Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

CINEMA GEEKS

CINEMA GEEKS artwork

TMNT (2007)

Jun 30, 202342 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Today on Episode 195 Join OptimusSolo and MovieRevolt of the CinemaGeekCast as they continue their journey through the films of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles franchise. This time they look at the first animated film in the franchise TMNT! Was the shift to animation a good choice? Is Patrick Stewart always the right casting choice? Where does this stand in the legacy of the franchise? Those questions and more are answered! Stay tuned as they make their way through each TMNT film on the way to the release of Mutant Mayhem this August! Be Sure to Follow The Hosts on Twitter! Kevin “OptimusSolo” Thompson and Dan “The Comic Concierge” Clark! Cowabunga dudes and dudettes!!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello, this is Cinema Geeks and I am one of your Cinema Geeks, Optimus Solo, and joining me again today is Movie Revolt Dan. Hello. Hello. And we are here to continue our trek through the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle franchise. So, you've already seen us do the original three live -action films, and today we're going to turn our attention to the first theatrical CGI or animated version of The Turtles. That's right, this is TMNT from 2007. So, Dan, before we get into the actual

movie itself, I know we briefly touched on it last episode, but remind folks what your experience was with this movie before watching it most recently, and kind of set the stage for us a little bit. I'll be brief because I had no previous history. This was the first time that I watched this. I thought maybe I watched it, you know, sometimes there's movies that you watch and you forget you did. But once it started, I'm like, no, I don't remember this at all. Everything was brand new to me. So, yeah, it was a... Brand -new experience and it was interesting because it was not at all what I expected going into it Yeah, I think

I may have seen this one time before and that was definitely it because there was a lot of stuff that I didn't remember But there was enough familiarity where I knew I had sort of seen it once But I don't know if I was paying close enough attention the first time I watched it or not Because there was some stuff that I was like, I don't remember this at all Did you watch this alone or did you have anybody watch it with you? This was I watched mostly by myself. I to be honest watched it a lot on my phone because I'm the kids The kids uh by myself this uh this weekend

So I was like i'm gonna i'll put it on let them watch their stuff on the tv and i'll watch it but honestly like In a way that makes me more focused on something because I don't have my phone distracting me since i'm watching it on my phone There you go. Yeah, so that's the trick. Yeah, but it's not that you know No one makes me be thinking somebody's gonna watch this on their phone one day, but you know That was that's what he did. How about yourself? That wasn't the vision? That wasn't the vision? No, Christopher Nolan would be like rolling over. Not in his grave. He doesn't have a grave, but like manifesto of movie making. Right, right. So this one is

a 2007 release. It was directed and written by Kevin Monroe, and it is starring a whole bunch of people that we'll get to as far as the voices go. We'll probably break that down a little bit. I was thrown off immediately, Dan, because it was just like plastering the Weinstein company up. Like the logos and everything and I'm like, oh you might want to redo that so But it's a Warner Brothers slash Weinstein company slash a man a medji animation studios I don't know if I'm saying that last one a hundred percent. Correct It was a very short -lived studio out

of Hong Kong that did literally two movies and then went bankrupt So here you go They did this one, the TMNT 2007, and then they did the Astro Boy in 2009. Oh, I like that movie. But the problem is, is the Turtles one actually, I think, at least made their money back. But the Astro Boy did not do well. Like, I think they lost over 20 or 30 million on that. Yeah, I could see that. It's not. But that was a good movie. I enjoy that movie. So after that, they went out of business.

They were. Kind of tossing around doing a sequel to this one. There was some unplanned or unrealized talk of a Legend of Zelda movie a gotcha man movie some other things, but Unfortunately, they went out of business. So we never got any of that So and it was released in March and made about almost just shy of a hundred million on a 34 million budget So it did pretty good. I know it said it opened it up At number one at the box office, I believe the week it came out. It'd be three hundred three. I mean, three hundred

was like in his third week. But right. Interesting. One comic book movie beats another comic book movie. Yeah and interesting because of the animated aspect I think and being turtles because this is something that had not been tried yet at this point like obviously a lot of animated animated movies especially Disney Pixar etc do very well in theaters but we hadn't seen something quite like this so it's always a question on how that's gonna do and how that's because a lot of movies that were made off of especially cartoon series from the 80s 90s don't do well So it was, you

know, obviously we had had the three live action films to kind of set a little bit of the stage, I guess. And they all had various levels of success. But this is kind of the first time we've seen this. So it was good that it made some money. And it's kind of debated, I guess, between Kevin Monroe, who, like I said, is the writer director and then Peter Laird on if this is connected to the live action films or not. Laird says that it's a completely different. Universe and different continuity but Monroe seems to want to try to

Connected a little bit here and there and there's some sequences and some things that you can see in it that seem like they're at least homages But I don't think that's really consequential either way whether it's connected or not for the turtles It seems like they can just do their own thing standalone or it can be a new version and I think that's More than some franchises, but I transformers does it a lot turtles does it? And obviously there's various success varying success levels to that But I think when you have all this different stuff to pull from whether it be the animated series the comic books You

know takes on the live -action movies you kind of can do a whole bunch of different things What's your thought on how much it should be either connected to any of those other properties? Yeah, I wasn't sure like on it like watching it It definitely feels like a movie that's connected to something because it you know obviously takes place You know the turtles are disbanded There's talk with a foot like it felt like a tv movie like a movie to a tv show Cartoon that didn't exist in a way like I didn't know we there's a turtles in time or something like that It felt

something akin to that because the world felt like really lived in already Uh, you had you had the foot in the leader of the foot who was a character I don't like I didn't place her no, but it felt like we're supposed to know who she was uh, right Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I didn't but it didn't feel like it was connected to the live action films to me like The way the characters were especially like Casey Jones like he felt I mean obviously characters mature in April I don't know like I wondered that at the time like obviously mentioned some references like they

had You know the two minutes were high -sticking and like some jokes like that But it definitely felt like in partially because it's animated and it's you know, it does not to me Feel like part of the same universe as the live -action films, especially the first and third one Yeah, I agree with that I didn't really feel too much of a connection and the stuff that that you see I think there's some stuff you see within the animation towards the end. There's something I don't know if it was in their layer or Where that's like visual cues to something that would

be in the live -action film I can't remember exactly what it was, but there's like something that appears So I mean, but you could say that that's just an homage It doesn't necessarily mean that the universes are connected so to speak I don't know. I guess it's up for somebody that's way more intelligent when it comes to turning Teenage Mutant Turtle franchise than I am. Yeah, it's not that debate. It's not impossible. It's not like there's anything that count is contradictory to the previous films. I just don't feel of the same world in the sense of like how they're so impartially just because the anime it's animated and the actions very different. But yeah, and

also like in the write up, it's saying that the reason that the turtles have grown apart is because of a defeat from Shredder. And that to me wouldn't connect with the live action films. No, they defeated Shredder. I mean, yeah, I mean, technically, but by default, the second time he kind of defeated himself. Yeah, for sure. So I just have to read the plot for this one and then we can get more into some of the characters. How much time do we got? Because I just want to read a couple of lines just. I feel like if I say it out loud,

maybe something will click with me, but. So the plot says in ancient times warlord I'm gonna say his name wrong yaddle. Is that how they say it in the movie yodel? It sounds not yodel, but yaddle opens a portal into a parallel universe that grants him immortality and petrifies his four generals But the portal also releases 13 immortal monsters that are gonna destroy his army and his enemies while becoming famous mythical monsters as centuries pass and Then if you skip ahead a little bit Sorry Basically like I love

the the explanation for this so we have cry we have shredder foot clan etc kind of we don't see shredder, but his Quote -unquote second command is cry and the foot clan are part of this so they're searching the city for these 13 monsters before the portal opens again Winters who we find out is actually yodel yaddle whatever spoiler alert reanimates his four stone generals and How well use technology created by his company? Yeah, so we basically have this guy who's playing

a dual role Winters and it's very obvious that he's also the guy like if you don't realize that like from Immediately, I don't I don't think you can spoil that so you have that person and then you have these four generals who were once Obviously on the side now. They're kind of not so sure because he's trying to get these 13 monsters Before this portal opens, which is going to make everybody mortal again so they can all die at some point and. They can be human. I guess and

the turtles are worked in here so. So yeah, you know this was when Lord of the Rings was really big and around that time I think and it feels very influenced by something like that. It does not feel like a turtles plot like when it opens up. That's when I'm like I definitely have not seen this before because this was in not what all at all what I expected. And I would say that is probably the the. The weakest element of the movie is the plot, which is sometimes, you know, not not a good sign, but it's a bit laborious like with just how many pieces there are. It

falls in line with a lot of tropes like with the stars and lining and there is that running gag for a long time. To be fair, this was early in that run where you had all those movies that had the shining light in the sky. You know this Avengers and obviously just came beforehand, but. There was a lot of things it was hitting along those lines. But yeah, that that piece was like a little much for me. It was hard to kind of keep track of it. I wasn't sure why all the monsters were in New York. I don't know if I missed something, but like opening it up and watching it say this. It's a little overwhelming

to start with when you have this big prologue about all these monsters and immortality. It feels like a lot of different pieces from different scripts kind of brought into. One and then like, all right, let's add the turtles on top of that. Right. Which was a bit weird. But it, you know, it was probably my least favorite part of the movie was like when it kind of dealt with that stuff. But it wasn't it didn't tear it down completely for me. It's I think the word that comes to mind for me, like if I want to sum up the plot is

just convoluted. Like, yes, just like because you can honestly just take this Max Winters slash. Yodel I'm gonna call him yodel cuz I like it you could you could literally take that character and he's battling these generals Because they both want different things and then I guess you could even have the 13 monsters involved because that's how he's gonna Set everybody back to being human and mortal like that is a story in and of itself I guess whether you like it whether you like it or not I mean, I still probably wouldn't be a big fan of that actual plot, but that could

be in of itself But then we have the turtles and then we have cry in the foot And then we have Casey Jones and I know it's just becomes very weird to me and I agree with you the plot is my least favorite part about this movie if you just did the stuff with the turtles and You focused on that I might have been fine because there's a lot of other stuff that I'm fine with But it just you keep getting thrown into these like random weird monsters and things of that

nature Like one of them is called vampire sucker burr suck sucky bore second war and I think the main thing with me that Kind of throws me off and I've kind of mentioned this a little bit with any franchise like this It's like you have again all of these characters to draw from and it's not just that you're not drawing from one of the characters I know from a preview like the TV series or the comics or something Although cry is from that but she's not really that important to this plot, but It's not just that you're not

drawing one of those characters. It's it's when you have these like almost nameless faceless Characters and that kind of like the the monsters and even to a point the generals are very nondescript generic Bland just characters. I'm gonna get you get like the Winters as the kind of the main guy even though he's somewhat good in the end, but I don't know I just don't like where you just have these are random antagonists that don't

really have a personality don't have a name don't have an identity and that was the kind of my biggest drawback within that also convoluted plot yeah they're more of like a natural disaster they're trying to stop the right characters to spoil at the end when they're trying to when he when winter's changes his mind or I guess he doesn't change his mind but you find out that oh no he's actually trying to get rid of the monsters I think the reason like that doesn't work that well Because like they almost made those monsters seem one either comedic or sympathetic like I didn't they didn't seem like this threat that had to be You know gotten rid of like obviously

they're crazy looking monsters, but it seemed like they weren't really bothering anybody So and where have they been where yeah been for all of these decades? And well, I mean it's been what like it's been a long time like we're talking hundreds of years. I'm assuming It seemed like this was a plot that was better designed for a miniseries or like his first season of a TV show Then then a movie because of all the moving pieces and stuff like that was there So but like you have to you either have to explain where these 13 monsters have been for the last Whatever

it is hundreds of years. Yeah, or why they haven't been wreaking havoc everywhere Yeah, I can't just buy that they're just out and about and we just I don't know And all in New York and all in like, you know easy to find a very very easy to catch. Yes Like it's one, you know like something about How there there were the mess come from you know that we have and i guess that's what they're trying to lean out with someone and stuff like that one of them is called bigfoot yeah so. Those things weren't really my favorite thing but i don't want we actually got the elements

with the turtles first of all i think the biggest thing with this i was worried about it because this is an animated film like you said from a. An animated company doing like its first really big movie from 2007 It's like how how bad is this gonna look like, you know not seeing coming in with fresh eyes CGI animation doesn't always hold up unless it's like Pixar But I thought like it legitimately, you know, I don't know if it's because I had low expectations I thought it looked really good. I thought the action was pretty solid Especially like there's some really

good sequences the one with Raphael and Leonardo in the rain. I thought that was great There's really some great -looking shots on a technical standpoint the long takes as well and they didn't like they didn't you know use any shortcuts when it came the animation the action i thought was crisp and fun and especially i don't know because like the last we saw was a team in t3 which you know the action was not the strong suit that i was just like taken back by how great it was in this but like when we had the turtles there i was excited i was happy was i thought like

their dynamic even though it felt like it was treading the same ground of rafael being rebellious one his jealousy with leonardo at least it made sense and maybe because everything else was so convoluted having something that was simple and straightforward was welcoming but i thought as a tmnt movie it succeeded for me but as like those pieces is where when i tried to be something else that's where it kind of got got a little bit lost It actually got nominated for any for outstanding storyboarding in the future production and i agree i think the look was fine like i

was not thrown off by the look i didn't have any negative reaction to it i thought the turtles look good i thought like you said the action look good. It's just one of those it's like a conundrum of a film for me because there's aspects of it that i enjoyed there's aspects of it that i respect or like and then there's just like this. Terrible plot that it's all wrapped up in and it's just hard to forget but. Let's get into a little bit of the characters voicing etc whether it's talking about the actual performances or whether it's talking about the characters within the movies we can get a little bit more

into that because we've talked a little bit during the live action. Topics about how the turtles are portrayed. You know the characteristics of the fit kind of the classic what were you doing things of that nature so just going down the voice cast a little bit we have. It's interesting because we have some very very experienced voice actors involved here. We have some lesser Experienced voice actors and then we have like the celebrities So it's a it's an interesting mixture of kind of all of that It doesn't get much more iconic

in the voice acting world, especially in the last probably 25 to 30 years than Nolan North and James Arnold Taylor and that's who is playing Raphael and Leonardo so they are just Legends in the voice acting business so obviously they have a lot of experience and then some of the generals and some of the side characters like the The leader of the South American bandits is John DiMaggio Kevin Michael Richardson is one of the generals Fred task to task your he is one of the other generals so you have like just a Substantial amount of just really good

voice actors Then you have some lesser -known voice actors in Mikey Kelly and Mitchell Whitfield as Michelangelo and Donatello And some of them have done a little bit of live -action work as well So a little bit less experience with Michelangelo and Donatello. I thought Mikey Kelly is Michelangelo sounded as close to The same actor has they had for some of the live -action Films as you could get like or at least got that same kind of feel for me and then from the celebrity standpoint We have Chris Evans as Casey Jones Sarah Michelle Geller April O 'Neil and Patrick Stewart as one

of the most Bizarre castings that I can ever think of as Max Winters who is a businessman I get that that the warlord guy is like Ancient yeah, but this but this Max Winters guy is like a middle -aged man and Patrick Stewart is not Yeah, I think Patrick Stewart just has one of those voices That it's just like it just it's just Patrick Stewart. So you kind of recognize it right away I had no idea it was Chris Evans when I was watching it because I didn't look at this level listening access until I was over and it's funny like that ever gets caught up.

People always talk about how he was, you know, of course, you know, Captain America as well as the Game and Torch, but also Casey Jones. That's right. Quite an array of comic book characters he's played. But yeah, I didn't think Patrick Stewart was bad. It just was distracting. Yeah, that was my. Yeah, that was my problem like his performance is fine. He does a great job I just needed them to match the design of the character to what I'm gonna think of when I hear Patrick Stewart I mean, it doesn't have to look exactly like him, but I can't see somebody that is half

of his age Not half his age, but you know way younger It just kind of was very distracting to me and especially he looks like mr. Incredible with but like in shape. So right, right And then we had a kind of a cameo from Kevin Smith. He plays a cook in a diner. And then we had this is Mako Iwamatsu, his last role. They basically announced that he was Splinter at like, I don't know if it was San Diego Comic Con or one of the comic cons. And then he unfortunately like passed away the next day. So he he is part of

Splinter's role. And then they brought in Greg Baldwin, who's a voice actor, to kind of fill in all the gaps and to You know make it so they could complete it. So this is Mako's last role. Obviously, and he's very famous Japanese American actor obviously, so you know, I can't forget that we had Laurence Fishburne as the narrator So that was interesting right from the beginning. I'm like, oh they brought in the big guns for the narration here It's like Morgan Freeman and Laurence Fishburne. I don't they're like neck and neck for me And i'm not gonna try to pronounce

the actress's name that did cry she did crouching tiger hidden dragon. She's like one of the most well -known chinese actresses of that time like I think they said something about like Forbes or somebody does like a top 100 like most Notable or most powerful or something like that and they do it for both They did it for like for china specifically and I think she was in the top five like 10 years in a row Or something like that. So very well known there. I've only seen her in crouching tiger hidden dragon i don't know if you've seen her in anything else but but any

thoughts on any of the characters whether it be the performance or just kind of how they were depicted in this film that worked or didn't work for you i thought it got the characters pretty well like uh i when it came like looking at all the four this is our fourth film it came to like feeling like i'm Seeing each character each turtle well defined within their personality. I feel like this one was probably the best so far Obviously, it's mostly, you know, Leonardo Raphael story like they are the focus for the majority of it like that Yeah, but even like little bits that

Donnie gets and Michelangelo gets I thought you know They balance out. Well, I love voice cast overall was pretty strong Casey Jones I thought we could get a little bit more of but again, there's a lot going on here But at least he was in it. We actually got to do some stuff, you know compared to right beyond last film We were just comic relief I like that they kept I like that they kept Casey Jones and Raphael both kind of is like these crime fighters on the side Yeah, yeah that worked for me. I do like the relationship and they kind of touch That's like where that's

where it did feel like the first film see their kinship felt like it was coming from that first movie And very similarly compared to what we got before but yeah I thought the character was like the characters that we got regarding like, you know besides the the villains that we talked about which were kind of lackluster The main cast, the main character, especially the turtles, even Splinter, I thought was... Splinter's like this enigma though, like they can't seem to do Splinter the same way twice, ever. I don't get why he was so against them going to the service

world. It seemed like that was just contrived to cause some conflict. I'm going to be interested as we make our way through the rest of these, if they ever... What depiction of splinter is the most common when we're all done with this because i feel like he has moved around the most out of all of the characters donatello obviously in the beginning we didn't really get a whole bunch with the first live action film of his geekiness and his kind of tech savviness and it seems like since then though they kind of course corrected and. And they hit that every

time like he definitely is very much in that lane in this film michael angelo very much the the carefree him to in the birthday entertainment stuff was i thought was clever i like that. And then like you said there's some you know not just casey jones and rafael's relationship is akin to what we saw in the first live action film but he said leonardo's and rafael's kind of very much similar to. With their kind of back and forth, you know, we we start this film, like we kind of briefly touched on where all the turtles are kind of separated. So we see Leonardo, who's like in Central America doing training. Yeah.

My man was like, how did he get to Central America? Well, he flew in the bottom. He flew with the with the dogs go apparently. Yeah. I was like, well, just watch. We'll figure it out. And then obviously, Raphael is kind of cameoing as this night watcher character. Michelangelo is doing the birthday entertainment. And Donatello is like a IT tech support guy, which led to a weird like sex line joke. Like there was a sex hotline joke in here and I'm like this is turtles. Yeah, I mean, I technically like the early like, you

know, comics that were not. But yeah, I mean, there's been some. Even even put it even in like the some of the movies so far. They've always had especially came to April They've always had some really weird remarks towards her right? Yeah Nice paying all the bills like that's how they're gonna That's how they're getting cable and sat or whatever they have, you know He's the one doing all the hard work, right? And another interesting thing that it might be especially with some news. I just kind of got posted online I don't know if you saw this or not, but they they just released the Character descriptions

for each of the turtles for the movie that's coming out this year No, I have not so so that is online and the thing that's gonna make everybody Talk is what I'll get to in a second, but it's gonna be interesting to see Throughout all the other movies that we watch how consistent they are with April O 'Neil and her love interest because we Commented briefly in the live -action film that it was kind of weird that the turtles were kind of goo -goo Gaga for April Yes, and

then we obviously have a Casey Jones April connection Writing that first live -action film and we see that kind of carry on so far with the other stuff. We've watched definitely in here They're you know a couple Yes, yeah, you know pretty and and so it went to describe the turtles that are gonna appear in the 2023 and almost all of it matches up like they added a little bit with Donatello like he is into kpop and Something else but but it was still in that world and they

did all Michelangelo lined up Raffaele lined up Leonardo lined up like exactly what you would think when you're just kind of trying to describe them off the top of your head and then they add this like little blurb at the bottom that's a that basically says that Leonardo has a crush on April O 'Neil and is dead set on going to the surface world and and Like following his feelings for April There you go So I think that's going to be something that people are talking about here in the next week that you're going to see online online a little bit. So but I'm

interested to see how many different people they try to like connect April with, because I want to say at one point, Donatello has a thing for her. I don't know. I don't know how I feel about it all, but I'll watch it and see you see where it goes from there. So I also thought another thing was that the music that they put in here made me think a little bit of. The first and second live -action film like I feel like they at least tried to hit that vibe Definitely it like especially when you have the big like throw

down at the end within the big compound that it it definitely seemed like they were going for that type of Tone in that or that style if it felt much more there was a lot of there wasn't a lot of like music in the sense of like like we but there were some key moments like you mentioned where the soundtrack really kicked in Right. They also added a couple lines that were reminiscent of the live -action films. They had like the I love being a turtle thing Obviously, that's been something I think we've heard that in all the films so far. Yeah, I don't I don't know

exactly I'd have to go back and actually find out but I know we've heard it a couple times so far in the in the films What what were your opinions of the turtle layer in this one or the turtle van? Any of that stuff? They were okay. Like the layer seemed pretty nondescriptive it felt You know just kind of basic especially you know compared to the subway the old subway when we got in the past it didn't feel like it was in the sewer but i guess it makes more sense since you've been there longer and they've been able to clean up a bit and it doesn't seem like

the foot or as much of a threat so maybe they're not you know i like the design that rafael had for his like you know super hero get up or whatever you want to call it with the motorcycle and whatnot Nightwatcher yeah that's what you know it was a little goofy but it kinda made sense considering. It's rafael trying to hide the fact that he's a turtle in some sort of get up so right right. The other thing i was thinking on this one is i know we talked about the the plus convoluted obviously that's like a parent right from the

get go by the way guys when you start a movie and there's like five minutes of narration. You know you're in trouble. Like when they have to explain that much stuff to you off the bat before you ever see anything, you're like, I know it's Laurence Fishburne, so I'm listening to it all day. But like this is this is a bad sign. But is there can you just take Karai in the foot out of this and nothing changes? Well, they they're the ones that capture like the last beast or I guess, but I don't know. I just feel like that

is completely shoehorned into this movie. I it is you know it it felt like that like I said I felt there was more there cuz you see that I don't like how does she become the Leader of the foot in the begin with like where does she come from? I think maybe supposed to be a red herring you're thinking like oh It's the foot supposed to be the bad people here, but they end up I want to know what happened to Tatsu or whatever Plus I think they're also there to set said this kind of set breadcrumbs for what they hope would be sequels so But yeah, they

didn't have much to do here except be cannon fodder and, you know, you know, help out a little bit at the end. Yeah, I guess the talks originally there was when they were talking about the sequel, like they were throwing around the idea of it being turtles, like somehow in space. Nice, why not? Why not? I guess Fast and the Furious got that idea and like, you know what, we'll steal that for. 11th ninth movie was it not yeah, it's something like that and there was another one that he I guess it was like a planned trilogy by Monroe like he wanted to do a three -parter

and I know one of them or somewhere in there he wanted to have like the technodrome be a part of it and the Triceratons and things like that so I saw them to where they thought about like where There was like Michelangelo would be you know Upset with the turtles and joined the foot which maybe would make sense with what happened here since they kind of Show that they were honorable so maybe they weren't like the foot of the bat, you know the right evil It seems like I think that's existed somewhere. I don't know if it was in one of the comics or not But I always

wonder like is that the turtle that would join like isn't it way more? likely that Raphael would be that character I think Raphael would be too stubborn. I think Michelangelo can kind of make sense because He he's a little bit easier to manipulate. Maybe like they younger more naive. Yeah potentially. Oh, they also they also in the little blur, I know this kind of sidetrack, but in the little blurb for the twenty twenty three movie, they also make a point to mention how old the turtles are, not like an actual age, but like in relation to each other. So in the

new one, Leonardo is the oldest, then Raphael, then Donatello and then Michelangelo. He's the youngest. Yeah, that makes sense. Yeah. I actually always think the graph being oldest makes the most sense, but I agree. that would add to that would add to like the the tense the tenseness as far as like why is Leonardo leading me when I'm the older brother but I could buy that. the

fifth Dad I I don't even remember that to be honest with you, but I mean I'm over my head So obviously this one came out and did okay right away at the box office as far as at least it didn't lose money for this company and Like you said a beat 300 and some other stuff critical response not great. That's gonna be a theme I

think probably for all the films we talked about except for maybe one and Had like a 34 % on Rotten Tomatoes How do you feel about it especially in comparison to the four films that we've looked at so far i'm not necessarily saying you have to rank them all what kind of what's your like first instinct as far as like where does this one fall the plots terrible but there's a bunch of other good parts is that enough to like make up for it and get it decent rank for you. Yeah

like i was not like i didn't went into this try to be as blind as possible not knowing anything and when i was like i was like what is the rating for this and so thirty percent which was like. That feels really low to me. Again, I talked about how I think the plot's really convoluted and complicated, which is true. Honestly, out of all the ones we've watched so far, it's probably ranking right now, right below the first one. Not that there's a huge amount of competition there, but I genuinely enjoyed myself. I don't know, because maybe I had low expectations. I didn't know what to expect, but like I said,

I enjoyed. The turtle dynamic. I thought the action was fun. It didn't overstay its welcome. I don't know if it's because it's 90 minutes and like we can never get a 90 minute movie anymore and just something that can kind of just do what it needs to do and get out. But yeah, it certainly has its faults. I went through it. I was curious like why people were so negative about it. And I agree regarding the pot stuff, but I also saw a lot of people saying it wasn't. It was not goofy enough or not fun enough or whatever. Which I don't agree with I felt like it was I feel like that people were just comparing it to like

the cartoon show and because it's not like that But I thought it had a good bounce. I felt like it it had the jokes when it needed to but it had some serious moments some of them Good moments that carried out for me were like that the action. I thought was all there was a great like Long not great but a pretty solid long take in near the end when they're entering the compound and like they're going through all the different turtles It felt like people that really wanted to make a good movie you know like they put their heart and soul into it and maybe they needed

a bit of a better editor when it came to the plotting but it was good like. Basically saying the action was solved it was a funny film when it needed to be the characters were good when it came to like the turtles and their surrounding cast so despite my apprehension despite like the issues I had you know with with everything surrounding that. It didn't bother me enough despite all that's false. Yeah like i said the plus terrible the casting of patrick stewart is distracting even if he's a good performer

so like those are like my two biggest negatives it's an interesting thing though because it's like you see all these things were there. Going back for me to the first live -action film where it be the relationships between the characters and some of that with Casey Jones and rafael with rafael leonardo and kind of the The inner relationships between the turtles reminds me of a lot of the first turtles then it has A little bit more of that serious i'm not saying dark necessarily but it has a little bit of like let's go a little bit towards the comics versus the

cartoon Which reminds me a little bit more of the third live -action film because it seemed like that's both of those films were trying to do that in a way And then you know, you have the music and nods So it's like it seems like it's a little bit of this film a little bit of that film And it makes me wonder if the third film had been animated by this exact same company with the exact same look You know how how would they have stacked up against each other at that point? Yeah, because something that's distracting for me in the third one is so much of the The

visuals are just super distracting for me and I'll put it in the third So I'm like if the third movie had been animated in CGI like this would it have been better? I don't know. Like I definitely put yeah Yeah, definitely agree. Like if you if you just put that story pen the paper and maybe made it a comic it would probably be a lot better than it was when you're distracted by the fact that You're looking at what are clearly bad puppets that do not work the way that they should. Right. So yeah, so this one's definitely

for me below the first live action. I don't know where it falls after that. I think I'd have it right close to the second movie with me. And it just kind of depends on what you value more, whether you value the story more or whether you value the character relationships and the look and the sound and everything like that. And I still think I have the third one. Third live -action film as as my least favorite so far I would probably watch this animated one again before I would watch the third live -action film But that's just my personal preference Yeah,

and anything else that you haven't had a chance to to talk about Dan as far as this film goes or where we're sitting right now with the four films in out of I believe it's gonna be ten in total nine ten like that No, I'm definitely glad I watched it because I was I was I don't know what took me so long I think I was interested in what was coming out And then I think I heard and I just never saw it. It was one of those things where it's just like, yeah, never went around around to it, but I was glad I watched it in the end. I can't say that about everything. Every move we've watched now this is turning out a lot better than you know the video game

retrospective. Yeah, I don't think I can get that back now. So next on the docket would be just what came out. Two years later, which was an animated made -for -TV film called Turtles Forever, we've referenced that a couple times. That, I believe, is one of two, one or two or three that didn't actually make it to theaters, so the Turtles Forever from 2009 is where we'll get to next, and then we'll jump back into some live -action look with what we saw in the 2014 -2016 era, so. I don't know if i'm looking forward

to those two as much but i remember enjoying turtles forever i know i've seen it at least once for sure yeah i remember enjoying it have you seen turtles forever i watched it once i watch the back when we were doing like the animated movie countdown so this will be a second watch for both of us but but probably at least. Five plus years since we've seen it definitely yeah. So it'll be interesting to see where we go from there dan anything that you have going on with your tiktok or comic coverage that you'd like to uh, share with everybody No, you can just

you know, just the same as always for my stuff on tiktok at comic concierge. It's also instagram youtube, uh twitter all that good stuff with it being like halfway through the year almost i'm gonna try to do some like Favorite of stuff for for june. So we'll see how that goes. You did do something turtles related though recently. I saw right I thought you did something that was like a look at something turtles comic. Oh, I did. Yes. So recently I did a review of the day right now just started a new comic Saturday

morning Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. I forget the exact series, but it's basically a comic that takes basically takes place in the universe of the original. Cartoon cartoon series from the 80s. It's you know, very much inspired by that So I did a review of the first issue and you'll be happy because it you know rankings in it And then we've been talking about racking a lot. So he made it's a fun book I did a review of the first issue. This is the second series are doing of this. They did a series earlier They also did one for GI Joe as well, you know

taking you know, it's for IDW but they really you know find different ways to use their properties, but If you love that cartoon definitely check that out. There's a lot of uh, one comics coming out right now too because there's the ronan comic that's out soon and I just I was actually working on a review of They had a crossover this week with street fighter Uh, so that was interesting to see very 90s. It was like, you know, 90s are coming back in a major way So you can check for that soon as well Like it and you can keep up

with whatever I'm doing if you follow the geek showcase on YouTube I've just finished the ultimate Saturday morning cartoon lineup series that I did which was going every year 1983 through 1989 and highlighting eight cartoons that aired in that year and There's some other stuff that kind of goes along with that into the 96 and I'm gonna take a break from that series for a minute I have I've been wanting to do this like We've been making our way through every star trek series in a logical order and we're down to like the word on the card which is one of the more recent

one so we've watched all of enterprise all of voyager all of deep space nine all of. We've been doing it for a while now So but I'm gonna go through and do some quick videos where I'm ranking the crew from each of those series Like my favorite to least favorite characters or something of that nature I haven't a hundred percent decided so I'm gonna be doing some Star Trek related content and then I'll probably jump back into some cartoons because that seems to be what people like right now, so It's getting that some views that i didn't expect so i enjoy that and you

can keep touch with us to on twitter or facebook you can either search out geocast radio network which is gonna give you all the different podcasts that are done. By the by the network and by the other guys or like you said you can look at Dan stuff on Twitter or my stuff it would be at optimus solo or at geek showcase and That does it for this episode. We'll come back next time and look at turtles forever from 2009 So that is it from cinema geeks to the next time for more

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Western Retrospective: The Outlaw Josey Wales

    Nov 16, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 269, the guys continue their Western Retrospective. Next up for the revisionist western block is the classic Eastwood film, The Outlaw Josey Wales. How will this stack up to the other films the guys...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Halloween Special: Rocky Horror Picture Show

    Oct 31, 202641 minAudio

    Today on Episode 268, In honor of the Late Great Tim Curry Kevin and Dan are taking a trip to the strange, outrageous, and gloriously weird world of The Rocky Horror Picture Show! Are they ready to dress up and head to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Halloween Spotlight: The Exorcist

    Oct 29, 202642 minAudio

    Today on Episode 267, the guys continue their spooky Halloween fare. Next up is another classic that is a blind spot for both hosts. Will the religious under belly of the Exorcist conjure up too many bad memories for...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Halloween Spotlight: Carrie (1976)

    Oct 26, 202639 minAudio

    Boo! Did I scare you? No okay. Anyways on Episode 266, the guys are getting into the season with a look at the original Carrie from 1976. Which ironically brings us back to the early days in the podcast. Be Sure to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Halloween Spotlight: Texas Chainsaw Massacre

    Oct 24, 202651 minAudio

    Today on Episode 265, the guys start a special look at some classic Halloween fare. To start things off we have a first time watch for both hosts of the iconic Texas Chainsaw Massacre. How well does this film hold up...

    Credit the people on this episode