Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

CINEMA GEEKS

CINEMA GEEKS artwork

Review: Project Hail Mary

Apr 17, 20261 hrAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Today on Episode 238, the guys take a quick break from their Western Retrospective to give you their thoughts on one of their most anticipated films of the year, Project Hail Mary. Did it live up to the hype? Tune in to find out! Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on X and Blue Sky! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark! #UNLEASHTHECINEMAGEEKINYOU!!! #CinemaGeeks #ProjectHailMary #MovieReview

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hey guys, Raphael here, the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Did you say podcast? Dudes! Doodads! You're listening to a podcast on the Gatecast Radio Network. Cowabunga! Hello and welcome to episode 238 of... the cinema geeks i am one of your cinema geeks optimus solo and joining me

as usual is the comic concierge dan hello hello how are you i am good uh we are back at it again there's a brief delay in some of the episodes being put out i had to my aunt my mom staying with me for about a month and it kind of threw me off my schedule on top of some work things on top of that but we did have some episodes already recorded we just released one of those uh last week and we'll have another one this week and it should be almost on a weekly pattern

here i think going forward here so i'm not going to tell you which one's going to be released when because behold to anything that doesn't happen if we release them in a different order i don't know how it's going to happen hopefully they go in number order i guess um so dan how have you been doing good been doing good keeping actually been watching a good amount of movies so that's good i saw that I saw your letterbox recently. I had been away for a while. So I went to log in a few movies and I always, whether you know this or not, I always click on your feed to see what you've been up to specifically.

Like I do, I click on like activity from like all of my followers, but then there's a few that just post like either super long reviews or do so much that it's like, that's all I would see. So occasionally there's a few folks that I'll just click on and be like, well, what does Dan seem late? And you've definitely been busy. i was jealous i've fallen behind in the movie watching so far for the year yeah well i watched a bunch of like 1930 films which was helpful because they're like all an hour long so you know that does help so and then you've been watching some

foreign or foreign films as well correct yeah i've been going through uh a few um goodness what is his name um miyazaki kobayashi's filmography i just on my own accord uh because there's uh so i've been watching a lot of his movies and i've watched like 14 of his films so i still have a few uh i've watched like all the ones that are easy to get to now it's like the ones that are a bit a bit out there so yeah and and and to counteract that i've also been just watching some jackie chan films you know because you know

you gotta balance things out man yeah yeah but good Yeah, so it's been interesting seeing your journey through all those. If people are interested, you can always follow Dan on Letterboxd. We'll give information on all that stuff probably later. But we're going to flip the script a little bit today. We've been starting our Western Retrospective series. We heard a couple of episodes out of us so far in that series, talking about some John Ford and John Wayne films. Today, we're actually going to pause that for a second. The

planets and the sun and the stars and everything in space lined up for us. Pun intended, I guess. Not really, but it happened. And Dan and I both were able to see a film in the theater this last week. In fact, Dan, you even saw two films in the theater in the last week. So I don't know how you pulled that off. Yeah. It's been, I mean, the last time I saw a film in theaters, I think, was Fantastic Four? I want to say so, but then

I guess I made up for lost time with two this week. So there you go. Yeah. I give credit to all of those folks that have children under the age of like six that somehow still find a way to go see movies because we just could not pull that off very much. Like it's always either I'm with a seer show or my wife is. So unless it's a movie suitable for the five -year -old, we're probably not going to the theater. And she does not like to go. She does not like movies in general. So that makes it even harder. she's much more of a tv series person she does not like villains um so it's hard to get her but she will sit through

all of the jurassic parks no matter how many times those play so it's it's a weird thing we're working through so we think she wants to go see the mario galaxy movie but then if you ask her the next day then she does not want to see it because bowser's is scary um but we'll see what happens so we both were able to see project hail mary and i think we're the last two on on the planet earth that got to see it um because it is just going bananas at the box office so here's i'm going to set the stage just real quickly here if dan and i have both been able to go see

a film at the theater then we are going to assume that everybody else has as well so this review will contain spoilers yeah so I don't think there's that many people that have not seen Project Hail Mary yet. But if you haven't and somehow you stumbled upon us, you may want to pause this or come back to it after you watch the movie. But Dana, tell me about your return to the theater. What was your theater experience like? Did you see it with a lot of people or just a few people? Give me the lowdown. Sure, yeah. So I went with my wife. She was actually a fan of the book.

So it was one of those movies we both had an interest in. It was nice because I took the day off. She was off for spring break. It's weird because my wife teaches in one district. My kids go to school in another. So their spring breaks weirdly don't line up this year. So we were just like, all right, well, the kids are at school. So let's take a day -day and check out the movie. It was like the first showing on a Tuesday. I think maybe one other person or two other people. It was hard to say because we were up on the balcony, so I couldn't see. beneath us. But there

was like at least a couple other people in the theater. So it was good experience, you know, so it was basically almost a private showing. You know, it was been a bit last time we saw a movie together was actually Bad Boys three, right before COVID shut down everything. Oh, my goodness. Yeah. And we didn't even get to finish it because we got a call because our kid got sick. So yeah, so it's been a while. I've been obviously we've been to the theaters with like our kids and stuff, but not like yeah not yeah so it was it was fun and it was nice to

have a movie we both were interested in in checking out so it was interesting getting her perspective because you know like i said she was someone who really enjoyed the book um so that but the theory experience itself was good it was solid the only thing that was kind of annoying was of course like the 35 -minute commercials before the actual movie began. And commercials slash trailers. But I did some good trailers. I saw the Supergirl trailer. I saw the He -Man trailer. I'm actually thinking my kids might like that.

So I actually think this summer is looking pretty solid. I'm excited to see what's coming out. But I'm definitely enjoying my time. How about yourself? um yeah so i we took advantage of the fact that my mom and my aunt were staying with us basically and uh the last weekend they were here we convinced them to it took very little convincing um to have them watch the my daughter and we went to see the film that was the opening saturday we were gonna go see on the friday but when we checked uh this one you buy like you're in the theater we go to you buy your individual seats you don't have to like wait or figure it

out you just pick a seat so we looked at the friday and it was like sold out almost we're like no that's not gonna work So we got the Saturday one, which no tickets had been sold to at that point. So we got our preferred seats, which are the middle two all the way to the back. And so it's also a special time for me because I stopped drinking soda back in like September of last year, basically. for some medical reasons and whatnot my my sugar stuff was too high so i cut soda out of my my diet and like instantly fixed

all my issues and uh but going to the movie theater is like the one time i allow myself to cheat yeah and so i don't know if i was looking forward to the movie more or if i was looking forward to the dr pepper more um but it was a good combination so we ended up just getting one between the two of us so we could share it so i didn't drink too much but uh that was a part of the experience i guess but this one obviously was also one of my most anticipated films of the year both last

year and this year so whenever that's happening you're worried that you're uh setting the bar too high possibly like you're hyping yourself out too much like for two years you've been waiting for this thing to come out and and sometimes that's a tough task for a movie to do so i was intrigued um about this one there was basically two films that i knew this year i wanted to see like the first week that they were out I don't know how many films I'll get to see in total, but I knew there was two of them that for sure I want to go see right away. And this was one

of them. And the other one was the aforementioned Masters of the Universe trailer, which or movie, which, by the way, I think we both screwed up by not having that in our box office team. Yeah. And also regret not getting Dune because that's clearly coming out. If I could have slid in that Masters of the Universe with my 10th pick, I think I would feel pretty darn good about myself. But I do feel good that I had Project Hail Mary on my team. It seems to have captured that spring,

early of the year spring type of thing that we sometimes see from the non -IP, etc. I think it set a record for... non -ip non -franchise uh opening or something or it was the highest one since oppenheimer or something i know there were some different things involved with like how well it did at the box office um so that was interesting and good to see like we need more movies like this that do well in the theater right like if you're a movie fan so i think it's it's always good to see a non -ip film that that

does good um at the box office i know you had known about this one ahead of time and you were a fan of the Martian. So I'm assuming that you were kind of looking forward to this one as well. Right. It definitely was. And I completely missed that. This was written by Andy. The book I should say was written by Andy where, who did the Martian, which was like my favorite movie that year that came out, which probably would have ranked it even higher if I realized that. But as I was watching this, I'm like, this is a lot like the Martian. He's like, I was like, yeah, it's written, but I'm like, Oh, I just, i completely missed

that i think he has another space one too i i heard somebody saying something about it i mean i'm sure he has more than three books i don't know how many books andy weir has written but i know that they were like already trying to like um guess as to which his next book would be that would be turned into a film but that was part of it like for me when we do those most anticipated of the list of the year lists there's lots of stuff you look at right and this one had like all of them going for me like it's the right genre for me in the right kind of setting It had Andy Weir, which I was a big fan of the Martians. So I'm like, okay, he wrote that. He wrote this. That's going to be good. It had Ryan

Gosling as a star who I'm a big fan of. It had, you know, Lord and Miller as the directors who have done some pretty good stuff with like the Lego movie and everybody knows their filmography. And then Drew Goddard kind of helped take Andy Weir's book and turn it into a screenplay has been involved with some films that I. have enjoyed including the martian right uh world wars world war z cabin in the woods cloverfield those were all good at different levels um so i for me it was like the whole package i'm like everybody involved in this has done something i've liked

so i don't know how it's not going to be something that i like so if it is it's going to be a letdown so i guess we can just like jump right into it like what was your initial thoughts uh after watching project hill mary So yeah, obviously going into it, we saw it much later than you. You saw it opening weekend. I just saw it about a week ago. So I obviously had some high expectations going in, because like you mentioned, I was interested in the trailer. From what little bit I saw, it

was Lord and Miller. So I was curious. What exactly this was about. Because I honestly didn't know. I knew about the alien piece. And I honestly thought the story going in was going to be like. Roger Kilmery was him trying to find life on another planet. I didn't even. Because I didn't see the trailer. I guess the original trailer that gave you that piece. I didn't see the part where it's like actually the earth is dying. And that's where this is coming from. So that actually I thought was helpful. Because it allowed me to kind of discover it along the way. But I generally really enjoyed this. I thought. If

this was the borderline, the tentpole, or the bar that blockbuster films were set by, we would be living in a much better world. Because to me, it has that feel. You mentioned, I know... your daughter wants a film without a villain and like that's that's this it really isn't a villain there isn't really a villain here there it has a lot of what i liked about the martian really smart people in this case a really smart person and a rock person and an alien trying

to solve a complex problem and kind of and going through that process do you think with this we don't get as much you know breakdown of like what exactly they're doing it's a little bit more abstract in some ways but i still had that that general feeling and there's also like an earnestness to this that like we don't see very often it's interesting because one of the trailers we saw before this was you know the disclosure day with spielberg and it does to me have a lot of like that type of spielbergian um like uplifting

moments you know that within it and it could easily i know it's pg -13 but i think this definitely you know there's not a lot it's not like there's a lot of cursing or anything like that but i do this like this i think does kind of work as like a family film and i could see if like people that are maybe a bit more cynical or something like that maybe having you know not enjoying it as much because It almost does feel like it could be a Disney movie, and I don't say that in a negative term. Much of this is a guy and a puppet talking with one another, but it works,

I thought. I thought it was an intriguing way of... approaching an idea like this like a world ending event uh the world you know seeing actual world come together and trying to solve it certainly maybe not the most realistic thing in the world but that's okay and i gotta give props to ryan gosling like it's not easy being the only person on screen for what 75 percent of the movie for the most part outside of obviously the um his little rock friend and the person who puppeted

it and voiced that as well but still like He's got that type of presence, similar to Matt Damon with The Martian. He can be comedic, he can be funny, he can be vulnerable, and also just the way he is not your typical type of hero as well, and the reasoning behind it. I thought there was a lot to really enjoy here, and I also thought it was a beautiful film as well. Definitely enjoyed my time. I thought it was deserving. of the praise

it's receiving and definitely excited to see it again. And like I said, I think it is one that it could, it is a crowd pleaser in the best of ways. And like that type of life affirming film that you, we don't get very often, but it's also one that I think doesn't try to dumb things down or try to. I don't know, simplify things in that manner. So it's, I don't know. I thought it was really solid and it was very happy with what we got. How about yourself? I know you said

you, this was really high on your anticipation list. So what were your thoughts of it? Yeah. Obviously, like I said, two, two years in a row, it's been on my top 10 for most anticipated films. The bar is really high. I just got to say like, typically that doesn't work out, but it's so nice when it does. It's so nice when you have something up there and like, it pays off and you're enjoying every, like, I don't know when the last time I've. enjoyed like every minute of my movie going experience as much as i did with this one like there's movies that you enjoy

and there's movies that you maybe are a slow start and you end up enjoying at the end or you really like how it starts or you know like you like different parts of it along the way and other parts you're waiting to see what happens like i don't know how many times i've just like literally from the opening to the closing been like totally like I don't know, like a kid in a candy store, like, just like, give me more of all of this, please. Like, I would like to see, see this and just like live in this space for a while. Like, I don't know if like what you talked about, like, especially given the backdrop of the reality of that we live in, like,

can I just escape into this for a second where people are working together? Like, yes, there is some commentary, I guess, on some things from the politics side, as far as like what they're willing to do in this. movie and things of that nature that you could i guess get grossed out into or like delve into further but like to me it did flip the script a little bit like i i was under the impression that from the little bit that i had seen like we know this is in space we know ryan gosling's up there first i thought

he was going to be on a one -man mission or something like that i didn't realize that there was going to be other folks involved uh and then the other thing i it made it seem to me or maybe i just wasn't trying to read too much into it that He was basically going to a planet or going to do something and interact with a different life form, an alien life form, or something of that nature. I'd never realized or thought about the fact, and I don't know how many times I've seen this in a movie, where instead it's two different, I guess, aliens to each other, two different

races or species that are running into each other as they seek a common purpose on a... in a setting that's not home to either of them like yeah that that to me was kind of some of the genius and and how this whole story sets up because it makes it something that's unique compared to a lot of what we've seen in the science fiction genre so i was i was here for that for sure i am a big ryan gosling fan and i think he was perfect for this part i think matt damon is perfect for

the martian because i think matt damon pulls off more of the quote -unquote sciencey part of it Like we're, we're doing, we're delving more deep into the science. And I think Ryan Gosling can pull off that he's intelligent and that he's the person that they're portraying him as. But I think he also fits really well in the fact that this one's a little bit more relies a little bit more on the humor, right. And a little bit more on the personality of, of Ryan Gosling to kind of have that comedic timing and, and have that aspect of him with

this film. So I feel like they both were like, the films are so similar but like in the ways that they're different the casting works perfectly for them i thought um another thing i really enjoyed and i know you talked about it a couple times here is that this is yes there's some cg involved in different aspects or whatever but the amount of time that they took into making this as real as possible i think paid off exponentially in this film whether it be to have an actual

puppet being puppeteered and being voiced on stage versus a CGI character, first and foremost. Second, to have the set that they made for this spaceship where it was realistic. All of the stuff that we see in space, that's actually him in a place that looks exactly like that. That's not him acting against a green screen and doing a lot of that where it could have been so easily heavily green screen or ai or different effect

you know pizzazz and magic that we have available to us and i just like that they went so much more for the practical sets and the practical effects and the the puppeteering and stuff like that i think that just paid off in spades um i think it's interesting like if if this movie comes out in the 80s which i know it couldn't have probably but if if it had like i feel like this is like et this is like back to the future this is the blockbusters that we got in the you

know 80s to early 90s like this is like going and seeing jurassic park for the first time you know what i mean like it's just like a fun blockbuster that like delivers and shows that you don't just have to like throw away expectation just because it's a big blockbuster you know we don't have to settle for you know some of the slop that we get in in blockbusters it can be done intelligently And when it's done and done right like this, it just pays off so much. Yeah. That's a good point. I think it, like you said, it not being

a franchise, anything like that, it being a standalone film, obviously having a book, having some sort of foundation, fan base, but even that, it's not like... if you look at how many books are sold, it's not like if you had every single person that read the book, go to the movie, that's still not, it's not making the money that it did. It's a lot of those different factors, which is great. You know, I, hopefully this is, you know, shows that studios can get behind a movie like this, both in the sense of the originality of it. And, and also just the style and tone that maybe this

is what people want right now. And maybe it's time to, cause we've had a lot of, You know, more of the cynical, more of the downtrodden type of ultra -serious. Obviously, we've had the comic book movies and things like that. But also, on the flip side, the Christopher Nolan type of blockbusters as well. Maybe something like this. We don't get movies like this as much. Like I said, there's no villain in here. That's one thing. I love The Martian, but if there's any major issue with that, you do have some of

the forced... drama they could try to create with like conflict with NASA on earth and things like that. And I was kind of waiting for that to happen here. And obviously this is different in how it's structured, where it opens up, he doesn't have his memory and then, and then he doesn't know what he's doing and why he's doing it. And then through flashbacks, which is also how we're seeing it and then how he's experiencing it. as well. It starts filling in the blanks. It's not linear with how the story is told. And

I thought, not only does it help film in general, but often that makes that ending make a lot more sense in what it's going for. I thought that was the structure of it. I really appreciated it, too. But yeah, I think there's... Go ahead. I think you touched on a good point. It doesn't rely on a villain. it doesn't rely on even like yes like there's some shady things that happen i guess with how they get him there or whatever i don't know if i would consider that like as

villainous i guess as you see in other situations where it's like a more concerted effort and you can kind of also understand why i guess in a way they're doing what they're doing not saying it justifies that or that you're okay with it but you can kind of see so like it avoids doing the villain thing it avoids doing the like against like a conglomerate or you know political side or big corporation even it doesn't even do like that generic villain and also like resist the need to like throw in some sort of love story or you know all of those things that a lot of

other movies would be like well we gotta have this in there or we gotta you know they're not gonna watch something that you know doesn't have this or doesn't have that like I feel like it's like you know what we're gonna be an intelligently written film that deals with human nature and the human condition and how we interact with things or people or species we don't understand and i'm like like that's gonna be enough like we're gonna throw some humor in there we're gonna throw a kick kick butt like score and soundtrack in there and we're gonna make things you know work on on another level and i think they do

it in a in a interesting way too like taking for example like how they balance the humor and the drama and like the sadness i guess of the situation that he finds himself in the beginning like really brings like they do a good job of creating him as a believable human being like you believe that this person could exist right like he's had some things not go his way necessarily

you know he's not necessarily living the life that he probably envisioned at one point but then he finds himself in a situation where he just like pours himself into this you know being a teacher and he it shows that like in the film in some of those flashbacks that he's really enjoying like what he's doing like yes he probably views some of the kids as like a little annoying or this that and the other but that's all teachers do that so um you know he gets this way of just pouring himself into that profession gets a chance

to like go see this thing but it doesn't just portray him as like this i'm i don't know like like i feel like they could have done this whole thing where he just didn't have a soul and didn't have emotions and didn't have feelings and stuff like that because he doesn't you know he's the perfect individual he doesn't have the family yeah separation he doesn't have this good infinite other so they could just like portray him completely kind of cold when it comes to that but for example like when they're doing the the funeral sequence i guess you could call it or the whatever the

eulogy that he's given to his crew members that he at that point doesn't even know like he can't remember them yet he remembers more about them later but he's literally like the humanity that they put into that scene where he's viewing a picture and trying to do his best to say something that could be relevant to these folks before he's basically shipping them off into space. I just thought that they chose ways where they

could really show the human side, they could show his soul and his emotions, yet not go so far that it just feels like they're trying to just draw tears out of the audiences. I just liked how they balanced that. And there's a couple other moments that they do that. Obviously there's some moments where he thinks it's going to go one way and it might not go another way. And, you know, he, he's envisioning this to be a one -way trip. You know, Rocky gives him another option. You know, the fact that it immediately

draws like a tear out of him and like his reaction, his reaction, when Rocky is trying to figure out like the brave word and like how he would be described. Like, I thought there were just some very, Nice touches not necessarily like Like subtle but like not heavy -handed and I like that I felt like they never were heavy -handed in this Yeah, despite the fact that he you know, he ironically despite the fact that he played Neil Armstrong This is not a type of character that is like, you know, the right stuff type of person, you know who was like the embodiment

of What like a hero trying to be the hero he isn't you know, the, the guy that breaks his hand to do it, he's reluctant and how it kind of unveils that obviously the reluctancy and he's trying to figure out like, why exactly did he make this choice? You know, he doesn't have, doesn't seem like he has any immediate family that we can see. He doesn't have any kids. He's not married. So maybe that's why. And then he seems to have made peace with it, or at least that's what he tells himself. And there was that

great scene where he finds out, no, Rocky's going to be able to help him get home. And he's like, well, you just say that. I didn't actually think that. But then he played it as a joke at first. But then as we later find out, not only did he not actually feel that way, he had no desire to go on this trip in the first place. And even though... him not doing it could mean the end of the world still the idea of like going on a suicide mission that's like he couldn't muster up the courage to do it um which you know that's

that's a hard thing to do you know that's that's certainly choice where you're making your protagonist basically you know uh i want i wouldn't say it's cowardly i think it's understandable because it's making that choice is i don't think any it's easy to think about or do but i think it's a good look at like what is it you know what does masculinity actually mean without like you said being overly heavy -handed with it and i also find it interesting when you look at because like i said i didn't know going into this like it was going to be the end of the world like they're trying to fix it but how um it was an

ending of the world or like this catastrophe that i really haven't seen before i mean we've seen like ideas of like the sun dimming with like sunshine but this wasn't you know this wasn't trying to be a take on like global warming or something like that. Not that it would be bad if it was, but this was something that humans had no control over. It was something that was not just impacting Earth, but the entire, you know, all planets from what they could tell. So that was, I think, made it a bit different,

too, that it didn't have a political angle in that side. Not that it would be bad if it did, but it just, it was... different type of end of the world movie where it wasn't like i said it wasn't like the 2012 or something like that where just like the world is ending but it was it's also allowed it to separate itself from a lot of some say something like interstellar which clearly was more of like you know certainly had a lot of commentary on the way humans were

interacting with earth this i think was not necessarily a criticism of humanity i think it was more so of a hope of what it could be like the thing that actually came to my mind was star trek right because star trek is the ideal of what we could possibly become you know where the world comes together has a star fleet or whatever you know you know we you know star trek much better than i do right but like this could be a prequel to star trek in some ways because it's they're all you know this is the ideal of all these people

putting things aside and coming together to try to solve this problem. And maybe because of that, you know, that's where they build upon that and become like this utopia in some ways. So I thought it was just, I thought that was an intriguing way of handling it. And honestly, when we, when we get, when we, when we first interact with the alien chip, my thought was going to be like, oh, okay, they're protecting the star. They figured this all out. and it's going to be like um contact

what is the movie arrival where next step is trying to figure out how to communicate with the species to learn what they're doing and then use that information and bring it back to earth i wasn't expecting it to be actually they don't know either they are trying to figure out just like we are and then or work together to solve the problem like that i was like oh wow that's that's actually a much better way of doing it than what i had in my mind so right um and i

know we haven't talked go ahead no go ahead go ahead i know we haven't talked much about you know obviously rocky and uh frank gosling's but like obviously like that's the movie and like i never thought i could care this much about uh a rock before but certainly do now i thought that like that character in itself was great like their the voice they chose clearly a lot of um you know it's almost reminding me almost like a star wars character or something like that i don't know but it just there was a lot of their relationship became so believable and

seeing this guy who clearly had no way of connecting with humanity on earth finding a way to find connection you know literally light years away was i don't know again it goes back to that earnest feeling that has really worked with me yeah i think that's interesting too like there's so many different movies that people are bringing up when talking about project tail mary like we we know the obvious one's going to be martian right like that comes without saying because it's done by a lot of the same people i have heard a lot of like some more other modern ones that i don't necessarily see as much of a connection

to this one but i think one that does come to mind that kind of goes back to like you're talking about ryan gosling puppet like having this amount of emotion and stuff behind him it's like the opposite of what we get with something like armageddon like let me throw something crazy in like right because armageddon like we we are you know this sci -fi and that's one that's not as subtle like they're literally trying to pull on the emotions every every second thing get right like they're

trying to and i like armageddon for what it was i think it was one of the first films i ever saw twice in the theater for i don't even remember why but uh that one is like it's trying to get you to cry it's trying to get you to do this but it also is doing it because it has a whole cast of characters right like we have a father -daughter dynamic we have you know co -workers or friends we have like saying goodbye to this person or that person which makes all of that so much easier like we're getting an emotional

roller coaster with one character and a puppet and it doesn't make sense that that works as well as it does in this one like it's like take the flashbacks out of it you know the flashbacks do show his students and it does show the other scientists and the astronauts that are involved with this it does show the i don't know what her title is the head of whatever this task force is that's kind of putting all this together but if you remove all that you know 75 of the movie

or whatever it ends up being is ryan gosling and this puppet and it's amazing how much of a emotional roller coaster we get just with those two characters right like how many different things can you do with these two characters that's going to pull on your emotional like heartstrings like you know you have the instance where he thinks it's a one -way trip and then it turns out not being and then then he's gonna find a way to save rocky and then rocky's gonna find a way to save him and then he has to go back and like it seems like this could very easily

be almost like repetitive or redundant if done not skilled like in an unskilled fashion like we we could be like well how many times are we gonna go back and forth with like who's gonna die and who's not gonna die um and i felt like they did that in an expert way that It was just enough where it didn't necessarily feel that. I didn't get any redundancy out of it. I didn't get like, oh, now we're just going to go yo -yo back and forth. It just felt like, okay, here's this twist. Well, that's a natural progression to this twist. I don't know. I just felt like

it's amazing what they were able to do with these two. Hats off to James Ortiz, who does the puppeteering of Rocky. He's the one that leads it. There's a team of people like there is in most situations. you know the fact that he somehow ended up getting to do the voice even though he didn't realize that that was going to be what happened you know just from naturally dubbing his voice over and being able to like have the official voice but it's also fun like when they go through adds to the comedy obviously when they go through the different uh options for who the voice of

rocky is going to be yeah um you know obviously the the rocky and adrian stuff to the actual movie rocky like there's lots of these like just little clever things like obviously the thumbs down which i don't know like i get like a lot of people on social media are we're reviewing the film and giving it a thumbs down i understand why yes it's somewhat clever because that's what rocky does i don't know if i was involved in the marketing of project hail mary if i would be pushing for that to be a thing like if anybody

doesn't understand it they're gonna think you're giving this a bad review yeah i mean if cisco and ebert were around still you know they'd be like wait that's that doesn't that's exactly they'd be in a conundrum yeah um as far as the the stuff that happens outside of rocky and rylan grace the the stuff that does happen in the flashbacks his interactions with sandra huller's character uh ava strat is that her name i don't know if i'm pronouncing it right but and carl the security personnel who i thought was phenomenal but but

what was your take on all of the more human interaction stuff that we see through the flashbacks. Do you think, you know, Carl was, I mean, you can think about it. Carl did help save the world. Cause it was his idea that really about, you know, that led to the discovery of how the, what is it called? Astrophage. Astrophage. I think like, I liked their interactions. I thought it was, that was kind of the beginning of seeing them figure out what exactly. He saw the curiosity

of Ryan Gosling's character, what drives him, his ingenuity as well. And as you said, what is her name again? I'm sorry, I can't think of her. Yeah, and Ava, great. That's a hard role to play, right? Because like you mentioned, she's kind of no -nonsense in a way. It could be very much a thinkless role. It's like the sergeant in a cop movie where they're always telling the person what they can't do. But I thought they actually had a good dynamic and the faith that

she actually had in him and was actually pushing him forward. Also, there's times where you saw a bit of a comedic side to her, as well as the random sequence of karaoke, which, again, is one of those scenes that doesn't really necessarily add anything to the plot, but it gives us insight to that character. It shows you that she's not just this, like... I don't know if she is in the military or what her actual role was beforehand, but at least you could see that there was a lot.

She actually does enjoy fun. She's human, but also she understands the weight of what is on her shoulders and what she has to do, and she has to make the hard decisions sometimes that are morally gray, and she's willing to do them because... that's what has to be done. So, and I also thought too, like we mentioned with the ending, like the fact that she's obviously the one that made the decision to force him into the situation that he's in. So he's on there, even though it was against his choice. Like I

thought there would be, again, talking about conflict, like there would be more anger or like, I don't know, like maybe he would even think, okay, well, you know, they, they forced me to do this. So I even bought, you know, as a way of like retribution. Or something like that. Or being angry or coming back to Earth. Being like, you did this to me. Or I don't know, something like that. Something cheesy. But it definitely avoided that. And actually preferred where it ended up. Where he ends up back at the alien

planet. And I do wish we got a little bit more of that alien ship. I feel like we get a little bit small glimpses of it. And I feel like I didn't fully... i understand the functionality of it still right so maybe like on a rewatch or something like that but i still didn't really like we didn't get enough but you know i understand what did you think about the fact that like basically when we're doing those flashbacks i feel like that's the heavy science part of it right like that's when he is trying to learn you know how

the astrophage works and that's when they're trying to come up with all the different things once we move to the rocky and rylan part of that which i know it happens intermittently but when we're dealing with that aspect of the story yes there's science but those bits of science are much quicker and a little less deep than i mean i'm not saying there's not science involved but it's not quite going i don't think to the length that we get with the the earth science that's

going on you know when they're trying to figure out the plan and they're trying to like get this whole thing off the ground when They're more complex, probably, like the stuff that Rocky and him are doing. But I feel like it's also done in a way that is a little more surface level, I guess, is the best way I can think of saying it. Coming up with how he's going to learn how to speak and communicate with Rocky, right? You get the seeds of what they're doing. It doesn't feel the need, which I think is fine, of really going into it super in -depth to shore that up.

It's like, this is kind of the science behind it. we're going to jump ahead and like, we have to move on with the movie. So then, you know, they're going to understand each other. And there's, you know, a lot of that part, obviously we don't get like, we don't get a lot of what's happening inside Rocky's. brain or head or whatever because he's like on another level genius when it comes to like engineering and creating and like building and and all the stuff he can do um do you think like they played that dynamic okay with like the amount of science that's involved i i know we said it's less than what we get in the martian

but do you feel like there's enough of it where you're able to like go along for the journey or did you find yourself saying well that's just like that's hollywood or that's movie magic that just forcing us to go from step a to step b i was fine with it like it never felt like anything was out of the realm of possibility where like, oh, I don't believe that that could happen. Certainly there are like leaps and you think you have to kind of buy in for certain things. Like you said, with the language, you go back to Arrival and we had an entire movie where they just tried to have, you know, a basic understanding of communication

and how, you know, and that could have been this movie, but it's not. That wasn't what this movie was. So it was a bit more, like you said, fast -tracked. But at least I thought you got it. it gave you that initial foundation of, okay, we're going to figure this out here and we'll build upon it. Certainly it, their advancement was very quick. And, you know, but I think, I think I prefer that within this because it's not what the movie necessarily is about. Like knowing, I haven't read the book talking to my

wife and her explanation of the book. That is much more technical. It is, like, that's what Andy Weir does. He gets really into the deep science of everything, gets into the huge, like, that's, like, he struggles with more of the human part of it. Like, he's more of, you know, kind of like, you know, Christopher Nolan with his director where the characters are a bit cold. But he's, when it comes to more of the procedural aspects, getting into the nitty gritty there. So I feel like if you want that, you have the book, but where the movie is like, okay, let's,

we'll give you enough. and i could see some people taking issue with that because i do think there are things that it kind of just glosses over or things some things are really easy fixes but i think it's i'm okay making that sacrifice to get to where it gets to it gets to the the core of what this movie is which again is about all the about you know human connection or connection and some what does that mean and just the camaraderie of what they're able to bring through that relationship

to me was worth it in the end and i think we're already dealing with a two and a half hour run time so like how much longer do you folks want it i know some people like the marathon films but uh the last thing i kind of wanted to ask you about i've read and heard in different reviews and podcasts a lot of commentary on the cynical nature of rylan grace's character potentially and if he cared about humanity or if he cared about life on earth or you know the fact that he wasn't willing to make this sacrifice the

fact that he's gonna choose to stay on this alien planet and not go back to earth because he doesn't really care about earth anyways and like a lot of this like cynicism and and and negative view on on the human race i guess i didn't pick up on any of that like that's not how i read the film like i was wondering what level of cynicism do you feel like is involved here and like how much Do you think it mattered as far as your viewing of the movie and his decision on whether he goes back to Earth or stays on Rocky's planet

for however long that's going to end up being? Yeah, I don't think he was cynical towards the human race. Because me, seeing those classroom scenes, he seemed to be enjoying what he was doing. He seemed to find and get something out of it. And I don't think he's in that role if he has no faith in humanity or faith within... the importance of, you know, especially middle school, you don't teach middle school for as long as he was teaching middle school, unless you enjoy it or something like that. You clearly

has other options. So I, I didn't take that. I took it more. So like, like I mentioned is that he didn't have a connection beyond that. Like he, like he didn't, he wasn't able to connect with people for whatever reason. He didn't have a relationship or a long -term relationship from what we know of. There wasn't even like, you mentioned the eulogy scene. Even those people, he didn't know much about them because he didn't have much of a memory, but even the scenes that we see with them together, he struggled with

trying to come up with a way of connecting with them. He's in the bar, but he's not with them. You know what I mean? They're doing karaoke. He's there. He's there. It's not like he's anti them, but he's also not in the middle of them. It's just like he hasn't learned how to get along with people in that way. Well, it could be, too. Sorry, I keep cutting you off. Oh, you're fine. Somebody that is that level of intelligence, what did he have? He had a PhD in molecular biology

or some form of field within science. There's times when you're at that level of the IQ spectrum. like it may be hard for you to have those connections with people like you know what i mean like he there's a difference when you're dealing with kids right because they're not adults yet like you're you could be like trying to like teach them and do different stuff that's a different dynamic but i think when it comes to people of his own age or whatnot there could be a situation

where it's just harder for him to connect where when it's when he's able to fully put himself into the science of it which is what his passion is like it's i think it's a little bit easier for him to get lost in that so i always viewed it as he's that's what gets him involved in this project right like it's his love and his passion for discovery and science and everything that goes in in that right and i think that's also

why he makes the decision to to kind of do some of the things he does towards the end of the movie is because he's who else has this chance right like if you're that it's different like if you're the astronaut and you've ended up on a distant planet and you have a chance to come back home you're probably coming back home like you don't have as much pulling you there but for him he's probably thinking of it like what other person in my field gets the chance to hang out on an alien planet for a him as a person

not being cynical about life on earth or human nature or whatever else you could you could throw in there it's more about somebody that like is passionate about certain things and pours himself into that when he has the option and you know if there's not it's easier to do that also like we said when there's nobody necessarily at home so it's not like an abandonment of the human race but it's like i know i don't have a wife waiting for me i know i don't have a child waiting for me So I can do this and I can like delve into the sciency part of, of learning about this

alien race. And, you know, he does have a connection with Rocky. So yeah, it all made sense. Yeah. I thought his apprehension to go on the mission was often wasn't because like he didn't have, he didn't care what happened to me. And he won. I think it was also, also just a fear because of the, just knowing that you're making a decision that is going to, and your life is not an easy thing to do. Like, it's hard to get yourself to do it. Like, it's like, you know, it's when

you're, there's a burning building and you need to jump out of the building. Still, like, there's that fear of like, okay, but will I survive this? You know, it's, I don't know. And I don't care how smart you are in whatever field it is that you're in. That's not the same as somebody being like, hey, we want to use this, but we need you to get on the spaceship. Yeah. Go to another planet real quick. And not to mention that you might just be worried he can't do it. So much

of that movie up to that point was him being reassured that he belonged within that conversation. Because up to that point, before this began, he's been a failure. So he's a person who's never succeeded in this life. Now you're going to put the weight of the world on him. And he's also not coming back. So, and I took the decision of him staying with the aliens, at least for a brief period of time. It's because, like I mentioned, like at home, he hasn't for whatever reason. And I don't know if the book gets into it more, but for what we see, he just, you know,

he's able to connect with his kids maybe because, like you mentioned, he's really smart and he can use his curiosity and his... knowledge to, you know, they're excited about it too, where if he sat down and tried to have a conversation and just talk about, you know, his science for an hour and a half with like somebody else, they might be, their eyes might gloss over. But with Rocky, he found that connection. So I think that's kind of like, oh, this is something I couldn't, not just because of being able to be on an alien

planet and what it can mean knowledge -wise, but certainly that's part of it because he's certainly a person that it's all about learning. and in knowing things, but also because for once there was the thing that he cannot do it on his home planet. He was able to do. So I thought that all kind of made sense. And at first when like that ending was happening, I'm like, do we really, it's like, is this Lord of the Rings? We're getting, we're getting like 8 ,000 different endings, but as it kept going and we got into

that final spot, I'm like, okay, this is actually, this is actually better. This, this makes sense. This is a better spot than him just returning home, like I said, and going up to that person and be like, see, now I'm here, and trying to confront them. This is a far more satisfying and, I think, complete journey for him as a character. Last question for you. On a scale of 1 to 100%, I was 100 % sure that Rocky was dead at that one point. i thought he was dead too i could

i i thought i would 100 until um until he made the comment regarding like you need to wake up because i don't know how to get it back to your own planet like okay well then now now he's you know the way they made him look though like the the effect that they used and like how how that affected him when he left his little uh biodome yeah personal biodome was like oh like they made that so convincing I was like, oh, that is rough. I think my wife is ready to lose it at that point

for sure. But any final thoughts on Project Hail Mary? Was it kind of a wrap -up? No, no. I definitely enjoyed it. I'm looking forward to seeing it again. It's 2 hours and 20 minutes, so it's a tough watch to think, will my 6 -year -old and 10 -year -olds enjoy it? But maybe in a few years, maybe my oldest would probably like it. Yeah, definitely go and check it out. I know, like I said, it's PG -13, but I do think... I don't know why. I think it's... Well, there's a drug

reference in it. And the dead bodies? Probably would be my guess. But, yeah, I think that's probably why. And I think, too, you might be scared of a PG rating because people make up such a huge... I know when they were the... when the predator movie was big PG 13 and people like freaking out or whatever. So if it like, like, Oh, that's PG. But I don't know. It's, it's also like why the MPA is really weird. Cause I've,

I've seen like other, you know, PG 13 films that like that are far worse in the sense of like with violence and things like that. This is on the tamest side of PG 13. Yeah. Yeah. i would have like no issue i think showing i think that like you said that the dead body scene might be a little bit challenging but even that is i think handled handled pretty tamely so but man if this is like a if this could be a sign of like what 2026 has in store for us i am all

here for it like if if somehow all the other science like there's so many science fiction movies coming out this year like if three or four more of them could like deliver like project hail mary like a disclosure day and like uh you know I know that it's not sci -fi, but the Odyssey, some of these other directors could deliver like this one does. We could be in store for a great year. Have you seen any other 2026 films besides this one? I've only seen three so far. I've seen R .I .P. and I've seen... Last night I watched

the movie Mercy, which is a science fiction film with the guy that's from... Chris Pratt, right? Chris Pratt, yes. I've seen The Wrecking Crew with Jason Momoa and Dave Bautista. It was a good movie to watch while you're on the treadmill. RIP was good just to see Ben Affleck and Matt Damon together. I know Mercy got absolutely annihilated

by critics and whatnot, but I don't think it's nothing that I'm going to probably have on my top 10 or 20 list at the end of the year. it was fine for a late night watch i thought i mean project hill mary is easily sitting in the number one spot for now we'll have to wait and see what happens and like you mentioned i went to the movies earlier and i saw super mario i saw the mario galaxy movie with my kids and it was it's fine like they liked it but they didn't love it like you know there's movies you see and then They're all about it, and they want to watch it again. And this was kind of one of those.

It was very similar to Dog Man last year. They watched it once, and they never talked about it ever again. And that's been the case. And then today, I also watched Crime 101, which just became on Prime. I just saw that. We added it to our queue. I liked it. The title is exactly what it is. So if that interests you, especially if you like Michael Mann movies, it's like, OK, let's just do that. kind of um but i enjoy but this but of the four or whatever five films i've

seen of 2026 like you said by far my favorite um but you know still early in the year but if this i could see this making my top 10 like certainly it's hard to say we're we're very early early on um but i mean the martian definitely made my top 10 you made your number one it was my number one i think i still like the martian a little bit more um But to see both of them again, I think, yeah, I think it just, yeah, it's, I don't know. Maybe, maybe if I watched them also, like maybe I watched it again, it would be different,

but I, I didn't think they're very comparable. I think if you like the Martian, you're going to like how to kill Mary. And I, I'd also feel like, I don't know, like how you would dislike this movie. I could see you not loving it. Or again, maybe if you're really cynical. And like I said, it is very, it does have this Disney quality to it in a way, like with the puppet. So maybe if it's, you might find that a bit, I don't know. If you want something deeper and serious, if you're looking for Solaris or something of that nature or Interstellar 2, it's not that.

But like I said, if you like The Martian, I think this is going to work with you as well. I feel like if you can't like this film, I don't know if I want to be at any type of party with you or anything else. I feel like you're just a Debbie Downer at that point. I don't know. I definitely would recommend anybody that hasn't seen it. You shouldn't have listened to this first, but, but go watch it for sure. And it's an easy one to recommend to like just about anybody, right? Like you can, you can recommend this to your parents. You can recommend this to your coworkers.

You can recommend this to your friends. Yeah. It's, it's certainly a crowd pleaser. Like I said, it's not, it's not surprising in terms of quality that it's doing as well as it is. It's just surprising because it's, we haven't, we. We had Sinners last year, of course. That did great. It's good to see that we're seeing more and more films like this do well. So I think that's hopefully something that they'll build upon for the future. Alright. Before we completely close out, Dan, I thought I'd give a really super fast update because I feel like now that we're

in April, the box office for last year is done. So you did get the number one film right last year. Zootopia by 4 million took over. minecraft movie so there you go copia 2 is in first then minecraft movie then lilo and stitch and avatar settled in and four i was surprised by that unless it's still out in theater somewhere and i just don't know but it's got it would have 20 million behind lilo and stitch so the rest didn't really change for us superman wicked for good jurassic

world sinners fantastic foreign how to train your dragon so you do get the number one and the number seven right so good job on that one. And I'll let you have last year and I'll start on a positive note with project Hail Mary for this year. So yeah, we'll see how it goes from there. So Dan, let everybody know how they can follow you on letterbox or social media or any of that type of stuff. I'm on comic concierge on most social media platforms and on letterbox. I think my, my name is movie revolt on there. So yeah. And you can find me at optimist solo

on most things, letterbox. I'm at Kevin Thompson. You can search out the Cinema Geeks by searching Cinema Geeks or Cinema Geek Cast. And you can also visit the website we're hosted on at geekcastradio .com. So we will be back with more Western talk on our next episode. So it was just a brief stop in the modern days. And we'll try to go back, you know, 60 years like we normally do for our next episode. So that does it for this episode. Tune in next time for another chance to listen to more of the Cinema Geeks.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Western Retrospective: The Outlaw Josey Wales

    Nov 16, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Halloween Special: Rocky Horror Picture Show

    Oct 31, 202641 minAudio

    Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Halloween Spotlight: The Exorcist

    Oct 29, 202642 minAudio

    Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Halloween Spotlight: Carrie (1976)

    Oct 26, 202639 minAudio

    Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Halloween Spotlight: Texas Chainsaw Massacre

    Oct 24, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...

    Credit the people on this episode