Today on Episode 247, the guys continue their Western Retrospective with another episode in which they discuss overlooked westerns. Coming off of their biggest disagreement in McCabe and Mrs. Miller, will the guys find common ground once again with Johnny Guitar? Tune in to find out! Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on X and Blue Sky! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark! #UNLEASHTHECINEMAGEEKINYOU!!! #CinemaGeeks #Westerns #WesterRetrospective #JohnnyGuitar
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey, this is Greg Berger and you are listening to the geek cast radio network Hello and welcome to episode 247 of the cinema geeks I am one of your cinema geeks optimus solo and joining me as usual is the comic concierge. Hello Dan. Hello. How are you? good good i feel like i want to
be one of those radio guys that's like from back in the day like uh it's like soothing like soothing and just like grab a cup of coffee and sit back and i don't know um enjoy the soft underbelly tones or whatever i yeah it's been a while since i've listened to the radio me too obviously since that probably hasn't happened in decades uh but we are back talking more western films with you guys so we've been covering a whole slew of different western films and last time we talked about mccabe
and mrs miller and today we're here talking about uh johnny guitar from what year is this 1954 1954 yes so before we get the facts about johnny guitar just remind everybody dan what your experience was or thoughts were going into it was it something you knew something about was it completely blind and kind of set the stage for you as you kind of went to view this time. I knew very little about this going into it, and I kind of tried to keep it that way as much as possible. The
only thing I knew about it, because as we were doing research, I knew it was the general tagline was it was a feminist Western, in which I was interested to see what that meant, especially for a movie, as we mentioned, that came out in 1954. That's really all I knew about it. Never watched it before. Never saw a trailer. I don't think I've ever even seen scenes from this before now that I've watched it. But how about you? What was your experience with this? There's a bunch of movies that we're covering on this retrospective
that were blind spots for me. But many of them I have obviously heard or knew they existed or knew lines from or certain things about it. Like there's a lot of famous Westerns that we're covering. This is one of those that falls in the category of like the least I knew about. Like, I don't know if there is a single thing I knew about this film other than what I saw on the, I think I may have seen the poster and saw that, you know, there was going to be a strong female presence in the film, but outside of that. I knew absolutely nothing about this, so it was very interesting
kind of going into this, coming off of McCabe and Mrs. Miller, also not knowing anything about our next film, which we'll get into towards the end. So I was very curious how this whole section was going to play out. ChatGPT was very skeptical on if I was going to like this one or not, so I was curious if it would keep its streak of being somewhat correct or if I would buck the trend for that one, but definitely going in very blind. um yeah so i'm interested to get into our thoughts but before we do that let's let dan set the stage with all the facts about johnny
guitar and then after that we'll get into our feelings after we finally watched it for the first time so take it away dan His name is Guitar, Johnny Guitar. As this week, we continue our Western retrospective with a look at Johnny Guitar from 1954. Set in the American West, the film centers on Vienna, played by Joan Crawford, a fiercely independent saloon owner who is waiting for a new rare world to arrive, believing it's going to make her a fortune. Her success and
confidence, though, do make her the target of suspicion and resentment from many of the townspeople, especially Emma Small, played by Mercedes McCambridge. Emma is bitter and very influential in the town, and she harbors a deep personal grudge against Vienna. Into the situation rides Johnny Guitar. As a titular character, played by Sterling Hayden, he's a former gunslinger who now carries a guitar rather than a gun, hence the name. He does have
a romantic history with Vienna, but does try to remain neutral in the town. although he's brought into it after the town is looking for someone to blame due to a series of robberies and violent incidences. As those accusations add up, Vienna is falsely accused, linked to the gang of outlaws led by the charismatic Dancing Kid. Gotta love the names back then. Emma uses fear, jealousy, public outrage, you know, those classics, to turn the town against Vienna, leading to a dramatic... final showdown the film adapts
the 1953 novel johnny guitar by roy chancellor though it's a very loose adaptation it changes much of it making the focus the rivalry between vienna and emma The film is officially directed by Nicholas Ray, but reports that cast and crew have suggested that was really Crawford who did most of the directing, using her power and influence over the production. Joan Crawford had a number of issues with other co -workers as well, most notably Mercedes McCambridge. They reportedly really hated each other and fought all the time,
according to the crew. Apparently that paid off because you certainly see that on screen as well. Cinematographer Harry Stranding Sr. often would combine location photography with studio close -ups. A scene might begin with a wide shot in Arizona, but then cut to a studio close -up under careful controlled lighting. This editing style can make it seem like Crawford was never out on location, although she was, so just to clarify there. The film earned around $2 .5 million in the North America market, so it did turn a profit,
although its reception with fans and critics at the time was very mixed. However, it was extremely well received in Europe, especially in France, including two critics, François Truffaut and Jean -Luc Godard, who gave it rave reviews. Of course, two people who would go on to make some legendary films themselves. It has gained more respect over the years and actually has a 94 on Rotten Tomatoes as we speak. But... where do kevin and i stand are we with those original
who saw it when it first opened or are we more with the more modern audiences back to us to discuss all right thanks for the facts dan on johnny guitar so kind of just to get us going here dan give you a little bit of a setup here so a lot of critics love this film they say it completely flips western conventions They enjoy the rivalry between Vienna and Emma. They like some of the political subtext. They praise the
direction, its willingness to be melodramatic, and its influence overall. On the opposite side of that, some critics feel like the acting is too much over the top, that the dialogue doesn't sound natural. They wonder why Johnny is the name of the movie but not the focus. Felt like the romance felt underdeveloped and that the melodrama could become unintentionally funny. wondering what side of the spectrum you fall into and what was your reaction on the first watch of Johnny guitar? Yeah. So interesting.
I think I could see and understand a lot of those high and low points regarding it and watching it. Like one of my biggest first impressions was like, if this movie came out today, like the. internet grifters would like have a field day because it it is a movie called johnny guitar as mentioned he's basically a side character you have kind of the females taking center stage you know joan crawford kind of looking not like you would typically see uh a leading lady in
this era or with the western you think of like you know the femme fatales or things like that like clearly not she's she is More, you know, she's certainly more in a masculine role than you would typically think of. And even like her rivalry with Emma Small, both on screen and off screen, they really are this movie. It is interesting that it is called Johnny Guitar when he's really like C character in this. I think there is a lot to like about it beyond just that portion of it. I do like the dynamic between Joan or
Vienna and Emma Small, the character. like their rivalry uh i do feel in a way which we got we have a briefing of where it comes from we get some idea but i do think maybe a little bit more would be able to let you buy buy in and maybe understand why they are so vicious to one another but They do have, I don't know what the opposite of chemistry is, but they have it, like, in a good way. Because apparently, in real life, they
did really despise each other. And that came across on screen. And I do, knowing this was written by a blacklisted writer at the time because of everything going on with the Redskins, I certainly see the ideas of mob role, what that, you know, the impact that can have, the negativity it can have when people just... just kind of go along with whatever they think the big bad is and not really think think it through so i think there are a lot of interesting ideas i do agree the
romance like there is when it comes to the romance there's like no chemistry between any of these characters like the love triangle that is being developed like they not feel like they at all belong within a relationship with one another and i do think that like by the end It takes all these interesting ideas. It takes like this groundbreaking approach and then kind of just becomes another shootout Western, although maybe with different characters. So I generally thought there was some interesting ideas here. And I
found the approach pretty refreshing, especially considering this was coming out near some other films we've talked about, which had a very different take. But I didn't think it was one of the strongest films as a whole. There's a lot of ambition here, but I don't think that ambition was always warranted with the overall end up product. And I do think reading into it, some of my issues made a lot more sense when I looked into the making of it and like, okay, we can get into that later. Why
some things felt a bit off, it all kind of connected for me. So I generally... would say i'm positive i get you know where where am i on the spectrum between the high end and low end i guess to do have a major comp out i'm like right in the middle but i'm curious you said chapter gpt and didn't think you would like it and it was right last time was it right this time i would say that it thinks it was right when i told it my opinions but i don't think it was um and i'll tell you
why I think there's a lot to appreciate about this film. I think there's a lot of good aspects of it. When it all comes together in a final product and through execution and whatnot, did everything work and did everything click? I would say probably not. But I think it reminds me of... Like if you were looking at a director's... retrospective like what you know if you're looking at like a famous director and their body of work it reminds
me of that film that is done early on in their career that then they come back and like later in their career make kind of a different version of that film but they do it better like to me it's almost like something like that like there's a lot of good seeds and good ideas here was it done and executed like at a top level i would say maybe not But, I don't know, it's almost like, I know they're different directors, but to me, in a way, it's like the earlier, not as
good version of Once Upon a Time in the West in a lot of ways. Like, Once Upon a Time in the West takes a lot of similar things that this film is doing and just does it better. I'm not saying they're like apples to apples, like they're different types of films and they're doing different things, but, you know, they both have similar backstories for their main characters as far as like saloon keeper or prostitutes who become saloon keepers and and different things like that they both have like a strong female presence
in it they both kind of have like this triangle situation going on they both have like the mysterious guns slinging outside i know a lot of these things can be said for a lot of westerns right um but to me it's like something that you would look at any famous director and say like this is like the the version of a movie they did before they had honed their craft and then later on they they go on to do something that maybe is on a different level but i i generally enjoyed it like the other thing that it really screamed to me when watching this is and you you talked
about the lack of chemistry and i think that's definitely a thing right like that's definitely prominently featured in this film is i guess a lack of chemistry but not always like in a bad way But it really reminds me of a stage play. And I know we'd say that a lot, but in this respect, when you go and watch something on stage, I think subconsciously you're much more aware that these
are individual actors that are putting on a show that feel less connected with each other in a way. i don't know if i'm explaining that right but like i feel like in a movie sometimes you can get lost in the movie and really feel like these are family members or lovers or things of that nature and i think that's much harder on stage because of the like just the dynamics of of a stage play and i love stage plays and
i love theater and stuff like that but i think you're always aware because they're right in front of you that these are actors right and i and i think in a movie sometimes it can get lost in like you just get wrapped up and lost in it and like it seemed like it was always evident that these were individual actors doing a job that was a little bit like takes you out of it a little bit like yes it is very melodramatic yes there's some kind of like similar to whatever one of the very first films we watched in this
retrospective where i asked you i was like is this how it's is this how it's gonna be like from here on out like are they gonna overact like throughout this whole retrospective and and are they gonna be like larger than life and stuff like that it has a lot of that in this like especially especially from and it's crazy because mercedes mccambridge is emma small she won she either won or was nominated nominated for an academy award in her first role ever like the first movie she ever did she was already on the biggest stage but she is a lot in this
movie and it feels like she is playing for the back of the theater like the way that her facial reactions and expressions and her like the everything her eyes and like the way she's speaking and i was like oh my goodness did somebody tell her that this was a movie um but so there is definitely a lot of that there's a lot of larger than life which I wasn't a huge fan of like, I didn't really care for McCambridge's performance, even though I did appreciate the dynamic between Vienna and
Emma. Like, I think that's obviously pivotal to the movie. It's, it's interesting. There's a lot of things like every poster of this has the name of the movie, bold and front and like size, a thousand font Johnny guitar. But yet every poster and everything is a picture of Joan Crawford and it's starring Joan Crawford. And then it says like with, you know, these other people. So it's like it's a weird choice as a title, I guess. I mean, but she was. Yeah, go ahead. She was a star. She was a star of that era. I mean, she was clearly the biggest star
going into this. So, yeah, absolutely. No, I totally get why. But like you are like thinking like, well, the name and the star usually match up better. But that's really has nothing to do with my. liking of the movie or different things like that but I just I found it where there was nuggets of stuff that I like there was I could see why some people would call it influential on some other stuff that comes later maybe as far as like some stuff that you could see it I like the fact that it's two two females that are kind of carrying the most weight especially
for this time period I did enjoy the fact that I think there is there is even though from an acting standpoint it's very dated i think there is a timeless aspect to the psychology of this movie like mob mentality and groupthink and all of that is is something that's always going to be present like it's always going to be prevalent it's always going to be something that people can relate to no matter what generation they grow up in so like i like those timeless aspects of the film and i did enjoy bits and pieces and
i did enjoy my overall experience so i was positive in general but like does it stack up to some of the other films that we've seen in execution like absolutely not yeah so that's kind of like my initial reaction interesting so i did actually like mercedes cambridge's performance i i obviously like you said she's over she's a lot but i felt like it was fitting i guess because she was surrounded by a lot and just like i mentioned like the back and forth with her and joan crawford and i mentioned like learning about the film and like the the
history of it and like what was going on stage apparently like they truly hated each other and there was like a lot of things she did i guess one time john crawford like got a lot of her coats and jackets and stuff like that and threw them into the street and they had a pretty intense feud and joan crawford herself was had a lot of like demands, I guess you would say, making this movie. I don't know if you noticed, especially, I think it's very apparent in the end shootout where you have, you know, they're tracking everyone
down and you nearly, when you have all these shots and like you look at everyone and they're all like on location in the background, you see like this kind of rather picturesque scenery, very realistic. They're clearly at a location. But then every time you see Joan Crawford, she's, you mentioned like how it feels isolated. Cause I think that's kind of how they had to make it because they would pan to her. And clearly you look at, you know, any shot with her in the background
was very different. The background was clearly like, you know, a painted background and it had a very more like set feel because it was on a set where, because she demanded that everything she did be on, you know, on a set. So the lighting was perfect. And I do think, Like it's almost in a way it feels like it was edited where like as a spoof or something in a way where they're just putting in someone else. Sometimes it's like she's in a completely different movie because it looks so very different. So that final sequence
where it's like panning to all these different characters and they're supposed to be in the same location. But clearly anytime you get to her, it's like very much not, I thought. so i think that too like it seemed like it wasn't just those two that had issues with each other either oh yeah they all had issues with everybody yeah i guess yeah sterling hating mentioned like he felt like everyone was crazy on the set which seems like it was the case so he said that he said that like he would be on his way to the
movie and just have to pull over and like throw up because he was so like not wanting to be a part of it or something i thought i read and i think i also read that he said that no matter how much money was offered he would never do a film with Crawford again and he's like in that saying something because I like money but so I can see like why some of these didn't feel like they had like like it works for Vienna and Emma right because they're supposed to hate each other so that works but then when it comes to the the I guess quote -unquote romantic chemistry
that some of these characters are supposed to have I think it definitely works in reverse against some of that Definitely, yeah. You don't feel it at all, because it wasn't really there at all. Even with the dancing kid, Scott Brady, again, their performances by themselves work. I do feel like Johnny Guitar, you get some sense that he's trying to escape a violent past, and he doesn't have guns, but clearly that's not
the case. I do feel like there's a story there. Apparently, this is very different than the actual source material because it does make Vienna's character much more prominent, which I don't necessarily have an issue with. But he does feel like a very undeveloped character who just kind of pops in and pops out when necessary. But overall, the cast is pretty stacked, though. I didn't realize... Ernest Borgnine shows up, who I love,
and he's one of those great actors that comes in everything. He's super young in this, too. Yeah. He's not super young, but he's young compared to what I knew him. I just recently saw him in something else. I forget the name of it, but he plays a similar character. The other movie takes place. one takes place in one day i could get the movie in a second but um he plays a similar character where he's like this kind of tough
guy enforcer who kind of tends to uh you know tough but that ends up being the one that beaten up at the end uh so it was interesting seeing him play that in my head like when i think you know i think of him in the movie marty he's like this great like you know who's like one of the most endearing characters ever so ever seeing him like role like this but uh you know it was it was great seeing him show up because he's always a fun presence and then what you know word bond who we've you know we've seen a lot
in the all the different uh movies with john wayne seeing him without john wayne it's like i didn't know you'd love to make movies without john wayne let's go see i think i saw spork nine like way later like in his tv roles he was like in oh yeah murder she wrote and highway to heaven and like little house on the prairie and stuff like that like like i did not see him when from the i know he's in a lot in the 50s and 60s but i had not been exposed to him yet so i was like oh that's the same guy like that's crazy yeah
yeah i also remember like mckell's navy i remember him in the funny thing is remember him in the like i saw the tv not the tv movie but the tom arnold movie and he's in that too yeah he's one of those guys who kind of showed up and shows up in everything Which one was Ward Bond? He was in The Searchers, right? Yeah, yes. Ward Bond was in The Searchers. I know that's one of the ones we watched. He's been also bringing up Baby from our last retrospective. Yeah, I've seen a lot of Ward Bond. And John Carradine was
in this as well. Yeah, old Tom. I didn't realize that was him either. I forgot to mention this with Emma Small's performance. I did like her performance, although like... I don't know if you felt this, but her voice, it kind of sounded like Rocky from Rocky and Bullwinkle. I kept wondering, I kept checking, like, did she voice Rocky? Because she feels like her voice sounds, it has that same pitch to it. Maybe that's what my problem was. Like, I don't know if it was
the voice as much as the, I think it was more the voice than the performance. Like, I just felt like she was always shouting to the back of the theater. I don't know. Oh, definitely. I mean, I think her and Joan Crawford are trying to have an act off where like, you know, they just like, you know, who can be, who can, you know, have the biggest performance and they both won. You know who I liked in this? I liked the dancing kid. Like, I'm not saying like his character necessarily, but I thought his performance was pretty, he was the, he was out of the whole cast,
like the least person that was trying to overact. like I feel like he was just doing his thing like it was mainly the two women that were doing most of the overacting but and a couple of the townspeople but like the dancing kid just seems like a little bit more subtle compared to all of that and I actually enjoyed his performance I looked him up to try to see like what else I've seen him in and I haven't seen him in a lot but his last film role was the sheriff in the original 1984 gremlins movie oh wow so if
you want to look that up anybody you can look up uh look that up but apparently he's the one of the sheriffs in uh the gremlins movie that was his last role but i thought i thought uh scott brady was pretty good movie i have yet have yet to see so gremlins intriguing yeah i've never seen we're gonna add that this christmas has got to be a part of something christmas movie retrospective oh and the movie i was thinking about with earners board nine was a bad day at black rock um it's like uh okay it's a About this guy who, it's kind of like a neo -western
in a way. It's about this character played by Spencer Tracy. He comes into this town. He's trying to find out this secret. And it's a very secretive town. And then Ernest Borgnine is one of the criminals there. But that takes place after World War II, from present day of its era. It came out in 1955, actually a year after this. Intriguing there. yeah so um i'm curious too um as far as the film goes and you know we talked
about some of the themes and you know the paranoia the mentality you know power and stuff like that we do see some like pretty mature elements as well like obviously we see a uh this place get burned to the ground we see a hanging which they just don't really pull many punches in that sequence yeah like that just happens and there's a bunch of people around it that are okay with it i i yeah definitely it i think it did it pretty tastefully and i was i was thinking okay well here comes
johnny guitar to save the day and like yes but there's a cost there so i was like are we gonna get the shot again like somebody's gonna shoot the rope like is that what's gonna happen they're gonna i did think that was i was like oh he's gonna shoot the rope but no actually did like the the solution to that where he's on top of the bridge and cuts it like that actually makes much more sense so there you go what did you think of the constant use or go to of the like secret trail through the waterfall like i think
we saw some of them go through that seat that like that path like six times at some point in the movie where they were going back and forth to like the the hidden layer on the mountain for the for the quote -unquote bad guys yeah i did i mean it's a cool layer so i guess it's like all right well we came up we're gonna use a lot of our time on our layer budget oh i was very confused though it's like the the the space we were living in yeah like that the distance from one place to the rest the how it's all is
oriented like it seemed like they would be going off on this like long trail and then they would just be right back in front of the saloon or whatever it was and then it was like back to the back to the dancing kids layer and like i was like are these things next door to each other are they right next door it's just a waterfall connects them that had a similar idea because i wasn't really clear if like they went through that waterfall and that's where the dancing kid hideout was on the other side of that and it was like a quick yeah the geography was a little strange overall like where everything was located
like even like the the vienna's like place like where it is within in relationship to the actual town because it felt like it was like out on its own doing its own thing but it i guess it was more so part of the actual town itself so it i think yeah that the geography is a little is a little odd here but the other thing go ahead yeah no no not to the point where it like takes you out it was just something that was kind of like a minor detail that i was like i am very confused as to like how big this actual place is another thing that was a little bit confusing
for me was the actual dynamic between in relationship between multiple people in that mob or like between emma and like one of them was a sheriff and then one of them was just like a powerful guy and like it seemed like it was a little foggy as far as like the hierarchy in that group like I get like Emma's in control and like most of them are listening to her but it was very confusing as far as to like at times they had differing of opinions but you didn't know quite how everybody
ranked and like I guess it was just more of that just general mob mentality but I was not sure where like I think it was Ward Bond was like one of the main guys there and I was like is he just like what's his relationship with Emma like are they just townsfolk that both have a lot of power i think well you had the marshal and then you had the sheriff and then you had emma who was like the you know she had she was the you know bank i guess in the sense because her husband being dead so i i took it as like
the the marshal was there because of like the overall you know being a marshal he's more of a on the federal end so he has technically the the most authority but in the sense of uh you know that authority doesn't mean much if if the mob around you isn't going to recognize it and you know the the person who's actually having the money and can control the town really has the final say so i don't know if like that was what they're going with it per se like you know
we've had a few films even talking about again once upon a time in the last where it's like you know what's more deadly the dollar or the or the gun so I don't know if it's something partially regarding that. Again, possibly, but that's the way I took it. I get that. I also did enjoy the dynamic between the dancing kid and then, what is it, old Tom and Bart, I think. That was very Spaghetti Western -ish, where it had this posse of people that, how much could
they trust each other? How much? Were they just in it for themselves and kind of how that dynamic was going to fall down when it came to like loyalty and who would cross who? Like, I thought that was an interesting dynamic. I'm curious what you thought of those three. And then we haven't spent a lot of time talking about Sterling Hayden. Obviously, we know that he wasn't getting along with Joan Crawford. But like, what did you think as far as him as Johnny Guitar? An interesting casting that cast a guy that didn't know how to play guitar and didn't know how to ride a horse. Yeah, but he was tall. Yeah, you can fake
it. So I did like the dynamic of the gang. Also, I did like the fact that when it began and they show up in the bar, or I guess casino, whatever you want to call it, I did actually at first think, oh, because when you see that opening scene, you don't really get to see who really robbed the stagecoach. And I did think it was them, because they walk in and they kind of have that presence of... being this ruthless gang and finding out, no, actually, it wasn't. They were trying to do the right thing and how they
get pulled into doing the wrong thing because, hey, if they're going to think we're going to do the wrong thing anyways, might as well. So I did like that aspect and their dynamic together to how they had each other's back but to a certain point and how it was a bit, you know. How they had a lot of rivalry within that group as well. So that, I thought, was effective. And I thought Sterling Hayden, I thought he hit it beyond not having chemistry with Joan Crawford. I thought he was a good presence. I've loved him in so
many other performances, but I don't think he had an opportunity really to do much. Like I mentioned, his character... we don't know that much about like the little song he does do sure like i couldn't tell he didn't know how to play guitar i also don't know how to play guitar either so perhaps that's that's why but i thought like he has you know he has certainly a presence to him he has the the cowboy look but it's not necessarily
a performance i would go to is like oh we want to see certain hayden being that iconic actor i didn't think that he had even the opportunity to even do that here It says that he was offered the role of Quentin Jaws, but turned it down. That's an interesting note. The other person we didn't, I guess I kept saying three, but one fourth member of that gang that, you know, spoiler alert, doesn't make it to the end, is Turkey Ralston, played by Ben Cooper, who also apparently has a, supposed to be a love angle with Joan
Crawford, even though they're like, I don't know, 40 years, or not 40, they're like. 20 years, at least an age difference. But what did you think of, I kind of liked Ben Cooper in general, just as a presence on there. It's kind of like the young guy who's kind of unable to be bottled up or like, you know, he's kind of like the loose cannon, so to speak, or, you know, the emotional punk kid. I don't know if I really enjoyed the romance connection between him and Joan Crawford, but I did enjoy him as just an extra person who didn't fit the mold of everybody else in the
film. But what did you think of Turkey Rolston's character? yeah and we've seen this role a lot right the young gun trying to prove himself and often those characters can come off as really annoying and i never thought that was the case here there was a bunch more tragedy to his character uh in a bit like the first time he has guns he gets them blown out of his hands then you you kind of can understand like the put in a situation where he is trying to save himself in a way and you could kind of criticize that character for
that but also just the fact that he he succumbs to this this group and then pays the ultimate price even though he told was told that he didn't have to just like the tragedy he plays in that scene like he told me I would be okay like you can see like just the utter defeat within his character so I agree I think he was a really like a character that often can be the weak link in a lot of other westerns I thought worked here I think he was a good looking kid too he had
a lot going for him for this one I was pleasantly surprised because he could easily have come across as somebody that was kind of an eye roller in this film especially with as large as they were allowing everybody to act I could have seen him trying to seize the moment and make every scene about him but I thought he did a decent job this film was uh nominated for a couple of the different afi lists so it got a nomination for when they were compiling the list for afi's 10 top 10 for westerns and emma small also got nominated for
an appearance on the 100 heroes and 100 villains um list as well so uh some love out there i think it has like a 94 on rotten tomatoes and like a 80 something on on metacritic but uh i guess not necessarily a polarizing film, but I feel like there is people on both sides of it. I am glad I watched it. I was entertained enough that while I watched it, I'm glad I've seen it. And I can see, like I said, where some of the other films may or may not have seen certain things
and kind of grabbed towards it. I do, like I said, it broke a lot of the conventions with the way that they treated the two main female characters. So I think there is enough to appreciate. like a easy recommend for like somebody who's really trying to get like a full picture of all the westerns like i do feel like from an execution standpoint there are some misses and probably a lot of that is due to this filming back and forth whether they're on location or on set for mrs crawford or the the lack of chemistry in
real life between sterling hayden and joan crawford probably didn't help that where i guess it probably helped with her and emma but like it's one of those like i know you said like it's kind of a cop -out to say it's in the middle but like I can totally see that, and I feel like that's kind of where I'm at as well. Yeah. Like I said, I do think it's ambitious. It's going for a lot of things that, especially at that time, you didn't see Westerns do. So I do think it plays an important part in that aspect. I also think it looks really intriguing. The use of color,
even in Joan Crawford's outfits, they're very striking. It's a very different style and look in a lot of ways. I know when it came out, it was not well -received, because I think because it was so different and a bit ambitious, at least in the sense of United States audiences didn't know what to do with it. I read a lot of the contemporary reviews at the time, and some of them are very, very harsh, especially to Joan Crawford, the way she looked. I can understand why some of these actresses were the way they
are. they like went after her pretty strongly regarding the way she looks like there was an uh critic who called it like basically like beauty and the beast with joan crawford being the beast i'm like wow that is yeah they were pretty vicious uh with with with her um so yeah but i i think that's far too far too harsh for a number of reasons but uh and i so like i said i think there's a lot to take out of it also it's intriguing too because i think originally this was designed
to be in 3d like they were thinking which i don't know how that would understand how that would work i mean maybe that fire sequence could look pretty cool but you know it was like the you know the gimmick at the time but i don't know if that's why it had some of the color choices it did because it had a lot of like flat colors a lot of like a lot of monochromatic colors i think or is that i don't know my color that'd be something research like what how they were doing a 3d option in 1954 or whatever year this was yeah but yeah like i said i'm glad we watched
it and i think it is worth a watch just to see its place within history and and seeing these seeing some of these performances and just even if they are a little bit big at times and i think it gives you a lot to look at and like i said i think too especially speaking toward to the time obviously with this going on at the red scare and the you know with all the concerns about communism and all that stuff certainly speaks to that and it being written by a a writer
who was on the blacklist you can certainly see a lot of the impact of like what was trying to be said and having that context i think adds a little bit to it as well i just think it you know sometimes it just and everything works which is which is okay but yeah no absolutely i totally agree so but what do we what are we going to next so we're going backwards a year actually so this was 1954 we're going to go back to 1953 which should put us you know in the same time
period same it's going to be interesting seeing these back to back and knowing that they were filmed kind of at the same time ish uh yeah i the name of this one's called the naked spur uh from 1953 and the only thing i know about this film dan is the fact that i just pulled it up and i can see that two of the stars are people that were obviously pretty well familiar with which would be jimmy stewart and janet lee that is all i know about this other than the poster has jimmy stewart holding a spur and has
a couple guys punching each other and that is it says it's packed with technicolor thrills so like Sign me up. I'm ready. What do you know about the Naked Spur, Dan? What you just said. That's basically what I know. I know the year. And I know it has Jimmy Stewart. And like you mentioned, Janet Leigh. So, you know, it's nice to see two actors from the Hitchcock retrospective coming together for Western. So I don't, again, know much. Don't know much about. Wow. Don't
know what it's about, which I like. I like that, going in not knowing anything, especially for a movie that's as old as this. So, intrigued to see. I know it's, like I said, this is the overlooked western section, so I'm seeing if it deserves to be overlooked, or maybe it'll be a surprise hit. We'll see. I'm definitely interested, like you said, to see the two of the people we saw in the Hitchcock retrospective now completely in a different environment in the westerns. Obviously, we already saw Jimmy Stewart in one of the westerns we covered. so
far but we have not seen janet lee so i'm interested to see how how that works out and you know we just came off of a film that kind of had two females like front and center so i'm interested to see like how janet lee's character is portrayed in this one is it another strong female or is it taken more of a traditional kind of stereotypical female role from this era like that'll be interesting to see for sure so i'm excited to uh see this as kind of a the last of our three is this the last of our three in the overlooked we've edited
it a few times and then we we did after where are we going after this so we're in the overlooked western section the naked despair was the last one and then we did make some additional additions additional additions that's that's about english but we went and we added some we have like a more classic western section i couldn't think of a better name for it but we're gonna go back and get some more of the classic westerns we haven't included like red river high noon shane rio bravo so um that's gonna be interesting too
because it gives us a chance to like go back to that classic era now after watching a bunch of these other kind yeah or like these other like subgenres so i think it's going to be an interesting way to do that versus watching just all of them straight in the beginning um so i'm intrigued to see how this this all goes what else are we going to be like sending out into the the episodes for people to watch recently for those that uh are not western fans yeah so we were thinking about like okay we've been doing this western retrospective and we're adding much more and we're like whoa what about people who
don't like westerns they might have No interest in all this. So we thought, OK, well, let's try to do something on the completely other end of the spectrum. We're going to pick a franchise and we pick the franchise to kind of go through. And one, I think that we've had some experience with in the past. And we're going to start that very shortly with Planet of the Apes retrospective going through all of those movies from the first until the most recent. So I'm curious. Kevin,
what's your experience with Planet of the Apes? I know we've talked about the more recent ones a few times, but what about the franchise as a whole? So yeah, so it was probably, I'm guessing about 15 years ago now. Man, that makes me feel old. It was before the modern ones. I don't remember when the very first of the most recent films was on, but I think it was probably somewhere around 2009, 2010, around that time. okay so that's if my math's correct that's about 15 years
ago um and so uh probably 17 years ago if i can do math correctly but it was somewhere around there that uh my wife and i actually went through i believe we hit all of them so we watched all of the classics uh planet of the apes films we watched the mark walberg film and then we started in on the modern films and i've seen so i've seen every planet of the apes film at least once And I've probably seen the modern films multiple
times. The first one I know I've seen three or four times. And then the other ones I know I've seen at least twice. So I actually do have some experience with all of the Planet of the Apes films. The thing that I'm interested in, though, is when we did that all those years ago, we watched them in chronological order. And we finished with the more modern ones. So now that I've seen those, I'm very interested. to go back and watch the originals again to see like what other stuff i pick up on or connections i can make which i know a lot of people probably written written
ad nauseum on on all that but like i haven't experienced myself so i'm i'm definitely intrigued to like go back at this point and watch them now that i've seen all of them but what's your experience with the franchise i've seen the original uh it's been a it's been a very long time since i've watched it though probably similar to you so the rise came out 2011 so i guess 15 years ago, which makes sense. Makes me feel better, Dan. Yeah, sorry I gave you some more time back. But I've never seen the movies after that. I've
seen here and there. They'd often be back when I had cable. They would come on cable and I'd see scenes popping in and out. Why are they playing under the apes in modern times? I know ideas of where the other movies went, but I've never seen them start to finish. I'm not really sure much about where they go or what happens. I love the newer films. It's crazy. I can tell you that much. I can imagine. I love the newer films. I remember when Rise was coming out and thinking, why are they doing Son of the Apes? They tried
that. It failed. I think if I'm looking at my favorite franchises of the 2010s, that might be on top of my list. I get that seeing the 2001 version with Tim Burton and Mark Wahlberg was like, they did that, it didn't work. I don't know what happened in those 10 years between 2001 and 2011 or if it was just who was involved with it or what, but my goodness, I don't think any other film has made 10 years feel like 50
more than the difference between the 2001 and the 2011 version. I remember seeing the 2011 one and like, going bananas for it like it was definitely in my top 10 films of the year that year I proceeded to like every movie since then and I just think there's so much there like I really wish that it would have successfully gotten like mocap into the Academy Awards and things of that nature but it's definitely interesting so now that everything that has come out has
come out and I know there could be more or something that would come on down the road but we're at 10 of them 10 films so far so Nice round number. So out of the 10, you've fully seen how many? I've seen the first and then the next, the three. I actually have not seen the most recent one. And you haven't seen the Tim Burton one or no? I've seen the Tim Burton one. Yeah. I saw that in theaters actually. You've seen five of the 10. Yeah. So I've not seen half of them. So that's
exciting. I have read some of the comics. Yeah. I have read some of the comics, because there's been a lot of Planet of the Apes comics, and I'll talk about that when we get into the first movie, because there's actually a comic that is an adaptation of Roger Sterling's original draft for the Planet of the Apes, which was going to be much different than the movie itself, but had to be changed because it would have been far too expensive to do, because it was more of like... Planet of the Apes in more like modern
time. So I've always loved the franchise. So I've always wanted to go back and watch those movies. So now it's a good opportunity to do that. And then, of course, like we mentioned, if you're someone who doesn't like Westerns, perhaps you'll like science fiction. And also, I don't think we've ever talked about them or done reviews of them, even the newer ones. I think we've talked about them as they've come up in year -end awards or top tens or stuff like
that, but that's probably about it. The other thing that's interesting is that there's ten films and there's eight different directors. So it's always a different flavor. Yeah, true. So yeah, you can either get to our Western love and continue on with us there, or you can switch over to sci -fi, or you can do both. Just mix it up and watch both and listen to us if you can't get enough of us. I don't know if that's possible. And you can keep up with all that stuff. Dan, do you want to give them a heads up on how
they can interact with us online? Yeah, and hopefully I'll get back to doing more. I've been on vacation. But check out our Facebook page at the Cinema Geekcast podcast. We've been putting hopefully more stuff up on there. I'm going to put some stuff about our box office draft, how that's going, and other things like that. You can also follow Dan. i am getting crushed i am doing horrible so we'll see well i still got some coming yeah well but like supergirl did not help me no but
animal like animal farm i think lost somehow like has negative money i don't know there's a couple picks we wish we could have back that's for sure Yeah. And certain ones I wish I definitely picked, like I really underestimated some of the horror films. We'll talk about it another time, but yeah. So, but I am not, it's, if this was a fantasy football season, I'd be like, Oh, an eight at this point. So, but yeah, I can also, and you can find me on social media platforms at comic concierge. Yeah, and you can find me
at Optimus Solo. We also may be putting out an episode soon that gives you some more modern takes on 2026 films as we have crossed the halfway point. We might give you guys a little update on the stuff that we've seen. I know Dan's been hitting the pavement hard with film watching this year. You have me destroyed. I think I accidentally let myself get wrapped up into like... four or five different tv series that really started dominating my time and i need to i need to catch up on some movies so uh but i know you've seen a bunch and i probably have some great recommendations so we'll try to get that out for people to listen
to soon as well so um if you have any ideas or comments for the show dan just gave you the ways to to search us out and and drop those comments and we definitely will listen to all comments and take all feedback and as we go forward but and that does it for this episode so tune in next time for another chance to listen to more of the cinema geeks
Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...
Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...
Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...
Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...
Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...