Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

CINEMA GEEKS

CINEMA GEEKS artwork

Cary Grant Retrospective: The Philadelphia Story

Sep 8, 202548 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Today on Episode 224, the guys travel to Philadelphia...kind of...to discover how the ensemble of Katherine Hepburn, Jimmy Stewart and Cary Grant handle this classic story. Will a bit of domestic abuse be enough to derail this one for the guys? Find out on this episode of the Cinema Geeks! Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on X! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark! #UNLEASHTHECINEMAGEEKINYOU!!!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hey guys, this is Rob Paulsen and you're listening to the Geekcast Radio Network. Hello and welcome to episode 224 of the Cinema Geeks. I am one of your Cinema Geeks optimists, Solo, and joining me as usual is the Comic Con series. Dan, hello, how are you doing? I'm doing good. I'm glad we're doing this show because it was it was little

touch and go there for a moment Our power went out internet went out like literally like 30 minutes ago. I'm like, oh no, but came back So but if I cut off in between you'll know why I don't know. It's not even stormings I don't know what's going on. That's the crazy part. Yeah Here here it could always be storming. So it's like well, you know, you never know but Yeah, I'm glad you're able to do this one looking forward to the conversation today. I have no idea what direction this is going to take. So I'm intrigued to say the least. We are continuing our talk

through the retrospective that is the Cary Grant retrospective. We covered four of his films in the Hitchcock retrospective and decided that we had not gotten enough Cary Grant. We hadn't gotten our fill yet of the actor. So we decided to continue through his filmography. We've already talked about bringing out Baby and His Girl Friday, both of which would be probably considered screwball comedies, whereas Today's topic we're going to go more into the, I guess, romantic comedy. This is a fine line, I guess, that distinguishes one from the other. We can get into that a little

bit probably during the course of our conversation. But we are talking about 1940s, the Philadelphia story. Before we get the lowdown on the film and all of the details, Dan, just remind people what your background is or what you came to this film as far as knowledge of the Philadelphia story. Came with zero knowledge of the Philadelphia story. I have not seen this before. I didn't really know much about it It's like one of those movies I've heard about of course because it's Oscar nominated has big stars in it But I really knew nothing about the plot the background where

it comes from so kind of going into this completely blind Yeah, I had for once I've seen the film that you haven't so I like that for I'll take my moment in this It didn't help me at all. But once upon a time like I said probably in different episodes my mom and I were I think it was while I was home from a break at college or maybe right after college or maybe towards the last couple years of high school. I don't remember exactly when, but we were trying to make our way through some of the AFI top 100 films that I had not

seen. A lot of them she had seen because she grew up in that time period and things like that. Well, I guess not in this time period. She was born a year after this came out, but we were making our way through a few of these. And this is one of the ones that I remember watching and I remembered Having a positive reaction, but I could have told you nothing about the film until I rewatched it this last week so it was probably 20 to 25 years ago when I saw this so outside of a vague recollection that I liked the film at that time I couldn't have told you

anything about it nor did I probably even know really who Cary Grant and all of these people were back then I mean I probably did but not to the point that I do now so it's definitely interesting so Let's let Dan do the dirty work here and lay down the foundation for the Philadelphia story and then we'll come back with our reactions and thoughts. Don't call it a comeback, she was doing it for years. The Philadelphia Story is one of those movies that's own history is as interesting as the movie itself. After being labeled box office poison, Katharine Hepburn left Hollywood and headed to Broadway to work

on the production of The Philadelphia Story. It became a major hit and Howard Hughes bought the film rights and worked with Hepburn to make a film of their choosing. They cast who they felt would be the best chance of success for the movie. That cast included Cary Grant, Jimmy Stewart and Ruth Hussie. Those choices proved to be correct as all but Grant were nominated for an Oscar, with Jimmy Stewart winning his one and only Academy Award. The film was also a box office success, making over three million dollars, making it one of MGM's biggest films

of 1940. In the film, Tracy Lord is a wealthy Philadelphia socialite and she's preparing to marry George Kittredge, a successful but stuffy businessman. On the eve of her wedding, her charming ex -husband CK Dexter Haven reappears, determined to win her back. Dexter arrives with two reporters, writer Mike Connor and photographer Elizabeth Ombre, who are covering the glamorous event for Gossip Magazine. As reporters mingle with Tracy's eccentric family, Mike is surprised to find himself drawn to her wit and vulnerability. Meanwhile,

Dexter quietly shows his general love and support, in contrast to George, who judges Tracy harshly. The legacy also led to later adaptations of High Society, and it is seen as one of the greatest romantic comedies of all time. Does that remain to be true? Considering this is Katherine Hepburn's movie, where does it fit into the career of Cary Grant? Back to Kevin and myself to discuss. On a play so first watch for you dan of the philadelphia

story going in a little bit of a different direction than the previous two films we talked about with carry grant all those still comedic what was your initial reaction of the philadelphia story after watching it. It's interesting you know going through these retrospectives the hedgecock one now this one we've watched a lot of really good movies and this one how i claim like i said it's going into it not knowing much about it and. Honestly like it's one i'm kind of still struggling with with for a lot of reasons You know it's a movie certainly that is of its time

And i try and not to like judge a movie by 2025 standards when it was made when it when? because takes Very little time to realize. Oh, this was definitely a different time You know you get you know kind of the domestic abuse joke like right in the beginning like oh wow This is a not not holding back and there's a lot of that stuff that may maybe not hold up the greatest But I was like not trying to hold that necessarily against it trying to judge a movie for where it's at And you know, there's so many great stars

in this as we know, of course care grant James Stewart the only movie they've ever done together Catherine Hector Yeah. Uh, but I guess, yeah. And then Hepburn as well. So you, it's a stacked cast. Like you can see why it might be game so well regarded. Um, and as I'm watching it though, and there's elements about it that I, that I think are, I love the story behind it. Like there, how this was kind of a play that Catherine Hepburn

Had she kind of for she was looked at for this came out as box office poison for a while so she stepped away from hollywood the display and this was kind of like her big comeback story and she let a lot of it even help the kind of getting the cast together but the movie itself. Just as I'm going through it like there's there's good laughs there I don't know if I would qualify it and I saw people qualify it as a screwball comedy maybe just because we're coming off of his girl Friday and Coming off of bringing a

baby. It is so much like more tamed than those. It's not nearly as fast -paced It's not nearly as like off the wall It's more true to life compared to those in a lot of ways, but I don't know. I I wasn't super invested in dynamic of the storyline you have this kind of marriage going on and you have kind of like not even a love triangle it's like a love like octagon it's all these different people kind of you know involved and it's a lot

of the care like Catherine Hepburn is fantastic the performances I think are strong although I think Cary Grant really doesn't Get much to do compared to like what we've seen them so far. He's he's really on the sidelines for so much but I I struggle too with I will say as I look at this movie. I'm trying to understand like what is it? Trying to say like what is the point here? And I and I don't know what was getting at like I do wonder if it's a movie that gets hindered by a lot of the Code at the time like

if yeah during when this was made if you had a divorce They had to get back together. That was a rule You know if you have people of high society they had to look be looked upon in positive light and you feel that here and it's it's strange and I guess that's I was I don't know I I struggle with this in a lot of ways. I don't think it's necessarily poorly made or or bad I just I didn't really enjoy it though. I guess is my best way of putting it So i'm struggling with it on a

rewatch And I don't know if I'm struggling with it in the exact same ways or. I guess I'm still trying to come to terms with how I feel about the film, and one thing that I'm struggling with for sure is trying to decide if watching this after watching bringing up baby and his girl Friday. Does. You my viewing of this film, I don't know if that makes sense, but like. Obviously,

the other two are way more screwball, like they're way more crazy, fast pace out of this world and things of that nature. And this is a different animal, so to speak. And I don't know how that worked for me watching them in the order that we watched them, if that makes sense. I don't like I'm trying to decide if I if we would have started with the Philadelphia story, what would have been what would have been my take. Yeah. And then we watched those other two later. I'd

like to think that I can separate all of the films and just watch them for what they are and just like in a vacuum, so to speak. But I guess that's it's that's not the word. That's not how brains work. So it's really hard to like separate that. And then the other thing granted, like you said, it seemed like a lot of not only was there the Hays code that's going on during this time, but reading up a little bit on this film, which makes sense. They talk about how there was like a kind of rush of or rash of these types

of films that are dealing with the topic of divorce or the topic of temporarily going away from your significant other or your husband and wife and then coming back to them, those types of things, which I hadn't even really thought of. And then as I'm thinking back, it's like, well, OK, bringing up baby, he's leaving his fiance and, you know, having this this this playing that leads to something else. Got it. His Girl Friday. We have a divorce

that ends up, you know, she's getting remarried and then, you know, the first husband comes back into the picture and then we get almost that exact same plot line here. where she's getting remarried and he's involved. But then there's also now a third person involved. So it's like we're getting all that. And it's. I agree with what you said. I'm wondering if also part of it, because we've kind of been focused on Cary Grant in a way is. Skewed by, like you said, he's kind of not 100 % relegated to the sideline,

but he's not nearly what he is in the two films we've just watched like. He is front and center in those two films. And it's going to be interesting to kind of go through the rest of this series to see like what kind of roles he plays in all the rest of the films, because we didn't necessarily set out to watch only films that he was like the lead or star in, although he's Perry Grant. So he's going to be a star probably in most films. But we were just looking at films that he appeared in. So it'll be interesting to see if we have

other ones where he's kind of, you know, third or fourth. I mean, he does get top billing for this film. But he made that happen. So yeah, you know, you could say he's third. Well, it's interesting because he gets top billing. But in reality, he's probably third on the list as far as like screen timelines and things like that. I'm just completely guessing. That's just I have nothing to back that up. And you have Jimmy Stewart, who is third on the billing, but gets the Oscar for the best actor. for this film,

so it's kind of an interesting, not only is there this like, it's not a triangle, you're right, but not only for lack of a better term, this triangle of love story going on in the film, but then it also seems like there's a triangle of who gets credit for what as actors in this film as well, you know what I mean? And I did not realize, I was... I guess dumb to the fact that this was Cary Grant and Jimmy Stewart's only role together. I just figured that there was probably other films that they appeared in. This is the fourth time that we've seen Cary

Grant and Hepburn together and the second one we've covered bringing up baby being the other. He's also on holiday with her and then an earlier film called Sylvia Scarlett. So they are there together a number of times. Yeah, I'm really struggling with like the order that we watched it and trying to decide if that's influencing it. I'm also trying to think back 25 years to why I had a positive reaction the first time. outside of maybe it was just something that I hadn't seen before and it didn't necessarily fit into the, I think sometimes people, especially

younger folks, look at older movies and think it's gonna be a certain way, whether they think it's gonna be boring or they think it's gonna be something they can't relate to or something like that. And maybe my, maybe I was like 17 or 18, I don't know. Maybe that was refreshing when I saw this and was like, well, this is actually like something I can follow and it's... Got some humorous parts and things of that nature, but I yeah, do you think it? It's at all weird to watch this one after those other two that are way more intense It's very much a different speed

Yeah, it kind of is bringing a baby and his girlfriend a kind of in the same vein and in style of execution Helps us both both of those are Howard Hawks and this is certainly a left gear I think even without that I think I would still have A lot of this the similar issues because I was able to eventually kind of settle in to like what this was. Okay, this is this is going a different way definitely more romantic con, you know, kind of a combination of the romance in comedy and I again, I think that I struggle just looking

at kind of like Catherine Hepburn's character and like her Progression and you certainly feel bad for her in some ways like it feels like especially at the end It's like this is just like gasoline 101 where she's led to believe like she did something when she didn't necessarily do it And the people are just not being like it's it's it's a strange Feeling but I also feel like in a lot of ways. She still has that kind of take charge Element of her character and like I said, I do think

it's interesting that before this she was looked at she was labeled as box office poison because of She was an actress that was more You know, she didn't fit that stereotypical role. She I guess was seen as more kind of she stood up for herself a bit more I guess and You see that here and she's certainly like a broken individual and this is has a lot of broken people but I feel like it ends up being Very forgiving of

all their transgressions and a lot of was like everyone kind of gets out of this unscathed unscathed Yeah, it's like it wraps it up with a with a bow at the end. That's that's a little too neat and pretty yeah, and you know when there's that now like a bite I think really hurts it because Again, that's where I'm like, I'm trying to alter like what is like what is ultimately the point here? It's almost like the point here is like the bad guy is the guy that like you had to work himself You know was started at the bottom worked himself up. He ends up being the bad guy and

everyone else that kind of like, you know that was born into their into their situation is seen as like You know that they're in the right which is a weird weird thing. Although I guess jimmy stewart's there is meant to be more of the uh, you know the everyman, uh, and I guess that's also what we remember way back when we did vertigo we mentioned like how the The like the romantic dynamic dynamic there wasn't didn't work for us and I got similar feelings here like Jimmy

stewart and catherine heparin like I think catherine heparin tells a lot more but I never saw either of them having much chemistry so like there's that dilemma of like okay like oh who do you want them to get together like who's who you know that that's you want that tension there and i was like i just hope all these people just leave each other alone i think that's kind of the best i felt bad for um you know ruth uh yeah Or the photographer like cuz she's like the only

innocent person she seems like the only likable person because it's like get away from all these people But I don't know if that's that's where I just I struggled with it. So like, okay Well, it's it's interesting to be in a couple points that you brought up number one. I is Jimmy Stewart just a hard person to pull off the romantic angle in a film or I mean, I haven't seen like all of his films, but it seems like we've seen that a couple times where it's like I think it I think he works and it's a wonderful life. I think I

think it works. Yeah. So that's true. That's true. I also was not prepared for how young Jimmy Stewart is in this one. Yes, because we just came off of, you know, some of his Hitchcock novels, which are like 15, 20 years later. But I was like, holy cow, he's young in this film. It's like he's 30. third year You know did Katherine

Hepburn end up with Jimmy Stewart? I was like no she didn't oh she ended up with the guy that she was like Engaged to her whatever. I was like now. She's like wait. What I was like yeah She just ends up with Cary Grant. She's like what? How why I don't understand so it is interesting. It's like I get that he's like trying to you know potentially win her back and things of that nature, but They sure don't spend a whole lot of time developing it from her angle as far as

why she is willing to go back in that situation. And then it also makes you question like. It comes out right out of the gate and she, like you said, has the domestic abuse where he just like throws her to the ground and then they decide to make like some comedy jokes out of it with like the little sister or don't say socket. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. And all this other stuff. And it's like, how was that angle even important? Like, I feel like you can take that completely out.

You can just have some dialogue that like references that. They didn't get along similar to like what we got in his Girl Friday. And it doesn't change anything like it's so it's like it's a weird choice to like have him do that, because then it makes it even more messy. The fact that she just goes back to him with little to no Like. Yeah, development of that. So that's kind of rough, like they spend the time developing her and Jimmy Stewart. Like that's granted, they're

both drunk off their butts, but like that's where they spend them. By the way, I think they both played excellent drugs. Yeah, like I said, I think all the performances here are really good, even if like the chemistry wasn't perfect. And part of that, I think, was purposeful because, yeah, you don't want them to be together. Jimmy Stewart's character is a bit lost. He's kind of not be made it into that mature level yet. Right. I guess kind of has in some ways, even though he's kind of a predictive jerk that is

just trying to drive her crazy. But yeah, I feel like sometimes, though, like when we get those when we get characters that are, quote unquote, like drunk or whatever in films that sometimes it gets like it gets overdone. Like the people are like going to bananas or it's like they have trouble pretending to be drunk when they're sober type deal. And or, you know, obviously we saw Cary Grant play a drunk role in North by Northwest. Right. And it's played up a little bit more on the comedic side, whereas this one is doing it.

Yes, it's funny. And yes, there's a lot of moments during those scenes that are. Comedic, but I feel like it's more believable that it's natural. Not being played for comedy, but it's funny because of what just naturally what's happening. So I did appreciate that part of the film Yeah, I agree. I think that and there are some really good community bets in it as well. Like there's the funny joke about like I'm asking for the typewriter forget the exact line, but there are

some good back and forth moments here and there Yeah, so I do think there are some strong comedic bits like you pointed out and I think the cast does work well together and then they feed off each other pretty well like the chemical chemistry is a group is strong and It does feel like a movie though. That was a play it and it's very stagnant. Yes, it's not it's not moving very often it in Kind of like there's no momentum. That's kind of the thing too. It felt like there was even the like the wedding I'm like wait there

That kind of just happened. I didn't even know that they were already like it just kind of comes out of nowhere and That that was one of the issues too. It's just like things just kind of happened because they have to nothing kind of moves from the moment from one moment to the next all that organically and That kind of I think that's where a lot of my disengagement came from too. It's like you had a It didn't kind of bring you in it kind of just went from one moment to the next in a rather like a hazard manner it almost reminds

me of like Something that you would have seen like a TV. I'm not trying to didn't this may sound overly harsh But like if you had a romantic comedy like a sitcom and like this was the this was the movie That they produced for the like out of the sitcom because the sitcom was popular then they're like, oh we need a movie for it And like they threw some stuff together. I feel like there needed to be like. Like there was no momentum like you're saying. Like it didn't. It just seemed like it was put together to be put together in a way I don't. There's not. I

mean, granted, there's acts like there's a beginning, middle and end and all that type of stuff. I'm not saying that it doesn't have the structure of a story and stuff like that, but you're right. There's no, there's not much of a crescendo. There's not much of a build. It's a little quick with the switch at the end. and it almost is anti -climactic where it's just like, oh, I guess that's what we're doing here and now the movie's over. So I didn't feel much of a build for anything. I want to get your take too because I think we both said that, you know, Cary Grant doesn't get quite as much as we're used to him getting.

I don't know if we think that he should have got more or not, but just like that's what his role was. Two things that I found interesting on that. Number one, I did read that he was given the choice of which role he wanted to play. Yeah, and he won't he went with the abuser so I'm just And the and though it's it it's interesting that he didn't go with the Character that gets the most like pizzazz out of it He did go for the I guess maybe he wanted to be the character that gets the girl in the end I don't know but he had his choice and then there was also an interview with the director I believe it was and he was

talking about the film and talking about the cast and you know saying how A lot of people say that this was a fairly easy film to make like it only took eight weeks of shooting I guess there was very few retakes the guy that gets the Donald Ogden Stewart who gets the Oscar for screenplay says it was like the Easiest Oscar one in history because he hardly had to do anything He just listened to the play and like wrote some notes to react to like whatever the people laughed at during the play and he was like that I'm getting an Oscar for this But the director, I know, made

some type of comment about how, you know, there was all these awards given out and we had this like great cast and he's like, Hepburn gets a nomination, Jimmy Stewart gets a nomination, Ruth Hussey gets a nomination and he's like, Cary Grant's the one person out of the group that doesn't get a nomination and his quote was, and he's the best of the, he was the best of the bunch, which I found that was interesting from coming from the director that he considered Grant like the best of the bunch, but maybe just from a... Acting standpoint a talent standpoint because I don't see where he would have gotten. He doesn't get enough here. I don't think to

warrant Award nomination, but He may maybe has like the most command of his role. Yeah most comfortable because he He he's very natural. He fits a role pretty well. Like he yes that conniving We've seen shades of his other Like I think so yeah, I is I do agree It's not the most showy performance and I think that kind of makes sense because I think Jimmy Stewart

as an actor kind of fits that role better because he He had He can play that every man a bit more like if you have a character that's supposed to be your average individual and someone that's meant to be or like the El the individual of high society and you have right If you were to switch them, I think it would have come out a little strange, right? so I think I think it was the right choice even if they didn't give him it didn't give him as much to do but I think

what he does he does well he's just He's the one that is kind of poking and prodding the one that is kind of pushing things to happen and just just watch it and then stepping back and watching the chaos. So, yeah, he's very much an observer in this, which is something I think Cary Grant does really well. Like he when you see him in scenes like he's really good at reacting. And I think his reactions go a long way in a lot of these scenes. He also is very like intent,

like he's very. careful to be. In the moment, even when he's not in the moment, like he's if you watch his eyes and his body language. Like he he's paying attention to what's going on. You know what I mean? Sometimes you see somebody when it's not their time to speak or it's not their time to do stuff. You don't 100 % get like them selling the fact that they're in that moment, and I feel like he does a really good job of like. Being a presence even when he's not speaking. And paying attention and kind of being a part

of whatever's going on and he's very good at the little side comments and like the little like he is almost like better. Being able to just interject some ad lib lines or some little one liners here and there that it's kind of fun like I almost always want a little bit more of that but you know we have had some films where he gets a lot of that so like that's good too. Gary Cooper made a comment to that I thought was kind of interesting he was quote unquote upset that they. cast grant in the film that maybe I don't know if he was genuinely upset if he was just making kind of a comedic quote

or whatever, but he he said Carrie Grant shouldn't have got the role. I should have Carrie Grant's too pretty and nobody would believe that Hepburn would have thrown him out in the first place. So it should have been me because I'm ugly enough where it would have been believable or something along those lines. So I thought that was kind of kind of funny as well. Obviously, this wasn't like you mentioned that, you know, Katherine Hepburn gets a lot of say in this like part of her deal with like owning the rights to the Howard Hughes bought the rights but then gives them to Katherine Hepburn and she sells them but has

some say in like the director or the writer or different people and I think she got like some able to suggest like some of the casting and things like that and I did read that you know she wanted Clark Gable and Spencer Tracy to play these roles first but they were both busy with other commitments so then I you know, ended up being Cary Grant and Jimmy Stewart after the fact. I don't know about enough about Clark Gable and Spencer Tracy to know how that works. Obviously, Clark Gable would be playing the Cary Grant role and Spencer Tracy, the Jimmy Stewart role. So that was kind of interesting as well. And then

I do find Cary Grant just he is a fascinating person like he's had some interesting things in like the negotiation of his contracts. And I don't know if it's him doing it. If it's somebody I don't know how, you know, their agents, if they had agents back then, I don't know much about classic Hollywood. But, you know, we talked about like in one of the Hitchcock films where he had it, like wrote in that he gets so much more money if it was after, you know, the the time period, which it was like all after. So he made like a ton of money in this one. He demanded top billing and one hundred and thirty seven thousand dollars, which was a lot at that time

period. That's the equivalent of like two point eight million, I think maybe five years ago. So he demands like all this money for it and then he just donates it all. He they said he at least everything I read he donates the entire salary to like the British War Relief Fund. So like he made this big stink that he needed to be top billing to get all this money just so he could donate it all, which is like, I don't know. I just find him a fascinating human being. So, yeah, another thing I wanted to get your take. I know I have a feeling obviously based on what we've talked about, how you're going to feel. But this film, I believe, like you talked

about, probably has 100 percent, you know, Rotten Tomatoes. Rotten Tomatoes named this the best romantic comedy of all time and AFI on one of their list of top 100s when they were doing the genres had this number five on the all -time romantic comedy list Do you feel that those are rankings too high for what you? Observed and watched with the Philadelphia story. Oh I certainly want to put them like if I'm ranking romantic comedies on that list I think you know the movies

we've done already. I mean we Say I would rank bringing up baby and his girl Friday a lot higher than either of it then then this But again, I don't know in the sense of like this is certainly more on the romance side So if you're looking for more of the romantic angle like this spends more time there, but personally for me, it's I I couldn't Do you know would you I don't have that admiration yeah, no, I get that Do you have any guesses as to what AFIs number one romantic

comedy was on that? Top ten. It happened one night. It happened one night was number three. OK, got another guess. That was good. You got like a you got one of something that was in the top three, just like that. Well, it's like it's the you know, it beats Harrison Cain. What like give me a hint of decade or the number one film is from 1931. You want. Starring Charlie Chaplin. Charlie Chaplin. Yeah, city lights. Yep. City

lights is number one. The second film is from 1977. Any hall is any hall and then we have it happen one night. I'll give you number four is Roman Holiday from 1953 with Audrey Hepburn. Then number five is the Philadelphia story. There's two films on this list, one from 1989 and one from 1993. Oh, actually one from 1987. Any guesses on those three? Harry met Sally. Yep. That is number six Pretty woman. Nope. I have 1987 starring

Share Oh Moonlighting is that what it's not moving? Yeah, and then number 10 on the list is from 1993 93 that's not one pretty woman, right? I try to know Holds That's not he got me. What is that other one? Is it Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan? Oh, I don't remember them. I can't think of that. I can only think of he got mail, but that's not

the one before that. You have the right to people and that's the same type of thing that I would be thinking through. It's Sleepless in Seattle. See, of course. Yeah, which I've never seen. So there you go. Okay. And then the only other two on the top 10 would have been Harold and Maude from 1971. And interesting. Number seven is also a George Cukor film who's the director of the Philadelphia story. He also directed Adam's rib, which also has Katherine Hepburn and this time Spencer Tracy. So I haven't seen that one. That one's from 1949. So those were the AFI's top 10 romantic comedies of all time that was

done, I believe back in 2000, maybe. Is when they did all those? We did it. Yeah, like 100 and then they redid it again. They did one and then they did it again. I think it was the wrong time. Yeah. OK, so interesting how everybody thinks about. I guess it depends on if you're going to put more of an emphasis on the romantic part or the comedy part or like how you balance those two things out. I definitely would not probably put. Philadelphia story like you said higher than some of the other ones that we have talked about but Other thoughts that you had

about the Philadelphia story other things that worked or didn't work for you that you haven't got a chance to mention yet I didn't want to reiterate that just how good Katherine Hepburn in this is in this because I think like the best part of it is her character because there are so many there are many layers her character there's she's got a lot she has to do she's pretty much in every scene and She has to kind of ride this line of like Being likable being you know, but also kind of broken and having like, you know

you see and when she has to be more dramatic even if the script is a bit maybe quick and it's pacing like she sells it like it feels like she has to go through so many different emotions in a very short period of time and It really remarkable you see why she was the star she was and you know, of course, you know she worked on that she wasn't she was she did the Broadway play and You know, it was a role, you know made for her and it it's really strong and so I I

did want to mention just how strong she is. I know this is a Cary Grant retrospective, but gotta give her flowers as well. So I thought this wanted to end. We didn't talk about her, but I did think one of the funniest parts of the movie was Virginia Wielder as her younger sister. She certainly was that comic relief. You talked about... Kind of a sitcom feel or character did kind of feel like, you know, maybe that was kind of a. Inspired a lot of sitcoms

to kind of take a character like that, because you feel like you always get that spunky. Little kid that is wise above their years and you see that in so much and I don't know if this was the first person movie to do it or what have you but I thought she was at least good and It gave a lot of really some of the best moments of the movie so almost reminded me a little bit of the sister in the Hitchcock film that we watched with Goodness gracious the one that was like the picture of not suburbia, but like of the

opposite of suburbia the rural town setting where the two Charlies. Suspicion? No, shadow of a doubt. The little girl in that family. Almost. Yeah, yeah. That type of vibe. Yeah, definitely. Also, Hepburn does her, I guess her own quote unquote stunts in this film. When she jumps in the pool, that's actually her and all of that. So she wasn't afraid to do that. Interesting note. There's a. This is off of Wikipedia. I

hadn't read this beforehand. So I'm kind of just reading this as we're going through. And it's just an odd take, but this is from one of the cameramen from the film. And his quote is, everyone had enormous fun on the movie. The days and nights were sweltering that summer of 1940, but nobody cared. Carrie got along very well with Kate Hepburn. She enjoyed him pushing her through a doorway in one scene. So she fell over backwards so much that she had him do it to her over and over again. And I'm like this just shows you the difference and I guess there was a scene in which she had to throw Carrie out of the door of a house with

bag and baggage and she did it so vigorously he fell over and was bruised as he stood up looking rueful Kate said that'll serve you right for trying to be your own stuntman. So apparently they got along well and they didn't give to two thoughts about the domestic abuse at the beginning of the film. Yeah, different times. So that's kind of crazy. But yeah, you can say that a lot because you have drunk driving. You have like, you know, open, you know, do you have a plot that hinges upon a rich bureaucrat and not. but not that he's cheating on his wife like that's

that's that's the story rooting for it's like it is a definitely a different time so there's no Philadelphia and this whatsoever not one shot of liberty liberty bell on what um only the opening the opening uh the text in the opening right isn't that from where they do the declaration of independence yes yes sure that's true that's it that's it yeah i guess this is based on like an actual like socialite splash like person that was like the Catherine, I know it's written for Catherine Hepburn, but they had like an actual person in mind that they were doing the writing

and whatnot. And I think they said something about the fact that they were going to try to film it at their estate or their mansion or something like that. But they didn't end up doing that either. So but that was kind of an interesting little note, too. There's obviously a lot of trivia on a film that has been around since 1940 and has definitely been. reviewed in lots of different ways over the generations. Mostly positive, but I can kind of see some of it. But like you

said, I think my takeaway at the end, as I kind of struggle to decide how this fits into the other films that we've watched of Cary Grant's is kind of what you said, like what's the point ultimately? And where is the build, the momentum, the... You know crescendo and some of that stuff that you kind of hope for in a romantic movie comedy like especially even when we're thinking about some of those ones that we listed off I think of like when Harry met Sally or any romantic comedy that we've seen like some of them are like a dime a dozen or whatever, but There seems

to be more of an arc in those and to me that was what the main thing that was missing here was if she's gonna end up with Cary Grant I need more of an arc between those two characters and a more of a rationale for how they end up together. I feel like Without that. It seems like we're. Just along for a weird ride that doesn't necessarily like it's it. It reminds you of like a story that somebody would tell you about an experience they had, and I don't think I would. I would hear that story and say like, hey, this would make a great movie. Because because it's like

missing the bang like it's missing the the gusto. But what are your final thoughts on it? Yeah, I think it even like. She's always she has a lot of decisions to make in this and like even when she decides to break things off with her fiance like that that moment just was I mean a bit too clean and almost like it felt like there needed to be a bit more there and like I said, I think that's the biggest issue is that I think these are characters that in a lot of

ways do some really like awful things and And are so especially even like Jimmy Stewart's character who's supposed to be the everyman like the way like he's kind of like so dismissive of With house his character and and but like there's and there's no resolution there and I get maybe that's kind of the point it's not as trying to show that life isn't that clean but then at the end of the movie a kind of Kind of reverts against that and everything kind of comes together far too quickly So I do think there was power I don't

know how much this is in line with the play and I wonder if the play was able to maybe Give us a bit more But I don't know like it and like I said, like you mentioned maybe it's just be coming off of the other films It's changing direction as quickly as possible. But like I said, I do think ultimately like I I walked away with even trying to you know not allow you know the process of time to make me like overly judge it but even without that I just I was just disappointed and

just ultimately did not really enjoy this so I also find it I also find it weird like it's like the director wanted to do a swerve at the end but I don't feel like you can do swerves when it comes to relationships like You have to build it to a point where it's believable. You can't just throw a curveball at the end and be like, oh, you thought he was going to be with that guy, but she's with this guy. And that doesn't work when it takes time for us to believe in the relationship. I don't know. That's ultimately what leaves me wondering. Because it sets it

all up that she's not getting married to her fiance because of Jimmy Stewart. That's how they set that up. Whether it's just Jimmy Stewart is the window to her to let her know that she's not really into that guy. I guess you can go that route. But like I said, I feel like it just is too quick and too clean at the end for me. And then, like you said, there's a lot of. Ultimately. Bad decisions that don't have consequences. Yeah, for the most part, which. Like even like Cary Grant, like his. He everything he does is basically

like a lie and. kind of just does gaslighting and kind of manipulates everyone and at the end it's like, oh, I never have saw a reason why them getting together at the end is a positive for either of them. This feels like the next day it's gonna be a replay of where the movie began, so. Yeah, absolutely. I would be interested because I heard like there was an interview with like Julia Roberts. There's a lot of people who love this movie, which is fine Yeah, he says

that it should never be remade because it's perfect. But I don't know like I could see Like I said, I think there are the bones of something really interesting here and maybe without the the Oversay of the you know the code that you can maybe get around some of those issues So I don't know would you be open for them to kind of take this and remake it I know they they obviously did the in a way musical the musical way back after this and stuff, right? Yeah, like we talked about

you take all the domestic abuse out we don't need that You make it some other reason why they're not together and then you do something there has to be something between when they're having their drunk sequence and she's realizing maybe that she's not meant for the other guy. There has to be a whole nother act then to me that like makes her go from Jimmy Stewart to Cary Grant or there has to be something like so. I mean, I think there's the bones there for for possibly something. And obviously, you know, you can throw different types of comedy in there to make it work. It's just I don't know. Like

I said, it's hard coming off of such fast paced comedy to also have this like as a slower. this is burn comedy type thing but I have learned one thing as we've covered Cary Grant is that it seems like he and maybe this works because the characters in these movies do the same thing but as an audience he's done, we've seen him play some roles that aren't like the greatest human beings in the world yet it's really hard not to like him he really is Yeah, he's really

like smooth and he's really likable as a as a performer. And so even when he's playing these, like we talked about with suspicion, like he's playing, he's lying the entire film. Like there's nothing good about him for most of that film. And it's like, hey, I still I still going to give him the benefit of the doubt. I think he can turn this around. It's like, well, Perry Grant has that going for him, I guess. And we'll have to see if that continues in our next film when we talk about 1941's Penny Serenade, which unlike this film, he was Actually nominated for an Academy Award for that one. So like we do

every time let's give them a brief glimpse of what to expect Dan What is your history or knowledge of the 1941 film Penny Serenade? I Like this. I honestly know even less about penny serenade than I do the Philadelphia story. I've never watched it I don't know if I heard much about it before we started doing this retrospective. So I'm looking forward to it because I know Literally nothing. I don't even know if it's a comedy or if it's more, you know where falls into that line I'm assuming it's a little bit of both because that's what Cary Grant would did did back in

the day But yeah, I'm looking forward to it because I'm wondering like what about that role Gave him the Oscar and right is it so is he doing something extra special to deserve it? Or is it more of those like bright place right time? So here's to see it's directed by George Stevens starring Cary Grant and Irene done who we've heard that name a couple different times as we were talking about some of the Hitchcock stuff and it's listed as a melodrama Dan so we'll have to see how that plays out but it's also got Cary Grant making a very much of a kind of funny look

on the poster so it's hard to see him not adding some type of comedy in here so like you I know nothing about Penny Serenade other than the picture of the poster that I'm looking at and a couple names that are attached to it. So I'm definitely interested to see what his Academy Award role looks like compared to the other, what now seven films that we've seen him in. So that'll be very interesting as we make our way through this. So Dan, how are ways that people can reach out to you if they have any questions or comments about your take on the Philadelphia story? So

if you love it and you hate me now, you can reach me at comic con tears on all the social media platforms Also, I guess I should throw out our letterbox because I never talked about that but I'm on I'm at the only social media site that I'm not Comic con tears its letterbox for a movie revolt so we can find me there, too All right. Yeah, you can check my letterbox out as well. Just search out Kevin 1981, I think is my screen name or Kevin Thompson, either one. The other

thing I forgot to throw out of the introduction is I'm going through a weird phase of movie watching. So we're watching all these Hitchcock and Cary Grant films and different things like that. And I decided to pair that up with going through all six Final Destination films. So it's really weird out of me going from one to the other and back and forth. I will say that much so. That's an interesting journey for sure. You can also reach out to me at the social medias at Optimus Solo. You can search out the show name Cinema Geekcast or the network, the Geekcast Radio Network.

So that does it for this episode. Tune in next time for another chance to listen to more of the Cinema Geeks.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Western Retrospective: The Outlaw Josey Wales

    Nov 16, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Halloween Special: Rocky Horror Picture Show

    Oct 31, 202641 minAudio

    Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Halloween Spotlight: The Exorcist

    Oct 29, 202642 minAudio

    Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Halloween Spotlight: Carrie (1976)

    Oct 26, 202639 minAudio

    Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Halloween Spotlight: Texas Chainsaw Massacre

    Oct 24, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...

    Credit the people on this episode