Today on Episode 146 of the Cinema Geeks …..we complete our Hayao Miyazaki Retrospective! We discuss our favorite moments, scenes, characters, and rank his movies from top to bottom. After that we discuss where Miyazaki ranks in the world of today’s directors. Also we announce what director will be covered in our next retrospective.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to Cinema Geeks as we complete our Hayao Miyazaki retrospective. Joining me today as always is Hard Candy Mandy. Hayao! Final Miyazaki. Optimus Sola. Hayao! I gotta do it too. It took 12 records. Right. And last but not least, Matt for Lucent. Oh man, I'm literally and figuratively phoning it in today guys Matt is super dedicated. He's
on vacation, but he is he is as he says he's on the phone So I think the audio should come out pretty well, but we'll see we'll see We do want to thank everyone for joining us today. And if you're joining us for the first time you have a lot of podcasts to catch up on because we Went and reviewed every single Hayao Miyazaki film from his very first film in order to his Currently his last movie and what we're gonna be doing today is kind of doing a wrap -up ranking
his films We have some favorite scenes and characters to kind of point out, but just to give you a lowdown of where we're coming from, where we're coming from before we started, give you an idea of where we started and when we can give you an idea of where we ended at the final minutes of today's record. So Amanda, can you just refresh everyone's mind? What was your experience with Hayao Miyazaki as a director and his films prior to doing this retrospective? I had only seen Kiki's Delivery Service, which I liked, I enjoyed,
but everything else I had a total blind spot for. Nice, nice. And Kevin, I don't think you watched one of his movies, if I'm not mistaken. No, every episode we did in this retrospective was a first time watch for me, which is one of the reasons why I had suggested Hayao Miyazaki as one of the options because it was going to give me an excuse to watch a whole bunch of films for the first time and finally catch up, I guess, with the rest of the world. So yeah, I was the newbie on the block. And man, I think you were probably the most experienced book because there's
only a few of his films that you were watching for the first time. Yeah, just a couple at the beginning and then one or two at the end. Otherwise, I'd seen them all a couple of times. And I'm someplace in the middle. I saw Princess Mananoke in Spirited Away. I think I saw the majority of his movies like Matt. I didn't see his first couple of films. I only saw the majority of them one time way back when we geared up for the top 108 animated movies countdown. So it was kind of fun to revisit some of those for a second
time and go back for the first time. So what we're going to be doing is we're going to be actually ranking All the films we watched in order but instead of doing one long continuous list We're going to be doing it in chunks and we're not going to go in great detail You know why because we reviewed every movie already so you can go back and hear our more complete thoughts on that specific episode Which i'll make sure to link to on the episode post at geekhousereator .com So Amanda, we'll start with you and we're starting obviously at the bottom and we'll work our way to the top So how do you rank the bottom third of Miyazaki's films? I I went off what
rankings what grade I gave it in the episode and I still feel the same I think about those rankings I feel pretty good with the number I gave them so I grouped my list here these chunks based on those numbers and also how I felt about it so maybe two movies had the same Number ranking but I felt a little bit strongly more strong on one end for one film versus another so I have
like a little bit of a split but the bottom here is Surprisingly, my bottom chunk is the biggest chunk of all my chunks What is it what is it I don't think we're ever going to be ready for it, but go right ahead. Ready for these chunkies? This jelly? I don't know what you're talking about. We're just talking about movies. All right. I'm going to walk away from that. Yeah, me too. That was gross. So my bottom third, the very bottom, I'm going to go from my worst up here
throughout. So Ponyo is my least favorite Miyazaki film. I gave it a six. And there are movies I ranked lower than that, but my feelings for this movie surpassed those ranks. If that makes sense, I don't even think that makes sense to me. But film -wise, I think this film wasn't as bad of a film as some of these others, but I didn't like it. So I did not like Ponyo. Next up from
the bottom, Nausicaä, Valley of the Wind, I gave that a 5. Then Castle of Cagliostro, That got a 4 .5. Castle in the Sky comes next with a 5. And then Porco Rosso also got a 5. Interesting. I was not expecting a couple of those. Did you not hear me shit all over Vanyo? I must have missed the shitting part. She thought it was an inferior version of The Little Mermaid. Oh that's true, okay I remember now. But it's just
different than the Disney one is really the problem. I didn't like it. Kevin what about you? I got four in my bottom grouping I guess as just the ones that maybe just didn't quite work with me on a whole I liked aspects of them, but I think if I'm just taking like the whole Picture some of these other movies have worked a little bit better at least for me personally So I'm going from again from the worst to the best I guess through this whole thing So I have pork or rosa actually as my bottom of the barrel the the 11th ranked film that we covered and then I went up
to Castle of Caliostro on the first one obviously like we talked about just feels a little bit different than than the rest of the films but I still think that the characters in that film is what kind of brings it a little bit ahead of pork or rosa for me I think there was more characters. I could kind of appreciate in Castle of Caliostro Then I went to The Wind Rises. I guess if there was one that had the most potential to rise over time, no pun intended, it would be The Wind Rises because I do think it has a lot going for it, but I just found it, I don't know, the disconnect from the first half to the
second half bothered me a little bit even though I know it kind of pays off, but that was my number nine ranking and then the last one for this chunk It just didn't work for me on the emotional level at any point. I talked about it during the episode. Amanda's not going to like this, but Kiki's delivery service would be my number eight ranking. It just was missing something about it. I couldn't pinpoint it during the episode record, but there was just something missing for me for Kiki. So that's my last one for this chunk. Interesting. Matt, how about you? All right. So I think I
gave two of them sevens and everything was above that. saying, oh, man, this is the worst Miyazaki movie is like, you know, it's like, oh, this is the least sweet chocolate guys. Like, it's not like there's not a bad movie in this bunch. But I think at the bottom of my list are going to be the less magical ones. Like, I really love his magical realism. So like, I've got to put Castle Cagliostro and Wind Rises at the bottom. And I think I'd still flip -flopping on whether
I'm bothered or happy that Wind Rises starts off as a biography and then makes a hard left into fantasy world. But I don't know how I feel about that. Then after that, probably Kiki's Delivery Service and Castle in the Sky would be bottom or tier. I'm real sad. I'm real sad. Like again, I think I gave kiki's an eight like it's top tier movies. It's better than 90 90 percent of the movies coming out this year But
I don't like it nearly as much as you know, the other movies on this list Yeah, and i'll also get mad so like I would I think the lowest I gave was a six and I would think probably even I would erase that going going through and I would recommend every Film to me is aki's done. I don't think there's a bad movie in the bunch similar to when we did tarantino and I think I like all of his films, but I mine's I think kind of so much everyone's with my bottom four. Mike, like Kevin, I have Poker Rosso as my last,
then Ponyo, sorry, Amanda, then Kiki's, the literary service, and then Lupin, Castle Kelly Ostro. And those are very similar to one another for me. I will say I like Kiki's interview service this is the second time I watched it much more in the second time than I did the first time I think I was especially after going through his career I was able to kind of appreciate it more and I think I mean some Lupin's actually in the Castle of Cassiola sure has actually grown on me since we first watched it for some reason But um, that's like that would be my bottom four
I feel the same way that you do about castle. Caliostro Like I was probably harder on it during the record than I would have been at any point after that Because I it has stuck with me and kind of grown more and more Very cool. All right, so we're gonna shift focus and go from overall films to kind of you know We talked about some of his movies. We're gonna specify some of our favorite characters some remain favorite man characters minor supporting characters and Obviously with Miyazaki of a lot of crazy creatures from side characters to animals things of that nature
So Amanda, I guess we can start with you if you want to just give a listing or talk about some of your favorite characters from these categories And his sass. I love him. He's like my kitty. And then my second choice for favorite character. I wanted to pick something that you didn't know if you guys would pick. And it's the cat bus
from my neighbor Totoro. Oh, man. Nice. So two kitty choices here. But I'm OK with that. I'll be the crazy cat lady. I like those characters. Can't go wrong with cat characters. Which is not like a cat in the form of a bus. Kevin, how about you? What are some of your favorite characters? I guess for creature wise, the one maybe I was most entertained by was the soot sprites from Spirited Away. I just thought that they did a lot of cool things with them and they were just
fun to watch, so I thought that wasn't entertaining. I think there's so many good voiceless or nameless characters, creatures, etc. that really... Give Miyazaki a little added flair in some of these films But those were one that came to mind right away if I'm going for I guess you can call this a supporting character But he's really kind of also a main character because his name is in the title, but I mean Totoro How do you not like Totoro? I just think he's one of the easily obviously he's part of the you know the logo or you know kind of the iconic symbol of Miyazaki for a reason
but if I was going like with an actual main character the one that I kind of was the most impressed by? I think I would say Ashitaka from Princess Mononoke. I just think there's so much to that character and and everything he goes through and he's just someone that you could like like if you're if you have kids or younger audiences watching these films like that's someone that you kind of look up to I would think you know and and see all the different stuff that he stands for and and I don't know I just think there's a lot to Ashitaka so I would put him as like my favorite overall character. I could really
agree with that. Like, Prince Ashitaka, he feels like a real person. He's got this depth, he's got this story, but at the same time, he's very much a hero. He always makes the good choice. Well, maybe it's not a good choice, but it's the right choice. He's always putting people forward, even willing to sacrifice his life for someone else. He's got great ideals, but he also feels like a real, relatable person. There's there's quite a few characters that we discovered or or met along this journey though that I would
Definitely if we were going back and doing that top 100 animated characters list I would I would have a lot more of these in that listing than I had Since I hadn't seen any of these films But I can definitely see why some of the ones that we mentioned during that countdown were in that countdown Definitely I yeah, I agree with you even like I said, even though I saw some of these films begin with seeing it again Definitely strengthens a lot of that man. I know you had a lot of favorite characters going into this any any Ones maybe stand out even more going through this a second time or watching these
movies again. Oh Man, well, I would say like no one from the movies that I hadn't seen are really like Perked me up actually come to think of it like I think the characters that I relate with most are probably like Porco Rosso and Lupin but they're not the characters I want to see the stories about, right? I want to see stories like the kids growing up, like Kiki and the kids from Totoro. So I think those are the stories that I enjoy more, even though I don't necessarily
relate to them as much. But like really, I think the spotlight's on the creatures, right? Like the forest spirits from Mononoke, Cat Bus is hilarious. He's in like 10 minutes of that movie, but he steals the show from the second he shows up. All of the creatures in his world are so amazing even the little even the little like goldfish and ponies that are like Human -faced goldfish, but no one sees them as human fate like the the way he weaves creatures into a story is amazing Or just even to with some of them
that you know Are they creatures are they more humanoid or different things like you know? Like you had turnip head and no face and a couple things like that like they're just Intriguing a lot of these characters that he that he puts out there that are not necessarily you know front and center Any other characters you wanted to bring up before I give mine? Oh, that's that's enough. Okay So for me like probably my looking at like specifically kind of creature area and I to be fair when I was looking at these I try to spread the love or across all the films and I try to give some Different answers, but I pretty
much agree with everything that's been said. Well, one of my favorite Creature characters is Moro from Princess Mananoke from this design of the character Just you know this gigantic wolf and I just the way that they speak in how like the mouth doesn't necessarily you know, it's not Completely, you know morphized but it's just has a haunting feel to it. But there's also some sort of like beauty to the character as well as like viciousness as well. Princess Manon, you know, okay, it was the first Mizaki film
I watched and it was those giant wolf characters that really made it work. You know, they were, they had giant wolves long before that of Game of Thrones. So it, maybe, actually, I don't know when the book came out. So I could, I could be, I could be wrong there, but I really enjoyed that character. One of my favorite characters was actually Sophie from Howl's Moving Castle. This is a strong -willed woman character who gets dealt a really kind of crappy hand of being kind of forced to become this old woman. Yet,
you know, she still kind of forces her through. There's sort of like a kindness to her, obviously. We made many comparisons to Wizard of Oz when we did the film and certainly see that there's... just the respect she has for others and her ability to really kind of see the good in all people. It really makes that movie work very, very, very strongly. And if I, you know, if I was going to pick a side character or maybe if you want to even say like villainy, even though it's hard to say if Madagascar's films have true villains,
one of the closest would probably be Lady Bashi from Princess Maninoke, but still she has some qualities that make her interesting Like how she does help some of the sick and ill and she's yeah, she's not completely evil. There's some Legitimate reasons for what she's doing, but I also find her very interesting character and a part of why I really like that movie Yeah, that's good point. All right, so we'll move on over to the our middle chunk of films in the world of Miyazaki. Amanda, we'll again throw
back to you and start. So we had your bottom five. What makes up your middle section? I've got three films here for my middle section and start out with The Wind Rises. I gave that a seven. Super sad and a little traumatizing. But I think that it had its own Tone it you could tell it was a Miyazaki movie by some of the subject
matter like the planes and You know some of the animation and all that good stuff But it didn't feel like the other films even the other serious films, so I really didn't know How exactly I felt about it, so I just put it in the middle, so That's my first middle choice middle chunk choice, and then I've got how's moving castle up next I gave Howl's Moving Castle 7 .5. I thought that this was a good middle of the road pig.
I liked it, but I wasn't blown away by it. Also, Totoro... I can't say... Totoro? Totoro? There we go. The CatBus movie? My neighbor Totoro? Yeah, my neighbor Totoro with the CatBus. That's my next and final middle chunk choice. Liked that movie but is also super friggin sad and it had some scary little dudes in it. So middle middle middle ground there for me Nice Kevin the float over to you a lot of people put this one in their bottom section It just missed out
on being in my bottom sections the first one here in the middle of my number seven ranked film would be Ponyo I like aspects of it and other aspects maybe didn't work quite as much but it was one of those that did have me intrigued big time the entire time like I was always interested to see where it was gonna go next so I think that's why I put it a little bit higher than some of the films I already mentioned. For my number six film I'm going to go with Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind and I think the only reason that's down at number six right now because I think this is an impossible film to rank on one viewing. I think there's so much there there this film is complex it's layered and I think
it's just requires more than one viewing to fully appreciate and I've only seen it once so right now it's sitting at number six. For my number five film I put Castle in the Sky apparently a little higher than that one than a few of you but I think there's a lot of fun characters in there too with Dola and Pazu and Shida and I don't know I like the concept of it and he definitely gets to explore some of the visual you know the aerial aspects of it so that was my number five. And number four, I was surprised, but this one just kept going up the ranks for me, is Howl's
Moving Castle. And I think, honestly, with Tyham Howl as a character, could be one of the best characters in the library as well. I think there's a lot to him. You get the fun part of Calcifer, Turnip Head. There's just a lot interesting about Howl's Moving Castle. I kind of like the way they use the castle to make the story go in different directions and whatnot. So that's my last one for this middle chunk, would be Howl's Moving Castle. Matt, over to you. Alright, I think I
can agree with Kevin putting Ponyo right at the bottom of the middle. I mean, it's weird, but it's a good story. Then after that, I think Porco Rosso, I really like that one, but it was kind of spoiled the way I first viewed it because I owned it on two different DVDs and neither one quite worked and we bounced back and forth. And so like it was really rough the first viewing and it was really nice to see it You know crystal clear for this retrospective But I think that
one might might could go higher then above that would be princess modern. Okay? And then spirited away like that like towards the top you like the more magical the more fantastical like that's right where I want it Some some more some differences here for me. I'm starting my middle at number seven for you would be castle in the sky Similar to Kevin I one thing I loved about it was when they actually get to the castle and just the layout of that castle and the robots and the
space pie I mean sky pirates what what there's what isn't there to love for six is for me is my name or Totoro Which I think maybe one lacks for plot and story just makes up with characters and emotional impact That probably would be, you know, someone saying, what's the first Miyazaki film to watch? That may be the one I would recommend first, especially if you're watching with kids. I think it's one that really would work at all ages. Number five, I think, is one I am probably the highest on from everyone, which is the one Ridden Rises. I just kind of love the idea that
were a lot of the ideas are brought up in that as we talked about in the actual retrospective of the film, especially the idea of like innovation and how it can be used for greatness and as well as kind of ultimate destruction and how you balance that. in Lush for me, which was interesting because if I did this list before we did this retrospective, it probably would be in the bottom of the list, but it rose a lot more as we watched it again for me, and that's Hal's movie Castle at number four. As Kevin mentioned, just that it's so stacked
with great characters, as I talked about Sophie already, and as, you know, Hal himself is a great character and it just continues from there, so. Alright, so we'll chip focus again. We talked about some of our favorite films. We talked about some of our favorite characters We're gonna now look at the scenes. You know, we what are some of those specific moments that mean these movies stand out? There's a lot of great action moments or some more dramatic moments Amanda for you. What were some of the specific scenes that really stood out throughout this retrospective? One of my favorite scenes and I think this was probably
the hardest section trying to figure out favorite scenes because there's So much to choose from with all these movies. There's so much stuff going on That I would like to pick from I like the stuff that Matt was talking about like the more magical and fantastical the better here but I wanted to pick some smaller scenes and One of the scenes that I liked the most was the little dust mite sprite things when they were
shuffling the coal around and the one got smashed and so she was helping it and then the other one acted like he couldn't pick it up so she would help him too. I think those things were really cute so I like that scene and the bath house there and I also like Kiki's Flight like her first flight to the new town. I thought that was a cool moment and I think the little montage the little music montage to get there is it really sets up like like a hope feeling like a new beginnings
kind of feeling and I liked that and then I Think one of my favorite scenes has to be no faces freak out in the bathhouse There's a lot. Yeah a lot of great moments. I would I would have to agree with you there Kevin, how about you? What are some of your favorite scenes that stood out for you? I was real close to picking No Face's Freakout 2 just because that was something to behold for sure. But I guess I went with, you know, she talked about maybe some of the more magical moments and things like that. I think another thing that Miyazaki does really well
that maybe I wasn't expecting as much because I had heard about, you know, the aerial things and the female, you know, protagonist and the fantasy magical realism. Aspects, but I wasn't as prepared for some of the emotional beats that he really hits in a lot of these films And I'm sure that's something that he's known for as well I just wasn't exposed to it so I most mine kind of revolved around more of the emotion Just so I'm not completely hating on Kiki's delivery service even though I ranked it in my bottom chunk I will put a moment from there as well, but a different moment than what Amanda was talking
about I think when when Gigi goes silent when She no longer is talking Instead just resort Reno like they don't have that connection anymore where they're where they're able to talk and communicate with each other And she kind of turns back into a cat that's just meowing or he excuse me I keep saying she but I just thought that was just a very touching and very simple thing but Like a genius decision to to do that and kind of the impact that that has in that moment I think is really cool I think things can be
cool that are emotional. Ironic coming from a guy who like shows one emotion. Like that's it. That's what you get from Kevin. Yeah. And just again, I guess it's weird that I'm picking some moments from these films that I had towards the bottom chunk. But I'm going to go with a moment from Wind Rises as well. I think when... when the main character, their hero, has that moment where he's finally successful with what he was trying to do and it coincides with most likely also the moment where he loses his wife. I think that's just a crazy circumstance and a crazy
set of emotions to try to reconcile, especially if you kind of know that they're happening simultaneously. I think that was a really interesting decision from Miyazaki and I think it makes you think about a lot of things. So I enjoyed what that moment kind of triggered as far as thought process and emotions. And then I guess for... I'm really tired. I'm gonna have to squeeze two in here. One, when Sophie visits Howl as a child in Howl's Moving Castle. and finally kind of realizes why everything is the way it is. I think that's an
emotional moment. But I don't know, one of my favorite moments, I guess, is the iconic bus stop moment from My Neighbor Totoro. I think that just, I don't know if there's another scene in all of Miyazaki's films that does more by doing less. I mean, there's nothing going on and it still has such an impact from a lot of different aspects. So I think that's probably one of my favorite moments. Matt, how about you? What are some of your favorite scenes of Miyazaki
films? Man, this is so hard, because I feel like it's not about the scenes. It's about all of them. I love Howl's Moving Castle, the way it's this building adventure, and characters come and go, and it builds up a party. But it's like, what's the best scene? Is it when she has the flip turnip head over? I don't know. It's hard to just pick scenes from these masterpieces. And a lot of them are so just emotionally draining.
But I really love Totoro, the dream sequence where they're dancing and growing the tree. That one always puts a smile on your face. And I think I really like the moment where Ashitaka is leaving the village. and then he gets shot and he's like opening the door, but he still just keeps pressing on and everyone's just like, like, you're gonna kill yourself, what are you doing? But then he like gets out and gives the princess back to
the wolves. Like I think that scene is like real good. But I also like some of the, I don't know, like the smaller scenes, like a Nausicaa, like at the beginning when she's under the dome and like the poison's falling and she's just watching like it's a rainfall, but it's like this deadly poison. Think that's I'm gonna I'm gonna start getting into the mundane now and be like also when Kiki bakes that like bread with the old lady I mean, I love these movies. Yeah so I'll
start with some of them, you know the bigger bigger moments and Going back to a movie that was on my bottom half with this first film and that's the car chase in the pond opening moments in all of his movies and I think it kind of just gave you insight into like what he was going to become as a tractor and it's what a car chase that many notable directors and actors have actually gone to is like a really well executed car chase and not necessarily car chases something that's associated with animated movies by any means.
You know Princess Manonoke has a lot of great moments for me and I think its opening also really works Well, it's just it's frightening. And it's everything that the film has, I think, wrapped up into like a really quick moment where you have this board just covered in disgusting creatures, and you're not sure what's going on. And it's just, it's insane. And it's really action packed. And you're but there's some beauty to it at the end as well. And you have the voice of Keith David, I believe. So that's always a great moment.
And I'll echo the one of the moments that Kevin brought up with The One Rises and when he discovers that his wife has this disease and it pans to her basically coughing up blood and it was just like a silent moment of just huge emotional impact because it kind of comes out of nowhere and it just flips everything all at once in a really powerful way. And lastly just a really fun enjoyable
scene and as Matt talked about the magical realism and was spirited away And it's just the bathhouse scene with the mud monster or whatever you want to call it. It's just it's humorous It's fun. It's just the crazy imagination of Miyazaki, but also I think symbolizes a lot with him and kind of what he was getting at and I think there's that's the kind of what I think makes spirited away the movie it is or kind of scenes like that Good picks. All righty Getting down to the nitty
-gritty. So we'll talk about what Films made it to our top of Miyazaki films. What were the best of the best Amanda? I think you have three laughs. So what your top three of the Miyazaki films? My number three is Spirited Away. I think this movie was one of the most fun for me. There was so much going on, so much detail, so much color. It was a great ride. I loved it. I was kind of blown away. I wasn't expecting anything really, but this surpassed any expectations that I could have had. Number two, I've got Kiki's
delivery service. Not number one, huh? Not number one. I decided that Princess Mononoke would be my number one. I think there was so much going on in this movie, and I remember just how gangster it was, and it was scary and exciting, but also had this, you know, message that was played out in this crazy way, so it was... probably one of the most unique things that we've seen. So I liked it. Very nice. Kevin, how about you?
I'm going to be boring because I'm going to have some repeats from what she just had in her top three as well. I guess for this. I have two that are probably more objective, I think, two of the best films that he did. And then I have one that's a little bit more of a personal choice. But my number three is the exact same as Amanda's, that'd be Spirited Away. I just think there's so much there between the main characters, between all the different creatures. We talked about the soot sprites and No -Face and Yubaba we didn't talk about. But there's just a lot there. And
I think it's fun. There's a little bit of some mystery. There's... obviously the magical realism and the fantasy elements there's a lot to just enjoy maybe doesn't quite have some of the emotional pulls that some of the films do but it still has them and it just maybe not those like striking moments besides maybe some of the things as far as, you know, forgetting or remembering your name and that type of stuff, but a lot to enjoy a spirited away. My number two is Amanda's number
one, that would be Princess Mononoke. I think objectively this is probably the best film he's ever done. I think just the scale, the epic grand nature of everything that's going on, I think it does encapsulate a lot of the themes that he's been tackling here and there with a lot of the different films up until that point, so I think it's... It's a masterpiece for sure. But my number one, I have to go with the personal choice and it's not going to be a surprise to anybody. My number one would be My Neighbor Totoro. Something about that film, I cannot deny how
fun it was to watch, but then also how moving it was for me personally. It just had that magical element that maybe I thought a few of the films didn't quite hit as well. So My Neighbor Totoro is my number one. Very nice. Matt, how about you? All right. So my number three is going to be Nausicaä, which is the highest ranking of anything that I hadn't seen before we started this. I just really love that movie. I love the world. I love the technology and the factions
and all of that. I just love it. And then my top two, I think I said were my top two when we started this, and it's always hard to rank those two. But that's Howl, which is just an amazing fantasy adventure, the exact thing I want when I'm sitting down to a movie. And then the other ones, the only one I gave a 10 to, My Neighbor Totoro, one of my favorite movies of all time. You haven't heard it in my countdown yet, but you're gonna. I love that movie. It is the most touching movie I think I've ever seen. Impressive impressive. I like your picks
Matt My top three of all obviously all been spoken because we talked about all the movies already but similar with Matt and not sorry similar with Kevin and Amanda a spirited away is also my number three again, I like I said is it's just a great blend of humor and imagination, it's Kind of like we talked about a lot of Miyazaki films which tend to be either just packed with plot or limited to where I think Spirited Away was able to kind of blend the paths of both of those
worlds. Number two, similar to Matt, it's Nausicaa Valley of the Wind. This was the first I watched for me and I just, it kind of set the... The recipe to how to make a great Miyazaki film that kind of just kind of got remixed as the years went on And I was just mashed impressed by it the man animation that still holds up It would came out the year my birth and it still looks like it came out just a few years ago So I was majorly impressed with it And last but of course
not least as it was my favorite film coming in and it remains my favorite Miyazaki film and that's been Princess Manonoke I just I love the world the creatures To me, there's something about it that always sticks with me, and I just think it's his most complete and greatest film, which is saying a lot for Miyazaki, because he is, every film he has is packed with imagination. So, we talked about our favorite films, our favorite scenes, our favorite characters, all that great stuff, and I guess we talked about where we came
from. Coming into this question them rain remains like how is Miyazaki? What are your over feeling overall feelings of him as a director? Does he belong as one of the best of this current generation of all time? You know is this you know is he maybe overrated? I don't I don't think we'll get that compared about based upon a lot of our responses, but Amanda overall thoughts after finishing this retrospective of the career and directing style of Miyazaki I think that he definitely
is an innovator and at the forefront of grades when it comes to generation. I do appreciate a lot of what he's done, but it also made me expect more from him. So should I give my grade or are we holding off grades? You can go ahead and give a grade as well. I give him a B only because feel like I would want a little bit more
of a variety in I want to say genre I mean I understand like you know animation is this thing I'm not asking him to do like live -action but maybe something just a little bit different like you know we we watched all these films and you can tell for sure that it was a Miyazaki film because there was all these elements that show up in all of his movies so it would be cool to see something even You know completely different and I know that the wind rises was kind of that but I Still don't even know how I feel about
that. So maybe just a little bit more variety in what was going on and I know he has the ability to do that because he puts out great stuff. There's a good point. I don't want us I Don't want to start an argument, but I think almost the fact that his movies are recognizable as him is of more of a plus than a detriment like Like if you think about like like great musicians, you know, like you can always tell an acdc or a van halen or a metallica Like these huge mega bands
they have a sound And like the ones that reinvent themselves like if you check green day right from dookie to american idiot Like their sound changes and I think that's to their detriment as a band and I think that applies here Where miyazaki can do an like an almost biographical movie as well as a movie about two kids that are growing a tree, as well as a movie about a hat shop owner that goes on a sprawling time traveling magical adventure on a castle that runs on chicken legs, but they all feel like
they're made by the same one guy and they're all amazing, I think is more a plus than a minus. Like he has a feel. I'm not going to give him an A plus. I'm not going to do that because if I'm wanting more, then I'm not going to give him an A. And I know that he you know has these elements that we see I don't mean to take away his elements that you can see like hey this is a Miyazaki film but why does it all have to revolve around playing stuff why does it all have to have I don't know just I Like some of the stuff
like the his escapes and hit the artwork that's put into it and and some of his brushstrokes I love yeah, but I don't want every single film revolving around some airplanes or super heavy -handed about the You know environment or the economy or whatever. I don't know. I just wanted a little bit more Kevin overall grade and thoughts about me as a director Well first, I think it's hard to talk about Miyazaki when it comes to a director of animation because there's no other
director that can put a resume against him. Like, who do we compare Miyazaki to in the world of animation? Disney is a company and he wasn't a director, you know what I mean? so it's not like you can put their entire library against Miyazaki or something like that and There's so many other directors that have maybe had one or two good films or maybe maybe I don't know Maybe there's some that have had three or four how many have had eleven that would be all ranked pretty high So I mean it's hard to like he's in an he's on the island by himself So I think
for that like he is definitely one of the greatest directors we've ever seen I think just not just in our generation but of all time and I think that it is a plus as far as the different elements that make a Miyazaki film and kind of give you that feel regardless of if we're doing more of a coming -of -age, if we're doing more of an adventure, if we're doing more of all the different stuff that we've talked about. It's like someone saying all the Marvel films are the same genre, they're not, and all the Miyazaki films are not the same genre. But yeah, there are all those
key elements, the female protagonist, or the aerial aspects, or the magical realism, or the human versus nature, or technology versus nature. Those things do obviously find their way into a lot of his films. Think there's enough different like going through this retrospective. There was enough of a variety I think in the tone like there was some that were Much more emotional much more sad and then you had some of the more lighter ones and you had ones that were more adventurous Versus ones that were more like, you know thematically driven So I think throughout
the thing I never felt bogged down or felt like I was just getting the same thing over and over again Would it be interesting to see him go completely, you know? Do something completely different that has nothing to do with some of those elements, but then still be a Miyazaki film Yeah, that might be interesting, but I don't know if I'm gonna hold it against me He he does what he does very well, so I think it's a it's like Tantino You know if you've done something that the worst film in your filmography is still universally accepted as a good film That's something that most directors cannot say so I think for that.
I have to give him an A All righty Matt how about yourself Well, I think I mean and I'm the ringer right like I got brought in because I'm such a me as I can fan like His movies are the movies I want to see like if you're like, hey, what movie do you want? I'd be like I want a fantastical adventure about a teenage girl coming of age on the road But she's meeting a bunch of different
like weird characters like a bouncing scarecrow and a talking fire demon and a frickin' chicken castle. Like, the movies he makes are the ones that I could only dream of. And he does it over and over and over again. And even when he does, like, an almost biographical movie, it still has, like, fun magical elements to it that I can really get down with, and the animation's great, and, like, it's hilarious, and I love it. Like, and that's the thing, is I usually,
I like, I go for fantasy, and I go for comedy. and sci -fi, but that's really kind of fantasy for a lot of these movie guys. So the fact that his movies aren't laden with Joss Whedon quips and stuff, but they still manage to really get me, just shows to me how good these movies are. There aren't very many levity moments in My Neighbor Totoro, right? There's just heart -wrenching...
Is the mother gonna die? Did the daughter drown? And then the levity moments aren't comedy so much as they're like, oh, they had a nice night before going to bed. They planted a tree, that was cute. But they take you for a ride. Just like a roller coaster, I get off and I go right back to the beginning. I need to take that ride again. And it's just every time. I'm always enjoying myself and I'm always loving these movies and if I had to name the top five directors of all
time like Miyazaki's in there probably top three like he's he's one of my favorites and all of his movies are great and I like like a a -plus I don't know like he's the best I definitely I can see what you're saying because like clearly there are a lot of Factors that are repeated in his films either through thematically or just elements of his level of planes and aviation And things of that nature so I could see why?
Wanting more variety would be beneficial But I think sometimes is it depends on what you want from a director perhaps I think there are directors that you have careers which are so widely versed that people almost Forget we'll get to it as we talk about who are we doing next? But in a way I wonder if a certain choice that I may have come up with Did very poorly and I wonder it's because a lot of people his movies are so different from one another that in a way Do people even know what he's directed because it's there's
there's no connecting tissue. It's so it's challenging I think for a director, but ultimately if I just look at the quality of the films by themselves He's made some of the best animated films of all time, unquestionably. done so on a consistent basis and you know, he you go outside of just his movies what he's done for the animation world the studio Ghibli and I'm sure he's had his hands in a lot of the films that don't necessarily has his name as a director and the standards
that he puts on himself in the films that he put up puts out I think that says a lot to you know, like he was able to kind of go go to war with Disney and When in the sense of like making sure that the cuts that were made were the ones that he wanted Which doesn't happen very often to me. It's Unquestionably in a like I said, I don't I don't think all of his movies are perfect I think there's some issues here and there but I feel like you there's such even though some of the elements are the same there are a huge
variety there that in the sense of from a princess Mennonoke to Anasaka to more of my neighbor torturo or like our porquerosa there's There's some uniqueness within each film. So I was really, I enjoyed the retrospective as a whole, just seeing his career progress and getting to see some of these films for the first time again, learning about Lou Pollen, because I had no idea that was a thing before starting this whole podcast. And that was a fun adventure as well. So, but yeah, if you want to hear more of our thoughts about
each film, like I said, you can go to the... Actual retrospective, but I think it's time to get to the moment of truth and maybe what everyone's been waiting for as we looking to see who will be doing our next retrospective and this has been interesting because I've been monitoring this throughout the day and We, this whole thing has been going up and down. Like at one point there was two choices that were completely tied at the top and then the choice that was in third at the time came all the way up to be almost
in the lead and it's gone back and forth and every time I've reloaded it during this record there's been more votes that have been cast. So we started this record with I believe 70 votes. And right around 70 was what we had when we started this record and currently there's 77. So we've even gotten seven more votes just during this record. Dan, before you reveal what the winners are for this one. Interesting to think last time we did this there was also four choices, and we only had about 50 some votes 50 55 somewhere
around there, so we far surpassed that about 20 25 more votes this time And I forgot who all we had put up last time, but last time the four choices were Heyo Miyazaki Guillermo del Toro Robert Zemeckis and Denis Villeneuve So we've actually thrown two of those from last time back in it this time with del Toro and Zemeckis So I'd be interested to see because last time Miyazaki won with 40 % of the vote Zemeckis was second with 29 % Del Toro was third with 22 and Denis
Villeneuve only had 9 % So that was a long time ago But we'll have to see what kind of things changed with a few new choices thrown into the mix, but I'll swing it back to you, Dan Interesting, I guess I need to be more creative because I repeated Zemeckis. I forgot that I brought him up last time And he was my choice and he rocked the bottom of it this time with only 14 % of the vote and like I think I was just reading some of the comments I think people mentioned how you know, he started everything from back
to the future the castaway to Forrest Gump and I guess if you watch those, maybe you don't even realize that we're all done by the same person, I'm not sure. But coming in second place, which I thought was winning when I checked, but not anymore, as Kevin mentioned, it's been going back and forth, was Kevin's choice with Alfred Hitchcock. And Alfred Hitchcock had 25 % of the vote. In these last, these top two were really battling it out, and it came very close. Amanda's
choice of Guillermo del Toro, came in second with 29 percent of the vote and winning it was uh you know the the mayor spawn cast himself kevin smith with a grand total 32 percent of the vote and the person will be doing next for her retrospective so uh very different from i think uh what we what we were doing with miyazaki i think uh but i think it should be fun uh i i guess amanda i'll start with you how much experience you have with kevin smith for our next retrospective.
I would say I have a pretty good smattering of films of his that I've seen. I think there's only, let's see, one, two, three, four, five, six, seven of his films I haven't seen. So I've seen quite a bit, but there's definitely some blind spots there So looking forward to rewatching some of these and then catching up on the others You've seen about half of them interesting, too There's three votes that separated like every selection almost so very close vote for sure.
I'm with This is weird because I didn't think this was a thing I'm gonna be just like I was with Hayao Miyazaki. I don't think there's a single Kevin Smith film I've seen from beginning to end Yeah, I've seen most of clerks I've seen most of mall rats I've seen a very small part of Dogma and I've seen most of Jay and Silent Bob strike back, but I would not bet anything that I've seen the entirety of any of those films because I think I've always been, they've been broken up or I didn't finish them or I didn't
see them all the way through. And I know for sure I've never seen Chase and Amy, I've never seen Dogma, I've never seen Jersey Girl, I've never seen Cop Out, Red State, Tusk, Yoga Hosiers. Maybe I saw a scene from Zach and Mary maker porno, but I don't even remember Wait, wait, you didn't see cop out? I don't think so. I would put money on the table that I watched it at your house, but you might not have been there I've seen it Okay, man i'm gonna be the newbie again
somehow Matt well, he was your choice. Uh, how much of his films have you seen? I think most of them. I haven't seen his most recent horror thriller stuff. I haven't seen Red State Yoga Hosers or Tusk. And honestly, really Tusk has got me worried because that's a gross -looking film. I love the concept behind it, but I've heard it's not very... I've heard it fails on the horror marks and stuff, but I'm sure it's
horror and disgusting enough that it's going to bother me since I'm not a fan of that genre. Yoga host I heard is more silly than scary and like fingers crossed that that's true I also haven't seen Jersey girl because it's really hard to get a hold of two two years ago. I took a week off work and I watched Seven of his films over that week like I made sure a minimum of one movie a day Particularly ones I hadn't seen like that was when I first watched Chasing Amy which like strike a chord with me so much It's one of my favorite films of all time and I first
saw mall rats like Because I hadn't seen his earlier stuff nearly as much, but I've seen most of his films, but not all of them. Yeah, I'm the same. I haven't seen Jersey Girl. I have seen Tusk, but I haven't. I've only watched the first 20 minutes of Yoko Hosers and I'm like, I don't need to watch this, so I won't. But now I do. So there you go. And I've not seen Clerks 2. I think the rest I have seen. I watched a
lot of his movies in the 90s. I thought like I was I was a big fan of him and I remember first watching clerks, which we can talk about later, but I'm interested in going back because I've not watched a lot of his movies in quite some time. So I'm curious how well a lot of them hold up. So that should be a lot of fun as we get into the career of Kevin Smith. So I think it'll be a lot different retrospective than Miyazaki for sure. That's for sure matt. I want to know did you did you actually get votes from uh from kevin smith on this or or from tweaking? Sadly,
he did not uh, he did not retweet or even fave or like That I think if I if I was thinking a little better because I think I posted it kind of late like right after a record or something Like it would have been better if I had done it, you know, like at noon on a monday or tuesday Or I should I should have pushed it a little bit more. I do know that at least one person voted um because of my twitter uh campaign and voted specifically for kevin smith so i i did bring in the boat i'm still blaming hitchcock's
lack of twitter presence on my law here yeah i don't know what he's doing let's go step up that game Alrighty, so if you want to get in contact with us, let us know what you think of the upcoming Kevin Smith retrospective We also have the video game retrospective going on or remember if you want to be entered in the Chance to win a bunch of video game movies do so by going to keep cast radio or sorry go to an iTunes leaving review And you can be entered into that no matter what the review says so feel free You
can also email us a few back at GeekCatsRadio or also on Twitter at CinemaGeekCats and everyone else is also on Twitter because that's the world we live in. Amanda, what is your Twitter name? At HardCandyMandyEyesNoWise. Kevin? Mine would be at OptimusSolo, but I'm thinking about creating an account for Alfred Hitchcock too. So I'm sure one exists somewhere. Matt, how about you? I'm at FridleySutt. And I'm at MoodRevolve. And thanks for listening and join us next time as we begin
the Kevin Smith Practice Packer. Thanks for listening.
Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...
Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...
Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...
Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...
Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...