Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

CINEMA GEEKS

CINEMA GEEKS artwork

Hitchcock Retrospective: Rebecca

May 4, 202551 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Today on Episode 215, The Cinema Geeks go into extra innings with even more Hitchcock coverage than originally planned. First up on the extended journey, is a look at the classic film, Rebecca. How will this first bonus film go over with the Cinema Geeks? Tune in to find out! Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on X! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark! #UNLEASHTHECINEMAGEEKINYOU!!!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hi, this is John Delancey and you are listening to the GeekCast Radio Network. Hello and welcome to episode 215 of the Cinema Geeks. I am one of your Cinema Geeks Optimus Solo and joining me once again is the comic concierge. How you doing, Dan? Good, how are you? I'm doing well. We are back at it again in like extra innings

sudden death bonus material I don't know what you want to call this, but we are in the extra innings of our Alfred Hitchcock Retrospective we've covered ten films and now we're going into some bonus films that we had not planned on originally But we're having such a good time that we decided to just keep it going for a little bit longer So today we are covering the 1940 American romantic psychological thriller is all the words that they put against this one. I guess this is Rebecca one of his more famous ones I'm not sure how

it didn't make it into our first draft, but we're making up for it now so Rebecca is a film that is based off of a 1938 novel of the same name by Daphne de Moria Who is also the person that did the short story that the birds was based off of this one's obviously directed by Alfred Hitchcock and it stars Laurence Olivier Joan Fontaine, Judith Anderson, George Sanders, Gladys Cooper, and a few other folks. Dan, just to reiterate, I know we talk about it at the end of every episode, but for those that are just tuning into this

episode, what is your experience with Rebecca going into this one? Have no experience with Rebecca, which is a weird thing to say Because I have a sister named Rebecca so but now this is a first time watch for me and I honestly think unlike a lot of other Hitchcock films Where you have so many scenes that are just so well -known in the zeitgeist like that like when you watch the Oscars or any, you know movie award show that they always get reference like For Rebecca like I feel like I'm going in the most blind

out of 39 steps, but you know His first the first film we did so I was going into this Rather fresh like I've heard rumblings. I think I've listened to some reviews way back when but I did not really know what it was about outside of I knew Rebecca was a character that was not in the movie, but about the movie was about her But that was about it Yeah, I am much the same. I did not know anything about this one. I Had not had anything spoiled

for me. Really. I didn't know what it was about I didn't know anything about the characters and even think about the plot or anything whatsoever So I was going in completely blind now Part way through the viewing for this episode. I did obviously pick up on a character that I have heard of obviously I think we even talked about it during our top 100 villains of all time. And if I'm not mistaken, we mentioned one of the characters in this film.

So I was immediately suspicious of her, I guess, just because of that. But outside of that, I didn't really have any experience with this one. And just to keep everybody somewhat clear with where we're at here, the first 10 we did were in chronological order starting then. 1935 and going into the 60s now we're going all the way back to 1940 so to put that in place of what else we've watched the 39 steps was 1935 Rebecca

is 1940 and then notorious is I believe Right after that So this comes out after the 39 steps and before notorious if we're trying to place it within his other Work so upon first viewing Dan of this film that we had to resort to crazy methods to watch. What was your initial reaction? Crazy, but legal methods. I think we should point out. Yes. Yes. Very legal. Yeah, I'll be enough.

This is on YouTube, but like no actual streaming service at the moment, which is crazy considering, you know, it's such a notorious film and not notorious the movie, but you know, well known and everything like that. But yeah, so going into this, I'm gonna make a weird comparison. Maybe it doesn't make sense, but I'll try to explain it. But to me, after this viewing, Rebecca is to the Alfred Hitchcock filmography that Jackie Brown is to Quentin Tarantino's filmography.

And let me explain why. I feel like when you tell someone Quentin Tarantino made a movie, they have certain ideas of what that movie is like. There's a certain style that is associated with his directing. And Jackie Brown, I think, is an example of him going a different route and I think maybe being a bit more reserved and having a story that is far more driven by a plot and narrative compared to a lot of what he did before. And I feel in a lot of ways similar with

Rebecca, where Rebecca is a story that is you know it it has thrilling moments and it certainly has some bigger moments in general but it is not a movie that is spectacle like a north by northwest or even a psycho or uh you know some of the other films we did vertigo for example uh most of it takes place it's almost the inverse of rear window it's a lot of it just takes place inside uh in in that regard and it is far more

driven by the narrative by the story where the other Hitchcock films we've done so far what I have enjoyed about them at times the narrative but it was pretty much just the craft of it and the characters and this was great characters as well but um but I was enthralled by the narrative I was actually and it took me a bit to kind of hook into it but I thought I knew where it was going and not that I need surprises for a movie to be good but When it like inverse on itself i was like oh okay it all started to click i'm

like now and now i see why so well regarded and it's not that it's not shut well it's beautifully lit it's. You know that the manner that this take place takes place in as we share the sound becomes its own character but i really enjoyed it i was fascinated with the story progression. And just the way it went, uh, you know, there may be some issues we're talking about, but, or some things that I didn't think fully connected, but as a film, it's very, it feels very different from Hitchcock films we did before. So I'm glad

we included it, but despite it being different, I think that's a lot what I enjoyed about it. And I was a big fan of watching this. How about yourself? Um, I interestingly enough was finding it. kind of a fascinating journey to go all the way through two and a half or three however many decades I guess 1935 to what 1963 What was bird's 19? Yeah, so like we we covered like three decades

of films right and we we saw a progression and what Hitchcock was doing and things that he was the way he was making films though the what his focus was and what he was trying to do in different aspects kind of traveling through time with him and I found it very interesting to then go back now and watch what we're gonna be doing I guess for the most part is like now Filling in some gaps along the way and it's kind of interesting how they fit in and if they remind you of the films From that time period that we were watching

or if they connect to films that come later I think that's gonna be something interesting to kind of keep track of and this is about smack dab in the middle of the 39 steps in notorious right so it's five years after the one i think it's like six years before the other so it's in the middle of that and i one thing i appreciated was something that i felt like we were somewhat veering away from towards the end which was these great sides supporting characters And so I really

appreciated that we kind of got back into that there's a lot of characters to enjoy whether you Enjoy them from the entertainment standpoint of just like what they're doing and how they're portraying the character and how the actors portraying them or What they if you know if they had a bigger part in the story or different things like I found drawn to a number of different characters in this one outside of just the main two Leads which was something that I enjoyed The another thing that I think separates this and you're basically alluding to it with your opening commentary

is a lot of the Hitchcock films that we talked about were very Regardless of film length were very quickly paced I guess is the way I would say it like there never seemed to be a lot of like lulls there never seemed to be a lot of Really digesting like a scene and taking it all in. Like a lot of his is somewhat fast paced where it's like you get that and then you're onto the next thing and then you're onto the next thing. And this is definitely a departure

from that. Like he definitely is taking his time in the way that he is telling this story. And I'm not sure how I land on that because I'm so used to the other thing that he had been doing. I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing. Like I like taking my time. I like taking being able to like Think through and kind of like really mull on the stuff as it's happening It threw me off a little bit though that it was happening in a Hitchcock film, which I had not seen yet So like there was a little bit of like pacing

Questions, I guess in my head as I was going through here. There was a few moments where I was wondering If this really felt like a Hitchcock film where we were going I will say that the the final or the first act is Fantastic, like I really enjoy the first act. I think it's very humorous It is quick paced in the beginning and I like the way it sets the stage. And then I think the film in the last, we'll call it the last act. I don't know what the timestamp was. I don't know if it's the last third or the last quarter or whatever the case may be. Really ramps

up there at the end and is kind of firing on all cylinders during that last, we'll call it, I don't know, 30 minutes. There was some moments in Between that or in the middle that I felt it was dragging even a little bit But I don't know if that's just because I've become used to how fast he's been moving in all the other films Versus if I was watching this next to watching like a whole bunch of non -hitchcock films Like I don't know how that would would come across, but you're definitely right. It's definitely Hitchcock going down a different route with this one, which I appreciated I just I think there's

a couple things that in the middle and a couple times where it felt like we were doing the same thing over and over again, like a little bit of repetitiveness. But I think the beginning of it's fantastic. I think the end of it for me saves it. So I ultimately come down favorably on this film as far as like liking it. I am wrestling with myself as far as where it like stacks up against all of the other films that we've seen. I think it's probably top half for me, but I'm still kind of wrestling with that and hoping

that, you know, talking it through with you a little bit here may may help me even more. Before we get into some more about the story, though, I'm curious if you have any experience with some of the actors or actresses in this film. Like, obviously, Laurence Olivier is like, everybody knows his name, right? In the film world. I had never seen a film with him in it. I'd never seen a film with Joan Fontaine in it, I don't believe, or just about anybody involved with this. Did you have any experience with any of the actors or actresses in this one? No, not that I know of I yeah like Laurence Olivier it is like that

name it is like you synonymous with Hollywood old Hollywood, but I Don't the only thing I think ice movies. I've seen any actor. I think I've seen movies with was George Sanders like he Trying to think of what I've seen him and all about Eve He was all about Eve, which is one of my favorite films. So he's he's in that so I was a familiar with him and that film but Or to believe hey as you know has Horrible as it might sound

wasn't really familiar with it. This was Joan Fontaine's first first major film I think But I can't think of much else. I have seen her in Outside of this, I know she's done some other of course some other Hitchcock films as well. Same thing was like you just finished Judith Anderson Not that I'm aware of that. I've seen her before. I know this was kind of a huge role for her like her first Oscar nomination But oh she wasn't cat in a hot tin roof, which I have seen but I don't remember her in that per se

so but I Guess he was in Star Trek 3 2, but I don't know her in that as well. Wow. Okay. I don't remember that at all I'm gonna have to like do some research after this about the Vulcan high priestess. So Crazy Learn something new every day. So yeah, so fairly new to most of these folks I remember a few of the names like I sounded familiar Whether they've been in Leo Carroll who plays the doctor was in Strangers on a train and North by Northwest But I'd have

to like try to figure out who he was in those films right off the top of my head But it was interesting. It was fun to see Laurence Olivier and in like the first my first experience like I haven't seen Spartacus I don't know Like that's probably a crime against humanity when it comes to film review that you haven't seen I own but I have seen Spartan but I was I was I was not one of my dad's favorite film so I was like super young like Ten so it's okay a long time since I've seen that So it was fun seeing some of these folks for what was me for me the first first time seeing it What did you think about the beginning?

So the beginning we have basically we're in a hotel and we are introduced to The what who would become the second mrs. De Winter played by Joan Fontaine were introduced to the mister, you know max de winter played by Laurence Olivier and then Joan Fontaine's What kind I don't know what name you would give her the employer of? Her yeah player. Those are employer. Yeah. Yeah, so played by Florence Bates and it kind of sets

the stage to how The the main two characters are introduced to each other and kind of how they fall for each other and things of that nature So everything that's happening in that hotel, which I'll just call it like the first act. What was your take on that? I Liked it. There's probably honestly you said the middle part was your least favorite it I don't say it was my least favorite. I guess out of the three acts But exactly talked about how it was a bit repetitive and I could see some of it there But I think it was important to kind of build that relationship between Who would become Mrs. Fontaine? It had a bit of a

it almost had like a whimsy to it like I almost felt like a classic Like romantic comedy in a way like the way it was portraying. Yeah Not knowing what this movie was. I'm like, oh does this become more of a romantic comedy because the way it was, you know going about it, of course, you have the employer who's like you lose overweight person that just trying to Hit on someone that was a get with someone who's like half her age, maybe not half her age But I don't know but yeah,

it was it was I think a good introduction into these characters It really gave mrs. DeWinter like a sense of innocence Which was I think really important as the movie went into its second act to see that innocence kind of be Taking advantage of in some ways, but yeah, so I thought it was it served its purpose. Of course the fifth going

to be interested in her for whatever reason is kind of crazy. And then, of course, she's treating the what is I got to find out what the second Mrs. Winter's name is. Do they give her a name? She's got to have a first name, right? No, she doesn't. That's the whole thing. She doesn't have a name. Oh, that's a weird name. OK, I feel weird. She's just the whole time. That's her. Yeah, that's her actual name in the script. She's never given a full first name. And Same thing with the book as well. That's based on okay given

a full first name So I think it's obviously a purposeful person purposeful choice with a movie called Rebecca that the main antagonist protagonist is not given an actual first name to just it's just a It's a little right. Yeah, you know It does know too like it definitely adds something to it because of the and we'll jump ahead this in a minute when they get to the mandrelay but what i was going to say is just you get to see how how poorly the employer is treating the employee

in that situation uh and like you said it really does add to the innocence and whatnot and then i think it is clever that they don't give her a name because she's constantly you know being compared to this other individual the first mrs de winter who does have a name so it definitely sets those two apart in a lot of the aspects whether subconsciously, consciously or whatever. So I do agree. There is a little bit of repetitiveness as far as like the, the courting of between the two of them. And I'm not sure how well all of

that is executed in general. It's almost like, I don't know, it's a sequence that you almost feel like today when you get like a montage, right? You just get, you just get like the, the real quick version, or you would get something that's much more. Clever and romantic and like you're buying into all of the the different things and we don't get either of those here So it's like half like a montage and half like we're sort of like learning about them But a little bit on the execution there was was not the greatest

for me I just like the the dynamic that they were shown between these three individuals as they kind of navigated that and I thought it was a clever way to introduce us to those three and then of course we transition into them moving into his mansion the Mandalay and introduced to all of the different people that work there whether it be the housekeeper the I don't know what all of their titles are because some of them are Doing different things, but there's maids. There's butlers. There's housekeepers

There's somebody that apparently takes care of the finances or something They all have different roles and then obviously introduced to the fact that there was a former Mrs. DeWinter and that's gonna play a crucial part in the middle section of this film obviously It's gonna play a crucial part in the whole film, but in the middle part, we're really navigating this water of the two Mrs. DeWinters and this new one trying to come to terms with it, trying to become comfortable in this estate and things of that nature. So you said you liked that part of the film. And

I shouldn't say I disliked the middle. I think there's a lot of clever stuff that happens in the middle and a lot of very important stuff. I just felt like sometimes the pacing in the middle section was a little like stop and start. But what were some of the things you liked the most about this kind of middle section as she gets introduced to this estate? I just thought Joan Fontaine, who I think you could argue maybe gives a performance that's very much of the time for a lot of it, especially in that first act where you have that love story. And it's very much like, you know, fairy tale. They meet each

other and they're in love and it's, you know, melodramatic. And there are some of those moments, but I feel like in the second act, that's where she gets her. ability to opportunity I should say to give some more subdued and nuanced performance beats like just seeing her because being in that house alone and Just her reaction to everything just there's you could see her becoming overwhelmed with like the weld she's kind of thrown into and this like ultimate competition she's playing

against in the back -and -forth with her and Mrs. Danvers who like Tudors Anderson to me makes this movie I get it she like I know you talked about one of the best villains list we did I you know if I were you to do that list I would have ranked her much higher of all the Hitchcock films we've done thus far. I think to me even like looking at psycho I think she is my favorite villain out of all of it and largely because of the performance of Judith Anderson She just has this bleakness this coldness to her that

you know, the one scene where she's like showing like just the Delicacy of the the garment and the mind game. She's playing I just I found fascinating like in very much Doesn't almost even seem of that time in a way, right? The way that she's approaching the character and I that's what I liked about that second act was there back and forth, but then like you get those moments where this is the winter kind of takes charge of it where She, you know, she gets to the point where

she has a breaking point and moves through it but then that's when the third act kicks in and the Well near I shouldn't say that's what they're like she kind of that final piece is played with her Putting on that costume and things like that. Um, so I like that back and forth and seeing just like, you know, I felt for her because of just, you know, she's always going to play second fiddle and which is why I think I ended up liking the third act more when we get the twist and I don't think we can spoil this movie. It's been

out forever, but if you have not seen it, uh, where in fact it wasn't that Maxim loved Rebecca is that he hated her and I get the So like, feeling like I knew where this was going or had an idea of what was happening, it just recontextualized everything that happened beforehand. And I really liked that. I just thought that was kind of, you know, I wasn't, I guess I wasn't expecting a twist because I didn't, I don't hear many people talk about this being a twist and maybe it's not necessarily like a, you know, M Night Shyamalan

type of twist, but it it completely changes kind of the direction of what was happening and the relationship and even the impact it has on Joan Fontaine's character and if anything you could it's kind of odd that she is so just nonchalant about the fact that her husband may be murdered or at least committed manslaughter to her previous to her his previous wife but and i also kind of get it because she hated she was becoming to hate rebecca so much that i think she Relief

me it kind of made it all feel okay, but that's why I like like it I just liked how those acts connected and the importance it was to the growth of that character So that's why I worked for me. Yeah. No, I agree And I think a lot of the things that you're mentioning did work for me as well I don't want to try to like downplay what I said in the beginning I probably was a little bit too harsh from in the way I categorized it I just thought that there was a couple times where there was a little bit of that same type of repetitiveness that we got with like when their first meeting or maybe just a few slow

moments or something like that. But I agree like the introduction of Mrs. Danvers like completely changes this film. And you could argue that like from a plot standpoint, you don't necessarily need her as far as like it doesn't advance any of the main plot lines, right? Like all the other stuff can still happen whether she's there or not. Which is crazy because she adds so much though in the actual like whether she's important or not to to like some of the Superficial elements

of the plot. She's so important to all of the other things that go into this and like I agree like she Has a presence about her like just immediately like as soon as she's on screen Whether it's how it was shot whether it's the performance. There's just like a cold Calculating presence of her like it to me the only thing that I can connect this to and I know it's a much different character but from Old like Hollywood is the Wicked Witch of the West Like in Wizard of Oz

and she has a lot Helping her on that side because she's got the whole Which look right? Like she's got all that going for it. Mrs Danvers is pulling that off with none of the makeup with none of the costuming but still that same presence of like when she's on screen you're like, oh like Something's gonna happen here and I think that's part of what there's a couple things that really helped that twist number one, it's almost set up like where we're basically going down a path to an ultimate Like showdown between these two

individuals, right? Yeah, like the new mrs. De Winters and mrs. Danvers and we get some of that along the way but it like it feels like that's where the movie's going right like we're gonna keep hinting at the fact that she doesn't like her and that she's you know, doesn't like that she's taken the old Mrs. Rebecca spot, things of that nature. And it seems like it's going to be keep going down that road and culminate with something like where those two specific, they hint at it like at that window scene where you're contemplating with yourself whether she's actually going to like toss her out the window

right there. That scene was diabolical. She's like, yeah, just do it. The way she was playing that because like before that she was, you know, Had a little bit of a light touch, but then she went all -in like trying to get you to jump up Like this lady didn't do anything to you. It's right so mean. Well cuz that person's much more at first is much more passive, right? It's much more. Yeah You could interpret it one way or you could interpret it that way. So you're trying to like put yourself in John Fontaine's shoes

and like how you would take that and You can see yourself debating like oh she She's just uncomfortable with, you know, they're a new person here. And there's, you know, that's, that comes with a human nature, right? A new person in charge or a new person in there is going to do things different. You're not used to that. You're used to the, whatever your habits and routines were before. So you're kind of like finding yourself excusing a lot of what she's doing at the beginning. And then it just keeps getting like worse and worse. And then that obviously that sequence you're like, well, there's no gray. There's no gray area anymore. Like this, this lady. wants

her to kill herself. So I think that's one twist is that we don't go down that road a hundred percent. We kind of do in different ways, but that's not where the movie is kind of culminating. I know the last sequence or the last scene would say yes it is, but obviously there's a whole nother sequence with the court or police and like... the Jack fable character and all that other stuff, which is kind of like the main culmination, right? And so it's going to completely different

direction. And the other thing I think that really keeps you from guessing where this is going is you're never going to guess that this, that max despises Rebecca because of how much of Rebecca's stuff is still here. Right? Like he still has all of, like not only does she have like a room that has all of this You know her bed area and all those embroidered things and her clothing and stuff like that But then we find out, you know, you you have this whole other like cabin

that's full of her stuff as well and it's like You wouldn't that doesn't correlate to somebody that you know can't stand somebody you would think Gets rid of her and gets rid of all of her stuff immediately because he doesn't want anything to remind him of her so like that really kind of throws you off to when when you find out that he he actually doesn't love her because it's like all the signs are is that he not only Loved her but that he's not over it Based on everything we see in this house everything we see in this cabin and things like that So it's it's very clever the way they kind of completely

are throwing you into different directions before you see what the real Kind of substance is behind their relationship, which they kind of keep Hidden for a good chunk of the film. Well, you think it's good You think it's you think it's like pain you think it's like right agony, but it's really guilt I guess maybe not even guilt the more fear or anger which is it you know, he got angry because of but Not it wasn't because of

the way or the how you assumed it was, you know since he lost the one he loved and yeah, I thought it played with that really well, which is why I think like even like rewatching this would be interesting because it Would make scenes read so much differently knowing what you know once the movie ends, right? and then obviously we get into this sequence with the Jack fable character who is implying that Max Killed Rebecca Rebecca would never commit suicide after they find her

body Which is not the body that he originally claimed, you know identified as hers so we have a two different body situation her body is still in the boat at the bottom of the Water and you know, he's saying that it's not a suicide that he killed her which is kind of true And then he's going about this whole thing where he's trying to which is just a clever sequence where he's gonna Jump in the car. I guess when the courts out for lunch while they're eating a picnic inside the car, which I've never thought of doing but I guess that's one I guess you do it during road trips. It just is it's an interesting setup

They're like, yeah, they brought us lunch and we're gonna have picnic in this car real quick before the court continues And he jumps in there and obviously is blackmailing them. And you don't expect Max to just immediately go straight to the officials and be like, Hey, this guy's trying to blackmail me right now, which I thought was fantastic. And I'm like, Oh, how is this going to work out? And then of course, you know, he shares the note. They're going to, uh, there was a doctor involved, a potential pregnancy. They're going to drive to the doctor to figure all that out. And that does not go how this Jack character thinks it's going to go. What was your

take kind of on this whole like. twist and turn like fast pace conclusion of his Trial so to speak or the trial of trying to figure out like what happened to Rebecca First like it has to be like the worst police officer ever who's like, oh, I guess I have to bring you along like no you don't you don't Like that's not how that works But whatever it makes for a better story again looking into it. Like I thought the way it was gonna play out was that that one guy who

that older gentleman that was acting strange that it was going to be played on him like there was going to be a thing where they have to like have him take the fall for what he did so i wasn't expecting as it as as many different twists and turns also weird that this also delves into incest and no one seemed to question it like no like that much like it was like why are they like They're not they're just gonna go with it like they you know He doesn't say it like but he heavily

hints at what they were doing but I was just waiting for someone to react to be like Wait, what are you cousins? And nope that we're all gonna be okay with that. We're so okay. I guess you are her favorite cousin weird And then when the scene breaks out and we learned that there was another body there. I thought it was going to be that Rebecca was like cheating on him. That was where I was going. Oh, there were so many else that She was actually cheating on him

and that's not where it went I it does play out pretty quickly. Like I did like how he went directly to to the I don't know if it was a judge or what role basically saying like hey I could do this and how it played out and the resolution of it I think was pretty satisfying in the sense of Knowing that in the in the end Rebecca really ended up winning because She was going to die

and clearly baited baited him into doing it beforehand just to win their statistic game, but right making Making here such a kind of really fascinating figure even though we don't actually ever see Rebecca in any meaningful way outside of some photos But it did it did go rather quickly. You know, you mentioned the pacing piece I think clearly they knew where they wanted to go and then it's like, okay, let's let's get there I'm guessing in the novel. It's probably maybe prolonged a bit more, but I was okay with it I was okay

just get move it along, you know get to what you need to get to Maybe tied things up a little bit And it is all kind of Dependent upon happenstance as well, which I didn't have a problem with because I think it led to a better story but uh, but yeah, it I think I could see having issues with the way it went down, but I I found the end end result worth Made it worth it. Yeah, I actually quite enjoyed that that whole segment because

I think my favorite part is we're led to believe that I mean, the setup here is that this Jack character is right. Like in our minds at that point, he's right. Like he's right. Max did kill Rebecca. It wasn't a suicide. We know that as the audience and this guy's onto it. And it's like that suspense of. How are you going to try to prove this? But in reality, he's right. So he should. So it all sets that kind of up where you're like, well, how are you going to get out of this? Because he's on to you. He knows what

happened. That is what happened. And like. we're expecting different things to happen as opposed to, you know, especially when that doctor reveals what she was there for as far as, you know, the terminal illness and all of that type of stuff. Like that's completely out of the blue. Like you're not expecting that. Um, and, and that whole doctor sequence is kind of clever because they started with, I didn't see anybody by that name. So we have to go through that part. Cause it's like, We think we think this jack guy is gonna have them like hook line and sinker basically

and then the first piece of information we get from the doctor is I never treated somebody named Rebecca and So we have to figure out that she was under it, you know, mrs Danvers name and then we're like Well now you're still gonna get screwed because now they have the right person and then we find out it's you know, completely different diagnosis so like it was just clever the way they did that because in from the audience standpoint they gave us enough to for us to be like well he's right and This max guy's gonna be screwed And then I also think what I really liked about that whole sequence from beginning

to end is it really gave Laurence Olivier a chance to kind of strut his stuff a little bit. I felt like for different times in the movie that he was a little underwhelming. Maybe not at the very beginning when we're introduced to him, but there's this like back and forth where he's... About her and not about her and very cryptic about this Rebecca not and like all this other stuff so there was like some points in the middle which I get why but like he doesn't really get

to like just come out and and Do everything that he needs to do from an acting standpoint? It's like it's a very subdued performance and kind of a very hem hall like in and out of this like how much are you really into? the second Mrs. DeWinter Yeah, we believe it. Can we not believe it and But then when we get to this last sequence, he's really just like he's not Cary Grant in North by Northwest necessarily, but he is having fun with. Playing off of this Jack Fable character

and kind of going through this different route, which I did appreciate because up to that point, I was like, I was expecting more out of this famous actor that I've always heard of. Yeah, it hit a tough role because he had, like you said, he. I guess I can understand like. Well for the second half he is not there for a lot of it right, but I Don't think he ever came off as super charming But I think that's also purposeful because of considering everything like he always had a bit of There was always something like

darker underneath and it all made sense and I think like you said in that final act it all kind of came out and then everything kind of starts to make even more sense regarding some of the choices early on so I I do think he gets outshined by You know, oh you want Fontaine and Judith Anderson, but I think he plays the part he needs to Yeah, and and that does obviously lead us to a point where as an audience, especially an audience in 2025 We're knowing immediately when he sends her back to like the the house that that's like a bad idea Yeah, and especially

then when you see Jack call Mrs Danvers to tell her how things went and that you know the real story behind Rebecca and then obviously there's a race by Max and his I still don't know what that guy's role is but his right -hand man at the at the mansion to go back and then obviously they see the the mansion on fire and we get our final sequence where we See that the second mrs. DeWinter is gonna survive and then we get to see mrs. Danvers in the what was it the West

Wing? I don't know if that's where yeah the West Room As the as the house comes down. So what did you think about that final conclusion? I really like I felt the the final act was really strong and as I mentioned previously You know the spectacle was something that this film didn't have a lot of but we got it with that Mass of fire and it does you know is it is that cleansing that was needed of you know for this For them all to move on and then obviously mrs. Danvers who couldn't do that having to deal with the

ultimate fate Of what happened so I thought it all kind of came together really nicely in the end Yeah, I agree. I think that was a clever way to end it Some definitely some harrowing last sequences that we see mrs. Danvers in which is interesting because you don't always see like the villain so to speak of You know classic stories like that take themselves out I guess but that's definitely what happens like she starts that fire herself and Is the only one that's gonna go down in it? So I thought that was interesting

too before we kind of get into some final thoughts. Was there anything? Hitchcockian that we saw along the way. I know we talked about it's a little bit different with the way it's telling the story and kind of the the pacing and some of that type of stuff. There really isn't a. Mother figure, although I will say that from what I read, Mrs Danvers in the book is a mother figure to Max or more of a mother figure that is basically very protective of him. Doesn't

want any, you know, doesn't want to share. Her affection of him with you know, any of the the girls or the ladies that he's interested in things like that So the kind of interesting that for once I know it was still early on but Hitchcock had a story that did have a mother figure and he changes it or maybe the screenwriter changes it but Alfred Hitchcock obviously puts his okay on it stamp of approval that removes the mother from the story altogether, which I thought was interesting, but it was there Any thoughts on that or anything else that you picked up that

we've talked about along the way that we you noticed in this one? Well, we mentioned how like a lot of his films his cox films there are There is like hints at homosexuality like obviously with rope and some others were certain characters And you mentioned that you brought up with mrs. Danvers how she is more of a mother figure like I like in this I don't know if i'm just because of the history we've talked about in the past, but like I maybe wonder about what the relationship was between mrs. Hanzer's and Rebecca because it felt like there was an infatuation there that

was You know, she loved her and I think it was more so than just a friendly love That's what I got from it. I don't know if that was intentional, but it seemed I got the same theme that way Yeah, yeah, I got the same thing. I even read a Somebody had put out like a I don't know if it's a research paper or like an article or a review or something Where they kind of outlined all the different? Moments that you that you could like support that with you know, especially like when she still has her You know her Dress like her. What

do you I'm totally blanking? What do you call that? I can Yeah when she has her nightgown and things like that and the way she's handling it and how Careful she is with it the fact that she knows exactly where it is how she presents it to the new mrs. Dan de winter Like, I think there's multiple times in here where you can see that there was a infatuation slash obsession slash some type of relationship or a desire for a relationship between those two characters. I agree. Yeah. And you mentioned Hollywood Blondes,

of course, like Joan Fontaine. And usually we've had the situation where someone was wrongfully accused. And this was kind of the flip of that, where someone was Did it and wasn't accused because people misunderstood it. I missed the hitchcock, uh cameo I completely missed it. Uh, but I guess it's near the end when you mentioned the picnic scene around that time I completely mentioned hitchcock cameo and this was the first time I didn't see it without having to go back And you know seeing where it was and and in catching him this time Uh, but I'm not sure for the record.

Yeah Yeah, anything else that you had that regarding? No, I didn't I didn't see necessarily anything like I think that there is definitely that play on The audience knowing what happened or thinking they know what happened and whether it's somebody that's falsely accused or somebody that's rightfully accused It's getting away with it. Like that seems to be a there's different takes on that for sure And no, I think I think most of what we talked about was was pretty on the nose I did read that there was some potential problems

with the with the movie back in this time period, because in 1940, there was some different standards and things of that nature, as far as the fact that we have somebody that murders somebody and that's going to get away with it and is portrayed as a hero, I think caused a few sideways reactions from people that were involved in whether they're approving it or whether they're just reviewing it in the time period or trying to censor it after the fact. I think there was a little bit of that going on as well. Overall, I mean, I

think you can connect enough dots to Hitchcock that is still you can still tell it's a Hitchcock film, even though it has a different feel than a lot of the other ones we've talked about. I do think it's interesting, like I said in the beginning, though, like going back now and trying to connect it to some of the earlier work. And I definitely think there is that attention or focus on some of the side characters and making them enjoyable characters that you almost want to know more about. Like not that I necessarily want to know more about the employer of Mrs.

Edith Van Hopper, but it's still it's still somebody that you're like, you know, she obviously disappears for the rest of the movie and you're like Well, what's going on with her and then the estate manager? I think his name is crawly like he has an interesting you're wondering what else is there because there's a few interesting interactions between him and Joan Fontaine's character as well, you know, they have that the beach hermit like you're wondering what what's going on with him like Well, how did he get here and stuff like that? So there's enough of that where I feel like that's very reminiscent of some of

the earlier Hitchcock films we watched as well But how do you think it fit in kind of in the timeline and it when you connect it to like in the realm of 39 steps notorious and kind of that time period I Think if it's well, like I mentioned, I do feel like the acting is of that times, especially You know, Mrs. Fontaine, where it can be a bit, you know, they're playing for the back of the room. You know, movies are still a relatively new phenomenon. I mean, guess what? They're probably around for 20, 30 years at this point, which isn't a huge amount of time when you think about

it. So where you compare it to some of the, like when we did some of the films that in the sixties and things like that, where I think have a different approach. And when you think of like what Notorious, I don't think even in that, I feel like the relationship in there had a bit more chemistry. I guess chemistry would be the right word. But it does feel very much of its time, but also dealing with the taboo in ways that are, like you mentioned, having

a character that is morally questionable be the hero or not have to feel like They need to have some Moral lesson, you know where they kind of get away with everything which is not not that I'll comment like they're these are some broken bad people and it doesn't necessarily paint them in that light, which so totally like so there are aspects that very very much of that time but also just the approach it takes with some of the narrative choices are They're pretty Advanced

for that era No, I agree as well as far as some accolades for the film It's got a 98 % approval rating and rotten tomatoes AFI and a couple that are different lists. One of them was a hundred years a hundred thrills It came in at number 80 as a film and then also it's a hundred years a hundred heroes and villains. Mrs Danvers was the number 31 villain as far as Academy Awards. I got nominated for 11 including Outstanding production, best director, best actor, best actress, best supporting actress, screenplay, art direction, cinematography, film editing, original score,

and special effects. It won for cinematography and it won for outstanding production. Alfred Hitchcock loses one more time for best director, this time John Ford, and the Grapes of Wrath took it over him. But obviously it has, I don't know if this is the most Academy Awards of any of his films, but it's got to be up there towards the top. Any final thoughts on any of that or just final thoughts on the film in general? It wasn't the best picture too, right? Like I remember I think that's outstanding production at that

time period was a picture. So yeah, it beat out the Grapes of Wrath foreign correspondence. What other ones? The Philadelphia story. So yeah, it did win the quote unquote best picture. Just called it something different back then. It's a good year for movies then, huh? But yeah, I really like this. It was high on my list of what we've seen thus far And I was really glad I watched it I'm glad we continued it because I think this is a huge important staple in his filmography

like I mentioned I I it might be a random comparison, but I do feel like it it does fit as that movie that uh It shows that he has multiple speeds as the director which I guess is much more you could say much more because he's made like a thousand movies, but Of that high quality like if you think all he can do is really good horror films or thrillers Rebecca is the answer to that claim Yeah, absolutely. I agree It's gonna be interesting for me to try to find where this one ranks amongst all the other ones the more films we're covering the harder It's getting to slot those into the spots. Yeah as we for

sure We'll do a final episode after we go through all the films with some of our own awards and things of that nature I've been I did a little work this last week to try to make sure I'm not gonna get lost in the number of films recovering. So I had to go back through before I forgot anything and be like, oh yeah, I like this character, I like that actress, whatever the case may be. So for our next film, it's gonna be interesting. We're gonna be going to 1941's Suspicion, which does in fact star Joan Fontaine, who wins an Academy Award for Best Actress for the film.

We're gonna also see her play with Cary Grant. So this is one of the, I believe, the two Cary Grant films we haven't seen yet of his appearances in Hitchcock films. And we're also going to get Leo G. Carroll, who was in this one, and Strangers on a Train. He's going to show up again in Suspicion, I don't know, assuming a smaller role, but we will see that as well. So any thoughts or experience with the film Suspicion from 1941, just a year after Rebecca? Have not no no no experience whatsoever

like similar that I know nothing about it have never seen it so Going in completely blind again this time Yeah, so I'm interested to see that it got nominated for three Academy Awards including best picture best actress and best score And has a 97 % on Rotten Tomatoes, so it feels like it should be another Interesting watch that I'm sure will be good on different levels. So I'm interested to see Cary Grant again And now that I've seen Joan Fontaine, I'm interested to see those two interact with each other have no experience on the film. So I'm Intrigued on where we go

next So if you want to give us any comments or feedback on our plot through the Alfred Hitchcock filmography You can do that in a number of different ways You can search out on social media the cinema geeks and leave us comments directly for the show Or you can go to geekcastradio .com and comment on any of the web posts as far as the site goes. You can also get in touch with us directly. Dan, you can search out at the Comic Concierge and just about every social media platform that exists, or at least more than I'm on. I'm

still trying to learn how some of those work. And you can reach me on some of the main ones at Optimus Solo. Dan, anything else that you want to let anybody know about before we close this one out? No, I nothing I wasn't mentioned we're recording this by the time it's out free comic book days already happened So but if you missed it, maybe go to your local comic book store and I have some leftover free comics if you wanted to check that out Awesome. Awesome. So that does it for this episode tune in next time for another chance to listen to more of the cinema geeks

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Western Retrospective: The Outlaw Josey Wales

    Nov 16, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Halloween Special: Rocky Horror Picture Show

    Oct 31, 202641 minAudio

    Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Halloween Spotlight: The Exorcist

    Oct 29, 202642 minAudio

    Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Halloween Spotlight: Carrie (1976)

    Oct 26, 202639 minAudio

    Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Halloween Spotlight: Texas Chainsaw Massacre

    Oct 24, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...

    Credit the people on this episode