Today on Episode 244, the guys continue their Western Retrospective with another episode in which they discuss an original and a remake. This time they tackle the Magnificent Seven. Will the Classic ensemble led by Yul Brynner or the modern day version led by Denzel Washington lead the way to victory for the guys? Tune in to find out. Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on X and Blue Sky! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark! #UNLEASHTHECINEMAGEEKINYOU!!! #CinemaGeeks #Westerns #WesterRetrospective #MagnificentSeven #OriginalvsRemake
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hi, this is John Delancey and you are listening to the Geekcast Radio Network. Hello and welcome to episode 244 of the Cinema Geeks. I'm one of your Cinema Geeks Optimist Solo and joining me as usual is the Comic Concierge. Hello, Dan. Hello. And I'm back. We are back for more Western
action. Yeah, we're continuing our Western retrospective. This is the final chapter in our original or it's hard saying original because they're all like also based off of other things, but our original versus remake section. So you've already heard us talk about 310 to Yuma and True Grit, both the originals and the remakes. And today we're doing one more just like that covering. The two magnificent seven films, one of them
obviously came out in 1960 and the other one came out in 2016. So almost 60 years between the two. And then after we finish this one out, we'll start a new chapter in our Western retrospective where we go into some overlooked Westerns. We'll talk more about that towards the end before we get the facts and get into the nitty gritty of. Today's movies, though, Dan, remind everybody what your previous experience was with both of the Magnificent Seven films. Oh, I have seen
the original, but it's been about a decade or so. So like I remembered very little of it. I have seen Seven Samurai as well, just to, you know, give that comparison. But I had not seen the remake. So it was one of the interesting ones where I've seen the original, but not the remake. But how about yourself? I went into this one just like I did with the 310 to Yuma and True Grit, having not seen any of the originals of these three films, but seeing all of the modern versions. And I remember on first watch of all
of them being more in the positive camp than negative. I remember liking all of them to varying degrees. And that's what was interesting about going back and watching them with the originals and seeing how they either... grew or fell or how they kind of held up over time also it's been a long time since i've seen i've seen magnificent seven more than true grit and 310 to yuma i will i know that for a fact this will be my fourth
watch of the 2016 magnificent seven third or fourth it's at least third but i think it's probably the fourth um so i don't know why but i've seen that one more than the the remakes of true grit and 310 to yuma not saying that's a good sign or bad sign just have more experience with it i guess so um i'll be interested to hear kind of we've had different takes on the other ones right like i think we both felt with 310 to yuma that the original was easily the better of the two maybe i don't know easily might be too strong
a word, but we both definitely favor the original one. Yeah, definitively appreciated the original one. I think True Grit, I think we were both more positive on the remake. Yeah, I liked both, but definitely thought the original was better. Yeah, I don't think maybe the gap between the two was as big for us on True Grit as it was maybe for 310 to Yuma, but I don't know. I'm interested to see kind of how that... which one magnificent seven will mirror more and kind of
hearing your thoughts i definitely have some so before we get into that let's let dan lay the groundwork for the 1960 version and kind of get us all prepared for that and then we will come back with our thoughts on that one whoa double remake as we end our remake first the original section of our western retrospective with a double remake, as we start with 1960's Magnificent Seven, which of course is a remake of Seven Samurai, relocating the story from feudal Japan to the American frontier in Mexico. The
film opens on a poor Mexican farming village that is repeatedly terrorized by an infamous bandit and his gang. They ride in each harvest season, steal some food and supplies, and then head out. Desperate and unable to defend themselves, some villagers travel north to the United States, looking for gunslingers willing to help. protect their town. They eventually recruit seven very different gunmen. Oh, that's where they get the name. The calm and experienced Chris Adams, the cocky drifter Vin Tanner, professional fighter Bernardo O 'Reilly, trouble gunslinger Britt,
hothead youth Chico, con artist Harry Luck, and the knife -throwing Lee, each drawn by either money, pride, boredom, or just a search for meaning. You know, that old trick. The seven arrive in the village and begin training the frightened farmers to defend themselves as well. At first, the villagers are intimidated by the gunfighters, and it's hard to blame them with all that denim. But the men slowly gain their trust while preparing barricades and teaching them how to shoot and fight. Several of the gunmen form emotional connections with the villagers, especially Chico, who falls
in love with a local woman and becomes increasingly tied to the community. The film spends much of its middle section exploring the contrast between the wandering, lonely lives of the gunfighters and the humble but meaningful lives of ordinary people. Though at first, the initially succeed in driving the bandits away, the villagers eventually panic and betray the gunmen out of fear, allowing them to retake the town. After being expelled, most of the seven realize they couldn't simply just leave and let them survive on their own, but they choose to return anyway, knowing that
they'll probably die. They are magnificent after all. And many don't survive the heroic battle, but eventually... they do drive the bandits away. In the end, only Chris, Van, and Chico survive. Chico decides to remain in the village with the women he loves, while Chris and Van ride away, recognizing that the farmers, not the gunfighters, are the true victors because they have homes, family, and a future. The movie closes on a bittersweet note about the fading age of the gunfighter. and the cost of violence. This was a bit of a
breakout party for a number of these actors, including Steve McQueen, Charles Bronson, James Corbyn, and Robert Vaughn, who of course moved on to do much bigger things and become much bigger stars. Unlike A Few Dollars More, which of course we also covered in our Western Restrospective, check out an episode on that in your favorite podcast feed, this adaptation of Curacao's work did not lead to a lawsuit. In fact, Kurosawa was a big fan, so much so that he awarded director John Sturgis a ceremonial samurai sword as a
gift. Man. That ought to have been great. Not that this didn't create some bad blood, but just between the actors. The scene McQueen reportedly caused some ill will with Joel Brenner. McQueen would supposedly do small distracting things in the background during Brenner's close -ups, shaking shotgun shells, moving strangely, adjusting his hat, anything to draw the attention of the audience toward him. Brenner eventually became so furious and reportedly had scenes refrained so that McQueen would not dominate the shot.
Their rivalry became a thing of Hollywood legend. The production itself was a physically difficult one because much of it was filmed and under harsh conditions in rural Mexico. The cast dealt with intense heat, dust, long shooting days. Director John Sturgis was known for being calm and controlled despite managing such a large ensemble cast and with several strong personalities. Although, you know, of course, as mentioned, he did have some issues. He was kind of like the Phil Jackson of Hollywood directors when it came to this film. It also helped considering the pressure many
felt knowing they were adapting such a respected film like Seven Samurai. That carried over a bit with its initial reception as well, as it received a mixed reaction from critics. Many thought the film was entertaining, but inferior to Seven Samurai. Others, however, praised the movie's pacing, charisma, and memorable cast. It's quite interesting. is that the movie actually performed much better internationally at first than it did with the US. It was especially popular in Europe and Japan. Japanese audiences were reportedly fascinated by seeing an American Western
reinterpret a beloved samurai story. Now, it was successful in the US enough to earn three sequels, Return of the Seven, Guns of the Magnificent Seven, and lastly, The Magnificent Seven. Ride. Yul Brynner was the only person to return for the sequel. Steve McQueen's character did return, but was played by Robert Fuller instead of McQueen. Perhaps it was that old rivalry. No word yet if any of them will be returning for Avengers Doomsday later this year. But where do Kevin and I stand? Are we with the critics who feel
like it is a pale comparison to Seven Samurai? Or do we feel like it adapts it well for the Western genre? back to us to discuss all right starting with this 1960 version dan i will start with you because you had some previous experience i know you said it had been like almost a decade since you had seen this film and now you're watching it after watching uh a dozen or so it seems like westerns you know in in the last little bit here so i don't know if that had an effect on your viewing or even just going through the two other
modern versus the original ones but uh what was your take after all of this kind of table setting with your rewatch of the 1960 original magnificent seven and going back to this i didn't remember much i remember obviously the general framework the one scene that that stuck out to me was the like one of the earliest action sequences where they're on you know trying to transport the the casket but i didn't even remember like the the reasoning behind it just remember they had to like go through the town for some reason so it was basically like going in fresh because i what
i thought happened and beyond just the general framework was completely different than what actually happened but honestly this has or in the sense one like i mentioned i do love seven samurai and it's seven samurai is one of those stories that has been adapted in so many different ways like actually we're watching a bug's life a few months ago and that obviously takes a lot from it we we watched an episode of the mandalorian of the first season that takes elements of it there's a you know it's one of those stories
that has been retold in a lot of different ways but at the time certainly probably a little bit more fresh especially this isn't the first time we've gotten a kurosawa film that was adapted for western although this one came before the uh you know, the previous one that we went over, but this, what it has going for me, for me is that it has one of my favorite type of storylines that exist in any type of medium, whether it be a comic book heist. And that's the getting the band together story. And it's just something
about it. It's just, I just, I just, I just love it. It's like, it's like, you know, it's why I love fantasy football. It's like drafting your team, what they're kind of doing here. You know, you go around and you're, You get to get a little glimpse of what each person brings to the table. You got the guy with the knife. You got the guy who's clearly muscle. You got the guy who's more of the wild card, things like that. So that element, like it was just, it naturally appealed to me. So that was part of it. But also what surprised me about this was I thought it had a little bit
more to say than I remembered. Like I didn't realize or didn't remember. that it does talk about things about what does real bravery look like what does masculinity look like and actually takes some real time to dissect that like you get a great conversation with Charles Bronson's character and some of the kids from the village regarding them being disappointed in their parents thinking that they're cowards but him talking about what real bravery looks like you know taking responsibility being willing to ask for help
and things you know it seems almost some of the dialogue at times almost felt it was ahead of its time now it doesn't completely you know bring that home by the end that we can discuss but i thought at least had a little bit extra kind of like watching the original 310 to yuma i was really impressed with some of the themes and that and i thought this you know it's taking some of that from seven samurai as well but i know going into it like people were saying oh it it's a it's a less in -depth version of that
story and perhaps it is but still I think there is something there it doesn't abandon it completely and lastly you just have a really solid cast so I think it was highly entertaining I think managing this group of individuals I think it did as best as it could like does every character have an amazing arc from beginning to end not necessarily but I do think as a unit they come together and you can clearly see each like role each person is playing so i had a good time with it i thought it was really solid and i thought
you know it was looking at all the westerns we've done thus far i don't know where it would rank within it but i think it certainly holds up really well and has a little bit extra beyond just you know the the western shootouts and its ability to kind of take the story and that was so well known and just twist it for the western genre but what was your Being coming into this the first time, having experience with the original or the remake, and I know this is probably the one that has the most changes that we'll get
to, but what was your thoughts? How did you enjoy or not enjoy the original Magnificent Seven? See, I thought you were going to give us another wrestling analogy. I thought you were going to say like... like it was like picking members of a faction or something like creating you know what i had that opportunity and i completely wasted it i should have yeah it was like the enforcer and the the you know like the technical wrestler and the the guy on the mic like i thought we were gonna get that but um so i this is interesting
for me because i feel like this film perhaps more than any other film that we've watched so far in this entire retrospective represents one of the main reasons why I wanted to do this retrospective because not only did I know that I had a big blind spot for a lot of classic westerns but I also felt that it wasn't just going to appease
or scratch that itch But that it also was going to be able to help me see different actors that I also have blind spots for. And I feel like this movie does all of it, right? It gives me one of the classic Westerns that I've not seen. But it also exposes me to a whole cast of characters that I wasn't alive during this time period. And for some reason, the... 1960s and 70s is
probably like my biggest blind spot out of any decades from film and so like i haven't seen a whole lot of films that these individuals have been in so it was a nice like kind of just all -encompassing like hey this is why we're doing this is because i wanted to see classics and i wanted to be exposed to like all of these different people that i feel like i got with this one i i do feel like i couldn't help but think about and you already brought it up but the 310 to yuma comparison right like i know we're not comparing
the the original and the modern one quite yet and we'll get to that but what i will say that this 1961 does in a different way than what the original 310 to yuma does is really takes its time and lets you sit with some of these characters granted this one is a little bit larger of a cast we're dealing with a tiny bit bigger of a setting the 310 to Yuma we're spending a whole
lot of time like in a hotel room but there is some other stuff you know the journey to and from and a couple things and this one we're really just you know involving a town which is still fairly like secluded and things of that nature so it's slightly different but I feel like you still get those slow moments you still get to sit with these characters dissect them a little bit get to know them get to know what makes them tick to different degrees like obviously they spend a little bit more time with a handful of characters than they do with some of the other ones but i still feel like you got a sense of most of the characters in this like i didn't
feel like there was ones where it was just like he's just along for the ride i guess and we don't really know why and he's just part of the band so i thought it did a good job of balancing the fact that we have not only these seven people in this group But we also have the villagers, right? And we need to understand their background and their plot, you know, the kind of their place in the story and their lot in life. We also have to deal with the villain in this film and kind
of his gang of folks and stuff like that. And I think that's a large task, right? Like when you have not only seven quote unquote heroes, but then you have the villains and then you have the villagers and you have all of this stuff like. competing against each other for time and dialogue and moments like i feel like it is impressive when you can pull that off and still give the audience a feel for the fact that they felt like they got to know all of those individuals at least enough to suffice not just like we're just
skipping along and you just get like these real superficial aspects of them or they're all just playing stereotypes and you just kind of have to connect the dots on your own so i really appreciated that aspect of it that it was able to take its time i felt like it handled violence in a decent way uh as far as almost like a necessary evil and it didn't um just hit you over the head with the violence it didn't do it in a glorified way
and things of that nature like i felt like you are you understood that these guys weren't like bloodthirsty people that just enjoyed killing people or did it for sport you got to feel for like they're doing this because they feel like there is no other option in a way um for the most part i mean they all have different motivations for being involved but i also thought it was fun to see like the recruiting of the individuals and i know you have to kind of do that somewhat quick in these films right like you can't spend half the runtime recruiting the folks you have
to do it in the first act basically but i felt like this one did a decent job of introducing us to each of those characters and kind of how they came to be what their relationship was with whatever they're calling ewell brenner's character what was his name it didn't feel like it fit chris which is such a basic name it's almost like i feel like like all right i mean chris i guess i i would never look at yule brenner and be like let's name his character chris yeah that would not it's never great when your character
name is far less interesting than your actual real name it's like it just right yeah um so i i was pleasantly not surprised but i i enjoyed myself like i anticipated that i would somewhat like it because I kind of know the gist of it, having seen the modern one, but I thought it delivered in ways that I didn't 100 % expect. So I came across fairly positive. Before we get too far into it, I'm just curious. You probably have a little bit more experience with these individuals, but obviously the kind of star,
main bill of stars of this film are Yul Brynner, Steve McQueen, Charles Bronson. and james coburn like i feel like those are like the biggest out of the seven that like just everybody kind of knows from name recognition and i'll tell you what my background was and i'm kind of curious what your background is with these actors in general so yul brenner i've only ever seen in king and the king and i like i've never seen him in anything else so like my only experience was the king and i um james coburn i didn't realize
i've seen a bunch of his films But now I feel like I need to go back and watch these films and, like, pick them out. I've seen him in Maverick. I've seen him in Sister Act 2. I've seen him in Eraser. I've seen him in Payback. In Charade. Yeah, in Charade, obviously, we just did, you know, as far as the Cary Grant films. And he also was the voice of Lute and Plunder in the Captain Planet cartoon, the main villain. So I have a variety of experience with James Coburn. Not as much from this time period outside of
charade and this. Charles Bronson we just saw in Once Upon a Time in the West, but otherwise that's my only exposure to his films. And Steve McQueen, this is the only film I've ever seen him in. So I've never seen Steve McQueen in anything else. I know he's been in other stuff. So his whole filmography is kind of a blind spot for me. What was your experience with all of these actors as far as the main seven group coming into this? So Steve McQueen is probably the one I have the most experience with. He, of course,
like The Great Escape I have seen, which also does have Charles Bronson in it as well. But McQueen is easily the biggest star there and probably another big one. Bullet is another one of his that I have seen as well. The Towering Inferno, which was like. It has a lot of people in it. If you're just looking for a movie with a lot of stars of that era, there's Paul Newman as well, and McQueen, who kind of headlined that, but Faye Dunaway is in that. Fred Astaire is kind of crazy. O .J. Simpson, and also Robert
Vaughn is in that as well. So that does have a good casting there. So he's the person I probably have the most with. Yul Brynner, I actually haven't seen The King and I, but the only thing else that I've seen him with... I know of I mean Death Race which was like his last movie and the Westworld as well where he plays the gunslinger and that like he's the you know the robot I guess or whatever you want to call it that turns evil so that might have been now I saw this before that but he he
doesn't really say much in that you know he's kind of he's just this evil black hat you know just doing so I don't I have much experience with him outside of that. Charles Bronson, also I've seen a good amount of his stuff as well. Like I mentioned, Magnificent Seven, Great Escape, Once Upon a Time, and the last, Death Wish. I have seen one or two of those, perhaps. And if you've seen one Death Wish, you kind of have seen them all. And then some other small, Hard
Times is another Bronson film where he kind of plays like a bare -knuckle. knuckle boxer that i have seen too so okay but yeah i'm a big steve mcqueen fan i during i had a like um back in the dvd days i like had a steve mcqueen pack and had like okay on this clown affair uh the great escape and a few others that i've seen but i mcqueen is like the you know argue like i didn't say the first action star but maybe the first action star outside of like westerns
because obviously he did this but he'd go on and kind of almost he could say like john wayne and then mcqueen was like around that as well like he was like the you know ultra cool ultra you know him and paul newman kind of uh i thought i don't think he is nearly the actor paul newman is but he's you know he's got But it certainly helped make him a star. It was the first thing
that really helped him break out as well. I think this is also, for Coburn, I think this is his third overall film role. I don't know what kind of presence he had in the two that came before this, but this is one of his first major film roles as well. And I believe he got the job simply because he was friends with, I think, Robert Vaughn, because he wasn't originally cast, but the person that was couldn't do it. And this whole film was also interesting. with the background of it, which I didn't cover just the facts. Cause I was, I just learned this recently, but this
was being made like right before there was expected to be like an actor strike. So they were trying to get it kind of done and cast really quickly, which is a big reason why like he, he got, you know, they're just like, you know, someone, all right, well, he seems good enough, which is crazy. Cause I think, you know, he certainly fits that role really well. He, he's kind of got that silent assassin down. And we saw that with charade as well. yeah so we got those those headlining four along with like you said robert vaughn and then we get brad dexter and horse buckholtz is forming
our magnificent seven in this film how do you think they all work together playing off of each other was did one stand out more than the other were you finding yourself more uh kind of in like wanting to see more of any of them specifically or how did you feel like they fit in these roles The thing was, like, you got, each had a very distinct character right away. Like, Robert Vaughn's character, like, he just, you know, he's all prim and proper. He's got, like, he's, like, dressed in the nines. You learned a lot about him just, like, almost immediately. Same thing
with, like, Charles Bronson. Like, he could have been... i don't know almost like the cover of a romance novel with this like denim shirt he's like chopping wood like it like it's with with ease uh i really was impressed with bronson in this i think he had like he was almost like the soul of the movie if there's one person i felt like i don't know if it's the performance but the character it's kind of what the character has to be but horace buckle as you know chico being that like you know he's a young kid who's just trying to improve a point uh but he does
come on a little strong. I know that. So I guess he's supposed to be annoying, but he was really riding that line a little bit. And like I said, I like James Corbin. Brad Dexter, to me, his character was the one that just didn't really stand out in any meaningful way. I did like the chemistry between Brenner and McQueen, even though in real life they kind of were not big fans of each other. I felt at least the movie, it felt like they, you know. they had a good connection and maybe that rivalry would actually just made
it better on screen. I don't know. Uh, so yeah, that they, they did a good job of hiding that. Cause I thought they had great chemistry together. How about you? Anyone setting up for you or good or bad? I mean, I really liked Ewell Brenner and Steve McQueen. I thought like they, they made a perfect kind of partnership in the movie as far as the main lead. And, and almost like the, not really like the number two, cause there weren't necessarily like, 100 subordinate but like just that kind of character that could play off of him he was you know obviously mcqueen's
character and this is cooler than the other side of the pillow as the kids say or maybe that's what old people say um what's what it was scott's on you know maybe it's right but i thought those two uh were well i thought james coburn was an interesting character like i didn't always know what to make of it but i was intrigued by it enough to be like you know what's going on with this guy i think you're right charles bronson brings a lot of uh heart to the film i know you said soul i would probably say even more so heart for me like he just yeah kind of really brought that i feel like you know robert vaughn and brad
dexter are who they are and they're necessary for you know the movie you can't have all of them being like this super charismatic uh boisterous you know magnetic people um or they would take away from each other i do think like you like horse buckles was probably overacting a tad in quite a few scenes especially in the first half he gets a little bit better throughout the rest of the film, but he comes on strong in the beginning. That's for sure. It's like one of those sour candies, right? Like you don't know what to do
with it at first, but so yeah, I enjoyed that. Obviously we get the return of Eli Wallach here as our villain to go from the good, the bad and the ugly is here with his, with his gang of bandits, I guess you would call them. What did you feel of, of him as the main villain? So that I completely forgot. I hadn't seen the good and the bad and the ugly before, but going back to that, I'm like, whoa, Tuco's the villain? I completely didn't know that. With the good and the bad and the ugly, he was villain -lite, I guess. He certainly
had some, but he hammed it up here in a good way. I felt like he was very hateable. He really played that role well, but I don't think it ever became too over the top. The fact that He understood the restraint like he there was a lot of like he maybe wasn't the best decision maker when he's like Well, just let him go, you know, it's like okay. It seems like not the smartest move in the world but you know I thought he was charismatic and He gave you a good person to want to see take down to make a wrestling analogy. He was
the good heel He played it well, and I thought I was a fan of his performance. How about yourself? Um, I liked it. He's like a hard character for her hard actor for me to pin down because then Then you view a picture of him, which is obviously a picture of him much older when you go to Wikipedia or IMDb or whatever. I'm always trying to place that picture I'm seeing with this character, with the character we saw in The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly. I'm like, none of these people are the same people. I don't buy it. He definitely
comes across as a completely different character in The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly. I had to do a double take when I was like, I know this is Eli Wallach, but... i'm not seeing the connection between these two characters um as far as that goes but i thought he did it well like i think there's a maybe like one minor nitpick or negative about the film is i do think some of the plot it's a little clunky i don't know if clunky is the right word it gets a little bit there's like a little bit of a back and forth here when they
go to basically get information or see what they can see about you know his gang and of bandits and whatnot obviously eli wallach's character and his bandits you know take over the town in the meantime through some like you know collusion with some of the locals and then we have the magnificent seven go back they get caught then they get put on horses and get their guns taken away and get sent away and then they come back like i i don't know if all of that like a hundred percent worked for me as far as like the back
and forth of that it didn't necessarily like take anything away it was just something i noticed kind of as i was watching that was like what why are we what are we doing like we're we're why are you like kind of what you said like why are you letting them go and like i don't know there was there was a little bit of back and forth there that i wasn't a hundred percent sold on but other than that i do feel like even though i know this film sometimes gets listed as far as like a con goes as far as like some of the pacing and maybe being a bit slower i didn't feel any i didn't feel that like i didn't i didn't
think it was too slow i didn't really have any problems with the pacing there was that little bit of clunkiness i felt like in that kind of getting towards our our final act but but other than that i thought it moved at the pace i needed and i sometimes prefer if you're going to take it a little bit slower and give us some time with like i think they did a good job of connecting with the community yeah especially through I believe, especially through Charles Bronson's character with the kids and things of that nature. We also obviously have a, I guess, a love interest angle with, of course, Bill Colts and the one
female from the town. So, but I thought you had, you know, different situations where you get the old, like the elder on the outskirts of town. Like that guy is fantastic. I needed him in, in more, I think I needed him for sure in the modern one, but, um, or just in more movies in general, he's like, you know, come to the town where we've, where we've got it all protected. He's like, no, I'm good. I'll sit out here. And he had some wise words at the end too. Like, I think like really gave you the theme of the movie in a way where it's like, you know, the
villagers are the ones that will come out on the top of this, you know, gunslingers are just like tumbleweeds. They'll come and go. Um, I thought that was a great, you know, kind of. buttoning up of things towards the end. So how did you feel like some of the supporting cast and the setting and kind of the pacing went for you? I guess I have an issue with the pacing. I could see what you're saying regarding the structure of like they're in the town and then the townspeople like come scared and turn on them and whatnot. I thought what that allowed,
it gave you an opportunity to see the true character of them because ultimately they had to make the decision of like, going back and you know basically facing death rather than it's they had to make a choice there rather than it just being an element of like defending the town so there was one there was that benefit it was like i don't know if it was the one thing i'd say it hurt a bit was like i meant we mentioned i mentioned earlier that they had that great conversation about how
a lot of the villagers were the true heroes because they were making this decision and then they go back on it. But then again, they... Did you get the impression that all of the villagers made that decision? I got the impression that it was just the one guy that kind of backstabbed everybody. Yeah, that was my impression too. It wasn't necessarily... I don't know. That he kind of made the choice. I mean, it's not explained super well, but I thought it was kind of alluded to that it was the one guy. I guess... Where I find it a little bit, like, from a structure
point, it's maybe a little structure and maybe a little bit of just, like, decision making. Like, I feel like multiple people were making decisions that maybe is reality because people make bad decisions. But it was like, there's seven of you. Like, maybe half of you go on the little scouting thing. Yeah. And half of you protect the town still and make sure that doesn't happen. And then on the flip side, like we talked about, like, you're just going to send them. on the horses and just assume they're not coming
back. Give them their guns back afterward. It's like, thank you. That takes a lot of trust and just like they're going to keep each other's word. And then nobody really gave them him their word that that was going to be what happened. So I'm sorry. I didn't mean to interrupt you. No, you're fine. No. So, yeah, I do agree. Like the clunkiness, it's not super clear again regarding like, is it that it was maybe the one guy, but then did everyone. also not fight against it per se. But then you do get the opportunity for them to have that redemption piece with the villagers
as they're, again, fighting and making that decision. But again, it's like one of the things it says earlier is that, you know, they made the decision not to fight because they have responsibility. So then is it kind of going against that by then trying to have its cake and eat it too? I don't know. I think it at least got to the point where, I mean, perhaps they just had no choice because of the situation. They were in surprise. That's that's where I struggle with it in the sense of I don't know if it does or not. Like I haven't come up to that decision, but I never thought it was more like it's only two hour and eight,
two hours and eight minutes. And I don't know if it's because we did the spaghetti Westerns, which were going up to nearly three hours that, you know, this felt, you know, light. But I was never bored. And like I did like like you mentioned it taking its time and getting an opportunity for them to have a true connection with. this town and the town also like seeing their hesitation you know where they're they're not trusting at first like you know they don't know if like these guys just another evil like you know are we are
we gonna replace one with another so they're hiding the women in most in many like the older children but then that dissipating so i thought that progression was kind of nice to get like it didn't feel like this could have been very exploitive and super racist to be honest we've gotten that in many of the western west perspectives and perhaps maybe some of it doesn't age well but i don't feel like mexican the the town itself was ever the butt of the joke or they were ever like looked down upon like they like like you
said with the elder like they if anything it's they were more celebrated so i thought that was a benefit of it i think it worked too like i think they handled the fact i think the setting works for this film with it being like this poor Mexican farming village in a way. And I think the other thing that they do a decent job of is with Eli Wallach's character. And I have it pulled up so I keep forgetting what the character's names are. I know it started with a C. Calvera.
Calvera. With his character, I thought they did a decent job of not making him this mustache -twirling, dick -dastardly villain. I thought it was believable. uh somewhat authentic that you know this guy's just a leader of these bandits and he's coming in and he's doing a lot of the things we've seen in some of these other western films right like he's taking advantage of people who are scared of him but he's not like you could understand the the villagers fear and you could
understand why they like they don't want to do this but they're also scared of the repercussions but i i thought they balanced the line well of him also being just a normal obviously a bad guy but like he's believable in that like this person could exist and this is not like a hollywoodized villain and so i appreciated kind of the dynamic there where yeah he does have some power because there's nobody that stood up to him but that's really the only thing that has kept him in power is fear and intimidation but not i don't know
he he does some things right I'm not saying he's a bad guy still, but he's not as ruthless and over -the -top terrible as you could have made him, if that makes sense. Speaking of Spaghetti Westerns, we saw some of the villains in there where they're just shooting people left and right with little disregard. I think he... he understands that he needs the villagers as well so he's not he's going to take food but he's also going to
leave them enough because he needs them to be able to still survive to bring him more food so right and not that he makes good points but he's like well you know i can't we can't farm we're not farmers so what other choice do we have he has some good lines too about it you know regarding them being sheep which we see repeated in the next movie that comes back up as well so yeah I agree like he clearly is an evil dude but he at least the decision making
or like his reasoning like you buy it it doesn't feel like it is playing it up to the point where he's just super super evil just because and doing things like just shooting people with a little disregard. He has purpose behind his actions, and you never wonder why anyone would ever follow him, considering how little care he has for the people around him. So I thought it was a good, balanced performance overall. Yeah, I agree 100%.
My last question on this one for you is, I know it's a product of its time, and it came out in 1960. Do you think it's problematic that all of our seven gunslingers are white men? Or did that not bother you at all? Not for this time period, certainly. I think it... Well, I mean, Charles Bronson, I don't know his ethnicity, to be honest with you. I believe he... I do think he has... I don't know what his full ethnicity is. In the movie, he was supposed to be part
Mexican. I don't know if that's actually the case or not. But I didn't necessarily have an issue with it, because I think... certainly at the time when it comes like in the time that this is portraying obviously we did there were black cowboys that that's not a question but i do think it it makes sense in the sense of like that would be uh there's still racial divide you know like at at this period i don't know right i guess i mean more of like uh i don't
i guess i'm thinking more of like and i don't i'm not saying i thought this i'm just I know I could see this being a critique more of like the white savior, I guess is, is kind of, yeah, I think in a way, I think that certainly is a valid critique because it kind of, you know, it is the ultimate white savior story. I think it saves itself a little bit, you know, being the fact that it's based upon, it's taking the story from seven samurai. So it's like, it has that, that basic, that base of it. And in the fact that at the, in the end, It's almost as
much of a critique of these men who come and save the day and showing that their lifestyle certainly makes them heroes in some way, but also short -lived lives. But I do think the white savior critique is valid. It's there. It is a bunch of white people literally coming to save the town. But I think at least it tries to add something to it in the sense of that act is not without. repercussions nor is it like it's not
saying that they're superior it doesn't glorify it necessarily it goes out of its way to show how they're not in some way so I think that makes it especially for this era a little bit more advanced than your typical story Yeah, I can see that too. I probably agree with that. So I think it's tough to get too much more into the 1960 version without kind of doing some comparing and contrasting. So are you ready to move on to the 2016 version? Yeah, let's go to the 2016 version, which is I think the most recent film and also makes me sad when you realize 2016 was
10 years ago. But let's get to that version. All right, let's let Dan lay the groundwork for the facts about the 2016 version. We'll come back with our thoughts. Seven Samurai ain't got nothing on this. Eh, well, maybe it does, as we turn our attention to the 2016 version of The Magnificent Seven. This time around, we open on a frontier mining town where a ruthless industrialist Bartholomew Bogue, and with a name like that, what else could he be, terrorizes the townspeople
in order to seize control of their land and mining rights. During a tense church meeting, Bogue murders several citizens, including Matthew Cullen, and burns the church to the ground. As a warning. Matthew's widow, Emma Cullen, refuses to surrender the town and travels west, looking for men capable of standing up to Bogue's private army. She eventually hires a bounty hunter and warrant officer, Sam Chisholm, who takes a personal interest in the mission after hearing Bogue's name. Chisholm begins assembling a team. Of dangerous but highly
skilled fighters, the cocky gambler Josh Faraday, a traumatized Civil War sniper in Goodnight Roche, a knife expert in Billy Rocks, an outlaw in Vasquez, a mountain man Jack Holm, and a Comanche warrior, Red Harvest. They arrive in the town and quickly drive out Bogue's hired gunman in a chaotic street battle that gives the frightened townspeople hope. for the first time. Knowing Vogue will return with a much larger force, the group spends days training the citizens to fight, building barricades, laying traps, and fortifying the
town. Along the way, The movie spends time showing the personalities and fears of each gunfighter. Roche struggles with severe trauma from the Civil War and loses confidence in his shooting ability, while Faraday hides his growing attachment to the town behind humor and arrogance. Chisholm gradually emerges as a moral center of the group, though hints suggest that he is a deep personal vendetta. against bogue bogue eventually rides back into town with a heavily armed army leading an enormous final battle that dominates the last
section of the film explosive sniper fire gatling guns and street to street combat turn rose creek into a war zone one by one members of the seven sacrificed themselves protecting the townspeople eventually bogue flees into the ruined church where chisholm confronts him alone It is revealed that Bogue previously destroyed Chisholm's family and nearly lynched him years earlier, making the mission deeply personal. Chisholm overpowers Bogue, but before Bogue can draw a hidden gun, Emma shoots and kills him herself, finally avenging
her husband and reclaiming the town. In the aftermath, the surviving townspeople bury the fallen gunfighters as heroes, while a few surviving members of the Seven ride away. as legends denzel's character appears to have some historical inspiration specifically bass reeves the first black deputy u .s marshal west of the mississippi known for his tracking skills and bringing thousands of outlaws to justice This is quite the complicated production history and spent years in development, but it started to come together when director Antoine Fuqua
came on board and brought Denzel with him, who of course he worked with on Training Day. Denzel agreed to do this as long as they were going to do a gritty, real -life western that was more old -school, and that was certainly seen in production, where they built an enormous set in Louisiana rather than relying heavily on digital sets. The climactic battle caused massive destruction to that set. Many of the buildings were literally blown up during filming. They purposely used a lot of practical effects, dust, smoke, real
squibs, to give it that old school feel. The Gatling gun sequence near the end involved extensive prosthetics and careful stunt coordination, making it one of the most technical difficult parts of the movie. The cast also went through extensive weapons and horseback training, so they can do some of their stunts as well. It paid off for the most part. Critically, the film received mixed but positive reviews. It has a 64 % on Rotten Tomatoes currently, and the positive focused mostly on the action as well as the quality and chemistry of the performances, while the negatives
focused on the lack of depth of the story. It was somewhat successful on the box office as well. It made $162 million worldwide. It did open at number one in North America its opening weekend, making $34 .7 million, which is... pretty hefty for a Western of this time period and did far better than other flops like the Lone Wanger. But where do Kevin and I stand? Do we prefer the original or extra crispy? Back to us to discuss.
All right. So the 2016 version of the Magnificent Seven, obviously, like I said, it's almost 60 years after that 1960 version. So we're going to. Obviously have complete new cast, complete new makeups of the characters and things of that nature. Some differences in our settings and our motivations and things of that nature. So we're definitely going to get a different feel here. Before you give your thoughts, Dan, to me, another reason why this set of films reminds
me of 310 to Yuma is I feel like... both of them had a modern version that was a little bit more interested in sitting with the characters taking its time not necessarily being slow but but having a concerted pace as far as like how we're going to do things and both 310 to human magnificence 7 with the modern version go a little hollywood on us as far as that goes so what was your take on the the modern version starring mr denzel
washington Yeah, so it's actually almost where I was going to go with it, because I do think a lot of it is very similar in how this is executed. I think of all the remakes we've done so far, these two have the biggest differences in both storyline, like the plot, they change a lot, and also just the style and execution of it is very different. And, you know, Antoine Fuqua as a director, you know, is one that I'm very hit or miss with. Like, I do really like Training Day, but he's also done a lot of stuff that I
am not the biggest fan of that doesn't really click with me. And he's even done like the Equalizer films, which I have liked. I think those are good for what they are. And like certainly the partnership with him and Denzel has gone really well. And this cast is pretty incredible. You know, Denzel Washington being the lead. Chris Pratt, which I know a lot of people hate Chris Pratt for different reasons. I still like the guy. I'm in Parks and Rec for life, so I still see Andy. Ethan Hawke, who I'm a huge fan of.
Vincent D 'Onofrio, who just shows up randomly in a lot of different places. But overall, really saw it. Even people who have come back and become bigger stars, it was interesting seeing Luke Grimes being the sheepish young Luke Grimes. yeah it's being like the sheepish like uh person from the town like oh he doesn't know what he's doing because i'm just i have seen yellowstone and enjoy it and so it's like he's the opposite he's like kind of the exact opposite of this
character so kind of intriguing there it's almost like a yellowstone prequel but i do and similar to 310 to yuma it does take a lot of out the window a bit and i think it one thing i didn't mention with the original is like i do think you get a good sense of why those individuals are magnificent you understand who they are their motivations it goes out of its way and to show that they are generally good people uh making
in like because they they make a point of like how much they're going to get paid and how little that is compared to what they're used to but there is they see the the benefit of the responsibility of this opportunity and what what it actually means with this i never feel like i get a sense of why anyone's doing much of anything outside of chisholm who we learn more about by the end and i do think too ultimately, or the original
wasn't. And I'm not against changing things. I think it makes sense. But I think a lot of the changes make it less interesting. And the cast here, they feel, to make a wrestling comparison, why not? It just popped into my head. It was like, you know, when you get the original NWO, all come together and make sense and then you try to repeat that magic with a lot of like try it again with the new black and white or when
they try to do it like in wwe with like poker t was part of it i'm going way too in depth with that comparison but it's just trying to build that same idea but with individuals that people know so and recognize but the characters behind it aren't necessarily as there or at least they're not as connected so i still had a lot of general fun with it though i do think the action is well done i especially that that final sequence it's
nice seeing like old school like practical effects being used in this era and even if the performances aren't as or I should say the characters aren't as dynamic I do think these actors are having fun with it and doing the best they can with the material that they're given so generally I enjoyed it but I'm far more mixed on this probably out of maybe like the only movie I was less I had a lower feeling on was Django at this point
so it's you know I would still it's fine it's enjoyable I just think pairing it to the original it doesn't have the same type of execution but how about yourself I know you saw this before you said it was your fourth time so you had it was it even better I don't know and again perhaps on rewatches I'll enjoy it more but I'm curious now that you've seen the original where does your opinion stand I think one of the things that had it one of the reasons why I was attracted
to this film originally and why It was one that I watched a little bit more often than most. I'm not a big movie rewatcher. Really, the only reason I would rewatch a film is to watch it with somebody who hasn't seen it. Typically, most of the time, I'm not going to rewatch a film just for my own purposes. I'm going to watch it with somebody because I want to show it to them. I want to see their reactions. I find some joy in that or whatever to kind of... expose
them to new things or just kind of see how they like things and if it's the same or not but i'm not like someone who's just going to go back and watch things on my own so i think some of those rewatches maybe were with other folks but one thing that it has going for it that that is the type of movie that i would re -watch in some respects is i do enjoy not only the assembly of the team even though i think it was done better in the original But I do enjoy these team concepts like you talked about where it's like we're creating our own Avengers team or we're creating our own wrestling faction or whatever comparison you
want to make. So that works for me in most of these situations. I do really, and this is probably coming back from just my love of MacGyver and watching that TV series so much as a child, but I do enjoy, like a big part of MacGyver is he gets out of things without weapons, right? So he is very big on, on booby traps and different ways that he can use his environment and things to like increase his odds against sometimes what
seems like an insurmountable situation or foe or whatever the case may be so i do like the aspect of this one that they are coming up with like all the different booby traps right they're coming up with all the different ways that they're going to try to shrink down the number deficit and they're not going to resort to jango style we're just going to pull out like a machine gun out of a paper bag and just surprise everybody with it and just you know like it doesn't work like it works a little bit better when i know
they've had some time and i know they've like thought some of this stuff out and they've they've set some of this stuff up now i get like when you do that sometimes you risk the the critique of you know would all of those things have worked just like they do obviously there's some movie magic and the fact that you know they come across all the things and they work the way they do and this that and the other but um so so those types of things i find enjoyable and i do think it's shot well enough and the action is decent enough and the actors are good enough that it
has some fun in rewatch ability or like kind of just like going along for the ride now watching it in conjunction with the other films that we've watched and you know even coming specifically off of this 1961 there are definitely it's different when you're comparing it to other things right like if you're just watching it in a vacuum for what it is and you're just having fun with it I think you can maybe come away with a different take but having watched it right after the 1961 now I'm in this like mode of thinking about the
two in conjunction with each other and it does come down quite a few pegs when you do that So I think number one, I feel like the setting of the poor Mexican farming village and kind of that community and how they interact with the Magnificent Seven works a lot better than this mining town and how they interact with the Magnificent Seven. So I liked that kind of the setting. I liked just the general bandits led by Eli Wallach's
character versus like this. what everybody seems to do in this time period which is you know just the greedy ruthless industrialist or like capitalist or whatever like to me that becomes the the man with the twirling mustache right like it's it's just not as yes that exists i'm not saying court you know the corporate world and and some of the capitalism and doesn't doesn't present some of you know some super greedy people that you know could even become president and things of that nature but um but you but you have Unless
it's done really well, sometimes that can just lose its character because it becomes the stereotype instead of the character, I guess. So that doesn't work as well for me. In the first one, you have this idea of growing fond of the community and interacting and interlacing with them. This never came across as more than, to me at least, than truly hired hands or mercenaries. like yeah it's a revenge story and it's hired hands and i don't
know how much i mean i know you get some interaction with luke grimes character and and uh emma um what's what's her name's i'm gonna say the wrong name um emma cullen in this film like you get some of that obviously but i don't feel like there was quite as earned as as far as the connection to the community and and like you know the first one i mentioned you're really killing out of necessity right like you're doing it because you don't feel like you have any other odds you're not getting enjoyment out of it but you're doing what needs to be done in this given the situation
this one they're comparing kill count like it's killing for sport at this point and in this one and i guess some of those moments are funny and played for laughs and adds to like the camaraderie between the seven but it shades the action a little bit for me in comparison So I think I still get some guilty pleasure out of it. I could watch Vincent D 'Onofrio. I could watch a whole movie based on his character in this film. Some people may think it's over the top and whatever.
I'm here for it. Sign me up. I will watch that. The way he does his inflections in his voice and just his whole characterization of that. give me more of that like i love that i love d 'onofrio and and this is one of my favorite roles of his so like i you get some of that right like you get to watch denzel you get to see some of chris pratt's you know comedic stuff you get to see even hawk bring a little drama to it you get vincent d 'onofrio just being batshit crazy um i don't know really what do you get that much out of young hung lee and manuel garcia rufo
and martin sensmeyer you know the the the three people they brought in i guess to be diverse in this um and to be a little bit more modern i don't know a little bit here and there but i don't know if the ensemble works as well like they work individually but i don't know if they work as well as a group as what we got in the original one so i find it interesting you know watching this indirect comparison would make me come way down on this one compared to if i'm just if i just watched like the modern 310 to
yuma and this and like a couple other modern westerns and that was my only background of like talking about the films i don't think it falls down as much but it does for sure after watching the 1961 for me yeah and it's interesting because like you know you mentioned brung hun lee who like i think he also was brought in for like international audiences for sure because he's you know a pretty big star internationally And still kind of is he was in the kpop team in hunters last year, you know in a few other films I saw
the devil a movie I'm a big fan of but like I think I did like the inner you say like I can watch a whole movie with the novice character, which is the same I could even watch a movie with Ethan Hawke and Brungle these character because I feel like there's you think in a sense there's history there and Like I mentioned like I do think the actors are bringing a lot to the characters even if the script doesn't like even you know you see hawk going through what's clearly like ptsd even chris pratt i thought brought a lot of humor uh i think i do like his character
i had a hard time figuring out like what was driving him like what he obviously was there because he wanted to get his horse in a way so i don't know but that ultimately like you know the little magic element of his character give Yeah, and they all had a little bit different attribute or gimmick along with who they were to let them stand out a little bit. And I do think seeing them come together was a fun experience.
Vincent D 'Onofrio certainly comes on screen and makes his presence known immediately. But again, I don't know. You mentioned how they're just basically mercenaries, which is... I don't know why he's deciding to do all this, like why he's risking his life going as far as he is. So that's, you know, it does feel like almost like a script that was meant to be something else. They're like, oh, you know what? This isn't going to work. We can rework this enough and make it a Magnificent Seven remake and get it made. And I don't know if that was what happened
or not, but it feels like that. It feels something that feels tacked on. But at least, like I said, the performance is there. And one thing I will say, Give credit to for Antoine Poucault. Like even when he is good when it comes, like I do like the way he puts action together in films. Like I mentioned, like the Equalizer films. I think he did the Olympus Has Fallen movies. And there's a whole bunch of those films I don't like. But I do feel like he does bring that old school action that has a sense of physicality
to it. The use of practical effects. I do feel like I'm looking at real things happening. And even though this is 10 years old at that time, it's still, it's refreshing. So I do want to give it credit for that. And I think it shot legitimately well. I was a little surprised by the fact that, you know, this is the guy that helped get Denzel his second Oscar with Training Day. Denzel legitimately in Icon. How did you, what was your overall thought of his performance?
I'm curious because in the way, and what he did in this film. i feel like i'm a hard person to judge denzel like he is so far up the list of like my favorite actors of all time that i i don't know if i can watch one of his roles like unbiased like without bias like i i just feel like he's always his style of line delivery just has me like it doesn't matter he could be like literally it's one of those you know obviously people say this all the time but it's like one of those or he could be like reading the phone book and somehow i would be like all on the edge
of my seat like what's he gonna say next Probably just the next name that comes in the alphabet, but I would be there for it. So I did find myself not being as head over heels about it this time as I had been in previous watches. I don't know what caused that exactly. I still was a fan. But there was some parts of me where I was like, I remember liking his character more than I am as I'm watching it this time. And I couldn't
quite put my finger on it exactly. Maybe I was just distracted by trying to watch other things and kind of comparing and contrasting what I had just seen. Or his killer sideburns. That too. That too. For sure. And I don't know. He gets some cool lines and he gets some cool moments and things like that. But I kind of go back to what you were talking about with... why some of the folks are doing it and why some of the actions happen and i feel like too often in this film the answer is probably because we needed to get to from here to from a to b like yeah
we why did that person do that well because we had to move to this next sequence or we had to get to here like versus like an actual character motivation which i think is where this film kind of suffers the most i think you're right though from like a a shot perspective and like the visuals and all of that stuff and the action choreography and things of that nature and the practical effects. I think that's all where it's, where it's strong. What did you feel about Denzel? I would never say like, I don't think he's ever given a bad performance. It's like, you know, like, you know,
it's like a bat. It's like Michael Jordan, like a bad night for him is scoring 20 points and 10 rebounds. But I guess I was hoping to get that like standout scene. Maybe it's because I'm thinking a training day and like he has so many great standout moments in that and But I also wonder if that was purposeful because he's like, you know, there's a lot of people in this movie I want to give them the opportunity to shine too I could see that and he was playing more the facilitator in some ways and so that could also be it like It's not he's magnetic
when he's on screen, of course, and he does a lot of really solid action But yeah, that was just the thing. I was looking for that scene. Is there a scene from this movie that would be on his sizzle reel that you would show? Probably not. I think the closest you get is in the beginning, which is something that you're looking for more throughout. But I think when he comes out of the bar, if I'm remembering right, he comes out of the bar, the first scene with the note in his pocket or whatever. I think that's probably the height of his... stuff in this film which
is weird because you know you usually don't get it like right out of the gate so but i do think like as far as the sizzle reel i don't know if you get you might show a visual of him being in the group of seven walking towards the camera but i don't know if you're you're pinpointing a line or a scene for a sizzle reel it certainly looks great stylish and also too like we mentioned with the original you had that great chemistry even if it was manufactured between brenner and Queen, and clearly they were trying to go for something similar here with Denzel and Chris
Pratt, but it was never there. They never felt like they had any like that bond or anything like that. You didn't buy the history like you did with Yul Brynner. You bought that Yul Brynner had history with multiple characters or multiple individuals that he was bringing along for this trip. Here you get that slightly with Ethan Hawke, but other than that, like i don't know if i ever bought like the the big history between denzel
and any of them like it was more like i heard of this guy like let's go get him which yeah that that that's the sense i got too like i do think you mentioned like ethan off certainly one where you get a bit of that and he probably has the biggest arc here i did feel like they like they would his return though i was i was hoping like his return would have to something more, but, you know. I guess it doesn't in the original one either, though, if you're kind of... No, it doesn't. So it's true. If anything, he fares much better. But you mentioned Peter Sarsgaard,
who's an actor I generally like, but you're right, he's going full ham. There's no subtlety in anything he does. And I get it. You have to make him seem... insane because why else would he come to this town in the first place and yeah it just loses the believability that I got with Eli Wallach's character though like Eli Wallach's came across way more authentic to me like yeah I don't know it becomes almost like honestly this has more
in common with the Avengers than it does those type of films than it does like the magnificent seven and the way like it forms the team it like the the the villain and executed and but uh the other thing too was like the the mining piece and like how that was incorporated that seemed like strange like the i don't know there was it's just like almost from like from go like from peter sarsgaard first appearance where he's just like shooting down people and whatever burning
the church or whatever i don't know if that all happens at the beginning i'm probably getting confused but i just felt like no that doesn't yeah from go it's just like all of a sudden we're just like we don't even know the guy yet and we're already just like elevating him to like evil beyond evil where i felt like with eli wallace character like it was more subtly like slow not slowly necessarily but like it was like brought in and waves and like we're kind of understanding why he has these people intimidated more from a mental standpoint versus like this we're intimidated
by this guy because he's actually batshit insane and burning churches and just like shooting people left and right like i don't know like it just didn't work for me as much one of the you know biggest changes with this we brought it up with last one where we had the mexican mexican village and perhaps there was concern with you know avoiding the white savior story so that's okay let's change it makes sense But we get kind of two different places here. We have the mining location and then this town. What did you think of that change and how it impacted the film overall and just
how it was handled? That's one of the things, like I said, just from jump, I didn't like as much. I liked the authenticity of the farming village. I think it made it more believable that the folks didn't know how to shoot guns and didn't know how to protect themselves. It's easier to buy farmers that can't protect themselves than miners. Maybe that's a silly distinction, but I don't know. Miners are used to dealing with explosives and things of that nature. I know it's not a one -to -one comparison, but I don't
know. I just didn't quite enjoy it as much. I know there's the white savior part, but there was something about this being complete outsiders. and how they learn to interact and appreciate the mexican farming village and when it's this other group of just like diverse folks that we don't really get a background and then they're helping this mining town like there was something missing by changing that dichotomy it's helped
a little bit i guess by emma cullen's character in a way because i guess it does give us like this strong female agent like that's her own agent or whatever you want to however you want to phrase that and like I guess that adds, like, some element to this one that you're not getting in the 1961. But overall, I just felt like the setting of the first one did the movie more favors than the setting in the second one. Yeah, I think part of it, too, is, you know, with the farming village, you understood, like, why those individuals
have, like, they've been there for generations. You can't just leave. You know, you're a farmer. Like, it's not easy just to go someplace and start a farm. With a town like this, it's hard to understand why anyone would not just go. What does this town have? It's probably not that old. What role or professions do these individuals have? Some of them were, I guess, farmers, but not all of them. If they're hunters, they should
at least be a little bit more capable. I think the justification of why they would be as inept in the element of being able to defend themselves as well as why they are so beholden to this area it doesn't hold as much water compared to the original because the the if anything like i was gonna say because the first one the magnificent seven still come across as believable people
that aren't necessarily glorified or set up on this pedestal compared to the others it's just that they have a different background right like they're more familiar with guns they're a little bit better shot like they're a little bit more experienced with gunslinging and that type of thing but they're not like these avengers right like they're not the superheroes and in this one it's it's played differently where it's almost like we are glorifying each one of these guys
as like bigger than life in different aspects right like the one guy can you know like byung -hun lee's character with his knives and you know vincent d 'onofrio i guess with those you know like they each have their different thing that's like they're less coming across as just normal people that are just using their life skills to help these individuals out as avengers that are coming in to like so i felt like that made it a completely different dynamic in a way as far as like how that interaction goes Certainly. I think that's a good point. And you bring up
a good point regarding Hilly's Bennett character and what she does bring in. She does bring a different dynamic, but I think in a way, you have these two competing revenge stories, and I don't know if you needed that revenge element of Denzel's character. I get it. It seems like a shortcut of... before you keep going with that how do you feel of the tactic that directors do sometimes where they don't bring the motivation
for the character in until the final scene or the final line or the final shot like do you feel like at times that does a disservice to the performance throughout if we're not able to like understand that earlier on compared to like just at the end being like oh yeah and this was his motivation the whole time I think it's tricky because I think it's difficult when it's the main character, when it's in here. But I'll
be thinking back to the previous Western retrospective. We had Charles Bronson's character in Once Upon a Time in the West. We knew something was driving him, but we didn't know the complete history. And I thought that was very effective. So it's like, why did it work really well there and not here? I think we at least got glimpses of it in that other one. Like, we knew something was driving him. This one, I don't think there's enough breadcrumbs. You know he knows his name.
You know he has history with him. You know he... Clearly there's something there, because he knows him very well. But I think when the twist comes across as a sixth sense twist, it doesn't work as well for the motivation in this setting compared to something where it's like, you don't have to telegraph it, but I feel like you've got to give us a little bit more than what they did. Because otherwise, it's just like at the end, you're like, oh, well, let me completely rethink how I was viewing that character. But I've already gone through the experience, so I don't know.
And it's also because it's not like he set out originally to do this, right? He was brought into it. So the logic of this movie is that he has this history with this individual who also is controlling this town who then he ends up meeting with someone from that town. Very coincidental. Trying to get him. Yeah, so there's... I mean, coincidences happen in movies all the time, but I guess it's... It's almost like this revenge meant so much to you that you really just bothered
to get to it now just because this thing happened to happen. So the fact that it wasn't driving his decision -making from the beginning, it just became like, oh, well, I guess I can kill two birds with one stone. And then when it's revealed, I don't think it's revealed in a way that's all that memorable. really great things about Once Upon a Time in the West. It is revealed so effectively. Here, not as much. And also, because I don't think necessarily, like I said, you need it. It makes them, if anything, it makes them feel
less magnificent because it's a decision based purely on revenge. Well, it takes the noble aspect out of it to me. Yeah, so it hurts them in a way, which I will say I did like the fact that in the end, It wasn't him getting that revenge. It did circumvent those expectations. So I did like that piece. I did like the fact that it gave it to... Emma Cullen's character. Emma Cullen's character rather than him. So that was a good
choice in my opinion. But yeah, I just don't... I think that's the fundamental problem with it ultimately. With The Magnificent Seven is that it doesn't do enough to show why these individuals are magnificent. at the end of the day. How did you feel about the different booby traps and the different things? I know it works for me, but I'm a sucker for that. I'm the same way. Those things are great. The hidden compartments or the secret plan. Thinking of something similar.
The Last Samurai. We know we have to come up. We have to be creative. What the secret is. You get a little bit of the windmills. And the dynamite. It gives you just enough hints. Of something is planned. And it all comes together. I'm the same thing. You get a little of that in the original Star Wars. With the Ewoks. I was a fan. None of them were so outrageous. That it didn't. didn't buy it because like you know just trenches and
explosions so it wasn't like it like this elaborate mousetrap they had to hit in order for it to work so i thought it was it was believable enough and i bought it like i like i said like that that sequence like had that makes it worth watching it's just you know i did miss that in the original one having seen the modern one more i was looking for that for some sort of sequence where they had all the like the little secret things and yeah we never quite get that in the original
one where i was like oh they have a wall and a net that's that's about as far as they go so they try to teach them how to shoot that's about it yeah all right well anything else you have for this one or do we want to bring this section of the of the uh Western retrospective to a close. Yeah, I think we've talked about as much as we can about Magnificent Seven. I was a little bummed that I didn't like it quite as much as the modern one as I had in my mind previously, but like I said, it was a lot like 310 to Yuma for me, where once you watch it with the original one,
you do get to see the Hollywoodization of some of this stuff, I guess. I guess next time we'll have to... Yeah, watch Seven Samurai, and then the original Magnificent Seven, and then you won't like that one. The goal of the show is to make you less like the movie. Diminishing return for each movie. But no, I've enjoyed watching all of these, you know, the original with the modern one. I think that's something I've kind of wanted to do for a long time, so we got to knock three of them out. So I do appreciate that. Dan, why don't you give the listeners a tidbit
of what's to come here next in our Western retrospective as we kind of turn a new chapter. Yeah, Western retrospective is so much harder. Why did we name it that? I don't know. But yeah, so our next block are going to be our Overlook Western. So we did a lot of the most iconic Westerns of all time. Still some we haven't got to, but we also wanted to say like, okay, let's get to some that maybe aren't always on the top of everyone's list or the most popular. So that will be our
next section, our next three films. Hoping I pronounced this right. McCabe and Mrs. Miller by Robert Altman will be our next film that we'll go over next week. So that will be our first Overlook Western. And then we have Johnny Guitar. And then The Naked Spur would be rounding out this portion of our... Western retrospective of these three. And then we'll be finishing off with our revisionist Westerns at the end, which we'll go into later. But I'm really excited for
these next three because I have seen none of these. So I definitely overlooked them. But how about yourself? Any experience with any of these or specifically McCabe and Mrs. Miller? I think this will be the first time. Has there been a film where it was a blind spot for both of us? i'm trying to remember uh i think some of those you know the original ones good and the bad and the ugly yeah okay so yeah all three of these will be first time watches for me like not only have i not seen these i don't know anything about them and i think maybe at least one or two of them i had not even heard of before so i i don't
think yeah i'm similar to you with that uh i'd heard of mccabe and mrs miller i i don't think i'd heard of the naked spur before this Me either. Hopefully there's no naked Spurs at the game that I watch tomorrow. Or maybe there is. That means they won and they're celebrating. We'll start that next week as we get into our second to last section before we get into the final piece. If you've missed any of our previous episodes,
you can always go back and watch as we did cover some John Ford and John Wayne. collaborations we covered some spaghetti westerns so feel free to go back and listen to those and give us your feedback on what you thought on those films if you want to get in touch with either one of us you can search out dan on social media at the comic concierge you can search myself out at optimus solo or you can search out the show cinema geek or the cinema geek cast as well as check out our hosting website the geek cast radio network .com but that does it for this episode tune in
next time for another chance to listen to more of the cinematic
Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...
Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...
Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...
Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...
Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...