Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

CINEMA GEEKS

CINEMA GEEKS artwork

Western Retrospective: Shane

Sep 20, 202654 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Today on Episode 257, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up is one of the most critically acclaimed westerns of all-time, Shane. Is Shane a film that is benefitting more for being one of the earliest influences on the genre or is it truly a masterpiece? Tune in to find out! Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on X and Blue Sky! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hi, this is Jim Meskimen, voice of the Blue Genie, and what geeks are you listening to? I'll tell you. You're listening to The Cinema Geeks. Always know what geeks you're listening to. It's very important. Hello, and welcome to episode 257 of The Cinema Geeks. I am one of your Cinema Geeks optimists, Solo, and joining me as usual is the Comic Concierge. Hello, Dan. Hey, how's

it going? It is going, going well. It's storming here, so hopefully none of that comes across in the record. It's been very stormy all day for sure, but that's fine because it finally got us away from like some record heat that we were experiencing recently. So I'm all for that if it makes it, if it like puts us into Florida's version of the fall, I guess. i don't know which is really just hurricane season so whatever fingers crossed but yeah that's what's going on with

me and i i believe all your kiddos are in school now right yeah yeah we're fully back in school it's kind of crazy summer kind of flew by this year doing the back to school night all that fun stuff my oldest is now middle school and that hurts me dearly in a lot of different ways so it's uh it's crazy so that's been you know I thought it was bad that my daughter wasn't going into first grade, but middle school I can't even fathom. It's crazy. In the blink of an eye.

Growing up, I didn't have middle school. I did, but technically didn't because we had elementary school, which was K -6 grade, and then we went into junior high, high school. So 7th grade to 12th grade was all in the same school. And realizing as an adult, like, that's a bad idea. Because, like, yeah, most classes were separated, but not all. Like, we had gym class together. And I'm thinking, like, why would they put seventh graders and, like, 18 -year -olds? Like, that's

crazy talk. But it was a very small school. I think every school does it, like, it seems like it does it a little bit different. I also went to a super small school. And we only had two buildings, two school buildings in the town. and one of them was k through eight and then the other one was high school and the difference in the k through eight building was i mean it was multiple stories like yeah i think you i think there was at least enough stairs to go up like four levels three or four levels and

there was one part of the school that was the what we called our junior high which was sixth seventh and eighth grade Okay. So sixth, seventh, and eighth grade had like a different level or a different section of the school. And then the K through five was all kind of on the lower levels. So they kept us separated fairly well. And then it was in sixth grade was when you started changing classes for every period. So sixth, seventh, and eighth grade, you had like a different teacher for every subject and all that kind of stuff. Whereas, you know, K through five, you didn't

have that. A little bit with fourth and fifth, I think we changed for like math and maybe English. But other than that, I guess. you just basically just had your your own classrooms then we had to travel uh two blocks down the road to go to the high school which was one block from my house and that just kind of tells you how small this town was so there you go there was no uh there was no need for a bus for me like i could i could either walk a block but i either had to walk a block to high school or i had to walk like maybe six blocks to k through eight so interesting

i don't think they would make me walk in kindergarten but ours was just a lot of small towns together because like i couldn't walk to my schools because it was too far my elementary school like one time for uh we rode our bikes the last day of school because this will bring it back to movies because the last day of school was on a wednesday and on the way back like it was like the town and the town is like the it was the place that had a grocery store and a movie store because that was basically all that existed but on wednesdays

you got like half it's like two dollar rentals or something like that oh so it's like the first day of summer we're gonna do like we we're gonna have a sleepover my one friend so we're like all the neighborhood so it's gonna be like four or five kids and we're gonna do a sleepover and like so he went to rent a bunch of movies and like video games and stuff like that and we did our bikes to do that and uh yeah i think it was one of the things lost yeah lost element of life like i remember doing that so much And then I brought nothing back on time and had these really

bad fees, and my parents got really mad at me. So that, yeah. That was the catch. That was definitely the catch. But then the police went out of business, so we didn't have to pay. Oh, well, there you go. You got out of it. There you go. I remember the thing was always going to rent something on a Friday or a Saturday night when you were about to have the sleepover, right? And for us, if you were doing a game. The object was to beat that game and that like one to two days before you had to return it. So I was, uh, yeah, we, we had a video rental place too. It wasn't blockbuster,

but it was, uh, it was a video store of some sort. And, uh, yeah, I was just called one called solid state. And then we had another one that was called McDonald's video, but, and it wasn't had nothing to do with it. It's this kid. It really confused me. Cause I'm like, wait, how does McDonald's has a video store and it's, but it was just the last name of the people that owned it. I don't know the story behind why ours was called what it was, but ours was called WHO, like W -H -O, WHO Video. That was the name of the video rental place. Don't ask me any questions.

I don't know. All right. But yeah, speaking of movies. Yeah. We're here to talk about some more of our Western retrospective. So we've been bouncing back and forth between talking about planets of apes and talking about... The Wild West. So today it's back to The Wild West. And this is the last in our, we're going to rename it the Dimitri Tiomkin block, but this film wouldn't work for that. So it's our second classic block

here. We've talked about Red River and High Noon and Rio Bravo. And today we are going to talk about the 1953 film, Shane. So just remind everybody, Dan, what was your experience with Shane going into this one? So I have seen this before, but it's been like 15 years, so I didn't really remember. I got a good idea of what the general plot is because it's pretty straightforward, but I didn't remember much of the details, so it's been a while. Okay, and it was a blind spot for me, as have most of the Western retrospective films

been. So before we get into our thoughts after we watch the film, let's let Dan lay the groundwork and spit some facts. Did kids ever say that? I don't know. Here's just the facts about Shane. Personally, I don't get what the big deal is. I love soda pop because this week we continue our Western retrospective with a look at Shane from 1953. directed by George Stevens. The story takes place in the Wyoming territory in the late 19th century. Shane is this mysterious gunslinger

trying to leave his violent past behind. He arrives in the valley where homesteader Joe Starrett lives with his wife and young son, Joey. Shane takes a job working for the Starrett family and quickly becomes very close to them, Joey especially. Joey sees him as this hero, this person to look up to. Shane hopes to live peacefully, but the valley is being torn apart by a conflict between the homesteaders and a wealthy cattle rancher, Rufus Riker. You should have known something when his name was Rufus. Riker wants the homesteaders

off the land because their small farms interfere with his cattle operation. He employs imitation and violent tactics, using a ruthless gunfighter, Jack Wilson, to terrorize the settlers. Wilson even eventually kills the homesteader. named Stonewall Tori, escalating the conflict even further. At the funeral, the settlers discuss abandoning their struggle and leaving the valley altogether, but after witnessing one of their own homes being destroyed by fire due to Riker's men, they find a new resolve and continue the

fight. Riker concludes, Sterret is primarily the one responsible for keeping their resolve. With the purpose of killing him, Riker invites Starrett into a meeting at the saloon with the idea of negotiating a settlement. Both, though, know better. Shane included, and he intervenes, getting in a fight with Starrett, and it's a drop -em -out, drag -out fight, but Shane does walk away the victor and rides into town instead. Shane kills Wilson, Riker, and Riker's brother,

but is injured in the process. Shane sees Joey, who notices that Shane is bleeding. Shane bids farewell and rides out into the valley, ignoring Joey's desperate cries of Shane. Shane comes back, but Shane... does not come back. Director George Stevenson didn't initially want Alan Ladd as Shane. His first choice were actors Monka Marie Cliff and William Holden, and they were going to play the role but became unavailable, so eventually the role went to Ladd. Perhaps the reason he wasn't a first choice was due to

his height. Ladd is 5 '6", 5 '7", where many of his co -stars are much taller, 6 '2", 6 '3". In order to avoid seeing the obvious height difference, he would often stand on risers, which proved to be effective because Shane became such a prominent figure within the film and within the Western genre. Although it may seem very conventional for today, there's many things Shane did that were out of the ordinary for its era, especially the sound effects. Stevens didn't want the normal bang -bang sound effects you would get in most

westerns, so instead they recorded new sounds that sounded more like a cannon being fired to make it sound more visceral. Shane was well -received when it first came out, although it wasn't universal praise. Some did feel it was too slow and its solemn style became a little excessive, but there were pretty positive reviews, including that of Bosley Cawthor from the New York Times, who praised the film's understanding of the conflict between the homesteaders and the cattlemen. of that era. It also received a number of Academy Award nominations and won one. It received an

award for Best Cinematography, which it won, but also was nominated for Best Picture, Best Director, Best Supporting Actor for Brandon DeWild, and Best Supporting Actor for Jack Palance, and also Best Adapted Screenplay. It eventually lost Best Picture from here to eternity. The film performed quite well at the box office as well, earning around $9 million in the US and Canada. But what do Kevin and I think? Back to us to discuss. Hey, thanks for that, Dan. Those are

the facts for Shane. And now we're going to get into our thoughts and opinions on it. A rewatch after about 15 years for you and a first time watch for me. So Dan, I wanted to start off. Obviously, we can acknowledge that this is oftentimes listed amongst. the best westerns of all time it gets you know put in a lot of those best of lists top 10 top 20 whatever it might be when it when we're specifically talking about the western genre and so i'm curious i don't have no idea what your take is on the movie if you

like to dislike that somewhere in the middle but as one of those westerns that has such a massive reputation and a film that's like deeply ingrained in the in the history of the genre I'm curious whether you think its reputation comes more from how well the movie works as a story and with its characters or from what it represents and what it helped establish for the genre overall or a mix of both. So what was your take on Shane? It's a good question. And I think one thing I appreciate by the way we kind of

ended up doing this, which wasn't originally planned, like doing some classics, going a little ahead. doing some of the more spaghetti westerns and going back it's like we talked a lot about how there is this idea of how the spaghetti westerns in that era maybe uh made the western a bit more sophisticated maybe indicated that it we weren't we had heroes that weren't always this black hat white hat But then we mentioned, you know, that wasn't always the case. There were plenty of Westerns before the Spaghetti Westerns that maybe were a bit more complex and didn't deserve

the simplification of, like, that was what they are. But then we get a movie like Shane, and I can kind of understand where that mindset comes from, because I guess in a way this is going to sound inflammatory, or like I'm degrading the movie, but it's not meant to be. This is like Baby's first Western in a lot of ways, because it is very... basic in its approach or it's very straightforward and also does make sense because most of this movie is kind of being designed to be seen through the eyes of a child so with

that it is very simply you know good guy bad guy type of situation but even within that we do get a little bit of nuance at times we get you know some understanding and i do think a lot of what this did for the western that was unconventional has by by this time become conventional so just in the research some of the things that they changes that they made i do think it is an effective story and i think it's well made like and there's a lot of little things that

does well that i think help establish it ahead of some other westerns like shooting on location you feel like it feels like you're in that location it's very much of improvement to those that are more on backlot it feels like there is more time and effort put within this compared to maybe a lot of the standard westerns that we're not even talking about but ones i've seen because of this retrospective that are very like generic and by the book so i think in a lot of ways compared to some of the best of the best that we've done

so far some of the the greatest westerns that we've done i don't think it may come off as to their level in a lot of ways, because what does well has been surpassed or made a bit more complex. But I am still glad I rewatched it. I think there is a lot to take from it. But I do think if you went into this thinking you're seeing the top of the genre, I don't know if you'll get that, but I do think it's a great introductory Western,

as I mentioned, Baby's First Western, because it is... hitting the notes of the genre rather hard easily and it almost feels like a disney movie in a way it feels like it like a classic family film but maybe with a little bit edge to it but what did you think so i i wasn't prepared on you know we for a long time i felt like we talked about a lot of movies that we were kind of lockstep with uh yeah And we agreed on most of them, even going back through like the Hitchcock

retrospective, the Cary Grant retrospective. We varied on some of them here and there, like to what level we liked or disliked. But we were very much similar in a lot of those. And I felt like that kind of carried over even into this Western one. And then recently we've had a few more films that we didn't agree on. And I was very curious going into this one where it was going to land on that spectrum. And so I'm intrigued. by your statement and kind of your opening here, because I think we're probably going to have more in common with this one than not. So Shane

is a movie that I can absolutely understand respecting more than loving. I can see the craftsmanship. I can see the influence. I can see the great cinematography. They did a lot with the sound design, with the gun violence to make that feel real and things like that. I do think they do the tension fairly well in Shane. And I can see why it became such an important Western based on when it came out and the impact it has on

stuff that comes out afterwards. However, movies ultimately for me live and die based on whether I care about the people I'm watching. And I'm not sure Shane ever gave me characters that I really was so emotional invested in that I... cared too much about what happened to him um even joey even joey oh my god don't get me started i think that's that's one of the problems right and i guess i can go right to that but like everything

you said is right like that kind of disney -esque like i'm picturing like the films that i would have got on the couch with my mom when i was like i don't know seven or eight and we would get i don't know if it was movies we had rented from the library or if it was the i'm making stuff up the abc saturday night movie or the disney primetime movie or whatever but you know it would be like heidi and uh you know like baby crockett i remember that yeah yeah all of those types of films like this is kind of what that reminds me it does obviously have a much more violent edge to it so like it wouldn't have been

on the disney channel i get that but it kind of reminds me of a little bit and and you totally get the fact that in some ways they are trying to tell this story through the the child's eyes and it's supposed to be like i don't know if it's necessarily supposed to be our way in but i think it definitely is supposed to be touching on like us viewing it through the inner child that we have and like what we would have thought had we been that child in this time frame and obviously there's a lot of mythological or almost

like fairy tale aspects of Shane himself and things of that nature where it does kind of pose that question, which we've seen come up a couple times here. But one issue that I do have is we're funneling all of this through this particular character in Joey. And Brandon DeWild got nominated for a supporting actor for this role. And that is about the most mind -boggling statement I've ever made in my life. I don't understand what

was going on in 1953 that this was considered one of the best supporting roles in all of film that year. He drove me absolutely bananas. That's part of the problem, I think, for me, is one of the main focal points that we're funneling all of this stuff through, I wanted to throw off a cliff. Maybe not that dramatic. He is a child, and I'll give him some grace. But if I heard him yell out Shane one more time, I, I don't know what I was going to do, but I, I had

bad thoughts. Um, so like, I, I really didn't care for that character and like the, the way that it was performed. I understand kind of what they were going for, but it was like nails on a chalkboard for me. So that was one of the things that kind of detracted a little bit for me, at least. Um, what was your take on joy? Cause it is the emotional entry point. He has the innocence, you know, the hero worship is all there, right? Like it's supposed to be all there. but my god was that performance irritating for me what did you think it definitely is of the time i think

we've come to see much more natural child performances since then where you know thinking of like random comparison but beast of the southern wild you know where i forget the name of that actress but she was nominated for and i think that feels much more natural especially you know having a kid and like this is this kid is does not act like a normal child but it it does it to me I don't think it's a great performance either. And it's tough to be like, uh, tough on a kid acting. Yeah. But, uh, I think it was, like I

said, it is a very much like the, the, uh, Disney ass version of like what a child actor, everything is so big. Everything is like, um, you know, on the precipice of being a little bit annoying. And like, uh, so he, every time they're almost like they like, um, never felt like a real person. Basically. I think ultimately it's just that you, you know what the movie was doing. It's very transparent in what it was doing. So it just, yes, he was a child, but I feel like at

times maybe like he should have been a little bit. Yeah. Just a little better. So some of his lines were just terrible too. Like even that like ending where he's, it's like, he, he's not so young that he doesn't understand. Like, yeah, he's like, calling for him to come like he's like basically saying his goodbyes and then immediately calling for him to come back and then like I don't know like he was just like going all over the place I was like I get that in in like a maybe even like a younger child that really doesn't understand it but like how old do you is he supposed

to be in this film I mean I would say something like that because he's not they don't have him like hunting yet or anything like that he's acting like a six -year -old though I would say he's supposed to be probably like five or six, but he probably was like nine or ten would be my guess. I think another thing that hurts it, though, is that even though the movie itself does have a lot of the heightened stuff, like the mythological stuff, but the characters don't necessarily.

A lot of the characters, yes, Shane is like this. mythological character, I guess. Like we, we don't, he's mystery mysterious. We don't really know much about him. And he does like bring a lot of that type of stuff, but like a lot of the other characters are somewhat, I don't know. I didn't feel like they were as over the top. So it was almost like this kid was not only kind of over the top himself, but then he was over the top against a setting and the cinematography and the rest of the movie that doesn't feel as

over the top. So it was almost like he was like in the wrong movie. I don't know. I mean, some of the characters are big, but like some of them are like our main character, Alan Ladd or not. Yeah. Alan Ladd, his, uh, plays his father. Well, no, then Alan Ladd plays Shane. I'm sorry. Van Heflin plays the father, Joe Starrett. Like I'd never found him being over the top. too much yeah i guess i don't i think joy wasn't meant to be over the top i think it just comes off

that way now perhaps i i see i really like the dynamic between for me what's like a strength within this is a dynamic between joe van heflin's character marion's starrett uh the his wife by played by gene arthur and then alan like their dynamic i i thought was the strength of it uh in like how they would relate to one another i really did like van heflin who's becoming like the breakout star of this retrospective in a lot of ways uh you know like 100 years after

the movies have come out but like obviously 310 to yuma's a lot you know we saw him in that i thought he was really strong there here he plays a very similar role again like he's the the dad of a farm that is in trouble trying to make the best for his town where you have the uh you know the the bandits or whatever who you know were trying to take advantage of him and i think he plays that role well and with gene arthur she maybe was not given like a lot to do in the sense of like she's always worrying it's like that's

her role like you worry but she's also gets moments where you can tell she's she's understanding things quicker like i think she figured out who shane was before joe did uh in the way like she would act and like he she would you just a lot of that was within the performance maybe not as much within the script and so i do feel like they all feel down to earth in a way and shane is that you know is the classic like mysterious stranger you know you clearly like influencing movies we've done already like with the man with

no name trilogy but he's a bit softer i think even like as a performance like alan like he's not as harsh but i also wonder if that's you know a feature not a bug He gets soda pop, which I love. I don't know why they're backing him up for getting soda. Yeah, it's so cruel. I mean, technically, there's danger to that as well. It's not just a number on your teeth. But so I think that was the strength. I do agree, Joey was a little bit much, but I think that's more

of a product of the time than it was an intention. At least that's the way I took it. Yeah, I liked the Van Heflin and Alan Ladd dynamic. I liked their interplay between each other. It wasn't huge. I mean, I understand the love triangle of Marion, and I get that dynamic, and I'm fine with that. I didn't care for her character or her performance a lot. Part of it was, I don't know. We can get into it maybe a little bit later.

I didn't like her aspect of the triangle as much. If I'm breaking it down, I really was drawn a little bit more to the two men in that triangle and kind of how they were interacting. He's working for him, but then you can kind of see Joe somewhat also kind of seeing the same stuff that Joey is seeing. He is somewhat taken by the... the mystery or the mythic aspect of shane but he also sees him as somebody that can like serve a purpose and help him work and stuff like that and the kind of a at one point like are they

going to be friends are they going to be just a worker co -worker type thing is it going to be we're battling because you you know we're both into the same woman so like there's a lot of different strings being pulled between those two so i did enjoy that i like i said marion wasn't my favorite part of that but that's kind of I guess I, I, I don't know. Like part of it is, you know, you mentioned like she figured out who Shane was early on and I'm like, did she, or was she just kind of crushing on him?

You know what I mean? Like, was it, was it just kind of, there was like certain things she says that I think she under, I can't think of exactly, but I think she, she understood that like, the way you use his gun and like certain things that where i feel like she knows like okay this is um i know who this person is in the sense of like or at least she was a bit more cautious around him at first compared to like joe who was like you know i just thought there was too many moments that bugged me that she's doing

right in front of joe and her son that are like nobody else is seeing how he how she's looking at this dude like everyone's just cool with this yeah um but yeah i did find that a little bit uh interesting but another thing that so we have two different other aspects kind of of the film right we have the rest of the homesteaders that this stare at family is kind of i don't know connected to kind of like their own little community and then obviously we have the cattle cattlemen

cattle drivers whatever which is our villains so to speak in this one that are giving them you know a hard time for soda pop and all that other stuff so yeah i'm curious you know between those two groups kind of how you took those and then also kind of piggybacking on what you were saying about shane i do think it's interesting it's an interesting way they kind of paint him because in a way he is like the clint eastwood character or the john wayne character or like whatever that is but in a package that is way

more similar to like the jimmy stewarts and the gary coopers and then like the the the more like like he's not this big imposing person he's like fairly i don't know regular size small like he's not like technically in real life he's like five he's like tom cruise height but they try to make him look like normal so he's not this big bulky like imposing person so and he and he doesn't come across you know he's much more subdued in like his demeanor and like his look but then

he's it's it's an interesting way because instead of just having like the clint eastwood john wayne like big bigger than life person you still have that role being played because he is this like can do everything is is great at like the the guns and all the other stuff but then he's in this package of like a jimmy stewart type package or a gary cooper type package so i thought that was kind of an interesting choice do you do you feel like he worked in that and kind of how that all played out and kind of get your thoughts on on the homesteaders and the cattlemen yeah i actually really like that dynamic because just

the historical context of it as well and i mentioned how like you know this is very white hat black hat but we do get a little bit of you know a little bit better understanding of like what uh you know chris the rufus the reicher like what his mindset is because we get some understanding that like we get that one scene where he's explaining why he's so against the homesteaders because he feels that they're taking advantage of what he helped settle. And then I thought, what was

good about that was Joe had a good comeback. It's like, well, you weren't here first either. So it's interesting because that very much, in a lot of ways, one, that did happen. You had a lot of conflict there, and then there was a lot of mirroring of today and similar conflicts that exist even to this day. So I did like that dynamic in the sense of it made sense. And I did feel like there was real stakes there because they have no marshal to go to. There's really

nothing stopping them except for just hope that they can stand together and the odds keep stacking against them. And I thought Shane worked well as just that speak softly and shoot well or whatever instead of carrying a big stick. And I did really like Jack Palance as, like, the opposite side of that. And actually watching this made me realize, like, he would have been a great Joker. Like, I hate, like, doing fan casting and stuff like that. But I'm like, he just has that smile, that,

like, evil presence to him. Like, he was, I think, a really good balance. And so I thought they played off of each other. If anything, I wish we got a little bit more there. I agree. And it is, like, relatively slow -paced. I didn't know that was the purpose of it. that was kind of the you know to bring all the violence to the end of it but i like that dynamic between the the homesteaders and the settlers and everything like that like the the way that played out and you know the performances i think worked well there what did you think of the fact that like the homesteader or excuse me the the cattlemen

are basically like they represent the old west right like if we're just talking about like the american old west like they're the white man, American old West. I don't know how many qualifiers I can put on this, but obviously, you know, there was, there was people here before us, but, um, and stuff like that, but they're like the old West. And then we have the homesteaders who are coming in and they're kind of like representing the, a newer version of that, right? Like they're, I don't know if it's new West necessarily, but like a change in that. And I, it's interesting that Shane is put in a place where he's essentially

fighting to build. help build this world that the homesteaders are trying to build which is a world that has no place for him because he is part of the old west yeah so it's like it's an interesting dynamic that he's put in and we don't get he's not a man for a lot of words right like a lot of times he's like the quiet person in the background you don't really know what his motivations are and what he's doing but it does set him up on like a very interesting like there's a lot of layers to this because he is

definitely trying to help people who are somewhat not they're not eliminating the like the need for existence of the cattlemen and the ranchers and all that others or the you know cattle drivers and stuff like that but it's definitely like a move to this other form of society that would really have no place for him so what did you kind of make of that yeah and there's that interesting conversation that they have where he talks where joe talks about like How they're going to basically do the factory farms in a way where they're going

to fatten up the cows rather than having them range. And the impact, like, obviously that was easy. I mean, foresight, because obviously this takes place in the future. I think Shane has that great line where he's like, you know, your days are over, cattlemen. And he's like, well, so are yours, gunslinger, and probably butchering it. But then he says, the difference is I know it. So, like, he has that realization that, like. The world's changing. He's not going to. And I think that is kind of very much a representation of what this movie is. It's the transition. It's

the settlement of the death of the Wild West in a lot of ways. And what killed the Wild West wasn't gunslingers. It was barbed wire. So it was being able to keep farms isolated and have more. Instead of going the range, having cattle kind of stay within a specific section so you didn't have to have them miles on end. And that really helped create more settlements and things like that. this is that transition like this

is kind of showing that element of it which i think is really important that it's shot on location because you get that sense it's and it's much more effective when you're seeing that done and you have the you know it's in jackson home wyoming so you have like the gorgeous mountains in the background so you feel like you're there so i thought i thought like that dynamic was really the strength of the film yeah it was one of those that i almost wish i could have seen in like 4k yeah color well did you watch this in color or in black and white because it's available

in both i think i watched it in black and white if i'm remembering correctly yeah so i watched a lot of westerns this week yeah i watched it in color the first time i did watch it in color i'm sorry i did watch it in color i was just meaning like i wish i could have seen it in even like more vibrant like yeah yeah color because i think there was a lot there i think that's what some of the stuff they did well like going back to the beginning like the actual art of the the filmmaking is is very top -notch like the visuals are good i did appreciate i'm not usually someone that cares about sound at all but i do think they like do some stuff with some

of the shots and stuff like that to make them feel a little bit more real like and and things of that nature it's also interesting because we keep getting throughout this western retrospective we keep getting stories that are centered around community right like in a lot of different ways whether it's a community that's under fire that's asking for help whether it's a person asking for help from the community whether it's this one where it's almost two competing communities

obviously one's a little bit more migrant but like but we keep coming back to various versions of what it meant to be a part of something bigger in the west which I've spent a lot of time talking about the west in college and studying it and teaching about it and stuff like that like that's when you were talking about the barbed wire second class like oh that's like straight from one of my lesson plans um from from back in the day but you know what i think from wasn't a lesson

plan was from a it was from a comic book of course oh nice there was a it was a lone ranger comic by mark russell and bob q they did it was actually had a very similar plot to this about you know But they introduced barbed wire, and it was a big center point of it. I mean, I knew it beforehand, but that's what kept it fresh. I think a lot of people don't, though. I think a lot of people don't realize that it's not some big conflict or something like that. It's something as simple as just a new technology for them at the time.

But one thing that I don't think it's thought of when people think about the West so much, we think about the cattle drives, right? We had a movie about that. We think about the gunfights and the saloons and we think about cowboys and Indians and we think about all of this, you know, whether, you know, even like Oregon Trail or prospecting or different stuff. It's all of this like journey things. And I don't think people think as much about what it meant to build or

be a part of or find a community of people in the West. and yeah i don't know why we don't think about that more because it's all over these movies but it's not something that i expected when we went into this right like yes i knew magnificent seven had to do with a town that you know was under fire and stuff like that and they were asking for help and i knew a couple of these like loose plot things but i was not expecting like the overarching like theme in again and again and again like even in the spaghetti westerns right like we're still dealing with communities or towns or places that are trying

to like build a better tomorrow or or stay a unit or develop or different things like and we've seen it again and again and again and it's interesting because it's all over these movies but i feel like it's not something that gets thought of much when people just generally like if you just go on the street and say like tell me the first thing that comes your mind when you think about the old west or the wild west like they're not going to come up with that so i do appreciate that we're getting so much of that here and a lot of times with painted and

slightly different shades i think yeah it's it's showing you know that'll question how the west was won and we're seeing that it was won and lost in a lot of different ways but a lot of it was you know through greed through individuals either kind of taking advantage of a situation where there was a bit of lawlessness And here, obviously, getting that conflict between the homesteaders and the ranchers and just the back

and forth that would happen, like using cattle to just plow through their fields and things like that, just to try to see who would own that land and just how... In order for states to become states, even going back to the man who shot Liberty Valance, I forget what state they were in, but that becoming a state was a big part of that plot. Here, you have similar ideas. In the background, there's a lot of the... laws and politicking that exists existing in washington at the time

that then we see like on the ground and how it impacts here because like you know obviously the homestead act is a big part of like why this even exists so and it's not like you know they're bringing that up but you're you're being able to if you have that historical context it's i think it's a little bit more interesting because you kind of have an understanding of where this is all coming from but without it i think you at least see or at least get a good understanding of why it's happening like what everyone's motivation is it's very clear and i think everyone feels

like they're the hero of the story and even though like i well jack balance is just pretty straight evil but i do think at least rufus reicher like he has at least like a point like i don't know his point maybe is a bit jaded and he's going about the wrong way but i guess like at least at least you understand why he's doing it it doesn't feel like it's out of left field i did want to get your take on a couple other characters as well that we just haven't mentioned and kind of as we get closer to wrapping this up so uh we have chris calloways uh is one of the characters

that kind of switches sides in a way or maybe not switches sides but he has a different interactions with shane at different points in the movie and i wasn't curious what your take was on him i was curious what your take was on the store owner the Sam Grafton character and then going into some of the actual homesteaders, like two of them that obviously stood out to me would be like Swede, um, who is what they called one of the individuals and then Stonewall who, you know, nicknames for a couple of these guys. So, or, or any of the other homesteaders. So what was your take on, on some of those characters? And

then do you think they, how much did they add to the movie or did you spend your time with them? I did find it interesting that, like, you know, of course, like, the Northerners are always the bad guys. The Yankees are the bad guys. It's always the Rebels from some reason are, like, so interesting. You know, Ben Johnson as Chris Calloway, I thought that was fine. He didn't necessarily stand out. I did, you know, another person we've done, he's been in some of the movies, Edgar Buchanan. He was, of course, one of our favorite actors from, was it Penny St. Erinade? Was he in that? I liked him. His voice was one

of those things where it's like, his voice is super familiar. Where do I know him from? And then obviously being able to figure that out. Those stood up for me. I did like Stonewall in the sense of him having a bit of a temper. You knew that clearly he's going to be the catalyst for bad things to happen. But I do feel like everyone had a personality. Even the little bit that you got from them, you understood. Who they are. So you were invested in their plight. Even if you didn't get as much time for it. You wanted

to see this community succeed. So I thought it was effective there. I could have taken about. 15 to 20 % more time. With like Stonewall. And Swede and Calloway. And Grafton. And then you could have taken that away from Joey. And I would have been cool with that. And also I will say Stonewall. That dude had a loyal dog. Some of the best dog acting. i have seen in a movie like yeah so i thought you know like the you know as he's getting buried the dog it's like me like

i think joey should have learned a few things from that dog about being able being able to sell emotion because that dog was amazing so so i'm curious dan kind of as we wrap this one up any other takeaways that you or comments yeah i did have one thing about what did you think because i think one we mentioned action and we had to shoot outs but we actually got a lot of like drag them out punching type you know we had the bar fight and we had a fight between joe and shane what what did you think about those

fights in general and did you in the sense of the length of them like like what was your reaction to them i guess to kind of keep it open -ended i mean i thought it was decently done for the most part. I think it was easy to follow and the choreography was good. I was a little surprised just because I didn't think they had placed enough breadcrumbs for the intensity of the Joe and Shane fight. I get that you don't want the guy

to go and that you're trying to take his place or whatever, but it never seemed that they had this super bad blood. Yes, there was kind of this love triangle, but it never was touched on. to a point where i felt like either of them were mad at the other one or like yeah it was like they acknowledged that this was a thing but they also acknowledged that they were never going to do anything about it so like i don't know it was a little intense and it went on a while and i was like is nobody going to stop these two from killing each other because i don't think that's going to work in anybody's interest like yeah well i didn't i didn't take it as them

mad at each other i guess i took it more so joe was like he was destined to like go and get himself killed basically and Shane didn't want that to happen like he was definitely he didn't want to see it was basically Joe stubbornness against yeah but I mean maybe there was a bit some personal stuff in there too no I just mean there was a couple points where it's like if you're not actually mad with someone can you really do a couple of the shots that they're doing to each other I mean he hits him with his gun like that's like that's that I think that's what I like that yeah

joey did two seconds later joey's fine with it but he did not like that in that moment it was almost an unhealthy obsession this kid had with shane yeah it was it was a little bit but i i guess i but i guess it gets it because it's like this is like the it's like a real life you know he doesn't have comic book superheroes he is shane that's his iron man what did you think about the other action sequence and the other um kind of what with what happened with stonewall in that sequence I thought that worked well. I was just surprised with the level of violence,

mostly with the Joe and Shane fight, like you mentioned. That was a bit shocking. And the final shootout I thought was effective. I think they did a good job of building up the Jack Palance, Jack Wilson character, where he did feel like a legitimate threat in their showdown. If anything, it maybe even got on for a little bit longer, but I get it. It did what it needed to do. I think the, you know, the real emotional action was obviously that, that fight that happened. That's where the explosion of violence really occurred. But that's, I was just surprised with how long it went on. And then like, God, this

is, this is pretty, you know, cause like I mentioned up to that point, it was like baby's first Western. And then it's like, Oh no, it is not. Cause this is, I mean, I think kids would be fine with compared to most stuff today, but I thought it was. So one question for you as a parent, Dan. Yeah. You, you just have this like drag them out, you know, intense fight. With this Shane character who both of you are basically trying to prevent the other person from like going somewhere where you, you're pretty sure like somebody is going to end up dead and that all ends. And, and you know, one of you is going to go off to the town

to do that. Is there any chance on any planet that you allow your seven, six year old child to then run for like miles? after this guy and go into the town which is the danger spot yeah i would say probably not but i don't know if he was even in the you know in the it was even clearly had multiple concussions at that point so uh this kid just runs and runs and at one

point he's keeping up with shane which is i don't know like I didn't think that scene went on pretty long. I'm like, okay, they're going to show him. I'm like, is this happening in real time? I'm like, this could go. But anyways, yeah. I mean, it was Old West. Kids had to learn some way. I guess. Just duck under everything and watch the shootout. And then he had to be there to warn him about the one guy coming after him. He saved his life. So there you go. That's where he made his keep by saving Shane. for some reason

i couldn't get my out of my head like this is going to be a weird connection but like every time they're visiting the saloon and like the quote -unquote bullies are always there right like when when shane is going into the saloon it kept giving me visions of marty mcfly going into the diner and like you know you're going in there you know they're going to be there and you know at some point they're going to call you a chicken i didn't wonder though like it seemed like the the guy who owned the suite or

whatever like that was like the one person that rufus would listen to and always made me wonder like why yeah you know like what what it wasn't that he had that like he he was like the de facto law in a way and i was just i never feel like i fully understood it was simply just because like that's he was a guy getting supplies but i don't know well at one point they even have a conversation where they're like we can't do that because we're gonna you know make the shop owner mad yeah what is the shop owner got on you guys is he is he really like he was a he was a badass back in his day too so they just

don't want to i didn't i didn't know why it was the shop keeper but yeah so a final thoughts on shane dan yeah i definitely liked it i definitely glad i watched it as i mentioned i think there are elements that certainly i don't say don't hold up like we mentioned there you know uh it if If you're listening at this point, I doubt this is a first Western. But if you're looking to get kids into Westerns or watch it, I do think it's a good entry point into the genre. But I don't necessarily think it holds a candle to

maybe some of the films we've done so far in this more classic section as well as some other films. But I do think it... I understand where the love of it comes from because I think there's a lot to appreciate with it. Yeah, I think there's a lot to appreciate. I think the filmmaking is good. I think there's elements of it that are good. Like I said, I liked a lot of the people involved. I just wished I would have gotten more time with them, I guess. And like the Joey part really drove me bananas. But I think I get like...

the influence that it has and the respect that it gets for like doing what it did at the time i would say that this would be one of those that i feel like anybody that's putting this in like the top five westerns of all time is is giving more credence to first versus best and i think films that we've covered have have taken some of these themes and done them certainly yeah i think influence yeah i think certainly influence and uh like you said like the changing of the guard like in the sense of like it doing things

differently for the time certainly maybe why you would consider it that way but yeah i don't know but interesting but we're going into a new section next week that is going to change things up a little bit because we're going to end in talking about you know going back to westerns we're going to be entering our revisionist western section, so a bunch of westerns here. And I guess I don't, what people consider a revisionist western seems to differ, but these were all ones that

I saw on multiple lists that were considered revisionist westerns, so people say that it isn't one. I mean, a lot of these I haven't seen, so I don't know for sure. But next week is a first -time watch for me. I think it is for you as well, but it's the Oxbow incident from 1943. Curious, Kevin, if you have any background with that at all. I know. I believe Henry Fonda's in it. And that is all I know. I also am going to just put my stupidity right out there. For my entire life, I have not known what they meant

by revisionist Western. I know what the word revisionist means. But I don't know. I feel like some of them that we've already watched could have fit in that. Me too. I'm not going to lie. I don't know where the line is that you draw. i know i obviously in just to kind of well i gotta put this list it's on letterboxd but i gotta put it on facebook so everyone can see the entire list but what will be included in this block as well uh bush cassidy and the sundance kid uh the wild bunch which is something i have

not watched yet so i'm glad to give that a shot uh we're gonna go back to the world of Clint Eastwood with the outlaw, Josie Wales, which I'm glad we're doing because that originally wasn't part of it. But I know that's really well regarded by a lot of people. Then one of the most recent films we're going to do. which is The Harder They Fall. That was from 2021. I think that was a Netflix movie. And then ending with what people consider like the revisionist of the most revisionist Westerns. Again, going back to Clint Eastwood with Unforgiven, which was originally going to be the last film we did in

its retrospective. But that is not the case anymore because there's many, many others after that. But I'm looking forward to this block because it's going to, you know, it's one we're spanning. So we're going from 1953 all the way to 2021. So that's a long period of time. So that's going to be fun. How many of those six have you seen, Dan? I have seen Push to Cassidy and The Harder They Fall and Unforgiven. The rest I have not seen. I have only seen Unforgiven. I will know what a revisionist Western is by the time we watch these six films. If you've seen Unforgiven,

you should at least have some idea. I saw Unforgiven, again, like 15 years ago. So I'm looking forward to watching that one again. Absolutely. So if you've been enjoying our Western retrospective, Feel free to jump on the social medias and give us some comments. You can search Dan out at The Comic Concierge, myself at Optimist Solo, or you can search the show out Cinema Geeks or the Cinema Geek Movie Podcast. We're on Facebook and all the different things. So that's where we've been focusing most of our attention. So that's probably the easiest way to get in touch with us and leave comments or feedback as we

continue to make our way through this Western retrospective. But that does it for this episode. So tune in next time for another chance to listen to more of The Cinema Geeks. But then we get a movie like Shane, and I think that's very much where that mindset comes from, because... Jesus Christ. Sorry, my son just scared the living hell out of me. What do you need, buddy? I just

didn't know. Mommy's not home. Mommy's home. Go tell Mommy, okay? oh man if this was a video podcast that would have gone viral because like like he came behind me he's like dad like whispered in my ear like he was the kid from ring or whatever it was like oh my god that's our reason we got to go to video soon um anyways i don't even know where all right let me but um okay sorry i have to edit that my apologies or keep it in as a

blooper at the end because that's right um all right

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Western Retrospective: The Outlaw Josey Wales

    Nov 16, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Halloween Special: Rocky Horror Picture Show

    Oct 31, 202641 minAudio

    Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Halloween Spotlight: The Exorcist

    Oct 29, 202642 minAudio

    Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Halloween Spotlight: Carrie (1976)

    Oct 26, 202639 minAudio

    Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Halloween Spotlight: Texas Chainsaw Massacre

    Oct 24, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...

    Credit the people on this episode