My conversation with V Spehar, host and creator of Under the Desk News. V is a journalist and podcast host with over 3.7M TikTok followers and a bestselling Substack. Thank you Aaron Parnas, Yuri Bezmenov, Brandon Ellrich, Sue Ploeger’s script to novel, Souivon Hollins, and many others for tuning in. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit cb.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01We're already live. Friends are here. Welcome to my house. We're rocking and rolling. All right, I'll give the intro while you find the dogs. Sounds good. I'm Chris Best.
SPEAKER_00You're going to watch the dogs? Okay, Natalie's watching the dogs. There's my lovely wife.
SPEAKER_01Hi.
SPEAKER_00All right, we're going back upstairs, Chris. Sorry. This is the freedom you have as an independent creator. You get to be in your house and you and your wife, who also works from home today, take turns deciding who's going to deal with the screaming mini dachshunds.
SPEAKER_01Well, we saw them for a second there and they look adorable. They're very cuties. Okay, we're back. We're back. All right. I'm Chris Best. I'm speaking with V Spear, host and creator of Under the Desk News.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01You're a journalist. You're a podcast host. You have over 3.7 million followers on TikTok, and you have a best-selling Substack newsletter. Yes. Thanks for coming. Thanks for talking to me.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm excited to chat with you. It's not often you get to see the man behind the curtain, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'll try not to be too mysterious. I mean, maybe the first thing I wanted to ask you is just what's it like being on TikTok right now?
SPEAKER_00Oh, it's rough. So I think the optimism and the joy that we had from TikTok came from that pandemic era time. A lot of people were home. They were looking for entertainment. They were willing to be a little goofy. And I think for a lot of folks who ended up becoming big TikTokers, it really started just as a place to connect. And it was a happy place of entertainment and exploration and curiosity. And then I would say probably over the last two or three years, it's become a lot more difficult. And much of that came from our government not understanding the platform.
SPEAKER_00It's financial viability for people. It was creating work for them and small businesses. And people were even building churches on there. I follow a couple of non-denominational pastors who were holding digital church. It was really such a wonderful place. And I think that they lost a lot of trust when the government started talking about banning it. I think that time that we had the blackout, folks were like, wow, it really... It really can just go down. And I think now with the sale, people just, you know, they're suspicious of industry everywhere.
SPEAKER_00They're certainly suspicious of this. So I think the vibes over there are a little less footloose and fancy free like they were, which was kind of the draw of TikTok, that it was like a happy place mostly. And I think people are now, you know, whether it's actually happening or it's perceived to be happening, they're they don't trust their for you page and they're having a difficult time feeling like this is a place to continue investing in.
SPEAKER_01Right. And so there's this change of ownership. There's been this forced sale. There's been rhetoric from the new leadership basically saying we're going to decide what's allowed and what's not. And then because of the way the algorithm works, you kind of can never know for sure, both between the algorithm and between technical changes. You can never know for sure if the thing that you're saying is, getting censored or having a thumb on the scale, or if that's just how the algorithm is behaving today, I can imagine that that feels kind of crazy making.
SPEAKER_00Well, one of the things, if you talk to any creator, they'll say, I wish that any algorithm, any platform would just show my stuff to my followers. Like, number one thing, I've got 3.7 million followers over there, right? I wish that the app would just show my stuff to my followers. And I think that is also sort of playing into it. People who have big, huge followerships might not be be hitting their former followers FYP page. There's no ownership of who that audience is. You don't have a way to directly reach out to them. And God help you if you try to market your comedy show,
SPEAKER_00a gig that you're doing, a class that you're selling, anything. If it's not going through the TikTok shop, oftentimes that can feel like it's throttling your video too. right so there's there's benefits to having a direct relationship with your audience oh yeah even outside of kind of the freedom of the press freedom of speech implications of being able to say the things you believe but there's kind of the value for any outlet really it's like even when you subscribe to let's say the washington post or the new york times they have collected your email and you have a profile with them that they have ownership over if they want to email you
SPEAKER_00a reminder to resubscribe or say, hey, we haven't heard from you in a while or whatever, they could build that relationship with you. TikTok really doesn't allow you any kind of access to the back end, like where you would be able to build any kind of genuine community or take them off the platform. Your only ways to interact with the audience, sadly, are your DMs, which can be very difficult to navigate and there's no search function in there. So sometimes I see something I want to respond to and I'm like, and then it's like gone before I can even get back to it. Or your comments. And again, that's like a really difficult way to build like an authentic
relationship.
SPEAKER_01Do you find sometimes because I've heard people on TikTok say this, that in order to discuss the thing you want to discuss, you sometimes have to speak in code. Yeah. Use alternate words for the things you're saying. What are some examples of that?
SPEAKER_00So I think like right now I'm trying to do the Epstein files, right? This is a very sensitive case. I'm obviously have proven myself as like a legitimate news platform and source to TikTok. I've had a creator manager, they know who I am. So it's like, you should be able to kind of like trust me that I'm gonna bring forth the truth and be responsible about it. But there's no sort of like levels to you on TikTok at all. You don't ever achieve like a verified status where they give you a little more trust. So for example, if you're trying to talk about,
SPEAKER_00you know, Epstein, I've been calling it Jeff because something about the word Epstein triggers their AI comment detection and it says Epstein conspiracies, right? And then it'll label my video that way and it might throttle how much that video gets out. So I'm saying, I say stuff like, oh, we're talking about Jeff today. I don't want to talk like that about the world's most prolific pedophile. Like I don't want to be on a first name basis with him. But you have to to kind of like get around the AI picking up the word Epstein. Or you might be trying to talk about a murder that happened.
SPEAKER_00There's a lot of, you know, stuff going on, like when I was trying to talk about the killing of Renee Good or of Alex Preddy. I have to say the unaliving of them, you know, and even with that, sometimes it'll get it'll still get caught or marked as like, you know, for 18 and older only. And I think some of that is really sad because we need to be able to use, words have meaning and they have power, and we need to be able to use the real word for the thing we're discussing and not try to like code word it for an audience that is predominantly, my audience is all adults. It's all people who are over 18.
SPEAKER_00I don't have an under 18 audience. So, like, I have to say, unalived to 50-year-old full adults with full-ass jobs who are trying to learn something, like, it makes me look less credible. It makes the report seem less dire and serious. And, you know, I just want to use the same words they use on television to describe it. It should be okay.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it feels sort of, it's weirdly childish.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's very childish.
SPEAKER_01It doesn't actually, it doesn't help. You're still talking, you should be able to talk about the thing you actually talk about. Right. Yeah, it's very, very interesting. It sort of reminds me of, I used to hear these stories about how on the Chinese internet they would have to use code words if you wanted to talk about freedom because the government would say, it's not safe to let people say these words. And here we are, we've sort of accidentally recreated, maybe accidentally recreated the same problem. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, for sure. Well, I'd be curious. I mean, you've been on Substack. You launched just over a year ago. Is that right? Yep, just about. Why did you launch a Substack and has it gone how you hoped or expected it would go?
SPEAKER_00So not to, like, gas you up, but genuinely it went a lot better than I thought it would because I had done a different type of platform that, you know, allows you to, like, meet with your fans and do all this. It wasn't OnlyFans. It was the other one. So I had done it. The other other one. And I had tried... Over there, and I actually, I found it to be really difficult for me because I'm not like a super video person and I already make so much content that the focus of the other platform was to make like unique content that you would put behind a paywall that's not very on brand for me. And I also truly cannot create any more content than I physically do now.
SPEAKER_00And so... I sort of like flopped over there. Like, I was like, I don't, I don't like doing this. I don't like paywalling it or having to paywall it. It just, I didn't think it was going to work. And then I had met someone from Substack at the White House Correspondents Dinner, actually. I like went to one of the events and started chatting with people there and they were saying like, no, you don't have to paywall everything. It doesn't have to be unique stuff, but you can put like your scripts over there, your sources over there, even if you want, like, why don't you just try? And I found the user experience for me to be so much easier
that I was more willing to do it.
SPEAKER_00I didn't have to like learn a whole new skill. It's like now I'm trying to grow on YouTube and I have to learn like thumbnails. And that's worth it because it's going to pay off in the end. But coming to Substack was super easy. And then I also was like, okay, well, now I'm going to have to try to rebuild my whole following in another platform. This is going to suck. And it didn't because we, through the advice of Bailey, who was on the creator team, she was like, go live with people that you normally talk to or that are your friends. And that's a really good way to grow your audience and let
people know you're on Substack.
SPEAKER_00And we did, I think it was like a month of like a couple lives a week. And it's something that it's more than half of my audience comes from inside the Substack app, like getting recommended. So I didn't have to like hard sell myself. I had the recognizability from TikTok before. So a lot of people who like to get their news on TikTok would also like to read more deeply. We're like, oh, V's over here now, subscribe over there. And it was the money part of it made a big difference, too. On TikTok, there are times when you make really good money and then they'll remove that program. And on Substack, seven bucks a month, man.
SPEAKER_00That's how much it costs for my channel. And I don't pay well anything. So it's like people out of the goodness of their heart being like, I want to support you. Here's your seven bucks. I'm glad everybody gets to read it. That's no problem. And it's consistent. So once we knew that we would have consistent money, I was able to hire some people. So that's how we do the newsletter three times a week now. We're hoping to get to five times a week by the beginning of summer because we were able to get Jed, the researcher, who does our Tuesday deep dives. And we have Lana, who does our LGBTQ exclusive content. We have folks who contribute to good news. We're going to have a climate guy coming in on Mondays,
SPEAKER_00too, to just talk about climate and energy and, like, explainers on what folks need to know about that. And so I think those have been the benefits so far. And I could post whatever the fuck I want, like, genuinely. Like, even right now, intentionally just said an F word on the live. I'm not going to get a strike, right? Like, that's going to be okay.
SPEAKER_01Nobody's going to kill your channel or on the live.
SPEAKER_00It's not going to kill my channel. I'm not going to get a strike. I'm not going to get downvoted. We publish some... unfortunately incredibly difficult in graphic content on our Tuesday deep dives with Jed's investigative side. And people understand that they're opting into the Tuesday is going to be a raw and oftentimes, especially with the stuff going on with Warren Epstein, maybe a disturbing story. People get to make that decision for themselves, the algorithm, and the bosses don't make the decision for them. And I'm able to speak freely. I don't have to speak in code.
SPEAKER_00We can link sources, stuff like that. And I think it has helped professionalize my overall under the deskness. And it also is like a great relief to me to know, like, even if I have to play games on some of the platforms to game the FYP or the algorithm, if you follow me here, you're just getting it. It's just, it's just everything flat on the table, easy to understand, no games. And I think folks really appreciate that.
SPEAKER_01You can say it on Substack.
SPEAKER_00You can say it on Substack, literally. Some stuff, you know, maybe we don't want people to say on Substack, but you can. It's a very free speechy place. Not that there's no consequence. Like, I haven't ever run into, like, any... I get terrible comments on YouTube that I don't know. They must not monitor those so closely because you get a lot of slurs and bad stuff over there. Here, you don't get that. So I think that people behave a little bit more... responsibly here. And I appreciate that also. I think each platform has its own core audience that,
SPEAKER_00you know, benefits you where you learn from. And here I feel like it's like the most realistic professional space that I operate in. And then if you want my truly unhinged, then maybe go to Threads, right? Because Threads I treat like a live journal. Substack I treat like a job. Like it's different.
SPEAKER_01That's cool. Something I wanted to ask you about. I mean, you mentioned free speech. You know, I'm a big believer that free speech is not a partisan issue. But it feels to me like if five or 10 years ago you were sort of worrying about platform censorship, that might have felt like a right wing coded concern. I saw some people in the chat earlier being like,
SPEAKER_00well,
SPEAKER_01there was there was censorship of TikTok under Biden. Do you see any change in that sort of perception in left wing spaces?
SPEAKER_00I think it's the same. I think everybody thinks that they're being shadow banned. Everybody thinks that they're being suppressed. And some people are and some people aren't. But if you feel that way, that's going to impact the type of content you make. And I think throughout the five years, there's been code talk on TikTok. Throughout the five years, there's been videos that get suppressed no matter who the president was. And I think that speaks a little bit more to like the sort of corporatization of these platforms. Yeah. So, I mean, I don't think it's gotten any better or worse necessarily,
SPEAKER_00but I think people feel like it's gotten worse because now they, quote, like, know who owns it and are applying, like, all of that bias onto it. I don't know that left-wing people are getting more banned than they were before, right-wing people get more banned than they were before. I think the conversations we're having are more graphic. If you look at what's gone on really since Trump has become president, if we want to make that like some sort of mark, it's been really difficult. There has been the killing of American citizens in the streets by ICE agents. We have had the Epstein files released in this amount of time.
SPEAKER_00There has been the Venezuela coup. We're looking at a war in Iran. Like, we've seen all of these different things over the last year, so people may feel like they're being more censored, but it might be that there's more content that the authorities that be in the algorithms just don't want the American people to see because they want them to remain sort of calm and complicit, and why can't you all just go back to lip-syncing and dancing like you used to, you know, in 2020? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I hope that's something that we can all agree on, or at least it can sort of resonate with everybody. It's like the more, you know, the more there's important stuff to talk about in the world, the more important it is to have a channel where you can say what you believe and discuss, frankly, the real things that are happening.
SPEAKER_00When I treat Substack often like a portfolio too, right? Like I don't necessarily have the time to like update my website every day with every thought that I have and every blog I've been posted in or every article I've contributed to. But if you go to the Substack, we can very easily show you and link, like for example, yesterday's piece, which was on some of the Epstein stuff that's going on, connecting it to Russia and connecting it to Greenland, right? So I had already written about the billionaires who tried to buy Greenland. You can embed that in the thing and it reminds people, it's like, just keeps everything really neatly together in a portfolio the
way that videos can
SPEAKER_00kind of sometimes be forgotten because folks are maybe reading two, three, four, five Substack articles in depth in a day if they're really like a super user. But if you're scrolling in the internet, I mean, you're watching me and a hundred other videos. You might've forgot what we said about it, but at least over here, I could keep it very neatly organized. And I think it acts as, like I said, like a portfolio more than just kind of like a, sizzle reel which is kind of the thing with video very cool um
was there anything
SPEAKER_01else you wanted to talk about or anything you wanted to ask me yes so
SPEAKER_00What did you guys do? The live video that as soon as we're done with this live for folks who have never gone live before, a little thing will pop up that says post when ready. And I always click post. It will clip like the best parts of our conversation. It will issue me a thumbnail. It will auto publish it to YouTube. That is like incredibly valuable for creator tools. What made you guys like prioritize that?
SPEAKER_01You know, it's funny. This is something that has always been in the mission of Substack is being a creator is hard, right? Whether you're a writer writing something that's great, whether you're a creator talking, whether you're a podcaster who's having a conversation with someone, it's really hard to make something great. And if you can do that, that should be enough. This has always been our philosophy. My pitch to people is we want to do everything for you except the hard part.
SPEAKER_00There you go. Right. You do the hard part of having something to say and the technology should take care
SPEAKER_01of all of the fiddle faddle. And so if you're a writer, you should be able to come and type into this box and you don't have to worry about how to host a website or how to send email or how to accept payments. And we started getting into podcasting and video and I did a bit of work myself. I was like, I'm going to, I'm going to figure this out. I'm It's hard. It's hard. It's a lot of work. And some of it is hard in the sense of there's important skills you have to learn in order to do it well. And some of it is hard in the sense of, and I think you don't appreciate if you haven't tried it.
SPEAKER_01It's like if you're making a lot of content and every time you have to Go and cut 10 clips and put it in eight different places. It's just a huge pain in the ass to do forgetting about how difficult it is. And so our North Star has always been the human being that's making the thing is the central value. And we should let you do the thing that you're great at and have sort of maximum creative leverage. And as much as possible, we should make the software handle all of the details.
SPEAKER_01You shouldn't have to worry about, do I need to fix up the audio so that this can be a good podcast? Do I need to upload this to YouTube? Do I need to cut clips in different formats for different platforms? How do I find the right moment? How do I edit it so that it's tight? Our goal is to kind of just make all of that stuff magically work. And I would say within the past maybe six months, we've kind of – there's still like a lot that we can do and we're very excited about the roadmap. But the team has been working really hard on the clips, on the thumbnails, on the auto-uploading.
And they're at the point where I'd say I think they're the best automated clips in
SPEAKER_01the industry right now.
SPEAKER_00Even when you post your, like I'll post like my regular Substack post, and then you'll get the option for like a couple different Instagram carousel story. And it has like the little link and it has what the title is. Sometimes it has a couple quotes from it or restacking a quote. Those have been the ways that I've grown this account the most is by using those. Restacking a quote is huge for growing audience too.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome. What do you wish we had for you? What could be better? So the only thing is the watermark on the videos does make it not perform as well on the other platforms if there's any way to fix any of that because they are such
SPEAKER_00good clips. And we do have such good conversations here. But when I post it on TikTok, as soon as they see that little flag up there, they're like, I'm not going to push this out to anybody. So sometimes it can feel like I have to do things and then go live on TikTok to have the exact same conversation. So it's in both places. But I know that's, you know, that's asking a lot. But I think keeping up with these creator tools, like making it easier to clip your podcast and I know we already can like auto put it on the RSS feed, which is super important. I think that's going to make this space the most valuable as
more and more people
SPEAKER_00want to start doing this work. Even if they're not doing it to try and achieve a full-time job, they're doing it as a hobby or because it brings them joy or it helps them learn. I think that kind of stuff that you guys are doing, I super appreciate. And I know a lot of other folks who are in their citizen journalist era appreciate it too because it makes you look professional and it makes you look like, you know, what you're doing a little bit and saves you some time. Oh, people are saying spell checker within the writing space would be good. Okay. And they want to edit their automated clips. So that's it. You're hearing straight from the audience.
SPEAKER_00Can we edit the automated clips? Can you make that happen, please? That's what people want, Chris. Edit the automatic clips.
SPEAKER_01Got it. Yeah, I think we're planning to give you more options on those things.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I love that. I can't think of anything else because I don't, you know, like filters and all that stuff. I don't need any of that business. I don't think you need to recreate the TikTok tools over here. I think this is like a more professional space. Maybe if there was a little bit more ways to find other folks and... Because I know my friends that are here, but maybe if there was sort of like a creator networking thing you could opt into to be like, hey, I'm available to go live on these subjects or something like a LinkedIn does, where they're like, I'm an expert on these things.
And then people could be like, do you want to go live at this time or something? I think that would be a cool way to do some more crossover with creators and get to
SPEAKER_00know some more people here.
SPEAKER_01I love that. We'd have to do it in a less cringy way than LinkedIn. You don't want to have the open to live.
SPEAKER_00I'm counting on you to come up with that. Like, how do you make it less cringe? But like, I'm an expert at these things and you can ask me to go live or something. Or a topics section. People are saying a topics section. They want a topic section. I think like playlists. Is that what you guys mean? Like where you could stack like, oh, I did a video and a Substack and a note on a playlist.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's what it seems like. All right. Well, when this comes out, leave all of your feature requests in the comments. Thank you so much. This has been fantastic. Where should people subscribe? So you can find me at Under the Desk News on all the social media platforms,
SPEAKER_00and it's underthedesknews.substack.com. And like I said, this is what I use as a website now. We don't even use underthedesknews.com. So people yearn for MySpace. Yeah, if we could code our top eight, I think that would be great. Right now we can do recommendations. That's super helpful. I've gotten a lot of a boost from people recommending my account and recommending theirs. So that's great. But I think you guys are doing a great job. And the vibes are immaculate. The team is incredible. Bailey, if I could give Bailey a shout out, like she's so helpful to creators and just a wonderful person.
SPEAKER_00And I'm glad we got to chat.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. Likewise. Thank you so much. And thanks for being here.
Mike and I talk Slop World: Worse, the algorithms that govern AI also govern our accounts, which means any human sufficiently engaged online is gradually trained to behave like slop - is slowly transformed into slop....
see also * Against Claudefishing * Don’t Let Activists or Robots Choose Your Words This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit...
We talk about the new Pangram integration in the Substack app, the difference between AI-assisted work and slop, and why human perspective becomes more valuable as generated content gets cheaper.See also: * Against...