously in the beginning of this film you know she is the the the The newlywed, they make a lot of points about her Quaker upbringing or philosophy in life and kind of how she is very nonviolent and things of that nature. Obviously, they're going to leave and go off to their own life. That's what she wants. She really does not want him to go back to the

town for multiple reasons that you could read into, whether it's fear of what could happen to him or whether it's just like, I want you to put me first. and and stop worrying about these people that maybe she already sees don't necessarily um i don't know if she can already see that they don't care as much or whatever but she wants to be number one right like that makes sense he just married me like well let's at least go go have at least attempt to have a life so that's kind of what we get at the beginning and then obviously it's they do do some interesting dynamics between her and the other female character

which is um katie helen ramirez so it's interesting right because grace kelly's character is the non -violent one rejecting violence doesn't want to be there and you have the helen character who knows everybody in the town seems to be comfortable around them probably is a little bit more prone to embrace violence i don't know you could we don't have 100 of things that can say that but you kind of get that right um and then they kind

of flip it up as to which one actually leaves and which one sticks around so i do think there's some interesting things going on there and then you know spoiler alert for this movie that's super old but um you know obviously grace kelly's character plays a big part in the final showdown um and has some change in her willingness to accept violence or be moved to violence and and things of that nature so i was curious like what

your take is number one just within this film with those two characters and kind of how they play the two dynamics um against each other or or in their relationship to um especially our our main protagonist here and then also on a side note like your view of grace kelly in this film compared to like some of the other films that we've seen her in uh yeah it was interesting because we we get to learn like She wasn't raised a Quaker. She became one later in life after her family was basically murdered and killed.

And you could understand where her direction towards nonviolence comes from and why she wants to get out of that town and doesn't want to see her now husband deal with the same fate that her previous family did. So I thought it was intriguing how it was able to convey that information throughout we didn't know everything up front you obviously have a limited amount of time to like provide this information right and that

which is really hard thing to do and make in in a way that doesn't feel like you're just throwing in a lot of exposition so i thought yeah especially when you're doing this like real time where we're only what are we taking like just a couple hours of this day yeah i don't remember what the clock says at the beginning of the film when they first show it but it's not a long time yeah i mean first we'll get married that early on a sunday morning that seems like a weird choice but whatever uh so it's like that's gotta be tough uh but but yeah i i thought she was good you know this is like before grace kelly becomes great grace

kelly and also going through this i didn't realize how little films she was in she wasn't really even in that many movies um but i thought she was good i think she had the role and i i didn't take her actions at the end as her accepting violence it was i saw it more of an Or a tragic piece in the sense of she was forced into that because she had no choice. Either she acted or her husband died. So it's like the principles versus reality, I guess, in a way. She's faced

with reality. Yeah. Or how the failures of society made her go against what she believed because no one else would do what they needed to do. So she was forced to do something. It's going to be a random comparison, but it's like Batman is very anti -gun. And there's a story within, I think, Batman Beyond where he's older. He's not able to do what he needs to do. And out of desperation during one mission, he ends up using

a gun, which is against everything he believes in. So to me, it was something like that. Similar situation where she... had to go against her morals simply for an actor's survival. But apparently she's really good at it because she was able to get out of that hostage situation pretty effectively. So yeah, I mean, it's tough. The dynamic between her and Helen was interesting. Helen is a character

I feel like we could get an entire movie on because there's clearly a lot going on there. She's a self -made woman. She's part of the prequel. yeah uh you know that which is 11 o 'clock which is weird it's not as it's uh and then so it's low noon seven o 'clock low um but yeah i thought grace kelly's was like it's not like you said like she's it's not like she gets a huge amount to do like i mean she's there she's she's often reacting and she's meant to be that you know

it's not an easy role because she's meant to be the person to try to you know tell him not to do it like that you know the nagging wife in a way uh which is not the most glamorous part in the world but you could certainly see the star quality that is there early that's going to make her into like a hollywood icon but i would also say like i katie girardo was not an actress like i feel like i've seen it before i'm not sure but i thought she was like like i said i was really intrigued by her performance and like the And their random encounter was interesting

as well. But what was your take on Grace Kelly's performance? There's a lot of people in this movie that were coming around again that were in previous movies during retrospectives. Yeah, absolutely. I guess once you start covering this many Westerns, you start to come across with some of the main people of them. But no, I mean, I'm a huge Grace Kelly fan. I think it was criminal that she didn't do more films. you know i would love to see her do some more things but i think you can definitely see the seeds of what she would become within this film i think she makes the best out of what she has and what she's given

here i think like what you talked about it's a hard it's a hard task because not only is the role what like what you talked about right like the the nagging not nagging but like the the the wife that's trying to do what you know she thinks she should do for her new husband and the family or whatever like that there's not a ton for her to do and also the way that they have to do it within this time constraint doesn't leave us with a huge exploration of like everything about her and like they're not able to like really

draw out like what pushes her to do what she does at the end necessarily but i don't think that's i think that's just kind of like the constraints of what they were doing with the film which is nobody's fault and i think they did a decent job of executing that and kind of navigating that and i think grace kelly did a good job helping with that um so like i enjoyed both of the main female characters and actresses in this film and i thought they added some elements that were

needed and i didn't really have any issues with her her violent action at the end i perhaps they could have made it so she didn't shoot him right in the back but i don't know like i don't know how she would have done that like i don't know what else i don't have an alternative i'm coming with a problem with no solution but like i i can see how some people would be like well you know we didn't have enough time to like truly earn her movement towards that from being like

this super pacifist um character but i didn't see that as quite a as much of an issue as i had with some of the other parts of the film so i i enjoyed that she was in here and i would i too i was interested in um helen ramirez's character and like i would have loved to see like more about what that background was i know this isn't the film to do that based on the constraints of what they're doing though what do you think go ahead sorry uh like not someone that we've but played a big role we mentioned them a little bit like bridges as the you know his deputy because

i think if anyone he's another you know probably the he gets the second most amount of screen time uh with everything we see i was curious what you and i kept thinking he was kirk douglas because he kind of looks like him a little bit but it's i was like that's not kirk douglas but i was like oh that's the guy from uh oh i knew him from like hot shots i think yeah that's like that's guy from hot shots which is not an airplane but anyways that's not this movie what did you think of lloyd bridges i mean i think he did a fine job as far as acting in the film I was

hoping for a little bit more out of the dynamic between those two characters. I know they do have some interactions and some, you know, some, he probably has the second most or the third most arc in the film as far as like what's going on. And we do get an interesting thing where he's definitely like the quote unquote, like young buck that's trying to make a case for, you know, that he should be the one that's given the chance to, to be the Marshall. So there's a little bit of a back and forth between him. and gary cooper's character which has some interesting

aspects to it i i don't know i didn't love the character like to me it i still knew that you know he's not gonna have his back in the end just like nobody's gonna have his back like that's again that's telegraphed from the beginning so it's kind of like i couldn't get in i couldn't go along for the ride with any of these like back and forth with whether it's the the one individual that was seemingly on his side to begin with and that was waiting for you know

the time and you know go gather your people and i got your back and then there's the deputy and then there's the house that he visits where the guy pretends not to be home like i couldn't get invested in any of these like back and forth because it's already told to me that none of them are going to have his back so it's like well i know where this is going but it just took took me out of it a little bit i guess unfortunately Yeah, I think with him, too, like, that relationship, it certainly hints that there's a lot more there, because, like, why isn't he recommending him?

Like, what exactly is it about that character that, you know, perhaps the drinking, because we see that part of his character, you know, and then you think there's perhaps an issue with the relationship, because I guess, you know, him and Helen had their own history, and there is, I think, in a sense of like economic storytelling it's actually quite good and giving us a lot of information without yeah having to say it directly like when uh gary cooper or will cain's like going up the stairs and the uh although like uh the the guy in the hotel is like you

can you know you find your way okay or whatever forget forget what exactly the wording was but basically like saying that you exactly know where you're going because you've been here before in front of his now wife so it um that guy like just started a lot of trouble he seemed to enjoy it but um but yeah, I, I do think there's, as I said, like going into this part of me, I remember like, I also, that somebody came back or something like that at the end. So I wasn't sure, but, um, I don't know. Like there's part of that relationship

that I find intriguing. Just understanding like what, what is not. what don't we know because clearly there's right some some issues there but i think you get that with a few of the characters for sure um where it's like i i'd love to know a little bit more like i guess that's part of the um the attraction to some attraction is probably the bad word but some of the like allure to some of this is that there is a little bit of mystery between like what is the backstory between this person and that person or gary cooper and this

townsperson or that deputy or the um you know there's another what a judge or something that in the beginning a judge or a yeah it's not something like judge yeah judge who leaves because he's like you know he gives up right yeah and i think it you know there's and that's also part of it too like it you know It's interesting, part of it's this thing about how they'll arrest him and then they'll get free, and we don't really know why he got pardoned and whatnot. So I think

it's certainly speaking to the corruption of the government on that end, which also makes a lot of sense considering what was happening at the time and what the screenwriter was bringing his own experience into it. So there's a lot of that within it too. um yeah another person that we see too is which i didn't realize this was uh the film debut of lee van cleef who we saw yeah twice uh when he first appeared did you feel like you were like when they first showed his face like it was like a reveal as if you

were supposed to know who he was like i don't know it seemed like they show him and it's like look at look look look look who it is i'm like i don't know who that is it's interesting because it's it's one of those that i don't know i just always with tv shows or movies that put the actors on first like i'm i'm always reading all of the cast as it's being put on the screen beforehand so i see that lee van cleef's name is on there um you know i see gary cooper's name i see uh grace kelly and then i see lee van cleef and and so it's like oh three three people i know

that are like big names right like they're they're important people in this time period or in this genre so i i see him and i was expecting him to play a bigger role i did not realize it was his you know debut or anything like that so like he did look younger than i remembered him but i was like yeah this is all van cleef gets to do here looks like it looks different without the mustache for sure yes absolutely but it was fun to see him kind of in that than that early role for sure i was just like i guess it was one of those where i was excited to see his name

and then somewhat i wouldn't say let down but it was like oh i guess we don't get a whole lot of him as far as what this besides like the the classic shot to them another movie did this too i think it was 310 to humor or whatever where they keep going to the guys that are waiting uh yeah you're whatever like sitting on the the train station or sitting on the thing and it's like what else are they going to do what was the other was was which movie was it where like um what's the time in the west that opens up on the scene with them waiting oh that's the one with the fly and everything that was driving

me bananas yep oh so it was kind of like that it reminded me of that where it's just like well we're just gonna keep checking in with these guys every once in a while yeah um just gonna have to sit there and wait that's yeah that's the way of life back then i was curious dan on the other thing that i really kind of had an issue with that we haven't really talked too much about yet is the town i know we've kind of talked about it a little bit but to get into it a little bit deeper right like i can see like

this is a very important part of the film like it's a crux to everything from a thematic standpoint that we're dealing with right whether it's you know the town not standing up for itself whether it's a person dealing with the fact that you know what's it like when nobody has his back or nobody's willing to stand up for him which obviously has some political commentary on what's going on you know at this time period and whatnot which we can touch on in a minute but you know everyone has a reason not to help kane right like they're afraid they have businesses they

have families they don't want trouble they're cowards what there's there's a plethora of things we go through as we go to each person and each person comes up with an excuse not to support him not to help him not to have his back and it does you know point that question you know like what happens to a society when when everyone decides someone else should deal with the threat right like the And we've seen it a lot of different times, right? Like throughout history where a society or a group of people aren't willing to stand up and what happens when they're always hoping that somebody else should take the reins

on that. You know, we saw it with Nazi Germany. We see it, you know, in the political landscape of a lot of countries, et cetera. So it's a powerful concept. One thing that I'm really struggling with, though, is what actually happens to Hadleyville? And the problem I'm having in my head that I'm wrestling with. is nothing. They abandon Kane. Kane saves them anyway. He kills Miller. He leaves. There's no reckoning for this town of cowards.

In Magnificent Seven, the villagers initially do want someone else to solve their problem, but then the film makes them earn their transformation. The man who shot Liberty Valance, the town's development and civilization is... central part to the story and i love the idea of all of the stuff because of how much weight this carries throughout history but i don't know if the movie gives us like there's no consequence of that

idea in this film in a way that would have been to me and i know that's maybe some part of the point and that's why he leaves because the town's hopeless and he's giving up on him but like Not that everybody needs like a comeuppance or repercussions or consequences, but they're cowards. Somebody else does come in and solve the threat and they're all fine. Like there's no lesson for the town. There's no moral enlightenment. There's no, not

punishment, but there's, it's like the town gets away scot -free and I'm having a problem like reconciling that in my head. I don't know if it gets away scot -free. I think it gets away living in shame. Do they care? I don't know. Do they care once he's dead and Kane leaves? Is it just like, oh, back to business as usual. Glad that's over. I don't know. And I think it's not giving you that answer, which is, I think, okay. I think it's not necessarily about giving

you a direct... town come up and it's like now you have to learn your lesson or anything like that i think it's yeah i wouldn't expect something like just like stark with that but something's like something subtle something that like shows that they understand what happened or that they are living in shame i didn't get that like we didn't get anything that shows that they're shameful or that they feel bad or that they i think in in those final moments when again Going back

to a scene where I guess I talked about a lot, when he does give up on them and drive away, I think you do see them reconciling with, it's not super, it doesn't say within the moment a great deal, but I think you do see them coming into understanding of their failures and what they didn't accomplish, what they didn't do. We now think about, It's a town without a sheriff, a town without a judge, a town without whatever

the business was that What's -Her -Name was doing as well. A lot of the core of what that town is is no longer there because of their failures. So what does that leave them? What are they now? Maybe the new marshal comes and does it and fixes and he's just as good. We don't know that. also it's the west news travels fast so that marshall will probably know that maybe this isn't a place

you can trust you know maybe that reputation of who they are and what they stand for is forever tainted and i think that is what it's getting towards it's like this you know the the disgust of being unwilling to do what's right and making you sit within that and reflect upon it and then then like okay what comes next and putting that on the audience rather than giving you a way out so that that's the way i took it personally makes sense what did you think just because we

haven't touched on it like specifically or explicitly i guess obviously this is happening during a time where people are um getting blacklisted and and things of that nature and obviously that's happening specifically to you know foreman uh who is involved with the story and whatnot and you can see like an interpretation or an influence i guess you could say on on the picture and what we're getting like what did you read into that

did you did you know that going in did you pick up on that beforehand or did you just see that after the fact and kind of like what's your take on how the film balances that kind of analogy or allegory to like what was really happening in america at the time It's a good question. When I first watched it, I don't think I was aware of it. I knew the premise of it and whatnot, but I didn't know the history behind it, the history of the making of it and things like that. Going into this the second time, I was more aware

of it. And I do think, like I mentioned, it's clearly there. It's not trying to hide it in what it's trying to do. Because of that, it got a lot of pushback from individuals who weren't very keen on its approach. So if you go in this, you know, what you bring into this, I think, can impact your overall enjoyment of it for sure. Not necessarily. Obviously, your issues are more

so. It's not related to that, but it's certainly like if you're John Wayne or something like that, it's a different story. So I think it was a good. allegory at the time and considering how successful it was like universally uh like i'd be curious if like social media existed at the day like would it yeah whatever it would be looking at the reviews most people seem to not even like bring it up in what i read like they were talking about how it was thought you know things like

that but it was never directly stated as much as i could see so but i think it's very clear that Of what it's trying to do. You could argue it's a bit heavy handed. And perhaps it is. Especially by Detail's standard. But I don't know. What were your thoughts? I didn't feel like it was that. I didn't have any problem with how it was handled. Like I said. I think if you just watch this film. With no knowledge of the time period. That it was taking place in. Yes it may be specifically talking about. That specific instance of. When

society. Wouldn't stand up for each other. but i think it's still a timeless situation like it's a timeless concept like that that isn't the only time in the history of man that that's been a thing right like no it's happened a lot throughout history so i feel like that helps it like where you can watch that with no knowledge of what was going on in america at that specific in that decade and you could still probably relate to some of those things without feeling like that it was specifically trying to like browbeat

you with this specific thing i don't think i don't think it was doing I don't think it was heavy handed, I guess. I don't, I don't see it as that. Like, yes, you could pick up on all of that, but I feel like a lot of that's just, it could be taken and seen and applied to a lot of different aspects throughout history. So like, I didn't have any issue with that. I thought if anything, I thought it maybe for me actually elevated the film a little bit to know some of that inner workings of what was going on. Hey, I'll give credit to some of the members of the

film and Gary Cooper and, and some of the folks that, you know, were very vocal at the time that they were going to stand next to, um, this individual and, and support him regardless of, of what was going on. Cause it's obviously not something that was easy to do at that time period. So I think if anything, I guess the historical, uh, person in me enjoys that. And it adds a little bit of, uh, knowing what was going on at the time period. And that's not just like, a generality that they were making that it was something specific almost to me helps it and i i didn't feel like

it was heavy -handed and you make a good point about how we see similar ideas like revisited again in like 310 to yuma like there's a lot like i mentioned like there is a lot comparing these two in in like they say a lot of similar things i think on a holistic standpoint i think the individual stories are very different obviously you know but yeah you make a good point about how a lot of what was within this we have seen in other movies even within just this retrospective

and just the western genre so yeah like i said i see like i said i see connections to jimmy uh stewart's character and and who you know the man who shot liberty valence i definitely see some connections from the town standpoint even though it's done completely different to like a magnificent seven and then especially like that classic original 310 to yuma you can see a lot there um and then you have like you know even from the spaghetti western like they did a lot of the hey we're going to tell you that right from the premise that this is all going to lead to a showdown um yeah whether it's you

know they can go about a lot of different ways of getting there and why and and if it's important and not i would i would probably argue that the showdown in this one is really not that important um from a i mean i mean from a standpoint of like what's going to happen and how it's going to be executed and what's the and like it's more about the character's reaction before and after and things of that nature but like we already kind of know like where we're going from that standpoint so like i did have one question because you mentioned like you know you bring up a lot

of good questions about not knowing what does this mean for the town what like at the end of the day was you know they all said no they all gave up but at the end of the day it didn't really matter because he ended up winning anyone you know whatever you want to call it basically so yeah true true uh do you think it would have been i don't love like rewriting a movie or whatever but i thought that was what i was thinking like if he died like if like it was ineffective like he ended up and killed and maybe even if like he kills everyone but he ends up killing and

dying as well or whatever it may be do you think that would have left you in a better place considering the repercussions of what occurred or do you think having you know having him be able to literally walk away or in this case take a stagecoach and like you know take his uh gun and go to his new home yeah i think that would have had any different impact on the way you experienced i don't i don't think i would want to necessarily rewrite it but if i was trying to go from that standpoint

i honestly wouldn't have him die i would have her die because I know that's morbid. I know that's morbid and mean and whatnot, but I think it paints a better picture because they're expecting, the townspeople are saying he doesn't really have a chance, right? If she steps in as the person that is having his back when the town wouldn't, and she's the one that has to pay the consequences for all of their cowardice, and

it's a pacifist, and in the time period it's a female, and it's his wife, and all of these other things. i think then you get that moment where the town really has a reckoning yeah and and understands like the error of their ways or like she did what we wasn't we weren't willing to do and look what happened because of our cowardice like maybe i'm not saying i would do that but like i could see that having like a little bit more of an emotional punch Yeah, if they're ever going to do a remake, it would be a way to go.

And then you get the sequel, like Midnight, where he has a murderous rampage against the town. It's like the opposite of The Magnificent Seven. He's out to get the town this time himself. I could see that. I don't know. I don't think I would do that, but I could see how that would actually teach the town a lesson, I guess, so to speak. I agree. Rewriting a movie is always tough, but I was just curious if that reaction would have listed it a different reaction but

if anything it's interesting that you know i think this is the one we've had the most where the furthest apart so that's you know that's always fun do you have anything else you wanted to talk about yeah i just i'm a little surprised because you would think this one would work better for me because it does check a lot of my boxes right like yeah you know that a lot of the things that are happening like limited set and you know although we're dealing with a town we're not dealing with a lot of people like specifically like they get a whole lot of time like you're really dealing with, you know, a small handful that really get like substantial time. And, you

know, it's, it's really focused on decisions and, and, you know, the characters within them. And, and I, I understand why chat GPT or whatever thought that this would probably be my favorite. I think if I, if this had been like the first film we watched, I'm curious if I would have had a different interpretation because for me, it's a lot about the other films that we've seen since that I felt like did some of these things better. I will say when it comes to tension, I agree where the tension in 310 to Yuma, especially that hotel scene, there's no scene like that

within this where I feel like you can cut it with a knife, the proverbial phrase that they often see. It doesn't have that for sure. We have the gunfight, but there's some clever ways they come up with. using if they use the space well you know using this fire to smoke them out and stuff like that yeah but it's not you know it's not this dynamic you know one where you

go back to it's not the part of it that is it excels with the most so yeah i do wonder if this was like the second movie or the you know if this was like yeah it would have been different but i'm glad i watched it like i'm glad i watched it i'm not i i came across like probably more negative than like was my experience like i didn't detest the movie i didn't dislike the movie i didn't i wasn't hating my time with it you know i i did enjoy parts of it i did find some of it interesting it just when i when i'm when i'm stepping back afterwards and thinking about the

film it's like i just didn't think from you know the certain respects like i would take the tension in 310 to yuma i would take the character arcs in uh the man who shot liberty valance i would take some of you know some of these different things from some of these different films and it's like i get it it was earlier and it probably had a lot of influence on those films and maybe those films don't do some of that stuff and had this not exist i don't know but like yeah it was more like i just don't think it stacked up to some of those in some of that respect and i was curious kind of debating in my mind like

is it surviving more on reputation versus how well it actually holds up to some of the films that came later from it but i did not dislike it like i would watch this again long before i would re -watch a couple of the other films that we've covered. Makes sense. So that is our talk on our latest episode here, High Noon. Like Dan said, what are we going to cover? I'll let you say it again. What are we going to cover next? And kind of set the stage, I guess, for why we kind of called, nobody knows this, but

we kind of called an audible with what we're going to do next. So fill the folks in. Yeah, originally we were going to do Shane next, but we're actually going to adjust because we mentioned John Wayne a lot in this episode. And there's actually a lot of comparison, not comparison, but Rio Bravo is a movie that is often compared to High Noon and kind of almost like the answer to High Noon or it's seen as the very opposite on the political spectrum in a lot of different ways. So figuring that seems like a... Good way to transition to Rio Bravo next. And then after

that, we'll do Shane, another classic Western, to finish up this more classic Western block of it. But yeah, Rio Bravo from 1959, which is one I haven't seen before. And I believe you said that you haven't seen it before either. So that will be. And I think that is Howard Hawks as well, if I'm not mistaken. We've got a lot of him over the years here. Yeah. So I didn't realize how many, like him and John Ford. Like I know we had a John Ford block, but we basically had a Howard Hawks block as well. Yeah, it is

Howard Hawks. I thought so. But yeah, so intrigued. I'm intrigued. Yeah. And there's a lot of similar, you know, same thing. A lot of people we've seen before. John Wayne, of course. Although some new people, not new people, but you know, Dean Martin. I'm excited to see Dean Martin because when I think Dean Martin, I just think of the comedy. So I can't. I'm excited to see him more in the Western role, so we'll see. ChatGPT says this is going to be my second favorite out of the four. Well, it wouldn't be the first time

that ChatGPT is wrong. No, that's for sure. I don't even know why I'm using it. It's a funny thing that I like to see how wrong it is, I guess, how it's trying to predict what I like and what I don't like. Get out of here. So yeah, so that does it for... I shouldn't do that yet. So if you want to keep up with us and all the stuff we do, you can search out Dan at The Comic Concierge. You can search me out at Optimus Solo. Dan, what's the Facebook page for us again? Cinema Geek.

If you search Cinema Geek Movie Podcast, you should be able to find it. For sure, and we post some fun stuff for you guys to keep track of on Facebook as we continue to battle at the box office and look at the 2026 films that are coming out and questions about the films we're covering on these retrospectives. So definitely follow us on Facebook and check out those posts. And you can also go to thegcrn .com if you want to find the website that hosts our show as well as some other movie, comic, TV, cartoon. content

so that does it for this episode tune in next time for another chance to listen to more of the cinema geeks

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Western Retrospective: The Outlaw Josey Wales

    Nov 16, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Halloween Special: Rocky Horror Picture Show

    Oct 31, 202641 minAudio

    Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Halloween Spotlight: The Exorcist

    Oct 29, 202642 minAudio

    Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Halloween Spotlight: Carrie (1976)

    Oct 26, 202639 minAudio

    Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Halloween Spotlight: Texas Chainsaw Massacre

    Oct 24, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...

    Credit the people on this episode