Today on Episode 263, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the Wild Bunch. How will this first time watch for both hosts resonate? Tune in to find out! Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on X and Blue Sky! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hi, this is John Delancey and you are listening to the Geekcast Radio Network. Hello and welcome to episode 263 of the Cinema Geeks. I'm one of your Cinema Geeks optimist solo and joining me as usual is the comic concierge. Hello, Dan. How's it going? It's going well. I can officially
put the baseball season behind me now. I already put the football season behind me. So I guess when does the NBA start? I don't know. I don't know. Is it March Madness time yet, Dan? I don't know. almost there we got we got a little bit i mean as an orioles fan i put the baseball season behind me in like june so you know there you go i feel like we're both uh we're both yeah i mean i guess the cubs made the playoffs but we're both um out of the running this year for baseball and out of the running this year i feel
like for football so maybe the giants can pull off a miraculous like season i don't know the dolphins have no shot of that they beat the john they beat the cowboys opening game and like uh you know so i get we get like one a year like last year they beat the eagles in in prime time and like that was like the one of three wins so see i'm i'm fearful that the dolphins are gonna do something like that and i really don't want them to just be bad just lose everything they have they have they have accomplished that so now without their main running back i'm sure
it's going to be a wonderful sequence the rest of the year last uh last week they only had two running backs on the roster and one of them got hurt so they were literally uh made one of the wide receivers a running back i don't know that's what it is so we're not here to talk about sports though dan we are here to talk about movies and today once again we are finding ourselves in the wild wild west as said by will smith or something um i should be i should be using his like uh his wild west song as like background music for
one of these episodes did we fail not including that in the we did but it might have to be an audible at the end here find room for the wild west after we've seen all of the more serious westerns uh per se i'm not trying to hate on wild west i haven't i don't know if i've seen that since it came out yeah I remember the song though. I know that much. So we're in our revisionist Western block. So, so far you've heard us talk about a couple of different things. You've heard
us talk about the Oxbow incident and Butch Cassidy and the Sundance kid. We have six films planned for this block. So we're nearing the halfway point. And today we're staying in 1969, just like we did with Butch Cassidy and the Sundance kid. And we're covering the wild bunch before we get the lowdown of facts. from you on the wild bunch dan just remind people this is a first time watch for you correct and you knew nothing about this one going in yeah this was the first time watch i mean i knew a little bit about its reputation like for certain elements of it but
i didn't like plot wise or anything like that beyond the name i did not know it or have not seen it so this was i was happy to wipe this off my list of shame so Absolutely. First time watch for me as well. So let's let Dan lay the groundwork and then we'll come back and give you guys our opinions on what we thought after our first time watch of The Wild Bunch from 1969. So take it away, Dan. That is a lot of squibs. As this week, we continue our Western retrospective with a review of The Wild Bunch from 1969, directed
by Sam Peckinpah. The Wild Bunch is a revisionist Western about aging outlaws struggling to survive in a rapidly changing world. Set in 1913, near the end of the American frontier, the film explores loyalty, betrayal, violence, and the fading age of the Old West. The story follows Pike Bishop, played by William Holden, an aging outlaw who leads a gang of hardened criminals. After a botched robbery of a railroad office in Texas leaves several men dead, Pike and their surviving gang members escape across the border into Mexico.
Among them are Dutch, played by Ernest Borgnine. He's the loyal, independent second -in -command, and the Gorge brothers, who are impulsive and quite violent. That robbery turned out to be a trap set by... Deke Thornton, played by Robert Ryan, a former member of the Pike's gang who was captured and forced into working for the railroad, and he leads a posse of bounty hunters in their pursuit. Thornton knows Pike well, and their shared history makes the chase personal. Although Thornton wants to capture his former
friend, he's also trapped in a life he has no control over any longer. Once in Mexico, Pike and his gang accept a job from General Mapache, a corporate and brutal military commander. fighting during the Mexican Revolution. Mampaki hires them to steal a shipment of American weapons and ammunition from a train. The gang successfully carries out the robbery, but the situation becomes increasingly dangerous as his men grow suspicious of the political violence around them, and it intensifies greatly. The gang's trouble deepens
when Angel, one of Pike's men, secretly gives some of the stolen weapons to the Mexican rebels because of his hatred for Mapache and his sympathy for the revolution. When Mapache discovers the betrayal, he captures and tortures Angel. Pike and the others are forced to choose between protecting themselves and remaining loyal to their friend. Pike initially tries to negotiate Angel's release, hoping to avoid a confrontation with heavily armed soldiers, but when the negotiations collapse and Angel is killed, Pike and his men finally reach their breaking point. Rather than abandon
their comrade, they decide to confront Mapache and his entire army, knowing the decision will ultimately cost them their lives. The film culminates in an extraordinarily violent shootout, which Pike and his remaining members of the gang launch a desperate attack against the soldiers. Their final stand becomes an act of defiance against a world that has left them behind. Meanwhile, Thorin and his posse arrive in the aftermath, bringing the story full circle as the outlaws pursuit. finally reaches its end. The opening robbery and shootout immediately established
that this is not a traditional Hollywood western. Peckinpah wanted the gunfights to feel chaotic, ugly, and terrifying, rather than clean and heroic. He used multiple cameras running at different speeds, combining normal speed footage with slow motion and rapid editing. This gave the violence a fragmented feel. Peckinpah was an extremely demanding director, and the set sometimes became nearly as confrontational as the film itself. According to accounts, William Holden threatened to leave if Peckinpah continued verbally abusing the crew in front of him. Robert Ryan threatened
to punch Peckinpah after being kept in costume and makeup for days without filming, which interfered with his plans to campaign for Robert F. Kennedy. Ernest Borgnine threatened to fight the director because the dust on the location was making it difficult to breathe. The climactic battle was an enormous undertaking. The production used hundreds of extras, explosions, and multiple cameras to capture the carnage. The film was initially budgeted around $3 .5 million, but reportedly ended up almost $3 million over budget, The Opening Massacre and The Final Battle accounted
for most of that expense. When it was released in 1969, reception was divided but enthusiastic. Some critics praised the filmmaking and the emotional depth, while others were concerned with the violence. The Wild Bunch was a commercial success, making around $11 million on that $6 million budget. and did receive two Academy Award nominations for Best Original Screenplay and Best Score. It did not win either. It also has some pretty notable supporters, including Martin Scorsese. But what do Kevin and I think? Back to us to
discuss. Thank you for that. As always, Dan, the first time watch of The Wild Bunch is out of the way now. It's time for opinions and all of that. And I just kind of wanted to start things off with. something that i kind of saw after the fact after i watched the film and kind of looked through some of the different receptions and reviews that people had had both in its time back in 1969 and then kind of more modern takes and things of that nature and there seems to
be a lot of different opinions on what this film is ultimately trying to say or trying to do and i wanted to kind of get your opinion on where you fall on that in a couple different angles i've heard Different critics and things say that this was kind of a mourning of the Old West, like saying goodbye, mourning it, like putting it out to pasture type thing. Another that thought it was doing that in a way, but more so condemning
it. Others that thought it was doing a combination of that. And then when it comes to the violence and the bloodshed and all of that, that there was two different camps, one that thought that, Peckinpah was basically condemning that and talking about that as a, as a bad thing and others that said, but he was also almost glorifying it or romanticizing it and in different ways, or maybe he was again, doing a little of both. So as you
kind of view this in this revisionist mindset, what do you think the wild bunch is ultimately trying to do? And what was Peckinpah's kind of motive for making this film? Going through this, it seems like it is trying to de -romanticize a lot of the West in a lot of different ways. With all the Westerns we've seen, it's interesting this comes out the same year as Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid. And we have this movie about these bank robbers. And, you know, they
rob banks, but they have a good time. They're very entertaining. They're kind of like aw shucks type of people. You still root for them even though they're doing bad things. They're the classic anti -hero. This, to me, was showing what those people may actually be like in the sense of these are bad people. They are individuals that are committing acts of violence. There's individuals who are surrounded by violence, whose violence is their way of life. So most likely
they're not going to be the most upstanding citizens. to try to showcase what a violent life would actually be like. Now, is it realistic to what actually happened? I don't necessarily know, but I think it's more of a reaction to much of the ideal created in classic Westerns, like the John Ford Westerns and things like that. So it does feel like it is time to de -romanticize in this deconstruction period of the Western genre. It does seem like that's there. The wild
bunch is fitting because they are wild. They're bad people in a lot of ways, or most of them are. Certainly, you can see elements of nuance with certain characters, but even the ones that are supposed to be the quote -unquote good guys, even if it's hard to indicate who that would be, is it the individuals that are stealing? Is it the people working for the railroad? Both of them seem very much on the same line. It's really just where their allegiance lies that defines them. or is either allegiance all that
great uh so that was what i felt like it was romanticizing the western and trying to really show that it would be a brutal life in a brutal lifestyle with brutal people so that was my takeaway how about yourself yeah i i agree with what you're saying i think when i think of this in conjunction with the other Two films we've watched so far in the block. I feel like the Oxbow incident and which Cassidy and the Sundance kid are almost
more revisionist, more fitting the title of the block and this revisionist title. And then the wild bunch does for me. I'm not saying that's not trying to de -romanticize or, or do some of the things that you just described, but I don't see that as necessarily being different than some of the other films we've seen as well. So I question how much of maybe revisionist this is, but I don't think that doesn't make it good or bad. I don't think that has an impact on me on what I was viewing. But I see a lot of connections
between this and some of the other films that we have seen. I think in one way you can connect this to Shane, for example, in the idea that... in the film shane the the title character himself we talked about a couple different times is kind of finding himself as someone who exists in a world that no longer exists like we've talked
about that like he's his profession and his lifestyle and stuff it has been is fading away it's becoming a thing of the past and how is he going to deal with that and it seems like there's a little of that here as well Because of the fact that we're now getting into this situation where we're dealing more with machine guns and modern aspects where the old gunslinger is really not as prevalent.
And how are they adapting to that change in time? And then, you know, how are they going to cope with that? You also do see elements, I guess, just... We just watched it with Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid and a couple of different films that we've seen throughout this as far as the whole being hunted or being chased motif that we've talked about a couple different times because we definitely have that, right? Like the Wild Bunch themselves have a bounty on them. There's people that are trying to find them,
take care of them, and you almost get that sense where it's like no matter what they do or how far they go, they're eventually going to find themselves backed in a corner. and and what do they do with that right so we get a little of that so i did see elements of a number and those are just two examples off the top of my head i'm sure we could connect it to a few of the other films as well i don't think it's romanticizing it in a way that we would have seen in a lot of john wayne films or things of that nature but i don't know how much it distanced itself from some of the non -john wayne films we've
seen like even the spaghetti westerns i can see some connections between this and that so um I guess when it comes to that, I don't know what it, you know, I don't, I'm not inside the director's mind. I don't know what his ultimate, you know, ultimate motive was and how he was trying to, what message he was trying to say when it came to violence or when it came to the old West or different things of that nature. I, um, I don't think it necessarily glorifies the violence. I don't think it necessarily like it's violent.
Like the violence exists, but I don't think it's doing it in a way where you're like, gonna go out and try to mimic that or or or think that it was like this thing that you're looking up to and like it's not like the little kid in shane who's calling out shane you're not like a wild bunch like let me let me do that let me get in on that gang i don't think that's something that's happening um you don't want from anybody that watches this so um so that's kind of my first impression when it comes to that before i get too much further though i guess i'm also curious like What was your actual take of the film from
an enjoyment factor and especially compared to the other revisionist films that we've talked about? Yeah. So it's interesting. It's a tough one, to be honest with you, because of all the films I think we've done in the Western retrospective so far, it's the one I struggle with the most answering that question, which may seem weird because I think there are some really well directed. action scenes, you certainly see how this influences people like Tarantino and Robert Rodriguez and
how it utilizes violence. And I think there are, and I do think, like I mentioned, it's effective in how it tries to build these characters that are hugely flawed and not even heroes and kind of approach the Western in its own way to be different, to stand out. I think it's effective in all those manners. But at the same time, I do think it gets a bit. like too nihilistic for me and at certain points where it's a difficult watch it's it's like we've watched you know it's
not like we haven't seen challenging films within this you know torture and and whatnot but like i guess the way especially the way it approaches like the relationship with women and like you know there's a lot of violence in that and it's and i don't think necessarily with a movie you need to have someone to root for but like I don't know. I just, it felt like the best thing I can compare it to is like you're watching, we talked, we opened this talking about football and sports. It's like you're watching a sports game or whatever
you want to call it, watching a football game and you don't really have a rooting interest for either team. You don't either root for or against either team. You don't even like have any fantasy people or anything like that. So you're just watching it so you can appreciate it for what you. like just because it's football and you enjoy watching football, but you don't have any events investment into it. And that was my like overall relationship with this film. Like, I think I could appreciate it on a craft level. I think it was able to accomplish what
it set out to do, or at least what I thought it was sending out to do in my eyes. But my issues with it are, I think more so completely like on a subjective level and my ability to like, I wasn't really engaging with it or like, Oh, I was like, deep within the desire to keep going and there's been films we watched in this where i'm like i am fully in and with this it's like i just kind of hope they all die uh i guess which kind of comes true i guess but i don't know it's that it's just i had this like lack of investment
and again it may have been just the mood in which i was watching it the way it was done maybe if i watched it again that wouldn't occur like i wouldn't be against watching it again but it didn't i wasn't enthralled with it on a like a an emotional level compared to some of the other films and again i'm not saying that's necessarily a byproduct of the quality of the movie but more so the way i experienced it myself but how about yourself what was your overall take of this i think you made a really good point using that
sports analogy because it's definitely something like i think sometimes when you're a sports fan or when you're a fan of a specific sport or something in general or maybe just general i don't know athletic in your past or something like people assume that you like watching all sports yeah and like that's just not the case like and you like you said you almost have to have a rooting
interest i think i can watch most nfl games again there's fantasy connections or there's something that you're watching for or whatever the case may be i get like i can watch the super bowl and not have a rooting interest necessarily but if somebody just were to ask me like hey there's a mariners angels game on for baseball i'm gonna be like okay like i don't Think that's where
I want to go with my two hours of time or three hours of time. Right. Like, um, or, or like the difference between like the NBA and NCAA, like just because you like one doesn't, you don't like the other. And it is hard to get like excited about something that you, like, we all have our teams and we have our, our players and we have different things that we like can get really excited about when it comes to that. And when that element is removed, it's really difficult. And I think this film suffered for me in a number of different ways. I typically don't care about
runtime, like usually not a big deal for me at all. I did feel the runtime in this one. Like I felt that we were watching a movie that was, what is this? Two and a half hours long to something like that. Like I was aware of that, like not, not because I saw it or something ahead of time, but I was, as I was watching, I was like, this is lengthy, like this. And I feel the length. So like that, that part was a little, problematic for me I think another huge problem for me and
why I couldn't get a rooting interest was like you said like I don't know if I cared about anybody in this film like character wise performance wise any of the things I just couldn't connect like I enjoyed watching Ernest Borgnine a little bit and I'm not saying any of the performances were bad but they also we're not dealing with a whole bunch of charismatic guys here we're not dealing with a whole bunch of people that have like some clever aspect of their personality
or way they speak or something that's like i don't know like there was just not much and i think part of the problem was for like the first act of the film i honestly couldn't tell the difference between about three of the characters i'm like did they intentionally choose people that looked almost identical to each other i had yeah i had i'm not i was not I had a similar experience with certain ones. I'm like, wait, no, that's not okay. I thought he was aligned with those guys, but he's aligned with them. I'm like, okay. So I'm going to use another analogy
that's probably really ridiculous, but we have an emulator that has a bunch of old games on it that we've been somewhat introducing my daughter to. Just some classic video games, just in general. Things like Mario Brothers and whatnot. And we decided to play a Link... start playing a link to the past the other day like a week or two ago zelda link to the past and i've played through that game a number of different times over my
life like probably at least three start to finish if not four or five and i could probably figure all of it out right like if i wanted to just with no help of what anything like we existed in a time period where you had to figure it out on your own or eventually you had like the nintendo power that maybe you could get yeah but that almost even didn't exist when I feel like when I was playing through this, because I remember a friend and myself in our basement, hand drawing maps of like the dungeons and the worlds and
the things that we needed to know to figure out where to go and what was where and all that other stuff. Like we were hand drawing it. Nowadays, you can just go on any internet site, you know, Google. whatever and say like how do i get through this dungeon or how do what do i do after i get this or whatever like there's a lot of ways to just bypass all the thought process and just take shortcuts i guess and there was definitely times where we're playing through this and because i'm just playing it with you know my six -year -old and it's not that crucial that we like do
everything perfect there was definitely times where i was like i don't want to be like struggling for this for like the next hour like where do i go next just give me the hint right and i felt like watching the first half of this movie or at least the first act i wanted the guide like i i wanted the magazine i could pause and stop and say hold on who is who what's going on who's on what side and give me like the 411 on like what i'm supposed to know at this point in the
movie because i feel like i even though i've been watching this i am lost like i know some of that is intentional i know they want it to be chaotic in the beginning i know they want it to be like A little crazy, but it was a struggle for me at first to get my bearings with this film. Did you have any problems with that? I mean, in the sense of it opens up, obviously, on, I think, really great sequence that is, you know, bloody and violent with you see these individuals
are coming in with their, I think, Calvary uniforms or whatever. And yeah, like it. There's a lot of hints at certain things, and you certainly get the idea of, like, this is the group that is notorious for what they're doing, because clearly they're making all this. So it was a little challenging in the sense of really understanding the place or really understanding where the film wants to put us in the sense of, like, who are
we? Like, what side are we on here? Like in the sense of. What side is the film on? Is it on a side? And I guess ultimately it's not really on a side. So that's where I kind of struggled a bit. In that end. Which I think hurt the investment. What was the other film that we watched. Where they. The opening sequence is basically. A group of one gang. That's disguised as another gang. Or disguised as. They're using different uniforms. And it was also confusing in that film. When
they did that at first. I'm struggling to remember which one that was. That is not Once Upon a Time, is it? Once Upon a Time is where we're at the train station for a while. They're hanging out, waiting. Which one's the ones where they disguise themselves as another gang to implicate a different gang? You know what I'm talking about? Isn't that that one? I don't know if it's that. I don't
think so. there was like three people that are dressed up as a different p as a different group and then they we get ourselves to like the main character who is and there's like a one gang is trying to like clear their name like it wasn't us because the other folks had dressed up i know it happened i'm gonna have to like go back through my notes now but like there was a little bit of an aspect of that here which i don't think and i i think the main problem i had was that i was convinced that i watched every member of
the one gang which is only a small group i thought i saw them all die and then they all right away 100 okay and i'm like did they have like 40 other people with them that i didn't know that all got killed in this battle instead i was so yeah i think it was yeah it was mostly you know the that group of civilians basically that kind of got caught in the crossfire yeah They got it brutally. I think where I I didn't have an issue
necessarily with that. I had more of it like a confusion regarding the allegiances when it came to like all the different Mexican armies and things regarding who was on whose side and like where the civilians or where the U .S. government like where the U .S. government more so or the train corporation. working with the one general like were they that like those as Expanded further
and we had all these different parties kind of conversing That's where I was like, okay. Wait, who's who's with who they're double -crossing these people? Are they are they simply just double -crossing now though? So there's a lot of like shaky alliances and it's of understanding like are they a bigger plan here or are they just making this this call so it that like that there are like I could see why you would feel the length, as you said, because there are so many moving parts. We're not. We are going to all these different
factions where we're going to all these different lands. We have so much going on within this world beyond just like the main through line of like this wild bunch trying to do that one last job before they go free. So there are there's a lot going on here, I think, for sure. And. I think with that, it takes a bit to get caught up with the movie because then we start getting those flashbacks and things. So I think that was helpful when you had a better understanding of how we got to this point. But that was really just two
major characters. But yeah, I never felt like I was super confused, but I think it could be a bit overwhelming regarding all the things that were happening within one given moment in time. yeah i mean i think i got my bearings eventually it just took me longer than i anticipated to figure out like who's what and where and who how and all the other stuff and like i said it didn't help that like pike deke and the train guy all had the same like haircut and mustache and everything and i'm just like this is yes really confusing to me for a second speaking
of pike and deke though um i will give the movie credit because with those i think those two characters are probably the strength of the film I wasn't necessarily drawn to either of them or invested in them. Like as much as I have been with some of the other characters and some of the other films we've talked about. But when you think of these two individuals who are former partners who now find themselves kind of on opposite sides, because one of them is trying to basically track down the other, I did find it intriguing that,
and maybe it was intentional why they look so close to the same person because in reality, I mean, in all, honesty these guys are sort of playing two versions of the same person right yeah like they're they're playing two individuals with the same type of history and same type of background what happens if one of them goes this way and one of them goes that way and kind of they find themselves on opposing things but they ultimately could be the same person just making different choices so i did think that that was somewhat a strength of the film it's kind of
their dynamic between each other and kind of How that's going to play out. I don't know if I got as much of that. As I would have even liked. Maybe a little bit more. But I did feel like that was. Something that was intriguing about the film. What did you think about those two characters? Yeah. I'm a big fan of William Holden. And I know him best for his work in Network. So there's that. So that may be also why. But I did like that dynamic. And his character in general to me. I think was the strength of the
film. Because. You saw he you saw him like with this living in regret because it was his mistake that got Thornton to where he's at. His kind of overconfidence, his his not understanding the threat at the time gets him caught, gets him tortured. And he has that bearing over him. But now Thornton is coming back to try to try to capture him as a way of just getting free from that, that bondage, the bondage that he
put him in. so i found like that general conflict quite compelling because it's not the type of rivalry where thornton is like uh he's made him evil like you could really overplay that and it doesn't like i don't think thornton is in favor of what he's doing but he has to do it he has no no choice and perhaps a part of him wants to like seek that element of revenge but it doesn't seem like that is His driving force. It's not a revenge film. Which it could easily
have been. So I do think that. I was going to ask that. Because when I was looking at stuff. They kind of classified the final act. Or the ending. As. I guess like the question that I was seeing. As I was reading through stuff. Was like is the final act an act of loyalty. An act of suicide. Or an act of revenge. Or a combination of all three. And then at the same time. Is that final stand heroic. tragic foolish or Some combination
or just impossible to categorize. So you do not see the final act as one as revenge necessarily. Well, I'm more so Revenge the sense of Robert or Ryan's character Thor and like his influence like it's not like The conflict, you know the conflict that's driving us for most of the film is Thor in and piker or Thor in trying to capture Pike and He's not doing it because he's not like hiring. He's like, oh I want this job because I want to get revenge on the guy who got me caught and got me tortured. So the final act, like,
where does that fall? That's a good question. Like, I, I don't know. I don't know if I saw it partially as revenge. I think partially as upset acceptance of just like the reality of situation or just, I think one of those things where it's like, all right, well, let's, we're just a bit fed up. Like it's like, we've, we've done as much as we can. this is the reality that we're in. Uh, and then we're going to see, this is, this is what happens also with, uh, this is our answer to what happens if butch and cast,
which casting the Sundance kid doesn't freeze frame at the end. Yeah. This is the result. Yeah. I do think there is some revenge there, of course, because they're trying to, you know, stick up for their, uh, for angel and what, what, what he went through. Uh, but so I think of that element, what it would like, the angel character his connection to teresa his connection to this mapachi and their outfit or gang or whatever like you feel
like that's where i guess the morality of the film comes in yeah and also where they're able to use this mapachi character and his minions as a way to also get us to be a little bit more sympathetic to the wild bunch who in all other aspects is not really a morally upstanding group of folks but yeah when you compare it to what that other groups do yeah it's like it's like
the the lesser you know the defining the lesser evil so i think it it does work as in that element in like angel it was one that was Was hard to pin down and like that's I think that that's ultimately much of this point It's not it's trying to add a lot of nuance say pretty much everything Maybe it overloads with nuance if anything, which is not necessarily a complaint, but just an observation but with angel to because he began the of that moment where he pulls out the gun and kills the
woman and You know out of out of anger and perhaps revenge too, but then you're not not too long later seeing him kind of being tortured and then also the decision that dutch has to make or earners born nine where it comes to like walking away allowing him to be captured and going through it is like was that an act of survival was that an act of like do we he plans on coming back and saving him like so it does give you a lot of these questions to explore with no complete
answer which is not necessarily which is usually a good thing and i do think there is some intrigue there which is why i think even like a rewatch would be helpful just to maybe being able to better understand the perspective but but yeah i i don't know if i ever fully got like what the general like the relationship between the wild bunch and the apache like what they're were they really planning on helping them like you know it's that's where i think things get a bit muddled it's not necessarily super important
to the overall film but i don't think it was a strength here no i don't think so either speaking of the violence dan like obviously in 1969, the movie's violence I was reading was more revolutionary, shocking, definitely impactful to the audience at that time. We live in a different time now, and we've been exposed to a lot more violence in films and everything. Do you feel like the movie's violence still has the same impact on
an audience today that it did in 1969? How do you think that plays? I think it has a... uh it could still have an impact but in a different method like i mentioned like just like the scene of uh angel like shooting that woman like i think that would be hugely impactful to today's audience that's not something you would ever see and if you did you would never then be expected to have any sympathy for that character most likely but then we come around and have to do that was that
the expectation when that was originally made maybe not um so i do i do think the violence obviously wouldn't be nearly in general as impactful as comparing it to other movies of this time when it came out because you're thinking about like we did with the true grid and even like butch cassidy their their violence is like a two compared to this like it's no nowhere near is thinking other movies i've seen at the times like the other james bond movies like rarely did you see blood if you did it was never to this level and never to this degree so i it can't
it's hard to even like it's something that you almost have to connect it to like a mobster movie yeah you know what i mean like a really heavy violent like mobster gangster movie because that's the only other time that i remember seeing like i guess you know once you get machine guns involved it's a different kind of violence i guess i guess there's a connection to uh django a little bit but yeah yeah django is a good comparison but also i can also see why like someone like a tarantino would go so above and behind above and beyond
with his violence and something like django unchained because like this is what he's trying to talk you know in a lot of ways so you know for some people people have seen django unchanged or some other like other horror films that exist like the saws of the world i don't know if it's they're gonna there's probably some people the general have been desensitized but like i said i think there's elements that would still be quite shocking but they're just talking in a different way yeah absolutely um other other thoughts that you have like what have you seen any of uh peckinpah's
other films i haven't honestly i was realizing like he like his most of his films are ones that i have yet to catch up with like straw dogs i know is something that he's known for um which is i have not seen so i am interested to kind of catch up with his other work just to see like how it compares and things like that because Like I mentioned, I do know he is highly regarded by a lot of filmmakers, and you see that influence for sure. So I do actually plan on watching Straw
Dogs, because it's one of those things where I've seen the remake, but not the original, which is never the right way to go. But no, I'm... Well, there's only four films that he both directed and wrote. He directed a bunch of other ones, but there's only four, and reading the titles is interesting. Major Dundee, The Wild Bunch. Straw Dogs, and then the last one, Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia. I don't know anything about that one, but that's an interesting title. Well, yeah, at least I have an idea of what the
goal is in that. But yeah, I think I even like this a little bit more than you did, but do you have any interest in going down his filmography, or do you think you're kind of one and done? I don't know. I didn't find it... I didn't think it stood out in a bad or a good way in my opinion. Without seeing more, I don't know. I wouldn't
have been able to identify like, hey, this is kind of an auteurist or this is a certain style that I'm watching. Yes, there's some slow motion and there's some, I guess you could call it energetic editing and things of that nature. But it's also hard because... you know we've seen a lot more movies that came out afterwards and things of that nature so i don't know if it stood out more in that time versus like what it does now i so i'm not like anti watching any of his other films
but it's not something that i saw something specific that was like oh i gotta see more so i'm kind of like a little bit indifferent but intrigued because i did you know obviously read up that he was very well regarded that there is some um some other Articles, too, that make it seem like he maybe wasn't the easiest to work with or to deal with. I'm also intrigued because, I don't know, I'm assuming, do you know if you watched the director's cut or just the theatrical? I'm not sure. I watched the long version, Dan.
It was long. I'm just kidding. Which makes me maybe watch the theatrical or the director's cut. I don't know. Possibly. But I watched, I just watched, because anytime I watch a movie. like for the first time i try to watch the theatrical cut first so that's what i i did but i would be interested to see how much different like how much is added to the director's cut um it's a good point i didn't i guess i didn't even realize there was two versions i should get get up on that because it seems like every movie we watched recently has two versions yeah so uh i don't know if i don't think they did uh did what was
it the battle of the planet of the apes when they completely changed the ending and like did bad adr i don't think no i doubt that happened Overall, do you feel like you're positive on this in general? Or do you feel like you're still trying to figure that out? I think in the sense of the quality of it, I would be positive. I think regarding the list of my personal feelings on a subjective level. I wouldn't say negative. I would say more so neutral. It's not one that
I have a strong affection towards. And like I said, my issues are more... subjective than like objective issues with the quality of the filmmaking it's just it's like some things are for you some things aren't and i think part of you know part of watching movies is understanding like okay this is just not for me and that's okay and i think that's where i come down with this it's like i get why people love it i get why so many would put this really high but for me like in what i'm looking for and what i've enjoyed thus far it's not there i don't know what like when
we do our rankings at the end would it where it would fall i think it Won't be on the bottom, but I know it won't be in the top, but I'll figure it out. Speaking of an exercise that I'm going to need a cheat book guide to is once we get done with this, trying to go back and remember. I've been sort of trying to take notes along the way and rank them, but the longer this block gets, it seems like a very intimidating process. I know for me, there's definitely films within...
the retrospective that we've watched so far that i would either recommend or i would be interested at some point to watch again i don't think this one's on that list like i don't think i'm like i know you said you might get more appreciation for a second watch which i'm not disagreeing that that could be a thing i don't know if i would like he raised my hand volunteering to watch this a second time anytime soon um yeah just because for me it's not one that I just gravitated towards to the point where, you know,
I think back to some of the ones we watched in the beginning, like the searchers and stagecoach and stuff like that, which it was like, I could see myself wanting to watch one of those fairly soon again, just because of now watching through all these other ones. But I don't see the wild bunch of being on that list for me. All right. So what, what about next week? What do we have on the docket? so next week will be another first time watch for me uh we're jumping into the 70s here 1976 for the outlaw josie wales dan what's
your experience with that one this is another one that i have not seen before so i am double first time watch back to back yeah so it feels good i'm glad to give this this is another one that i've heard similar things for uh and like again like it's noted as like one of Clint Eastwood's best among it. People are like, oh, well, Good and the Bad and the Ugly is great, but also make sure to watch The Outlaw of Josie Wales. So excited, because he's also the director of this as well. So I'm curious to see how that compares to, obviously,
the other Clint Eastwood films we've done so far. Yeah, I'm intrigued as well. This is one that's been on my list of shame for a long time, so I'll be happy to check that box and give it a go here over the next little bit. So that's what we have coming up. next and then after that we kind of jump way into modern times we're going to cover the harder they fall from 2021 and then we're going to go back to a more i guess modern classic is that what you can call that um unforgiven from 1992 which i guess is not modern anymore i don't know i don't know can we call it i feel
like not calling 90 i feel like if we classic from our lifetime from our i don't know I'm sick of it modern if it came out when we were old enough to watch it. Which makes sense, though, because to give everybody an even further peek behind the curtain, we're going to go from Unforgiven, which is our last of the revisionist block, which did happen in 1992, which then leads us into a perfect transition to four other 90s films. So we're going to spend five films in a row in
the 90s, and that'll be fun to do after we've seen so many classic films. Definitely looking forward to that. Dan, how can people get in touch with us or leave feedback, comments, questions, etc.? You can find our information on Facebook and on Instagram by searching Cinema Geeks Podcast. And you can reach out to me. I am Common Concierge on pretty much all the social media platforms that matter. And you can reach out to me at Optimus Solo as well for all of those different things.
That does it for this episode. Tune in next time for another chance to listen to more of The Cinema Geek.
Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...
Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...
Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...
Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...
Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...